You really can’t beat P.R. like this:
The most famous journalist you may never have heard of is Sami al-Hajj, an Al Jazeera cameraman who is on a hunger strike to protest abuse during more than six years in a Kafkaesque prison system.
Mr. Hajj’s fortitude has turned him into a household name in the Arab world, and his story is sowing anger at the authorities holding him without trial.
That’s us. Mr. Hajj is one of our forgotten prisoners in Guantánamo Bay.
Here we are in America, where our we have three 24 hour news networks, hundreds of newspapers, periodicals, etc. and, of course, a series of information delivering tubes, and I’ve never heard of this guy, specifically, until today.
Suppose the Iranian government arrested and beat Katie Couric, held her virtually incommunicado for six years and promised to release her only if she would spy for Iran. In such circumstances, Iranian investments in public diplomacy toward the United States wouldn’t get very far, either.
After Mr. Hajj was arrested in Afghanistan in December 2001, he was beaten, starved, frozen and subjected to anal searches in public to humiliate him, his lawyers say. The U.S. government initially seems to have confused him with another cameraman, and then offered vague accusations that he had been a financial courier and otherwise assisted extremist groups.
So he is being held to cover their ass — and make sure he doesn’t tell his story in detail to the Arab world?
Nino Scalia would approve.
Most Americans, including myself, originally gave President Bush the benefit of the doubt and assumed that the inmates truly were “the worst of the worst.” But evidence has grown that many are simply the unluckiest of the unluckiest.
Some were aid workers who were kidnapped by armed Afghan groups and sold to the C.I.A. as extremists. One longtime Sudanese aid worker employed by an international charity, Adel Hamad, was just released by the U.S. in December after five years in captivity. A U.S. Army major reviewing his case called it “unconscionable.”
Mr. Hajj began his hunger strike more than a year ago, so twice daily he is strapped down and a tube is wound up his nose and down his throat to his stomach. Sometimes a lubricant is used, and sometimes it isn’t, so his throat and nose have been rubbed raw. Sometimes a tube still bloody from another hunger striker is used, his lawyers say.
“It’s really a regime to make it as painful and difficult as possible,” said one of his lawyers, Zachary Katznelson.
Mr. Hajj cannot bend his knees because of abuse he received soon after his arrest, yet the toilet chair he was prescribed was removed — making it excruciating for him to use the remaining squat toilet. He is allowed a Koran, but his glasses were confiscated so he cannot read it.
All this is inhumane, but also boneheaded. Guantánamo itself does far more damage to American interests than Mr. Hajj could ever do.
To stand against torture and arbitrary detention is not to be squeamish. It is to be civilized.
The Legacy of Bush.
Stupidity, abuse, injustice.
Now perceived world wide as the American brand.
Thank goodness, John McCain can’t be bothered with altering it.
Related posts:





Spotlight








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

heckuava post!
(and zed)
Attaturk!
Hello again, kirk…I thought you were going to bed…*g*
341 at most!
i woke up early this mornin n meant to git back in bed till i red that thar articull by mr kristoff. tiz the kinda thang to keep ye awake, witch i wish everbidy wood wake up n real eyes we are losin everthang that matters to us, bit by bit, weasly vote by weasly vote.
nor me
how long before we could relcaim tbe reputation lost under one administration, how long
if at all, generations
Gov. Sptizer:
My emphasis. Please check it out and tuck it away. You’ll need it again pretty soon.
OMG, only 11 more months of this vile administration. The filth we will find will make the Augean Stables effort look like a Saturday afternoon car wash.
My friend, you just don’t understand!
Ha! War Crimes for the Bushie! Guantánamo is under his direct control. Wait! a minute Congress does not make the rules there, the the Decider does.
So Bush by showing a decided willingness to write signing statements that nullify laws Bush shows that He not Congress not the United States government is responsible for what happens there.
In other words a friendly Supreme Court can’t save him from actions that are international war crimes committed outside of their jurisdiction.
All we need to do is turn him over. Or if he really does move to Paraguay inform the Secret Service that they must comply with any request from the Hague Court on War Crimes.
Lets not forget the payday loan loanshark companies. Let not forget that Pawnshops are doing great under the Bush economy, and lets not forget McCain wants four more years of the same!
Good morning, pups. 341 days to go. It’s Collins, Cohen and Kristof in the NYT today. TOMC says Democrats are having an exciting race for the presidential nomination, which always means trouble. Roger Cohen says the fact is that the independence of Kosovo is justified, unique and unavoidable. Mr. Kristof says America spends millions of dollars bolstering public diplomacy to the Islamic world — and then undoes it all with Guantánamo Bay. (But you know that, because Attaturk links to and quotes his column.)
http://mgpaquin.wordpress.com/
The coffee, tea and hot chocolate are ready, and I’ve got cranberry pecan muffins this morning. Have a grand day.
and then undoes it all with Guantánamo Bay.
