It was just under a year ago, that the Chimperor Disgustus rejected the findings of a commission of wise old hands (the Baker-Hamilton/Iraq Study Group) and said we’re stayin’ in Iraq forever!
And now that they are prematurely declaring victory…again, let us look back on that year and the reactions it had (and no, I am not above sleeping in on the holidays by using archival material from my primary blog).

And the Right-Wing Reacts…[The Corner for Example]
IRSG [Jonah Goldberg]
I’ve only had a chance to glance at the front cover of the Jesus-Mary-Joseph thingy and I have to say that I’m not surprised. I’m no religious scholar, but I don’t think many of the people on this Commission know much about war, other than the brownish and muslimy Mohammad. I mean looking at them they seem like something out the bar scene in Star Wars. Besides if Bush had been able to pick his own Commission, instead of having it forced on him by God, he would have been smart enough to have picked it like Kirk did in that one Star Trek episode where that rock creature allowed him to be assisted in a battle to the death and Kirk picked Lincoln. That’s what Bush should have done, insisted on Lincoln being on the Commission.
Posted at 7:01 a.m.
Betrayal [Bill Bennett]
Frankly, I am enraged at the tone of this report, or at least what I have heard of it. George Bush has spent most of the last ten to fifteen years worshipping Jesus, saying he is his favorite philosopher, attending Church, and reading books about how to be more like Jesus. For this Christ-guy to suddenly write something critical of how George Bush has acted, and to suggest things that are in opposition to what the President has done, seems to me to be the ultimate betrayal. And to think that this guy is said to have experienced betrayal first-hand seems rather to make it even worse. Jesus and the rest of these people should be embarassed at criticizing George Bush in public like this. They really should have chosen the alternative of saying nothing at all.
Posted at 6:56 a.m.
Mitt Romney, future President comments on the IRSG [Kathryn Jean Lopez]
(via Press Release) I am appalled at the recommendations of the Jesus-Mary & Joseph Commission. This is not the work of the Jesus I know. The philosophy it espouses, of peace, understanding and fellowship is clearly pre-9/11 thinking and the type of policies that this nation, the greatest and freest nation on Earth, can ill-afford to allow debated or spoken about.
Posted at 6:54 a.m.
SURRENDER [Victor Davis Hanson]
This document is nothing less than what Neville Chamberlain tried to pull over on the Jews during the Masada campaign before Napolean and Tamerlane came and saved the day. It is nothing less than surrendering to peace, when War is a LOT more fun to write about and discussed on Hannity & Colmes, where I will be appearing at 8:00 p.m. eastern this evening.
Posted at 6:46 a.m.
And so it would go…
I’m sure that at the end of the day, a year later, the year of the greatest refugee creation and the year of the most American deaths, we can now all take stock of the latest events and pat George Bush on the back…or maybe do something else entirely:
A suicide bomber exploded a pickup truck outside a residential complex belonging to a state-run oil company north of Baghdad on Tuesday, killing 22 people and wounding at least 50, local officials said.
Local authorities said that victims were still being pulled from the rubble of two destroyed buildings and that the death toll was expected to rise. At least three children were killed in the blast, which came amid a downturn in violence in the country.



55 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Does Doughy Pantload know that Lincoln is dead? He is pretty stupid.
Atta boy, Atta J……
H.L. Mencken is smilin’ down on you.
Just got in on the redeye from Toronto to LAX, soon to leave (Boxing Day) on a road trip to down hill & cross country ski up near Bend OR. Hey attaturk, Happy Hols, your post is excellent, image post included…
Since I’m currently in film research & restoration, here’s a Merry Christmas from Warner Pathe News (worth the time to watch alone for the cameraman/newsmen-women from that era):
Merry Christmas & a more peaceful New Year:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CM1KB2uuf80
Bwahhaha! Last minute shoppers save Christmas is the story today watch in 4-5 months that, that number gets “revised”. Elaine, Mitch’s Beard is the one we need to watch,
Merry Christmas!
