George Lakoff walked by me, alone, so I bolted out of my chair and asked to talk with him about framing: the next generation.
Main Lakoff point: McCain is sucking up all the oxygen with his false framing that he is "Country Above All" — that everything he does can be characterized as putting country over other considerations.
Be a maverick? That’s loving the country more than his party. Do what Bush says? That’s obeying his commander in chief. It’s fake, of course, but right now they are winning with this narrative.
They are taking what has traditionally been the Democratic narrative (think of JFK’s famous "Ask not what your country can do for you" epigram) and using it for themselves.
Democrats have to take it back by showing McCain is NOT about "Country Above All," that the things he does benefit his friends.
Second Lakoff point: whenever McCain utters the phrase, "My Friends," who does he mean? He means the corporate types, rich people etc.
Democrats can seize the point by showing who his friends really are.
Third Lakoff point: It isn’t that McCain is rich per se; rather, I told him we are trying to tie his policies to his being rich. Lakoff says that’s not automatically an issue — the problem is that McCain favors people who are rich and powerful while advancing a phony narrative that says he’s doing what’s right for the country.
Fourth Lakoff point: He thinks the folks around Obama are doing the right things with respect to framing but that there’s more work to be done. Others of us, including media, have to get to work dismantling the false "County Above All" narrative.
"Country Above All." Who could argue with that? It’s so patriotic! And yet we need to start pushing back against this. Today.
P.S. Oh, and Lakoff loved coming to FDL, and would enjoy be invited back again …
Related posts:





Spotlight








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

whenever McCain utters the phrase, “My Friends,” who does he mean?
That’s got campaign commercial written all over it…
Yay Egregious, seize the day!
Greetings pups!
I just met Lamont for the first time…he’s on camera now with Markos and Jane
Sure does!
hmmm, maybe too much information for a commercial – might require a documentary!!
would love to see that as a commercial
Sounds like you’re having great fun, eg. Watched a few minutes of C-Span this afternoon showing attendees on the floor boogying (sp?) to music; nice to see * real* people vs. the talking heads examining their collective asses.
Kucinich up on CSPAN
Dennis is UP !!!!
kucinich is up
*sigh* he was my first pick but dropped out before I could even give his candidacy a second thought
preach Dennis
Tell the truth
For McCain “the country” is people who make $5M + Everyone else are whiners
McShame served the country and since that time has served himself and now no longer cares what he says to get elected. He will lie, sell out to any and all bidders.
We’re working on some ideas for countering traitor Lieberman’s Republican Convention speech…
[whistles…walks away…]
wake up america
Dennis is bringing it!
sing it, dennis!
actually he seems hopped up
lol!
DK is on fire. Whoa…one for the books!
Wonderful stuff, Egregious. Thanks.
Kucinich is giving them hell – give that man some gloves and put him in the ring
You are up to something!!
lol a new friend from Mississippi LOVES these new framing ideas and is going to push it on their network
Has there been any jangling of keys or did that idea not come to fruition?
wake up, America!
brings down the house.
Moi?
…innocent look
wow. Dennis, you are the man
Plenty of jangled nerves, no keys
Yeah John chiang is on. I love that he stood up to the gubernator
John Chiang up now, the man who stood up to the Governator and said, “NO, you are not paying California state employees the federal minimum wage because you and the Legislature can’t agree on a budget. NO!”
That was excellent. And I like “Wake up America” better than anything else I’ve heard.
What a great get, egregious!
I don’t care that Dennis is a funny looking short man, he shoots from the hip and the heart…LOVE HIM!!!
oo thanks Teddy, I didn’t know that
I’m with you jackie.
Hershey a go go coated donuts w/ sprinkles
We need more stemwinding speeches like the one Kucinich just gave. Man!
Left ya one downstairs.
hello all,just got back from first day at class.
