The full report is available as a PDF here. From the report summary, beginning on page 92:
…[W]e concluded that McDonald committed misconduct and violated Department policies and civil service law by considering political or ideological affiliations in assessing Honors Program and SLIP candidates. (93)
[W]e concluded that Elston violated federal law and Department policy by deselecting candidates based on their liberal affiliations. (94)
We also concluded that Elston committed misconduct, and violated federal law and Department policy, when he deselected candidates and denied appeals based on his perception of the political or ideological affiliations of the candidates. (96)
We also concluded that OARM Director DeFalaise did not adequately or timely address the concerns that were brought to his attention concerning the Screening Committee’s deselections. (96)
Finally, we concluded that Acting Associate Attorney General Mercer did not adequately address the concerns that were brought to his attention by several senior Department officials that the Screening Committee’s deselections appeared to have been politicized. (97)…
[A]n OARM employee … recalled that one of the [deselected] candidates she raised to DeFalaise’s attention was first in his law school class at Georgetown University, had clerked for a federal district court judge, and was currently clerking for a Second Circuit judge. [footnote 41: This candidate also had worked as a law clerk for Senator Russell Feingold, a Democrat, and for Human Rights Watch, but the OARM employee does not recall pointing out the candidate's political or ideological affiliations to DeFalaise at this time.] (59-60)…
[Records of applicants destroyed]
The Committee used paper copies of the applications on which Fridman and McDonald made handwritten notations about the applicants, but those documents were destroyed prior to the initiation of our investigation. (68,69) (emphasis mine)
Allow this to soak in for a moment: documentary evidence in personnel files at the US Department of Justice was destroyed, including notes on hiring decisions and other pertinent documents which are generally kept in all cases for review by employers nationwide should there be discrimination or other claims which require later review. They were destroyed. As in missing, taken out of the files, not there…before the OIG and the OPR could look at them.
There will be a lot more on this to come, but that stood out like a big flashing sign to me — people at the department of justice destroyed evidence in a matter being investigated within the department by the OIG. Jeebus, we are going to have a lot of work to do cleaning up after these asshats.
(YouTube via Veracifier.)
Related posts:
- Report Confirms Poor Electrical Work by KBR Endangers US Troops in Iraq and Afghanistan
- Breaking: Senate Judiciary Approves Sotomayor Nomination – 13 to 6
- Eric Holder’s Secrets
- See You in September? CIA Wants to Stall IG Report All Summer
- BREAKING: Stunning al-Haramain Filing Shames Obama; Shows Duplicity of Officials





Spotlight








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

Morning Redd,
Wonder if the culprits are happy that this is coming out while St. George is still in office to pardon them on into the promised land…?
oh my
can i just give mad props to the chimperor in chief
GM shares at lowest since January 1975
Thanks Christy!
FWIW, I’m having trouble digging the post.
digg
snark
Monica said she didn’t “mean to.” That makes it ok.
/snark
The people in this administration are not conservatives, so none of this reflects badly on conservatism. Conservatism is not a failed ideology.
At least that’s what the conservatives are saying.
Thanks, Christy. What a mess. And we are going to be left to clean it up. How dare they destroy important papers! I thought that the gov’t was required to keep everything. Silly me.
Most of conservatism is a bunch of grumpy people who hate taxes.,The rest they just made up.
Document destruction? Mass email deletions?
Different Day, Same Shit in Bu’ush land.
I’ll, uh, have a side dish of “Fuck you and your subpoenas. Executive Privilege.”
they conserve nothing but their SWISS BANK ACCTS…period
Where are the arrest warrents for these bozos?
yea…let the LITTLE PEOPLE pay,like their posthumous high preistess Leona said…HER WORDS WILL NEVER DIE …”g”
Our own DOJ destroyed evidence before OIG or OPR could take a gander?
Oh. My.
Can’t wait to see where all those orders (via wink and nod) came from…
AZ Matt, I wonder the same…
and there will be no prosecution because?
Cindy Lou is hiding them in the beer vats
“Obstruction of Justice”
What did Alberto Gonzalez know and when did he know it?
