Just about every day brings another MSM newsbite about Senator McCain's latest bizarre and idiosyncratic departure from reality. Sadly for the Senator - and more sadly for America - the presumptive GOP nominee for Commander-in-Chief suffers from brain impairment so severe that his military peers publicly warn us he is unfit for command.
When so many struggle with basic literacy, much less biomedical literacy, I've give up expecting our incurious, superficial MSM to see the pattern, much less report on it. The pattern's quite obvious - as Howie Klein pointed out yesterday: in the UK's Financial Times, Professor Anatol Lieven was quite clear in describing McCain's obvious impairment:
...Mr McCain's policies would not be so worrying were it not for his notorious quickness to fury in the face of perceived insults to himself or his country. Even Thad Cochran, a fellow Republican senator, has said: "I certainly know no other president since I've been here who's had a temperament like that."
OK - so what does some ivory tower type like Cambridge Professor Lieven know? He must be a pacifist peace-nik, right? Uh - not so much. He was "editor of Strategic Comments, published by the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) in London. There he also specialized in the former Soviet Union and in aspects of contemporary warfare." Hmm. Not exactly a job for flower children.
When Mark Benjamin researched his piece on McCain's temperament earlier this month, he wasn't asking flower children, either.
In interviews with Salon this week, several experienced military officers said McCain draws mixed reviews among military leaders, and they expressed serious doubts about whether McCain has the right temperament to be the next president and commander in chief. Some expressed more confidence in Obama, citing his temperament as an asset.
It is not difficult in Washington to find high-level military officials who have had close encounters with John McCain's temper, and who find it worrisome .....the concern is that McCain has, at times, come across as out of control. It is difficult to find current or former officers willing to describe those encounters in detail on the record. That's because, by and large, those officers admire McCain. But that doesn't mean they want his finger on the proverbial button, and they are supporting Clinton or Obama instead.
I've never served, so how can I know what constitutes fitness for Commander-in-Chief? But these senior officers sure think they know - and they know McCain's Brain is not fit to serve:
"I like McCain. I respect McCain. But I am a little worried by his knee-jerk response factor," said retired Maj. Gen. Paul Eaton, who was in charge of training the Iraqi military from 2003 to 2004 and is now campaigning for Clinton. "I think it is a little scary. I think this guy's first reactions are not necessarily the best reactions. I believe that he acts on impulse."
Well, if McCain's Brain is "a little scary" for a Major General, what level of terror ought it provoke in those whose jobs don't include "people trying to kill me with guns and bombs and missiles"?
Hey, how does McCain's Brain look to senior officers from the service in charge of blowing up the world - the Air Force?
"I studied leadership for a long time during 32 years in the military," said retired Air Force Maj. Gen. Scott Gration, a one-time Republican who is supporting Obama. "It is all about character. Who can motivate willing followers? Who has the vision? Who can inspire people?" Gration asked. "I have tremendous respect for John McCain, but I would not follow him."
Well, at least McCain's Brain doesn't scare him - but he also finds McCain lacking in capacity to command. Not so good in a prospective C-in-C.
Maybe Professor Lieven and I have it all wrong - what we see as instability is just the Right Stuff to be a fighter pilot. Sadly, no:
"One of the things the senior military would like to see when they go visit the president is a kind of consistency, a kind of reliability," explained retired Gen. Merrill McPeak, a former Republican, former chief of staff of the Air Force and former fighter pilot who flew 285 combat missions. McPeak said his perception is that Obama is "not that up when he is up and not that down when he is down. He is kind of a steady Eddie. This is a very important feature," McPeak said. On the other hand, he said, "McCain has got a reputation for being a little volatile." McPeak is campaigning for Obama.
Hey - maybe we civvies and the flyboys just don't understand Naval culture. Maybe what seems like brain dysfunction to me is part of the fierce independence prized in command level officer in the Navy.
Uh, no:
Retired Rear Adm. John Hutson, who has been a Republican his entire adult life, but who now supports Obama, put it this way about facing a national security crisis: "When everybody else goes nuts, the president of the United States needs to get cooler and cooler."
Remember, these are just the senior officers who spoke on the record.
