There are many reasons economic immigrants come to this nation—driven out of their home countries by bad trade deals that fail to consider the impact on workers or because they are fleeing unfettered corporate greed that seeks out impoverished nations to pay the lowest possible wages. Last week in this spot, I took a look at why border crossings start in the boardroom.
Once in the United States, immigrants are ripe for employer exploitation—and many U.S. employers don’t hesitate to do so.
In the past several years, nine farm workers died working the tobacco fields of North Carolina. Thousands more suffer work-related sicknesses from heat and chemicals from the tobacco, according to the Farm Labor Organizing Committee (FLOC). Last fall, hundreds of tobacco workers rallied at the headquarters of tobacco giant R.J. Reynolds to demand safer working conditions and fair treatment.
This week, a six-part series in the Charlotte (N.C.) Observer describes the horrifying conditions of poultry workers, most of whom are immigrants. Reporters spent 22 months investigating the House of Raeford chicken and turkey processing plant and found the workers must endure long hours, painful injuries and are denied medical care.
Day after day, poultry workers are cut by knives, burned by chemicals or hurt by repetitive work, according to dozens of injury logs compiled by plants across the South.
Because many workers are illegal immigrants and can’t afford private care, their health rests largely with company medical workers.
Those in-house attendants are supposed to help workers heal. Instead, some have prevented workers from receiving medical care that would cost the company money, an Observer investigation has found. And in some instances, the treatments they provide can do more harm than good.
A 2005 AFL-CIO report found that the share of fatal occupational injuries for foreign-born workers increased by 43 percent between 1996 and 2000, even though employment for that group increased by 22 percent. Less than one-third of the costs of occupational illnesses and injuries are paid for by employer-funded workers’ compensation—with taxpayers picking up nearly 20 percent of the tab through Medicaid and Medicare. Injured workers and their families pay the largest share, according to Immigrant Workers at Risk: The Urgent Need for Improved Workplace Safety and Health Policies and Programs.
Documented immigrants also are exploited. Each year, 160,000 guest workers are permitted to enter the United States, supposedly to fill in gaps in our labor force. More than 25,000 of them work in the fields of North Carolina, harvesting tobacco, sweet potatoes, cucumbers and Christmas trees, according to FLOC.
Last summer, FLOC President Baldemar Velasquez told the U.S. House Education and Labor Committee that until we can protect the basic rights of guest workers already in the United States, Congress should not consider expanding that program.
Velasquez said expanding the current program would increase the corruption that plagues it and cited the longstanding problem of brokers extorting large amounts of money from workers to obtain visas. To ensure guest workers receive fair treatment, Velasquez told the committee, it is important that all workers’ rights , including farm workers’ rights, are protected, including the freedom to join a union.
Rather than improve the situation for guest workers, the Bush administration last week proposed to make it even worse. He wants to take away rights from workers here under the H-2A agricultural guest worker program. H-2A and H-2B visa programs bring agricultural and other seasonal workers into this country to pick crops, build houses and process seafood, among other jobs.
The AFL-CIO and the civil rights movement opposes Bush’s move. AFL-CIO President John Sweeney says the proposal:
will hurt both immigrant and U.S.-born workers alike. The Bush administration has shown once again that it will go to any extreme to cater to the interest of corporations at the painful expense of workers, and that it is not serious about real fixes to our nation’s broken immigration system.
It would strip the H-2A agricultural guest worker program of necessary wage protections, undermine other essential worker protections, weaken efforts to recruit workers from this country and further erode government oversight, Sweeney says.
A study by the Southern Poverty Law Center, Close to Slavery: Guestworker Programs in the United States, says it’s not unusual for guest workers to pay more than $2,500 in fees to obtain a seasonal guest worker position, about a year’s worth of income in a country like Guatemala. Thai workers have been known to pay as much as $10,000 for the chance to harvest crops in the orchards of the Pacific Northwest. Interest rates on loans brokers charge to get them into the country are sometimes as high as 20 percent a month. Homes and vehicles are required as collateral.
