When the Red State Senators circled the wagons and declared all-out war on the unions, their unrelenting determination to wound the UAW — even if if they had to destroy the entire economy to do so – baffled many. Even George Bush and Dick Cheney were left shaking their heads.
But the southern hostility to unionism has a long history. There’s a great post at the Black Commentator that I’ve linked to before, but it talks about how Southerners came to regard "unions" as organizations that wanted to take jobs away from whites and give them to blacks, especially in the wake of the 1964 Civil Rights Act:
Today, with wild and thumping pontification, these same bigoted bosses rail against “agitators” causing “dissension” among the “good working people” who stand to “lose their jobs” if “outsiders” wearing union baseball caps invade the sacred soil of the South.
It all sounds so familiar, especially to the insiders: southern Blacks.
When it no longer became "okay" to be openly racist, those sentiments seeped out in hatred of trade unions:
It was during the heyday of the civil rights movement that collective bargaining among public employees was made illegal in all of the Old Confederacy. This was not a historical coincidence.
Barry Goldwater carried five southern states for the GOP in 1964, running against civil rights and for union-busting legislation. This was the debut of the Republican’s Southern Strategy. Today, a white Democrat businessman is often hard to find in Dixie, while in many districts Blacks make up a solid and even overwhelming majority of the Democratic Party vote.
Republican rule is the reason the South remains entangled in the barbed wire of anti-labor legislation, with new bills passing all the time.
In scuttling the Detroit automakers, the Red State Senators got a twofer — they got to strike a blow against the union, but they also get the chance take good jobs away from African American autoworkers.
The Economic Policy Institute recently released a report on how devastating an auto industry collapse would be to African Americans:
Approximately 118,000 African Americans worked in the auto industry in November 2008, down from 137,000 in December 2007 when the recession began.
[]
African Americans earn much higher wages in auto industry jobs than in other parts of the economy, and the loss of these solid, middle-class jobs would be a devastating blow. Hourly wages for African Americans in the motor vehicle industry averaged $17.08 (excluding fringe benefits) in 2007, versus economy-wide average wages for African American of $15.44 per hour.2 African Americans have been particularly hard hit in this recession. The unemployment rate for blacks increased to 11.2% in November, an increase of 2.8 percentage points over the last year, as shown in today’s EPI Jobs Picture. The consequences of an auto industry collapse—which could eliminate up to 3.3 million U.S. jobs, as shown in the Briefing Paper When Giants Fall—would be nothing less than catastrophic for African Americans.
Why is it that the one thing the Republican caucus demanded – for the "health of the industry," we’re told — was that autoworkers take an immediate pay cut? They absolutely would not compromise. Why did they insist on spreading the debunked claim that autoworkers were making $73 an hour, and promulgate it with such spittle-flecked zeal?
Why did the very idea enrage them so?
Meanwhile, AIG is going to pay 168 of its top employees "retention bonuses" of between $96,000 and $4 million this year, yet there were no impassioned speeches by Richard Shelby in the Senate Press Gallery seething with moral indignation.
No, the outrage is saved for blue collar workers on the Detroit assembly line — who just happen to be disproportionately black — who not only aren’t getting bonuses, they’re told they have to be sin eaters for the banking industry and absorb the financial blow caused by Richard Shelby’s disgraced conservative anti-regulatory ideology by taking a wage cut. If not, they lose their jobs as the entire industry goes under.
GM confirmed today it will shut down most North American assembly plants for 30% of first quarter 2009.
Richard Shelby hates the Detroit automakers. He tries to dress his contempt up as concern for "fiscal responsibility" but that’s just Southern code for "you didn’t stand up to the unions, and you pay black people too much money."
His "fiscal responsibility" was nowhere to be found during George Bush’s 8 year budget bust-out. It doesn’t take too much imagination to figure out what he really means.



69 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Zed. and good job with the wingnut on msnbc. you were like a laser. or taser.
Jane !
Didja have fun debating Marcia Brady today ?
do you really think this is a race thing? Honestly, I see it as a class war and regional battle.
Also, Shelby did rail against the wall street bailout too. I gotta give him that. But he’s still a buffoon.
Corker is the one I have unbridled contempt for.
Race is much more sexy than class.
Was that today? Where can I see it? I don’t have cable so I have to be satisfied with web clips. I’d love to see her take on Shellface or Corkhead.
sbrrrrrrrrt – snerk!
actually I thought it was an accent thing, southern or foreign. so persuasive, ya know?