Why bother to look at this? Am I just taking an elderly man who served his country for decades and dragging his reputation through the mud? Don't we all know men who - as they have aged - have grown more irascible over time? Who would want to hear their father's - or their grandfather's - temperament and brain function dissected before the nation?
Unless Jenna and not-Jenna have dropped some kids they're hiding, no American has a grandfather who can launch nuclear weapons. Senator McCain doesn't deserve criticism for his advanced age or his brain dysfunction. Anyone with brain dysfunction so severe as to compromise their behavior deserves our pity. Yet Senator McCain has fought his way before us for an election, which is merely an elaborate job interview - he doesn't deserve the job just because he wants it. The power of the Office of the President includes the power to lay waste to our planet in a matter of minutes - and Senator McCain's military peers think he's unfit for command.
As every parent knows, none of us are born with the complement of neurons we need for self control. Over the first two decades of life, we slowly develop the neuronal systems that allow us to decide whether we will - or won't - take action when we're enraged or frustrated. This built-in emotional dampening allows us to pause and consciously decide what actions to take.
The fancy psychiatric term for the symptom of "emotions swinging out of control" is "labile". The underlying cause of "labile" is an impairment of CNS function (insufficient inhibitory activity in the CNS). Insufficient CNS inhibitory function is normative in females until sometime in adolescence, and males up until their mid 20's (ever wonder why medieval history is so entertaining?). However, even military fighter pilots find McCain is too dysinhibited for prime time.
After we hit our mid 20's we start a slow downhill slide in neuronal function. Like other hills, the farther up the neuron slope we start, the farther we have to coast. Alcohol, head injury (even one), severe stress (including PTSD), toxins (including some forms of chemo) and ionizing radiation (like that used for some cancer radiotherapies) accelerate the trip. If we're lucky, we cross the finish line of the slide - death - with sufficient neuronal function to keep us and those around us happy and safe, and to be able to know that.
Sadly for him, Senator McCain has a documented history of conditions known to cause CNS injury (repeated blows to the head in boxing/ heavy alcohol use/ torture /severe stress from imprisonment) as well as possible exposure to chemotherapy and radiation therapy.
Loss of neuronal function affects not only self-control, but also comprehension.
Impaired CNS inhibitory function greatly diminishes comprehension of even mildly complex situations. Thinking about complex stuff requires not only sustained attention (compromised in diminished inhibitory function), but also the capacity to tolerate the frustration inherent in confronting discordant possibilities (also compromised in diminished inhibitory function).
For these reasons, McCain's repeated bizarre mangling of basic information - together with his documented history of severely impaired impulse control - suggest that McCain's neuronal function impairs his capacity to comprehend complex realities. With advanced age, cognitive dysfunction as severe as Senator McCain evinces tends to grow worse with each passing year - as does the severity of the emotional lability which so troubles senior military officers.
Sadly for Senator John McCain, he's exhibited labile mood for decades - and advancing age tends to accelerate neuronal death, further compromise inhibitory cerebral function, and hence lead to more severe emotional dysfunction.
In the Oval Office, progressively worsening intellectual comprehension and emotional dysfunction would not merely be sad - but catastrophic.
A planet's a terrible thing to waste - especially when we only have one.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
so
What’s up, Doc?
There is no doubt, I used to be a lot better arguer than I am now!
Hi Dr Kirk! Hiya y’all!
McCain is crazier than Bush I think.
Wow, this is scary!
Cassero, how’s it in the desert?
Heard on Thom Hartmann’s show: one day after Vice Criminal Cheney visited Saudi Arabia, Deutsche Presse-Agentur reports that the Saudi Shura council is discussing means for dealing with radioactive fallout following the U.S. use of nuclear weapons in Iran.
So basically this latest neocon Mideast tour wasn’t simply to introduce the McCain/Liebermann ticket to the regional heads of state, but also to socialize the news that the U.S. is getting ready to initiate a nuclear war with Iran.
And familiar.
Anyone who can say this after 7 years of Bush-Cheney is talking about seriously scary.
very windy! but things are good here. But I miss my friends at home.
Hi SnarKassandra - how great to see you here!
