Today Jane and Lindsay -- together with Glenn Greenwald, Twin Cities Indymedia, and Pacifica -- gave us compelling reports from the Twin Cities: frontline du jour in corporatist America's seemingly endless War On The Commons. Congress - with eager support from Senator Amy Klobuchar - put out a trough of 50 million dollars to pull local "law" enforcement into the RNC feeding frenzy. As Amy K helpfully pointed out, Congress also set out 50 million troughs for local cops before the nominating convention in Denver last week and those in Boston and New York in 2004. That's on top of the tens (hundreds?) of millions for the Federal "Fusion Centers" and the FBI, Fatherland Homeland Security, Secret Service, and our very own Pentagon's Northcom -- the domestic strong arm of General Smedley Butler's enforcement racket—to criminalize public assembly and speech during yet another major party coronation. Why do America's corporatist controlled organs of "State Security" need to pay hundreds of millions every four years to keep paper maché puppets off the streets and out of the parks?
Today in the Twin Cities and last week in Denver—just as in New York and Boston in 2004 and LA and Philly in 2000—the nominating conventions pageants' "law" enforcement sit below the Department of the Treasury's Secret Service in the power pyramid. That's why every time local citizens and demo organizers go to Federal court to beg for some shard of the First Amendment to cover a "permitted" march route near the convention sites, their attorneys end up hearing the Secret Service has the final say in "security" decisions affecting the conventions. No surprise, then, that when local Twin Cities "law" enforcement went on a round-up rampage today, FBI and Fatherland Homeland Security were right there with the locals for (yet another) warrantless search.
I co-coordinated medical support for the April, 2000 IMF/WB protests in DC and served both on the "convergence space" organizing committee and as co-coordinator for medical support for the 2000 DNC protests in LA. There I and many others saw the same pattern of joint Federal/local "law" enforcement taking very deliberate and illegal actions that effectively pre-empted peaceful, legal public gatherings opposing corporatist rule and official enforcement of corporate edicts. The pattern of illegal mass arrests, searches, seizures, and harassment repeats across time (NYC pulled the same tricks for the 2004 RNC as they did for 2002 protests against the Iraq invasion; over the last eight years, DC has often repeated the same techniques to suppress public assembly they were successfully sued for in 2000). The pattern of illegal mass arrests and mass violent assaults upon peaceably assembled people by local "law" enforcement subordinate to the Secret Service repeats across time, with the LAPD and Philly PD in 2000, and NYC PD in 2004 all assaulting non-violent gatherings associated with convention protests.
Of all these assaults, the LAPD's deliberate use of "less than lethal" weapons on three sides of a large permitted concert to turn the permitted area and the sole route of escape into a free-fire zone is still the most egregious. Who says LA doesn't know how to put on a show?
By all accounts, Ramsey County Sheriff Bob Fletcher is a vicious man and a nasty piece of work. He—and local "law" enforcement tyrants like him -- are necessary and useful idiots in the larger pattern I've seen in America over the nearly nine years since the Seattle WTO protests. That pattern, however, didn't start in Seattle. The prodigious use of chemical weapons against civilians in Seattle -- the largest use of chemical weapons on our soil in American history—didn't just fall out of the nozzle that day. The Humboldt County Sheriff's choice to torture non-violent forest protectors by painting "pepper spray" on their eyes helped open the nozzles. [Humboldt County -- in California's "Deep North"—ended up losing a Federal Court civil suit, though by the time the derisory damages of one dollar came down, Seattle had already gassed their people.]
On a broader level, joint Federal/local violent force directed against social justice activists characterized much of the civil rights movement, and, before that, organized labor's struggle. Of course, that long history of violence grew out of the legalized genocide and oppression that brought the attempted annihilation of North America's First Peoples and the enslavement of Africans and others in the colonies and then in America.
Who benefited? Who benefits? From the destruction of the First Peoples up through the corporatists' sustained and massive assault on our public institutions and public resources over the past forty years, the answer is the same: the wealthiest of the wealthy. The plantation owners, the mine owners, Big Cattle, Big Pork, Big War Machines, Big Surveillance Machines, Big Serial Poisoners...and now, Big Mercenaries.
