The Washington Post's report on Obama's speech observed that this was a controversy that "threatens to engulf his presidential candidacy." Yet as far as anyone can tell, it was having only a marginal effect on the polls in the race before it blew up on the networks, and it was not generated by either of Obama's political opponents, or by any particular interest groups.
No, this is a controversy cooked up almost entirely within the media realm. Once they sank their fangs into it, the whole zombielike corps of pundits, cable talking heads, and radio talk-show hosts couldn't let go of it. And equally remarkable was the bias that was on display in discussing it: News anchors and talking heads flatly referred to the Rev. Jeremiah Wright's videotaped remarks as "anti-American," "hate-filled," "vicious," "offensive," and so on and on.
It's telling that none of them also observed that, for the most part, Wright's remarks (aside from his conspiracist comments about AIDS, which were indeed inexcusable, but which received little or no play before Obama's speech) were factually accurate, and deeply reflective of a reality that most African Americans live with -- and which most white Americans do their best to ignore, deny, and forget. The remarks that were broadcast all over YouTube and replayed endlessly on the cable talk shows were, no doubt, were impolitic, but they were also largely true.
Hacktackular Howie Kurtz, the Post's "media critic," in his column today -- while notably failing to critique the media for its performance -- essentially admitted that this was a media-driven frenzy:
[I]t wasn't until last week, when Fox News and ABC News bought DVDs of Wright's sermons from the church, that the simmering controversy reached full boil. The recordings have long been sold by the church, but journalists did not seek them until now.
Kurtz's description also encapsulates the blinkered bias that was at play in not just the discussion leading up to Obama's speech, but in the general response to it:
To their credit, the network newscasts ran four or five sound bites to evoke Obama's broader argument that while the anger of older blacks like Wright, 66, is understandable, the country needs to move beyond the racial wounds of the past. But Obama, 46, is trying to win the Democratic nomination, so the anchors kept returning to one core question.
"Is it enough to reassure white voters?" ABC's Charlie Gibson asked.
"Does it make too many white voters uncomfortable?" asked CBS's Katie Couric.
Their entire preoccupation, indeed, was with how Wright's remarks might discomfit whites -- while never examining the deeper questions of whether white complacence about race might be something worth challenging, as well as their own roles in failing to make that challenge.
So let's examine the remarks by Wright that whipped up this frenzy. The controversy largely centered around these quotes:
"The government gives them the drugs, builds bigger prisons, passes a three-strike law and then wants us to sing 'God Bless America.' No, no, no, God damn America, that's in the Bible for killing innocent people," he said in a 2003 sermon. "God damn America for treating our citizens as less than human. God damn America for as long as she acts like she is God and she is supreme."
In addition to damning America, he told his congregation on the Sunday after Sept. 11, 2001 that the United States had brought on al Qaeda's attacks because of its own terrorism.
"We bombed Hiroshima, we bombed Nagasaki, and we nuked far more than the thousands in New York and the Pentagon, and we never batted an eye," Rev. Wright said in a sermon on Sept. 16, 2001.
"We have supported state terrorism against the Palestinians and black South Africans, and now we are indignant because the stuff we have done overseas is now brought right back to our own front yards. America's chickens are coming home to roost," he told his congregation.
And there was more outrage over these quotes:
In one sermon in October 2005, Rev. Wright addressed the racial elements at play in the wake of Hurricane Katrina.
"The winds of Katrina blew the cover off America. The hurricane exposed the hypocrisy," Rev. Wright said, "protecting white folks' property took priority over saving black folks' lives." He continued, "This storm called Katrina says far more about a racist government than it does about the wrath of God."
In April 2003, Rev. Wright told his congregation that "the United States government has failed the vast majority of our citizens of African descent."
"For every one Oprah, a billionaire, you've got five million blacks who are out of work," he said. "For every one Colin Powell, a millionaire, you've got 10 million blacks who cannot read. For every one Condoskeeza [sic] Rice, you've got one million in prison. For every one Tiger Woods, who needs to get beat, at the Masters, with his cap-blazing hips, playing on a course that discriminates against women. For every one Tiger Woods, we got 10,000 black kids who will never see a golf course."
What Wright is talking about here, of course, is the long and ugly history of white prejudice against African Americans, a history that continues to this day.
