Ah, the Kagans America's First Family of War Mongerers (okay, second family) -- they're like the Flying Wallendas of Wankery and criminal appeasement.
Asked on PBS’s The Charlie Rose Show earlier this week about “how fragile” the surge in Iraq is, surge architect and American Enterprise Institute “military analyst” Frederick Kagan declared that “the situation in Iraq today is, I think, not that fragile.” He then added that he believed Iraq would be “fragile” if America made “the mistake of pulling out prematurely.” ...
This, of course, contradicts Iraqi Jesus,:
Kagan’s bold claim about the surge’s lack of fragility is directly contradicted by Gen. David Petraeus, the top U.S. commander in Iraq, who told CBS News this week that “while military progress has been made with a ’surge’ of U.S. forces, ‘progress in Iraq is fragile, it is tenuous.’”
In fact, the very next day following Kagan’s remarks, the Guardian reported on one key aspect of the surge’s strategy that is quite fragile: the reliabilty of U.S. alliances with Sunni militia. The report noted that “Sunni militia employed by the US to fight al-Qaida are warning of a national strike because they are not being paid regularly”
Of course, what Kagan said fits what Dick Cheney says to a "T" -- a wet-t. Let's pause to consider shall we?
Kagan likely did not notice this, but in the land of the mighty surge and the great stability:
As many as 20 mortar shells were fired Sunday at the heavily fortified Green Zone, one of the fiercest and most sustained attacks on the area in the last year...
No Americans were killed in the shelling on Sunday, officials said, but mortar shells that fell short of their target killed 13 Iraqis in neighborhoods east of the Green Zone. The first attack, about 6 a.m., sent thunderous booms echoing across the city, shaking buildings and rattling windows.
Although the source of the attacks could not be determined conclusively, two witnesses said the early-morning rounds were fired across the river from the Shiite-dominated Baladiyat neighborhood by militia men who the witnesses believed belonged to the Mahdi Army of the Shiite cleric Moktada al-Sadr.
Yet another sign that the "ceasefire" largely responsible for the drop in deaths from the apocalyptic levels of 2007 to the merely catastrophic levels of 2005 in recent months is ending.
Granted 20 mortar shells toward the Green Zone seems like a pretty big deal, but I've had Republicans tell me Baghdad's doing better at reconciling than Washington, D.C. so I imagine 20 mortars get lauched toward the Capital Complex all the time, right? I don't know for sure, I live in Des Moines and our capital only gets hit up by mortars or RPG's rarely, every couple of weeks tops. But when you are spending $150 billion annually on something as awesome as the Iraqi Occupation you always get more bangs for your borrowed bucks.
Four U.S. soldiers were killed when a bomb hit their vehicle in south Baghdad late Sunday, bringing the number of U.S. service members killed in the Iraq war to 4,000.
The grim milestone came at a time when attacks against the U.S. military are ebbing and officials have claimed significant progress against Iraq's deadly insurgency and sectarian violence. It was reached about 10 p.m. on a day when more than 60 Iraqis were killed and dozens injured in attacks in Baghdad and north of the capital.
Last month deaths in Iraq leaped 20% from the month before. In March, those deaths have already nearly equaled February's total six days earlier.
Yet it is hard to penetrate the shells of cable news talkers over the occasional badly edited sermon by a black minister, that the awesome surge has accomplished so little despite the best efforts of badly used and exhausted American soldiers. Besides John McCain says it's awesome no matter how much he screws up the facts, and his barbecue is delicious and he only makes the occasional racial slur. It's all good to American media -- to the press of countries not so beholden to their corporate overlords? Not so much.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight


Support this site!
Keep
up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

RSS/XML Feed
4000!!!
It’s just a number…
…with a comma.
It’s plural, not a possessive - Kagans, not Kagan’s….
commas matter too
Right you are.
Now I’m going to have my coffee.
Front page NYT online
when is it all going to end Attaturk?
Here are some posters made for the third anniversary of the war when there were about 2350 killed and it was One Trillion Dollars. Only the numbers have changed.
.
btw Phil Donahue is on Q&A with Brian Lamb on CSPAN 1 right now, discussing Body of War, just started.
