He was born 100 years ago today, in a log cabin with no electricity or running water, in Polecat Creek, North Carolina. When he preached these words to his peers in 1958, he was not -- definitely not -- preaching to the choir:
This just might do nobody any good. At the end of this discourse a few people may accuse this reporter of fouling his own comfortable nest, and your organization may be accused of having given hospitality to heretical and even dangerous thoughts. But the elaborate structure of networks, advertising agencies and sponsors will not be shaken or altered. It is my desire, if not my duty, to try to talk to you journeymen with some candor about what is happening to radio and television.
Well . . .
I have no technical advice or counsel to offer those of you who labor in this vineyard that produces words and pictures. You will forgive me for not telling you that instruments with which you work are miraculous, that your responsibility is unprecedented or that your aspirations are frequently frustrated. It is not necessary to remind you that the fact that your voice is amplified to the degree where it reaches from one end of the country to the other does not confer upon you greater wisdom or understanding than you possessed when your voice reached only from one end of the bar to the other. All of these things you know.
Make it plain, preacher!
Our history will be what we make it. And if there are any historians about fifty or a hundred years from now, and there should be preserved the kinescopes for one week of all three networks, they will there find recorded in black and white, or color, evidence of decadence, escapism and insulation from the realities of the world in which we live. I invite your attention to the television schedules of all networks between the hours of 8 and 11 p.m., Eastern Time. Here you will find only fleeting and spasmodic reference to the fact that this nation is in mortal danger. There are, it is true, occasional informative programs presented in that intellectual ghetto on Sunday afternoons. But during the daily peak viewing periods, television in the main insulates us from the realities of the world in which we live. If this state of affairs continues, we may alter an advertising slogan to read: LOOK NOW, PAY LATER.
For surely we shall pay for using this most powerful instrument of communication to insulate the citizenry from the hard and demanding realities which must be faced if we are to survive. I mean the word survive literally. If there were to be a competition in indifference, or perhaps in insulation from reality, then Nero and his fiddle, Chamberlain and his umbrella, could not find a place on an early afternoon sustaining show. If Hollywood were to run out of Indians, the program schedules would be mangled beyond all recognition. Then some courageous soul with a small budget might be able to do a documentary telling what, in fact, we have done--and are still doing--to the Indians in this country. But that would be unpleasant. And we must at all costs shield the sensitive citizens from anything that is unpleasant.
Come on with it, preacher!
Let us have a little competition. Not only in selling soap, cigarettes and automobiles, but in informing a troubled, apprehensive but receptive public. Why should not each of the 20 or 30 big corporations which dominate radio and television decide that they will give up one or two of their regularly scheduled programs each year, turn the time over to the networks and say in effect: "This is a tiny tithe, just a little bit of our profits. On this particular night we aren't going to try to sell cigarettes or automobiles; this is merely a gesture to indicate our belief in the importance of ideas." The networks should, and I think would, pay for the cost of producing the program. The advertiser, the sponsor, would get name credit but would have nothing to do with the content of the program. Would this blemish the corporate image? Would the stockholders object? I think not. For if the premise upon which our pluralistic society rests, which as I understand it is that if the people are given sufficient undiluted information, they will then somehow, even after long, sober second thoughts, reach the right decision--if that premise is wrong, then not only the corporate image but the corporations are done for.
Bring it home now, brother, bring it home . . .
I began by saying that our history will be what we make it. If we go on as we are, then history will take its revenge, and retribution will not limp in catching up with us. . .
To those who say people wouldn't look; they wouldn't be interested; they're too complacent, indifferent and insulated, I can only reply: There is, in one reporter's opinion, considerable evidence against that contention. But even if they are right, what have they got to lose? Because if they are right, and this instrument is good for nothing but to entertain, amuse and insulate, then the tube is flickering now and we will soon see that the whole struggle is lost.
This instrument can teach, it can illuminate; yes, and it can even inspire. But it can do so only to the extent that humans are determined to use it to those ends. Otherwise it is merely wires and lights in a box. There is a great and perhaps decisive battle to be fought against ignorance, intolerance and indifference. This weapon of television could be useful.
