"Collective punishment" is the name of the game, in both Gaza and in Iraq. The video clip above provides just a taste of what this looks like from inside Palestinian neighborhoods. Yesterday alone at least 60 Palestinians were reported killed in the latest Israeli attacks on Gaza.
While Israel's Deputy Defense minister Matan Vilnai threatens the people of Gaza with a "shoah," Gush Shalom, the Israeli peace party, gathered today to once again demand an end to the "siege of Gaza" by the Israeli government. Sadly, the Hamas led elected government of Gaza has been offering a cease fire and the majority of Israeli citizens support a cease fire:
Yossi Beilin, the former minister and ex-leader of the left of centre Meretz Party, said that a diplomatic rather than military solution was needed. He said that Hamas had at least twice made requests "via a third party" to agree a truce. He added: "My solution is to reach a ceasefire with Hamas."
A Haaretz-Dialog poll this week showed that 64 per cent of Israelis were in favour of such an agreement to end the rocket fire, and secure the release of the Israeli corporal, Gilad Shalit, who was abducted by Gaza militants in June 2006.
but these calls for an end to the violence go unmentioned in the US press and unanswered by both Olmert and the Bush administration.
The latest violence follows an increase in rocket attacks on Israel - following the killing of five Hamas members by Israeli forces. And this all occurs in the context of Israel's blockade which prevents Gaza residents from access to proper food, water and humanitarian supplies:
Following the Hamas takeover of Gaza last summer, the embargo has been intensified and this coastal territory has been largely shut off from the outside world.
Israel, which controls most of Gaza's borders, only allows essential goods - such as medicine and basic foodstuffs - to enter the territory. Almost none of Gaza's 1.5 million citizens are allowed to leave.
Ahmed Abdullah, 61, a retired headmaster, says he spent the last two days terrified in his home as fighting raged round him.
He had no candles or batteries - the economic boycott has led to widespread shortages - and following an electrical power cut sat in the dark unable to obtain information from his radio about the fighting.
Mr Abdullah says the only way to stop the violence is to allow to Hamas govern.
"We voted democratically and we're punished for our choice," he said.
"They need to be given a chance, they need to breathe. If you give Hamas a political opportunity then it will only moderate the movement."
Uri Avnery, a leader of Gush Shalom, provides a very good overview of the situation - and a sane call for an end to the violence in his essay "Good Morning Hamas"
We Israelis live in a world of ghosts and monsters. We do not conduct a war against living persons and real organizations, but against devils and demons which are out to destroy us. It is a war between the Sons of Light and the Sons of Darkness, between absolute good and absolute evil. That's how it looks to us, and that's how it looks to the other side, too.
Let's try to bring this war down from virtual spheres to the solid ground of reality. There can be no reasonable policy, nor even rational discussion, if we do not escape from the realm of horrors and nightmares.
More valuable background can be found in Al Jazeera's People and Power report on the "rocket men" and the Israeli forces who hunt them. Part one is here, part two here.
We've often noted that US tactics in Iraq have mirrored the Israeli military's tactics and this weekend we again see the disaster this approach creates. Collective punishment of the residents of Gaza is not so different and no less illegal than the ongoing killing of civilians by US forces in Iraq. Just this week, there are reports - again unmentioned in our own press - that US troops shot and killed an elderly, deaf, disabled man in Miqdadiya , a US air strike killed an Iraqi teenager who was digging roots for firewood north of Samara and
"Three civilians were wounded when U.S. forces blew up an explosive vehicle in al-Eslah a-Zirai district, western Mosul," Brig. Khalid Abdul-Sattar, the spokesman for the Ninewa operations command, told Aswat al-Iraq – Voices of Iraq – (VOI). "The U.S. troops opened fire at the vehicle, leaving three people nearby wounded," he added.
AFP reports that Iraqi violence "surged" in February with 636 civilians deaths reported "compared with 541 dead in January."
When we will learn to look to leaders like Bellin and Avnery for guidance rather than the provocative and inhumane hawks such as Vilnai?
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
Siun!
