The panel this morning was an interesting conversation about constitutional and rule of law issues — me, David Cole (a fantastic law professor at Georgetown and a real light on civil liberties issues) and Rep. John Conyers, who chairs the House Judiciary Committee. We all agreed that one of the lowest points during the last few years was the MCA and the gutting of habeas, because that coupled with Gitmo and all of the other questionable practices in how we treat others have brought the US to its lowest ebb in terms of influence on human rights and social justice around the world.
We will be years in the reparation of these wrongs. Including the long road back to restoring the DOJ to a more just and less politicized department. As David said, the attempt to return the Presidency to the Nixon Doctrine — "if the President does it, it’s not illegal" — is a failed experiment for which we will all be paying for generations to come.
I have gotten a few requests for my opening remarks from a few audience folks — so here they are as they were prepared for today:
When the patriots who fought to free the young colonies that became this United States of America put their entire lives, their property, their freedom, their claim to title and that of their families and friends on the line, they did so believing that freeing our young nation from the tyrannical whims of a petulant King George was essential to ensure the blessings of liberty for all the generations to come. So that the will of the people and the rule of law could triumph, and that the American public would never again suffer under the thumb of a demanding, crony-riddled government led by the king’s ego and his courtiers’ greed and lust for power.
Oh, how times have changed.
The Founders established a government by and for the people, a republic which included three branches who were to balance each other by a constant check and accountability tug of war for supremacy — executive, legislative and judicial — each with a discrete set of duties, but whose powers overlapped and intertwined, and all were subject to the consent of those they governed. In other words, they answer to all of us, and we should never, ever allow them to forget that.
For it is the governed — we, voters — who provide the ultimate check and balance on how our nation’s government operates — and we must continue to demand more transparency, more accountability, and more answers to the growing list of questions on what is being done in all of our names.
Citizenship is not just something that you have and are born with — it must also be something that you DO.
I write for the political blog firedoglake.com. Every week, we have some initiative going — calls to members of Congress, meetings for groups of our readers being set up with their elected representatives or their staffers, letters to the editor being written to local newspapers all across the country, issues education for our readers — you name it. Every single week.
Why? Because it needs to be done. We all need to be doing more, learning more…and speaking up far more often. Dr. King said "that a time comes when silence is betrayal." That time is now.
I became more politically active after I had my own child — and realized that the long term consequences of allowing governmental behavior like torture or indefinite detention without a full and fair trial, politicizing the Department of Justice so that legal practice became subordinated to "the math" of the never-ending quest for electoral supremacy, the gutting of civil rights enforcement, the stacking of our court system with judges with a Federalist Society agenda to actively service, the disrespect for the legislative branch with Presidential signing statements that override our nations laws with the stroke of a pen…I could no longer look at my daughter’s tiny little fingers curled around my own and sit back and watch my nation submit to a President who sought unilateral executive fiat.
And so I educated myself about the issues of the day, I started speaking up…and here I am. What I ask…all of you…is that you do the same. Benjamin Franklin famously said that "we have a Republic, if we can keep it."
That charge rests with all of us — each one of us sitting here today. It is a solemn obligation, a duty both to our history and all the generations to come. This nation was founded on the rule of law, the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, and a notion that "we, the people" are the ultimate arbiters of our fate.
There has always been a struggle for supremacy between the various branches of government. Each branch, at one point or another in our nation’s history, has seen its power ebb and flow over time. But there has always been a sort of unwritten code in the mutual respect that each has shown the other, even when they were fundamentally at odds over objectives. That has changed the last few years, where we have seen a wholesale attempt to shift power under the auspices of national security to allow for a unilateral executive to hold the reins of power with no tolerance for questions of the executive’s authority.
James Madison said: "It is a universal truth that the loss of liberty at home is to be charged to the provisions against danger, real or pretended, from abroad."
Giving up our civil liberties does not make us more safe. It simply makes us less free. And if we hand over everything it is to be an American — our core values to be sacrificed on the alter of consolidation of power in a false trade for a trumped up version of temporary peace of mind…until the next time we are asked to give up a little more liberty, and so on and so on…then we have already lost. We must all, every day, stand up for liberty, for our laws, and for the freedoms so hard won by so many generations who stood tall in the face of tyranny and threats in the past. We owe that to our forbears and to all the generations that follow ours.
It is up to all of us. Every single day. Being a citizen ought to be something that all of us DO.



