Sarah Palin’s denigration of community organizers is the domestic equivalent of her getting a passport for the first time in her 40s—the first demonstrates how out of touch she is with mainstream America, just as the second highlights her unfitness for understanding the global world we live in.
Attempting to dismiss Sen. Barack Obama’s work as a community organizer in Chicago, Palin stated at the Republican National Convention:
Being a mayor is kinda like being a community organizer, only you have actual responsibilities.
What she didn’t count on—because she’s too narrow minded to have grasped it—is that she didn’t just insult Obama. She attacked the integrity of community organizers across the nation. And they’re speaking out. Letters to the editor and op-ed pieces protesting Palin’s remarks in print and online forums from Utah to Florida attest to the difficulties and challenges of community organizing. They also show Palin hit a chord among many people—but not the one she hoped.
I talked with Rick Powell the other night at our phone banks here at the AFL-CIO in Washington, D.C. (We’re phoning union members every day, every evening and every weekend, telling them why we support Obama. If you’re in D.C., stop by anytime to make some calls.)
Back in the late 1960s when he was in college in Greensboro, N.C., Powell volunteered as a community organizer, helping low-income tenants join together to improve their conditions. As part of the Greensboro Association for Poor People, Powell helped public housing tenants to create food co-ops so they could save money. He and other volunteers created a tenant committee to fight a slum landlord who wanted to increase rents without making critical improvements, like fixing plumbing or holes in ceilings. His work empowered the residents to challenge the status quo. Their challenge ultimately resulted in local and state legislation that gave some protection to tenants living in residences with massive housing code violations.
The people Powell organized were not aware they had rights—they thought they were powerless. But all that changed after they were organized, Powell says.
We empowered a segment of the population of Greensboro, N.C., that didn’t know they had any rights as tenants. Usually folks who go through that experience, you’re never able to intimidate them again. They are no longer victims and they will never be victims again in their lives.
Powell, now the political and legislative coordinator for the Metropolitan Washington Council, exemplifies real leadership.
In contrast, trashing community organizing is an expedient way out of real leadership responsibilities for the GOP. John Manrique at the Miami Sun-Sentinel hits it on the head when he writes:
By conveniently supporting individual and localized leadership on tough issues such as poverty, homelessness and social inequality, con-reformers like Gov. Palin can shirk responsibility and avoid the difficulties of working toward solutions under a guise of eliminating "big government interference." So sidestepping the issues with lip service, a laugh and condescending kick to the ribs of community organizers who rise each day to make a difference, Palin and company say, "You’re on your own!"
But the issue is much broader than the power-hungry top politicos. Manrique continues:
While the zingers and one-liners may have been crowd-pleasers, the real joke is what such comments reveal about today’s brand of Republican "compassionate conservatism."
[snip]
What does that, and the roaring applause it received, say about the value Palin and Republican leaders have for the tens of thousands of everyday Americans who selflessly work to support their neighbors, improve our communities and put country first? It indicates to me who the real elitists are, and how much their party truly "cares" for those who don’t have the word "executive" in their job title.
Deepak Bhargava at the Center for Community Change sums up why the skills and vision of community organizers are those that should inform any U.S. president.
Any president would do well to adhere to the community values, often rooted in religious faith, that inspire organizers. They believe that problems are best solved through cooperation, that every person is part of the American family and that no individual can do well while others are suffering. A president familiar with community organizing would seek out diverse views to formulate policy rooted in the realities of ordinary life. He would know how to build coalitions to overcome the entrenched interests that block progress.
Most important, a president with community organizing skills might engage ordinary Americans in the practice of democracy every day—not just at election time.
Engaging everyday Americans in the political process—sounds familiar. Like maybe one of the main reasons the founders of this nation declared independence?