What possible evidence suggests our very own public servants -- the Congresscritters we seem to love so much the incumbents enjoy more than a 90% chance to return to Village service with each election -- what possible evidence suggests these august tribunes of the Republic would criminalize the commons and public dissent to protect the megacorps? Who could believe such a slander?
Well, anyone familiar with the American Legislative Exchange Council: the megacorps' wholly owned think tank that "ghostwrites" civil and criminal legislation for obedient local, state, and Federal "representatives" to put on the law books. ALEC and the corporatists' wholly owned Congresscritters just criminalized the lunch counter sit-ins and other non-violent tactics the civil rights movement used. ALEC also wrote the laws our servile Congresscritters signed to make non-violent defense of our shared commons a Federal felony, punishable by years in Federal prison.
What are "the commons"? The commons are the public spaces, rights of way, lands, institutions, and resources we all must share, and must preserve for furture generations to share.
A century ago, Americans who challenged corporate control and plutocrat ownership of civil society, public institutions, and the commons were derided as "anarchists" and mercilessly hunted by "law" enforcement and Pinkerton (the Blackwater of that era). After 1917, Americans who challenged corporatist rule and plutocrat rulers were hunted for being "communists". A decade or so ago, Americans who worked for social justice to oppose corporatist misrule were once again "anarchists". Today in the Twin Cities, we see that Americans who peacefully come together to feed one another, heal one another, document one another's struggles, and work together to preserve our wounded planet, ailing nation, and suffering people from corporatist domination and endless war are "terrorists".
How do we know? Why, the same traveling Federal propaganda show that makes the circuit preaching the gospel of fear and paranoia to local "law" enforcement before each major public protest of the last nine years tells us so. You know, the same Federal apparatchniks we can trust to change threat colors before elections, listen to our phones, read our email and letters, rendition abduct and illegally transport innocent civilians, torture innocent people, imprison children, and conduct secret show trials.
We can trust them, right? Sure, if we want to stand in line for handouts like the apparently power-mad Sheriff of Ramsey County and his uniformed mob.
Uh - no thanks. I'll stand with three centuries of Americans who have worked to expand the franchise and diffuse power -- peacefully and non-violently. Standing with the global justice movement may mean sending money or people to the Twin Cities protests...and the protests that are to come. Standing with the global justice movement may mean supporting the ACLU, NLG, Civil Liberties Defense Center, Partnership For Civil Justice, Food Not Bombs, Seeds of Peace, Ruckus Society, or even EarthFirst! -- all groups that work to keep open the door for public protest and non-violent dissent.
In the end, the strongest stand we can take to reclaim our Republic, protect our Constitution, continue three centuries of empowerment, and support the social justice movement is the stand we take with our own two feet. We might stand in the soup kitchen, or in the medic stations. We might stand with the legal observers, or the media observers. We might stand with the marchers -- or stand to open our front doors and back doors and garages when they are beaten or gassed off the streets. Or stand to open our places of worship and other sanctuaries to the innocent people fleeing the tyranny of mass arrest and mass raids.
Why stand together with them? Should we fail, we will only live in fear of the corporatist tyranny that can and does show the power to snatch us away, serially and separately.
The Twin Cities show us all one future. Together, we can choose another.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
question…
Does this woman look seven months pregnant to you?
http://stupidcelebrities.net/2.....rs-photos/
Aloha, Doc!
Aloha, CT!
Hi Doc…. well since they went after peace groups in Eugene Oregon…..well now to read it all
scroll down the page and watch the video:
http://stupidcelebrities.net/2.....rs-photos/
Hey, Dr. K! Wondered when you would weigh in on this. One heavy load of shit coming down. Does not make me very confident about BushCos intentions come November-January.
Thanks, Kirk. Good post. We had better stand together or……
It is sad that the 1st amendment is trampled with the dubious ‘Conspiracy to Commit Riot’ charges… As was demonstrated in the Twin Cities…
From EPU land…
A common misconception of Republicans is that the founding fathers drafted an abridged version of the Constitution in which freedom of expression, assembly, etc. was dropped and the second amendment became the first. Unfortunately, they sent the wrong version to Kinko’s.