125 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
WooHoo, Christy!
btw, that’s me laughing after Rep. Conyers identified me as the person who sends thousands of calls to his office every week. *g*
Now the panel is going back and forth a bit — Adam Green of MoveOn and Michael from Credo are debating the efficacy of e-mails versus text messaging. GOTV efforts are too important to just do one thing — need to do everything possible to turn out our vote in order to overcome the GOP machine.
I hope Christy, you and Jane are having a great time!
I assume Rep. Conyers meant it as a compliment, not a complaint. *g*
Excellent piece Christy.
Wish I could’ve seen the panel discussion, sigh.
I wonder if any of them know Phrenology, if they can read the bumps on their heads we keep givin’ em?
Adam talking now about the Fox debate crumbling…and how much Robert Greenwald’s and bloggers work to keep Dems from debating on their network.
Robert now talking about their latest Bill O’Reilly campaign — O’Reilly “in his infinite, ill-advised arrogance” decided to go after homeless vets. (There is a Fox News camera guy in the back…it’s quite a funny moment here.)
bravo, inspiring writing there.
my angle is just that this
“…solemn obligation, a duty both to our history and all the generations to come. This nation was founded on the rule of law, the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, and a notion that “we, the people” are the ultimate arbiters of our fate.”
also abviously transcends loyalty to the biases and needs of a particular political faction, around here, the (D) party.
if they are useful towards the goals of restoring constitutional rule, go ahead and work with them.
if they are not, they deserve opposition just like the (R) faction.
Good speech citizen Hardin!
Robert talking about how homeless vets went to Fox News in New York and tried to present a petition to them to retract O’Reilly’s attack. They were locked out of the Fox building, and O’Reilly started attacking Robert personally for pointing out his attacks on homeless vets.
Robert says they aren’t stopping until he stops insulting and demeaning homeless vets.
I’ll give him a dollar if he says ‘falafel”.
Well, thanks to you and your previous post about “If Bush attacks Iran…” I sent a fax to Conyers to call him on it: about why it is that duplicating the crime committed with Iraq is what it takes to get impeachment support from him but not torture, Justice Dept politicization, politically-motivated firings of AGs, politically-motivated prosecutions, ignored subpoenas, re-writing/gutting laws with the mere flip of signing statement pen, etc, etc, etc, etc, etc.
Hopefully, he was deluged with more of the same.
Bravo to you and Cole, etc, but BOOOO! to Conyers and the total, abject prostration he “stands” for. Thanks to him (and Pelosi, and Hoyer, and the rest of the Zeros in Congress) the Nixon doctrine of “if the President does it then it isn’t illegal” has been enshrined forever in precedent. They are happy to let Bush/Cheney out of office without actually calling Bush on the Nixon Doctrine so…that makes is OK and ripe for pulling out of the dictator’s toolbox by the next President, and the next, and the next, forevermore, amen.
Jane just got asked if our new format is working for us — she says yes.
I went to the Take Back America conference page and I can’t find any links to see the live stream, is there any?
Question now to Credo about using text messaging for voter protection during the elections. Michael says they haven’t used that, but it’s a great idea. And he’ll have to think about the way to do that…
It will work better if we can have the EDIT back.
Pretty please!
Robert talking about the need to digest large amounts of information and then translate it into a more populist form — video, etc.
Asking now about things that haven’t worked for folks…
AMEN, Christy! You go girl!
I’m gonna send this to a few folks.
Bob in HI
Amen Sister !
2 things -
I owe you, Jane, and this community everything for helping me to reclaim my activism. I’d just be some cynical paranoid had I landed at any other online place
if I could ask anything of our two candidates it would be please, puhleeze engage the electorate, challenge us all to take up the responsibility of citizenship
btw, you look fabulous !
It’s my understanding that the “edit” function puts a heavy strain on the servers. Do you want to personally fund the necessary increase in horse/hamster power?
I miss the jigs. But I am a luddite.
believe SEIU, La Raza, ABA elections monitoring project are all employing it :)
Thanks, Bob — I tried to write it as an American speech, not a highly partisan speech. Because these issues are American issues, not just Democratic ones. And that sort of lends itself to it being sent around which, I think, was why several folks in the audience asked me to post it.
And so, here it is…
More pictures of that vivacious redhead.
Doubt they’ll replay that one.