My guess, this goes to the top.
people at the department of justice destroyed evidence in a matter being investigated within the department by the OIG.
… brings to mind Joe Biden’s Freudian slip at one of the early debates:
“The Department of Injustice…”
pass the popcorn and red wine please
So Christy, I’ll ask the dumb question for the day…can these bozos be prosecuted for document destruction? (Assuming that someone wants to prosecute them, which I realize, is a huge gigantic massive leap of chasm assumption on my part….)
Pelosi will say it’s off the table.
Dugg.
It sure would be a lot easier to “clean up after these asshats” if someone would charge them, then cut a deal for insider info.
In my Fantasy World…..
*sigh*
Thanks Christy.
Quelle suprise, nez pas?
I guess we nasty libruls were right all along.
BC
How many of these thugs can we arrest, convict and incarcerate?
Where are the arrest warrents for these bozos?
check the baskets beneath the shredders…
Prosection will have to await AG Edwards or Napolitano.
I love red wine with my popcorn! lol
So, there are 2 of us, eh?, sadlyyes???
I just love red wine, period.
Ya think?
Elections have consequences, folks!
BC
ohgoodgawd! WHAT. DOES. IT. TAKE?!
AG Whitehouse.
I not only think he’d be the best, but I love the sound of that title and name.
:)
(((BobbyG))))
Trouble is- there is only one Justice Dept. and it’s in the hands of the gooper mafia. It ain’t a gunna indict it’s own- and pardons will keep the next justice dept. from indicting. There’s no way out of this perfect crime scenario that I can see short of civil suits.
Any natural number less than 1.
Bush is going to be signing pardons for his entire last month in office.
BC
si.
me toooooo.
Lambrusco and salami and popcorn.
A FINE meal if ever there was one.
hehe
begging. wag wag wag ;->
That works for me as well.
Prosection will have to await AG Edwards or Napolitano.
Are you suggesting that A.G. Mukasey won’t be all over this?
I crack myself up sometimes…
Me, too, red wine, white wine, popcorn…
“But I’m not drinking any fucking merlot!”
writer’s cramp. yessssss!!! it just might save the country, hecque, the whole world!
oh yes,ill be doing a show on the properties of red wine this month,you can also take the pills,which i do
http://shaggydogfarms.com/
From pp. 98-99 of the report:
LOL
OT – urgent fisa update from glenn greenwald:
my bold.
please call obama’s offices:
senate DC office: (202) 224-2854
senate DC fax: (202) 228-4260
campaign: (866) 675-2008 (choose option 6)
Sadly, you’re cracking me up too… ;)
Hmmm.
Where’s our lawyers?
Can pardons be signed with the Dim Son’s autopen?
I think it’s going to be interesting to watch the pardons come out at the end of the Cheney junta. I remember when Bush I pardoned the top 5 Iran-Contra conspirators and nobody made a peep, especially not in the media.
I wonder if Tweety and Pimpster are going to say anything next January?
and dawgs are expected to drink from the toilet… not this pack!
Goes to the top? Yes. As will the list of pardons.
Thanks Boo for the diggI am sure Jane, Christy, et al appreciate your digging! Now we just have to remind the rest of the good pups to also digg the post! Remember that digging and the clicks generated help support the Lake!!
Remember every one can see who is digging so please do your part to support the Lake!
Christy nice post and thanks for reporting what we all already knew about the DOJ. These appointiees are nothing but political hacks and value party affiliation and loyality to the party/prez over loyality to the Laws of this country and the Constitution! I can wait to watch the trials in Live Blogging from the court rooms…
I had some Shiraz last night with my sandwiches consisting of
alfalfa spouts
thin sliced cucumber
thin sliced tomato
thin sliced avocado
on Russian rye w/mayo, seasoned with seasoned pepper and sea salt
Try it. Hot weather meal par excellance.
and pardons will keep the next justice dept. from indicting.
I see GWB, sometime just before Jan. 20, 2009, holding up a Washington D.C. phone book, and announcing the pardon of each and every person whose name is contained therein…
That movie sucked.