Regardless how much Obama may concede that Wright's language was "anti-American" or "hateful," the reality is they can only be construed as such if one believes that any criticism of the USA, and of prejudiced white Americans particularly, is unpatriotic or vicious. It's akin to the long-running right-wing notion that America is like a beloved mommy, and any criticism of her whatsoever means that you "hate America."
Wright may indeed have been short-sighted in failing to acknowledge that there has been progress made, but the reality is that the progress has not only fallen far short of where we need to be, but white complacence over that progress is itself a significant roadblock for creating a real bridge to cross the nation's racial divide.
The racism he's talking about is the lazy, blinkered notion that somehow whites have already overcome racism -- that they are not responsible for the years of institutional racism, embodied in Jimi Crow, segregation, and the "sundown towns" phenomenon that created the continuing residential and professional segregation that enables young white people to form the networks and connections that are the foundations of economic and social success while leaving young blacks, Latinos, and other minorities out in the cold.
Obama, to his credit, attempted to tackle this in his speech:
Understanding this reality requires a reminder of how we arrived at this point. As William Faulkner once wrote, "The past isn't dead and buried. In fact, it isn't even past." We do not need to recite here the history of racial injustice in this country. But we do need to remind ourselves that so many of the disparities that exist in the African-American community today can be directly traced to inequalities passed on from an earlier generation that suffered under the brutal legacy of slavery and Jim Crow.
Segregated schools were, and are, inferior schools; we still haven't fixed them, fifty years after Brown v. Board of Education, and the inferior education they provided, then and now, helps explain the pervasive achievement gap between today's black and white students.
Legalized discrimination -- where blacks were prevented, often through violence, from owning property, or loans were not granted to African-American business owners, or black homeowners could not access FHA mortgages, or blacks were excluded from unions, or the police force, or fire departments - meant that black families could not amass any meaningful wealth to bequeath to future generations. That history helps explain the wealth and income gap between black and white, and the concentrated pockets of poverty that persists in so many of today's urban and rural communities.
A lack of economic opportunity among black men, and the shame and frustration that came from not being able to provide for one's family, contributed to the erosion of black families -- a problem that welfare policies for many years may have worsened. And the lack of basic services in so many urban black neighborhoods - parks for kids to play in, police walking the beat, regular garbage pick-up and building code enforcement - all helped create a cycle of violence, blight and neglect that continue to haunt us.
Obama is hardly the first major political figure to address this. Back in 1995, President Clinton said something remarkably similar:
The rift we see before us that is tearing at the heart of America exists in spite of the remarkable progress black Americans have made in the last generation, since Martin Luther King swept America up in his dream, and President Johnson spoke so powerfully for the dignity of man and the destiny of democracy in demanding that Congress guarantee full voting rights to blacks. The rift between blacks and whites exists still in a very special way in America, in spite of the fact that we have become much more racially and ethnically diverse, and that Hispanic Americans -- themselves no strangers to discrimination -- are now almost 10 percent of our national population.
The reasons for this divide are many. Some are rooted in the awful history and stubborn persistence of racism. Some are rooted in the different ways we experience the threats of modern life to personal security, family values, and strong communities. Some are rooted in the fact that we still haven't learned to talk frankly, to listen carefully, and to work together across racial lines.
… The two worlds we see now each contain both truth and distortion. Both black and white Americans must face this, for honesty is the only gateway to the many acts of reconciliation that will unite our worlds at last into one America.
White America must understand and acknowledge the roots of black pain. It began with unequal treatment first in law and later in fact. African Americans indeed have lived too long with a justice system that in too many cases has been and continues to be less than just. (Applause.) The record of abuses extends from lynchings and trumped up charges to false arrests and police brutality. The tragedies of Emmett Till and Rodney King are bloody markers on the very same road.
Still today too many of our police officers play by the rules of the bad old days. It is beyond wrong when law-abiding black parents have to tell their law-abiding children to fear the police whose salaries are paid by their own taxes.
And blacks are right to think something is terribly wrong when African American men are many times more likely to be victims of homicide than any other group in this country; when there are more African American men in our corrections system than in our colleges; when almost one in three African American men in their 20s are either in jail, on parole or otherwise under the supervision of the criminal justice system -- nearly one in three. And that is a disproportionate percentage in comparison to the percentage of blacks who use drugs in our society. Now, I would like every white person here and in America to take a moment to think how he or she would feel if one in three white men were in similar circumstances.