You are so good to me. Have I told you that lately? *G*
LOL That’s what Robert said — to the camera guy. *g*
is that Hamsher power?
Why am I having this “Superfriends” cartoon flashback? hehehehe
I wonder what the camera guy is really thinking.
“Wish I could quite my job and work for Democracy Now.”
hey, just watched yall on cspan… nice speech!
You might want to gently chide the Fox guys on the bedbugs in HQ.
http://thinkprogress.org/2008/…..-bed-bugs/
Amusing, but don’t assume that the camera guy has the views of a Fox drone. I know people who do occasional freelance work for Fox who definitely don’t, and while I don’t know anyone who’s regularly employed by them, I do know people with a regular gig on Hardball who definitely don’t buy into the views expressed there.
Sounds like a great panel; I wish I could be there! I’m only a few miles away, but with the time I took off to work on the primary, I have no slack now.
You know I coulda worked the rigs when the money was big
Or hopped a freighter south to trinidad
And when they tried to draft me I earned a college degree
Buyin time til things were not so bad
But then I got a guitar found a job in a bar
Playin acid rock til I was numb
Tell me where are the flashbacks they all warned us would come
Chorus:
We are the people, they couldnt figure out
We are the people our parents warned us about
Oh, was it on? Wonder if it will be replayed — Mr. ReddHedd was wondering if he’d be able to catch it…will have to let him know it was on. Thanks!
1,794 DAYZ AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen Hardin Smith:
You have taken a step onto the path that America’s first and ,in my opinion, foremost feminist and humanist Abigail Adams blazed from the 18th century. Indeed, I believe that you and Sister Hamsher deserve the first Abigail Adams Citizenship Award. And lest someone accuse me of marginalizin’ you folks by placin’ you in a gender box…I want to thank you and Jane for bein’ here to help an old man encourage two young daughters and three grand daughters to step forward into this exiting new world and help fix the incredible mess their father and grandfather’s generation has left ‘em.
Thanx Sister Hardin Smith and…
KEEP THE FAITH AND WE WILL FOLLOW YOU OUTTA THIS HELL THEY’VE CREATED FOR US!!
Here is the “This call may be illegally wiretapped by the Bush administration. That’s my administration.” ringtone.
they’ll probably replay it tonight … they usually do
Warning — before you click through and listen, put down all liquids. It’s hilarious…
That’s very funny. Thanks
Takin a break from that writing?
yup, eating some pasta and watching the news slice and dice the obama speech
Why do people always grab the microphones and start talking as though they are on the panel without ever asking a question? (Yes, this is a rhetorical question, but honestly, just ask the damned question…and yes, I do need coffee.)
ego
So like, can I enter all my wingnut friends’ phone numbers here and have this ringtone self install on my phone? That would be cool.
which we are attempting to dissolve :)
I mean self “have this ringtone install on their phone?”
Maybe I’ll learn how to self-proofread oneday…
Me too.
Talking now about paper trail back-ups for elections — question is whether there are ways to help with organizing so that tere is more accountability and oversight of election process.
The link will be sent to you as a text message. When you open it, the ringtone file is downloaded. You have to set it as the default ringtone, at least that’s how it went on my Nokia N80.
Panel is over — lots of clapping, lots of folks trying to run over me and my laptop, so I’m going to move away from the aisle…
Oh, spit! Ya beat me to it while debating whether it was too o/t. *g* That one *was* worth a good chuckle….and couldn’t happen to a more deserving bunch of people.
Digg this!
Dubya probably would like to see that outsourced or privatized… perhaps KBR could do it! NOT!
The elections since 2000 have all been gamed by the republicans.
Voter suppression and caging are common. Perhaps a million D voters had the votes tossed out in FL alone. All done by Ms Harris.
Several years ago I was a volunteer at Food First, founded by Frances Moore Lappe, when they were located South of Market in San Francisco. I attended many of Lappe’s lectures but the one that stood out for me was on “Doing Democracy”. Since that time, democracy is what I do. It is an active force. That simple change of wording from “live in” to “do” changed the way I few myself in every aspect of my country.
It is amazing the power of one little word!
It’s pump and dump time on wall street.
Any excuse is good enuf–they were talking about Fox!
all the exchanges are up … and gold’s down
I’ve successfully downloaded it, but can’t seem to make my phone use it as a ringtone. It does sound wonderful when I play it, though.