;)
oopsie folks …Pop it on the stove OK?
When buying microwave popcorn, watch out for butter flavoring. The Associated Press recently reported that a man who had eaten three bags of microwaved popcorn a day for several years was diagnosed with a severe respiratory ailment known as popcorn lung. Diacetyl, found in many brands of microwave popcorn, is the suspected culprit.
very British,lived in London once upon a time
I use an air popper- works great and no fat.
absolutely NOT! we have our scruple to protect. at least i THINK we have one left, if i can just find it.
Ah! It was hiding in bed with the covers over its head.
Let’s go.
Cue the chorus of Valkieries (good spellers need not apply).
bows,dofts sombrero
Since Obama has shown he can equivocate with the best of them, I’m doubtful much will be done. Still I wonder, if these patronage and ideology based hires can be reevaluated using Civil Service SOP. Can any of our bureaucratic brethren out there let us know?
OMG
YUM!
thx!
lol.
omgthatsoundsgood!
The current govt.- all branches- has proven that a criminal president- if he is clever enough to start a stupid ass war, can get away with ANYTHING. Congress and- to a lesser extent- the courts, will treat him like a king.
Obama’s another politician with presidential fever. Don’t expect him to take any risks.
Not kidding. One yummie meal. Pile it high.
I faxed Obama yesterday with my anti-FISA rant.
OT – McBrain is touting his off-shore drilling epiphany now – in Santa Barbara, Ca.!!!
Brain-dead? I was on the Santa Barbar beach in about 1984, long after an off-shore spill. There were gobs of oil still all over the place. We picked a spot where there appeared to be no globs, put down a blanket, and everything was ruined anyway. Blanket, towels, swim-suits, and shoes – all ruined.
Santa-fucking-Barbara?
McBrain strikes again, in his never-ending campaign to commit political suicide. Who’s advising this guy – Dr. Kevorkian?
If you’re going to all that trouble, I hope you made the mayonnaise too.
color me surprised that anyone admitted it but then again this administration has conducted itself no different than any crime syndicate
i’m not kidding either. we grow our own ingredients, bake the bread.
hecque. even used to grow our own popcorn. the mr. complained because the corn popped up so big and fluffy, he had to change his recipe for toppings.
TRUE THAT.
We have simply gotta get past the fossil era. There are in fact viable nascent large alternatives.
we did, from our own hens’ eggs. fed with supplements of weeds from the garden. best stuff in the -drool- world. where u think i got these hips?!?!
Is this the testimony (video) that Gonzo prepared for for a solid week?
oh. now that was unkind. *g*
Great work, CHS.
Santa Barbarians will not be happy.
More McBrain brilliance – MSNBC reports that the idiot has now conceded that off-shore drilling won’t have much of a practical effect, but may have a “psychological effect”.
Teh Stupid – it just plain burns…
it’s possible something could come of this one – if, as it appears this is one bushco crime that was not facilitated by complicit dems, maybe the dems will pursue it.
but i’m not holding my breath. doesn’t it strike one as curious that this information came from within the bush administration – that even with all bushco has done to corrupt the DOJ, there are still some vestiges of accountability, unlike in congress which has the constitutional mandate to check presidential overreach and yet has not only completely failed to do so, but has facilitated the worst of bushco’s crimes.
What makes you think the pardons haven’t been written and signed already?
We have simply gotta get past the fossil era.
Well, not *electing* a fossil would be a good start…
Why on earth would we need a psychological effect for fuel? Are we supposed to pretend that our cars have gas in them?
excuse me sir. we’re not finished here yet. step aside if you must.
thank you.
judging by obama’s failure with fisa, I am not sure we will even make a start
ummm… not to sound too much like a broken record, but Mukasey could be impeached.
Honestly. He could. He really could.
I know… I know… Only when investments in porcine aviation show a definite promise of actual profits…
Yeah, I love the lame attempted McBu’ush justification that while new drilling won’t get us any more oil to the gas tanks for maybe 10 years, it’ll “send a message to the markets” that will attenuate price increases.
Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahohohohohohohohohohohohohohohohoheeheeheheeheeheeheeheehawhawhawhawhawhawhawhawhawhawhaw…
Sounds like a bumper stcker to me.
Why on earth would we need a psychological effect for fuel?
You’re asking me to get inside McLame’s head?
Please – noooo….
LOL. I knew that typo would open that up.
if there is to be a start, i think i has to come from us. if we are distracted by bushco’s crimes to the extent we fail to hold our own party leaders accountable, then we will have failed.
the “phsycological effect” will be they will vote for the asshat that says we should do it
OT: Bill Kristol has an interesting bit of inside information:
Emphasis added.
grab yer shredder and come with me…
*giggle*
Wasn’t it Monica Goodling who slipped (?) in testimony when she said she pledged allegiance to president bush?
If we ever get to hearings I think this would be an appropriate first question for any and all” Did you pledge allegiance to any thing or person other than the United States of America?”
got this email from AL GORE and the DCCC.
I called them up and told them I would send NO MORE money this year and would give to ACT BLUE instead.
I cited Steny and his atrocious leadership, saying in Nixon’s day Democrats didnt cover up for presidential lawbreaking. I wont support such behavior now.
Dear XXXboy,
The coming elections are shaping up as a historic opportunity to reshape the future of our democracy. Each of us has a personal responsibility to help advance Democratic campaigns that do justice to our exceptional candidates and to the unbelievably high stakes in this election.
If our candidates are successful, we will have leaders who will no longer trade in fear and failure…who will fight for real action on the climate crisis and achieve progress on health care and jobs.
If we want to deliver on the promise of these elections, we have to not only put a Democrat in the White House but we must also win congressional victories that will strengthen our hand as we unite to drive change forward.
The single best action for you to take today is to give to the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee’s (DCCC) and their United for Change campaign. If you make a gift today, it will be matched 2-to-1 by House Democrats.
Critical FEC deadline is just days away – Unite for Change now by making a matched gift of $35, $50 or more
The DCCC is working hand-in-hand with candidates and campaign managers in dozens of tough, hard-fought House races in every corner of the nation. The stakes are high.
sorry to disappoint. it triggers a strong psycho effect in this old bat.
where are my manners? a temporary interruption in my rant is called for…..
eCAHN – thank you so much for initiating/organizing/hosting the meetup sunday. i had a great time and hope there will be more chances to meet with fellow commenters.
All hires in all departments between January 21, 2001 and January 20, 2009, shall be immediately transferred by the Obama administration to their new working stations in Point Barrow, Alaska.
With apologies to the polar bears.
Was that a scripted pledge?
got zed on FISA call
Hey, the polar bears need food, too. Seals are apparently getting tough to catch.
Do serious people listen to Kristol? Still?
NOT to calling the self an old bat, Addie.
We here do not think of you that way and do not want that mental image as it relates to you.
Thank you.
:)
Hmmmm. Heckuva plan….
Sara Taylor. Leahy read her the riot act. I still think there was some kind of a loyalty oath…
oh, thank the goddess! i was going bat shit crazy.
i never have given them money, but i DO usually fill in the surveys, with honest-to-goodness opinions and fire them back to headquarters DCCC – yeah, they’re smokin’ and “revised” depending on my foul mood-dagnabbit-jour.
if they read, they see plenty reasons why no $$$ attached.
my 102 replies to 99
Froomkin nails Congress: WaPo
I have been sending a return reply to EVERY letter and e-mail I receive from the Democrats:
NO RETROACTIVE IMMUNITY
NO WARRANTLESS WIRETAPS
NO BASKET WARRANTS
So anyone seriously think that if they were playing political games with an intern program, they weren’t with career hires?
I slept all day yesterday. People were great about bringing everything down to the house, but my kitchen is piled high & I’m just getting to the cleanup today.
I had a great time. What a super group of people. Thanks so much for coming all that way..
she said she took an oath to President Bush. She forgot that the oath was to the Constitution.
hey. the bears will no doubt enjoy the tender vittles.
