So, George Bush and the Republicans have said they don't want to give bridge money to the Big 3 to help them get through this downturn, or at least till Obama can restructure them properly. Nope, the 3 million job losses and two hundred billion cost of letting them go under is ok by Bush and Congressional Republicans. Hey, those suckers didn't vote for them anyway.
I can only read this as union hatred. The Big 3 have a unionized workforce (one which has made concessions which put it on par in cost with Japan's workforce, mind you) and unions are EVIL. So who cares about all the people in all the supply firms who will lose their jobs, all the counties, cities and towns which will become ghost towns, or any of that.
No cost is too high for Americans who didn't vote Republican to pay, if it takes out a major union.
Note that the cost of bridge money to get the Big 3 (GM in particular) to where the new Congress and President can pass a bill to restructure them for long term viability is about 20 or 30 billion. Considering 700 billion has been put aside for financial firms who are paying themselves 70 billion in bonuses, you'd think the money could be found.
And Paulson and his enabler, Barney Frank, can spare me the cries of how their corrupt money pool was only supposed to be used for financial firms. In fact it was supposed to be used to buy up distressed assets, and now isn't being used for that, but as a slush fund. It can be used for anything the Secretary of the Treasury wants it to be used for. Barney wrote it that way, after all. And if it wasn't for the financial crisis killing the economy and car loans, the Big 3 wouldn't be in half this much trouble.
But hey, lavish retreats for AIG executives and making sure Wall Street gets the bonuses it is accustomed to is much more important than 3 million jobs or keeping a strategic industry like the auto business alive. Or even paying 20 billion now to avoid paying 200 billion to clean up the collapse, after which you're left with a completely devestated state with no jobs, in the middle of what is going to be the worst post WWII recession.
Too bad for the Big 3 that Republicans hate unions more than they love Americans.
Login Here
Spotlight



Support this site!
Keep
up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search


RSS/XML Feed
GAH!
Thanks Ian.
No thanks, George Bush.
Digg please
Dugg. Thanks for the link.
Thanks Ian.
this is definately their last throws to get rid of unions in america
the democrats need to get a bill done and pronto
bzzzzzz bzzzzz bzzzz bzzzz
Ouch!
Yep, that pitchfork is mighty sharp now.
Innocent whistling.
Eliminate criminal Republicans then start new. I could take years to restore economic democracy so let’s start now. Maybe a Gitmo like prison for Republican ‘economic-terrorists’?
Pottery Barn rule v. 2.0: We broke it, but now you own it. Good fucking luck.
Well said, but IMO should read, “No cost is too high for all Americans
who didn’t vote Republicanto pay, if it takes out a major union.”Putting our country into a depression is not too high a price for killing one of the few unions left. And, as detailed above, the sad fact is that rescuing the industry would require what amounts to chump change compared to the cost of bailing out the financial aristocracy.
Okay, so we get to blame the perfect economic storm on the Repugs.
I suggest Obama and any congressional leaders who were for the buy-out meet with a coalition of governors and development leaders along with the UAW in order to come up with combined state plans. Side-step the Federal government.
Lets see 3 million workers * $50,000 per year spending that would be about one hundred and fifty billion dollars taken out of the economy. Good work bushy
“I can only read this as union hatred.”
I’ll go a step further: They’re already thinking two years down the road. When the economy is still in the tank, the thugs can turn people’s misery to their political advantage and run on the old “what you need is more tax cuts” mantra.
hearing with bernanke, paulson and bair:
paulson says it’s important to stick with the original purpose of the tarp (bailing out his buddies at GS).
Eggzacktly.
Ian, some of the interesting discussion this morning at Attaturks, apologies for the EPU’dness
What would be your thoughts?
It really is time to start swinging people by ropes from light poles ala Mussolini.
I saw Senator Shelby from Alabamy all over the networks yapping against helping the US car companies. Of course nobody asked him how many foreign, non-union car companies are operating in Alabamy. That might require a bit of thought and real journalism which the US clearly doesn’t have.
Damn the US media disgusts me!
Didn’t you hear? The Revolution was canceled…
What will the bailout do though? Are we going to continue to pay these employees to make cars that are already backed up in inventory, nobody wants, and nobody can afford? or do we pay them to stand around and do nothing
Reissued due to popular demand (?)