The solution, says Sweeney, is comprehensive immigration reform
that provides relief to the growing number of undocumented workers in our country by offering them a path to citizenship. We do not need more policies that turn our nation back in the wrong direction.
Reflecting on the findings of the Charlotte Observer series, editor Rick Thames succinctly sums up the nation’s relationship with immigrant workers:
… the neglect of these workers exposes an ugly dimension to a new subclass in our society. A disturbing subclass of compliant workers with few, if any, rights.
Same as slaves and sharecroppers, same as the cotton mill workers derisively termed “lintheads,” this subclass is now a scorned bunch.
And yet they help power our economy. We live in houses they built. We drive on highways they paved. We eat the chicken and turkey they prepared.
Related posts:





Spotlight







Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

!
Hello Tula!
Capitalism is the new word for feudalism.
It’s essentially slavery without the plantations.
Hard stuff Tula, hard stuff. And, with the economy tanking it will probably get worse.
See? Nothing’s over your head.
Smart Cookie.
We welcome you and your important message.
Ahhh…Mittens is a good little goosestepper..
http://politicalticker.blogs.c…..se-mccain/
Endorses McCandyCain
It is no surprise that slavery continues. Trent Lott is a hero in his land. There is this group of folks that profit by using people up. They are in power across the board in this land. They will not go quietly.
Tula, thanks for this great post on a really important (and depressing) subject: how do we as a people treat the least fortunate among us?
One thing that is important to recognize here is that there are fundamental differences between historic US-style slavery (defined largely by race, predicated on continuity through the generations, and supported by law) from the slavery of circumstance defined today.
new?
Dovetails nicely woth Biodun’s post yesterday.
My grandparents were share croppers in Oklahoma. Cotton.
This whole vilifying of immigrants and suspicions they might be terrorists is getting beyond ridiculous. Just saw this story today where a 14-day old infant dies while the mom is being “checked out” at the Honolulu Airport. They were on their way to obtain heart surgery for the baby. Disgusting and heartbreaking!
Opps…here’s the link:
http://the.honoluluadvertiser……/?print=on
America has become one huge Republican, corporate, share cropping plantation.
Tula,
Great Post as usual.
A friend of mine is a fruit grower in California and did a tour with an ag group to Georgia about 10 years ago. At one packing facility they visited he was aghast at because of safety issues for workers. He felt that the place was about 50 years behind the times. Growers like my friend want their employees to return each year so safe conditions are important. They also don´t want bad public relations for their industries. He was not always happy when new regulations would come down for teh state but there was no way he would operate in the manner he saw in the South.
And they do have plantations in the far East and in the Marianas, which are a US protectorate. Remember Delay and Abramoff and the Marinas garment prisons?
Hello Tula -
This sounds terrible because it is terrible. I find the way the board rooms have used immigrant labor to be far worse than slavery. When the capitalists purchased slaves it was costly. It was a mighty investment. He had to make certain they remained healthy and strong, had good food and provided shelter so the slaves were protected from the elements. It was a serious investment.
Cheap labor requires no investment in the welfare of the person. He/She can be replaced. They are throw-aways tossed like broken down used up equipment. They are thrown on the trash heap of broken bodies and spirit.
New as in no one would call it what it is. But it’s been around for a while.
And it’s worse in poultry and the carpet industry here.
You nailed it!
Why don’t people tell it like that! Where is the media with THAT narrative?
Is there a difference between the expendability of our soldiers in Iraq and the workers in our factories here at home? Both groups are somewhat collateral.
A working class hero is something to be
OT The Repub. are walking out of Congress to protect Dems not going along with Fisa vote, I think Brief update.
Steny talking inside while Boehner whining outside…
Geez, that is sad. There should be a criminal investigation. This was a total f*ckup on someone´s part.
Yes, and both are very poorly paid. Plus it is in Bush’s best interest to keep things grim at home so people will feel they have no choice but to enlist in the army.
Protect or protest?
Why don’t the dems vote without them?