And I fear your assessment is accurate: McCain indeed seems to be even more impaired than Bush.
Hope life in you new home is treating you well.
Hi Karen! Long time no see…
Anyway, while reading this post, I figured out the perfect Republic ticket: McCain/Bolton.
i really would like them to release his medical records.
Hi Dr Kirk!
KO is on this topic.
Aloha, Cassie! It refreshing to see the youth grasp that notion…! 8-)
KO time!!!!
McInsane isn’t going to be able to keep from melting down on camera. Then the MSM won’t be able to deny the fact that he is unfit for command. He shouldn’t be serving in the US congress let alone be a candidate for president. I wouldn’t trust him with my dog.
Gasp!!!!!
We need links that substantiate that. If true, all bets are off. He must be impeached immediately….Conyers and others would if the info is true. This needs to be drilled down, pronto.
Albatross, after reading chris floyd’s post (courtesy of a link from another commenter at the Lake), I’m convinced Boosh will attempt to proceed with Iran War.
And I still think Cassie has it right: McCaquickin’s even worse off.
Time to finish up my post on “Defend America: Mutiny”. I hope there’s still time.
Among the saddest aspect of this is how MSM has willingly served to normalize departures from reality so severe as to meet criteria for psychotic: not merely form Bush/Mc Cain, but also from the global warming deniers and all the serial posioners from Big Ag/Big Chem who come out to tell us Toxic Sludge is Good For Us.
Kirk, this is an outstanding analysis.
This is why Lieberman and Graham follow him wherever he goes. To keep him on an even keel. (And cover up for him when he mistakes Purim for Halloween)
John McCain is an over-the-hill, delusional, loose-ruddered looney.
Oh, and have I mentioned that John McCain supports torture of human beings by the United States of America?
And that his BFF is Joey “Short Ride” Lieberman?
Case closed.
Yes, wobbly - as would I. He released tham in 2000 (for medical review) as has had serious medical lproblems /treatmetn since then. The valid need McCain’s campaign saw in 2000 is only greater now: release the treatment records to the public.
ALso, McCain’s brain dysfunction is so severe that the only he could dispel these concerns would be to undergo neuropsych testing at a major academic med center (outside of the DC / NYC /Boston “powerbelt”) and release the results the public.
_ _ _
Linky for Chris Floyd’s piece.
_ _ _
error correction from 20: And I still think Cassie has it right: McCain’s even worse off.
No word games with his name intended - I typo’d again.
Thanks, LS. I”m glad to see from Raven’s comment that KO is on the same subject.
I’ve been working on the piece for a few weeks: as a doc, I take no joy in publicly depicting how an elderly man’s brain is functioning too poorly for him to be hired.
I so wish our MSM (with rare exceptions) showed up to do work, rather than kiss ass and please power. Though McCaiin’s severe dysfunction has been obvious to docs, the Salon piece made it obvious even to mainstream journalists.
Yet (save for exceptions like KO): crickets.
Is he crazy or senile?
Yes
Thank you, Kirk. I always look forward to your posts. I appreciate the research you did for this.
Cheney and his NeoCon gang think they have it covered. Let McCain run and if he wins it’s a slam dunk. If he loses, nuke Iran and declare a national emergency and suspend the Constitution. Either way, Iran gets blown back to the beginning of time. If the initial blast doesn’t kill them, the fallout will.
The NeoCons have become embolden again. Their arrogance is greater than ever. They are giddy in panel presentation these days and AEI is getting more air time than ever. It isn’t that C-SPAN is favoring them; it’s that they are the ones being called upon for their “expertise” on the Middle East, particularly, Iran. Where are the other voices? Opposing views? Shut out of the dialogue (or should that be monologue).
Having a mentally dysfunctional McCain in the Oval is a perfect cover for the NeoCons nefarious continuation to remake the Middle East in their image.
We need to keep putting this out there so others can take heed and act accordingly.
No chance that he will have the tests done. just the thought of him being in close proximity to any buttons, phones, etc. that could obliterate the world is unsettling to say the least
It always astounds me that journalists, who have family, aren’t making sure that candidates have sound minds before covering it up or ignoring it. The country in the hands of a person with McCain’s obvious problems could end the world as we know it, so to speak.
