What's really interesting to me, in watching the Obama-McCain endgame play itself out, is the stark difference in how the two candidates and their staffs have operated. There are ideological differences and temperamental differences that play a part, but they all feed into a larger point -- which is that, ironically enough, straight-up civilian Barack Obama understands the value of an overarching strategy in a bone-deep way that would make someone like Bradley or Grant or Sherman nod his head in recognition, even as the wild and purely reactive veerings of Navy legacy baby John McCain show that neither he nor anyone else in a top-level position in his campaign has the slightest friggin' clue about strategy. Yes, the Obama campaign values hope, but they know full well the military maxim that hope, alone, is not a plan -- so they made dead certain sure that they had a plan, and a very well crafted one at that, one that both anticipated most of the McCain campaign's moves and had enough flexibility to allow for changes as needed.
As John Cole said the other day, about Obama:
He plays long ball. He knew what they were going to do. And that is why they panicked. Obama is running the most disciplined and best campaign I have ever seen.
Even better: He's running a disciplined campaign against a spoiled brat who doesn't know the meaning of the word "discipline". Here's what I mean by that:
Obama’s background has been a blessing to him, in the same way that Bush’s and McCain’s backgrounds have been curses. He not only had to claw his way up on merit like Bill Clinton did, he also knew that as a black man he had to keep his nose super-duper clean and to avoid any of the temptations that sunk Clinton, but which Republicans like Rudy and Newt and Dan Burton commit without electoral penalty.
Because of this, because he understood how the deck was stacked against him, because he earned every damned thing he got with hard work, discipline and talent honed to a razor’s edge, he is flummoxing the lazy, undisciplined, talentless time-servers on the other side. Not just McCain, but the ranks of College Republican legacy hires that fill up the sheltered workshops that they call ‘think tanks’—the Ben Domenechs and Jonah Goldbergs and Ann Coulters of the world. They screech and screech and chase their own tails because they have never had to actually think hard and work, and now they’re up against someone for whom hard work, discipline, patience, and proper use of brain and talent is as natural as breathing.
Worse yet for them, the old tools that worked for them in the past, the crutches they relied on to avoid thinking—the appeals to racism and stupidity and naked selfish greed—are losing their power. Despite the McCain's camp's breaking through the bottom of the barrel with their nakedly racist and inflammatory posturings, they're losing ground with the very group towards which those posturings are directed: working-class white people.
And meanwhile he rolls on, unruffled, No-Drama Obama, calm in any situation, and crushes the McCainites and the rest of the GOP while keeping a steady hand on the wheel.
Res ipsa loquitor. The thing speaks for itself.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight



Support this site!
Keep
up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search


Morning, PW.
This same concept has been rolling around in my head at different points in the campaign, and I could’ve never expressed it like you have PW. Thanks for posting this.
Interesting to watch the cable newsers, CNN and MSNBC, jump in this morning and emphasize that part of the TrooperGate Report which says that Palin was within her right to fire Moneghan (sp).
And that big meeting of the G-7 at the White House? It’s already over, and georgie is off riding his bike now.
Seriously.
Good Morning PW…..
At the next debate Obama should ask……”Who is John McCain?
The John McCain I knew in 2000 wouldn’t hire the same folks who destroyed him so who is the John McCain of 2008?
Morning PW!
Your post says it all .Obama understands the value of hard work ,hard work got him to where he is today.
McSame on the other hand has had everything handed to him,just like he expects the Presidency to be handed to him
McCain is a spoiled brat !!
It’s a tricky distinction.
The way I explained it to Mrs Mack is that Palin broke the law firing someone as an illegal exercise of her power, but the firing was legal.
Trooper Wooten was not the victim of the crime, the People of Alask were.
Because Palin abused *their* trust.
Let’s Hope that he and his team are already at work on the post transition need to find and replace those ’sheltered workshop’ folks who have been hidden in the bowels of the Government agencies deep below the usual political level. It will take a diciplined campaign to put the Dept of the Interior back in the buisness of protecting the land and resources rather than facilitating their rape and distruction.
