Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal is on a path to finish the job Hurricane Katrina started, destroying the public infrastructure that served, however imperfectly, poor and working-class New Orleans residents.
Jindal, the wunderkind who is being touted as conservatism’s rising new star and an at-least-half-serious contender for being John McCain’s running mate, has openly embraced some of the most extreme components of the right’s agenda, from tax cuts for the wealthy to public funding of private and religious schools. The New Orleans area can least afford to be the staging ground for a bankrupt conservative ideology, but Jindal is zealously leading the state into the void nonetheless, even to the point of criticizing President Bush for not being right-wing enough.
The impact of the ideological decisions coming out of the governor’s office for many of the people of New Orleans, as they approach the third anniversary of the hurricane that devastated their city, is that to the extent that the city is being rebuilt, it is not being rebuilt for them. "We’re getting the message that he is not open to us," Beth Butler, lead Louisiana organizer for ACORN, told me in an interview this week.
The signals are loud and clear as Jindal presides over the dismantling of public infrastructure for education, health care and housing.
With Jindal’s blessing, the majority of New Orleans schoolchildren are now lab rats in a massive conservative experiment in private and charter school education. More than half of the 79 public schools that have been reopened since the hurricane — there were 128 schools before Katrina struck — are now charter schools. On top of that are the 63 private and parochial schools operating in the parish, which Jindal wants to support through a $10 million voucher plan. In an article on New Orleans charter schools in The Washington Post this week, Leigh Dingerson, education team leader for the Center for Community Change in the District, called the result "a flea market of entrepreneurial opportunism that is dismantling the institution of public education in New Orleans."
The Post noted that the charter schools fight to scoop up the best teachers and attract private funding to supplement their budgets. School enrollment data collected by the Brookings Institution for its report, "The New Orleans Index," show that 18 of the charter schools, the ones outside what’s known as the Recovery School District, educate a lower percentage of poor and African-American students than the remaining public schools (which, incidentally, have a total white enrollment of 68 students — less than one percent of the total). Children with special educational needs are being virtually abandoned, according to Butler. "There is a whole group of children who have been redlined out of the school population," she said.
The conditions set up the remaining public schools for failure—and therefore creating more grist for the conservative narrative about the evils of public schools.
The state is also not taking steps to rebuild what had been a troubled but nonetheless vital public health network. The 550-bed Charity Hospital, a major provider of health care for low-income New Orleans residents, remains closed, and Jindal has refused to support rebuilding the facility at anything near its former size, despite the recommendations from health experts at Louisiana State University that said the area now needs a 484-bed facility. A clue to Jindal’s motivation here is in an interview he did with The Washington Times in May. There he said that the campaign President Bush and Republicans in Congress waged to blocked an expansion of the State Children’s Health Insurance Program was a "great example " of how "the Republican Party stopped being the party of ideas. "
"The Democrats had their ideas, but the Republicans said, ‘No, we don’t want to spend that much money. We don’t want to cover as many children.’ As opposed to saying, ‘Hey look, we think the delivery system is wrong. We agree that children should be covered, but we want to do it through a private health plan. We want to help poor families afford private care. We don’t want bureaucracies making health care decisions.’ "
The reflexive anti-government attitude in Jindal’s comments helps explain why the state has not worked with New Orleans to replace the public health care network that existed before the storm. Instead, Jindal’s health care advisers are proposing using Medicaid funds to finance a managed care network for the poor. If Jindal doesn’t want "bureaucracies making health care decisions," then he would not be proposing to perpetuate an HMO system in which private-sector bean-counters, accountable to financiers and stockholders rather than patients or the public interest, ultimately decide who gets care and how much they get.
Jindal knows that the private sector has no financial interest in providing care to a low-income, uninsured or underinsured population, many of whom have chronic health problems exacerbated by the psychological stresses of Katrina’s aftermath. At best, he would paper over the problem by giving people vouchers that would cover a fraction of their health-care needs, thus forcing low-income people to forgo care they can’t afford and can’t get donated to them.