These are the people who will never see fifteen minutes of fame so they go for fifteen seconds, even if it’s negative behavior. You know, kinda like a two year old.
I didn’t realize Larry Craig was even on Wall St.
Well golly damn.
This is some of the funniest snark I’ve read since NTodd was steamrolling dangerstein on what was once the Lieberblog.
You can’t make this stuff up.
As I say during nearly every political discussion, democracy is not a spectator sport.
Christy!!! Brava!!!
P.S. I love the picture…it put a smile on my face!
Wow, LOL, I wonder who brought them into the newsroom!!! Hilarious!
New governor of New York makes a pre-emptive strike and appears with his wife confessing that his dick has been all over the place. He DIDN’T pay for any though- so is that better? If he had paid, he would have helped the economy.
Read through the comments, there are several hypotheses in there.
My cheeks hurt from laughing…
got a link, please?
New campaign rules to require tax returns and a list of every person or animal the candidate has slept with in his or her life
It makes me feel so good to know there are panels of people talking about the serious issues this country has to face once the republics get cleared out of the White House and we fumigate the place. Maybe by the time my toddler niece is in college, the worst of it will be over.
Christy, the photo of you laughing is wonderful! Please tell Conyers everyone here at FDL says “You’re welcome.” :D
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/03…..on.html?hp
Link to gov’s dick story
required, that is, of all non-Republic candidates.
firedogs,
just got back – is there to be a re broadcast of Christy’s speech and/or the panel ???
What an enormous database that would be.
Oh, lor’…….sittin’ here with tears runnin’ down my face. Ain’t nobody does snark better than progressives!
crikey ! Tweety is lovin him some Obama speech
“read it in your classrooms “
“take it out every now and then and re-read it “
jeebus that speech gave folks like Tweety permission to actually think about race without anger, guilt, or anxiety – maybe that was the point
Yeah- and that’s just the animals
That’s good news. But I’m still not going to watch. I’m sure I’d throw something through my TV set when Buchanan gets warmed up.
I went on Fox News and all I got was this lousy case of crabs.
-G
And that’s a beautiful thing.
it would be my response as well, just stunned to see his man crush for a Democrat!
Remember the old Cheech and Chong routine on “Buster the Bodycrab”? Someone should paste that soundtrack over some Faux News footage.
Tweedy beside himself & clearly in awe of Obama’s speech – and postulated it may be “one of the greatest speeches in our history.”
Whoa..what have we here? Insider trading…whistleblower:
http://www.dailykos.com/storyo…..738/479280
And Obama wrote it himself.
Sounds like Obama hit it off quite well with his speech today. Maybe that’ll put the wolf pack at bay until later this year.
Bill Clinton back to his old tricks though……says he’s been “mugged”. Presumably by the Black guy.
-G
gregb at 82—YEAH, i was wonderin’ about the ’bedbugs’! huh? yeah, right.
that’s FOX for ya, always politically correct /s
Speaking of good lefty snark.
http://www.harpers.org/archive…..c-90002662
Just like Reagan or Bush…maybe not.
They quit looping the Wright video.
actually, those should be bed bugs according to what we’ve heard
Very interesting. I’m still waiting for a leak of “insider trades” accomplished through the Bushco wiretapping/datamining programs. I still think that has to be a route to very large amounts of untraceable money for certain government insiders, either for themselves or for other nefarious purposes.
Bear sterns paid 260 million in bonuses in 06
Good point!
Smerconish just called it a great speech
Tweety – “He is all of us” dear gawd, my fainting couch !
Was just reading about that
Then there’s this which is related to this
ecahn, note at the end of the last thread about how dad ’chooses’ which stocks to buy.
does somebody want to comment on this?
what the hell does that mean?
what kind of deadline?…is the judge gonna haul the president’s butt in jail?
I know this is off topic but I wanted to share a funny commercial we saw over the weekend. Maybe we’re just bent but we couldn’t believe that M & M’s got this past the censors. LOL
Click on the link and then select the commercial called taste. See if you think it’s as funny as we do.
Christy,
Was Rep. Conyers staying and visiting with folks? You, Jane, Suin or Marcy?