Which is exactly the purpose of these raids. They are intended to intimidate peaceful protesters from coming out. The irony is, these kinds of tactics actually attract the more extreme and potentially violent groups. God knows, the GOP has lots of enemies on the left.
Thanks for all who’ve joined to discuss what is happening in the Twin Cities. Save for the fact that chemical weapons can cause fetal abnormalities and spontaneous abortion, we’ll leave discussion of uterine contents for elsewhere.
Confronting tyranny is too important to be distracted by soap opera gossip.
Well said, Dr Murphy, well said.
Yep. As Dr. Dick observes, the broader purpose of the raids and “snatch arrests” is to terrorize the public.
Just as the US School of the
AmericasAssassins trained aspiring despots to do in Latin America.EPU’d from downstairs:
Good on ‘ya, Dr Dick. Thanks for standing up for the Republic.
Discouraging would-be protesters could be a motive for the raids. Seems like most of the really violent extremists are at the other end of the political spectrum, though. They probably hate the GOP more than we do but for different reasons, such as not being conservative enough.
I have been throwing (metaphorical) rocks for forty years. The FBI are well acquainted with me. Something about membership in the NIYC in my youth.
Heh, the Hall of
FameShame they have of alumni is a veritable “Who’s Who” of Latin America tinpot despots and their cronies… I’ve seen it at Ft. Benning…those seeking more links may enjoy a refresh….
Unfortunately, there are also violent groups on the left. Some of the actions at the WTO and some of the Earth First actions come to mind. Much more common in my youth than today, I admit. I understand their rage and frustration, but have come to recognize that violence is a very expensive and often ineffective strategy.
I think you’ve got the concept for a novel, girlfriend. Non-Fiction, of course.
Not like this hasn’t been adequately documented over the last couple decades.
In 2004, iirc, our illustrious police chief, Chuck Harmon, was asked by Sembler Company (yes, that Sembler) if he couldn’t do something about the protesters at BayWalk, a shopping/cinema complex in downtown St Pete. His solution were barricades that not only cut off access to the property by the protesters but shut off part of the sidewalk needed to gain access. At the time we were getting 50-75 folks out on Sat night. The 2nd week the barricades went up and for about 6 weeks afterward there were 250-300 folks with us. City council forced the chief to remove the barricades, one councilman saying, “Before the barricades we had 20-30 people peacefully protesting, after they went up we had 300 screaming people. Didn’t make much sense.” or words to that effect. We had 4 folks arrested one evening for a planned civil disobedience direct action. The heat lied on the stand and 2 were fined for “resisting arrest.” They were charged at the heat locker and released.
And then there’s the Brooks’ Bros.
Thanks, I’ve already spent 20 minutes reading links and still not done.
Actually, I believe that should be the Earth Liberation Front (ELF) rather than Earth First. My bad. I am afraid I do not really keep up with the green movement very much, being more of a red myself.
Violence is counterproductive, not to mention immoral.
This actually has always been the case and there is a rather extensive literature in political science and sociology relating to the use of force to suppress peaceful dissent.
To my knowledge ELF only burns stuff down.
Question:
When did our local police morph into the most advance military force?
[think some jurisdictions are more equipped than some national guard units]
At some point we went from community policing which caused the drop in crime to storm troupers….. as a person who lives in the country where Sheriff Joe has TWO tanks… when did this happen?
It is my understanding it was paid for by all those DHS anti-terrorism funding across the country but WHY?
Since it’s based on a common Republican misconception, I’d better make it a pop-up book.
It is also, in some cases, unfortunately necessary. Most scholars who have looked at the Civil Rights movement have concluded that the Black Panthers and related groups were a necessary ingredient to giving Dr. King and the nonviolent leaders legitimacy (same with Gandhi in India). It should, however, always be a last resort of desperation.
But that was a reich-wing operation, wang! ;-)
It is, admittedly, only violence against property and not persons, but it is still violence and does cause damage and injury (if only financial) to someone.