Also, as homelessness in New Orleans has by some estimates doubled since Katrina struck, federal and state leaders have collectively failed to address the need for massive amounts of affordable housing. Housing activists have complained that public housing buildings are still barricaded that could easily be fixed to provide at least temporary housing while new housing is built. The barrier, again, is an ideological aversion to public investment in housing and an overreliance on faith in the private sector. Anemic mandates for developers to build lower-priced hosuing units have been ineffectual in the face of soaring home prices and rents, and the only lifeline for working-class residents is federal funding for housing vouchers that Congress is struggling to approve.
In one of his latest exploits, Jindal has joined the Republican-dominated state legislature in pushing a tax cut that mirrors the disastrous and regressive Bush administration tax cuts. Last week the state House of Representatives approved doubling the threshold for the state’s 6 percent tax rate; instead of kicking in at $50,000 a year for joint filers and $25,000 for single filers, it would kick in at $100,000 for joint filers and $50,000 for single filers.
The impact of this tax change is that the higher the income, the greater the tax benefit. Democrats in the Legislature wanted to take a different approach, eliminating state taxes on the first $12,500 of income, which would have targeted tax relief on lower-income people. But conservatives rejected that approach. One of the Republicans justified his opposition with a bit of moralizing: "It’s critical that all people help contribute a little . . . to the taxation base in this state, because it engages people in government."
But they don’t want struggling New Orleans residents to be too engaged in government, because they might expect government to actually deliver on promises made by Jindal and by President Bush to not only rebuild what had been lost during the hurricane but to rebuild it for the people who had suffered the loss.
The American Prospect’s Mori Dinauer uncovered this note of praise of Jindal from Rush Limbaugh: "Bobby Jindal, the new governor of Louisiana, is the next Ronald Reagan." The title fits, given Reagan’s disdain for the poor and for people of color. (Though it’s unlikely that Reagan ever included performing exorcisms on his resume.) Add Jindal’s unconditional opposition to abortion under any circumstances (15 years old and raped? Tough.), his support for teaching the doctrine of "intelligent design" in public schools and his opposition to civil rights protections for gay and lesbian people, and you have a perfect storm of ideological disaster for the New Orleans and the state.
But, like Reagan, Jindal can be smooth, charming and even disarming. As the shock of Katrina recedes from the collective memory and as the recovery effort continues to boil in a murky stew of inertia, Jindal is well equipped to be the next great facade for conservatism — as long as no one is asking questions about what’s behind the front.



67 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Nothing worse than a “recent” convert to anything….religion, political ideology, etc….but may Bobby fits in with the new Nawl Leans….
Jus Cogens!
Isaiah – nice to see you again. Wonderful post. Am from the south and have many happy days in NO. I am appalled at what is happening there – or perhaps NOT happening. I actually don’t know what we can do about it except push the Congress to step in an help these poor people. They certainly have fallen down on the job so far. Keep writing about this awful situation and maybe it will get the attention it deserves. Thanks
Thanks Isaiah, terrific post.
Good morning Isaiah.
Republican family values.
That the powers-that-be, whether in government, business, media… have so completely ignored the continuing catastrophe of NO is mind boggling, heart-breaking, unspeakably cruel.
Boosh goes merrily along breaking the bank with his various follies.
How can the country mend so many gaping wounds without resources?
Thank you for this post Isaiah.
Goes with the supplies that FEMA had collected being given away elsewhere. (Louisiana didn’t ask for any of them, even though there’s still a serious need. The groups trying to help people hadn’t even heard about those supplies being available.)
they use the shock doctrine whenever possible to try to make the mega trillions of dollars they make when they privatize our government and turn it into their fascist dream
I keep trying to Digg this post, but Digg is down for maintenance for a bit. Thanks for this post!
It’s pretty clear that people in general do not understand that Republicans are against all government with the exception of fascism.
wow Isaiah – thanks so much, what a terrific post
yeah, that’s what Lousiana needs – a huge loss of public revenues, jeebus
Hopefully the WHOLE American experiment with allowing proven crooks and thieves run this country will be coming to a screeching halt.
If we can make people realize that it is THEIR money going down a rat hole we will be much better off. Some just don’t seem to know that.
Thank you for this post.
I’m thinking back to the other night when Dennis Kuchinich read the 35 articles of Impeachment.
