By now, you’ve read enough that I don’t have to tell you the story of Ashley Todd (who appears to be a creature of Mssrs Rove’s and Abramoff’s and Reed’s College Republicans. If you’re new to this, scroll down to today’s earlier posts. I’ll wait) and her evolving imaginary Obama-supporting assailant out of wingnut fantasy central casting, and you all have strong opinions about it, and I’d love to hear them. The person whose thoughts I’d most like to hear, though, is the first man I thought of when Ms. Todd’s story started to become increasingly lurid as the day progressed.
I’d like to hear from William Bennett
The classic suburban nightmare: White yuppie couple Chuck and Carol Stuart go home to suburban Massachusetts from a birthing class at an inner city hospital. Black everyman, 5’5", 150-165 lbs., with a raspy voice and a ubiquitous black jogging suit with red stripes, abducts the couple, robs them, and forces them to drive back to his "home turf" of Mission Hill. There, with no witnesses, he shoots the pregnant wife in the head and her husband in the stomach, a surprisingly flexible move from the back seat. He then runs off to the sanctity of his crime-ridden, drug-infested neighborhood…
The country was stunned and outraged by this senseless, random murder of both mother and baby. The familiar call for the reinstatement of the death penalty was heard, and the Boston police, aware that the eyes of the nation were upon them, rose to the occasion by initiating what is affectionately called the "stop-and-search" method: the idea being that if you stop every black man within a ten-mile radius, you are going to find your killer much more quickly. Civil liberties thus suspended, a number of black jogging-suit-clad men soon turned up. One might think that perhaps the easiest, most definitive (and legal) method of identification would have been to show Chuck mug shots… but he was apparently too weak and then too emotionally exhausted to take part. On Nov. 15, Willie Bennett, arrested on other charges, emerged as the prime suspect—thanks in part to the fine work of the Boston police who had thrown his 63-year-old mother against the wall and trashed her apartment. On Dec. 28, a rejuvenated Chuck Stuart picked Willie Bennett as the man who most closely resembled their attacker. The case was progressing to its inevitable and just conclusion.
And then it fell apart. Matthew Stuart, Chuck’s brother, identified Chuck as the real killer. Now Chuck Stuart has killed himself, Willie Bennett was freed, and the whole web of lies is finally being exposed.
Matthew Stuart was the brother of the murderer, and he confessed to helping his brother cover up the murder of his pregnant sister-in-law. Which was a good thing for William Bennett, because at the time the newspapers were reporting that he was at the point of being indicted for murder.
It was unfortunate for African-American young men in the Boston area who resembled the vague description Stuart gave police that Matthew didn’t discover his conscience earlier.
As remarkably revealing as Ms. Ashley’s behavior in this situation was – karma’s a bitch, and now we know who she works for – I find this, from the Politico, even more remarkable
Seems like McCain just can’t catch a break.
Pittsburgh station KDKA reports that Ashley Todd, the 20-year-old McCain volunteer who claims to have been mugged by a black man and had a "B" carved in her face, today admitted to fabricating the attack.
Geez. Poor luckless bastard. His campaign worker wasn’t actually carved up by a hulking black guy. Can’t win for losing.
Ladies and gentlemen, I give you Serious Journalism. And he got the story from Drudge! Oh, and the McCain campaign.
Me, I kinda feel as if you send the law out hunting for people who are less challenged in the area of melanin because you figure it’ll get you a few votes, it’s not a woopsy when you get caught. It’s more like cosmic justice, or at least really, really good literary symmetry.
If you think of it as an incomplete forward pass, you may be Serious.
Please leave your own frivolous thoughts below.
Related posts:
- Chuck Todd: When You Tell People What’s in the Health Bill, They Like It
- Teabagging Rep. Todd Akin Recites Pledge to “Drive Liberals Crazy,” Then Botches the Words
- Late Late Night FDL: Rahm Emanuel’s Karma Baby
- DC Teabagging crowd estimate pegged at 8675309 because it “has a good beat and you can dance to it”
- Come Saturday Morning: Is This Really What You Want, Wingers?