That table might wind up with a 7-courser on it yet. (In spite of everything I really am a cock-eyed optimist, you know.)
tell me I am wrong BUT, did the great war hero, the most famous POW do a Flip Flop on Waterboarding? Please tell me I,m wrong.Please!!!
Attaturk is Al Quieda, the Sunni, Shia, Taliban etc are any of our enemies torturing Americans prisoners that we know of? I would think that if they were Bush would be using the morally bankrupt “me too/them too ” defense to justify his actions.
I seem to recall an execution on tape of prisoners before but no mention of torture?
Which after 6? years seems it remarkable that a whole society under the stress of a foreign occupation might be more moral than American Supreme Court Judge Scalia.
Good Morning, Firepups!
It’s overcast and cold in central Jersey this morning. Great post, Attaturk. Our government does this in our name–and I am ashamed. That shame is what motivates me: to contact my representatives in Washington, urging them to shut down Guantanamo. I hope that the first order of the new Democratic president in 2009 is to close Gitmo, allowing those prisoners just recompense, and then burn the place to the ground. Bush and Cheney should be tried in the Hague for war crimes.
Time to make Valentine’s Day treat: brownies for the very chocoholic Mr. NJP. We’re have our annual “heart attack on a plate” dinner: Marcella Hazan’s recipe for spaghetti carbonara.
Marion, thanks for the cranberry pecan muffins! They sound delicious!
Work for peace, every day!
Has anyone else read the Valentine love letter from kurtz to tweety in the WaPo today?
Sorry, but I refuse to link drivel.
Yeah, McCain voted against it. I can’t believe the press isn’t all over that.
Good Morning,
Hearts and Flowers to Everyone!
Here’s what’s coming up on Washington Journal:
7am – Newspaper Articles & Viewer Calls
7:45am – John Hofmeister, Shell Oil, President
8:30am – Rep. Randy Forbes (R-VA), Armed Services Readiness Subcmte., Ranking Member | Related Link
9am – Newspaper Articles & Viewer Calls
9:15am – Rep. Jerrold Nadler (D-NY), Judiciary Subcmte. Chair
9:45am – Newspaper Articles & Viewer Calls
I’m shocked at this! I didn’t know Katie was a journalist…..
Close Guantanimo.
I am ashamed of this government period.
Hey Elliott:
Will you be my Valentine? *g*
as long as your other Valentine’s don’t mind! :)
Touche, Elliott…*g* (I guessed I walked into that one…)
OT
I have tried to find all the “democratic” critters that voted against the FISA extension last night. Does anyone know of a list showing what state these traitorous bastards are from?
Altmire
Boren
Boswell
Capuano
Costello
Davis, Lincoln
DeFazio
Doggett
Filner
Hall (NY)
Hinchey
Holt
Kucinich
Lee
Lewis (GA)
Mahoney (FL)
Moran (VA)
Murphy (CT)
Murphy, Patrick
Pallone
Pascrell
Payne
Peterson (MN)
Rothman
Sanchez, Loretta
Sarbanes
Schakowsky
Serrano
Udall (NM)
Walz (MN)
Waters
Watt
Woolsey
Wu
These are the dems that did not vote
Hinojosa
Honda
Lowey
Ortiz
Ruppersberger
Towns
I’ve been saying all along, this is a sick sexual perversion, this has absolutely nothing to do with gathering information
check out my bold;
oh, and “we don’t torture”?
tell me these aren’t sick bastards, tell me we can ever undo the damage these maggots in our administration have done to this ONCE proud republic
WHAT THE FRIG?
Have no fear the Reeevvvvereend Obam shall save the world for all mankind.
John Hofmeister, The President of Shell Oil is up on CSPAN for the next 45 minutes, energy policy
Good morning. Got a chip on my shoulder this morning, so sent CSPAN this email:
Good morning all.
This presumes of course that the millions of dollars spent did any good in the first place. Based on what I’ve read about the chimp’s Middle East public diplomacy efforts and his chosen emissaries, that presumption is pretty questionable. So there probably isn’t very much to undo anyway.
Isn’t it a good thing that the FISA bill is going nowhere? I mean, I know it’s not as good as stripping the immunity and all that, but Bush can’t veto this and it means that it goes back to the law as it was a while ago, with FISA courts intact, right? I must be missing something.
And what about Wexler and Boxer tearing into Condi yesterday? Not a word in the NYT, or anywhere else.
Good morning and happy heart-throb day!!
For some years I have thought our malaise akin to Germany’s flirtation with fascism, but I now believe the rot far deeper and systemic in nature. Our plight is like unto the destruction of the roman Republic. It is unlikely that we shall be able to recover sufficiently to ever again pretend to ‘democracy’ and our once-proud boast of ‘government of the people, by the people and for the people’ will be simply quaint nonsense babbled by empty, mindless little cretins whose miserable ’security’ is a prison, of both mind and spirit.