Good morning pups.
Merry Christmas Each and Every One, (as small voices are wont to proclaim)
The Christmas Pizza awaits, later
But Atta, Pulitzer Prize Winner! There is a waronterra. It’s real I tell ya….REAL.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/…..78089.html
We’re fightin it hahd too!
Okay, Christmas at my house began at 6AM EST and is now officially over…yes , over in one hour. All that craziness and it’s over in one freaking hour! Maybe this is the War On Christmas we should be fighting, you know, making the Christmas magic last longer? I’m in!
Hope everyone is having a good day so far. ;-)
We need a Lefty Business Channel Elaine’s Labor Dept is putting out false numbers Ableson of Barron’s has been making that case repeatedly for awhile, and hey if the guys who put out the WallStreet Journal do not believe you.
Then why should Lefties? My German Solarworld and my Danish Vestas wind systems both Alternative energy stocks do not get a full chart from Google, so I can not link or stockblogwhore them here.
Kos had a good bit about American made solar cars and Solarnano which are still private companies IPO’s baby! Initial Public Offerings I still can’t believe Kissenger got in on Google’s IPO.
What is there Special treatment for war criminals? We need Lefties to invest at least what we can afford to lose in alternative companies, good ones.
I do not see how we can do any worst than CNBC, Fox Business Channel etc, Actually by being selective maybe once every 6 months we could magnify our buying power and increase our results.
Now if we were to do this we would have to be better than Kudlow of CNBC, but if Jane has a dartboard and blindfold?
Or never mind picking on Kramer, Kudlow is Laffer Curve, Milt Friedmen is working almost every show. We need to start holding him up to some serious SNARK.
Merry Christmas to everyone.
Morning Christmas Pups! So has anybody here declared war on Christmas yet…I keep waiting for the email.
Although one of the education channels said the modern Christmas Celebration was all about giving the lower classes something else to do but riot.
Funny Christmas as a form of capitulation to lower class, CLASS WARFARE seems totally against Bill’ O’s idea for the holiday but I like it.
Oh yes, something for you all to enjoy.
Ok to be fair someone getting paid with a stronger stomach than me needs to hold Kudlow up to some serious SNARK. Although paying people to watch Kudlow might violate the Geneva Conventions.
The only war on Christmas that I would support is a war to end the commercialization of it. Imagine if all the energy and resources that are dumped into one day, and were spread through out the year to help end the suffering of the poor, the road to be be a great society would be a short one.
My Grand Father thought the moon landing was fake. He thought those guys got drunk in the desert and only thought they were on the moon. Those pictures are kinda convincing me that he may have been right.
Heck even a 10% sales tax on all Christmas sales for a month before and after Christmas that went straight to the poor would be a great idea. Plus we Lefties would have a whole year to push this WAR ON CHRISTMAS SELLOUTS.
Yes what an anticapitalist plan we weave hehe! a Whole year to blog whore a REAL WAR ON CHRISTMAS.
The Mainstreammedia never defended us once about Bill O’s “War on Christmas” NOW LETS GIVE HIS,AND THE MSM’s ADVERTISERS A REAL WAR ON CHRISTMAS, that they won’t like.
If nobody will stand up for us then we owe nobody!
Oh yes, Why spend billions when a million would more than do ya? ……nevermind
Merry Christmas merry pups!
and Merry Christmas from CSPAN
On Tuesday’s Program…
Every day the U.S. debt grows by $1.4 billion – a debt of almost $30,000 for each person. Federal budget analyst Stanley Collender discusses what this means for the economy. Then, Republican pollster Frank Luntz talks about the polling process, the importance of the results, & where the candidates currently stand.
that’s my bold, now where’s my barf bag?
merry christmas.
from mcclatchy:
Good morning.
Went looking for the good news from Italy. Is this it?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/7159666.stm
…about indictments, mentioned in previous thread. These, however are arrests.