McGiggolo,has not done ANYTHING positive for “the country” that i can think of…so how has he put the country first/ when he sez this …SIMPLY ASK ………HOW
SouthernDragon -
Got it! epu’d….keeping fingers crossed for all y’all. *g*
actually he seems hopped up
Is there such a thing as a Red-Bull hangover?
I thought he was gonna come out of his shoes!
loved it.
*g*
I came to the mountains from Fla. to escape the hurrricanes…guess who resides here right now?……………………………………………………………………………….Fay
[Mod Note: Please help the servers and the margins by not holding the keys down so long. Thank You]
Evenin’ egregious;
George Lakoff is one very astute observer of the human animal.
I have always found his perspective insightful, gentle and humane, but, clearly, through his research, he is very familiar with the ‘lizard-brain’ aspect of so many of our fellow ‘upright’ apes.
Lakff’s advice is sound. (Let us embrace the ‘fury’ and kick some very deserving butt!)
“My friends” translates into “Them what ‘make’ five million per anum or more, aka, the ‘haves’ and the ‘have so obscenely much mores’”.
Would enjoy Lakoff any time he finds the time to be ‘here’.
An alligator?
What class? Student or teacher.
Where is muh manners?
Good evening, all y’all!
Put some of his constituents from AZ up and ask them how he served AZ also ask him when the last time he voted on anything. Even when some filibuster overides failed 59-39 w/ the only other missed vote being Kennedy.
OK
digg this
and upvote on reddit, please
John McGiggolo,used nepotism to gain entrance to the Naval Aca,and flight training……………he has always USED political influence for his OWN INTENTS and purposes
Elliott.. funny digg title
student…digital media…Im pulling my own bootstraps as YOU know i must “G”
My Friends is his snark for assholes
No “Country” for old man.
Christy’s governor is up now!
bom dia DW
oh
BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
being ONE of the KEATING 5 John…vacationing with Keating in the Bahamas all those years….must have been teh difficult to put the COUNTRY first then…no?
howdy doodie sweetbones!
What school?
Howdy, wobbly.
a local university here….dont want to be more specific,but i feel teh stoooooooooopit,next to the youngins
Good to see you guys…it is a complete zoo in the press room. I am a quiet person. What am I doing here? They keep putting me in front of a camera because I can’t think of a reason to say no.
Today was Reuters and then Remix
oh i get it…he put NASSAU first
bwahahahahahahahahahahahaha
Hmm,I’m and adult educator, don’t feel stupid’ Lifelong learning is where it’s at.
enjoy,wear a fedora,no drudge….how about a cloche?
(((sadly)))
If John McShame is putting country first why is he lying to America everyday
i agree totally…every day i learn at least one new thing…my dear departed brillant dad,used to say,the more i know…the more i know NOTHING…a reason to trod on…no?
ugh. I turned to MSNBC and Scarborough was on. gag. But I did enjoy his lil meltdown this morning with David Shuster
Re Lakoff, all these sociolinguists with convictions will tell you they were framed. *g*
yup
Barb Mikulski and Barbara Boxer
well ya see,Cindy mixes up his meds,and poor John has lied and flip,flopped so many times,he just cant get it straight
John the Non….straightshooter
yay my senator critter is up
John McFancypants is really quite IG…noble ..no?
Now Mary Landrieu, from the GOP wing of the Democratic party.
What wing was Boxer from?
imo…there is absolutely nothing attractive about that man,in form or manner…..and yet while standing on top of his money he feels lofty no doubt
you aren’t kidding. I’m surprised she is up there speaking
what do you teach?
I agree but mr was wondering if Scarborough was drunk this morning after his lil partisan WATB fit he threw on tv
So does every democrat that ever lived get to make a speech?
he is teh lucky to have avoided the graybar hotel methinks
Marcy’s Senator Debbie up now. I wish one of these ladies would talk about the horrors of the Bush Administration. Everything is sooooo position, except of course Dennis.
Oh, she just said “Bush/McCain policies.”
