Why could wild salmon reach $40 per pound? DiFi, Dick Cheney, and other dessicated Village pols keep giving away heavily subsidized water to welfare farmers and energy megacorps in Oregon and California. Without enough water, the salmon die. Who'd a thunk it?
We can always eat farmed salmon, instead? It's cheaper anyway, right?
Not so fast, Charlie. Want some hormones and antibiotics with your salmon burger? Pound-for-pound,farmed salmon chow down more antibiotics than any other beastflesh you can buy: the pinnacle of the toxic food chain. But wait, there's more. The Environmental Working Group found 7 of 10 pieces of farmed salmon tested in 2003 had PCB levels so high as to render the fish toxic. PCB's -- another toxic gift from Monsanto that just keeps on giving -- are nearly indestructible oily compounds Monsanto hawked for use in electrical equipment. And Monsanto kept on pushing PCB's, and telling us how safe they were, for decades after they knew full well the indestructible little molecules were -- and are -- incredibly potent poisons. As far back as the 1930's PCB's were known to cause chloracne, tumors, birth defects, reproductive abnormalities, and a host of other horrors.
Oh well -- we can trust Monsanto on GMO's, right?
Anyway, farmed eat fish food made from fish oil, ground-up fish, artificial dyes, and Antarctic critters called krill. PCB's dissolve in oil -- so critters that eat oily fish get lots of yummy PCB's and other persistent organic pollutants. And critters that eat the critters that eat oily fish get even more of Monsanto's pride and joy -- PCB's. This process, called bio-accumulation, works so well that Inuit peoples -- who eat the walrus and killer whales and seals that eat the oily fish that eat the ... well, you get you the picture. Some Inuit peoples have concentrations of PCB so high that if they were food, they'd be confiscated.
Well, no one eats Inuits, so no problem, right Monsanto? Nursing Inuits and their babies don't see it that way: the way humans excrete PCB and other oily synthetic toxins our bodies can't break down is by excreting fat. As you've probably noticed, we don't tend to go sliming around leaving trails of fat. Unless, well, we're nursing. Yep -- to produce breast milk, human women (like the other mammals) break down stored body fat to nourish those little critters. Which is why Inuit women (and other circumpolar indigenous peoples) have been found to produce breast milk with incredibly high levels of PCB's and other potent, indestructible toxic compounds.
Hey -- better living through chemistry, right?
Don't wanna bother to go to the Arctic to raise levels of toxic PCBs in your diet? Hey, you don't have to -- just chow down on farmed salmon. The EWG found the farmed stuff is so laden with toxinsthat people should eat no more than eight ounces per month.
Fond of tumors and synthetic dyes? Well, lucky you -- here's a big steaming pile of farmed salmon. In addition to being flabby (from spending their lives in pens, rather than swimming through the ocean oceans), farmed salmon are a lovely shade of -- urp -- grey. Those thoughtful salmon farm owners think of everything, so they give their flabby captives a diet high in artificial dyes. Yum.
Fond of PCB's, tumors, synthetic dyes, and global warming -- and have it in for penguins? Well, step right up. Remember that yummy food for farmed salmon? Well, the part that isn't made from fish oil and oily fish laden with PCB's and persistent organic pollutants -- that part's made from krill.
What are krill? Oh, just another ocean critter we clever humans are mining to hell. Krill live around the Antarctic, where they are a main component of penguins' diets and an apparently nifty way of pulling CO2 out of the atmosphere and into the deep oceans.
An eco two-fer, right?
So, of course, we're killing them off for salmon farms. The krill, that is -- and hence the penguins that depend upon them.
An ecocidal two-fer.
But wait -- there's more.
Salmon farms also act as giant petri dishes for sea lice. Yum. Sea lice are parasites that slowly accumulate on some salmon as they grow to adulthood, spawn, and die. Mother Nature, clever woman, ensured that the adult salmon croaked and turned to bear meat and forest fertilizer long before their eggs hatched into smolts for the trip out to the ocean. No adult salmon -- no sea lice for the little ones.
