This is a story that fits in with two themes we have been talking about a lot lately at the Lake: marriage equality for all people regardless of sexual orientation (aka the firestorm over Prop 8) and dirty smarmy backroom political deal (aka Blago).
However, this is not a depressing story of scandal. This is a story of a man choosing to give up a leadership post rather than submit to a backroom political deal that would deny marriage rights to all. And I’m proud to say, that story happened right here in New York.
For years, the Democratic party has been trying to re-take the NYS Senate. The NYS DSCC (formerly headed by David Paterson) raised money, found weak GOP incumbents, and recruited and supported candidates to run against them. When he left the Senate to become Lt. Gov., he prevailed upon his friend, the wonderful Liz Krueger, to take over for him.
And we made some gains. With the help of the New York Democratic Lawyer’s Council, which launched a massive voter protection/election integrity effort, Andrea Stewart Cousins was finally elected in Westchester, with hundreds of lawyers in the field. A few months later, with hundreds of lawyers out there again, Dems won a special election and sent Craig Johnson to the NYS Senate.
This last Election Day, under NYS DSCC leader Malcolm Smith, we finally elected a majority of Dems to the NYS Senate! Yippee! So, Malcolm Smith had every reason to believe that he would become Senate Majority leader.
Not so fast, three renegades–no doubt inspired by blackmailer-in-chief Joe Lieberman–decided that they "had something golden here" and they were not going to give it away for free. They demanded all sorts of committee appointments and even wanted Smith to divide the job of Majority Leader and "President Pro Tem" of the Senate into two jobs and give the PPT job to one of them, possibly making that person next in line to be Gov?
He caved in to all of it, until Rubin Diaz decided to hijack civil rights. Diaz wanted a promise that Smith would not allow gay rights legislation onto the Senate floor. Smith’s answer?
Smith said he has the support of the Democratic Caucus and has ceased negotiations with the three, Sen. Ruben Diaz Sr. and Sen.-elect Pedro Espada Jr., both of the Bronx, and Sen. Carl Kruger of Brooklyn. Their support would give the party a 32-30 majority beginning Jan. 1 after decades of Republican control.
Smith acknowledged that this means he won’t be Majority Leader this year.
"We’re prepared to wait if we have to, to come into the majority," Smith said. He was flanked by senators Neil Breslin of Albany and Liz Krueger of Manhattan when he made the announcement.
Smith said the three renegades were motivated by "personal interests." He also said he wouldn’t subject civil rights issues to negotiation, referring to a proposal backed by many Democrats to legalize gay marriage.
Smith is normally known as a pragmatic politician, but he is taking a principled stand here and I think he deserves credit for it. So, Senator Smith, bravo!
Today we received the following statement from Senate Democratic Leader Malcolm A. Smith.:
Yesterday, I made it clear that we have ceased negotiations on the leadership positions in the Senate Majority. My Conference and I will not distort our vision of government reform. I’m meeting with my members on our plans to move forward, to address the Governor’s executive budget and close the deficit that we face in New York.
Related posts:
- Is Joe Bruno the New York State Majority Leader in Exile? (And What Does That Mean for Gay Marriage?)
- Advice on Health Care Reform from Malcolm X: Don’t Be a Chump
- Rush Limbaugh: Sotomayor is a Threat to Republicans’ Civil Rights
- Von Spakovsky Accuses Obama Civil Rights Team of “Nakedly Political” Acts; NYT Fails to Note HvS’s Own Partisan Work
- Hey, Harry Reid, Stop Protecting Democrats Who Want to Filibuster the Public Option





Spotlight








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

Loosehead!
Amazing story – thanks for bringing this to light.
Digg please
Change we can believe in
1,854 DAYZ AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen looseheadprop and the Firepup Freedom Fighters:
Thank you so much Citizen lhp, we all needed a story like this today…and I am convinced that there really is a growing corps of younger, committed citizens bubbling up in state and local politics all over the country. I am, however, confused, what is gunna happen now in the New York Senate…who controls the committees now and who’s gunna get Davis Patterson’s back up there in Albany. I’ve long thought that New York has gotten jest about as corrupt in its state politics as Illinois but both states look like enlightenment utopias compared to the glowing pile of toxic waste down in the New Confederacy!
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION, THEY AREN’T GIVIN’ US A CHOICE HERE!!
So do these renegades have names? I doubt that many of us would recognize them but something I decided from my scandals list was that if there was a name it should be put out there to be part of the record.
Not only is it honest politics, but when they finally get a majority it has a better chance of being a real majority.
Hmmm … Mr. Smith goes to Albany … sounds good.
Excellent point.
I believe these are the three…
Weekly roundup NewsHour with Shields and Brooks
Shields: Good faith effort by WH but Senate (not Republicans) wouldn’t budge.
Brooks: Corker had a good plan, autoworkers take a $10 pay cut to spread the pain around. Doesn’t really explain who else, maybe shareholders, will take a bath. Won’t say if he thinks it’s important that the American industry survive, just people will need to buy cars, i.e. foreign models.
Shields: Look how the easy time no strings treatment of the financial community.
Brooks: Laughs investors felt pain.
Shields: Repeats, no questions asked, just given the money
Brooks: I’m just following the Conventional Wisdom here but Detroit has had problems for years blah blah.
Then on to Blago, apparently they agree he was corrupt. How insightful is that.
Bobo is just being Bobo, but, Shields has no excuse… Tho, as per your recap at least he does point out the discrepancy between the financial bailout and the Detroit bailout…
Takin’ names and kickin’ ass!
Yeah Smith!
Nice of you LHP to highlight a ‘do gooder.’
Wow, a good news story! Thanks LHP.
Hey, that’s my state senator!