The Drum Major Institute's middleclass.org project released their report card on congressional support for the middle class today
With a U.S. Senator set to assume the presidency for the first time since 1960, and with an eye on the 470 other federal elections scheduled for November 4th, the Drum Major Institute for Public Policy (DMI) released “TheMiddleClass.org 2007 Congressional Scorecard” today... On the positive side, the scorecard reflects an overall improvement in Congress’ support for the middle class, with 34 Senators and 199 Representatives receiving “A” grades. On the negative side, one-third of all Representatives and nearly 40% of all Senators earned “F” grades.
“The middle-class squeeze is a recurring theme among members of Congress, all of whom assert their interest in alleviating some of the burdens faced by the middle class and those struggling to earn their way into it. If that commitment was universally genuine, 99% of Congress would have received an ‘A’ this year. Clearly, that did not happen and it was the current and aspiring middle class who suffered for it,” commented DMI Executive Director Andrea Batista Schlesinger.
I won't make you search for the spotlight quote (pdf)
As for the three top presidential contenders, Senators Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton each received an “A+” grade. Stunningly, Senator McCain was the only member of the Senate to receive an “incomplete” because he missed a majority of the graded votes. Even Senator Tim Johnson, who suffered a life threatening brain hemorrhage in December 2006 and did not return to the Senate until September 2007, managed to vote on 50% more pieces of critical middle-class legislation than did Senator McCain. “When it came to doing something about the middle class, Senator McCain simply wasn’t there for them,” said Ms. Schlesinger.
One of the problems with talking about middle class interests is that nobody can seem to figure out whose interests they are. I like DMI's take on that
What Is The Middle Class?
The middle class is more than an income bracket. Over the past fifty years, a middle-class standard of living in the United States has come to mean having a secure job, the opportunity to own a home, access to health care, retirement security, time off for vacation, illness and the birth or adoption of a child, opportunities to save for the future and the ability to provide a good education, including a college education, for one’s children. When these middle-class fundamentals are within the reach of most Americans, the nation is stronger economically, culturally and democratically.
Most Americans identify themselves as middle class. Yet DMI is concerned not only with those who currently enjoy a middle-class standard of living, but also with expanding the middle class by increasing the ability and opportunities of poor people to enter the middle class. The middle class is strengthened when more poor people are able to work their way into its ranks. In a nation that is increasingly polarized between the very wealthy and everyone else, DMI sees the poor and middle class as sharing many of the same interests. Simply put: what strengthens and expands the middle class is good for America.
Or to put it another way, I got (at least some of) mine, but it'll be worth more if you get yours. Our representatives in congress assembled, who have more than most, maybe don't feel that way about it. You can be pretty sure, though, that their own jobs and health insurance mean a great deal to them.
So look it up (individual grades are here, and the whole report in pdf format is here. A list of the bills they followed is here). There may be good behavior you need to reward, or you may be represented by a Republican (they're nonpartisan. I'm not). Either way, it'll give you something to talk about in the fall, or if you're a widget lover, something you can post on your own blog right now.
Imagine what we could do once there are sane people in the executive branch.
[FYI, DMI also has a public affairs blog and podcasts of their progressive policy seminars.]
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
Aloha, Julia!
I used to be middle class - and I still vote.
Hey Julia!
interesting post
Hi Julia. Remains to be seen if I have the brains for this thread.
MIA, what a miscreant…!
great graph!
Suz, my favoritest Mod! Bonne Soir!
I am with Suzanne. Used to be middle class. Still vote.
hey ct - how’s paradise tonight? is there still a middle class or are they being wiped out there too?
Honestly, policy geekery is not really my thing, but I find these folks really accessible.
Bond: F
McCaskill: B
For my rep — Cleaver: A
Not bad, all things considered. Of course, elsewhere in MO we have one of the worst in Minority Whip Roy Blunt (a very low F). Roy’s son is the Gov, who recently (and surprisingly) announced he’s NOT running for reelection. The MO GOP is still in a dither about that one.
still middle class, still vote
right…
Heh, three of my four critters aced it with 100% scores, sadly, Inouye, scored a pathetic 83%… I’ll be working on that in 2010…! ;-)
I kind of like the idea that it’s not quaint for people who work hard to have a sense of security. It’s kind of fallen out of fashion these days, I think.