The GOP walkout is being discussed in the last thread. Feel free to pursue that topic there. Thanks.
Thanks, I went back there. Sorry Tula!!
Two things I think: We are headed for protectionism and a very ugly recession.
Slavery and immigrant slave labor will always be with us until we correct the source that makes this possible. Corporations. Daily I remind myself that there is no humanity, social concern, human concern, preservation, morals, ethics in the premise of capitalism. Therefore it will never be there. You can’t insert it here and there. It must be integral to the premise.
The only checks and balances we have are regulations. If a business is applying moral and ethical standards to its business, regulations are self-imposed. If a business says it will go out of business with regulations, well, that indicates their business model is greatly flawed and as their business fails a better business will replace it. It’s Ok for bad businesses to fail.
Standing ovation for Hoyer. I think.
I’ll go back there too. Thanks for the heads up.
Sorry Tula.
Well regulated corporations and a strong labor movement with all workers represented by unions might level the playing field a bit.
But in US capitalism, labor is nothing more than a line item, like a hammer or a work bench, or a wood pallet – a commodity of labor.
When capital acknowledges that workers are humans and have rights hell will freeze over. It has been a struggle and workers have been losing ground since the hay day of unionism.
This is hardly an understatement from the from the Charlotte Observer piece.
Thanks Tula.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=njG7p6CSbCU
It’s always the same old ‘ol story, isn’t it? I do think we can correct it, but we have so far to go.
Workers. Regardless of the color of your skin, your religion, your background, your gender or lifestyle. You have two things very much in common. You are being taken advantage of in the workplace, and you have huge power if you all unite to change this atrocious situation.
Kinda crazy huh?
Does Pelosi understand nothing about political theater? She’s talking about National Heart Month. The ONLY thing that should be discussed in this press conference is the lack of accountability in the Bush administration for fighting the subpoenas. Ok, FISA too, since that’s th excuse the republics used to walk out.
Call them the whiny toddlers they are, Nancy!
As SanderO says -
There will NEVER be fair wages and respect of laborers if left up to the corporations. That can only come from the people. The consumer bears as much responsibility as the workers and the corporations. If I continue to disregard the rights of the workers I am in partnership with the corporations. The responsibility is on me to apply pressure on corporations through every means possible: supporting workers, congress, electing officials, boycotting, to mention a few.
With the Internet and netroots, never have We the People had so much power.
Bernanke: another very bad Bush joke on us. Perhaps the Fed can make it so they pay us to buy a house.
AP – Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke told Congress Thursday the economy is deteriorating and signaled a readiness to keep on lowering a key interest rate to shore things up.
How bout some healing?
NN) — Former Republican presidential hopeful Mitt Romney plans to announce Thursday that he is backing Sen. John McCain in his bid for the Oval Office, two sources familiar with the decision said.
Mitt Romney will endorse Sen. John McCain of Arizona on Thursday, CNN has learned.
A source familiar with the decision said Romney wants to endorse McCain “in the interest of healing.”
Tula, great post. You hit on everything that bothers me about our current immigration policies, tied it up into a neat package and made me eat it. Now my tummy hurts.
But what do we do about it? Much as it pains me, most of my country still wants to deport everyone. They don’t particularly care about the costs…in fact the quickest way to get someones eyes to glaze over is to start talking about the econonic impact and the costs involved. But they’re really interested in making the fence higher. And electric. Any congresscritter fool enough to vote for a sensable policy will lost his/her next election and they know it.
Boxturtle (Immigration is the sincerest form of flattery)
Great way to frame this. As a small biz owner myself, it drives me crazy how “pro-business” is framed in our national discourse. When I see that, it just means pro-MegaCorporation, and nothing to do with the biggest component of American business – the small business.
Not to mention the short-term view that typically means as well. It isn’t “pro-business” in the long term if communities are being decimated as jobs get shipped overseas or a Conglomerate Chain store moves in and shuts down several locally-owned businesses. The billionaire shareholders will be happy for another quick buck, but long term the country starts tanking, which hurts us all, and some much more than others obviously.