Sorry guys…I still can’t add my links. Paste this in your browser to see the commercial referenced at 102.
http://www.m-ms.com/us/fungames/tv/
I know this is off topic but I wanted to share a funny commercial we saw over the weekend. Maybe we’re just bent but we couldn’t believe that M & M’s got this past the censors. LOL
Click on the link and then select the commercial called taste. See if you think it’s as funny as we do.
http://www.m-ms.com/us/fungames/tv/
Here is another crazy story just up at Rawstory:
http://rawstory.com/news/2008/….._0318.html
and anyone that hasn’t seen this yet–
listing of political contributions, itemized, since 1978, for politicos, media, businesssmen, celebrities, sports..
eye opening.
it also lists where/how they were employed when the contribution was made, that has been as interesting as the contributions list. only thing is, for instance, donna brazille was chief of staff for someone in the house of representatives, but doesn’t say who.
all info is from the FEC
the bushes were interesting, contributions to florida republican committee, in 2002….
seriously, go take a look. DISCLAIMER-it’s addicting.
http://www.newsmeat.com
Thanks. Left you a response.
ROFLMAO. Chisii comadachi, or “little friends” in Japanese.
my 107–and it’s interesting to see that some people really put their money where their mouth is…….
I read it earlier. Do you have any idea how to regard Peter Lance? Is he credible?
CQ just upgraded Sen. Johnson’s seat to ‘Safe Democrat’… The Goopers can’t seem to recruit any viable contenders… Bwhahaha…
http://www.cqpolitics.com/wmsp…..0002689882
Fox is more like a case of bullhead clap!
I don’t think I’ve ever heard of him before, but Raw does a pretty good job on sources of articles they publish. Interesting how he ties everything together.
kinda funny, reminds me of.. was it Pete Rose? some ball player testifying about steroids and lickin’ his dry lying lips all afternoon.
Phoenix Woman has a whole new post up and ready.
Here’s the Wiki on him.
Woops…here’s the Wiki on him:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Lance
“For it is the governed — we, voters — who provide the ultimate check and balance on how our nation’s government operates — and we must continue to demand more transparency, more accountability, and more answers to the growing list of questions on what is being done in all of our names.”
“Citizenship is not just something that you have and are born with — it must also be something that you DO.”
Well stated citizen Smith!!!
I believe you are talking about Roger Clemens and his recent appearance before Congress. His arrogance in thinking he is above everything may make him this generation’s Pete Rose. Pete was eventually busted for gambling and Tax problems. He didn’t have to appear befroe Congress though.
Great post, Christy. It is essential that we restore Constitutional government in our country. We need to raise the issue with Sen. Clinton and Sen. Obama at every opportunity, so one of them doesn’t get into office and become enamored with the Bushian notion of unlimited government power. We need to get them committed NOW to restoring habeas corpus, ending torture, doing away with signing statements and acknowledging the legitimacy of Congressional oversight over the Executive branch of government.
I ask these questions of every candidate whom I meet on Blue America. We need to get the message to Obama and Clinton, too, that we’re mad as hell and we’re not going to take it anymore.
Unfortunately, I do not consider the attempt to return the Presidency to the Nixon Doctrine as a failed experiment at all. It has been remarkably successful, as a matter of fact! And if Conyers and those presently in government do not take to task the current administration for their abuses of power, their obstructions of justice, their utter contempt for our closest representatives in government, that is, the Congress of the United States, it will become the accepted law of the land by default. The Congress becomes complicit by not acting to defend their position in the balance of power, but instead creating new precedents. I wish that we had thought to print out Hugh’s list and hand it in bound book form to Conyers while Christy had the chance. He should be told that somewhere within the pages the Congress should be able to find enough to constitute high crimes and misdemeanors. What we have for an Administration today is the result of the offenses of the Reagan/Bush I era, the Iran/contra situation, being ignored. If you don’t hold their feet to the fire, they will not feel any burn at all.
Awesome post, Christy. Thanks! And it IS something I do, in one way or another, each and every day. What I’m discouraged about is that although I DO something daily, and have now for just years!, this criminal bunch is still in power and the Iraq war still rages on. Voting democrats into Congress in ‘06 didn’t help. Maybe that’s changing now, finally, but what about the signing statements, appointees, and deaths that have occurred since those elections. THAT was what I was trying to stop, and it marched right on anyway. I won’t stop being a patriot and DOING something daily. But this has been just disheartening as well as frightening to me.
When I LAST was a patriot every single day, it was during the Nixon administration and we got the bum thrown out. It’s not like that anymore.
and I STILL WANT MY COUNTRY BACK!
Oh Bravo, Christy.
Great speech, Christy.