Great post, Kirk. And you are right, now is the time to stand up together, and resist this blatent attempt to intimidate political activism. It is our RIGHT as Americans to assemble, to freely speak and exchange ideas, to peacefully protest.
When my son was smallish, I used to tell him what a great country we lived in, how it was the envy of the world for the freedoms, particularly the political freedoms, that we enjoyed.
Now, we witness Stalinesque thuggery intended to make us shut up, and sit down and not ask questions.
I say, Fuck That.
They also destroy equipment here in the NW.
Yessie, you’re right. How about with those little audio chips that play music?
(we could be on to something.)
Three words… Terra, terra, terra…!
Katymine, i understand that Blackwater has been training police depts around the country to be more like swat/jackboots.
dugg, doc
Crony contracts?
Now don’t go putting down pop-up books.
They are snatching people off the street? They are invading homes and detaining Americans who ask to see a warrant? They are handcuffing innocent citizens on their own living room floors? They are banging down peoples’ doors without cause or reason?
And we are surprised by this, why?
Thank you, Kirk, for reminding us that anyone who was paying attention saw this coming a long, long time ago. And that the behavior of our complicit Democrats in Congress facilitated this police state action.
I hope our FirePupReporters and Salonet stay safe! It’s a war zone out there!
Oh, OK. I get it now.
Dr Dick, thanks so much for the (accurate) correction. That was ELF, not EarthFirst!
I was on the frontline surrounding the WTO precisely when well-organized skinny punk folks broke some windows on (apparently “strategically” chosen) megacorps’ falgship stores. They melted away. Within a half-hour or so, some very muscular burly white men who appeared to be in their mid-20’s started breaking shop windows on and vandalizing the fronts of small independent businesses. Many of the vandalized indy businesses (and the chain pharmacy they vandalized) had been open all morning, and we protesters had been literally lining up to purchase food and supplies.
The burly young white men went up to the police lines — and were allowed to pass through.
Much of the destruction — especially the generalized vandalism the MSM filmed — on November 30 was done by those provocateurs.
And they were apparently quite well-prepared and organized to follow the “spontaneous” ELF protests.
Shades of the informant “Anna” who entrapped Eric McDavid.
ELF torches an empty structure in protest. The fire dept torches an empty structure for training. One is considered an act of violence and the other not because one causes a financial loss to some insurance company and the other doesn’t?
Howdy, stranger! ;-) …Dugg!
Music?
(For you, Dr. K)
Well looking at all this the chilling effect reaches all the way to my little out of the way place. As more and more surveillance of on line communication and the collection of data on who attends what rally. it just scares me, and keeps me from wanting to speak out or to work for any cause. Its so easy now to find yourself on a list where there my come a knock at the door at midnight. maybe its all that dystopian fiction I read in the 70’s.
Thanks, Suzanne!
I’d love to see this post get heavily Dugg and Reddited.
The Twin Cities crimes against the Republic aren’t an accident — they are one more point on an arc of very deliberate Federal and local collusion in service of corporatist rule.
It seems that when NOLA was flooded, Michael Chertof argued at every opportunity, for the first several days, that the military could not get involved because of restrictions imposed by posse commatatus. So it is alright to attack non violent demonstrators but not to rescue drowning and/or starving flood victims. We are in a very pathetic place.
Josef K., “The Trial,” anyone?
I haven’t tried to fly since pre-911. For all I know, “they” wouldn’t let me on a plane.
Thanks Kirk for a great post.
During the DNC, I discovered Twitter, and bookmarked Jane. Went to that, to see the latest. Info plus Jane snark at its best. Nothing new from Lindsay- she probably is in the thick of it, and twitter is the last thing on her mind.
Jane’s most interesting comment re: convention/ storm– “God takes out major ad buy during RNC on Republican failures of the past 8 years: Gustav”
http://twitter.com/janehamsher
thanks wang! i’m behind the dial-up curtain, but will listen from the ‘net cafe manana
The distinction is whether someone, including insurance companies (of whom I am no great fan), is harmed by the act. There is also the distinction that the buildings torched by the FD are abandoned and scheduled for demolition, while those destroyed by ELF are still in active use (though unoccupied at the time of destruction). Elf also has damaged or destroyed equipment as well here in the Pacific Northwest. While I at least partially agree with some of their causes, I take issue with their methods. Someday, as some of the radicals of my youth discovered, somebody is going to be in one of those buildings.