Spotlight







Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

julia!
From what I observe here at the University of Montana, she qualifies as an A-list College Republican. Most of ours have trouble tying their shoelaces, let alone coming up with something like this.
Hey, Bets
I don’t get it. What on earth could be going on inside your head? Someone who didn’t commit a crime could go to jail for many, many years, but hey, you Made Your Point.
Do what now?
Meanwhile, persons opposed to electing Obama have harassed early voters at polling places; have slashed tires at Obama rallies; have hung Obama in effigy; and have slaughtered a bear cub to make their alleged point. When is Drudge going to cover real campaign violence?
I can hear the crickets now.
I think that the College Republicans are dropped on their heads from the top of the tallest building on campus as part of the initiation.
just another case of “blame the black guy” eh?
IOKIYAR
I dunno. many many moons ago I used to be one (fell into being a rethug by birthright, without having any idea what it meant). neither did anyone else in the club at the time, and this was in Bush I’s reign, when nobody had any clue who was what anyway. most of the club members were nice bookish types. the membership overlapped heavily with the journalism club and madrigals for some reason. it was all quite innocuous, and membership made our parents happy
Twice today by yours truly and once by punaise, my frivolous thought (courtesy darkblack)
an actual College Republican or someone who was in college and was a Republican?
Ashley B. has been identified as a “full time field representative of college Republicans”. I did find this.
A lot of prosecutors build their resumes like that. A win is a feather in your cap and a loss is a black eye… So what if innocent people suffer?
Thank goodness in this instance it doesn’t appear many people found her story credible. I doubt if the McCain campaign, Drudge, or Fox News did either. Like crooked prosecutors, they don’t care as long as it advances their agenda.
‘course I was 17 at the time…
Things have gone downhill considerably since your day I fear. Of course, this is Montana, where moderate Republicans are to the right of Attila the Hun and our hard right thinks Dr. Mengele is a liberal.
no.. I was admittedly a card carrying Club member when I was a 17 yr old freshman
I think the idea that Politico is rumored to be hiring does not bode well for the Republic. Journamilizm, yes. The future of the Republic, no.
So they think the Nazis were so far to the right that they actually come out on the left? Jonah Goldberg should sue for infringement on his psuedointellectual property.
Of course it could mean that in light of developments in this electoral cycle they have decided to sack their entire staff and start over from scratch. 8-)
A few great graphics about the Mc$hame campaign and Ashley Todd. One in the post and one in the comments. (note: self-promotion)
So some frumpy 20 yr old college repug…… who again probably didn’t have a date for the weekend……. decides to make herself a celebrity and what they hay…… them brown people are guilty of something……
After all she is a white woman….. why wouldn’t they believe her….. OH sh*t….. that “B” is backwards……. OH….. no ATM video….. EVEN I know that you don’t claim an ATM mugging and think the police wouldn’t be looking at some video….. Is it only liberals who watch Law & Order and CSI?
I would love to see Pantload try to serve that one. Our hard right up here are the black helicopter-militia-patriot movement-Aryan Nations crew. There are hundreds of them up in northwest Montana, mostly living entirely off the grid in heavily armed, well stocked compounds.
Excellent! You done good.
thanks!
Note to Ashley… next time you scratch up your face in the mirror remember everything is backwards in the your reflection. Shoulda gone for the “O”.
Hawaii has many individuals living off-grid in the boonies, but, they’re hard left…! ;-)
Yepper, all the tires are flat on the old “Straight Talk Express” and the driver has passed out with his foot to the floor. There’s a tree dead ahead, this isn’t gonna be pretty.
You got too many of them dark skinned folks to attract our crazies. They like Montana because it is one of the whitest places in America and there are almost as many bears as people.
Everyone should take a moment to view TexBetsy’s two graphics on this topic. Well worth the diversion!