Stonewall Jackson, who knew something about the use of weapons, is reported to have said, "When war comes, you must draw the sword and throw away the scabbard." The trouble with television is that it is rusting in the scabbard during a battle for survival.
Can I get an "Amen!" or an "Hallelujah!" or two for our guest preacher, Brother Edward R. Murrow?
Login Here
Spotlight



Support this site!
Keep
up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search


RSS/XML Feed
whoooo
It was a privilege to hear his voice always. Truth is very powerful.
Amen!
We should all watch Good Night and Good Luck in honor of his birthday.
Peterr, this is fabulous! Amen, Brothers and Sisters, Amen!
I have a grandmother who is a dyed-in-the-wool republican, who thinks Nixon was framed by the evil media. Reporters and editors and such are anathema in her house.
Even so, when she thinks of Murrow, she hears “This is London . . .” and all that melts away.
*raising a glass, on this Friday afternoon*
To Edward R. Murrow, and those who follow in his footsteps!
*ding*
Murrow was truly a hero.
How refreshing, truth and integrity
There goes Murrow, talking about them “ideas” again.
AMEN, Brother Ed, Alleluia!
Thanks for coming back from the grave to warm our ears!
Bob in HI
I’m really, really hoping Keith will have an extended statement about Murrow tonight.
ay-MAY-un! Halleluja!
Prescient. Well, maybe just clear-thinking, realistic and far-seeing.
Thanks for this, Petrr!
FunnyDiva
Here are a few more choice Murrow quotes for celebrating, timeless:
Thanks for the post about the “social gospel.”
We may be related.
oh yes,i bet so
what a vacuum…there is
Our country once had a news media? When was that?
It reminds me of something published a while back: Four Arguments for the Elimination of Television Here’s the thumbnail, from Wikipedia:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/F.....Television
Every so often, there are these glimpses . . .
The Aurora . . .
WaPo, circa 1974 . . .
Glenn Greenwald, Murray Waas, FDL, circa 200x and counting . . .
707!
You’ve got to love your grandmothers!
Hey Peter great post on one of America’s iconic news reporter of the last century… I wish we had just a few reporter with just one ounce of the integrity that he brought to his craft..
I did a little digging for your post!
Thanks for an excellent post, Peterr.
David Strathairn in Good Night & Good Luck-
“Murrow on Freedom of Speech”
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5N3WJXK2PAM
Oh boy make my day :>)
Wonderful.
I’m so ashamed that the television medium is being used to foster racism and sexism in the year 2008. I’m sure Brother Murrow is rolling over in his grave.
i’m not sure it’s even possible to know - was there ever a time when we the people had the tools to not just ask the question but to attempt to answer it?
my toast: here’s to the hope that tomorrow will bring, with our help, a golden age for news.
Peterr!
Halleluja indeed.
I’ve got tears. Happy tears. And, sad tears.
(and it takes a lot to bring tears to me these days.)
Thank you.
Great post Reverend.
Great.
Most excellent and lest we forget the fight between truth and lies still goes on. And if we are going to be the movement, the people, we think we are then I would humbly suggest we deal with…
This incident.
One of the things which is becoming most apparent is that there are many who call themselves ‘progressive’ but who in fact are…
…anything but.
I’m sure that if Morrow was alive today he’d be calling on us, the people, to speak out about this affront to what I am sure we all believe.
That dissent is protected.
No matter what.
Or have I got that wrong?
Do you know of a recording of this speech? If not, I’ll go searching. I remember watching him on CBS in the good ol’ b&w days. I was always mesmerized by his voice. KO is the closest thing we have to Morrow today and that’s a sad commentary, with all due respect to KO.
No justice, no peace.