Good plan. Seriously, can they be charged with destruction of government property? I like the sound of AG Whitehouse!
no.
this has been another edition of simple answers….
I’ll bet the bears won’t eat them after one taste.
I LIKE that! May I plague-urize?
some a-plenty are used to garbage dumps. ymmv.
And I am calling them all too. Talk about asshats.
No democrat followed up on that little slip of da tongue.
Ot From the Pen:
Congress tells us they don’t have time to have real hearings on impeachment because they have SO much important legislation to work on . . . like trying to sneak through telecom immunity for the umpteenth time.
And for the latest attempted scam that has already passed the house, they came up with a shiny new proposed escape hatch. Now they say if the government purportedly told them it was OK, a right wing judge can let them off the hook, which of course they would. How stupid do they think we are?
This is just the same old “just following orders” Nazi war criminal defense. It did not fly then, and shame on the Congress for trying to enshrine it into U.S. law now. Just because some White House stooge attorney drafted a secret legal opinion (so classified that even Congress is not allowed to see it even now), that does not turn treason into patriotism. And if the telecoms did something wrong by enabling illegal domestic wiretaps, they KNEW it at the time, and must be held accountable.
Please call your senators toll free at 800-828-0498, 800-614-2803 or 866-340-9281, and demand NO “following orders” loophole for the telecoms who aided and abetting the White House criminals.
And to make sure your message gets through, please submit this action page to send them a email message as well.
No Following Orders Action Page:
http://www.usalone.com/no_following_orders.php
And while we are still talking about impeachment, we spent the last week packing up the latest shipment of the new bright orange “IMPEACH BOTH!!!” caps. So if you have already requested yours, it’s on the way. If not, we will send you one for any donation of any amount from this page
New Impeach Both Caps: http://www.usalone.com/impeach_both_cap.php
The reason we are not setting a price is we want everyone to have one who wants one. There is absolutely no doubt that the Cheney/Bush gang will commit even MORE heinous acts in the next 7 months, unless they are stopped first by impeachment. The right wing TV spokesmodels are talking as if starting the next world war is another one of those “done deals”. Our only possible salvation is to keep speaking out and demanding justice down to the last possible day. And we will.
Please take action NOW, so we can win all victories that are supposed to be ours, and forward this alert as widely as possible.
If you would like to get alerts like these, you can do so at http://www.usalone.com/in.htm
I called just now, Selise. Thanks for the numbers.
Amazing…every candidate who applied who had worked for a Democratic Senator or Congressperson was deselected”, while ever individual who had worked for a Republican Senator or Congressperson was “selected”. One was rejected because they discovered that he had written an article in the student newspaper that disagreed with Republican tax policies.How could they have “learned” this information??? Apparently they went through years of student newspapers to find out such information! Or perhaps they illegally contacted the local chapter of the Young Republicans or Young Americans for Freedom to hunt down the dirt on these candidates. Yet they ignored the academic recommendations, grades, and honors these students received!
It would sure be interesting to discover how these apparatcheks acquired such newspaper articles! Do they have willing spies on campus?
And really, if they are doing this for these important apolitical early internship programs, imagine what criteria they were using to eliminate those AUSA’s that
w/ regard to the link to the .pdf:
That link is no longer operative. The new link is
http://www.usdoj.gov/opr/oig-o…..e-slip.pdf
Lunch has been eaten (party leftovers for breakfast, lunch & dinner for the next week, I’d guess) so back to clean up chores. Catch up later.
Uhm! A “psychological effect”??? What does that mean? That people will think that $4/gallon gasoline is actually less expensive than $2.20/gallon gas? Or perhaps they will be stimulated to buy even more gas? Thus causing the price to increase even more?
What an idjit!
this says a couple of things to me. 1-they knew that what they were doing was illegal 2-they were attempting to fulfil rove’s vision of a rethug bureaucracy that would enable the rethug party to maintain power even if they lost to the dems. 3-They politicized the civil service( which I labored in for 18.5 years)4-because they appointed people who did not understand what they were doing(peter principle meet incompetent)they are truly screwing up the civil service for many years-it is hard to fire anyone in the civil service for good reason(remember patronage?)5- most people who labor in civil service positions for their entire careers, want to do a good job, they want their little cog of the govt to function as it was supposed to, they will do their best to ensure that the rethug incompetants will not last for very long, they know the laws reguarding politicking in the CS, I don’t think that the bush hires will last very long after bush leaves.