Yep, the Rethugs have the unions exactly where they want them. Let’s go ahead and get this Depression started. After all, the 30s were a beehive of union activity in this country, but it was a different time, lots of socialist immigrants from Europe, fascism developing in Germany and Italy. Of course, Americans today tend to be a bit spoiled; they couldn’t or wouldn’t get rid of the Fuhrer in office now and let fascism run rampant during the last 8 years. I stopped being a registered Dem and went Unaffiliated on July 5, 2007, when Nancy announced her table was clean…
Cheney and Gonzales have been indicted in Texas today. We needed ths kind of good news today.
Sorry for being off topic, I think it’s worth it.
Had about 15 minutes this morning. So I figured, being editor, I’d errm, take advantages of the privileges of my position and give it just a bit more time.
Keynes said when all else fails, hire people to dig holes then fill them back up again.
So yes, it is worthwhile to pay them to do nothing to get thru the crisis. After that it’ll be time to reassess.
Listening to senate hearing on auto industry reminds me that all cyclical industries get religion on the downside of the cycle. So if & when the economy recovers & we want those jobs, it’ll be a better industry with better products.
I’d rather not go through a complete collapse. It may happen whether we like it or not. Bernanke and Paulson’s actions have been intended to make sure that either it doesn’t happen, or if it does, that the rich are protected. That has been job one for them, and their actions make it very clear.
“Editorial discretion.” (It is a good post, deserves more than 15 minutes of fame.)
Some workers will be laid off, just as they would have been otherwise, but the companies will remain going concerns. In the case of GM, we bridge to the Volt, in particular. In all of them we use them to restructure the US automobile market to much higher fuel efficiency, among other things.
Glad you did. Busting the autoworkers union would top the air traffic controllers by miles. A major feather in corporatist bonnets.
Ian,
What are the consequences in a modified capitalistic system of government’s rewarding bad corporate behavior.
Not immediate consequences. Long-term consequences.
Bush has indicated that he would be willing to convert the $25B that has been voted to help the big 3 to retool to help the auto industry now. Could that be done and then on Jan 21 replenish that?
Oh my . . . . Cheney and Gonzo indicted. How can that be?
The pardon clock is running.
Would druther not myself, but if that is what it takes to oust the bastards, I’d like to see them go the way the feudal lards went, where they were no more than an impertinency.
sounds good to me. this afternoon is good timing as we listen to the senate banking hearing.
Yes, Paulson is dedication itself when it comes to bailing out the banking system in behind the scenes totally opaque deals. Keeping the rest of the economy from depression, hey not his problem.
These are state charges, Deb.
The pardon clock does not apply — Bushie only has the power to pardon offenses against the Federal Gummint.
This is delish.
US democracy! We’re all porn
starsextras; we just don’t know it. Yet.A suck-y day finds a silver lining, and beyond the pale of Whitehouse sway. delish indeed.
Naw. It’s a flakey from the getgo.
http://www.talkingpointsmemo.c.....244949.php
Ooooh. Dodd is pretending to care about auto workers.
yum!!!!! Way too much to hope for.
Geez, congress takes next to no time to give Paulson a blank check on $700 billion to dole out to the people he pals around with on Wall St., and wastes an entire afternoon on $25 billion for the auto industry.
Spit.
Aw, shucks and boogers.
Unions are being recognized as a corpse that is being swept from the soil while reports and citz and water bottles are kept out of New Orleans.
Sadly we do not as a people come to our brothers and sisters aid while they are in need - now they are coming for us.
The tech bubble was a bxtch slap to the genius workers, the housing bubble was collusion. People that have only been saving or living in the workforce for 10 or 12 years have nothing.
Boomers thought they were going to skate to the end and leave the bill - they will silly, they got smacked in the mouth as well. I have spoken to many that think as long as we keep bombing and even nuke people if needed as long as they can retire its all good - wow were they way off base.
not just an afternoon. tomorrow morning too - when the same folks testify before barney frank’s house financial services committee.
Look at UK’s economy from 1968 through 1978. Complete industries vanished. Incompetent management continue to burn cash in an unprofitable business.
Are the Republicans whigging out?