People are broke. The Iraq war is costing north of 12 billion a month–in borrowed Chinese dollars. McCain is on record as saying he doesn’t fully understand the economy. He’s running on Bush’s foreign policy. If the Democrats lose this one, they suck.
Good morning, pups. It’s [gag] Kristol, Cohen and Krugman in the NYT today. That creature Kristol has typed a fetid little thing called “Let’s Not, and Say We Did.” He claims ambitious men sometimes do a disservice to the best in their own communities, and Barack Obama is an ambitious man. If you loved him on Iraq, you’ll love him even more on race. Mr. Cohen writes about “A Second Life in Champagne,” and about tumult and equilibrium: it is not easy to marry images of devastation and death on the one hand, patient purpose on the other. Mr. Krugman’s column is titled “Taming the Beast,” and he says both Democratic candidates have been disappointingly quiet about the need to reform our out-of-control financial system.
http://mgpaquin.wordpress.com/
The coffee, tea and hot chocolate are ready, and the biscuits are out of the oven. 303 more days of W — we’re almost into the 200s. Let’s pray that the light at the end of the tunnel isn’t an oncoming train. Have a great day.
“Failure is not an option”
It’s a standard feature with this Administration
This morning on NPR.
Troops are being brought down by about 35,000 per month but the military are not going to be taking soldiers out after August…. so Apr. May. Jun. Jul. = (4X35) 140,000. Then they will have just 135,00 troops left. Thanks NPR that was informative. But….
Does this mean we have 275,000 troops in there now? NOooooo. It means we take out 35,000 per month and replace them with…..35,000 per month! resulting in 140,000 troops there in August. WTF.
Morning Attaturk
anyone, I mean ANYONE
oops, hit enter with my thumb
anyway what I was trying to say is that was trying to get us to attack iraq needs to be laughed at, laughed in the face whenever they say anything that indicates anything at all about iraq
This is a perfect synopsis of the current media cycle. And there seems to be no end in sight. Throughout the primaries and debates I was struck again and again (not that I should have been) by how effortlessly the words, “since the surge is working,” or, “now that the stability of Iraq is not an issue,” fell out of the mouths of America’s frontmen like Brian Williams and Tom Browkaw. As if it were fact, a priori, no need for actual discussion on that point.
I was reminded this weekend with one of the FDL front page posters including a link to Eric Boehlert’s Lapdogs, just how pathetic the media performed in the run up to the quagmire. Chris Mathews (he of the, “Chill runs up my leg when Obama speaks.”) is characterized as a good soldier, taking his marching orders and spouting the rhetoric directly from the White House press office. The rest of the media congregation is participatory in allowing entire press conferences to be blatantly scripted in favor of keeping the fool in the highest office from having to answer any tough questions. It was pathetic.
And it continues today with little push back except from the blogs. Thank you for that, Attaturk.
Good morning, and good luck!
Washington Journal this morning:
7:30am - Alex Pollock, American Enterprise Institute, Resident Fellow [this would be Freddie Kagan’s wingnut welfare agent]
8:30am - Roger Wilkins, George Mason University, History Professor - A Forty Year Update of the National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorder (pdf warning)
9:30am - Newspaper Articles & Viewer Calls
.
and then at 10:00 am, CSPAN 1 is covering
Africom Today:
Imus is killing the admin and the war. . .oh. WE don’t like Imus. Sorry.
The irony of Bill Kristol’s own ambition is that he continues to endeavor for his words to have meaning, even after the experiment he and his brethren in the PNAC have embarked upon has been show, and even in this narrow slice of history, to have been one of the great debacles of the 21st century.
But his words have no meaning. When the man uses the term ambition, he does so incorrectly. When he attempts to make application of his previously ill defined definition, he does so with equal ham-fisted inability. He is a man who has been given credit for having control of words and concepts and forming them to make meaning; but, he has been given that credit by fools and he was foolish enough, himself, to believe it.
A better critic of the human condition, with far more capability with words once said:
George Bernard Shaw
Kristol is the embodiment of that nature except that his ideas fail even at making progress.
Rarely is it asked, “Is our surge working?”