Katrina was, I think, #4, second only to the first three regarding 911. Man, he really spelled it all out.
The were forewarned about Katrina and the expected devastation. And, they were liars when they said who could have anticipated?
Now, this. It just adds insult to injury.
Remember the line from Billy Jack? Think of the kids, Billy.
What he’s doing is criminal, or should be. Amazing how some people will always vote Republican, with promises of tax cuts dancing through their heads, happily surrendering their liberty, their children’s future, and anything else, all in the name of “Smaller government.”
It’s long past time to drain the swamp.
What has happened to New Orleans is criminal.
Literally.
One word.
Rove.
He saw immediately an emergent Red State, even as people were drowning in the streets.
Yes. Like in Dickens’ Christmas Carol where Scrooge says (something like) Let them die and decrease the [needy] population.
More Big Porches and Mint Juleps!
There are certain things that people expect to be there in order for a city to exist and thrive. I used to work in economic development for a gas and electric utility and I can tell you what those things are, if a community is going to get to ‘first base’ in terms of job attraction and job growth. A few of them are infrastructure: good transportation network(and if you want manufacturing, you will need rail), municiple water and sewing, electric and gas wires and pipes, and now fiber optic cable access. Having good buildings that are either Class A already or can be brought up to Class A in terms of internal amenities and internal infrastructure is important but those things can be built if brown fields or green field development is available and buildings are NOT. But on the human side, you absolutely positively have to have: educated and trained(and trainable) workforce. To attract people to come to your area you absolutely need: good schools(and good public schools), a good at least class 2 hospital in your community and class 3 within 30 min. Depending on your population, you will need more than one hospital — availability of healthcare is extremely important. Additionally – and people forget this – there needs to be a whole retail infrastructure available and this too has been destroyed in NO – grocery stores of all types and sizes and at the neighborhood level – ditto on pharmacies, laundramats, and service providers including doctors and dentists and a way to get people to and from all of these. If ever anyone wanted to come up with a plan on how to destroy a city and make sure it would never, ever come back…what the Feds and now the State of Louisiana have and continue to do is it.
Less Jazz – Dat’s De Devil’s Music.
Vigilance and catapulting the truth… we shall yet overcome the pestilence that is Rethuglicanism.
Republicans–pro-Fatcat, anti-Families.
Thank you for your diligence, Isaiah. What can we who are not in LA do to help? Tactical strategies needed for the long haul as well as the short term; for the greater America as well as the in-state.
Thanks Isaiah for this important post!
I’ve long said that the Repugs viewed Hurricane Katrina as the “Perfect Storm”.
Their strategy to totally disenfranchise the residents of this disaster is not because of the fact that:
1. Many of the residents are poor, though that is a bonus ’cause poor folks are that way because they want to be.
2. Many of the residents are African-American, though that too is a bonus ’cause…well, you know…they’re African-American.
No, the primary joy the Repugs feel in disenfranchising the residents of this disaster is because those folks vote Democrat!
Dagnabbit, Democrats are the cause of all the
Repugs’World’s problems, doncha know?Now how about another Mint Julep before we foreclose on all their property and sell it to our fat white friends for beaucoup bucks?
Ain’t bein’ a Repug the funnest part of life?
Those Republic tax cuts always seem to miss those voters. It’s curious that those voters never seem to notice that.
Thank you for shedding light on the newest Republican devastation tool.
It is sickening…just like all Republican policy…sickening and destructive.
What I find fascinating is that much of the land in NO is right in the path of the next Perfect Storm and the levees have NOT been repaired or rebuilt properly. So are they going to build their casinos and fancy homes on this property and have this happen to THEM?
Absolutely correct.
All snark aside, you wonder how people like him sleep at night, knowing how you’ve ignored the pleas so many desperate people you could’ve helped.
All in the name of politics, vs. “doin’ the people’s werk” as Bush loves to say.
A very good point. Folks in CA are slowly waking up to the ‘it’s your money…’ tax scam rhetoric. Very slowly.
It would really help if the Democrats had something effective to say, but sadly, that is too much to ask of them.