The miracle of salmon farming, however, ensures that -- on their way out to sea -- the young salmon run a gantlet of farmed adultish fish in pens -- fishy versions of a sea lice Petri dish. This efficient system for killing wild salmon has already crashed salmon in Ireland, Scotland, and Norway. On Canada's west coast, salmon runs that pass through coastal areas with fish farms are expected to crash in four years.
Bye, wild salmon. Hello, fish farms.
What do toxic crap and chloracne and dead penguins and sea lice and liver tumors have to do with Cheney and DiFi? Without consulting genealogists, the incomplete answer is that Cheney and DiFi give their wealthy pals our Federal water, and their pals turn around and kill off wild salmon across the West by killing off their habitat.
Yesterday the Pacific Fisheries Management Council cancelled the 2008 Chinook salmon fishing season for California and most of Oregon, citing collapse of the only healthy salmon run passing though the California Delta and San Francisco Bay. The week before, DiFi "improved" her plan to give 500 wealthy families federal water that used to feed the Delta -- and the salmon.
Oh, the improvement? Well, under the old plan, the 500 Lords of the Westland Water District would only have been able to sell low-cost subsidized federal water for sixty years (twice the length of the average irrigation contract). Under the new plan DiFi loves, the 500 families get an indefinite contract for the water ... water they can ultimately turn around and sell on the open market.
What is low-cost federal water? Water from vast projects you and I and all the other U.S. taxpayers paid the Bureau of Reclamation to build for the public good; in the arid West, most of the projects carry water that originally flowed off public lands. The plan DiFi loves takes water from the slopes of the Sierra Nevada that once flowed into the San Joaquin River, and spits it into the Westland's siphons -- and pockets.
WTF does this have to do with salmon?
Well, the San Joaquin River and the Sacramento River flow together to create the California Delta, which flows into the Pacific through the San Francisco Bay. The vast Delta-Bay waters form the largest estuary on the Pacific Coast of the Western Hemisphere. As estuaries act as giant nurseries for fish and shellfish, the Delta-Bay system is the biggest single fish nursery between Tierra Del Fuego and Alaska.
And DiFi wants to pay 500 families who already suck water out of that system to do so for forever.
And all they had to do was poison 400,000 acres of land and stiff the Feds for $490 million.
Now that's a return on investment: for every acre of land poisoned and every million I stiff the Feds, DiFi will push through a bill to give me $100 million -- and push endangered salmon right over the edge to near-extinction.
Such a deal -- for the wealthy 500 families DiFi pays off. And for the deep pockets that own the fish farms killing off Northwest salmon.
If you or I willfully poison an acre of federal land -- and kill endangered species -- while stiffing the Feds for a million dollars, do you think we would get indefinite rights to sell cheap federal water to the highest bidder? Nope.
We'll get to be inmates.
In the meantime, we can have antibiotics and sea lice -- with a side helping of flabby farmed salmon. Or we can have fresh Pacific Northwest salmon -- before the fish farms kill 'em off -- for up to $40 a pound.
Ain't the Village sweet?
Bon Appetit.
[graph: water4fish.org]
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight

Support this site!
Keep up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

RSS/XML Feed
There is a real chance of ecosystem collapse in the oceans. The pressure on most schooling foodfish is overwhelming. And like you point out the farming of salmon, steelhead, and Atlantic salmon is a lethal solution.
I remember when Cheney turned over the water decision and the warnings of the repercussions. Another feather in bushcos legacy hat.
What’s up, Doc? Another awesome post!
More charts?
Jeez!
dont know too much of this topic…. dont like fish - but difi really doesnt seem to care much for common folk huh? is it b/c she’s not running again so the hell with everyone? or i could be totally off base here…
gdamned mofos…salmon is a basic staple
!@#$%^&*(@#$%^TY&U*argh
More than a “real chance.” More like a “strong likelihood.” Decimation. Coming to many foodstock species shortly, and then to the human species as well absent concerted, intelligent widespread change across a breadth of ecological fronts.
Suggestion to everyone: don’t eat farmed fish.
More positively: eat organic non-animal food that makes complete protein.
Hey, why is there unrest in Haiti. Rice and bean prices?