BobbyG, I read this essay in Time Magazine by Nancy Gibbs and thought of you and your recent loss. It reminded me of how I felt when I had lost my Mother 10 years aftyer my Fathers death. She has put into words what we as their children go through in those times of sorrow. (((((((BobbyG))))))
Thanks!
The bush hires will last after bush leaves if the Republics retain control.
They must have just changed it because I got in with the old link about 20 minutes ago.
Do they need newspaper articles if they intercept all her communications and have them cataloged ready to pull in an instant? See where warrant-less wiretaps lead leads?
That link was taken down. It appears the whole report was removed from the DOJ website.
I’ll take issue with your point 3.
This was not the Peter Principle at work. They knew full well what they were doing and that it was illegal. Shredding the evidence is proof that they knew the truth would create real problems for them.
I think most of the people involved in this stuff were political appointees, that it didn’t much move down into the SES ranks, much less into the GS levels.
I could be wrong on that.
BC
The report link has been updated in the post above — if folks will refresh their screens it should be there. DOJ changed the link location, but we’ve updated it accordingly.
..until they move it again, anyway. I found it by searching one of the text strings you quoted; that will probably work next time, too. I doubt they’ll take it down, but it wouldn’t surprise me if they kept trying to find a nice quiet, unobtrusive link for it.
Unfortunately for them, I’ve saved the report to my desktop for further reading. *G*
Couldn’t hang with the wunderkind from Regent Law…
No, it was the Rove Exec assistant who was part of the USA scandal and she got lectured by Leahy. Who did not point out the whole government that demanded personal alleigance oaths from employees was Hitler’s.
Anyone remember her name?
That was Sara Taylor, wasn’t it?
Bushie@19 asked over at EW’s:
I though negative, but too modest to quote myself. Anyone know,
That’s it. Flipped her hair at the SJC as if it were the finger. Will we ever see these people brought to justice, CHS?
I’m writing this up for my scandals list. Monica Goodling is mentioned as wanting to keep the politicized screening committee. And well, shades of Monica Goodling, Rachel Paulose and others, Esther Slater McDonald who catches heat in the report was appointed by Bill Mercer the Acting Associate AG (No. 3 at the DOJ) is described in this way:
The report notes that investigators could find no one who told her what she was supposed to do or how she was supposed to do it. IOW just another young Bushbot, plug in and walk away.
Does anyone think that the DOJ was the only department of the federal government where Bush’s top lieutenants used illegal political considerations in making career hiring decisions? I have a lollipop for those who do.
From the report, page 47, concerning 2006 Honors applicants that were rejected by the screening commitee:
snip
Holy crap Batman. This is finally going to get interesting.
It’s going to get interesting? Please tell me when.
I find it disgusting.
Congress won’t stand up to Bush. The European Community leaders don’t stand up to him.
How and when are we going to see some accountability for all of this shit, the worst abuses of American democratic law in decades if not a century?
The only 2 options I see now are General Strike and something like a Class Action suit against this administration. How far can executive privilege possibly go? No action on the environment is protected by executive privilege? Of course: because changing course on the environment will mean a commitment to ENDING WARS and these assholes are committed to keeping the war machine lubed and operational.
How the hell can something like RETROACTIVE IMMUNITY even be considered? What a farce! The Bushes have been painting this picture since 1985 when they began seeking immunities from international war crime courts, then sealing presidential records until safely sunsetted, and now this onslaught of cover-up and obscene misuse of power. It is nothing short of treason. And they do it with their hand on the bio-bull, pledging allegiance to that Great White god in the Sky before any consideration to the once-upon-a-time protections for all creeds and colors provided by a Constitution.
Any lawyers here ready to board the High Crimes and Misdemeanors Express?
We need some representation and we need it now.
Well, we needed it in late 2002…