I’m still with the folks who assert that it’s going to have to get worse before the citizenry is truly moved to say ‘Enough is enough…’
Perhaps four more years of McSame will do the job.
It’s tough to get the truth out as one thing the ReThugs have been really excellent about is destroying the public school system. I meet a lot of folks who graduated from ‘college’ who really have no better than the education I received through high school.
And what does Barkey and the DNC have to say about a real, integerated Progressive Agenda for Everyone?
(((((crickets)))))
This quote from Bush explains the pople he and Rove really work for:
Neither Bush nor Rove have problems sleeping.
Yeah, Tax Policy Center compared Obama’s and McCain’s tax plans, their conclusions weren’t too surprising.
Having lived in Louisiana (Baton Rouge) and having been acquainted with the pre-Katrina conditions of the places along the Gulf and New Orleans, I know much of the area was already pretty close to the bottom economically anyway. To grind it all underfoot adds insult to injury.
I was never enamoured of pre-Katrina New Orleans with its almost decorative lassidtude and proud and sultry decadence. I was never charmed by that. But I am profoundly disturbed that the way its residents have been practically zoned out of existence in a post-Katrina world.
A friend of mine is an architect who also likes Vonnegut. In that vein, he imagines a Disney-version of New Orleans where the bums and a host of street-people are actually paid actors who check-into wardrobe each day to costume themselves for a performance before real transients—wide-eyed tourists–and simply “evoke” a sanitized poverty and inequality for visitors. Everything below the street and behind the facades runs like Imagineered Disneyland. I think that is where corporate America wants to take New Orleans now. Replace all those real people with college kids on summer break in costume, earning some spending money for next term.
“…a Disney-version of New Orleans where the bums and a host of street-people are actually paid actors who check-into wardrobe each day to costume themselves for a performance before real transients—wide-eyed tourists–and simply “evoke” a sanitized poverty and inequality for visitors. Everything below the street and behind the facades runs like Imagineered Disneyland. I think that is where corporate America wants to take New Orleans now. Replace all those real people with college kids on summer break in costume, earning some spending money for next term.”
_______
I bet you’re exactly right. Poorly paid actors.
Why that clip has not been in heavy rotation in all Democratic contests over the last two years is waaaay beyond me.
I mean, it’s not like Michael Moore wouldn’t let ‘em use it.
Here’s a diary from Kos that says he participated in an exorcism…no, really:
http://www.dailykos.com/storyo…..297/534655
Another quote from my grad thesis:
Ahhhhhhhh! I grew up in New Orleans. I am fourth generation. Went to the crappy schools and know that they needed work before the storm. This is not the way to do it. The conservatives in LA have long hated the city. We are talking about centuries of hostility. The state government finally has the city by the short hairs and is going to inflict has much damage as they can. And they will relish doing it. And the oil companies have been ready to finish the destruction of the wetlands for years.
Click on my name to see my tribute to New Orleans. My heart is broken.
Surreal, you linked to that diary here, and I linked to this post over there.
why was there no support for the major dem in the race – why wasn’t there any support for Foster Campbell from the Party ?
Today’s Republican party and particularly it’s “rising stars” (Pawlenty, Jindal, etc) are indeed, “A Confederacy of Dunces.”
The difference being, of course, that in Kennedy Toole’s novel the dunces were the good guys.
Then these good ol’ Repug boys will ripoff those nasty insurance companies with inflated claims (whaddya mean Chevy pickup, that there was mah Rolls Royce…wink-wink, nod-nod, heh-heh), ’cause after all, they shoulda seen it comin’.
As usual, it is the only principle the Repugs will never abandon: “Heads we win, tails you lose!”
This clip?
In addition, Sen. Obama’s plan puts more money in lower income brackets, where it is more likely to be spent than saved, thus helping the economy recover faster.
I wish that Kennedy Toole was still around. I wish Walker Percy was still with us.
Two more reasons New Orleans should be saved:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v…..rbles.html
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v…..chive.html
Thanks, Isaiah. Great post.
Yes, I can see it now. Kids from faraway Arizona and Edonton, Alberta come to audition for parts and get dialect coaching—”Thow me sumthin’,mistah” (which is how one of the former mayors of New Orleans instructed tourists during festivities one year). Audio-anamatronic Ray Nagin telling us defiantly that “New Orleans will be a chocolate city” again. And of course the 9th Ward Flood and Thrill ride.