Immigrant “slave” labor fills the void as the already rich take more and more. Nothing will ever be enough for them as long as government stays out of their way.
“Haves and have nots”. I would be considered a ‘have not’. And I have a job. Speaking of which, my planning period is over and the kids are streaming into the classroom. Adios. For now. Time for math. Time for fun.
PARDON MY FRENCH SCREAMING…THIS FUK NEEDS TO BE IMPEACHED NOW
Bush Will Veto Ban On Torture
Thursday February 14, 2008 10:51 am
Source: CBS News (AP)
Published: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories…..0691.shtml
The White House said today that President Bush will veto a measure that would ban the CIA from using what the administration describes as “enhanced interrogation methods” on terror suspects.
RIGHT THE FUK NOW!
NAFTA is responsible for the immigration increase in the U.S.
when oh when will enough be ENUFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF?
yes ,im having a cow…..just another to add to the herd…about 10,000 head,and counting
Tula, great post. Sorry I went OT so early in the thread, but congress frustrates me a lot these days.
Of course Bush wants lots of guest workers and easily exploitable labor. Considering how much he likes torture he probably gets a kick out of desperate people getting injured or killed on the job too. Bastard.
All caps is considered shouting, so please adjust accordingly. Also, this and other issues are being discussed in the prior thread.
Thanks.
Bonkers -
This country has been hostile towards small businesses for decades now. Ronald Reagan hated them. He loved the GMs of the world. Multinationals were his favorite and they could literally get by with murder.
Republicans continue their faux concern conjuring up the image of small businesses while passing legislation that destroys them.
sorry i just saw it,and the title of the last post didnt suggest that,again my appoligies
Thanks, Boxturtle.
The immigrant workers who are members of FLOC are supported by labor activists and their communities, and they take their protest to the streets. It’s important to join together and fight back. The bigger pix solution is at the ballot box. And we’re all working for those big changes to happen at many levels in November.
I wouldn’t compare illegal immigration to slavery. They are at least mobile. There is no law they have to stay in one place.
I would compare illegal immigration or guest workers to be more comparable to a worker anywhere from the 1860’s to the 1920’s, when labor in this country was particulary taken advantage of. But at least during that time, there were some significant labor victories. There is not an open fight to secure guest workers with better working conditions. The fire is not there…yet…
Thanks, AZ Matt. Good to know there are good employers out there, especially for those most vulnerable to exploitation.
Slavery and immigrant works are driven by the same premise – cheap labor. Both are moral issues. Both are human exploitation.
Well put, QuakerGirl.
well if you would like to point me toe disscussion where our president has said he will veto the anti-torture bill,i would be very thankfull
News item. Right here.
Thanks.
Thanks for another super post Tula. I work for a small business. Maybe 24 employees. In Texas. Owned by 2 life long, hard core rebups. The older of the 2 (about 60) came to me this morning with questions about Clinton and Obama and who I thought would be a better pres. He shared that he was of the opion that there would be a Dem in the W/H in Jan. of ‘09. I relay all this as a way of suggesting that perhaps, on a real fundamental level, the country is ready for some major change. Your post on Thursdays continue to give me solid info in my push for converts in a very red state. Thanks again.
So glad I turned on C-SPAN:
Republican walkout, followed by fearmongering on the steps of Congress.
Pass the popcorn, the usual dolts are replaying the “Be Scared, America” script.
You need a lobbyist man… get with the program!
Thank you Tula, your writings are most appreciated.
Slavery had advantages compared to what these migrants have. Slaves were given a roof and a place on the floor to sleep and even food. They were taken care of as animals are taken care of. Migrants nothing. Free to go to Wall Street!
False flag coming soon to a city near you.
Change in Novemeber on Immigration? I doubt it. The Dems will likely control the house, senate, and WH but they WON’T be willing to risk that for immigration. Like it or not, deport ‘em all and shoot ‘em as they try to come back is the direction most of the electorate wants. I worry about humanity sometimes.