Gotta go. back later for news.
gee selise Fox News doesn’t see it that way
EPu’ed for eCAHNomics.
G’ morning in this BlueState House, tired but happy after sharing others’ festivities all these past days. Would love to have basil mustard for the next festivity where a turkey is to be the star.
Are you still thare eCAHNomics?
P.s. in the past 24 hours, unless I am confusing things, we have learned you ski, eat venison, and make mustard: anything you don’t do, and when the h*ll do you find the time to comment so much and well?
ya’lls hard core up in here. merry xmas
more:
i don’t think i’ve said recently how much i hate fox news.
and the bottom line, this president doesn’t seek or expect advise, he writes the advise he expects to get
the only surprise from this commision is the fact that bush actually commisioned a study without being able to tell them their findings ahead of time
i’ve gotten in the habit of reading the morning’s news in one browser window while fld is open in another. not hardcore, just a creature of habit – the morning news comes with fdl and a cup of coffee.
merry christmas to you to, raven.
and a cheerie and gracious “Bah humbug” to you too
Merry Christmas to all you wonderful pups. The NYT has a lump of coal for all of us this Christmas morning — a solitary Bobo. He’s writing on the Sidney awards. This year, the Sidneys come in two batches. On Friday, he’ll celebrate more polemical essays, but today, he honors articles that captured different (and often illogical) slices of American life.
http://mgpaquin.wordpress.com/
The coffee, tea and hot chocolate are all ready, and so is a batch of stollen, made using the recipe Mr. Marion in Savannah’s German grandmother used. It’s traditionally served with unsalted butter, so I’ve got enough of that to go around too. Enjoy, and have a particularly joyous day.
Well I got a Christmas flamingo (A flamingo with a wreath around it’s neck and a cute red cap, which you would normally see on a duck). It’s hysterical, and I love it.
The gift that you can give everyday: http://www.theanimalrescuesite…..s?siteId=3
No Elliott this is great now how many members of Congress and the Senate are millionaire’s? Those pus bags voted for the budgets so they should pay for them. God what a great talking point I bet the bought and paid for MSM never mentions it.
I don’t mean to disagree Elliott but so much bad news comes our way that if I didn’t try to spin or snark it in our favor I would go nuts.
Allthough despite the MSM we are winning the hearts and minds of America more and more every day as our poll numbers show. Our ideas about Ending the War, Health Care etc are more popular than the president the Republicans and sadly our bought BY SOMEONE ELSE AND PAID FOR BY SOMEONE ELSE CONGRESS.
Now when I find the guys who are blackmailing Nancy and Harry ARRRGH! Well it won’ be pretty!
But just imagine how popular our ideas would be if we had the Fairness Doctrine back and we could get 50% air time for our ideas with real Lefties and not Colmes or Juan Willaims arguing them?? Imagine how much airplay we would get if Mitt’s Bain Capitol didn’t own ClearChannel and Rush, Glenn Beck etc.
Just imagine how happy the stockholders of the MSM and Clearchannel in particular would be if we 70%ers would listen, read, or watch their stuff. The FCC would not need to *cough* relax media consolidation rules to help an MSM less and less people are willing to buy anymore.
This writers strike is great after all I would stop reading the Lake when Avatar or Battlestar Galactica wold come on.
An uneducated electorate in a polarized election suddenly stuck with no new tv programing? Horror of Horrors for the GOP and our center Dems they should forget about breaking the Union which is their normal want and think about the long term…because this only helps us.
The longer the strike the stronger the Left the better our chance of getting the Fairness Doctrine!
LouCostello, I’ve been looking to thank you for the gift of Jeff Healey the other night. *s*
Merry Christmas all! I was quite pleased to read the WaPo article on recess appointments. Ah, just gave me the “warm fuzzies” all over!
Funny how the Borkean concept of “original intent” fell away once it was no longer useful!
forgive me TCU, I’m not sure what you are disagreeing with me about.
Bobo for Christmas Noooo! Santa lies! I was not that bad! Oh wait could it be?