Pehaps the bigest target will be taking control of the Senate away from the likes of Harry Reed and his bunch. Getting the support that will be needed to restore posse comitatis, repeal the patriot act and restore habius corpus, and bring the Bush years fellons to justice will be a task even bigger than takeing the White House.
McSame is a puppet , his strings are being pulled by the leaders of our current shadow government.
It’s become apparent that McSame isn’t the one calling the shots in this campaign.
The John McCain of today is a desperate old man who knows that this is his last shot at his life’s ambition.
He is an imperfect person, as all of us are who faced with his ideal self and his real self is finding reality considerable short of ideal.
He is a man who, in the twilight of his career, is discovering all his failures anew.
He is not a happy man, and once the election is over, he an his running mate are facing disgrace and irrelevance.
That is because he sold his soul around 2004 to BushCo and now he is paying the piper
He’s gonna need that patience and discipline to clean out the Augean Stables. We are definitely in the shit, as Gordon Ramsey like to say, and it’s gonna be a long hard road out.
Yes Obama is running a masterful campaign but I sense that the corporate media is on the verge of stopping the hemoraghing of the McCain campaign. NPR this a.m. ran a piece from Minnesota where McCain tries to calm his rabid followers by saying Obama is a decent man. Rather than playing the boos and catcalls that followed this comment the played loud cheering. The corporate media needs a close race and they will begin propping up McCain to make sure he makes it to Nov. 4th. The MSM coverage of Palin’s abuse of power is nothing more than a wink and a shrug of the shoulders.
McShame has not really been able to overcome his proclivity to panic. Just like with the fire on the Forrestal where he went and hid out until he could escape, his all over the map dealing with the economic collapse has made his inability to define a problem and set a course to remedy it. McShame has now placed himself at a place where not only is he groping with the economy but also with an out of control campaign that is flailing about.
Palin will certainly be the subject of a TV show in the future that asks the provacative question, “Whatever happened to……”
Brava! Brava!
Nice work, PW!
McNasty may be done after the election , but Palin won’t I really don’t think we’ve heard the last of her.
THe right wing nut jobs love her she feeds their hate and intolerance,expect to see her on Fox or doing her own talk radio show.
If you can’t beat ‘em join ‘em!
Well said, PW, very well said.
McCain will eventually be seen as a tragic figure. He is currently under the control of dark forces in the Republican Party. In that sense the Republicans have destroyed McCain the man twice. First the Republican dark side destroyed him in South Carolina and they are destroying in this campaign. He has no one to blame but himself and their lies the tragedy. Why did he allow it to happen? It’s the old story of the turtle letting the scorpion ride on his back while crossing the river. When on the other side the scorpion stings the turtle. Before the turtle dies he asks the scorpion, why did you sting me and the scorpion answers, it’s just my nature.
I’d like to agree in full with this article, but it was the economic collapse that turned this thing in Obama’s favor, not his steadiness and work ethic. Obama was the same guy 3 weeks ago, and was pretty much tied with McCain.
It wasn’t Republican legacy laziness that doomed McCain, it was a financial crisis that provoked people to finally vote in their own economic interest.
McCain didn’t panic just because he’s a legacy brat, it was as much because the writing was on the wall because of the economic meltdown.
Impeachment is not out of the question.
Conviction - maybe not
I predict she will spend more time with her family.
…
I don’t think even Fox will want anything to do with her - she’s a loose cannon which has already issued friendly fire.
He’s the Tom Brady of presidential politics.
Good Morning Phoenix Woman - a tasty post - thank you
two things:
although I’d already given him credit for his ground game, I was not truly impressed with Barack Obama until he gave his speech on race. I commented at the time of how he was speaking to everyone like they had a mind and heart of their own and the intelligence to decide. He didn’t go the easy, broad strokes route or some Reaganesque folksy route - he has always treated the voters like grown ups
and I am so pleased to see the electorate,sheeple, joe sixpacks respond as rational adults - the majority of our fellow citizens seem to be “getting it”. at a time of such great, widespread uncertainty, voters could have easily gone the other way and gone the fear route
as grandpa cbl would say, that SOB has given me hope, I’ll be god damned :D
McNasty is so out of touch that he doesn’t see that his negative campaigning is actually hurting him.