IMO we need to start this at the very bottom. First, we have to put a human face on the problem so folks will maybe get off the Scary Brown Wave concept. The protests are a good beginning.
Next, we need to FORGET about humanity. We need to sell this to people as being in their economic best interest. Because people will vote their wallets once the voting booth closes.
Boxturtle (cynical bastard that I am)
nobody should ever answer a subpoena….why the hell bother
My brother used to be in the construction supply business, running a local yard that supplied drywall to construction sites. He saw some ridiculously unsafe (not to mention illegal) practices at a construction site, and pointed it out to the supervisor (as delicately as he could, because he needed the business, but it was really bad). The guy shot back something like “They’re just Mexicans. If they break, I’ll just get me some more Mexicans.” That and a few other incidents were pretty much the last straw; my brother wound up resigning even though he didn’t have another job.
Some people want to deny that illegal immigration has a negative effect on US workers, because we don’t want to sound like the anti-Mexican bigots. But construction work used to be largely unionized, and a high school graduate who learned a trade could by a house and have a middle class life. My father used to run heavy construction sites back in the 70s; his company built parts of the DC and Baltimore subways systems, among other things. The company was unionized, and paid well, and he always taught us how important unions were, even though he sat on the management side of the table. Now construction work pays about half, or even one third, of what it paid in the 1970s, because the unions are dead and foremen can hire cheap, powerless labor, people too scared to complain that they have no safety equipment, no benefits.
We need to give immigrants some kind of legal status so that they can’t be exploited, and we need to give workers the protections they deserve. Then we need to get them into unions. But we cannot pretend that it is progressive to effectively support the current look-the-other-way status quo, because it creates a servant class, a bunch of people who will cut our lawns for cheap and do a better job than the teenage boys who used to do it.
well the smart ones will,than there is the other 29%
I’ve had people try to argue with me that corporations by law need to maximize profit. If they do things against this goal, shareholders have the right to sue that corporation owner/controller. Thus, if a corporation has an opportunity to lower labor costs (immigrant labor), they need to pursue that since the competition will.
Seems such an easy counter to that to argue for the long-term sustainability of a community and country at large, the taking advantage of people will lead to a community, in other words customers, being decimated in the long term. So to maximize profits for a longer period of time, which would then mean more total profit eventually, a corporation needs to pursue sustainable practices in order to meet their corporate charter.
Usually just get, “Uh…hmmm…good point. I’ll have to think about that…” or some such response. All about framing and that’s why the ways the BigMedia drills certain storylines into our heads is so crucial. We end up having other small business owners voting in Repubs and Dems who are thought to be “pro-business,” who then enact laws that are killing our economy.
Seems like people might be understanding this better nowadaze though…I’m hopeful.
Ha! I’ll be happy first with just getting an office with a lobby. Then maybe I can start thinking about a lobbyist. ;)
Whoa. Contempt of Congress. It’s a much bigger deal than the media is making of it so far, I think.
So how about eh ExxonMobil suit against Venezuela that the courts have sided with ExxonMobil?
How are the fine, upstanding ‘Merkins going to like it when China and Dubai start using the courts in their disputes with American businesses?
-G
We are now entering into constitutional crisis mode.
‘Bout f***ing time.
-G
That’s one of the very few things that Bush and I agree upon: We both hold congress in contempt.
Boxturtle (I prefer to think of it as Bush agreeing with me, rather than vice versa)
Did you get my two emails?
Hello Tula!
Late coming to the thread. I’ve been mostly in transit today…
Tula needs to start a think tank!
Here’s a great one! Justice Alito, after defending the use of torture as a tactic to get a potential terrorist to spill the beans, then goes on to blame “The Spranos” for making people think Italian-Americans are a bunch of violent Mafia Dons that use torture to make their enemies squeal.
Alito castigates Sopranos
Seems to me that Judge Alito is doing a pretty good job himself of impugning New Jersey Italian-Americans as a bunch of brutal, violent thugs.
I think I’m limited to foyerists.
hehe
Christy has a new thread upstairs….
FWIW, it was Scalia who was defending the use of torture.