Thank you Peterr,
I can’t believe he was born in a log cabin, sometimes you just can’t make this stuff up. :)
It’s a shame that the movie Good Night & Good Luck didn’t move any of our current MSM journos to look inside themselves.
oh, and here’s to Amy Goodman. possibly the best of the best.
peterr–
i find it interesting when someone like murrow uses a quote to illustrate something he, in his mind, couldn’t fully articulate in the rest of his wonderful text…..i always think, it must be an important, separate thing to ponder..and in this case it is…..
”When war comes, you must draw the sword and throw away the scabbard.”
this is the part that we talk about all of the time.
to throw away the scabbard you are stepping into the breach, and that is the part that induces fear into anyone thinking about taking action in anything…..you can take a stand, with your scabbard, and that is standing strong in and of itself, but when you finally commit to something you DO throw away the scabbard, step into the breach and there is no looking back….
once that is an action you have taken, you can recognize it in others-whether they have or not, and again in yourself when that moment comes again, whether to throw away the scabbard….and step into the breach.
a fine relief-filled yet scary moment that is.
thanks peterr.
(whispering…)
and, speaking of reverends and journalists…Bill Moyers and Jeremiah Wright tonight.
just a gentle reminder.
Peace.
i don’t think he would be offended but i have to put helen thomas in there too.
Thank you Keith!!! Go get Rush for incitement to riot!!! Sic ‘em!!
Edward R. Murrow’s legacy to journalism is only tarnished by his failure to ask President Eisenhower why he hadn’t placed a American flag pin on his lapel.
It’s the only true measure of patriotism, as we now know.
Tell it!
Hear Hear! I can watch Democary Now now that I switched to Firefox3. It uses GStreamer :>
snort ,spit….hahahahahahahahaaha
That’s what scares most of today’s journalists: stepping into the breach.
Sometimes, you’ve just got to call a lie “a lie.”
Froomkin does it, Helen Thomas does it, but it’s a short list after that.
Oh good, he’s gonna do the newspaper levee story too.
Either you or someone else posted this earlier. Really, a molehill.
do i even need to use the google to know that GStreamer is opensource?
lol, nope :)
KO!!
Amen AND Hallelujah!
with all due respect to our hosts, i think we have to find a way to get rid of advertising.
it fucks with incentives and it fucks with our minds.
Don’t you love the double entendre on his initials?
Pow!
Molly spoke the truth.
oh boy Hillary looks rough
i just love the guy,i met him once 12 years ago…he is a BIG man..”g”
Yes, Molly Ivins and Ann Richards were both Texans of the Best Kind.
peterr at 38–yes, i was going to mention froomkin if noone else did, he is the apex.
but i was also talking about ’us’…..especially aimed at those murrow was talking about, the ones who have not thrown away the scabbard and stepped into the breach, in anything, yet wail and say ’let’s get ’em’……
those of us who know the difference are encouraging others to step on up and throw it to the wind….and hit the ground runnin’.
*raising a glass*
To Molly!
*ding*
Use Lynx!
if the fourth estate is to survive it will be through us, we are now what remains of that fourth branch of protection, the fourth estate
we keep the vigil and we might be lost, lost when we loose net nuetrality, it is the life blood now of the fourth estate and their purpose now is to silence us
Evening, all…
As long as we’re honoring those who carry on the tradition of Murrow, I have to give a shout-out to a local guy here in Central FL, Rob Lorei, co-founder and news director of WMNF 88.5 FM in Tampa. Rob helped found the station 30 years ago, and fights the war for progressive values every day on the radio and every week on TV. He could have sold out and gone to a network years ago, but stays to carry on. He’s one of the smartest people and gentlest personalities I’ve ever met, and is a model of what a journalist should be.
nice!
Rachel Maddow
Randi Rhodes
Indeed! Cassie’s role models are Ivins, Richards, Barbara Jordan, Helen Thomas and Rachel Maddow. I’ve been told I am #28 on the list.
Keith is doing Murrow right now!
I suppose with a teenager, I should be honored to be included at all.
Hey Truth fans, check out EW’s post on the General Sockpuppet scandal. Worth reading if you haven’t already.
In Los Angeles, our radical station, KPFK has Jerry Quickly, who is Righteous! Right on, Jerry.