And there is still unacceptable economic disparity between blacks and whites. It is so fashionable to talk today about African Americans as if they have been some sort of protected class. Many whites think blacks are getting more than their fair share in terms of jobs and promotions. That is not true. That is not true.
The truth is that African Americans still make on average about 60 percent of what white people do; that more than half of African American children live in poverty. And at the very time our young Americans need access to college more than ever before, black college enrollment is dropping in America.
These are uncomfortable truths, of course, but they are also truths. And the media have as much a role in the failure of white Americans to honestly and forthrightly confront them.
The reason we haven't done so is that we whites have done our damnedest to ignore them. We have effectively wiped the memory of sundown towns from our memories, making us almost purposefully ignorant of them and their surrounding history of ugly violence and vicious bigotry.
Indeed, as we have seen throughout the Obama controversy, the media have been consistent in encouraging white Americans to forget them. Meanwhile, the black people who have to live with these realities cannot.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
I wrote this downstairs but it is more appropriate here
we the people have a race problem, not only the media
I would have never thought it possible but polls are actually revealing McCain beats either and both Hillary and Obama
how is that possible with the most depraved administration in the history of this country?
how is it possible that it is even close?
I speak with democrats all the time and although they find a different excuse to use then bigotry, they will NOT vote for Obama and they will NOT vote for Hillary
we climb uphill and I am only given comfort by the mass of people who are voting in this election vs the republican electorate, however the republicans will energize for the general
we have a climb ahead of us and this is a battle that decides whether or not our republic survives
The MSM simply want to stir up shit, and throw it on any front-runner.
true dat
they want to make their corporate sponsors happy and corporate america is not happy with obama
BTW, interesting. State Dept “contract employees” have been found rooting around in Sheik bin al BaraBlackHusseinMadrassaOsamaBama’s passport file.
unbelievable
Here is the thing. The Secret Service is not supposed to reveal how you get somewhere, when you get somewhere, and what your travel plans are, plus, they make you take alternate routes to any destination.
If the State Department’s Bureau of Consular Affairs is involved, which is where this took place, they are the ones that know what your travel plans are going to be…not where you’ve already been. This is what is so scary about this story.
Ok, so does anyone think this breaking (I think, I just got back from dinner) news is just too “deja vu all over again” (MLK Jr.’s challenges with JEdgar?):
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/obama_passport
(State Dept fires 2 and disciplines one for supposedly “peeking” at Obama’s passport files…)
heya Joey, what BS u gonna dump on us now?
Hi Dave! Excellent post.
Wow, great minds all read the wires at the same time…
completely depressing.
Oh Lord, this is the best Abrams can get ?
Great post, David.
Here’s what Mike Huckabee said about Rev. Wright:
http://blogs.abcnews.com/polit.....efend.html
I thought it was pretty good. Very sincere too.
Yep. It was just mentioned on Abrams show that just LOOKING at the records is a violation of privacy laws.
“imprudent curiosity”
there’s a twist on words.
I must admit that I stand corrected, Joey being cool tonight.
Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton has moved into a significant lead over Barack Obama among Democratic voters, according to a new Gallup poll.
The March 14-18 national survey of 1,209 Democratic and Democratic-leaning voters gave Clinton, a New York senator, a 49 percent to 42 percent edge over Obama, an Illinois senator. The poll has an error margin of 3 percentage points.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/.....92562.html
Mike Huckabee is more sincere than McCain, which is why he lost the Rep nomination …
That is just creepy, spooky, disturbing but overall not surprising given the politicizing of pretty much every damn department and agency
Great post David!
This took up the whole Olbermann time slot. That’s when it broke. The dates are sure supicious. This is are security at it’s best LOL
Even Andrea Mtchell was bearable … must be a a Full Moon … *g*
Great article David!
And its a crime to sit on it this long, may be a crime to fire them before indicting, may be a crime for not indicting 3rd contractor…..
Great post David !!!
I agree that the two speeches are very similar.
tomorrow
I was wondering about this because there was just talk of it being referred only if info is disseminated. I’m glad an atty is speaking on this
The 3rd breach was last Friday.
ahah … I knew it … *g*
I believe the exact point of the full moon is mid-afternoon tomorrow
Do we know why 3 times? Were the records copied? I really want to know all this stuff.
I’m looking at it and it is gorgeous.
This comment cuts right to the bone.
If either of the Democratic candidates said they didn’t know much about economics, but they’re reading a good book about it, and followed that up by flubbing the ‘Al Queda training in Iran’ thing (four times - by the way), they would be laughed out of the race.