I must say, though, that Cheney might do it before McCain even gets to an election the way things are going….smoke and mirrors 24/7/365 with these people.
the Doc is teh funny!!
KO….IS THE BEST bar none…thanx Dick!!!
Doc,
your analysis is invaluable. Thank you!
McCain’s Brain - Unfit For Command, Or Merely Incontinent?
one of the nastiest and funniest comments ever!
Probably not senile. But he does seem to have a world view that is not healthy. JMO.
What’s up, Doc?
O/T Hope you pups have some floatees on hand
Vast antarctic ice shelf on the verge of collapse –
Do you think they should have an intelligence test and a sanity test for anyone who wants to be President?
I left some comments on McCain’s economic delusions under the post
“Just What DID Trigger That Investigation of Spitzer?”
The dude will be dangerous in economics also. He lied when he said he didn’t know much about economics. From what I have read the last few days, McCain does not know one single solitary thing about economics at all. Except that I think he knows that you need to have a lot of scratch to get what you want -I am sure he has that part down.
And now it appears that he is under the influence of some ultra free marekt nutjobs, like Steve Forbes, who are saying suffocating and rigid govenment regulation is what caused the current financial panic.
McCain will be a disaster and dangerous to life and limb in economics and finance as well as foreign policy.
I guess we will find out how little he knows about anything in the coming months and our jobs will be to make sure we warn everyone who will be misled by the corporate media. It is becoming apparent that McSame McCain’s only real knowledge is in the departments of self-promotion and aggresive manipulation of those whose support he needs (foremost, the press and his financial backers).
I love that picture of McCain– he looks like some character on the scifi channel. I have a similar one of Karl Rove.
I have a collection of unflattering pictures of Pukes. Once I printed up a bunch of them like a deck of cards and showed them around at work. Everyone else at work is a conservative. (Practically everyone else in Michigan, outside of Ann Arbor, is a conservative.)
Yes, but it would be hard to get a law like that past the Pukes. It would eliminate most of their candidates!
I have a feeling if John McCrazy becomes the next president he’ll have a teleprompter on wheels wherever he goes. Embarrassing.
Yes.
But who gets to write and administer the test?
typo alert kirk;
“give” should obviously be “given”
I think McCain is either dim witted… ie below normal intelligence or had some sort of brain injury which impaired his brain, or both.
He has no moral compass. But that seems to be normal for republicans.
Hi Miss Snarky! How’s it all going. Got a *boy* you’re stringing along? How are your classes? So wonderful to see you, sweets.
Great post Kirk .. thank you!
There should be, but many would not qualify.
Bush would fail. Regan would have failed
I think I can best answer that in terms of describing dysfunction (pending release of recent of neuropsych reports).
McCain has a long-term problem with severe emotional instability and impulsive behavior. In the last year (or more) he’s repeatedly shown he is unable to master basic relevant information.
The latter point to a cognitive dysfunction, which appears to be present over a long period. That certainly riases question of what lay peole call senile (the fancy medical word is dementia).
As a shrink, I can’t usefully use the term “crazy” here because it doens’t have a medical definition (no disrespect to you for asking about it, Cassie, but a lot of medicine is using specific precise terms).
One common form of mental illness is psychotic disorders: the conditions (like schizophrenia) where the core symptoms involve profound departures form reality. If Bush really believes the God of the New Testament has told him to go to war in Iraq - or told Bush how great the carnage is - thaen Bush appears to meet criteria for psychosis.
I’m not aware of McCain showning that sort of severe departure from reality over sustained periods. However, he certainly shows repeated episodes of intense emotional symptoms that repeatedly affect his behavior. I do not suggest he has bipolar disorder (”manic-depressive”disorder). However, a subset of patients with severe bipolar disorder in which the symptoms are not controlled will show patterns of symptoms coming during manic episodes in which their irritable or angry moods will come along with diminished impulse control and severe behavioral symptoms. In this repsect, McCain’s symptoms are similar in severity to those seen in some unfortunate patients with poorly controlled severe bipolar disorder.