Heh, They wouldn’t survive the natives…! ;-)
From RawStory here is yet another Republican Dirty Trick. Thugs vandalize an Obama yard sign. But it is just a cheap sign. Mine cost $6. They could be Democratic double agents!
Or perhaps Ashley B. Todd trained them since she was a fulltime contract employee. So many mysteries to solve! So few internet toobz.
They tend to prefer the company of grizzlies to people. Have more in common with them.
Or maybe Ashley Todd and her twin sister work for the Banzai Institute:
julia – great post – i dugg it
and I imagine that the bears are nicer than the rethugs
Sorry, it seems I don’t know how to post a link.
http://www.neweyestudio.com/ebayL/ebl227.jpg
Have a better disposition and are slightly less dangerous than Montana Republicans.
hehe… any possibility of providing a high respond version of that poster for downloading. I wouldn’t mind putting it up on my office door or something… maybe I’ll get lucky and a current generation College Republican will walk by and deface it
Y’know, I agree that she appears to be seriously unstable, but as a happily-married, gainfully-employed, I’d like to think reasonably stable, out and proud frumpy person, I have to say that it isn’t necessarily a character flaw :)
Has everyone else seen this? It is a HOOT!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7DIc8jdra0o
text
take out the spaces, and that’s a link.
And it’s a hell of a lot easier to live off the grid in the tropics than on the Canadian border.
A decent rifle, a taste for wild boar and goat …
From the CBS news link; “She was upset with the media for blowing this into a political firestorm.”… sounds like Joe the Plumber has a soul mate; maybe they can pen their memoirs together.
Of course we have huge herds of white tail and mule deer, elk, and big horn sheep, lots of moose, huge flocks of ducks and geese (not to mention dozens of prime trout streams). Lots of the rednecks around here bag half the year’s meat supply during hunting season.
neither was originally mine
Sssh! Don’t want to advertise that too much! ;-)
I think both images perfectly convey the fraudulent nature of the McCain campaign. They deserve to go viral.
In the Palin household, they call Montana “a grocery run.”
Oxdown.
Hannah?
And it regularly drops below 0 F there. CTuttle sees 0 F now and then, but only because he’s working at 13,000 feet or so…
Everybody needs to just lighten up on Ashley “B” Todd
She needs professional help.
;~P
Not where I am, but it is considerably colder than where CT is.
Who’d advertising? I learned to hunt on the Big Island. If you can hit on of those goddam goats with a medium bore rifle, a deer’s nothin.
I never did get to hunt boar, though. Too dangerous, per my father. He also didn’t hunt boar…
As the Queen of fump….. as Suzanne will attest to…..
it is the lack of thinking the idea that you could make a false police report of a mugging, sexual assault and that she could think that she could get away with this…… as a nurse who took care of victims of assault and rape…… this makes me sick that a woman would file a false claim…..
This degrades those women who have suffered and survived their attacks…….
Banzia worked.
? Huh….
Oh c’mon. Billings has to get way colder than Manhattan, KS. And we saw the wrong side of 0 several times a winter, and single digits way too much in Jan and Feb…
I hunted boar down in Ka’u with just dogs and a bowie knife with my friends…! ;-)
Since it backfired completely, I don’t really care much more than when Bugs sticks his finger in the barrel and Elmer Fudd gets a face full of powder. The fact that it actually served to further discredit the McCain campaign for promoting the story is a bonus.
Is that hard to do? Does it get you?
Apparently Unka KKKarl’s Big Book of Ratfucking for Boys and Girls omits the most important components. Don’t do anything that creates an evidence trail … claiming sexual assault gets the authorities involved in a big way.
The prototype op was Rove’s bugging his own office in the Texas Governor’s race. He made sure the evidence was discovered not by the authorities, but by a pet private security firm.