I’m appalled the Israelis are calling for ’shoah’… 8-(
Siun you are a breath of fresh air. It’s appalling how little air time is given to people who want to talk to each other.
What is shoah, please?
Essentially, Jihad or crusade in various other forms… 8-(
Evening!
Twain - Shoah is the hebrew word used for the Holocaust though it can also mean disaster but that usage is very very rare.
I stand corrected…! *g*
the holocaust.
The Israelis themselves now admit that they’ve killed 70. And “Shoah” is the word for “Holocaust” in Hebrew.
BRB
Dubhaltach
I just saw reports in Haaretz and Jpost that the IDF (Israeli Defense Forces) counted another 12 Palestinians killed today - not including the teenager they killed on the West Bank today .. and that they are gearing up for even stronger actions against Gaza.
Olmert is meeting with lawyers tomorrow to see if it is legal to bomb residential neighborhoods (though it sure seems that is already being done.)
Hello Siunshine, Do you have any idea what to make of this (if anything)?
Update: Masrour Barzani arrested in Vienna? [Michael Rubin]
Aloha, Du! I was just gonna ask Siun if you’d pop by for a visit! *g*
The U.S. lowered the bar on war crimes in Iraq. And look what happens. I only hope other countries don’t become as inured as we have.
Hadn’t seen that Eureka … perhaps our Guides friends have a comment?
It does point to the unsavory “friends” we have adopted in Iraq though…
Laura … not sure if you’ve read Pity the Nation by Robert Fisk about Israel’s actions in Lebanon but it is like a road map for our actions in Iraq … and the results are as brutal.
Crsp. How is that not an act of war? I hope the lawyers tell Olmert so, and that he’ll be visiting the Hague on a one-way ticket if he does bomb residential neighborhoods.
What, with cluster bombs…?! 8-(
Also the following in the FDL newsbox:
US and Arab states clash at UN Security Council
Just like in America, the citizens are outraged and want to see some peace and the governments of Israel & America won’t listen.
I haven’t, but I shall. Thank you. (Hi Du.)
How can shock and awe not be a war crime, while we’re at it?
Kay … the persistence of Gush Shalom in the face of such ongoing odds really inspires me. They’ve been pushing for peace and sanity for so long and we could learn a lot of lessons from them.
The National Review are as usual way behind times we’ve been reporting on that for ages. He’s a Kurdish human rights activist and a “clean government campaigner” and very brave. He got badly tortured when he was detained by Barzani’s thugs in Arbil and only was released after all hell broke loose in the European press about it. Masrour Barzani is Barzani’s son and is widely believed by well-informed sources to be even more vicious than his dad.
Du - thank you for filling that in.
The continuing support of thugs is an important story.
not to worry, our secretary of state is headed to israel and the occupied territories tomorrow. i’m sure she’ll get it all sorted out. /snark
on a serious note… .yes, the people who continue to advocate for a just peace are inspiring and i wish we would start listening to them.
ES, if the resolution was strongly worded it would be torpedoed by the US when it gets to the Security council anyways…! 8-(
From BBC News:
Hello Siun,
Thank you for continuing to speak out and blog on these ME issues.
Having read your post, I have to admit to being nearly stunned into virtual silence. Yes, I knew the outlines of this, but not in such detail.
The Israeli actions in Lebanon were an abomination. One of my dearest friends is from a family (Christian mother, Jewish father) who left Berlin in 1933. Although he identifies himself as a secular Jew (my label), and lost family in the Holocaust, he abhors the actions of the Israeli government. Said at the time of the most recent attacks on Lebanon that the Israeli government is using exactly the same abhorrent tactics that were used against the Jewish population during the Holocaust.
Hi siun!
from Paris…
Ironically, Abbas has no support from Gaza, a hollow gesture indeed…!
Selise … Condi going to Israel is so reassuring (not) and the Israelis are already preparing their comments for her:
Biodun, I thought you’d be amidst your hot date, right about now, your future bride, IIRC…! *g*
I see they’ve finally finished putting up the posting for today on “guides” if you scroll past the Arabic and hit the jump you’ll get to read about what went on today in Irak from Arabic sources summarised into English:
Those two day old terrorists are the worst.
