Krugman:

McCain has said on a number of occasions that he doesn’t know much about economics — although, straight-talker that he is, he has also denied having ever said such a thing. But one thing he thinks he knows is that the Bush administration has been spending like a drunken sailor. Has it?

Consider the actual record of spending. Never mind dollar figures, which grow because of inflation, population growth, and other normal factors. A better guide is spending as a percentage of GDP. And this has increased, from 18.5% in fiscal 2001 to 20% in fiscal 2007.

But where did that increase come from? Three words: defense, Medicare, Medicaid. That’s the whole story. Defense up from 3 to 4% of GDP; Medicare and Medicaid up from 3.4% to 4.6%, partially offset by increased payments for Part B and stuff. Aside from that, there’s been no major movement.

Behind these increases are the obvious things: the war McCain wants to fight for the next century, the general issue of excess cost growth in health care, and the prescription drug benefit.

So the next time Mr. McCain or anyone else promises to rein in runaway spending, they should be asked which of these things they intend to reverse. Are they talking about pulling out of Iraq? Denying seniors the latest medical treatments? Canceling the drug benefit? If not, what are they talking about?

McCain can’t open his mouth without saying these two contradictory things — we should’ve had more troops in Iraq, and we were spending too much money. Nobody ever calls him on it.

But with this embrace of "magical economics," he really does prove he’s a true conservative.


Related posts:

  1. The Max Tax: Baucus Keeps Up His End of Secret PhRMA Deal
  2. Rahm: White House Open to Triggers
  3. Frank Rich: McCain Was Wrong On Everything. CNN Treats Him As Sage
  4. HR 3962’s Expansion of Coverage Would Result in Very Small Increase in Health Care Spending
  5. Breaking: Pelosi Unveils Merged House Health Care Reform Bill