To clarify, the majority of people with biploar disorde r do not so symptooms as sever as those reporteded observed in McCain.
Another cause for severe symptoms of emotional dyscontrol and behavioral dysinhibtion can be seen in various forms of brain injury - especially frontal lobe injury. Such inijuries may be acute (one big event) or chronic (lots of small events).
Yet all of the former is informed specualtion about hte cause of McCain’s symtpoms - and strictly speaking, ascribing a cause suggests a diagnosis.
In the post above, I’m attempting to describe the symptoms McCain is widely reproted to exhibit - and the fact eh symptos are so severe that senior military officers not only conclud ehe is unfit to command, but are also taking the extraoridainry step of telling the public of their concerns about a fellow warrior.
Regardless of the cause or diagnsotic lable, the fact McCain’s brain functions so poorly should be of concern to every layperson - especially those who vote.
Rachel on KO analyzing McCain’s economic idiocy. Hooray!
Rachel
“McCain has brought shoulder pads and a helmet to a baseball game”!
heheheh McCain’t, i like that
Nancy Reagan has come out in support of McCrazy. Yep! She’s senile too and doesn’t know what she’s doing either! Nice fit, those two.
Thanks perris - I’ll consult the hamsters. Back in a bit!
I wonder if his mental and emotional challenge will make it into the MSM? I’ve never heard any mention of it aside from at FDL.
OK, so a really good debater should be able to totally destroy him, right?
Do you think they should have an intelligence test and a sanity test for anyone who wants to be President?
who administers the test? Anthony Scalia?
ya gotta trust the voters, there is no alternative
oh jeebus,….mebbe she will have his chart done…
yes
Hiya Loo Hoo.
Dr Kirk, does McCain have PTSD from being tortured?
OMG, showing Nancy and John. . .
Nancy Reagan has INJESTED herself …it seems
Rachel Maddow is great. She’s making the point about McCain in the same way I think of him, meaning, when he was a POW he decided to in Vietnam because he didn’t want to leave his buddies behind and he’ll do the same thing in Iraq…he’ll stay there to give the impression he’s being noble. To me, he’s scary.
She’ll do it with crayons too so he’ll understand it better. LOL
Dr. Murphy,
1) Great post!
2) (regarding your comment 49) I highly recommend you use preview! :)
I would think it would be from the sum of his experiences. When he got shot down he was beaten badly and then spent years in captivity. (please spare me a lecture on how he deserved it)
hahahahaha
OK, so a really good debater should be able to totally destroy him, right?
reply
if debates played any role we would be at the end of Gore’s second term and debating whether we should go with Lieberman or nominate someone else.
Off topic.
Seriously off topic.
I just posted some pix to my facebook page!
Good point
Can you tell me how he deserved in a non-lecture?
Nancy looks like a white chocolate tootsie pop,without the good taste,did i just really type that?
“As every parent knows, none of us are born with the complement of neurons we need for self control.” ~ Dr. Kirk
My mother would agree with you here. ;-)
Great post by the way. You’ve made it perfectly clear that McCrazy can’t be trusted for more than one reason.
That would hardly be even debatable…
cool easter eggs. Did you paint them?
masterpiece theatre…hahahahahaha
There are people who feel that he deserved what he got because he was engaged in an immoral war. That, by logical extension, would include everyone who served. Also, that theory can be applied to everyone who paid taxes or didn’t actively resist the war.
KO, must read FDL, he’s about to talk about the C-in-C test, at least the threshold…!
What DO they do to war tax resisters?
Billo lost it
hahahaha
But the soldiers are NOT the ones that declare war. They get SENT places.
Ever since the day she motioned Darth Cheney away from her as she was standing next to Reagan The Crazy’s casket, I get the feeling she’s nervous about being associated with the Reagan Crazies in the current White House. She now looks like she’s seen a ghost every time she’s in public. She’s scared I tell ya! I’m sure she got the 3am phone call from Darth this morning that started with, “You listen here you old goat, either you support McCain or you’ll never see the light of day…”.
New Obama Girl Video. It rocks.
KO is so happy…i love him muchy
scary, kirk–
so does the fall in neuron function increase exponentially as he ages? time wise?
