David Broder, if life was an ice cream parlor he would not be vanilla but the round cardboard 5-gallon container it comes in. Today he manages to write yet another timeless column, where he surmises the Presidential race from Mount Wanklympus.
Timeless, because when you subtract the cuts and the pastes it could have been written in any prior election…and was.
Although he does take time to get in a dig at a woman, the editor of the Des Moines Register, who, because she isn’t in Washington, becomes a suitable target for all manner of misogynistic beltway scorn.
And furthermore, what of "the Dean" and his Beltway-beloved reporting prowess?
Yeah, well there’s that problem too:
In the most-watched speech of his political career, speaking on “Faith in America” at College Station, Texas, earlier this month, Mitt Romney evoked the strongest of all symbolic claims to civil-rights credentials: “I saw my father march with Martin Luther King.”…
Asked about the specifics of George Romney’s march with MLK, Mitt Romney’s campaign told the Phoenix that it took place in Grosse Pointe, Michigan. That jibes with the description proffered by David S. Broder in a Washington Post column written days after Mitt’s College Station speech.
Broder, in that column, references a 1967 book he co-authored on the Republican Party, which included a chapter on George Romney. It includes a one-line statement that the senior Romney “has marched with Martin Luther King through the exclusive Grosse Pointe suburb of Detroit.”
But that account is incorrect. King never marched in Grosse Pointe, according to the Grosse Pointe Historical Society, and had not appeared in the town at all at the time the Broder book was published. “I’m quite certain of that,” says Suzy Berschback, curator of the Grosse Pointe Historical Society. (Border was not immediately available for comment [ed: Are you kidding, "Matlock" was on!?])
Berschback also believes that George Romney never appeared at a protest, march, or rally in Grosse Pointe. “We’re a small town,” she says. “Governors don’t come here very often, except for fundraisers.”In fact, King’s only appearance in Grosse Pointe, according to Berschback, took place after Broder’s book was published.
That was for a March 14 speech he delivered at Grosse Pointe High School, just three weeks before King was assassinated. But there was no march, and George Romney was not there.
Nice reportin’ there slick.



108 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Zed.
(((((((Attaturk!)))))))
I haven’t seen a retraction of the sub-headline in the NYT, but I do expect that the Times will re-affirm that Gonzo, Addington, Bellinger and Miers were in on discussions about the Tapes.
So, maybe not ‘widespread’ in the White House, but certainly with four people who make it almost impossible not to conclude that Bush and Cheney knew about the Tapes, too.
It’s going to be a great day!
Does it shock you that these politicians lie more than soeak truth?
Prevarication is their middle name.
Someone left a linky near the end of the last thread…
Here’s the retraction (appended) via MarieRoget.
http://www.freep.com/apps/pbcs…../712200442
“He was speaking figuratively, not literally,” Eric Fehrnstrom, spokesman for the Romney campaign, said of the candidate.
Oh. HoooooKay.
So I guess conservatives like to speak “figuratively”. So when they say Saddam attacked us on 9/11 they don’t mean it literally.
OK.
The whale may be related to a deer-like beast???
Shorter Broder:
Mitt Romney is the kindest, bravest, warmest, most wonderful human being I’ve ever known.
Attaturk, doesn’t the Dean of the Press Corps deserve more respect?
nah, you’re right
OK, so this means the media children of the Village of the Damned are all going to get together and make a list of Romney’s top ten lies, and talk about his “tendency to exaggerate” every time they talk about him, right?
Oh, wait– he’s a Puke.
Nevermind.
Maybe Dr King’s family can demand Mitt and Broder do a retraction! There are way to many GOPers making stuff up we need to apply the rapid response smack down.
I wonder if the King Family can be reached for comment. I would expect the Dean to stand by his story and call the King family liars. I would expect Mitt to blame the Dean and or the King family. KO could make a whole news day with this stuff.