It’s so ridiculous, it absolutely has to be true.
And I do hear Disney doesn’t pay scale.
Here in Vegas we do that kind of stuff every day. Absent gaming, this place would be Barstow II, but instead we have entire fake cities to complement the fake nails, fake boobs, fake hair, fake “Legends in Concert,” etc.
”Thow me sumthin’,mistah”-I said that as a kid.
Ray Nagin was a republican before running for mayor. He is a shill.
I went to Vegas once–when it was in the “all family all the time” mode. My wife can only remember how cheap food was at endless 24 hr buffets.
I bet we were eating fake food.
But then there’s Celine….oh, wait.
He demanded a minimum $10,000 per audience when post-Katrina cleanup contractors wanted to discuss projects with him.
FEMA Gave Away $85 million in household goods meant for Hurricane Katrina victims
http://www.first-draft.com/200…..ave-a.html
So he also said “thow me sumthin, misah”.
The local blogs are pretty interesting. If you go to http://righthandthief.blogspot.com/ you can start your journey into the progressive side of New Orleans. That and, of course, First Draft.
Don’t be crackin’ on Celine. She’s gona anyway. Bette Midler has replaced her (and the horn section in our band is doing her show).
I love Bette – Celine, not so much.
Yep. Ten grand cover charge.
The guys are doin’ Leno next Friday (20th) with Bette. Then they’ll be taping a “Vue” segment.
I bet he said “thow me sumthin, mistah” and added the Mardi Gras “waving hands” gesture too!
Great post Isaiah. Jindal is just going to be the poster boy for diversity for goopers.
My heart is breaking for Katrina victims. I ranted about the FEMA F up last night. I just cannot believe the callous heartlessness of all this.
“Gentrification” follows the Shock Doctrine using “Disater Capitalism” to reinvent the economy to the neocan corporate model. Show no mercy but remove the obstacles (poor people) and replace them and their institutions with faith based squeaky clean corporate development (the private condo zation of what was once public funded housing, hospitals, schools and government services.
It is an international movement to globalize the Friedman “Free Economy model”. Moving our jobs off shore to India to shore up the Indian rascist class system is a way of impoverishing AMericans with the Shock Doctrine.
It is no accident that Bushco (ie. Corporation) has spent the government coffers out a decade and transferred those payments to the Corporation. Blackwater is their enforcement arm along with covert intelligence. That is the price of a white elitist upper class who are the new “Enlightened Despots” the modern arisocracy has to have a poor servanr class, when that class gets uppity they get spanked. That was the Army Corps of Engineer in New Orleans not repairing the levees and the wetlands that acted as a buffer to soften the storm surge that was always on the horizon come hurricane season. The dreowning death and loss of property was predicted by insurnace actuaries and known.
Dennis is correct that the non response bt FEMA was a high crime against the citizens. I am reminded of the resurgence in high southern white surpremicist circles of Alabama Governor George Wallace.
bigbrother – How long have you been reading “Shock Doctrine?”
Seems like you started it last night, and it’s made quite an impression.
Actually I have been awarte of all the issues a very long time. Last night I read the Intro which is sort of an executive summary.
What impresses me most is that Ms. Klien gets her mind around the big picture and then lays it out in a clear text picture. A neocon roadmap of how they operate, their goals and philosophy. It is a difficult conundrum to explain and her explanation is about as artful as can be made.
I think Impeachment is what they fear most. It tars their label which forces them back underground.
Yep. Her grasp of this topic is nearly as frightening as the reality.
The next disaster capitalism will be the privatization of the public water wastewater infrastructure which is in need of $2 trillion in replacement investment. Corporate capital wants to own all of this public infrastructure in a for profit venture that will further impoverish us. As Naomi points out these disaters are opportunities for the Corporate Oligarchy to take more control of our lives reducing freedoms.
Thank you Isaiah
Is this not illegal? Like you know being on the take. His job was to repair the city. Im horrified. Not that he would be a loser, but so unseemly, if that’s the right word for a crook.