And rioting in Egypt over food prices. We are really in for some hard times.
haitians are reduced to eating dirt cookies….
Amazingly, enough, using food for fuel was not a good idea - who’d a thunk it?
Not good for us - or critters - or global warming.
In Asia, palm oil plantations for fuel are driving local populations to extinction.
Turns out a tiger in the tank was a bad idea, too.
We all live down stream.
Americans, who constitute ~5% of world population, consume ~25% of world resources. This relative level of comfort is unsustainable, and our sudden acute discomfort may well result in savagery we naively think we are incapable of.
Hey — better living through chemistry, right?
Sad but it seams just about unstoppable.
jo6pac
I always think of Jacques Cousteau - remember his documentaries from a few decades ago? The incredible abundance of the ocean - it was inconceivable then that that could be depleted.
The devastation we’ve wreaked on this planet is - no word comes to me. Beyond expression, beyond understanding.
I rather think our own savagery turned inward might make Sadr City look like a very small playground.
Motherf****rs.
jo6pac, it won’t be easy, but we can rapidly end the biofuels farce by ending:
(1) EU mandates for biofuels
(2) US subsidies for ethanol
As biofuels (from crops /arable land forests in general, and grains in particular) increase carbon gas emissions, they are low hanging fruit.
I agree. We differ substantively, in terms of our naivete, from those who have endured much more difficult lives. Burst our collective excessive comfort level — which we view in the aggregate as our entitlement — and we may very well descend rapidly into the worst sort of savagery.
The salmon fisheries have been fucked for years. Whole fleets have gone belly up. First the fuel prices kill ya and then they shut off the fishing altogether. Wanna buy a fishing boat cheap?
Go to any harbor on the West coast.
another excellent post, Dr Kirk!
water … Big Corporations are very interested in water. Next up, they’ll probably charge us to breathe.
I guess maybe they can be like tugs were in th eearly 90’s, when they became the trendy residences up around Puget Sound.
I’m far more hopeful.. Left to our own devices, we humans don’t accumulate at teh levels American accumulate.
The reason advertisers and PR firms spend so much to create the consumer demand (much of for pointloess toxic crap) that drives 70% of our economy is because without the ads, we buy a lot less. And all the ads and PR are tax-subidized (deductible expenses).
We have a whole lot of opportunities to decrease demand simply be elimiating corporate tax deductions for for-profit advertising/PR.
Have you noticed the sudden spike in touchy, feel good ads by BP, Chevron, Shell, etal…?
John Dean on KO!
As of today’s LA TIMES, the wild chinook season has been cancelled by federal fisheries management. So much for all the people who make their living off the trade.
http://latimesblogs.latimes.co.....an-on.html
yes sadly
Kirk what can I say about this sorry event, how many lives have been affected because the fatcats want all the water so they can make $$$ of the backs of all of us!
Great post Kirk… I know several fishermen in Princeton that are just devastated by the turn of events. First it was the water in the Klamath and now the delta is basically dieing because of the salt incursion and the lack of habitat for not only the Salmon but on their food they need before they can make it to the open ocean.
Oh yeah Digg it!
you and me on same page
Anyone know how to search google cache?
I’m curious about this pulled news story.
WIS News 10 - Columbia, South Carolina | Returning soldier …
Returning soldier questions methods in Afghanistan … national guard unit says things should have been much different during their mission in Afghanistan. …
www.wistv.com/global/story.asp?s=8154362 - 4 hours ago
Yep, CT, i have. To me, that’s a good sign that the megacorps fear gathering public opinion.
Current polling indicates the vast majority of even Americans favor stringent eco-regulations and punitive sanctions on rogue corporations.
Now that even mainstream media talk about nationaliziing Big Finance in some ways, we’re halfway there.
The paradigm shift is well underway, and numerous solutions exist for a broad range of problems.
All that remains - and it’s a big “all” is taking out the Village (the upper 0.1% and their wholly-owned talking heads). Not taking them out literally - but destroying their reputatations, credibility, and hence tools to deform our collective desires and will.
We’ll get there - and the coming recession/depression will help.