The MSM can try to prop up his campaign ,I think he’s already doomed himself!
some taking head blathered when I was channel surfed….. said that the race will tighten up, historically there hasn’t been a lead in double digits going into election day…… media desire for a horse race is more than the truth…
Wrong, the scorpion stings the turtle while they’re still in the water, thus drowning both of them.
I wonder if that story has its origins with the Native Americans in the southwest.
John McCain’s big mistake, if he had any chance at all to be elected President in the current environment, was to hire Steve Schmidt and turn the day to day operations of his campaign over to him. This happened on July 2. As a protege of Karl Rove, Schmidt, supposedly a master of message development and strategy, is using the same outrageous tactics against Obama that Rove used against McCain in the 2000 Presidential primary. But the American public, at least reasonable, thinking Americans have had enough of divisive and dishonest politics. McCain must be pretty desperate, or easily forgets history, to have lowered himself to this level.
Palin has done as much to drag McCain down as the economy.
Her choice has been number neutral, but he traded powerful support for populist - not a good one for one trade.
As a fellow Pats fan ,I like the analogy !!
In the version I remember the scorpion stings the tortoise halfway across, dooming them both.
It’s a tricky distinction.
Networks don’t do ‘tricky distinctions’. Neither do republicans.
tucker bounds was on this morning saying essentially that Mrs. Palin was within her rights to fire Moneghan (sp) because Wooten was such a jerk.
*No* follow-up questions like - “But tucker, you disingenuous little shit, that is not the reason that she’s been giving for the last six weeks about the firing, now is it?”
Morning PW. Thanks much for this. I always love reading your take on things. Very helpful and interesting.
Morning PW -
Great post.
Dugg
I’m convinced that the neocon Cheneyites are running everything to do with the McCain Campaign. John McCain and Sarah Palin are puppets for the very same people who have been running the country for the last three decades.
I’d like to think that not only is McCain going down with the ideological ship, but that the cable “news” creeps will find that no one with a brain will continue to listen to them barking at their perennial targets–regulation, taxes, the left.
As if….
That’s a much better ending.
Hey Dragon. Finally caught up and left some more cooking nonsense for your perusal downstairs.
PW, you are on fire with this post! Thank you for expressing the contrast as well as anyone has during this long, long, long election season. The length and breadth of his primary contest and, now, this general election is definitive proof of his intellect and physical endurance. The same cannot be said of “Weekends-Off Johnny”.
Like I’ve said many times on this blog and others: Obama is a pure strategist, both in a team format and as a soloist.
Obama/Biden 08
Sure thing! There’s always the Mrs. Amurka Pageant. And she might want to re-visit that flaut thingie. That’s a career right there, wink wink.
It wasn’t just the meltdown that pushed Obama ahead it was his reaction and response ,even tempered calm and level headed.
While McCains response has been erratic and often clueless.
This crisis gave us some insight into how these guys would lead!
Ahhhhh. Is that the reason why they’ve been running around banging into eachother and bouncing off the walls, keystone-kops style? It’s all beginning to make more sense.
I thot rover was rheumored to be involved also. No? To what end?
Looks like chaos theory demo tape to me.
I’d be happy if she just went back to Alaska ,and was never heard from again!
On the Howie Carr Show (right wing radio host out of Boston) the other day, Howie was saying he had heard the Obama campaign bus stunk to high heaven and the people working for him were abusive and incompetent.
Bah hahahahahahahahaha! Oh gawd Howie! You are something else! We all know you were describing the McCain campaign bus, but to make yourself feel better about your own candidate, you decided to turn it around to make it appear it was the Obama bus!
Pathetic. Right wingers deserve nothing more than to be crushed on election day. I would love it if Americans put a nail in the American Taliban’s coffin. The End.