Why yes, there is an election coming up…
Hey, you.
nonplussed, want to come to lunch tomorrow? i’ll pick you up.
It seems the Plantation mentality has set in, the Have-mores determine what the have-nots can and can not do…! 8-( The Gold Coast of Kona has all the jobs, but, nobody that will work them, can live near them…!
formerly middle class - now just barely existing :o(
Hold up. I think the ad at the top of the page has Obama too dark. Is this some kind of a racist conspiracy on McCain’s part?!
i do not think we are the only ones seeing our little slice of paradise crumble into the haves and the have nots.
two of my critters (Boxer - senate and Snachez- Representative) scored 100% and the other critter (Feinstein) scored 83% –sooooooo not surprised we need to toss her out to pasture
There are no “incompletes” in life. If St. McCan’t missed that many votes, he chose to. That’s a “F”.
Julia,
It really has fallen out of favor.
I read about it during the NYC garbage strike. People were upset at the wages and benefits the workers were making. “I have a degree in x and z and I only make…”.
I just had some serious dentistry done, I am afraid it is soup for me. Thanks, I appreciate it though.
Are you saying that Ms. Feinstein is an old cow?
Let’s hope not!
Hi Mary!
I hope our nominee will use “not showing up” against McCain, especially when it comes to the middle class.
Thanks for a great post, Julia — not at all wonky! Important!
There was an article in the paper a few months ago about fewer H-2B visas being available for seasonal foreign workers, and how it was going to force people with businesses in the Hamptons to hire local.
And I couldn’t help but wonder - how terribly hard would it be to find someone to work in the Hamptons with free housing?
Hey! Newtperson!
two of my critters (Boxer - senate and Sanchez- Representative) scored 100% and A’s the other critter (Feinstein) scored 83% (also A) –sooooooo not surprised we need to toss her out to pasture
Oh, no kidding.
Bloomberg tried that with the transit strike, and New Yorkers didn’t bite. I was kind of proud of us.
when i was in the middle class, i had dental insurance and was able to have dental work done.
ice cream used to be my post dental treatment method of choice.
The middle class is more than an income bracket. Over the past fifty years, a middle-class standard of living in the United States has come to mean having a secure job, the opportunity to own a home, access to health care, retirement security, time off for vacation, illness and the birth or adoption of a child, opportunities to save for the future and the ability to provide a good education, including a college education, for one’s children. When these middle-class fundamentals are within the reach of most Americans, the nation is stronger economically, culturally and democratically.
sorry …these are no longer affordable by ..the TRUE middle class
no, of course not, old cows are still useful, feinstein not so much
right now i need 5,000 in dental work…broke 2 teeth in hurricane Wilma,i will have to fly to Mexico this summer to take care of it
My brother has worked driving heavy equipment for my cousin for the last 20 years. (My cousin’s side of the family was always considered the wealthy, uneducated side.) Last weekend I took my brother out for lunch, and he mentioned that while he got a paycheck, he was told not to cash it. This has happened for the last five weeks. What good is a paycheck if you can’t cash it or deposit it???
My side of the family has had an ongoing argument with the cousins about politics, maybe their heads will be out of the bubble soon.
Ain’t that the truth! Nor can they afford to commute, here in the Isles you can easily pay $4 a gallon, I shop around and pay $3.60… So, when will reality come crashing down upon the privileged class’s head…?
part of what went into deciding to sell the house - i can hopefully have enough money to be able to go to mexico to get my teeth fixed.
That’s illegal.
Yeah, Wikipedia has a chart on the current income distribution that kind of makes you think about the term “middle”
When the working class can no longer afford to consume…and then the whole pyramid comes crashing down.
“Hi, I’m 1929! I thought we met already!”
so he hasn’t cashed any of his checks?
I put it off. Cumulative costs are just as Sadlyyes says, $4900. I did find a plan that took 25% off of it though.