Did you mean soak the truth? They’re real good at trying to drown it at every turn.;-)
Has Broder published a retraction yet? Can anyone find it?
Our Four intrepid lawyers are still right in the middle of this developing story:
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/12…..oref=login
The New York Times reported on Wednesday that discussions about the proposal to destroy the tapes involved four high-level White House lawyers: Alberto R. Gonzales, who served as White House counsel until early 2005; David S. Addington, who was the counsel to Vice President Dick Cheney and is now his chief of staff; John B. Bellinger III, who until January 2005 was the senior lawyer at the National Security Council; and Harriet E. Miers, who succeeded Mr. Gonzales as White House counsel.
(snip)
The New York Times said it would publish a correction on Thursday, and noted that the White House “had not challenged the content of our story,” the newspaper’s spokeswoman, Catherine J. Mathis, said in a statement.
You said it better.
Yeah, maybe we should write to Little Debbie– she’ll get right on the case!
I may just break a personal rule & watch the press briefing today- the Dana dance & question dodge on this might be entertaining…
Grosse Pointe Blank, Michigan
there, fixed with fiction
The Dean retract? No he will ignore it unless we make allot of noise and embarrass him. Only national TV News coverage of his mistake/lie is likely to get him to mumble an excuse. He will never admit that he lied.
Although how he made a mistake like this is beyond me completely inventing things that did not happen is a little hard to believe.
OT, but here is some of the garbage that is, or rather isn’t, in the omnibus spending bill.
The War on Science continues apace.
From Casmic Variance:
What mean treaty?
Spit! The wh idjit is having his final presser of the year today at 10…where’d I leave the supply of barf bags? This oughta be good for at least three. :-(
Good One Little Debby confront the Dean and demanding a retraction? Bawhahaha!
Stock up on koosh balls or wadded up paper[WaPo works well for this purpose] to throw at your TeeVee without injuring it.
idk the dean must be apart of the Dept. of Honeypot Security.
Got it covered. LA Times works well, also ;-)
And if this were the 1890’s, he’d be the slop bucket people used to keep under their beds.
General Electric really must be desperate to sell their current fission reactors. Fusion does not produce radioactive waste if the Europeans get this working and we are frozen out we will have to buy fusion reactors from France.
GE in going for short term gain could be left behind in the dust. Never mind we don’t have any place to store our radioactive waste. Transporting all the tons of the stuff we do have by train to a storage site all those miles away is a nightmare.
All Al Quieda needs to do is blow up a train, how can we guard that many miles of train track? How much would it cost to have troops and helicopters protect every train?
“George Romney”? Sorry, that name just makes me laugh. Oh the images in my head right now!
“My father walked with zombies”?
Chris Bowers is predicting an Obama vs. Huckabee general.
I smell the hand of Darth and his secret energy commission in this. Enron exploded even after they raked in huge profits by jacking up the price of California’s electricity.
This could doom GE if they get stuck with fission when the world goes fusion.
Has anything the Bush administration planed ever turned out well?
Our current Mitt “George” Romney has sons who are traveling around the country in a super-D-duper bus to show us this is how you serve your country during a time of war. We should be thankful for this George Romney too just like the other George who hid out during Vietnam to show us how to serve the country!
See?
*bashing snark meter to stop it from working*
Does anyone know if the Romney’s boys are paid staffers? Or are they living off of their trust funds? Interesting angle if they are paid staffers. More contraversial then a $400 haircut.
I wonder if Mitt’s hedge Fund is paying them or Mitt a salary? I wonder if its illegal. I wonder if Mitt’s hedge fund is exposed to the subprime crisis?
Even if they are not being paid by the campaign we are paying for them with mitt’s tax breaks and they are gobbling up enough fuel in that damn bus to heat a few home in Maine where heating fuel costs so much people are freezing.
that’s a good question, are they being paid by the campaign?
But isn’t Romney basically funding his own campaign so in the end does it matter?
