The ‘old’ (a few years ago) scientific consideration was that it seemed we could stabilize, without utterly catastrophic risk, at 450 ppm or below. This is the guiding thinking behind cutting carbon emissions 80 percent by 2050.
Jim Hansen, NASA and one of the strongest voices in climate research, came out with work stating that we must fall to 350 ppm to avoid catastrophic climate change, considering the impacts that we are already seeing globally.
350 is required, Hansen tells us,
If humanity wishes to preserve a planet similar to that on which civilization developed and to which life on Earth is adapted.
We face a simple challenge, as a society (and species): 350 or bust!
350.org (from the same people who Stepped it Up) is organizing ralies around the globe, from the Great Wall to the Eiffel Tower, from your backyard to mine, to call attention to the critical challenge and the opportunities created through addressing climate change.
As Bill McKibben wrote last month,
All of a sudden it isn’t morning in America, it’s dusk on planet Earth.
"Dusk on planet Earth …" Bill has a way with words, words to communicate the seriousness of the threat we face and the challenges we can surmount.
There’s a number — a new number — that makes this point most powerfully. It may now be the most important number on Earth: 350. As in parts per million of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere.
Forget inflation rate. Forget price of gasoline. Forget grade point average. 350 is about survival of the globe’s biodiversity and, potentially, survivability of a modern human society.
our last chance; you just can’t do this one lightbulb at a time.
Change those lightbulbs but forget about patting yourself on the back for having done so.
Fighting denialism …
Yet, even as the situation worsens, there is a raging battle (mainly in the United States) about whether there is even a problem.
It is an important reminder that when we discuss how to mobilize our country on the issue of climate change, we must reckon not only with educating the uneducated and mobilizing the inactive, we must also reckon with a surprisingly large group of the active, vocal and miseducated.
The whole stance of climate change denialists has uncanny parallels to that of AIDS denialists, who deny that HIV causes AIDS.
This is a battle fostered from many motivations but one that inhibits progress, meaningful change for the better.
And, the battling from misinformed and motivated denialists achieves its ends in no small part through that fostered confusion. What looks to be complications and debates in science (rather than voodoo manipulation of Lies, Damned Lies, and Statistics from Global Warming Skeptics) makes it easier to focus on other pressing issues, from the serious (Iraq) to fleeting (the latest poll on the Presidential campaign).
But, if we don’t deal with Global Warming, if we don’t change paths, we might lose the ability to sustain a meaningful modern society. We might lose the ability to have the luxury of diverting our attention to the Olympics or the missing white girl in Aruba.
We might lose the margin
Civilization is what grows up in the margins of leisure and security provided by a workable relationship with the natural world. That margin won’t exist, at least not for long, as long as we remain on the wrong side of 350. That’s the limit we face.
"Margin of leisure and security … "
A planet under stress from catastrophic climate change will have no meaningful margin.
This fact, that there will be no meaningful margin, is a core reason why the progressive crises are peak oil and global warming. If we cannot navigate a path through this perfect storm, there will be no margin for progressive causes … there might not be a margin for a meaningful modern civilization.
A simple question:
How else can one say it to make it clear that the sky is falling?
We face a simple challenge, as a society (and species): 350 or bust!
Related posts:
- “Whew, it’s a good thing George Will has no sense of shame”
- Progressive Groups Target Companies over Their Chamber of Commerce Membership
- Glenn “Instapundit” Reynolds Doubles Down on Powerline’s Fact-Free Climate Change Post
- GRITtv Live: Wangari Maathai – The Politics of Global Climate Change
- The Blue Dogs’ New Fossil Fool Trick: “Centrist” Climate Suicide Pacts





Spotlight







Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

G’morning, all.
I recently addressed the issue of global warming in a short essay published over Interstate 80:
http://freewayblogger.blogspot…..rming.html
gulp.
I think people need to be told exactly what to do. What should we do?
Become vegetarian.
Stop driving our cars.
Replace bulbs.
plant our own veggies.
Pull our own weeds.
Stop growing grass.
We need directives. I need to know exactly what sacrifices to make that will make the most difference.
I read articles that say one thing and then another. These changes are hard to make. That said, if I know for sure, that if I do this thing it will help. I will do it. But so many times I feel unsure of the best path and then because I don’t feel certain. I do don’t do as much as I could.
My husband changed out our bulbs. We planted a garden 3 years in a row.
We put our expedition (husband’s idea in 1998) in the garage and have not driven it in 6 years.