If Bushco was still popular…if the economy was thriving…if gas was at 60 cents a gallon…then they could get away with silencing the country. This is a different world now. People may not have family members at war, but they are feeling the other war…the one on the citizens of this great country. Most people only act when it affects them personally…unless you are the kind of person who is concerned with others that is…or see the big picture…or remember history.
and peterr, (and the ’you’ is a universal you) i don’t just mean politics, i mean people pick something in your life that matters to you and do what i said at 30….there are those that never will, and i can feel their fear, but once you have thrown away the scabbard, there is no looking back and you own your own life. forever. and others who have done it, we recognize each other.
it’s called little acts of courage…..and murrow was full of that…..
he didn’t mean sit back and point at the people who aren’t doing what they should be, he meant get out there and throw away the f%cking scabbard!!!!!!!
in his life, he didn’t just talk about news ethics, he talked about LIFE and human beings, what they do and what they are capable of……..and what they can rise above.
so, pick something that matters to you, no matter how insignificant, ponder how best to attack it while looking at your sword and when ready, wing that scabbard to the wind…and don’t look back…
Just got here, a loud AMEN for Edward R. Murrow.
Hi LS, you’ve been hitting the ball outta the park with every comment in this house *g*
It IS a different world and I wish some candidates would stop playing by the standards of previous elections, if you know what I mean.
Also, spot on about this whole thing affecting people more directly, hitting them at home now. Why haven’t we been rioting? Because we know we can vote! (Although we have been protesting without much press but the public sentiment has been building and building against the status quo).
Makes ya wonder what Murrow would have done if there were blogs back in his day. Kinda funny how the name Murrow invokes thoughts of broadcast news.
Wow…maybe Ike Skelton is finally waking up…he’s been a bit of a bonehead for awhile…but this is good:
“Mr. Speaker, maybe I am too idealistic, but this story is appalling to me on a number of levels. For me, it all comes down to trust and credibility. And it would be a dangerous thing for the American people to lose trust in the Pentagon, in our retired officer corps, and in the press, each of which has a critical role to play in preserving our nation’s freedoms.”
Ummm..Ike…Hellooooo…do you live in a cave?
I cut and pasted this..it says “Mr.” Speaker….ummmmm…hmmmm…maybe that was EW’s typo…or is someone sitting in for Pelosi. Anyway, no biggie.
oh KEIF IS FABULOUSSSSSSSSSS
Great post Peterr! Is this your first official post? Congratulations, buddy.
Earlier this week on Larry King Live, Speaker Pelosi said the anti war statistics are at 63 percent and that’s two points higher than any Viet Nam anti-war statistic.
This is kind of a frivolous remark, but don’t the McCain’s consult each other on The Look.
She looks like she’s wearing a Really Expensive suit, and he looks like he shops at Walmart or Sears.
Sorry. Just an observation.
Says something, tho, I think.
and did she explain why she was going to be ignoring that?
Heh, heh, heh….McCain said that if he was president he would have turned Airforce One around when Katrina hit, but he was with Bush when Katrina hit…it was his birfday…and it was a photo-op.
Smackdown….
Store in McCain file…for future reference.
No, nor did Larry ask.
one more sad statistic…average age Nam=19
average age Iraq=19…(soldiers)
i love him so very,very mucho
really! I would like to hear that explanation myself
On thatr list, you are in pretty fast company! I would venture to say that inclusion is an extreme honor. Besides, what can you do, you’re being held up against these people. Not all of us can be *!
* Your Idol’s Name Here
She need to do a better job leting us know who the Bush Dogs are so we can vent anger in that direction.
Maybe since she controls all the money…he’s on a ration…and that’s why he’s mad at her and called her trollop and the “C” word. I think that looking at pictures of him as a young man, he was good looking and a bit of a playboy…not to mention a cheater on his wife with Cindy. She’s got him on a tight financial leash.
Oh? Larry’s not on our List? Ha!