Our mercenary hearts shall thrill to depravity and destruction, as our ‘leaders’ extoll us in our virtue and orderly obedience.
‘Shame’ is a luxury reserved for genuine human beings. We shall not find the strength or inspiration to, ever again, dare such a meager purview as upright humanity and self-governance …
Speaking of which, what happened to the Times’ great flatulator? Is Friedman taking another sabbatical?
Please read the whole column quoted herein, it is stunning — as is John McCain’s perpetual silence regarding the Bush torture regime. Silence is complicity. Most of the Republicans voting for McCain are looking for a conservative with some integrity and he is spitting in their face to curry favour with those in his party who have none.
Please read about the Committee to Protect Journalists http://www.cpj.org/ and Reporters Without Frontiers http://www.rsf.org/rubrique.php3?id_rubrique=20 to learn more about this journalist and others.
Far more journalists have been killed in Iraq thus far than in all the years of U.S. involvement in Vietnam. And more than in World War II.
The longer this goes on, the less the outrage, the more debased the nation becomes, the less a reason there is to fight to preserve a system that is but a mere memory.
-G
They can’t offer anything that would be contrary to the ‘maverick’ myth.
-G
Perris
We deserve the loss of reputation because damn few Americans rejected the opportunity to cross to the dark side. Bush isn’t the one shoving a feeding tube down that guy’s throat. It’s some guy who thinks he’s following orders and maybe he is. Maybe he thinks if he doesn’t do it, he’ll join the guy in a cell with a feeding tube threaded down his throat. And here I’m no different. I don’t know what I’d do in that guy’s shoes. Except for some blog posts, I’m not protesting much. Another tax bill comes due and I’ll pay it.
The writer’s strike was an opportunity lost. Think of the powerful message of millions avoiding the movies. We need internet organization where each of us, individually, decide on collective action. I’m not talking hierarchy with a purported leader telling everyone what to do, but a place where individuals pledge they will behave a certain way. Trouble is we don’t trust each other enough to believe, sight unseen, the others will do as they pledge. We fear standing alone. If ten million took a holiday from paying taxes, that might get someone’s attention or there might be a legal means of protest like not going to the movies to demonstrate the people’s muscle. It’s something we should kick around. I’m not even sure how we go about doing that.
Ekunin;
Some will, no doubt, take you to task for ‘advocating’ or even broaching such ‘troublesome’ responses to tyranny.
Indeed, we have NO way of easily trusting anyone, not even ourselves, with regard to thoughts about ‘what’ we should ‘do’ beyond cajoling, begging or voting for far ‘less’ than is needful.
While the supremely powerful may stage a successful coup at their whim, the un-powerful must NEVER contemplate ’serious change’ out loud. There is no risk-free place or ’secure’ time for such behavior in a de-mock-racy.
All options are forbidden us until is is ‘too late’.
But, kick ‘it’ around? We should.
How ‘real’ do you think such ‘discussion’ should be? Lives and fortunes-time? Or just for ‘kicks’?
Supposedly 70% of the people don’t like the way things are going-for the life of me I can’t understand how anyone supports Bush-but that’s beside the point. The question is how can that 70%, assuming it’s a valid number, acquire a meaningful voice other than through emails, online petitions, telephone calls to Congresspeople, etc. How, for example, do we organize a general strike on line? Or if people fear loss of employment, these days that a consideration, how do we reach people for something massive? I don’t mean traveling to DC for a demonstration. I mean something national, something that happens everywhere. I’m not at the point of insurection, though a third party has attraction for me-I am not as hopeful for the Dems as some, but I like Obama-a big win for him may solve some problems-I’m sure (hope) he’d close Guantanamo. All I know is we somehow have to use the internet to give power to the people. I don’t know how and I’m not sure the people want power.
Ekunin,
I agree pretty much with all of your points, concerns and speculations, although I suspect we are roughly at the point where Rome was when Augustus had conferred almost all power on himself, much as Bush has done.
The difference is that Augustus did not intend to destroy the fundamental viability of the state, as Bush so clearly intends.
I hope that FDL and its ‘community’may be willing to encourage these broader discussions of what might actually be the beginning of a serious ‘push-back’. That will require discussion of topics which some here shall find both ‘different’ and ‘ground-breakingingly’ that is, different from what might once have been considered easy, ’safe’ and comfortable.
If the internet is to have the salutory affects which so many extoll, then it must serve as the vehicle which moves and distributes the very ideas you’ve touched upon.
I commend your courage and thoughtfulness in daring to raise these ‘questions’ and sincerely hope and encourage you to continue with bringing such heightened and rousing notions to the fore.
If one person is without rights, we are all without rights. We all have a possibility of this kind of treatment being done to us.
This has got to stop. The number of jihadists this kind of thing creates we will never know.