For six years, the Bush Administration and the nation’s communication companies have been illegally spying on Americans’ phone calls and e-mails. They did this in direct violation of the Constitution’s 4th Amendment and a federal statute – FISA. Both laws emphatically forbid such surveillance unless the government first obtains a warrant from an independent (eg, FISA) court.
FISA makes violation of these warrant requirements a felony, but the Bush “Justice” Department refuses to prosecute anyone. And rather than demand a halt to such lawbreaking, a full accounting of what happened, and legal accountability for the perpetrators, the US Senate is planning today to grant immunity to the lawbreakers, while sanctioning more warrantless surveillance, weakened oversight and a sham investigation.
These FISA revisions essentially gut the law’s protections; they will continue the cover up of criminal behavior and ensure that no one is ever held accountable for breaking the law.
And it wasn’t just a few, scattered incidents of warrantless surveillance, nor was the spying directed solely at suspected “terrorists.” The spying was massive, sweeping, and undifferentiated. Everyone’s privacy was vulnerable.
The telecoms violated both the law and their obligation to protect their customers’ privacy from unlawful government snooping. With their help, the Bush Administration diverted, stored and searched through millions of our communications looking for . . . what?
None but a few government insiders knows what they’ve got, who gets to look at it, what becomes of it. And because the FISA revision bill gives the telecoms immunity from lawsuits, we may never know the extent of this illegal spying. More important, we won’t know how our private information becomes misinterpreted and misused – that is, used against us, without us knowing why or being able to do anything about it.
Only a handful in Congress have been briefed, and given this Administration’s pervasive lying, we have no reason to trust that even these few were told the truth. Most in Congress remain blissfully ignorant of what these programs involve, and their attempts to explain their support for the revisions reveal they have no clue what they’re approving.
The Senate and House sponsors of this shameful effort have consistently misrepresented this bill. Their claims that it is a reasonable “compromise” between national security needs and civil liberties include the notion that if a bill makes legal what was previously illegal, that’s progress. They claim the bill requires the executive branch to investigate itself, so that is better than having the executive branch defy Congressional efforts to investigate. How pitiful.
A few courageous Senators – Feingold (video here, and see RawStory for text), Dodd (h/t emptywheel), Bingaman — are trying to stop this shameful action, but they are facing overwhelming defeat by virtually all Republicans and far too many Democrats, including their own leadership and the presumptive Presidential nominees of both parties.
Can you imagine the leaders of our present Congress signing the Declaration of Independence? Would any of them have insisted that the Constitution not be ratified unless it included a Bill of Rights?
The excuse these “leaders” offer for their craven refusal to uphold the Constitution and the rule of law is that we face unprecedented threats from terrorists. They are so afraid that they’re willing to give up our rights against a powerful government if the government will only protect them. But the Constitution does not give Congress the power to make this compromise; their oaths compel them to uphold the Constitution.
The nation’s founders were not such frightened people. Those who signed the Declaration of Independence pledged their lives, their fortunes and their sacred honor in open defiance of the world’s most powerful empire, a regime that would certainly have hanged them if they failed in their efforts to become free men. Now our Congress cowers because they fear a President with 25 percent approval ratings and a Republican Party that the electorate can’t wait to throw out of office. Pathetic.
Last week, I got several e-mails/phone calls from the DNC, Obama, etc asking for donations. “Can we count on you for support” they asked? Here’s my answer: The Democratic leadership deserves our scorn. If they want my support, my donations or my votes, they must earn them first. Clear enough?




46 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
We are no longer a nation ruled by the laws we make for ourselves. It is going to be difficult to teach junior high civics with a straight face.
A few brave souls are standing up and saying This. Is. Wrong. Thank you Scarecrow for being one of our leaders.
Digg this post
I’m thinking more like teaching junior high civics with tears rolling down cheeks. America is under siege and the perpetrator is Congress. How now?
Thanks for a wonderful post, Scarecrow. The Turley video is great; I saw it last night.
I just called Senator Specter’s office to thank him for his wonderful work on the floor of the Senate yesterday. He did a great job of highlighting many problems with the bill. I encouraged him to follow up on these statements yesterday with actual votes today. I asked for him to vote for the Feingold/Dodd/Leahy amendment or at least the Bingaman amendment and then to vote no on cloture if they fail. I didn’t ask how he planned to vote, since he said yesterday that he planned to vote for the bill anyway. I thought a little push might help no matter how unlikely his vote. At the very least, he deserved some measure of thanks for his clear statements yesterday. If he votes the wrong way, that’s worth another call to point out his inconsistency.
g’ morning, Scarecrow… I think Congress is quite determined to roll back the Constitution… according to Pundita, Feinstein and Pelosi are introducing bills to make sure Congressmembers get approval before posting any information to the web…
4th Amendment, 1st Amendment…. eh, what’s a few amendments between friends?
Coffee is strong and hot by the way…
Now it’s our turn.
Are you ready to pledge your life, your fortune and your honour for freedom?
It’s easy to say yes, harder to act upon. It takes real courage.