He’s from the faux wing of msnbc
politicos love to speechify
This is the Woman Senator section.
DiFi won’t be there, of course, because of her broken ankle. Kind of silly when you read in the Times today that Ted Kennedy got out of a Denver hospital bed with kidney stones to make his speech.
Link here on Ted’s struggle
he proved it this morning. everyone looked uncomfrontable. i wonder what would happen if someone said ‘dead intern’ in his presence
he is remarkable,and a real HERO John McFancypants
My doc is in adult ed, I am and instructional designer building online courses and working with technology in education. My interest was adult literacy but it’s almost impossible to make a living in that area.
wtf? I’m ready for the attacks to begin (been ready)
i would pay good money to hear that on Natl teebee”g”
This is also the 30 second soundbite audition section
Wow.
This has been very kewl all afternoon, but NO ONE delivered any kind of a punch like Kucinich!
Such a whirlwind of activity, and trying to keep up with the convention, the vids, the speeches, Mr. siri’s going nutz, can’t get a minute with me or the family big screen.
when he can’t take it anymore, i go down to dem headquarters with my puter and watch there.
this is pol junkie heaven.
i’m SO thankful for FDL. to know i’m ot the only one.
hi guys.
hi wobblybits
and sadlyyes and teddy, and just everyone.
:)
DenCo’s my home town ya know. this is the only time since i left in 2001 that i’ve been homesick.
lol
how wonderful,sending non chocolate KUDOS through the nets
Not a registered member
That’s why I’m not in the field anymore.
Though I still get to do some cool stuff.
i love you muchly!
bom dia Siri
agreed dennis brought it. Now bring some more dems!!!
it’s only 5:30 there
most excellent egregious
Jared Berstein:
wow, who invited Mary Landrieu to this party?
And – is Senator Mikulski more than 4 feet tall?
I would love for someone to say it to him on his show
Hi egregious and everyone. Just got home and tuned in. I love hearing the reports from the convention. Keep on keeping us posted!
Brooks on NewsHour continuing his screed that Democrats should steer away from the economy and that working class Americans (whom Brooks mystically channels) don’t want Obama messing with the economy.
Yea, my research was on the GED. I got mine in 1967 so it was an especially meaningful experience to do the study.
Sorry. I’m foaming at the chops to go after Mcsprinkles
Why, you forming a gymnastics team to compete with the 9 year old Chinese?
thank you
wooooooooooooooooooooooooooe,for 5 years i had no table,so now LIFES MY BANQUET,and yall can pound sand
wow
i’m so worried for Teddy.
trying to brace for another Kennedy funeral is just more than i can handle. I pray so hard for him!
wow
Thanks for posting that link teddy!
I hate this noise behind the speakers. Teddy said last night that FOX news is in charge of the feed.
This is really sloppy DNC work.
LMAO goodness not ‘foaming’ at the chops LOL. Sorry yall.
better lay off them sticky keys!
hahahahahahahahahaha
like everything our whore press sez
just do the complete opposite,and all will be dandy
yeah and i’m SOOOOO with you wobbly. waitin for the pounding!
yesterday i was just disheartened that a whole day went by and no one mentioned that we are FIGHTING FOR OUR COUNTRY here!
that we are rejecting 8 years of fascism!
where’s the rage?
i’m waitin’!!!!
yes ive always been a drama queen…Sarah Heartburn so to speak
i’m a vegan but i’m feeling like red meat tonight
didja see this?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v…..re=related
Why, you forming a gymnastics team to compete with the 9 year old Chinese?
Sen Mikulski might be the same height, but I don’t see her gettin’ much air in the vault competition….*g*
lol
Kucinich is very popular with progressives here in Hawaii, as well. He has boots on the ground here who are willing to walk the walk for him. And they are not real happy to have to work for someone else. Dennis is Da Man!
Bob in HI
jane named her “Ma Kettle”.
she’s so damned sharp.
Jane, that is.