Related posts:
- Halfway There: Donate for Organizers in Arkansas to Primary Blanche Lincoln
- Rich Lowry Suddenly in Favor of Criticizing American Presidents on Foreign Soil
- Presidents Baucus and Grassley Allow Obama to Speak
- Petition Drive: 28,000 People Want Congress to Stay
- Findlay, Ohio, Chamber of Commerce Kills Parade Because Unions Backed It





Spotlight








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

Cub Scout Mom, founding chair of regional Women’s Political Caucus, best Camp Fire Candy seller in jr. high….
we are all, at some level, community organizers…or we are Ted Kaczinskis.
Excellent post, Tula.
Digg it.
Jesus was a Community Organizer – Pontius Pilate was a Governor.
What a pleasure to hear, Tula. She has a narrow-mind indeed and is very short-sighted.
America’s founders were community organizers. Sarah Palin disrespected everything that’s good and true about America when she mocked community organizers. It seems to me that her own community could use some organizing itself. For instance, if there’d been someone organizing in Palin’s community around teen pregnancy, maybe her daughter would find herself in different circumstances.
I think narrow-mind and short-sighted seem to go hand-in-hand…
Per McCain spokesperson Brian Rogers:
h/t: TPM
Thanks for another excellent post, Tula.
All the Pilates had great abs, though. Pontius was no exception.
Community organiser us collaboration. Palin uses authoritarianism: voice are not heard. Stocks went up 400 points today because her neocon buddies in the White House have decide to use our tax dollars to bail out ALL rge bad debt the wall street crooks have accumulated. Sending investor a nessage that their investments are backed by our taxes.
Porky “Earmark” Palin has been at the pork trough but does not want any money left in the treasury for badly needed social programs that Community organiser need to continue their wonderful works.Here are few of them that help homeless and house low income folks.
http://www.clih.net/
Palin wonders why anyone needs community organizers when they can simply pull in millions of earmarks from the federal government for their community?
Response no workey ratfood @ 9
Let us not forget GWB was also a governor
we are attacking sarah yet mccain is the candidate
I know she is he draw but those that support her love attacks, it makes them support her more
I think the best method for dealing with sarah is to make mccain a laughing stock for picking her as the vp candidate;
“we are talking about john mccain, here is a man that actually picked a vp candidate who…[fill in the blank]”
just embarass the very thought of her as vp
Tyous corrected:
Community organiser us collaboration. Palin uses authoritarianism: voices are not heard.
Stocks went up 400 points today because her neocon buddies in the White House have decide to use our tax dollars to bail out ALL the bad debt the wall street crooks have accumulated. Sending investor a message that their investments are backed by our taxes.
Porky “Earmark” Palin has been at the pork trough but does not want any money left in the treasury for badly needed social programs that Community organiser need to continue their wonderful works.Here are few of them that help homeless and house low income folks.
http://www.clih.net/
OT
or is it really?
Tula’s hosting Sunday’s Book Salon
Crunch: Why Do I Feel So Squeezed? (And Other Unsolved Economic Mysteries)
Chat with Jared Bernstein about his new book. Hosted by Tula.
Country Club First!!
I love that one. Can we get MoveOn.org to make bumper stickers?
And I love the caption on the picture of the Continental Congress. Made the same point to a friend on Monday: The Founders were community organizers, fer chrissakes!
Thanks for the post, Tula.
FunnyD
With even less government experience than Palin. Made a great prez, though… no, wait a minute.
I think the narrow mind must be pinching the optic nerve or sumpin’.
Paging Dr. Kirk!
FunnyD
You mean ridicule McCain the guy who said “You the workers are fundamentally strong and innovative”.
Gosh, thanks, Mr. McCain!!! Jeepers. You don’t have to tip me…it’s an honor!
Tula !
made my 4th generation Labor heart skip a beat to see this is soon to go out to 1.5 million homes in swing states
I see more are planned. would love to see y’all unleash McCain Revealed in a series of tv ads – c’mon, ya know ya wanna :D
707!
hey ! – xoxox
Back at ya!!
Sarah Palin thinks taxing the rich is unpatriotic!!