It’s a couple of threads back.
Swopa’s got it right here. just page back a few.
bbl, pups.
Actually it’s the link right at the bottom of this page.
Downstairs has a youtube clip of it…!
Our Government’s balance sheet is worse than any of the auto businesses. Since the Repubs want retired folks to forego their pensions, they need to do that also. In fact all Government employees should forego their pensions. This includes civil service and military. Somebody needs to let Corker know how much money this would save.
Jane, you are so right. What a great insight you have. We now have our 1st ever Black President Elect in the United States history and the Republicans want to punish the blacks for thir vote. Everything is political with them and this seems like a mean racial payback.
Thanks all. That’ll teach the top thread to grab my attention right off the bat.
What is it with the Rethugs and their obsession with blonde, lipless Skeletors?
Actually It would save the public a lot if congress had to punch a clock; get paid at the same rate as the KIA plant and get $25 a week for them to go buy their own health insurance. But lets not take it out on govt employees or military especially since my son is in the AF and my SIL is a programmer for FAA
Someone had to fill in for Coulter …
goes back to the whole Aryan supremacy thesis
Sen. Shelby should have to register as an agent of a foreign government!
Bob in HI
I can name 3 off the top of my head like that *snap*
Nancy Poppinpower (or whatever)
Dana Peroxide
Ms. Heritage VP
Stepford women.
I don’t want to take it out on anyone. Many employees stay with a company for years because of the pension. Unfortunately the Repubs think that those pensions should be meaningless. It’s time to ask the Repubs whether or not they would forego their benifits to save our country.
Geez, I saw a clip of her on Cavuto at Crooks & Liars. The woman just gets batshit crazier every year. At least she blurted out at one point that she didn’t know the source of the lie she had just told. Even Cavuto laughed in her face.
Hegelin, Ms Heritage VP, was scooping up decayed turds from her cesspool and trying to pass them off as gospel.
Conservative = authoritarian
The Flint Journal newspaper’s headline Dec 12, 2008
US Senate to Michigan
DROP DEAD
cutting off the country’s nose to spite a few unionized workers… our hate takes precedence over our patriotism: the rethug Prime Directive
http://www.mlive.com/flintjournal/
TV says Bush is coming back.
Republicans are despicable human beings.
Coming back to…?
from where?
That guy is so low he has to look up to see down.
I hate to use the word hate . . . but I hate the ones who are letting the auto industry die and allowing the economy to enter a death spiral. Hate.
In their infinite cluelessness they may very well have sparked a resurgence in union organizing. If we could only clean up the AFL-CIO and SEIU and switch to a solidarity unionism modality.
There is also the issue of aristocracy vs democracy. The “Old South” was definitely about aristocracy. The slaves were their serfs. Now the south has risen again, and they are jumping at the chance to spread serfdom “democratically”
Their hatred of unions, yes, is mixed up with their hatred of blacks.
But I think that underlying the racism is a more profound classism. They don’t want equality of any kind. They are perfectly willing to build lives of ease on the slavery of their fellow human beings.
They tell themselves that if they give someone 4 dollars for an hour of his life they haven’t made him a slave. They don’t even know what it costs per hour to simply be a person in this country.
So while there is definitely racism behind the actions of Southern Senators, I hope people don’t get distracted from the aristocratic classism that even underlies the racism.
I know this sounds dramatic, but: This is our existential issue as a country. Are we of, by, and for all the people? Or are we a nation of two classes — the people who count and the people who work like slaves to make the people who count comfortable?
It’s a story we’d love to hear told by Flannery O’Connor, and a drama made by August Wilson (both gone).
In Detroit, Dearborn, and Flint might be the grandchildren and great-grandchildren of the black families who trekked North like Jazz and found a better way of life, a hopeful one anyway. In most of the South are the grandchildren of poor white trash, resentful (but not in those words) of the runaways and traitors who made it out.
That reminds me of the anecdote about how Eleanor Roosevelt got FDR to bring indoor plumbing and electricity to the slums of DC, by shaming him maybe, and how one of FDR’s insiders protested the modernization because, Then how would people be able to know the difference between them and us?
Me too!! I hate the repubs!
They wouldn’t. They don’t think working people live in the same country they do. The way things are going, they are right.
Not dramatic, well said.