I’ve noticed that too, but he’s never been a savvy dresser. Kind of a slump if you ask me.
My favorite moment was when she called McCain, McBush…and Larry hesitated and said, McBush?…and she said yes….
No, I’ve been doing posts for quite a while. But thanks nonetheless for the congratulations.
(If you’re curious about the earlier ones, click on my name up by the title of the post.)
Larry is almost as old a quick as McCain. /s
Oh, geez, and we’re worried about this ****** is gonna be the next president.
(screaming here)
Yeah, he wants to fool everybody into believing he is the “everyman” of Americana…
Two others to remember:
I.F. Stone: While other reporters were going hobnibbing in DC, he was reading through things like Congressional transcripts to find out the truth of stories. You would not catch him playing tennis or cocktailing with the people he was reporting on.
William L. Shirer: He hired Murrow during WW2 and was on the air first, although they later fell out, and Murrow played the corporate cards better (he also had a better radio voice). But Shirer was the one who chronicled in exhaustive detail the rise and fall of Herr Shickelgruber, someone we overlook at our peril, since many of his ideas seem to be in current circulation amongst wingers.
They were all part of a time in American journalism that’s unlikely to come again, at least in print. There is some hope via blogs, however.
Ayyyy-aaayyy-men, Ayyyy-aaayyyyy-men, ayyya-amen, amen, amen. Sing it, children….
Murrow is one of my very short list of heroes, an inspiration to my own lifelong caring about the role of the media.
It was absolutely sickening this morning to see one of the ‘bots [Contessa?] on MSNBC perky her way thru leading punditizing on the Wright appearance on Moyers with some guy from the WaPoo and a Houston Chronicleer. They were all full of spinerizing based on a wee soundbite as to whether or not it was good for Obama or some other such tripe. The jazz channel [DirectTV 850] a much better alternative.
Ya gotta wonder how these people can slime their way back to their homes and look themselves in the mirror without puking into the sink.
For the current crop of their ilk I’d like to be able to say “Good night and good riddance.”
Did you mean Schlump? and,
Nonplussed, I figured that part out…
That reminds me, there is an upcoming book salon on I.F. Stone.
There was another - H. V. Kaltenborn. He had a news broadcast every day at 5pm to tell us about WW2. My grandfather loved him and we would listen together. He got in trouble for saying we should get involved in Europe but he stayed on the air. He lived until the age of 87. He was a newsman - the highest honor I know how to give.
My apologies.
Slump, schlump…you got the drift. Hell, even Firefox didn’t pick up on it, but it did tell me that “schlump” was a misspelling. Go figure. LOL
No, no, no…
None needed. You are absolutely right!
I was just pointing out their disconnect.
:( I sorry too.
For what it’s worth, I heard Rush Limbaugh saying this week that Hillary is real and Barack Obama is just flashing his wallet around. Huh?
OT:
There are approximately 5 days left in this month….40 US soldiers killed in Iraq so far..it the highest death count since September 2007…tied with January…
I was at the local VA just today, many young people there. I had a PT session, everyone but me was a young man. I grieve…
It is just so awful…I hope the PT went well.
Peterr, thanks for this inspiring post.
I hope Murrow’s successors hear your call.
My husband goes to the VA for computer jobs and always comes home with an interesting story.
Heart goes out to all the kids who had lost limbs and heart.
(we’re good?)
Absolutely!
No argument. I was just focusing on TV. I’d probably have to add I F Stone and a couple others to the list as well.
Well, Richard from Gulfport will just have to agree with everything you’ve said. I’ve supported the station for many years. Tampa Bay would be an information wasteland (”Wasteland of the Free”) without WMNF, the Best Little Radio Station on the Planet. Far out.
I just today bought a paperback copy of Naomi Klein’s End of America. See page 98, in her section re the no-fly list. In a passage that will sound familiar to many who have encountered the vagaries of modern homeland protection, Bill Shirer writes how Kaltenborn was refused entry to Berlin in 1938.
The quote is from Berlin Diary: The Journal of a Foreign Correspondent 1934-1941.