I’m wondering about the political consequences. Does the GOP think they can own killing US automobiles now and crawl out from under in two years wtih promises of tax cuts? I hear and see them practically screaming DIE! DIE! DIE, worhtless US auto industry! for the last few days. Suppose one or more of the big three is liquidated. In two years, lots of unemployed, early involuntarily and incnoveniently retired auto workers are gong to want lower taxes on their non-existent union pay?
That doesn’t add up to me. Seems to me like the GOP has lost its mind. When will Michigan, Ohio and Indiana be swing states again? Or, am I missing something?
Oh man, I just heard it was gonna start in a thread downstairs about 5 minutes ago. Now it’s already canceled? What’s the fun in that? Do I have to return the pitchfork?
I suspect Democrats in Congress will vote money for an auto bailout, but I don’t think they can justify using TARP monies since there is no convincing evidence that the failure and disappearance of the car companies endangers the economic system.
However, Paulson is an idjit if he can’t read the name Troubled Assets Relief Program when he says TARP isn’t intended for buying up ‘troubled assets’. It was meant originally to buy up toxic assets and then helping financial firms to keep the money flowing was added. TARP is for both.
Now he says they have pretty well stabilized financial firms and they’re guaranteeing loans & stuff, so it’s clearly time to work on mortgage workouts. Paulson says there isn’t enough money for buying them up, but he is ignoring the FDIC workout program where much less money is required.
The Other Plan to Save Detroit
It looks like the folks in DC are hell-bent to give the stimulus package another try seeing as the first one didn’t have any real effect.
At the same time, the Democrats owe too much to the unions not to save the auto industry.
Let’s combine the two, give the economy a boost and save over a million jobs all at once.
Consider the following:
Manufacturing costs of motor vehicles are 65% labor (i.e.: W-2 income), that’s not all direct but due to suppliers. GM alone has over 1300 suppliers. (That’s a lot of jobs!)
1 in 10 Americans makes all or part of their income due to the automobile industry.
Money turns over 5 times in a year.
Thus a vehicle with a manufacturing cost of 20K produces 13,500 in W-2 income which in turn becomes a total of 65K in 12 months due to the 5 turnovers.
(This isn’t magic, it’s simply how the economy works.)
Our domestic car makers are saddled with legacy costs, most of which will reduce dramatically in 2010 due to contract changes.
They need to survive to get there.
This whole mess is not solely due to the unions
It would be easy to simply blame the unions; and it’s certainly not my job to defend them; however as it regards the current mess in Detroit, the facts get in the way.
The UAW has already made massive concessions some of which are already being implemented and others are timed to roll in over the next year or so.
Our own over-zealous government with an alphabet soup of regulatory agencies has been no help either.
Foreign competitors have worked off-shore collectively to meet various US gov’t. imposed emission and safety standards, thus dramatically reducing those R&D costs.
American car companies are prohibited from that by our FTC.
Make no mistake; it’s no surprise that once again government has been a major part of the problem.
Here’s the solution.
Instead of either shipping cases of cash off to car makers; or sending us all another check:
Send out a voucher for say $1,000 good on a motor vehicle for the percentage of the vehicle that’s domestic. (Civic = 70% Ford Explorer=80%)
Let those not interested in a new car sell or give away their vouchers (Ebay would be loaded with them in no time flat) and those that are so inclined can use as many as they can get their hands on up to the full MSRP of the vehicle.
This would bail out the car industry without giving them a dime directly
Further it would reduce the overall age of the nation’s cars which would in turn;
increase overall fuel economy & decrease pollution.
Strengthen the dollar!
Since vehicles with a higher domestic content would be moving better this would reduce our imports, strengthening our dollar which would in turn further reduce what we pay for anything imported …like gas!
Jobs
Instead of simply bailing out a few big companies, this would cause such a run that it would create employment throughout the industry affecting over 1300 suppliers and their workers.
That would give the economy good swift kick right where it needs one!
Pays for itself!
Since money turns over 5 times, and the vouchers are only good for the domestic content of the vehicle, every dime would be spent in the United States creating taxable income.
What is the income tax on 65,000 anyway?
(Remember? 20K manufacturing cost = $13,500 W-2 income x 5 = $65,000)
Another Stimulus Package?
I’m sure you’ll agree that this makes more sense than simply sending out checks; many of which will be used to buy new flat screen TV’s usually made in Malaysia or some such place.