That’s really hard on dogs…
Billings and elsewhere in eastern Montana gets a lot colder than here in western Montana. We are in a slightly different climatic zone and do not get those arctic fronts (they slide down the east side of the mountains) that plague eastern Montana and the rest of the Plains (all the way down to Oklahoma where I grew up). Missoula is in a sheltered valley and has milder weather than most of western Montana. I think I could count the number of times it has dropped below zero in the ten years I have been here on one hand. Down into the upper teens is pretty common in January, but subzero is rare.
the attention should be on the mcpalin campaign here… for jumping on Todd’s racebaiting express without a heatbeat’s hesitation, common sense or conscience
I like it. KInda reminds me of A for Adultry. But this is nicer –
B for Buttfucked backwards.
They were hunting dogs, but, I agree, sometimes we had to put ‘em down because they were gored pretty bad… That was also in my exuberant youth…! ;-)
Okay, I obviously had U Montana misplaced…
Just looks like it could be interesting as an Oxdown diary.
If you know what you are doing, it is pretty easy. Because our herds are large each person can get several deer and elk, as well as a moose. Bighorn tags are harder to get, but there are lots of them and the snow drives them down to lower elevations. While I like game meat, I no longer hunt (gave it up about 20 years ago when I moved to Chicago). I am more than willing to accept the odd steak or roast from friends who do, however.
Have you read Lois Yamanaka’s Heads by Harry?
No I haven’t! I recognize Yamanaka’s name tho…!
Oh I feel so cheap having to cite POLITICO. They do say that Crazy John and Saks 5th Avenue Sarah talked to the family of the victim, Ashley B.
Yeah, agreed on that.
I just fear a bit for this child – granted she seems as if she’s willing to be more of a danger to others than herself, there’s something seriously bent in a person who thinks the risks to innocent people is worth her game, or doesn’t think at all.
I mean, someone could have gone to jail over missy’s amateur ratf*ck. It’s a huge indictment of that school of political thought that someone who’s supposed to be in their idealistic years didn’t even consider that.
The first thing I thought this morning when i saw the backward B on her face was she did it herself. I’m thankful the police weren’t as stupid as the republics are.
Yeah, saw that. I wonder if they feel more sorry for McCain getting burned on this or themselves?
She’s a Hilo Intermediate/Hilo High alum … has written some good Hawaiiana. The only one I’ve been able to lay hands on is HbH. It was great, like going home again.
If I live to be 100, I’ll remember seeing the Hilo High Production of As You Like It, reset on the Big Island and performed in pidgin.
Wrong side of the state. I have only been to Billings once (drove through when I moved out here) and have never had any desire to repeat the experience. I try very hard to stay on this side of the divide. The pass leading into Missoula is the Hellgate and we know which side hell lies on. 8-)
Thank God nobody African American got lynched I want McCain to talk to his supporters Chicago Style about their hate.
Or is John not Man enough to handle delivering bad news?
Not. Gonna. Happen.
McCain can not be held liable for all the things people do on his behalf./s
Having grown up in Minnesota, I remember the drill. I only remember the dead deer, and being forced to eat freezer-burned venison.
The strangest thing about visiting the islands is that I still understand pidgin. I don’t speak it very well any more, but I understand it. I find myself breaking into it after three-four days in the Islands. Especially when I’m not on Oahu.
I know
Not gonna happen. He will go out yelling “not like us” at the top of his lungs. He’s lost it all – his name, his honor, probably his wife and certainly the election.
But Obama can and should be.
He and Sarah are instigating their supporters to riot. If this had happened after a McCain/Palin rally he might be liable. Or rather Cindy would be because she has more cash.
I wonder if she’s going to get expelled over this.
has the straight talk express issued a statement over this since she recanted?
I have hunted and dressed deer when I still lived in Oklahoma. I really like it. Elk is good as well, though I am not all that wild about antelope.
They just had another production of it, last month! In fact, my eldest, who’s in grad school now, did it when she was a member…! ;-)
His wife? What have you heard? I’m not sure if that is good or bad. Although a certain Lobbyist might welcome the news.
You really think Cindy’s going to dump his ass? I don’t — I think she’s the perfect little Stepford wife.
Besides that, she owes him big-time for keeping her drug-addicted ass out of prison.
