Holy crap, I actually agree with Brokaw.  He declared Joe The Plumber to be the winner of the debate, and I really can’t argue with that.  Obama came in a strong second, though.  Very poised, while McCain came across as dickish and angry, with lots of blinking and interrupting.

And now, the comments:

jayt  Our beloved Nancy Reagan… Who has despised McSlime since he left his first wife…

Marion in Savannah
  Have we decided on a drinking phrase yet? "My friends" just isn’t healthy…

kittykitty  mccain looks like he’s tryin to stay awake on ludes

FrankProbst  Not only did McCain not answer the question, he didn’t make any sense.

selise  just broke into the chocolate stash.

MrsK8
  Hooo boy, McCain’s gettin’ twitchy already.

helibrarygal  Well thank goodness I’m not drinking to McGrumpyPant’s smirks, I’d be on the floor already!

RonD  That smirk is just irritating. Like, "how am I supposed to be serious when I’m on stage with THAT ONE?"

Florasmom  I can save billions and billions – but I won’t tell anyone until I’m elected. the overhead projector again! holy cow. he is getting weirder

Suzanne  i’m wanting a john mccain meltdown – televised nationally – for my birthday present.

Hugh  McCain: I’m not George Bush
I just support all of this major programs.

jayt  CNN must have hired some even stupider "undecideds". the squiggly lines look way different tonight.

eCAHNomics  Oy, O supports tort reform, clean coal. Now there’s a real progressive. /s

MadDog
  If you’re watching on CNN-HD, notice on the Analyst Scorecards how Repugs Bill Bennett and Alex Castellanos are trying to work the Refs (American Public) by putting their thumbs down hard on the McSame scale.

Hugh  Obama: You are George Bush

dakine01  McCain thinks ads that point out his lies are negative attacks on him.  McCain is wrong again.

Hugh  John McCain, all the panache of a 3 year old poo-flinger

MadDog   Scheiffer, as EW predicted, lays out the Ayers question so that McSame doesn’t have to.  Bravo EW! You called it!

Mauimom  Sorry, but I don’t think Obama’s doing that well tonight. He’s attempting to answer McCain’s machine-gun fusillade of charges, doesn’t have the time to get in his own positive points.  Schieffer is worthless. Giving McCain way too much time.  Oooooh, "town hall meetings" again.

raisethebar  McCain, angry and interrupting.  the angry look went over like a lead balloon in the first debate.

Hugh  McCain: I’m proud of the people who come to my rallies. Whine, whine, whine.

diggeracity  well… a mooseburger in every pot.

Rayne  Oh nice, avoiding Ledbetter…apparently McGeezer gives not a shit about women, can’t even bother to suck up to us rather than continue to pander to the far right-wing.  Hello? McGeezer? Women are a majority in this country…you might clue in and suck up to them.

moondancer  Krusty has a meth enema. I’ve never seen him so amped up, and so out of control. Desperation is sad on a broken old man.

MDMD  Why, yes, we have *no problem at all* with nuclear waste. You’re exactly right, Sen. McCain.

JimWhite  Barack’s squiggly lines on energy are better.

Wordsmith  McCain’s left eye is going to fall out of his head soon.

Florasmom  McCain’s eyes look like little black marbles.

darwin1800  McCain’s graphs look like Cheney’s cardiograph: _________________________