As do the last 7 years and counting…(?)
Excellent post PW. Thank you.
Amen. Poor AK, sigh.
Thank you for this. Aren’t we ready for the end of this race? There is a good piece on Salon that gives “good” background on an Alaska view of Palin.
This morning I was thinking about a LTE to counter this racist zenophobic stuff. Roughly, since early in the primaries, I have thought of the Obama progress as representing progress in the country for a Black man to have gotten so far in the contest. Some healing for the the deep racial wound. A transformative moment that we want to move on, affirm equality, the good things we say we stand for. Can we be called to the better vision for ourselve? Who (other than Molly Ivins) could have thought one idiot could do such serious damage to our country.
My grandson has lived his entire life in a W administration. His pregnant mother and I sat transfixed to the Florida contest and charade. We knew who Sect. of State K. Harris really was, and it wasn’t good.
This may be an almost sacred moment for a fresh wind. Not to be easy. The opposing forces, the disaster of George, and the creepy pool of Repub. candidates, and the awful events of war/torture/lies/$$, scream for change and something different. Obama’s talents are gifts for the day and for the journey. What a moment. But the racists and the 20%ers will have their ugly, screaming day.
Don’t you wish for Ted Kennedy to remind us that “the dream will never die”. The vision and hope must call us into a future of promise, maybe even peace. What sharp contrasts. Thank you.
someone last night (Robert Reich ?) pointed out how the McCrazy campaign might be doing if the media was reporting on VP Candidate Tim Pawlenty’s stump speech on the Economy - a scary ring of truth in the comparison
Seconded!
Reluctantly, I must go do some outside work. Drat the luck, we have a beautiful day, so I should take advantage. Hate to leave.
Thanks pups.
PW. I’m definitely going to return and re-read. Fascinating, complex, albeit sometimes disturbing campaign season. But Obama Biden gives us hope in this household.
What a great post, PW. I’m stealing it.
a little o/t
Rev Peterr, are you around ?
St Louis Post-Dispatch endorses Senator Obama
ps firedogs - this is cbl commenting, just now noticed mr cbl was logged in and not I
Howie Carr is scum of the earth ,he’s the type of person Palins hate mongering ,and racist statement appeal to!!
morning cbl & mr cbl
Seconded.
I saw that. Thanks. I put my dad’s Chili Mac recipe there a few minute ago.
dugg, thanks 4 the link.
Well, the election is not over, but the campaign is most definitely over. There is nothing Barack Obama can do right now to lose the election, short of strangling a kitten on national television.
And there is nothing John McCain can do to win. Think of all the years he invested in building his brand - going on talk shows, currying favor with the press, etc, etc. In 2000, independents and conservative Democrats liked him for coming across as an independent, non-doctrinaire politician. But in the past six weeks, he threw his brand completely under the bus, careening from one talking point to the next, like a shipwreck victim looking for something to keep him afloat. He did not write out a long-term strategy for winning the election - a “story”, if you will. And his “story” did not include working Americans.
In a way, I feel sorry for McCain. He’s a classical tragic figure - blind to his own shortcomings and a victim of his own hubris.
I will feel sorry for him on November 5.
Indeed! Hear! Hear!
So many tragic figures have governed us: Nixon, LBJ, can almost include Clinton. The over reach and tragic flaw; all part of the hubris. Thanks
Why make a long term plan,when the job, is yours by right !!
Yeah, I know to repeat the above is using up bandwidth, servers etc., but every word is golden.
It captures the essence of where we find ourselves in this race, and thrust again the terrible economic backdrop we have, explains why the election is breaking far and wide for Obama.
Great post PW, emailed it to friends
as for McCain, he earned this ignoble defeat; so cold-hearted as it may be, I won’t feel an ounce of pity for him while I’m dancing in the streets Nov. 5th
mornin’ Tex - how are you and yours ?
were you aware there was a Texas Senate Debate on thursday night ? apparently the Soldier did a good job
I missed it and will try to find it online somewhere.
A Barack Obama presidency is the best thing that could happen to our country!