He never had any honor. The reason he will not do anything is that he secretly wants them doing shit like this to stir things up and excite the crazies in the base.
good night pups. attending a bar mitzvah in the morning.
There literally will be hell to pay when Obama wins. I expect at least random acts of violence by these lunatic he has set loose.
Is she at UofH or on the mainland? What’s she studying?
Night Betsy.
Hey, mean to ask, because the news reporting on the Islands is probably better than here. Any word on how Obama’s abuelita is doing?
In specific cities… at specific points in time….. someone could of been killed…….. some gun toting wackadoodle could of taken the law into their own hands……
Someone’s life could of been ruined…… someone’s family could of been ruined… It is that lack of thinking of the consequences of your actions that truly astounds me……
I think they detest each other but are enablers. She should leave him – give him a house, a car and go. What I meant is that she probably would have liked to live in the WH and is not going to – therefore, most everything is gone for her now. Very bleak life ahead if she stays with him.
She’s in Ohio, She’s a Toledo Zip, studying for her master’s in Psych, with a PHD in sight if she can…!
The only reporting is on Obama spottings here and there, no word on Tutu’s condition…!
The woman who did this needs help, but her personality type is indicative of the republic base. These people are willing to lie their asses off, and are willing to vote for someone who is a known liar. What does that say for America?
Yeah I bet Karl and Peggy will use the violence as a warning that Obama should not go to far Left.
I think Obama should set the FBI on all the racist groups starting with the college republicans.
I agree she needs help is she getting a psyche evaluation?
Good luck to her! Is she coming back to the Islands when she’s done?
I think the college republics should be infiltrated like the peaceful anti war protesters were. They could be domestic terrorists.
The end justifies the means? Lies, robo calls, carving your face, death threats the GOP are terrorists.
I believe she is.
College Republicans filed under Known Hate Groups.
I’d like to see that.
Agreed:)
I would love to find out what is wrong with her.
Probably not, except to visit…! Not sure where she’ll settle down, Ohio blew us away when she graduated from UH-H, we’d assumed Manoa…!
I fear that the forces McCain have unleashed are beyond anyone’s control at this point. He has enabled, empowered, and legitimized the far rightwing fringe dwellers and they now they are going to be pursuing their own agenda, which emphatically does not include a black man in the White House. They are and always have been the greatest terrorist threat to America. The Atlanta Olympics, Murrah Office Building, and the abortion clinics may well make a resurgence.
They’re shocked, presumably in the Casablanca Claude Rains sense.
It’s just a little hard for me to believe that they hired this woman to recruit college students to the campaign (according to that nice Mr. Fournier’s AP) and nobody noticed she was, um, excitable.
I would love to find out what is wrong with anyone who could possibly even consider voting for Mcnutjob.
Why stop with the College Republitards? The whole GOoP should be declared a hate group.
“Excitable” is a feature, not a bug. They are looking for fanatics.
That and an ongoing criminal enterprise. RICO, bitches, RICO!
Ding! Unfortunately!
You don’t know what we know about CindyLou here in Arizona ……..
They live apart….. and there are hits that there might be male companionship here for her….. She owns the purse strings, the property and after this election….. there isn’t much more for McCain but retirement….
It’s tough to find your way back as an academic. I applied for a couple of open faculty positions that I was qualified for in the U of H system but never got a nibble.
True but such a provocation could give the FBI every excuse they need to Party on Domestic Terrorists with the New Anti Terror Laws that Bush pushed through.
I bet a lot of GOPers will suddenly care about civil rights.
Obama needs someone good at the FBI.
Send your Pennies to Bush’s kids.
Still not healed from the flu. Gnite pups.
There is no reason for her to keep him if she isn’t going to be first lady. I’m sure he’d have been long gone by now if not for that.
I agree that the FBI needs to make these whackjobs a priority. Bush has largely ignored them in favor of pursuing bogus brown skinned “terrorists.” Couldn’t afford to alienate “the base”.
Night!