Ohhh, Olmert getting a little testy with Rice? My, my, my. She can tell him to do as we say, and not as we do, huh?
Condoleeza Rice is probably the most incompetant high rank gov official of our lifetime.
Totally unprepared for the job as National Security Adviser; one reason that 9/11 was not foreseen or prevented, even though she had been briefed by the outgoing admin. Should have been fired on 9/12/2001.
Instead, continues to be incompetant as Sec of State at a time when we have needed world class talent. Shame.
I’m guessing she’ll make the appropriate “gosh we’re concerned” noises and then arrange another rush shipment of clusterbombs
The sheer irony is astounding, Du! What a travesty…! 8-(
Conditions in Gaza appear to be worse than the situations on Native Indian reservations in this country a hundred and seventy years ago. The people of Gaza are living their own “trail of tears”.
Lahoma.
swell (not)
thanks for covering this siun.
Yes.
Kiddo … very apt!
The rhetoric is heating up all over the region this is from the Saudi government press agency:
They’re starting to realise the level of fury in the general population and are getting worried and it’s not just the Saudis.
As a backgrounder you might want to read the entirety of the Analysis by Darryl Li again here’s a quote:
Aloha, Lahoma! Is OKK still sore…? Did ya see my Lenin comment on the Book Salon thread…? 8-)
so sad, no learning from the past.
glad to see you here again Lahoma.
Didn’t the US recently deploy a war ship of some sort near the area?
we had a great dinner last night at a couscous restaurant on rue Xavier Privas in the Latin Quarter–not too far from where she lives…We had drinks afterward, and then retired for the night–separately. I need to sleep to get up for work at 3:30 AM Monday (Paris Time). I’m working now–double-dipping as usual when I’m at the Lake.
In any case, Assia and I are both headed fro London on the EuroStar in a coupla hours…I have to be at Bush House (BBC HQ) to meet with some powers that be–negotiate my contract–current one ends in August. (So far I’ve been under subcontract with one of their major US correspondents, a close friend of mine who was in grad school with me at U of MN in the mid-1970s).
Assia and I will spend sometime in London, then take the EuroStar back to Paris…I’m not sure what’s happening tonight. Tomorrow morning Paris Time, I head back to the US, to Minneapolis…
Looks like Assia and I are in for the haul…we’ll see how things unfold.
welcome back, my friend…*g*
Yes. I keep thinking we’ve learned something as a folk, but we haven’t. Not well enough, anyway. Indifference to the suffering of others is the most invidious form of hate.
The wall the Israelis are building reminds me of the Berlin Wall…
Insanity. Here we go again. No shame.
Picture
More here
Lahoma @ 40 click here
Off the Lebanese coast (Hey there, ES!)
You’re a true Stud Muffin…! Good Luck, all the way around! *g*
Hello CTuttle.
L.
Yeppers, the USS Cole, no less…! ;-)
Look, I’ve said this before here: Condi’s expertise was the old Soviet Union, which collapsed outta history in 1991. And Condi’s expertise disappeared along with that of the defunct Soviets. The current Russia is not at all the same Russia that was part of the extinct Soviet Union.
Translation: Condi has been left since 1991 with a totally useless expertise and a body of knowledge.
The Middle East? She’s completely benighted– and at sea…
Aloha, Ma’am!
They remind me of the walls the Germans built around the Ghetto in Warsaw and so do the walls being built in Baghdad, Baqubah, Fallujah, al Basrah, Tal Afar, Al-Mosul, Kerkuk,
Need I go on?
I posted the onion bread for you down in Rule of Law Still Clinging to Life
Useful and interesting editorial in the Daily Star from Lebanon:
http://www.dailystar.com.lb/ar.....ateg_id=17
Ding.
Hello Laura, Hope you are feeling better this evening.
Got it. Thanks so much..)
Not at all! I fully concur with your apt analogy! 8-)
So true. Good to “see” you Lahoma.
Just one story from today in Gaza:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/new.....aza203.xml
Hello Biodun Ignila.