I’m not certain how many species and eco-systems will survive to see it.
OK, that was weird. This page disappeared for a while, both here & on the front page.
Oh - my laptop and the toobz were having issues today - and the beachball mostly won.
IF you rrefresh, you’ll see a whole lot of linkies -a nd the link to the good people at water4fish, creators of the nifty graph above.
W4F has ther great idea of mobilizing sport anglers against the water rustlers and megacorps.
Brilliant- especially considering the demographics of sport anglers. Great plan to peel off even Republican electred officials from Nestle, Westland, and the like.
Whole lot more fisherman than their are water barons.
sorry for disappearnace - that was me saving new linkies.
here’s for your first one
http://64.233.169.104/search?q.....#038;gl=us
is that right?
I have been thinking about that for some time now.
I think so. Thanks!
Kirk - It’s dinner time! Ugh! Good thing I’m vegetarian and live in an area with lots of small organic farmers. I will have a fruit salad for dinner and a dish of plain yogurt on the side.
Keep dirty talking, Kirk, and I won’t even sit with relatives who eat the sea lice infested salmon.
It’s 80 plus degrees and I am wilting. I started out praisng the day now I feel like a steamed clam. Six pounder Molly has gone into full lazy mode. Nothing like the first heat wave to remind you the rest of your body is still in winter mode. Just five days ago I was in the snow. I need to ease into things.
Seriously, that is a lot of good information that people need to take with them to the supermarket, even Whole Foods, now that they are corporate and public. I avoid the meat area because of the smell never mind the visual but I see lots of people making purchases.
Did anyone here know Foster Farms acquired Crystal Dairy? Nary a mention on the label. The way I found out was when I purchased a small container of cottage cheese, unsealed it, and looking straight at me was a little fly (or something). I checked out Crystals web site and called their number. The person answering the phone said it was sold to Foster Farms and FF just took over production in the past three months. She gave me a number.
So I called and had to leave a message. A couple of days later some guy calls me and asks why I called. I told him. He was all put out with me and said he’d check into it. “But, wait”, I said, “please send me a letter letting me know what you plan to do about it. Don’t you want my name and address?” I heard a sigh. “Ok. What’s your name and address.”
That was two months ago and I still haven’t received a letter. But I have my sweet ways. Every time I am by the dairy area I chat up the people around me and ask, “Did you know Crystal is now owned by Foster Farms?” I have quite a collection of people moving on to other products, pissed that FF doesn’t identify itself on the Crystal label.
Great to see this exposed in the blogosphere at last.
Let’s not forget case of the Chinese cadmium in the Norwegian farmed salmon and the subsequent coverup. It was a huge scandal in Europe and Russia a couple of years ago. The Norwegian government was caught falsifying data and destroying whistleblowers. Perhaps the first in the recent wave of Chinese contamination scandals and thus deserves its place in history. A few courageous scientists finally managed to get past the holier than thou veneer of Norway (”we give out the Nobel Prize, we *must* be pure!”) and got the law changed to protect whistleblowers and reduce but not eliminate institutional conflicts of interest such as the same scientists sitting on regulatory boards as on fisheries marketing boards, and substitution of PR department propaganda for direct expression of scientists, as also famously happened at NASA under Bush. Thankfully, the same bad actors in the Norwegian equivalent of the FDA were caught in the more recent scandal about shoddy fish oil production practices.
Social democracy is a great thing, but there’s never a good time to dispense with accountability, as Norway did while trying to keep their reputation and the fish money rolling in. Meanwhile the medical community swallowed the propaganda whole about the need for long chain omega 3s, when most peoples’ bodies can make all they need out of the shorter chains found in flax and other safe sources. My own nutritionist tried to get me to use fish oil instead of flax!
Note also, even the good studies of bioaccumulation leave a huge hole — they detect what bioaccumulates in fish, but not what bioaccumulates in humans that doesn’t significantly bioaccumulate in fish but is present in fish — and a lot of that is potentially very bad stuff too.
Thanks again for getting this out in such a prominent venue!
Maybe Blackwater’s true mission is to protect the one percenters from the rest of us when the planet goes south.