It does matter because of FEC legalities… but then he is a gooper so legal does not count
I smell the hand of Darth and his secret energy commission in this.
Did y’all hear that chimp’s EPA just blocked California’s emissions plan?
OT– they’re talking about global warming on C-Span right now. This always brings the roaches out of the woodwork.
It’s a little early for a drinking game, but– whenever a wingnut says that it’s cold outside, you know what to do.
Has anything the Bush administration planned ever turned out well? I like it I think that phrase could be a talking point for our MSM people. The War the Economy, the Stock Market, Healthcare, No Child Left Behind. Darth’s Secret Energy Commission, Privatizing Social Security, either his plans fail or they never get off the ground.
Scaring Dems and bullying them is all he is good at.
Saw this in the FDL news thingy on the home page: E.P.A. Says 17 States Can’t Set Emission Rules for Cars
Lead Headline in LA Times, dead tree version:
California Emissions Law Rejected
Here’s the online article from LAT Cali/Local section:
http://www.latimes.com/news/lo…..;cset=true
From my linky:
Sen. Barbara Boxer, who chairs the Environment Committee, said she would support a move in Congress to overturn the EPA decision, using a states’ rights argument, and make it a national issue.
States’ rights! I love it!
Enriching his buddies, stacking the Supreme court, rigging elections, disenfranchising voters, making snuff movies and blowing up the twin towers to name a few.
Yep and with gas above $3 a gallon well cleaner burning cars are more fuel efficient cars. The silent hand of the market keeps smacking Detroit but they never seem to learn. Bush knows that high oil prices are good for his family the rest of us can hang as far as he cares.
This morning I’ve already signed 3 petitions: one about the EPA blocking California’s new emissions laws, another one about Kevin Martin’s FEC decision to help Rupert Murdock, etal and, one to HUD about their decision to raze 4500 low income, perfectly good, housing.
This administration is absolutely soulless, intent on destroying every last vestige of decency in this country.
Oops, the 4500 low income housing units are in New Orleans.
Sure Bush is good at corruption but has any government policies he has made ever turned out well.
In a word. Nope
carmen, were they online petitions, and if so do you links?
I’d be interested to sign a CA emissions petition if I could locate one. LAT coverage says the Governator vows a court fight on it. He’d do well to stick by that…
The single act that I would give Bush a little positive vibe for is the Do Not Call List. That has made the dinner hour more pleasant. Definitely not a significant accomplishment. Perhaps that will be his “legacy”.
OT – Chimpy presser in 30 minutes.
Maybe Chimpy’s going to announce that Rove resigned to spend more time in the shadows?
Please don’t make me watch the Chimp. I beg you.
Ooooh, here’s a hilarious* RFP (worth $17,500,000) from the DOJ this morning:
The Victim Notification System (VNS) is a web-based victim information tracking and notification management application that automates the process of informing victims of crime about the custody status of defendants/inmates, court cases, and investigative issues. The VNS is designed to be the main source of crime victim contact and notification information for the Department of Justice (DOJ) through the United States Attorney’s Offices and the Criminal Division, the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), the United States Postal Inspection Service (USPIS) and the Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP). Information contained in the VNS is considered “Sensitive But Unclassified” (SBU). Under the scope of this opportunity the contractor shall provide professional information technology services to support continuous operation and maintenance of all aspects of the Victim Notification System (VNS) and to update the existing system technologies.
Likely bidders:
AT&T Government Solutions
Computer Sciences Corporation (CSC)
General Dynamics
Indus Corporation
Lockheed Martin Corporation (LMCO)
Science Applications International Corporation (SAIC)
Chimp’s war profiteering buddies gots they fingers in everthang!
*In light of the way they’ve treated the women raped by KBR/Halliburton
OT Did reid keep the senate in session or has he totally capitulated?