Well, that is what you are meant to feel. So as people peel away from speaking out and speaking up, fewer are left and they can be picked off. But that does not mean that those who sit back will be safer, because things will only get worse.
Think of it this way: someone is trying to abduct you and they say if you allow them to tape your mouth and hands, they won’t hurt you. You know you might get hurt if you fight back. Is it safer to be rendered defenseless?
Ha! Thx VG, I missed that.
Condolences, dude.
On behalf of eCAHN who wanted to post this doormat link which says “Come Back with a Warrant, I give you this link. I can’t believe that Target is selling it!!!!
Wasn’t there an old saying which started “first they came for…)?
Hot diggity Dugg!
Not a bad price. Think I’ll toodle over there and get me one of those tomorrow.
Just what every progressive household needs! 8-)
No shit. I started to post that a few ago.
Hi wang- it’s fun to read Jane’s twitter messages.
they don’t sell them in the stores, only online.
yes! I wanted to quote it, but he is out of my league. I’d be happy to see it posted in the comments, though!
As you wish.
I haven’t twittered. Where do I go to do that?
Perhaps these people could help out in New Orleans, or wherever Gustav strikes, in order to do something constructive instead of something destructive.
I just fired up Google Earth and set the cloud animation running. For some reason it seems a lot more real to watch this thing run across Cuba in a north westerly direction when it’s silent, just looping….
I understand your point about how groups espousing violence made MLK appear more acceptable to white Americans. The Black Panthers were founded in 1966. While King remained influential until his death in 1968 (and after), his most successful protests occurred before that. The Nation of Islam was around earlier but their violence was primarily directed inward. The passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 was driven in large part by acts of violence such as the Birmingham church bombing, etc., which were committed by segregationists. In other words, the long term result of their violent acts was counterproductive to their intended goals.
Down the hall, last door on the left.
;~P
thanks, CarolynU!
By the way, argosfalcon, I do share your unease. But. I have a kid, and in the future, I don’t want him to look at me and say, why didn’t you try to do something? One of the reasons I don’t use a psuedonym on line. I want it to be very clear that I oppose this fascist and criminal administration.
well, go here to read Jane’s comments.
http://twitter.com/janehamsher
And then there’s info (somewhere, click around) about how to set up a twitter account. (I haven’t, but I did check it out
Thanks for saving me the gasoline! I’ll offer up the CC and wait for delivery.
moose and squirrel upstairs
;)
Whatever the possible role of violent groups or property destruction may have been in the civil rights struggle or the PNW, the Twin Cities protesters aren’t employing those tools or espousing them.
I hope we don’t lose sight of that central fact.
Fire department burn an abandoned building in order to train the new recruits.
As you I’d like them to find a different method and fear that someone someday may end up being harmed or killed. My feelings about harming the insurance industry financially, however,…
Thanks VG, I bookmarked it to study later.
I love pop-up books. I’ve always wanted to design one but I’m really, really, lazy.
I’ll check it out. thanks. But the stormpulse site is interesting too, and has great links. Complementary.
I must admit this abuse of power is what I was afraid of, most of america has been made numb to it in the media, like the saying went from one group to another making a cascade effect. This effect has become broader and those who’s interests are served have become more and more entrenched. To me Katrina show on a scale larger than ever before how fragile our freedoms have become.
Fuzzy sound, girlscout.
Kirk, I haven’t checked all your links, but I thought you ought to know that I-Witness, the people who documented the 2004 NYPD atrocities and whose video evidence got over 400 of the 1800 cases against demonstrators dismissed, were attacked in the residence they are using in Saint Paul today:
Later, Eileen posted this:
This seems like a very clear plan to intimidate those who documented the police actions in NYC four years ago. Earlier today, I wondered if the Minnesota authorities had contacted NYC authorities, in order to avoid the huge fines and violations NYC incurred. It seems, instead, that the Minnesota authorities took away a different lesson entirely.
LOL!