Paid $3.47 for gas today. Grocery prices make my eyes pop out. Buy clothes for 12 yr. old granddaughter that stun me. People can forget about college and vacations - they will be just be feeding the family.
hahahahahahaha
ill meetcha there…as you prolly know…the circulatory system is tied to our teeth and gums…they must be taken care of,im going on 2 years now….yea AMERICA
Arizona
2007 Middle-Class GradesPie Chart
Senators:
Kyl, Jon(R) ~ F
McCain, John(R)~ INC
Representatives:
Flake, Jeff(R, District 6) - F
Franks, Trent(R, District 2) - F
Giffords, Gabrielle(D, District 8) - A_plus
Grijalva, Raul(D, District 7) - A_plus
Mitchell, Harry(D, District 5) - B
Pastor, Edward(D, District 4) - A_plus
Renzi, Rick(R, District 1) - C
Shadegg, John(R, District 3) - F
Isn’t pretty clear…. Repug gets an F and my congressman got a B…. wow that sucks
If they are lucky.
My rep - Akins (blergh). I helped get Claire elected, but the most I can say good about her is that she’s better than Talent. She has really disappointed me on the war and FISA. My bet is that Carnahan, who will not disappoint, will run against Bond and win. The only problem is he’s not up until, I think, 2011. There are rumors that he will retire sooner, but I don’t believe any of them. However, one can hope…
Twain, will she wear second hand?
*sigh* De Ja Vu all over again! BTW, ftfy!
My then insured graduate student daughter went to the emergency room for what turned out to be an ocular migraine. She lives 10 hours away from me, you know, in graduate school. My insurance would not pay for the emergency room because “it was not in my network” you know, 10 hours away.
Problem is the gated community group doesn’t give a shit about the rest of us cause we don’t have anything they need. Like making the economy work. Like factory jobs. Etc. They make their wealth through financial games not on the labor of others.
I have a friend who runs a freight business, He was telling me local diesel at $3.95 a gallon at the local big truck fueling place.
yeah, we’re planning on planting quite the vegtable garden to offset food costs
surely you jest !
what was that study that came out a couple months ago (i think) that found most people are overly optomistic and consider themselves to be middle class when they are not or may barely be considered lower middle class?
Yes. We no longer create wealth by manufacturing products. Now we manufacture debt.
shit i have that rare malady ,i can tell her what to expect,we can compare notes…it is quite rare,and tell her not to woory too much
Eddie Bauer. They have an online outlet site that regularly holds up to 75% off sales, and frequently has free shipping promotions. They’re well-made, not cheap looking clothes, and HM pretty much lives in them. Lands End also has overstock sales that go down pretty low.
universal health care not universal health coverage - the later only give more victims for the insurance companies to screw over and fleece.
Hey, I just went to Tijuana for a dental appliance. (Mine broke, and the insurance only covers it every five years.)
I could not believe my eyes. Hadn’t been to downtown Tijuana for probably 20 years. The place is beautiful! We walked across the border, and all you see is dental, medical and pharma joints. I was absolutely shocked. It is the economy of Tijuana now. Americans everywhere. Police (and juvenile police-so cute-on every corner.) The place is clean, absolutely no trash on any street, and street signs and lights we would envy in San Diego. Mindblowing.
And, the best dental appliance I have ever had.
They might wake up, when the restaurants they frequent, theater they attend, and the service they need is non-existent…!
!!! missed your comment before mine. Contact me, I’ll take you to Dr. Gastelum.
OMG, really! It happened to her again last week, and I’m pretty freaked out.
oh goody,now to find a cheap flight
AND, she is NO LONGER insured as she aged out of my insurance.
I have a difficult time finding the right size for her on line and she’s at the age where she is out-growing everything (including shoes) about every 3 months. I would rather buy for her than for myself and I love shopping with her. At her age they have to look just right all the time.
I’d heard similar tales. People have laughed at me when I tell them that they should investigate it. Some people you can’t help.
Illegal is a sick bird.
no no ,dont worry,email me at kismecat…yahoo,its vaso motor
Careful, Southwest just grounded a bunch of their planes…! ;-)
She will be find. It is not any fun but usually not dangerous. I have them. Ron has them.
oh thank you,am saving up right now!
I cured the Calvin Klein syndrome with the teens….. idea given to me from a friend who had raised her kids….. set up bank accounts with X amount of money per month and tell them…. thats it….. don’t ask me for anything else again. It worked….. my daughter went from high end labels to k-mart brand.