I was wondering what happened! Ya went *poof*!
Yes, this is a castrophe for them - and even so , these small independent businessmen overwhelmiingly supported the closure.
They are doubly hit - they are just coming off closure of much of the same waters a few years back after Cheney played a cynical game allowing diversion of Klamath RIver water to (largely) subsidized welfare farmers in the klamath basin. Result was that water in klamath (trapped behing dams that increase water temp) was so hot it killed young salmon migrating out to sea.
No salmon to speak of behind me in the American River this year.
But they do raise the levels on the weekends for the rafters.
Idiots.
Valley Girl, I had no idea - thanks! A while back our mod suz kindly passsed on a chart re megacorp ownership of natural/organic foods. While people still have a chance to plant their gardens, I should address that.
In general, avoiding processed foods whenever possible - and only purchasing sourced (by origin / means of production “organic) bulk ingredients is the only way i know to mimimize food risks.
_ _ _
and wial, thanks for the info - I’d had no idea - you learned me. Thanks also for your kind words.
we knew better, we know better, we are smarter than this. That’s what drives me crazy, Kirk. We are so much smarter than this
Kirk it also stranded many adult fish that never spawned… what a freeking waste … kill the young and squander the breeding adults…. this alone should be grounds for Impeachment!!!
Hey guys Kirk deserves more diggs than this 5 !!
The Hill reported this today…
WRT to the Klamath, the dams on the river (owed by a megacorp Warren Buffet owns a big part of) produce power that isn’t worth the value of the fishing economies the dams destroy.
Dams have to be re-licensed under FERC (Federal Energy Reg commission). Even under Bush/Cheney, NOAA fisheries and the US FWS found that dam removal is the best possible option.
FERC claims carting the Klamath salmon around FOUR dams is better.
One more set of indictments to come after january 20, 2009.
$40 per pound for prime wild salmon may be exceeded this year. The prime stuff, Copper River King and Copper River Sockeye, hit the markets in five weeks. We’ll see. Here’s what I do with half of mine.
Most of Alaska’s wild salmon populations are very sturdy, but the villages and towns around the majority of the streams are dying, because their heating, their refrigeration, their boats, their pretty much everything, is based on diesel and gas, which, in some parts of Alaska are running wll over $10 per gallon right now.
Kirk you can grow quite a bit of veggies in large pots. any sunny place will do. I have a small plot 10×10 so I also use lots of large pots for single plants… I always get more than we can eat so my neighbors get the bennies.
What a sad post. Can it be reversed?
Most people don’t even remember what real food is anymore…I had to raise a litter of puppies some years ago from birth, and they started dying (at 2 days old)…I usually have organic milk in the house, but at that particular time, it was regular bovine hormone milk temporarily that I had for the formula….I rushed the babies to the vet and the vet told me it was dying puppy syndrome, and they would all die…he gave me some formula in a carton…it didn’t help….I got online, and a commenter somewhere identified the problem….I immediately went out and bought organic milk and switched the formula (milk and egg yolks), and the remaining puppies immediately, within hours, turned around and survived just fine. Like canaries in the mine….
I wish Gore was running…I think…
Pardon the OT: Rabid lambs with a twist..
SHEEP’S RIGHTS END SHEARING CONTEST
I’m still so envious. :P
I gotta wonder what Ian (Anderson) thinks of this. I’m betting it makes him sad. And mad!
That was to ET and the smoked salmon….
What is this; “A Conversation about Race” at Howard U with Brian Williams hosting…? Spare me please…!
Does anyone here know if Everybody’s Business An Almanac: an Irreverent Guide to Corporate America has been updated? It was first published a few years ago by Bob Levering, Milton Moskowitz and Michael Katz. This is the same team that went on to write The Hundred Best Companies to Work for in America.
In Everybody’s Business they trace a mega company from its simple beginnings and through many acquisitions. What you once remembered as a good product no longer exists though the name may be the same. Try and find this info on a label. Hah!