Even racist pricks get some things right.
That should read racist, misogynist pricks
How long will it be before the MSM starts harping on the concept that the increase in violence in Iraq means we have to have McCain as president? I’m betting on sometime around June or July.
The war is unjust. The perps are not the American people. We are among the victims. An election was stolen from us, people were criminally negligent on 9/11, we were lied into a war, hundreds of thousands Iraqis are dead and maimed, 4,000 young Americans will never again see their family or friends.
The best foreign policy America can have is to bring the perps to justice. Let the world see we are a nation of laws and righteous people. If we cannot clean our own house, we are unworthy of the sacrifice of brave Americans who have given their lives for their country.
Good morning everyone. Nice post Attaturk. Iraq isn’t fragile…it’s destroyed already! The Bush Regime and their cohorts can’t see the forest through the trees and like to keep telling themselves the forest is beautiful.
The surge thing is a logical trap. If it is working then they would have to begin packing up and leaving wouldn’t they? If it is not working then they would have to carry on the escalation or escalate it more.
It is so obvious that Americans are the victims of consensus makers called “the media”. This has nothing to do with truth or facts. It is simply the narrative to justify whatever those in power want to do. And they drown us with prevaricators to bury the truth.
The truth does not have sides like left and right.
The truth is.
I’m glad I brought it up.
I am like the shark and the chum. I couldn’t resist!
My recent comments have all be lost in moderation for some reason unknown to me. Is this a common occurrence: moderation without notification?
Good morning Nomolos! Cold where you are this morning? Bitter cold here. I wonder if I could buy a blade of grass to remind myself what one looks like? Huh. I wonder. ;-)
Oh I bet we’re in a much more tragically increased news cycle. I’m predicting we’ll make the May Day military celebrations of cold war Soviet Union a run for their money. If the Rovian policy of, “Lie it big and lie it often,” has time to work its evil magic, it’s going to need that extra percolation period.
Yea, well all I hear is whining about the MSM giving Bush a pass on the war and Imus doesn’t do that. IMO he is also attempting to engage in the conversation about race that we all say we want.
As I look out the window I see NO SNOW! However the fish pond is a block of ice and there are icebergs along the shore line (low tide). You are still under ten feet of snow I understand. I even saw a hint of crocus in the garden yesterday. Here’s hoping fro spring. Stay warm.
The ROM (republican owned media) is no longer reporting on the illegal occupation of Iraq, because the ROM knows if the images are not being seen the American people will forget about it and they (the Bush Regime) can say what they want about what is going on over there. Spit.
Wha? You got crocuses popping through the ground???!!!! I’m jealous! We’ve got 3 feet of thick icy snow from the house to the fence and the snow along the road out front is still well over 5 feet. Tired of it! I noticed my brand new beeee-u-tee-full fence I had installed last fall is starting to bulge from the weight of the snow. If we don’t get some warm weather soon, the fence will be money down the drain!
true but his approach to the subject was interesting. However having never heard the man I honestly would not know what he talks about.
I have been trying to find out how many funerals our mighty leader has attended but don’t seem to be able to find a record of any attended. Is this a state secret or something?
What I find very disturbing about war is the use, abuse and manipulation of the soldiers. Most of them simply do what they are told and do not even question the underlying motives for their being sent into war.
This is a very difficult postion to be in and demands that people suspend their rational thought and simply focus on some micro task, like driving a humvee or protecting a check point or fueling a plane. Soldiers are not allowed to think about the politics or the social implications about what they are engaged in.
I see this as completely wrong. It’s a kind of imprisonment and loss of freedom. The army takes away your freedom to think and speak out about your thoughts.
While I understand the need for discipline, I also think that ANYONE who does not understand their mission, the over all mission or who does and does not want to participate should be honorably removed from the army and operations.
I see armies as forced labor and it seems terribly anti democratic for a democratic society.
However having never heard the man I honestly would not know what he talks about.
At least you admit it, not so some others here. I salute you.
Wow and I was only a pvt.!
I hadn’t realized he noticed that our soldiers have died! Huh? ;-)
the Flying Wallendas of Wankery and criminal appeasement.
that is a great phrase