Tula excellent post.
Deepak Bhargava at the Center for Community Change nails it.
Think of all the devasted places on the gulf coast let down by their fed, state and local governments in all the hurricanes and the comming ones.
Think of all the devated neighborhoods in foreclosure, raided for metals and stripped, boarded up or used for crack houses.
The neighborhood watch programs are Community organiser that help keep people safe. Palin’s state has a huge crack problem in part because Community organiser are discouraged.
Sit! Wolfie says Trump will discuss his endorsement of McCain. Yesterday it was Lynnie from the Block.
The Billionaires are circling the wagons….
He likes women like Palin.
Tula, how far does the history of community organizing go back? (I mean in this country and similar to Powell’s work as above.) It would be nice to hit Palin with a grand old history. And as an aside, it looks like we will need community organizers now more than ever.
Trump’s choices are at least attractive.
Weren’t the disciples community organizers? Isn’t that the point of many of the chapters in the New Testament? Isn’t the Bible actually a document of community organizing? Same with the Koran or the Torah.
hmm yeah and spend it on football stadiums or something similiar. Does anybody know how much the feds spent on NOLA v. AIG? It’d be interesting to see those figures side by side.
Jesus was a community organizer. Pontius Pilate was a governor.
Unbenownst, Sarah Palin was actually praising community organizers when she was speaking in tongues.
Isn’t it why they call specific religious community beliefs “organized” religion…Isn’t that exactly what Palin is a product of…that of which she is so proud? Does she think being a Mayor is “better”? Does she think that she is better than her pastor?
Gee, when I think “Small town values” the first thing I think of is community, followed immediately by organizing. Jest sayin’
Oh.
See my 9.
Dr King gets all up in her lipstick smeared grill:
(h/t Mayor Cory Booker)
I think Sarah was simply making the point that organizing Americans who make less than $5 million a year distracts them from their patriotic duty, which is to go shopping.
I was thinking of Chimpigula’s “faith based initiatives” bs
McCain forgot to put on his flag pin today…
Our small town (now not so small) has about 6 benefits a year for just plain folks that need a hand. Organized mostly by bikers. All Austin Texas Motorcycle Clubs work every Christmas with the FoodBank to distribute food with their presents to families they “adopt” that otherwise would have no holiday. Last year over 400 families. There are so many people offended by that woman’s flip remark and she has no idea.
Interesting post regarding Sarah’s early days in politics up at BAGnewsNotes.
Early Signs Of Sarah Palin’s Radical Agenda
oooh, burn! good one!
He found it taxing to remember it.
Why does McCain hate America?
Nah McCain doesn’t hate America. He’s like most Republicans – he loves America, he just hates Americans is all.
I thought he was against taxes.
Oh
Ian upstairs on the ‘Tinkerbelle rules’
Us too here in Sacramento! There’s a hardcore group of aging hipsters who set up a charitable org called Day Dream Believers and have several fund raisers including the big Thanksgiving RideRaffle/Party benefiting the local homeless groups (and their pets) – especially homeless children. Our bikes are mostly of the pedal variety, but I am sure that you would find kindred souls.
In better times, we were able to donate the bulk of the earnings/scrappings to outsiders including victims of hurricane George and Katrina, but now were focusing on the locals in need.
If you ever find yourself in sunny Sacramento, do drop by the Rubicon Brew pub at 20th and Capital – I’ll shout the first round.
I guess we can only hope that some people take notice.
Great post, Tula!
And I really like the graphic!
Bob in HI
One caveat Tula, I am 50 and have never had a passport. I traveled to Canada in high school but never anywhere else out of the country mainly due to lack of money. I think if you check the vast majority of Americans do not hold passports and have never been out of the country. That said, the vast majority of Americans are not running for VP either.
Or for a more recent take on this:
–Dr. King was a community organizer.
–Gov. Wallace stood in the schoolhouse door, and a Democratic president moved his sorry a$$ out of the way!
And we’re the better for it.