MSNBC Hildebrandt responding to Jane’s post
Uh oh, Jane! Hildebrand is confronted with your post on him…! ;-)
Just listened to CBS News with Katie Couric and they asked Bob Scheifer what his take was on the failure of providing loans to the U.S. auto industry and the asshole said nothing about breaking the unions just that the cracker Senators were expressing the “will” of their consituents who are opposed to the “bailout.” How long must the nation suffer these rich celebrities that are nothing more than spinmeisters for the status quo? They are merely foot soldier in the service of power and priviledge in the class war that the Republicans have been waging since the last great Depression.
Huh? He denies being in charge of the list, then, in the next breath he says he’s utilizing it…! WTF?
Don’t forget that a lot of those union organizers–those ‘outside agitators’–were also Jewish, as were a lot of those who headed down South to help with voter registration. Bigots are bigots and most of them in the South have migrated to the Republican Party, whose arms have been open and welcoming for several decades now. They can protest all they want about their ‘libertarian’ proclivities, but the fact is, the segregationist wing of the Democratic Party moved wholesale to the GOP brand with the active help of Pat Buchanan and the rest of the Republican racists and religious bigots back during the Nixon infection. In recent months, with the Obama phenom, we’ve seen them become more and more willing to say what they’re really thinking, and it hasn’t been pretty.
News Ass Bob Sheiffer faithfully slammed the UAW for the breakdown in the bridge loan on the Katy Couric “News” Show.
Sheiffer said, “Majority of Americans are opposed to the bailout“.
UAW won’t make concessions.
Republicans voted the way their constituents wanted them to.
Sheiffer said it so it must be true. /s
Froomkin on msnbc now
Froomkin on MSNBC
Bush is coming back from Texas and going back to DC. Congress is out of the negotations. Bush will do a deal to mirror the House Bill.
Froomkin = Bush has failed every test that doesn’t involve a mirror
1,854 DAYZ AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen Hamsher and the Firepup Freedom Fighters:
I surely do love the way you say things sister Hamsher but this is all stuff that all of us out here in the wreckage of democracy understand…but the complicity of the Democratic Party leadership in Congress succeeding in adroitly trianulating unions right out of politics during this current crisis is what is most illuminating today.
First of all, if it isn’t clear by now that One Hung Harry Reid and almost the entire senior Democratic leadership in the Senate must go then it never will be…but jest as importantly, Mrs. Pelosi and the rotting core of senior leadership in the House must also be pruned. The leadership of the two political parties share the same functional political ideology and owe their existance to the same oligarchy that replaced slavery with industrial capitalism in 1877.
Oh my, what to do, what to DO??!!!
It’s simple, bring the kids back from Iraq, reinstitute the draft and march a couple a battle tested infantry groups right through the heart of the New Confederacy. Not only will we emancipate the workers but we ken then finish the job of radical reconstruction that was interrupted in 1877.
Wake up Firepups, this is a war that we must finish before they are allowed to starve us into submission.
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION, NOT ALL FASCISTS CALL THEMSELVES REPUBLICANS!!
That’s how I see it. An overclass and underclass. If the foreign car companies were in different states it would be those senators acting up.
Except he will have to use Tarp funds
although I do like how Rachel Maddow put it on her radio show today…the Plantation caucus.
I see that as a bit of an upside. do you too?
From Michael Moore who is from Mi and made the movie of the auto industry “Roger and Me”.
Absolutely!
Another successful point for Shrub’s Legacy:
After Congress failed, I revitalized the auto industry with a single bold stroke of my crayola.
“The Plantation Caucus?”
Oh I’m so using that. Have been trying to come up with something good — that’s beyond my abilities.
Powerful stuff. Thanks for bringing over here.
Yeah, it just hits the mark, doesn’t it. That Rachel.
It was with an interview with Steve Bennett? I believe. with the washington journal I think? I’m sorry. I was in really stupid street traffic, quite annoyed with my fellow drivers and the content of the story. so aggravating. So I missed the gentleman’s name. But Rachel is the one who came up with Plantation caucus.
UAW Pres Ron Gettelfinger’s press conference, read my post # 135 or watch ithttp://www.wxyz.com/mostpopular/story/Gettelfinger-Calls-on-White-House-to-Act/se5LGnHlGEa-vfoa6JoCag.cspx . Here’s the first question, I have more to transcribe.
Corker tried to pull a fast one and do a deal with the UAW Pres Gettelfinger by himself and outside of Congress. Gettelfinger didn’t know who Croker was representing. Corker wanted to bust the UAW but it didn’t work. When Congress found out about his deal they said no deal, Corker couldn’t broker a deal without them. That must be why the vote was so odd.
dirty dirty dirty.
and Corker’s name is missing from those listed as holding the press conference…is that because he might be the one distributing the message??? as the junior member of the Plantation caucus?