Time tells us “Palin administration is SHOCKINGLY AMATEURISH”
gee ya kiddin?
http://www.time.com/time/polit.....99,00.html
=====================================
But the Branchflower report still makes for good reading, if only because it convincingly answers a question nobody had even thought to ask: Is the Palin administration shockingly amateurish? Yes, it is. Disturbingly so.
The 263 pages of the report show a co-ordinated application of pressure on Monegan so transparent and ham-handed that it was almost certain to end in public embarrassment for the governor. The only surprise is that Troopergate is national news, not just a sorry piece of political gristle to be chewed on by Alaska politicos over steaks at Anchorage’s Club Paris.
The way I heard it the turtle asks just as they are both about to drown, “Why did you do that? You have killed the both of us.” The scorpion answers, “This is the Middle East.”
Check out today’s Salon.com, a view from another Alaskan. Says her rambling nonsense should not be a surprise and lots more.
Time tells us “Palin administration is SHOCKINGLY AMATEURISH”
Like a bunch of BFFs at a slumber party,except maybe no pillow fights!!
* No-Drama Obama *
What exactly is drama? Why did Obama forbid it?
I have a sort of feeling about what he means, and that it was probably the best strategy, but I would like to understand this better.
McCain has the same problem Bush has, they just can’t look down the road and anticipate what will happen. It is my biggest complaint about the Bush Administration. Please don’t attack me for that statement, I’m fully aware of 9/11, Iraq, Katrina, et al, but it is that inability to think ahead that is their big problem.
I, for one, will be most happy to have a president that can anticipate what will happen based on certain actions. Without a doubt, Obama will irritate me on occasion, but that will beat the current bunch by light years.
knew it was happening, even got invited, but was busy with a relig holiday at the time. burnt orange report should have the video.
You must be a Republican, cuz you can’t see past the end of your nose.
I think what he didn’t want was for internal campaign squabbles to become public, and for high turnover in campaign staff.
No attack, of course. That’s why he thought we could do the Iraq thing in a few days. What? Plan?
He truly is, Billybugs. Whenever he goes on a rampage about the homeless, homeless being beat up goes up in the Boston area and in Portland, Maine. It’s so disgusting to me. There is a certain block of right wingers who have owned guns for years and would just ONCE like to use them to kill someone rather than killing an animal. These are the freaks Palin & Carr are stimulating right now.
In Wisconsin, some 527 is running ads against Harry Reid and Chris Dodd. They don’t mention Obama or McCain, but they try to fix the blame for the economy/bailout on Democrats who took money from Fannie and Freddie lobbyists.
It would be a terrific time imho to launch legislation against corporate donations to politicians and political parties. I think there would be a lot of support from the right and the left. Sara over at tnh always talked about restricting donations to registered voters. That always made sense to me.
Terror, terror, all the time, followed by “we don’t need no stinking draft” to defend America.
Could not agree more.
It’s not an overstatement that the mood of the world will change when this pack of criminals, thieves and nincompoops exit stage left and are replaced with competent people of good will towards its citizens.
What a simple, yet novel concept.
Adults in charge again, not thieving WATB’s.
Good morning, everyone! Sorry I’m late.
Katymine @ 4:
Simple: The John McCain we see today is the John McCain that has always existed; the main difference is that he’s got less energy to be able to fake decency for long enough to fool anyone outside of the reporters to whom he cuddles up. Just as he counted on his admiral daddy to bail him out of trouble, he counts on the press to cover for him — and even now, they still follow his lead and cover the talking points he wants covered.
S/he who is a community organizer will have the last laugh.
No sympathy here for McC. The only reason he’s backing off (if he really is) is because of the backlash. It has nothing to do with honor. Plus, I sense they’ve found a way to discuss the economy….blame everything on Dodd and Frank.
Maybe the attack on the financial system was supposed to be the October surprise. They have terrorized the Congress into the bad
bailoutbig theft from taxpayers plan. TheskyDow is falling, theskyDow is falling.maintain an even strain all cases
We’ve come full circle, back to the divine right of kings. Will we, in November, break the cycle or just slow it down?
