looseheadbetter20.thumbnail.jpg

This time of year we get to celebrate Emptywheel's birthday. I have wracked my brain about what to get her and finally came up with the perfect thing, a timeline!

July 2007 - North Fork Bank sends a suspicious activity report (SAR) involving Eliot Spitzer to the Treasury Department. No action is taken by Treasury.

August 2007 - Roger Stone is approached by federal agents in the wake of the message left on Bernard Spitzer's voice mail in August, a source with knowledge of the matter said. Stone denies leaving the message and declines to meet with the FBI.  It is unclear what information his lawyer gives to the FBI at this time.

October/Early fall 2007 - HSBC bank sends SARs to Treasury about two shell companies, QAT International and QAT Consulting Group, which triggers an IRS investigation of these companies. In the course of the investigation, the July SAR on Spitzer is rediscovered. It has not yet been publicly reported when in the course of this investigation the Spitzer connection became apparent.

November 19, 2007 - Roger Stone (a Republican dirty trickster hired by NYS Senate Majority Leader Joe Bruno to fight back against Spitzer when Spitzer accused Bruno of using a NYS plane to fly to fundraising events) has his lawyer sent a letter to the NY field office of the FBI.

In a Nov. 19 letter, an attorney for Roger Stone, once a consultant to Republican State Senate Majority Leader Joseph Bruno, said Spitzer had spent "tens of thousands" of dollars on prostitutes using prearranged financial transfers.

"It is also my client's understanding ... that Governor Spitzer did not remove his mid-calf length black socks during the sex act," wrote attorney Paul Rolf Jensen of Costa Mesa, Calif., to special agents in the FBI's New York field office. "Perhaps you can use this detail to corroborate Mr. Stone's information."

NB- Although much has been made about allegations that Spitzer tried to structure 3 wire transfers amounting to approximately $10,000 so that none of them would trigger the $10,000 reporting requirement, that is a misstatement of the law. Checks and wire transfers generate their own paper trail and therefore do not trigger a currency transaction report. Even the former officials of the Comptroller of the Currency (who as you will see below has every reason to bury Spitzer) admit as much.

The requirement to report such large transactions applies only to currency transactions — “the coin and paper money of the United States” — not to wire transactions of the sort that Mr. Spitzer allegedly made, Mr. Serino said.

January 8, 2008 - SDNY Judge Haight issues a wiretap warrant to intercept calls to and from the Emperor's club.

January 23, 2008 - SDNY Judge Sand extends the warrant to cover an additional phone number.

January 25, 2008 - SDNY magistrate Judge Gorenstein issues warrants to obtain email messages.

February 7, 2008 - The wiretap warrant expires.

February 11, 2008 - The wiretap warrant is renewed by SDNY Judge Lynch.

February 11, 2008 around 11PM - [Warning: very long pdf]  One of the Emperor's Club managers sent a text message to another Emperor's club manager asking if client 9's package had arrived in the mail. It is unlikely that this text message, even if it mentioned Spitzer by name, is the reason Judge Lynch renewed the wiretap warrant as he was likely home for the day at that hour.

February 12, 2008 - [long pdf] Much texting among Emperor's Club managers about the impending arrival of Client 9's payment.

February 13, 2008 - [long pdf] "Kristen" travels to DC for appointment with Spitzer.

February 14, 2008 right after midnight - [long pdf] "Kristen" calls one of the Emperor's Club managers and they engage in a conversation that, at least on the manager's side of it, appears to be scripted to include as many humiliating details as possible.

February 14, 2008 - Eliot Spitzer publishes an Op-Ed in the Washington Post excoriating Bushco for enabling and protecting banks that engage in predatory lending practices and using the office of the Comptroller of the Currency to block the efforts of State Attorneys General form all 50 states to protect their citizens from these predatory lenders. It was titled :

Predatory Lenders' Partner in Crime

How the Bush Administration Stopped the States From Stepping In to Help Consumers

You should read it.

Question: How long before Feb. 14 did Spitzer turn in his draft to WaPo? And did WaPo leak its contents to ..... anyone?

Ask Joe Wilson what happens to people who write Op-Eds accusing Bushco of wrongdoing. 

March 4, 2008 - Spitzer introduces a bill to make it more difficult for banks to foreclose on mortgages and to crack down on some predatory lending practices. It would be a bill that any NYS legislator would find difficult to publicly oppose.

March 5, 2008 [very long pdf] - A sealed complaint is filed pertaining to four members of the Emperor's Club prostitution ring.

March 6, 2008 - the Comptroller of the Currency (who evidently cannot command an OpEd of his own) writes a letter to the editor of the WaPo denying the charges made in Spitzer's Feb 14th OpEd.

March 6, 2008 [short pdf] - The Emperor's Club defendants are arrested and SDNY US Attorney issues a press release about the arrests and posts a copy of the complaint on his website.

March 7, 2008 - A reporter at the NYTimes Metro Desk got a "tip" that a john in room 871 of a Washington Hotel as described in the federal indictment of a prostitution ring was a "New York Official." March 7th was a Friday.

March 10, 2008 - NYTimes reports that Spitzer is linked to a prostitution ring. Spitzer cancels his public schedule and holes up with his advisors. March 10th is Monday.

March 11, 2008 - Spitzer holds a press conference saying that he has betrayed his own, and anyone else's, standards for behavior.

March 13, 2008 - Spitzer resigns.

March 14, 2008 - NYTimes reports that feds are now looking into Spitzer's campaign expenditures to see if any campaign money was used in connection with the trysts. Why? Because unless Spitzer tried to evade the $10K reporting requirement in a cash transaction, the only way he can be guilty of "structuring" is if the money that was being structured is itself the proceeds of an illegal activity--like a violation of campaign finance laws.

As I relayed to you previously the feds have submitted an affidavat swearing that all the money was Spitzer's personal funds. They are now apparently trying to disprove their own sworn document.

March 17, 2008 - David Paterson is sworn in as NY State's Governor. State Senate Majority Leader Joe Bruno becomes next in line of succession. There is no provision in the NYS Constitution to appoint or elect someone to fill out Paterson's term as Lt. Gov.

March 18, 2008 - Paterson and his wife admit they dated (and apparently slept with) other people during a period when they were separated and believed themselves to be headed toward divorce.

March 21, 2008 - NYTimes does an article detailing the unusual amount of resources devoted to this case and the ways in which this case appears to be a departure from normal DOJ and SDNY practices.

March 22, 2008 - Paterson reimburses his campaign for two hotel stays.

March 24, 2008 - The NYPost questions Patersons' decision to sleep in Albany capital area hotels.

It begins to look like someone is trying to hound Paterson into resigning, thereby making Republican Joe Bruno the Governor of NY State?  The voters of NY State elected Democrats Spitzer and Paterson by a resounding majority, nearly 70% of the vote, it is certainly not the will of the people to have a Republican in this office. 

It is curious to note how quickly the Spitzer investigation was concluded, probably because so many resources were thrown at it.  It is also curious to note that someone seems to be spoon feeding reporters the information they need to home in on all of Paterson's hotel bills. Hmmm?

Yet the investigation into allegations that Bruno has spent the entire Bush Administration steering union pension money into an investment fund that has him on the payroll, seems to proceed at a pace most charitably described as languorous.  

photo by crazyneighborlady