See if she can get insurance through school. Fairly cheap. Better than nothing.
can she wear a small size 4,i have an outfit leggings and a pretty fleece sweater ,bought for somebody i no longer talk to…”g”
He’s told when it’s safe to cash them. Apparently my cousin gets a check, and tells the employees when they can deposit them. Sounds really bad to me. He’s got a building in an industrial park, and probably 10 expensive pieces of heavy equipment, but no income. He’ll have to give the equipment back to the bank, I’m guessing. This is his collateral. I’m thinking he may turn into a democrat.
sheeeeeeeesh you have them too?
We shop at Target and Old Navy - none of the high-end stores at all. Her special treat is to get a new t-shirt from Hot Topic.
Suz, we’ll all go to Tijuana together. It’s the best experience I’ve ever had. Seriously.
Thanks, but she is a size 10 - at least the last time we shopped. She will be here next week and heaven only knows what the size will be then. I appreciate the offer.
don’t forget to join the hot topic discount club card thingie - i remember baby girl’s hot topic days and that discount certainly helped.
they suk big time anyway,true story…i once was denied a seat by one of their stewards and his wife,while they were deadheading on a vacation…
Weird. It’s been 10-15 years since I’ve been to TJ, and that does sound amazingly different. A presidential candidate had just been assassinated before we got there, and the poverty was astounding.
You sure they didn’t just clean up an area for Americans and brush the riff-raff under a rug somewhere?
Surely sounds different from the old Tijuana which was dirty and dangerous. Makes me want to see it.
OK — I will tomorrow at work.
Heh, my middle girl has discovered Ross’s, she can get the Klein’s, even if they’re slightly irregular…!
Katymine, you should write a parenting book. Seriously, every single idea you mention here on the Lake is wonderful and makes perfect sense, but especially the ideas about kids. I mean it. Write a book, please.
i REALLY need to take care of this
Yep, me and Joan of Arc. I have had them since I was 24. I was really pregnant. Apparently, women often have their first migraine (ocular or otherwise) when they are pregnant. Hormones do the trick.
The Republiclans score was abysmal. What a surprise! They appear so compassionate. Not toward the middle class of course but the upper crust. If things get really bad just remember what someone once said, maybe it was prophetic “eat the rich!”
Thanks, I’m catching up. Let me know how you cope.
that would do it
mr wobbs just came back from an emergenmcy run to the regular grocery store and told me cxereal for $7.00 bread almost $4.00!! who the hell can affored those prices??
The ‘Factory’ outlets in San Ysidro is worth it alone…!
My mom says a lot of folks in Palm Springs area drive down to Mexico for dental treatment. A real estate agent she knows had an estimate from his dentist for over $27,000 for bridge work and repairs - he went to Mexico and got dental implants for $5,000 and was treated like a king.
We did buy a semester of insurance at University of Delaware, but have not tested it yet. Thanks Mary!
hey ,hey…1 washing and everything looks irregular”g”
Time to recirculate the story about Bush staying at the 3 billion dollar UAE hotel with all the white sand imported in from Algeria.
-G
yup,ive really researched it indepth…the hormones control the blood vessels,just like when women get hot flashes
Does anyone here know anything about scleroderma?
Or the story about his dad being driven to school in a limo during the Depression.
if i may suggest, line drying your clothes or using a rack (indoors) will extend the color and life of your clothes
youtube baby….
Actually, our manufacturing output continues to set records. It did in 2006, and though the data is not completely released yet, 2007 looks set to break the record again. American workers are far more productive than workers anywhere else, which is why we can make so much stuff while employing less in manufacturing. our manufacturing output is actually about 2 and a half times that of China.
And our economy began to shift to an information economy long ago. That is just a fact of life that people are going to have to accept. The old days where everybody you know worked in a mill or the coal mines or whatever are gone.
isnt it auto-imune?
Does stress have anything to do with the onset of an attack?
yup,hand wash ,or gentle cycle …cold water,mild ivory soap…and line dry…iron on inside out
No, but I’ve always found the Mayo Clinic website useful for research.