You shoulda joined the Navy.
I have not heard much morning news. Has the McC-Palin group reacted to the report out of Alaska?
This, my friends should be seen as a Bingo!
I’ve been saying the exact same thing; if you can’t get election reform (public financing of all Federal elections, at least) after this clusterf%^& we’re going through, then it will never happen.
Use the anger over this mess to point out this would’ve never happened without the financial services industry spending billions of dollars on lobbyists and direct contributions to politicians over the last decade.
And, when the inevitable response is “We can’t afford that”, ask that poor misguided soul “Which would cost less — a billion dollars for the elections or the 700 billion and counting the lobbyists have cost us?”
At that point I think we’d have a convert.
Another strategic benefit of campaign finance reform would be it effectively puts another stake in the heart of the Rethug beast.
Money has been the only way they’ve kept these elections close; that and stifling voter turnout.
Finance reform and efforts to increase voter turnout would beat them down to the 30% levels they really represent.
And it couldn’t happen to a more deserving bunch.
It’s time to drive a stake into the heart of the Reagan era ,this country will not survive another 4 years of conservative policy.
The people of the world will think that Americans have finally regained their sanity!
The Palins through their
high powered‘middle class’ attorneys are blaming the messenger rather than themselves:http://edition.cnn.com/2008/PO.....stigation/
This is so interesting because this is exactly what George Bush & Dick Cheney did for 8 years! Spit.
Marcy has a new piece over at emptywheel!
What Does TrooperGate Mean for November 4?
PW, congrats on a brilliant post. You nailed it and articulated it masterfully. The magic is competence, coupled with hard work and insight into what people can hear.
I’ve been responding to the competence but with reservations about the message - not concrete and specific enough for my taste. My mistake.
There is comfort in knowing he’s not issuing a laundry list of promises he can’t realistically keep.
Brilliant to highlight the effective habits possessed by anyone who can make editor of the Harvard Law Review. It’s a source of great hope to realize he is in fact the brains behind his own campaign.
Your Clinton analogy is well made. The presidency of the US is not a job for someone of average intelligence and skills. Why TF have we been allowing folks to run around suggesting it is?? If intelligence and application makes one an elitist, go elitists!
Thank you for so eloquently stating the thoughts that have been floating around my brain over the past several months. I know that millions of people (across the political spectrum) see and understand exactly what you have described here. What surprises me is how many people still don’t get it.
i agree that Obama’s discipline and organization have been tremendous. i believe that even without the economic downturn, he can win the election. the depression we are sinking into has helped alot, however, because he cannot afford to win by only 2 or 3 %, not with election fraud like it is today.
however, i would caution that the “disorder” in the GOP camp, while indicative of many problems, is also a tactic among neo-cons of the Rovian blend. while it seems they have no strategy, these thugs have used that very disorder as a tactic in recent years. what seemed like lack of a strategy in Iraq was a strategy for permanent presence. what seemed like disorder in Katrina was a tactic for stealing property from the poor, and changing the face of NOLA forever.
just saying…..
Actually, I’ve been wishing that the Democrats would have Ted Kennedy tape a “public service announcement” that says, “I’ve seen what hatred and violence can do in politics. It’s irresponsible and unAmerican to encourage these dark emotions and the actions that result. Please stop.” [And I’m lookin’ at YOU, John McCain.]
You are perfectly correct about McCain being responsible for this situation in South Carolina.
After all he’s pumped $190,000 into the coffers of Richard Quinn, the editor of “Southern Partisan” a neo-Confederacy magazine for the “thinking mans” KKK. McCain has used Quinn as an advisor since his 2000 campaign and still does. Quinn supported David Duke, called the MLK holiday “vile”.
McCain’s Southern Segregationist
An interesting link…Pat Buchanan is a “Senior Advisor” to “Southern Partisan”. And McCain also counts George Wallace, Jr. (who has not made the sorts of apologies that his father did late in his life) as a supporter.