They used to up date this book but I no longer know its status. I think when companies were raped, plundered and their skeleton thrown to the dogs in rapid succession, they may not have been able to keep up with it. I don’t know.
good news is that’s why the ad men ;/pr men WPP / burson marsteller have to spend more to get less everyear. Even the majority of Americans now believe having more (above basic food clothing shelter - and affordable education /healthcare /energy / transport) doesn’t imp-rove their lives.
With these cultural shifts underway, the collapse in US borrowing - and hence purchasing - power is a real opportunity to curtail the culture of ecocidal conspicuous consumption.
The challenge and the art for progressives will be to ensure the least well off experience some increas in capacity to meet basic needs as the total purchasing capacity declines. The fact income distribution is as skewed as any time in US history - and the megacorps are distrusted by the majority - will make that easier than one think.
The art will be in accurately and clearly conveying that process - so the upper 0.1% can’t use economic deprivation among the least fortunate to discredit progressive changes.
The same gloabl brain trusts that smashed the image of the WTO, IMF/WB, “free trade”, etc are well along in working on this, too.
The US Army and State Dept began plannig for the postwar occupation of Germany in 1943.
Many days it seems like that’s where we progessives are: we’ll have more years when we watch the fascists we’re working to defeat kill people and communities we love - and then we’ll be able to recast the whole mess.
The Lake and our community here seem like a growing piece in that great effort. What a cool time to be a progressive?
Who’d a thunk that four days of Torch Tour would prompt global leaders to start telling China to drop the hissy fits and join the community of nations - and start with freedom in TIbet?
LS, growing up our kitties routinely live nearly 20 years eating commercial food. Now vets seem to regard kitties over 10 as “senior” - and think I’m not grounded in reality to have had different expectations.
But many, many kitties living so log tells me something awful has happened to make a 50% reduction in lifespan the (apparent) new norm.
Thanks so much for your comment. I’ve no proof, but in addition to acute toxicity like that we saw last year, I’m iincreasingly concerned that even the best prescription cat food from the vet is not as safe as was regular store-bought food twenty years ago.
WOnder what out-sourcing our supply of raw ingredients to the cheapest global bidder is doing to human health and longevity?
_ _ _
New post upstairs, pups - thanks fo rcoming!
We’ll get there - and the coming recession/depression will help.
And the blind greed of the collective on Wall Street will be showcased to the world. As more financial heavies find themselves in trouble they will look to the Fed for a bailout and the Fed will happily comply. The free market mantra of self-regulation will be exposed for what it really is. It already has with J P Morgan/Bear Stearns but the administration and financial press doesn’t want you to see it that way.
As Churchill said, “The is not the beginning of the end; rather it is the end of the beginning.” (from memory, so be kind, please)
Doctor Murphy!!
Loosening ‘the Salmon of Doubt’, then Kirk? (Apologies to Douglas Adams and yerself, if offended)
Great post, as always …
Of late, Kirk I’ve fond optimism at both ends, as it were.
I’m optimistic in the short run, IF the human species gets ‘it’, together… then …
And, in the long run, if we don’t, then old mother nature and the earth herself will get along just fine WITHOUT US.
The penquins and their polar opposites, those white bears, just don’t appear to be smart enough to understand ‘Murkin appetites and global economic realities.
But, I especially like the ‘War on Krill’, looks like it has a great future…
In addition to #2, there is the little matter of the farm bill recipients who are happy as pigs in mud about growing more corn for ethanol.
“Americans, who constitute ~5% of world population, consume ~25% of world resources.”
Buckminister Fuller was preaching this in the 70’s
One of the better posts I wish I hadn’t read.
I’m a sushi nut and since tuna’s now out (mercury) I switched to salmon, which I love(ed). Yet another casualty to irresponible corporatism along with lack of goverment oversight and resource management for the public good.
And another point, that I didn’t see made (unless I missed it) is that as the price of wild salmon rises it becomes more profitable to harvest, accelerating the decline of the wild salmon population driving more business to the corporate salmon farming industry which ultimately increases their profits. So it would actually be in the interest of the salmon farming industry to see wild salmon either disappear entirely from the planet or at least decline enough to insure the increasing profitibity of their industry.
Sigh!