My guess he will blast the ‘democrat controlled congress’ for getting nothing done all year. they are so irresponsible, blah blah blah heh heh heh…
Sorry but you must watch. It’ll be on CSPAN 1 me thinks.
So Mitt doesn’t even know enough about what his Dad did to not rely on some staffer hunting up Broder’s erroneous reference to a Grosse Point march? MLK Jr. DID go to Grosse Point Michigan, but he apparently did so in 1967, just a few weeks prior to his assassination. I’m sure that Mitt would have remembered if his Dad went to THAT event. But that was a vociferously anti-Viet Nam War speech by King. Perhaps Mitt doesn’t want to recall THAT version of Martin Luther King, Jr. or his own peacenik Father.
http://www.gphistorical.org/mlk/index.htm
Morgan, Hugh. (1989). “Martin Luther King, Jr., in Grosse Pointe.” Michigan History, (January-February), p. 33-39.
BTW Apparently it was Senator Conyers who was involved in bringing King to Grosse Point, so I’m sure he’d recall if Governor Romney was there.
http://www.house.gov/list/pres…..19_04.html
Ok thats one thing.
And Clemons never used steroids!
Don’t worry I’m sure Bush is going to complain about the do nothing congress and brag about Iraq.
Noooooooooooo
I would rather staple Christmas cards to my forearm instead of the bulletin board. No way.
He is going to keep trying to sell an image of a fiscal conservative. LMAO. What’s next, they will try to portray Bush as a pacifist? Bush a fiscal conservative. BWWWAAAAHHHAAAAAAA. Please, Bush a fiscal conservative?????
well then here’s a viewing alternative for you chimpyphobes
RESPONSE TO TERRORISM
Fair Elections in Pakistan?
Fmr. Sen. Tom Daschle (D-SD) co-authored a report on the upcoming elections in Pakistan. He is one of the witnesses at a House Oversight & Government Reform subcommittee hearing on the vote scheduled for January. The report warns about political violence & interference in the electoral process.
scheduled for 10 am on CSPAN 2
Here’s what I’m looking for from Bush this morning:
Some humility and contrition, and awareness that he is just a man, who makes mistakes and feels responsible for his failings – and agrees with US that he Serves at Our Pleasure, and not his Whim.
Am I dreaming?
Excuse me that should be that King’s Grosse Point speech was in 1968.
Here’s another citation from the Grosse Point Civil Rights League…and it’s quite clear from this that King never marched in Grosse Point in 1963, although they did have a march there in June of that year. It’s likely that King ONLY spoke there once, in 1968, since the group makes special mention of that event. I’m dubious that Romney would have been in that early march, but if he was it’d likely be covered in the archive.
http://www.reuther.wayne.edu/c…..a_1456.htm
OT
Finally the evidence I’ve been waiting for on one subject, C-SPAN’s wingnuttery.
http://thinkprogress.org/2007/…..hink-tank/
Please email them at journal@c-span.org & express your opinion.
Maybe they’ll refer to this speech as Romney’s “I HAD A DREAM” Speech
Bush as a War President…who can’t invade the country Osama is in despite all the bribes and I’m sure all the begging he has done to the Pakistanis.
Great post, Attaturk! Only thing you might want to correct is one misspelling:
I believe my correction is a safe assumption.
Yep problem is it was the Dean’s dream.
Yes.
Another case of simple answers…
So who is the Bush tool in charge of C-span?
Didn’t one of the Romney sons field call in questions on a talk show today? Or was that “figuratively speaking”?
OT-but Guiliani is in the hospital with “flu-like symptoms.” When I went to the emergency room a few years ago with “flu-like symptoms,” they said I had had a heart attack, not the flu. They wouldn’t let me out before a quadruple bypass.
Did you hear the caller this morning who said he knows what to do? He said he’s going to go to the White House lawn and state his griefs and isn’t going to leave until he’s shot dead. Wow! Another happy American under fascism this morning!
The country has gone to hell. Thanks to all the Georgies & Dickies of our country!