Race and class can often not be separated, but they can nonetheless be used to divide. Don’t make this just about race, because it effects all union workers. I think you are trying to pigeonhole this battle in a way that is not helpful to those workers generally. The plantation caucus has its agenda and it is anti-black, but it is also anti-union and anti-”Yankee” (and I don’t mean the baseball team) all wrapped up in one big nasty Dixie-crat ball.
Hey, Jane!
How does it feel to become one of the Talking Heads on the TeeVee?
*G*
Congratulations!
Bob in HI
Giving “black auto workers the pink slip” is a bit of a stretch and taking us down memory lane to the civil rights struggles of African Americans is wholly irrelevant to what’s going on with the big 3. I’m gonna throw down some opinions here. 1.) There is no guarantee that even with a bailout that the big 3 will survive. If the business model doesn’t change dramatically, I’m guessing they won’t or will continue to operate by being subsidized by the taxpayer.
2.) Governments role in the Big 3’s decline isn’t being exposed enough. The big 3 ARE NOT good at building small cars at a profit. They lose $3,000.00 on every small car they are mandated to make to comply with CAFE standards.(which most Dems favor, and most Repubs oppose, I should add.) The cash cow for the Big 3 is SUV’s and Trucks. Big vehicles that can transport lots of people and pull boats. Far from hating on the union guys, me and my center-right friends kept them in business by buying these big vehicles. I dare say that there aren’t many F-150’s thundering through the streets of suburban D.C. You’ll see lots of Volvos there. Your side grinned when HUMMER production nosedived since it was “good for the planet.” Imagine that, a guy working in the truck plant in KY, and a tofu Liberal railing against the behemoths built by Detroit being aligned politically. Politics does make strange bedfellows.
I have been confusing myself by feeling guilty for *never* having ever owned a car … and planning never to own one. It’s nonsense to feel guilty for not doing ’my part’ to drive the economic engine.
Do/should others feel guilty that they bought the ’wrong’ cars or didn’t buy the ’right’ cars?
—————–
Unrelated?
We are all black now?
We are all facing economic suffering because of this insidious hatred and stupidity.
’Other’ morphs into race morphs into slaveholding morphs into underclass morphs into poor morphs into ’unworthy’ morphs into stupid morphs into a comfort of ’justified’ hatred.
Just so the ’winners’ can deny their own feelings of fear and anxiety and live in a bubble stolen from the rest of us.
If “pensions” are the problem why don’t the Red State Gooper fiscal heros forego THEIR federal and state pensions?
Let the foreign carmaker graft make up for the loss.
my email to Bob “Buster” Corker.
I am a union member from Tennessee. I did not vote for “bob the builder”, and he does not represent my values.
Not everyone from the south is anti-union.
http://corker.senate.gov/public/
$350 Billion of the $700 Billion for the bank bail out is lost. Washington expects the people to believe that nobody knows who has it or where it went? I would submit that one does not get to be as well off as Bob Corker by letting billions of dollars disappear. Thank you though Senator Corker, for standing quietly by as the banks lined their pockets while the American worker struggles to survive.
While at nearly the same time you vocally and vehemently oppose a loan for Detroit because you are anti-labor. Would bankruptcy/restructuring cost $35 billion dollars in tax payer money? Bankruptcy would probably cut out the investors(even though they knew the risk going in). Is it better to let the middle class bare the financial weight, even as you try to bust the union to cut wages and benefits, further burdening the middle class.
Shame on you Senator Corker. Shame on you for lying to America. Shame on you and everyone else who had a hand in stealing our money. Shame on you for trying to bust the UAW and hurt the American worker. To hear you berate and condemn the union for an economic crisis they did not make or choose was disgusting to say the least. A bipartisan economic crisis brought about by the policies of you and your ilk.
The voters spoke loud and clear in ‘08. I assure you Senator, the voters will not forget what they have witnessed and we will be heard again. Next election I will be voting strictly anti-incumbent.
Pat Buchanan has been telling us for years that we need to be more protectionist and the Republicans in general have been telling us we’re not patriotic while at the same time they’ve pushed ’free trade’ and now they’re trying to kill the American car companies & unions.
When will a Republican say it’s most important to save the American industry and push foreign car companies out?
Isn’t ”Country First” really important?
Where’s WalMart’s (not to pick on them) spokesman to crusade for ”Made in America” cars?
That’s my guess too.