And he’s leading?
Come on.
David, Thank you for such an important post. For those who are cable impaired like myself, you can listen to Barack on Larry King Live at www.cnn.com
Number 3 isn’t fired because they suddenly realized it was a crime for them to fire before indicting……….. :)
And the mass-psychotic LeftWingnuttia Dittoheads over at taylormarsh.com are throwin “he’s toast” high fives.
I recommend we see what the numbers look like in May or thereafter.
Can you please explain that. Are you saying that the first two cannot be charged?
These polls are BS.
David, as usual your post was excellent. Thanks.
DiGenova: “Welcome to big government…. When government gets this big, this is inevitable.”
Once in January, once in February, and once last Friday.
They cannot access these files without a special code to go past the warning screen. You can’t just snoop around. You can’t get into the file, period, without a code, and the only people who have those codes are those who are in authority….like a doctor in a hospital for example, but the “secretaries” don’t have the code.
so now obama is no longer presidential huh? hmmm who wudda thunk it…… we are soooo not over race in america no matter how much we say we are….
That means the cat has to stay outside tomorrow night
I’m like you, I figured that all tis ass craziness had to be due to a full moon
My money is on this weekend or Monday hahahahahaha…..
Thanks for the link, JPL
David, thank you for this great post.
Digg!
I wonder if Keith is going to come back on live at 10 rather than rerunning the 8 pm show.
From what I understood, as they are contractors. The supervisors are now culpable…….:)
oh, the US voter has a much shorter attention span than that
and america will go for another rethug and damn the war and economy….
Uh, excuse me. I resemble that remark.
And I loooooooove Taylor Marsh!!!
I think Pres. Pissypants Fisa telecom immunity just went into the toilet.
How could any Senator now want to grant immunity when this just hit the fan?
Number 3 must be twitchy as hell.
just finished reading post and it is fantastic, Dave. Gonna pass this a long to a few folks
3 “mistakes”…one time each month…
Repug Joe DiGenova states that it is an obvious conscious cover-up. Woot!
I guess Dave’s not here.
(Hey, remember that old Cheech and Chong skit?)
It is a proven fact that during the full moon, the Brain holds the highest level of fluids …
The MSM’s gist as I’ve understood it is that “Obama has decided to make race the central issue of the campaign”, which was not his intention, as far as I understand it and which would, in my opinion, doom his candidacy.
As it probably should, because we have urgent issues staring us in the face: war in Iraq, upcoming attack on Iran, collapsing economy, shattering of U.S. society into two classes, the haves and the have-nots. If we don’t solve those issues, it’s going to be years and years before we have the wherewithal to advance social justice.
Is that part of the plan? Impoverish the society to such a degree that there is no money or will to effect improvements in the way we treat the disadvantaged?
The “Obama’s all about race” meme may be the Swift boat of this election.
And what terrifies me is that Cheney may order an attack on Iran in May, and then there may actually be attacks on the continental U.S. in retaliation, with the declaration of a national state of emergency, suspension of the electoral process, and complete consolidation of power and authority in the hands of the Executive. And Cheney would like nothing better than that. Is anyone else thinking this unthinkable thought? Anyone who is in Congress?
Obi’s campaign spokesman Eric Holder is the former deputy AG under Clinton. Innersting
I just threw up in my mouth a little
I can’t stomach her at all talk about biased writing.
Yeah, it’s surprising that he’s that close to being honest, but he did take the step of blaming it on big government.
I don’t love the Osama-Is-The-Devil-Incarnate shit goin’ down over there of late. It just makes McBu’ush more likely as the next president.
I want to know why the breach was admitted to.
Oh crap, they took the word of the supervisors that this was just curiosity? WTF?
What a letdown, going from Keith to Dan …
He truly has more of a personality for sure! Wow. I was really happy to hear Huckabee say what he did.
I think you worry too much, no offense intended. Sure, Cheney might do that shit, but it would only help, not hurt, Obama’s chances.
i didn’t know that. Is there something specific I should be or shouldn’t be doing with so much fluid on the brain? *g*
Taylor has gone whacky… I thing she went off the reservation and she is lurvin all the scores of commentors she has corralled on her site. She’s grovin on attention.