I want to do more. I need a list. And then, like any change I need to pick the ones I can commit to quickly. And set long term goals for the things that might take longer. I’d like to get a smart car, but no money for that and with the monster expedition which is worthless, we are starting from scratch. I’d rather someone find a car that runs on air. I would save every penny to own it and give up my childs education if I thought it would save the earth.
We need to know what to do, how important it is, what kinds of sacrifice do we need to make.
Jus Cogens!
THANK YOU for this post!
As Obama and Congressional Democrats have just demonstrated how they are incapable of doing what needs to be done re FISA, I think it is a safe bet that they will show themselves equally incapable in addressing much more complex and intractable problems like global warming and peak energy.
“I really didn’t love america untill I was deprived of her company”
he said that a number of times
“I was not in love with america until I was deprived of her company” at other times
crooks and liars has the clips
oh, those are mccain clips
What needs to happen isn’t going to happen with 6.5 billion people on this rock. It’s as simple as that. And yes, I’m childless.
I have a friend who’s inteligence I respect who believes there are plans for “depopulating” the planet
no kidding
Recently, I purchased a package of frozen food from the Sac. Co-op. The packaging was overly romantic and featured an image of a traditional barn and silo. It could have easily been in Iowa or PA. I turned it over and, lo and behold, it came from forking China. My husband, Ron, called the co-op and they were horrified. They called the distributor and raised hell immediately. They called us back to say they were going to be more careful.
Ron and I have also started emailing and calling manufacturers of food products that do not have packaging that can be recycled. Usually, I go to their own sites and find their mission statements. Then I use their own quotes juxapositioned against the reality of their packaging. The smaller companies tend to respond.
I have had that thought.
he also said *this* (h/t Drifty:)
http://driftglass.blogspot.com/2008/06/wrong.html
Lower the speed limit could cut fuel consumption. Denmark and Israel are going electric with their cars starting in 2010. Sun and Wind power are Clean and free.
But to get these numbers down wouldn’t we need to increase the amount of trees taking in carbon and increase the amount the ocean takes in as well?
“I never realized how much I loved (to f*ck) the old whore until I was deprived of her company by Reds.” – John McCrazy
ok, bolton agrees with krystol but says it happens regardless who wins the election, this is from think progress
jayt, I appreciate what you did for me on the other thread, I believe I will boycott that author
thanx
Ok Folks please Digg this great Post on OUR enviroment. It is such an important topic!
So will I any attack on Iran will make oil prices go so high my Toyota, Sun and Wind, Stocks will rock!
Oil companies though might very well face windfall taxes in such a political climate from Republicans…the Dems will be pushing to nationalize the oil companies.
Re: Be Fruitful and Multiply: Religion needs to tell people to do the exact opposite of what it tells them now. Church’s should advocate birth control.
Good for you Mary and thanks for sharing yet another way to fught back against all this crap coming from China… If we are reduced to importing our food we can easily be cut off from those sources and of course our farmers will be put out of production if our mopre of our food is imported. Support your local Farmers Markets. They are your friends!
Maybe we can get Anderson Cooper to change the name of his show.
Solar Ovens for poor people how many trees are killed for wood fires in poor countries?
All the more reason to work hard and elect better Democrats.
Dugg
Thanks for the link.
Maybe we could juice the oceans ability to absorb carbon temporarily by adding chemicals that the oceans need to make alge and plankton in areas that are nutrient poor.
A serious plan to reforest areas that are now deserts would help too. Just how fast are deserts growing now?
It was interesting that the people who run the co-op didn’t even think about the carbon cost of getting the food to us.
Ok we know how fast the PPM of Carbon DiOxide are growing but how fast can the environment absorb them and can we increase that number quickly and significantly?
I believe I will boycott that author
I’m planning to do the same thing.
Lots of people running the local farmers market were driving trucks sure they need big cars but diesels can haul more and get better fuel economy. The only drawback is the high price of Diesel. Hmmm? just why is the price of Diesel higher than gas right now?
A lot of the economic maladies afflicting Americans right now can be viewed as long term corrections for the environment. Gas too high? Don’t drive. Can’t pay mortgage on your suburban mcmansion? Live in an urban setting in a small apartment. Can’t afford veggies? Grown ‘em. Can’t keep your house cool? Insulate. Don’t know your neighbors? Carpool. Can’t afford health care? Start a community clinic.
The world’s population is expected to hit 7 billion 4 years from now in 2012.
http://www.breitbart.com/artic….._article=1
In 1930, there were only 2 billion. We are using up resources at an alarming and unreplaceable rate. As I often say, unless there is a major change to the population/energy/resources and I should add global warming equation, the earth’s population could be a billion or less by 2100, and most of the decline will be due to war, famine, and disease.
judging by the actions I have seen of late, the decline in population will be by design
Thats the plan… lower the population by billions then the rich can have their cake and eat to… The rich and powerful could care less for the common man!