============
and someone on the radio said his medical records released were 1,000 pages long, and that that was a lot, but i thought it wasn’t so many for a man who has had health problems……and especially if you add in his early records.
how far back do the released records go?
==========
my new nickname for him is–
stutter-brain mccain
or
scatter-brain mccain
but i’m a scatter-brain, so think i’ll not use that one.
===========
cspan watchers-
and senator hagel/ret jan ’09, met with admiral fallon for two hours, so keep an eye on what he says and does…….was on diane rehm today, but wouldn’t reveal anything.
You are preaching to the choir kiddo. Look up “sanctimonious” .
If McCain were senile or has some deterioration of the brain that often appears in the very elderly, he would come off more like Reagan especially in his last four years. Chemo brain is very different. It’s usually described by patients as feeling their brain is sluggish (something is gumming up the works). McCain has something else and given his behavior has been volatile all his life. This is exacerbating his condition.
There are many elderly people not like McCain: Jimmy Carter, Dalai Lama, Maya Angelou, Lily Tomlin, to mention a few.
Rather than McCain’s age, the focus would best be on his mental state.
Although testing for emotional lability is really challenging (it requires repated observations over time), testing for cognitive function is quite do-able.
At UCLA (and other major med centers), the psychologists were quite well-versed in adminsitering day-long tests of cognitive function. THe instruments used are quite well-established and valid. These assessments ( a subset of neuropscyh testing) have very high “inter-rater reliability” - afancy way of saying that the same instrument (test) used in differnt traianed hands reveals the same results.
Yet just as people were squicky abot cancer fifty years ago and squciky about heart disease a century ago, our culture is currently squciky about publicly discussing the organ known as the brain.
Funny thing - we’re given breathless dtails of Presidential colon polys, but even Bush doesn’t really think with is intestine.
Yet - cultrually - our media don’t even attmept to call for objective tests of relevant brain function.
To me, brains are just another organ - and we voters deserve to know about brain function in all candiates for President, Vice President, Cabinet, Senator, or Federal Judge. The same power structure is happy with cops and firegifghter and soldiers having to have assessments of organ function to have FEdral employment. IF it’s good enough for the rest of us, why should our servants -’our Federal leaders - be so fucking special?
WIth that information, we voters could make far better informed decisons.
If the precious cndidates for Power don’t like it, they can always not run for office or decline the nomination for Cabinet /Judiciary ? Veep, etc. THey’re our servants - time to remind them.
KO with the Presidential Threshold Test.
Personally, I think his mental state is effecting him. He can’t do a speech without a teleprompter which tells me his short term memory is busted. Is that what we want for 4 years in the White House? I don’t. And yes, his age has something to do with his mental capacity and add his time as a POW and his chemotherapy on top of it, well, I’m scared of him. LOL
O/T
zipper to the bunghole ??? LMAO funny segment, Keith
You are absolutely correct. Sadly, the same fingers that produce the typos mangle the corrections.
That’s why - based on objective function - I shold never be considered as a surgeon. (In fact, I considered family practice before I figure dout I was too klutzy to suture).
I hope one day we’ll select Presidnets with no more negligence that currently used to select docs for speciality training. One bad surgeon can only kill dozens. OONe bad prez will kill billions.
(butthis doesn’tt excuse my sucky typping)
Keith will have a special show Sunday at 7:00 eastern!!
oooh special KO show on Sunday
jinx
Bye for now. I will be back in a few days. I might even update my blog once in a while with real content and not easter eggs.
Yep - if they push his frustration buttons, we could see a melt-down in real time.
McCain isn’t very old in the scheme of things. With McCain, it isn’t because he got older he is this way, he was like this when he was very young. The major difference is now he is in a position of power and can do some long reaching serious damage to many rather than just be obnoxious to his family.
I wouldn’t want Mohammed Ali as president either. Boxing can do some serious brain damage as can football.
It’s OK Kirk. Everyone knows you can’t read a doctor’s writing, why should their typing be any better?
Kirk,
Do you know Nicki Shouse at ucla?
experimental neuropsychologist.
teehee
I’m gearing up for part 2 of the PBS special tonight