Dugg. As I said in my faxes yesterday to Clinton and Schumer: This date will go down in history as either a day when the Senate stood up and supported the Bill of Rights and the Constitution…or be remembered as the day the Senate decided to allow Bush/Cheney to hide their crimes and put this country on the fast train to totalitarianism. Every Senator who votes for this bill will be remembered. Every Senator who votes against it will also be remembered. Both in the history books and at re-election time.
Does someone have easy access to names of telecoms that caved to Bush? There is more than one way to extract a ounce or two of flesh about this, I’m thinking. As I recall, Qwest is one of the (the only one?) that refused to play ball. Never mind that the CEO was more or less covering his butt re other issues. They did the right thing.
And Scarecrow? You’re absolutely right about refusing to give dollars to weak-kneed pols who seem to have parked their integrity in their wallets. I’ve done the same thing, sent the same messages. But every time I do, I’m haunted by the consequences of failure to send my widow’s mite to Dems. And by the way, have never received acknowledgement of my “threat” to disengage financially.
Another good response would be: “I’ve been asking the very same question. But by the votes I’ve been seeing on FISA, the answer would appear to be ‘no, we can’t count on you, at least when it comes to supporting the Fourth Amendment.”
Its a good thang that da Dimocrats is da opposituhn party cuz udderwise we wud be in bad shape indeedy.
Well, initially, ways to separate us from our money by analyzing financial records and spending habits.
But now, ways to separate us from our liberty by observing every possible transaction, every move. We are at a dangerous point regarding what’s left of our personal freedom.
It can get to the point where anyone who speaks up against the matrix will be considered a terrorist.
We got a couple of good updates last night from pow wow over at Glenn’s blog. They can be seen here and here.
There is a very good explanation of why an old fashioned filibuster would accomplish nothing and support for the opinion that the really crucial vote is the cloture vote, where we only need 40 brave patriots to stand up for the Constitution.
Just when one imagines that Ms Pelosi couldn’t git no lower, why she snake bellies through the deepest wagon-wheel rut she can find, way below sea level.
I expectorate her comity-lovin colleagues are slidin’ ‘right’ along with her.
Mo’ und besser Polelosiums.
Please … no.
Welcome to the corporate fascist aristocracy country of the “United States of America”. I see the 4th estate is in on it as well. AP Article giving Senators cover to vote for illegal spying on Americans.
I think it must be shouted over and over again that it wasn’t until the incompetent neoCons took over the executive branch that all of a sudden they needed to violate our consitution in order to protect us from some terrorists living in caves in the mountains of Pakistan.
Let’s pulll for the amendments.
BitchMitch McConnell is telling us an amended bill will be vetoed.They’ve worked hard to earn our contempt, and succeeded. Barnacle to Reid: “Right back atcha“.
amen, scarecrow. well said. thank you.
burp!
I think it’s time for a new host. This going down at least once a week and little burps all the time is unsatisfactory.
Excuse you.
Amen
digg and upvote on reddit too
Called my two: Schumer is voting against immunity. Clinton’s office line is busy, which I take as a good sign.
funny how the connections get funky when we talk about FISA,
and yes, I am crafting myself a fresh hat from some shiny tinfoil – why do you ask?
It just means she’s got the phone off the hook.
Hi, pups. Sad, sad day. I’m looking for my blackest, black clothes.
Anyone know what Give-em-no-Hell Harry is/was going on about? I couldn’t bear to listen to Miss Mitch, and didn’t think I could stomach Hal, either. Kit Bond up? Procedural crap?
Thank you for this, Scarecrow. I thought Professor Turley was just breathtaking last night.
FunnyD
Heh. Patty Murray has gone one better: full voicemail box, not answering phone.
Hope we can primary her sorry a$$ next time she’s up for re-election. IIRC, she voted for cloture on this a week or so ago. (spit).
FunnyD
I wish the residents of Missouri, all of them, could watch their shining star Kit Bond as he makes an ass of himself right now. I’m so tired of listening to these pussies patting themselves on the back for the fine job they’ve done wiping out the 4th Amendment.
Vote at 11:15 EDT according to CSPAN, but that might not be the latest info.
FD
the masks are really coming off of the Democratic Party leaders now that the power of the presidency as well as congress is within their grasp.
from John Wonderlich (program director, Sunlight Foundation – and long time kossack)
I think Randi Rhodes is going to be playing a LOT of choruses of “you’re a lying sack of crap” today.
Good to see you pups. Gotta get ready to go earn the paycheck.
FunnyD
Someone once said ‘one of those forefather guys?’ that once freedom and democracy is lost it is lost for good. Our country and democracy is gone and we might as well get use to it. There is no group of people pols or otherwise with enough guts to retain a free government or country for the sake of free people. So get use to it the same way China has and Germany did and the USSR. Just relax and accept it and all will go well for us and the spinless population. The final ’straw’ was NOT impeaching Bush/Chaney and Republican and Dem enablers also. The 4th of July Independence will be renamed the ‘The July 4th Great Day Of Irony’.
I would tune in a lot earlier then, just in case
I’m sorry, but it’s all I can do to keep from throwing things at the screen when he steps up to speak. More than once I’ve had to simply mute the sound.