I have long suspected that the dems in office who are so unresponsive to us are making sure they survive the next decade. The people in power know full well what is going on. That includes the oil companies and big ag. Rather than trying to take care of the situation in a mature and compassionate way they are positioning themselves for elitist survival. I have news for them. They are not the ones that will make it.
we are the virus
are there animals that destroy themselves when they are overpopulated?
we need analogies
Missed the author/book. Specifics please and thanks?
about three or four years ago where I live there were a suprising amount of spiders
everywhere I looked, all over the place, spiders
no a few years later there are none that I can find, I don’t remember a cycle like this before
their children will though, that’s really all we’re here for, our legacy
War, famine, disease and greed.
We recycle, compost, try to remember to use cloth bags at grocery store, invested in a more fuel-efficient vehicle, nearly done replacing incandescent bulbs with mini-fluorescents, etc., etc., etc. We are working hard to multi-task when we go out to do errands to avoid too much gas usage. Heroic, eh?
That said, I am sitting here stuffing my already fluffy face with popcorn I don’t really need. We are watering our lawn even as I type. In spite of our generally good intentions, we aren’t doing enough. But as someone early on in this thread asked, what is enough? We need to know, because we are complicit in the overuse that is resulting in shortages.
Ya know, it would be nice if every once in a while you’d provide some in depth ideas for solutions to the worst-case or doomsday predictions you espouse.
No. I am sorry. Their children will not. I believe that the survivors will be the children of Blackwater types and people who have been fighting to survive their entire lives. Rich corporate types are so filled with hubris that they have no idea what reality is about.
solution one;
get more better democrats
Thanks for the enlightenment.
TCU you will never re-forest the desert…. not going to happen… only specific plans can grow in the desert, either it is high altitude or low rain fall or variance in day/night temps or all of them together that affect which trees/plants that can grow in the desert. If you force it then it is trying to sustain something unnatural and probably using resources better used elsewhere…
Reforest those areas that naturally grew forests, Oregon, WA, CA, MI, MN and other states that used be forest before the lumber companies did clear cutting…. land, climate and rainfall are right for growing forests.
Okay. Where are they growing ‘em?
ASiegel, thanks for the post.
Well, we’re trying to grow one here in GA12 to take out John Barrow, and we apparently are not making the big boys happy. I still have no earthly idea why Obama endorsed Barrow, or why he’s meddling in a primary.
Is there a visible show of support for Barrow from the DCCC?
Check out this ActBlue page… Hmmph. Scroll down and you’ll find the odious Mr. Barrow.
more from the belly of the beast
And KBR knows it. A story on the front page of today’s New York Times lays bare the leverage that KBR holds over the U.S. military.
In short, KBR can charge the U.S. government anything it wants under the implicit threat that the firm will halt logistical services to troops in Iraq. If the military doesn’t pay up in full, KBR has warned, “it would reduce payments to subcontractors, which in turn would cut back on services.”
That’s according to Charles M. Smith, the senior civilian overseeing the multibillion-dollar contract with KBR during the first two years of the Iraq war. Smith, speaking out for the first time, said he was ousted from his job after he tried to question KBR’s massive billing.
The Army itself admits to the Times that it really had no choice but to pay KBR
Hmmmm, a whopping $471. I know DCCC is making robocalls where allowed. And people who are on that list generally will not give to someone not on DCCC’s kiss list. We’ve found that out here already. I’m wondering if staff made a huge boo-boo on this and Obama’s stuck. But your questions remain.
One of the things the military is going to have to do is go back to the old ways of taking care of all the logistics themselves. Just in cost effectiveness alone it’s a no brainer.
these 2 wars were pnac wet dreams and rackeeteering of the MIC mob period,a few families got filthy rich,like in Smedly Butlers time…funny ONE was the same family
southern at 43–he usually IS one of the ones with ideas, 24/7. first time i’ve seen him anywhere near morose, and i’ve been around here a while. maybe it’s because he’s had it, as far as i’m concerned, he can be as morose and complain as much as he wants, he’s earned it.
others-not so much.
BOO thanks for you…..”g”
Uprising upstairs. New Sirota.
David Sirota is upstairs!
The Uprising: Taking the NAFTA Fight to Fox – and to McCain
and i want to remind people that while you are calling obama about thomas/barrow, please call reps and sens about the medicare cap that goes into affect july 1st—-
once a patient reaches $1800 dollars in therapy they have to pay out of pocket unless they are an in-patient at a hospital……last week at therapy they are already notifying patients. how many people can pay out of pocket on medicare??????
there is a consolidation bill in the works, but won’t be completed in time……
need another emergency extension presented in congress to extend benefits until the new bill is done…..
please call about this, affects long-term recovery of surgery patients, stroke patients, etc….all therapy types, even speech, etc.
and affects their families.