Is Bobo that desperate that he has to work on Christmas? I think I remember a time when the newspaper was not even delivered on Christmas.
But now under Bush Bobo is so fearful of being outsourced that he has to work on Christmas when nobody else from the Times has to.
Ha! Spin that Bobo!
No need to be forgiven the news you reported was bad. I was just trying to put a happy spin on it.
Still looking for a decent youtube of Personent Hodie [On This Day Earth Shall RIng]. Great fun to play as an organist. I always made the little kids in the choir laugh because I played the pedals with stocking feet, to feel where the next pedal was. Don’t know how people do it with shoes on.
Hi Elliott,
Merry Christmas! Glad you liked it. I ‘happened’ to see him play by mistake…and wound up so close…he ‘looked’ me in the eye.
PEACE!
Merry Christmas everyone.
I have an idea, that if Clinton were still President, the Republicans would have made an elaborate show of posting a duty officer to make sure the underhanded President couldn’t pull something SLICK, even if it had never been done. On the other hand, after all of the John Bolton type appointments, Harry Reid still tries to reach an agreement whereby nobody has to come in on Christmas. It really does remind me of the Lucy-Charlie Brown place kicking thing.
Oh, Merry Christmas, all.
I got it “Shock Doctrine” Namoi once a week taking apart Kudlow! Tell me that would not be hilarious!
Merry Christmas from Arizona…
thank you for the pick of monument valley this morning. Actually the NASA moon mission training was done up near Flagstaff at Meteor Crater
Wave at thingscomeundone …. my FDL ornament that Funnydiva2002 made is hanging on my tree
Katymine, hope you saw the Christmas Eve music post last night, with our fav Josh Groban singing O Holy Night.
I missed the FDL ornament. Link?
I was hoping that the stollen would make Bobo taste better!
Merry Christmas, all, from snowy Minnesota. And bless us, every one, but especially Jim Webb. While BushFam is doing the Camp David thingie, could someone close to D.C. storm the White House and take it back?
what bah humbug? I said merry xmas
FunnyDiva2002 made red firepup Christmas ornaments for all of us who met at the Seattle Firepup meetup.
egregious, I missed late night, actually went to bed at a decent hour AND now I am up at 5 am ;)
I wonder what the new polls from Iraq will say now that we helped Turkey attack the Kurds? Wasn’t Suliamen the Great that guy who fought the Crusaders and all modern Arabs from Saddam to the Saudi’s and Turks revere a Kurd?
I think the northern Mosul Dam is now a target. After all destroy that and sure you attack America but you also damage downstream Iraq long term. This would help the Kurds and weaken the Sunni and Shia they plan to fight later in a civil war, plus they could blame the Turks or even Us for doing it!
I hate being outmanoeuvred especially by one time allies deserting us well…because they feel they have too.
We need to fire ever General who went along with Bush. Every Retired General who went along with Bush should be banned from joining any corporate boards, consulting or lobbying. If they want to work and really are such valuable *cough* experts they can start their own companies without any direct or second, third hand etc Government contracts.
I knew it mt Grandpa was right:)
Stollen? Make Bobo taste better? Is Stollen another word for a brain transplant?
Waving Back!
Conyers does NOT care about Wexler’s Petition to start Cheney impeachment hearings!
Read the transcript from Democracy Now.
http://willyloman.wordpress.co…..-petition/
He will NOT allow impeachment hearings to take place.
Conyers knows that Pelosi will undercut the efforts of impeachment rather than helping to build a bi-partisan coalition to impeach.
Conyers knows that Pelosi will again be Speaker of the House next year and she will take him off the Judiciary Committee if he goes against her wishes. It’s a “lose-lose” for him and impeachment.
Let’s help him and the rest of the members of the House of Representatives by removing an obstructionist Speaker. It can be done and must be done to start the impeachment process.
http://www.petitiononline.com/…..ition.html
My new bumpersticker idea:
Want To Fight Terrorism? Stop Being Afraid.