Apparently Kit wants to change the state motto from “Show Me” to “Just Trust Us.”
With his slurred speech, I could have sworn he said “surveillance mythologies” when he tried to say “surveillance methodologies”. I think that was a Freudian slip. The myth is that our surveillance will catch the terrorists. The smart ones stopped electronic communications in the 1990’s.
I now believe with growing certainty that the reason “impeachment” is “off the table” is that if there were investigations, the complicity of Nancy Pelosi, Steny Hoyer and Harry Reid would be dragged into the sunlight and none of those three moral cowards could face that disinfectant.
Their parts in the destruction of the 4th Amendment to the Constitution would be so overwhelmingly evident that they would not only be thrown from office, it would make the departure of Nixon seem insignificant… grab the torches and pitch-forks and meet on Capitol Hill, time to toss the Franken-Dems out of office would be the battle cry of the men and women who actually give a shit about our Republic…
That the Democrats have forgotten how to govern is a given, to say that they are afraid of their own shadow is a sad reflection of a once-great party that actually stood for something once upon a time, instead of standing for focus-grouped, poll-driven lobbyist-purchased pablum for the low-information constituents who might not ever vote.
It’s sad, almost criminal, to see the “presumptive” nominee of my “party” shrug this offense to the Constitution off and act as though it’s an inconsequential matter of “partisan politics”. The only change we’re going to get in Obama seemingly, is someone who speaks in complete sentences, and while that’s an improvement it’s not much of one if he shows absolutely no desire to Support and Defend the Constitution of these United States.
Sort of OT, but election related
MEMPHIS, Tenn. – (Business Wire) FedEx Express, a subsidiary of FedEx Corp. (NYSE: FDX) and the world’s largest express transportation company, today announced its support of Express Your Vote, an initiative of the Overseas Vote Foundation (OVF), a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization dedicated to ensuring an estimated six million overseas Americans have the ability to effectively participate in the federal electoral process.
http://www.earthtimes.org/arti…..1316.shtml
Marcy is live blogging both the Mukasey hearing (CSPAN 2) and the FISA debate (later on CSPN 3)
Oops, Scarecrow, switch those arms to the other sides. FISA is on CSPAN2 and the Mukasey hearing will be on 3.
Doubleliveblogging?
Now that’s impressive.
I wake up this morning to read about Obama getting it wrong about his getting it wrong:
Obama Says His Critics Haven’t Been Listening
What an insult! But, I suppose that’s why the telecoms are doing the listening for us — so we don’t have to.
This is from the NYT on BO re: Fisa??? “. . .supported a proposed wiretap law that he once promised to oppose. . .”
Thanks NYT for that bunch of words.
Amen on your conclusion. I am becoming so disgusted with the Dems in Congress, it is nearing the level of contempt I have for the democrats.
It is totally incomprehensible to me. “My heart is breaking” and my mind
is beyond understanding and certainly way beyond any hope of affirming these creeps. How in the world did they get there; because iimpeachment was off the table, because folks like Feinstein and McCain’s wife and Dubya’s family connections are doing just fine with receipts from the endless warmongering. Hooray for Maliki saying we want a timeline and if we don’t get it, we’re not dealing. Still they have dealt with State and others to insure minimal return to Iraq for the oil. As Bill Moyers says, it was always about the oil. I wish to God we had a Supreme Court that could get the early energy talks info and use that to charge “them all” with war crimes, including the oil companies. Lord have mercy.
Blessings and thanks for always being a great commentator
A used car salesman have more dignity than all the members of Congress combined.
It’s the product of the American education/indoctrination system, Congress.
These US Senators swore to uphold and defend the US Constitution. That they would engage in and effort to create retroactive immunity to shield those in the Administration and the telecommunications industry who may have broken who knows what laws in the name of expediency and equivocation is gut-wrenchingly disappointing. This erosion in the rule of law will lead to more craven attempts to supplant these lesser individual values for the supreme values that have been the underpinnings of our representative democracy for over 230 years. If the leaders can cut these corners and not be accountable, why shouldn’t everyone else? It’s a disgusting turning point for our nation.
Your flashing Breck advertisement near the top right of this article refuses to allow me to scroll down to actually read the whole article.
Doesn’t that just say everything …about the ‘New and Improved’ America?
The argument that this is a compromise BILL is false. The 1978 FISA law that was violated by this administration well before 9/11 does not need to be overhauled. This bill, being introduced is trying to use smoke and mirrors to state how our privacy will be protected in the FUTURE. All these protection schemes were already in PLACE in the original FISA LAW. This administration ELECTED to by-pass the LAW – it is that SIMPLE. It is only being introduced as something NEW to redraw the starting line to PROTECT the CRIMINAL ACTS of spying on AMERICA, and granting a free pass to the TELECOMMUNICATION Corporations who failed to uphold our privacy and a Congress that failed to do their job of oversight powers and thus COMPLICIT in the CRIME. Investigate Prosecute, and IMPRISION ALL who facilitated the CRIME. UPHOLD THE LAW OF THE LAND and do NOT grant immunity to the lawbreakers, and if this fails, let’s clean house of those co-conspirators and appeasers.