L.
Wouldn’t it be great if everybody with out of date expertise could still get a job with benefits?
Lots of folks here in the U.S. need that deal.
Hello Du, and the best as always. Where are you posting from?
Thank you for posting on these abominations, Siun. The silence has been deafening from the, um, media and I am wearing out the floors by stomping on them while cursing a blue streak everytime I hear/see/think about the tepid pablum we are being served up on the “news” while people in Iraq, Afghanistan, Gaza etc are being terrorized, murdered, starved, frozen, maimed and much more.
How is it that all of our “leaders” vociferously support our and Israel’s right to defense but dismiss and revile the notion that a Palestinian/Iraqi/Afghan has that same right/obligation in the face of brutal occupation and terror???????
How come UN Security Council resolutions only count when it applies to others– you know, the ones we don’t like??????
How come international law does not apply to us or our allies?????
Just some questions I have.
Thought I’d add Mexico…for the hell of it…oh, and Canada…too.
Compartmentalization. Isn’t that the latest “word”.? Lock everybody behind all kinds of “walls”…real walls, firewalls, wallmart..
This f*cking madness needs to stop…! 8-(
An affectionate hello Loo Hoo.
L.
Full account of clashes, with map, from BBC News here.
Listen live to BBC World Service Radio here.
(World Today, the premier news program of BBC, will be on air until 5 AM Monday-GMT)
Time-Zone World Clock here…
Not yet, but I will, thank you. Of course, compared with ordinary life in Gaza or Fallujah or… a little flu is pfft.
Du, how is your son doing?
Hello Laura Doty.
L.
I am at home in Denmark, dad is somewhere close to Baqubah, where exactly I don’t know, Mohammed Hashi, is in al-Mosul, Mohammed Ibn Laith is I think hope and pray back in al-Sadriyah, and I’ve no idea where Khaled Al Basrawi is posting from.
Biodun … thanks!
Since the BBC only provides a windows friendly stream, folks with Macs can hear it overnight on several NPR stations listed under Public on Itunes (I listen to KCRW or WBUR.
Even better, look for streams from Al Jazeera English here: http://english.aljazeera.net/N.....62E31A.htm
and Link TV’s Mosaic broadcast daily here: http://www.linktv.org/mosaic/streamsArchive/
So, while we have been innundated by HRC/Obama/McCain overkill, they are killing MORE innocent people….?!?
Stop!!!! Stop!!!!!
Hello, dear Lahoma.
Hello John in Sacto. Our former home. Before we came home.
L.
LS - each Saturday I do a scroll through several news sources, and each week there are more accounts of Iraqi civilians killed by US troops … but not reported in the US. (And horrifically, we have to assume these reports are not in any way complete)
Hello foxman.
L.
Du…Fy faen i helvede!!! Stritt imot!
Without a doubt…I can’t stand it!
Siun,
I can hear BBC from Biodun’s link on my Mac. Try Flip4Mac if you don’t have it, allows macs to play Windows Media.
Continuing our Sunday night tradition of encouraging donations to the Red Crescent, here’s an article about the work of RC aides in Gaza:
http://www.ifrc.org/docs/news/08/08020101/
He’s doing well enough ctuttle a kidney removal in a baby that young is a big thing but the alternative was far worse, he’s still in a lot of discomfort but healing well. He’s happiest when we put him with the twins as babys always find other babys fascinating and he seems to like the way they gurgle and wave their assorted paws at him :-)
Erdla and I have forgotten the meaning of “sleep” :-)))
And torture cases, of course, we only learn about MUCH later. Still, to imagine it’s not happening is, I believe, naiive.
Thanks Foxman … I continue to be mad at the Beeb for their refusal to directly support Macs (and having listened to them each night for over 10 years, it’s gotten personal y’know )
Oh, Du, my heart goes out to you, your family and your extended family. Now, and whenever I see you at FDL. Thank you for all you do. I will stop now, because whatever else I might say just won’t measure up…
But you certainly haven’t forgotten the meaning of the word love, I’m quite sure. : )