Rev. Wright was a Marine and has six years military service. How many chicken hawks (Carlson, Goldberg, Limbo etc.) have tried to destroy his reputation? He has earned the right to say what he wants. The Government Controlled Tee Vee has not told us that Wright has 7 honorary degrees. This Pastor looks better and better the more I know.
http://www.answers.com/topic/jeremiah-wright
At least Schuster is still on the beat and doing some digging.
I don’t love the
OsamaObama-Is-The-Devil-Incarnate shit goin’ down over there of late. It just makes McBu’ush more likely as the next president.Miss the edit feature.
Huckabee says a lot fo great things … the things he’s against makes him positively dangerous but not more so than McInsane …
And, on the Obama passport thing, my first reaction was that they’re looking for his travels in the Middle East (if any).
All they needed was one long trip to the area and he next would be starring in Al Qaeda training video that coincidentally occurred during that time.
The very sad part is I’m serious.
Wow! Is that true? Bah hahahahahahaha! I hope so!
Well, she is a Hillary supporter! What do you expect? I think she’s fair about it. If you read the comments she corrects her commenters regularly when they go over the line.
We should be able to support our different Democratic candidates and still remain somewhat respectful of each other, don’t you agree? And wobblybits too.
Banned without explanation by MyDD here, a badge of honor.
Sorry, make that “Shuster”
Do whatever your husband asks … **g**
what?! is dan going to talk with all the rethug spokespeople?
This wasn’t cooked up “in the media realm” as opposed to his opponents - the corporate media IS Barack’s opponent. C’mon, people! The media is a right-wing propaganda tool, stop pretending it’s supposed to be impartial or journalistic. Those values are DEAD. We need to recognize the real problem! The corporations own the media, and oppose Barack Obama.
Watching Obama on Larry King. For such a powerful speaker, his interviews lack energy. And he’s less charismatic.
Via Josh at TPM
By Josh Marshall
My bold added.
I have my fingers crossed that the House/Senate members tonight are thinking twice about pushing FISA through with immunity for the telecoms. How could they think that the Bush Regime and their intentions are always legitimized and legal? Jees.
Thanks so much for this great post. I’ve gone back to YouTube to view Barack’s speech in its entirety and was more impressed than ever. I’m pretty much appalled that so many White Americans are offended, nay, outraged, about the anger and resentment that some Black Americans express to each other. You don’t like being the fly on the wall, do you?! Oh, and btw, I’m White.
Thanks; I’ll try to think soothing thoughts. But … if they don’t see that they can win the game, might there not be a possibility that they would call off the game? They’ve certainly set up the EOs to give them the powers to do it.
he’s parsing his words….. no surprise here
Yes, I agree, but after viewing thousand of vitriolic anti-Obama comments on her site, I have to disagree that she reins in the excesses. The place has turned into a firestorm of stupid and counterproductive rhetoric.
Although I don’t agree with what she, Joe Wilson and Larry Johnson are doing, I think they’re pushing back against the ridiculous anti- Hillary diatribe across the blogosphere and the MSM.
I just happen to think that rising above the muck is far better than rolling around in it …
Telling people to not be as hysterical as this isn’t as bad (as far as he knows). Well darling since none of us knows anything and given this administration, I’d say there is good reason to be a bit excited.
Yep, methinks Shuster was getting Tucker’s slot, until that comment about Chelsea …
So, breaching a passport file of a presidential candidate is so common as to occur one time each month for the last three months by contractor employees… and it is just treated with a slap on the wrist….
Gimme a break.
He’s probably feeling the wrath of the wingers. I know what you mean, though. He’s such a classy guy and I’m sure he would like to show some rage for 30 seconds or so. I know I would if I was him. He’s cool as a cucumber when it comes to important issues.
Well, I guess that my now being an “Obamabot” (her words), I simply have lost all lucidity.
((((( juslin )))))
I’m watching Barack on CNN … much better than Abrams, IMO …
I think I understand how you feel that way– that’s how I sometimes feel when I visit the Great Orange Satan. It’s one thing to support Obama, but damn, a lot of those people really hate Hillary. It’s kind of weird.
Well to each their own.
Isn’t anyone, besides me, curious as to why this info was revealed? Not because they’re required to report the breach since they follow no laws. So, why?
Shuster is a great reporter. As a commentator, not so much. I don’t think he could sustain a show. He’s better doing what he does. Now Rachel, however . . .
Somebody inside is ready to talk. :)
switching back and forth .. and i’ll see you next week ;o)
Interesting, State is taking the position to not confirm or deny….CIA?