1-800-450-8293
======
and rep rahall out of wva, chair of natural resources committee is proposing that oil companies that don’t use their leases after ten years have to give them up…..so, he could use support on that, too.
68 million acres of land have permits and leases already, and they’re sitting on them and wanting to drill offshore and in anwar……..he’s trying to stop this looneyness.
Butler’s time is exactly what they want to relive. Lincoln had to put logistics under military control because the sutlers were making a killing. Same thing after WWI. Now with the privatize everything to a select few in full swing the military is going to have to take control again. The PNAC crowd thought they could repeat history but they neglected to read the whole book. They got to the part where Augustus had conquered a large portion of the known world, put the book down and said, “We can do that.”
forgot the word PUBLIC LANDS………68 million acres of PUBLIC LANDS have leases and permits issued already.
Yes perris, there are analogies in nature. In fact, the reason we are in such deep shit is because we have been trying to live contrary to the laws of nature. Since we have taken the agricultural route, store food for lean times, aggressively kill off competitive species, our population has burgeoned way out of whack to the natural carrying capacity of the planet.
Nature deals with overpopulation by starvation, disease, and a wave of predator species.
I read recently a theory that some of the so called “rainforest” diseases – like Ebola virus and AIDS, are a type of immune response of these hot climates to an aggressive predator – humans.
It is our humanity (behavior-wise) that has pushed humans (the species) out of balance. Our own advances in medicine, nutrition, and unsustainable harvesting of the planet that have extended life expectancies up by almost 30 years from 1904 to 2004.
Most people will agree that it is a tragedy for someone to die from starvation, but that has been part of the natural balancing act that has been thrown off by international food aid programs, petroleum based fertilizers and pesticides, and aggressive unsustainable harvesting of natural resources.
Since humanity has been pretty successful in removing the disease factor from acting as a natural population limit, the next one in the list is starvation. IMO its more likely that war and civil disturbance will be the limiting factor in the US.
This may be slipping too. There’s an upswing in multiply drug resistant TB, methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, and other resistant strains of bacteria. So the “age of antibiotics” may effectively last one or two generations.
Actually, Obama has been working with the Apollo Alliance and is a strong backer of wind power; he proposes, along with windfall-profits taxes on Big oil, cutting the $14 billion a year currently given to Big Oil and giving that instead to the renewable-energy industry. Whether we can get even a windfall-profits tax through Congress is another matter: The last effort to do so was two weeks ago and the GOP got it shot down in flames.
Love the signs. Time to do this in the DC area …
There are plenty of “lists”.
For a home, might I suggest that you take a look at the Home Energy Diet? Have you had a home energy audit?
And, assuming that you have investments, how green are they?
And, right now the critical action is political. We, as individuals, can change, but we must have national policy and regulatory change to make real progress.
PS: Dealing with Global Warming is not all about ’sacrifice’, either as individuals or larger society. A more energy efficient and greener home is also one more comfortable and healthier to live in. Eating local/fresh is healthier. Etc …
Every voice, every action. There are likely no silver bullets, very likely many silver bbs, and every action we take to foster better progress forward is silver dust/silver molecules. Individual action, group action, government action — all are necessary to achieve what is required to find a path through the perfect storm of peak oil and global warming.
Solar stoves can make a real difference. You might be interested in: Energy Cool: Frying in the Sun.
I don’t think it takes that much to make serious change re desertification. If we were serious about it. Permaculture is pretty amazing. Check this out:
Video didn’t come out. Go here.
Well, heroic is wonderful, but moving forward is critical.
So, have you had a home energy audit? Moved to LED lights rather than CFLs? Do you have reuseable shopping bags? Do you give other people CFLs/LEDs/cloth shopping bags as gifts? With each day, a new step forward?
While I want to reforest areas that have lost forest, have to beg to differ about greening the desert. See links above in comments 72 and 73.
Not that this is a timely post or anything. A Siegel says living green is healthier. He is right. I only use heat for warmth below 40 degrees. I only have one fan for cooling. I almost never get those illnesses that “go around”. I use sun heated water and have a small garden. I would do more but I catch rainwater as my sole source and it’s wonderful. When it’s really limited, it really tastes better. I’ve been cultivating a wild plum grove and the trees that have started spontaneously here for 15 years and I can tell you that it’s helped my climate. The bees in the beehive in my north wall like it too.
:)