LOL
she sure is!
okay Fay is outwearing her welcome…..
Hey Raven, my Dad did his doc in Adult Ed, too. If you’re interested, I’ll give you the backstory.
Bob in HI
You have FB mail.
It CANNOT possibly rain too much. You are either in Tennessee, North Carolina or Va and this drought is horrible!
Just interviewed John Hall on energy policy and possible changes in energy policy after the election…bottom line he is very encouraged over what will be possible with more and better Dems. But the clock is ticking on climate change.
Do I need to write another post?
Since there is nothing else going on tonight. . . .:)
yes.
Michael Moore’s new book “Mike’s Election Guide” is # 3 on amazon already. He writes about Mccain.
http://www.amazon.com/Mikes-El…..0446546275
This is from an article about Michael’s book:
….
http://www.alternet.org/blogs/…..civilians/
Good luck with that.
Emanuel up.
How about a commercial, showing series of clips of McC saying “My friends,” over and over, along w/ a montage of folks, starting w/, say, the Keating Five, then Ralph Reed, Jack Abramoff, and then some nice recognizable not-so-popular figures. Needs work, but I like the principle. Of course, there’d be a voicover saying the above “Who are JMcC’s friends?”
hissssssssssssssss
Rahm
ohhhhhhhhhhhh yes…good!
Michael Moore Dares to Ask: What’s So Heroic About Being Shot Down While Bombing Innocent Civilians?
——————-
McFancypants called himelf a war criminal on National teebee
When is Hillary up?
Brokaw says the country wants “an elevated debate”, while the delegates want red meat.
Tom Brokaw, Repub concern troll…
And since it’s almost 8:00 P.M. EST, could we plese just have Olbermann, and ditch, say, Pat Buchanadana?
There’s really a pretty good convention going on – it’s too bad that no one on MSNBC or CNN has seen much of it….
Webb was on two hours ago explaining that “many” Vietnam Vets and other Americans still blame the Democratic Party for the U.S. “failing” in Vietnam (personally I blame the Democratic Party for getting us in it). Do you really think attacking Mc Cain on these grounds is going to increase Obama’s chances?
toward the end of the evening
wobbly – Is there a link? What triggered it?
Thanks Sweetie :)
Good point. Anyone who buys that argument is already going to vote for Obama.
if he keeps using his POW experience an OMNIPOTENT sledge hammer yes…he is not my definition of a hero,he is NOT selfless,he does NOT put country first.he is a very confused man,he does not confuse me
LOL – I was thinking – weren’t you a shy one?
btw, where can we see you? C-span? comedy central?
We don’t need to talk about Vietnam and McC. His policies NOW are plenty of fodder for the campaign.
I submit that it is a mistake. Let him beat it to death and it’ll take care of itself.
ding
yes if continues to flog it,by all means YES…the boy that cried wolf
‘Egregious’ is a bloggin’ force of nature. Great eye, great catch, great insight for us all. Thank you.
That “My Friends” hooey got on my last nerve about 3 months ago. It’s no more than a reflexive grunt by an unimaginative clod.
I’m in The Big Tent, too, btw. You long-time FDL readers are fortunate to have E over here, in the trenches for you.
BenGoshi
posting at http://www.leftinalabama.com
i hope Biden does…a word ,a noun,and iwas apow ….worked well on Julie annie
oh he is a clod…tone deaf,and apparently has FEW friends he doesnt have to pay
Raven-
YGM @ Facebook.
Bob in HI
Yeah, so why did the Dems help McCain shoot down Wes Clark for saying the same thing? Shame on them! I wanted Wes Clark for Veep. But Biden is almost as good.
Bob in HI
Sounds like a winner, to me.
Bob in HI
Oh my stars. Thank you. Making new friends….
im still suffering Hillary fatigue,from what Terry McCauliff just said ,i shall NOT catch her speech
Egregious! great catch!! and thank you for your reporting – fascinating what FDL i showing us.