CBS’s Harry Smith singing a country tune with a nice beat
Red State Blue State Blues
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_rIgWvx38vM
I think her putting the cry for help (if that’s what it was) into a political context is a pretty good indication what is wrong with her, but IANAS.
I can recall a
defense attorneyveterinarian saying once that “allmurderspoodles arehomicidesdogs, but not allhomicidesdogs aremurderspoodles.”Boy, karma is really a bitch, isn’t it?
Check out Raymond Crump, a black man tried for the murder of JFK’s favorite girlfriend, Mary Pinchot Meyer.
http://www.spartacus.schoolnet.co.uk/JFKmeyerM.htm
Good night, my friends.
We can only hope.
This is what the debate should have looked like !
*spew warning*
Nite Bargain.
Night.
Aloha, BCT!
Thats a good one!
I think I will turn in as well. Take care all.
Aloha, Dr. D!
Hi pups late but never too late to visit the Lake! How are the good pups doing this fine Friday evening??
And as to this person(Ashley Todd) who would make such claims as she has, well looks like Justice is being administered to her for her lies and deception!
Everybody’s gone to bed, it seems.
;~P
Almost everybody!
I’m here, lurking. But trying to pay attention to some good tv.
Still up ….. getting more Pellegrino…..
nahant!
Disturbed or not, the young lady needs some ‘time’ to work things out.
Funny – if this story had been reversed, it would be akin to a terrorist act if the GooperStruppen had their way.
There is such a thing?
PBS?
WHAT on a Friday Night?? Boy I thought it would be time to party!!
That was for Christine
Is it late night nude drunk blogging nite, or is that Saturday? I forget.
Yes,until 11:00, and then to HBO for Bill, and random stuff from there…
I think that is Saturday late late nite IIRC!
‘Now’ w/David Brancassio, Bill Moyers, Foreign Exchange w/Dhaljit Dhaliwal, some must see Tee-Vee…! ;-)
*putting trousers back on*
Thinking I’m working on an ulcer, and with Mr. CE traveling, I’m almost looking for shows I never see (hey, NOT that kind!) just not sports.
funk the vote upstairs
CNN: Ashley is in jail with $50,000 bail. That is the Cost of three Sarah dresses I would say.
How politically tone-deaf is McCheese’s campaign? Anyone want odds on whether they post her bail?
As out-of-touch as they are, i don’t think they’ll go there.
There’s always hoping, she does need counselling & stuff, dontchaknow?
You betcha!
Oh good grief.
Political Karma Will Get You in the End.
I hope that in the course of all the empathic out-pouring for Ms. Todd, you will spare a few thoughts for all the black boys and men who narrowly escaped being beaten, or maimed, or killed by the people whom Ms. Todd sought to arouse. I have been sick with fear since first hearing about this: I never believed it for a second, it had all the hallmarks of the standard “black man assaults/whistles at/looks funny at a white woman, let’s get the bastard.” Thankfully, it didn’t get to be a tragedy, but who knows how close it came to becoming one? I never thought I would ever have this thought, but thank the whoever that the police didn’t fall for it.
Todd was upset with the media? Pittsburgh police were upset with her, because she drew precious taxpayer-paid resources away from a REAL and important police investigation. I think they were suspicious from the start, not only because of the backwards B but also because the scratch was on HER right side. Most people are right handed, so the scratch should have been on her left side. The only black eyes here are on Ms. Todd, who I hope gets help for her mental affliction, the Pa. GOP campaign communications director, who avidly shopped the story around to various media before police had finished their investigation and the media who published the story in advance of its sad conclusion. I am sad that African-American men were once again singled out falsely here.
You say she needs help for her mental affliction. What do you propose for all of the other fanatical supporters of John McCain and the failed Republicon ideology?
Do you think she thought of it herself or do you think others were involved?
My ex is Bush in drag. She is also from Tennessee. It is very instructive to see that Ashley is wearing a Tennessee sweat shirt because most of the “people” from there that I know fit her personality profile. (I do make an exception for the guy married to an ex-sister-in-law who refuses to work for an employer who is not green.)