I presume it’s Brian Lamb. Never seen any definitive history of the channel, but it seems to be his baby. Off to check wiki.
…and there’s been 2 or 3 callers since that have “agreed 100%” with him and want to “congratulate that man.”
Chimpster live on cspan1
President Bush up on CSPAN 1
accuses David Gregory of swiping silverware from Christmas party
Nope, missed that. My sympathies are with the caller.
Remember in the GOD (Good Old Days) of the Cold War, there was a saying, ‘Better Dead than Red.?’ Well, I always thought it should be the other way around. (That is taking the slogan litterally, where communism meant an economic system, not a political one.)
Well in fascism, not so much.
taking credit for everything congress passed, ending this year on a high note
Wow! Well, it’s not surprising. Wasn’t it last year that a man in Chicago set himself on fire during the morning rush hour traffic to protest the Iraq occupation? Yep! It didn’t get any national news coverage either. Why? Fascism baby! Dissent is not allowed to be heard, seen, or even thought of.
Your right just checked wiki
America’s War Crime Hero is now speaking!
Blue Texan has a new thread upstairs.
Commander McShitheel can’t pronounce the word OMNIBUS.
-G
chimpy whining about FISA
Thorazine slush mouth, maybe. Could be, if he’s drooling a little too.
chimpy says he will not comment on the video tape destruction until all investigations are complete. i am shocked.
George Bush can’t make any comment about the destruction of the CIA videotapes showing torture at the hands of Americans. Now why is that? How come he can’t talk about it? Oh that’s right! Five of his White House attorneys, himself, and Dick Cheney are involved!
Chimpy wondering what the new Russian president will be like. He can’t wait to gaze into his eyes and view his soul.
Chimpy will veto any attempt to weaken no child left behind.
When is DAD’s briefing?
Iraq doesn’t have a Congress like us? They don’t know how to hold votes? Well, if that is the case, time to bring the troops home, because the Iraqis are like Fred Thompson where raising one’s hand is hahd werk! Why should our troops die for that kind of behavior?
I just can’t help myself. I hate that SOB. I hate his smirk, I hate his arrogance, I hate his line of BS, I even hate his taste in ties…
Not sure.
I just realized when your ? came up I can’t stomach her anymore than GWB today, so you’re on your own as to time, I’m afraid.
shorter chimp: there is progress being made everywhere – except the democrat controlled congress
Busharraf is now saying the war in Afghanistan has been fun and Americans shouldn’t be acting so bored with it! Yes, that’s right. Busharraf doesn’t want us to forget that raping, torturing, and killing is what America does…and does so well. It’s no different than a war video game for crying out loud! That’s what Our Dear Leader believes, so therefore, we should too. Americans are barbarians is the new fascist motto, people! Jees. Get with the program.
/double snark with a tinge of angry sarcasm
He referred to the war in Afghanistan as an “experiment.”
Iraq is he and Cheney’s nation building experiment and their new country will be the windshield and central front to the rest of the Middle East for years to come! See? It’s the Waronterra brought to us by America’s One Media Compnay…the Bush Regime!
He could only stand the super bright gray shadow cast by Darth Cheney for so long. Now he’s moved deep into the darkness where no light escapes and he can use his super mole vision. Heh.
Funny he had that speech at the time when Giuliani must be thinking the same thing. Instead, that goofy-looking hucklebee is going to roll past them. Bizarre year for Republicans.
With Afghanistan, where they wanted to put oil & gas pipelines, there was no doubt Bush would view the Taliban as obstructive and protecting the enemy. They had to go. Now Al Qaeda is (apparently) in Pakistan and yet Bush doesn’t see the government there as protecting our enemy.
Maybe the Taliban had to go because they were suppressing the poppy crop! Just why is it they nicknamed George H. W. Bush as “Poppy”?
I thought the Republicans were precisely about a child’s left behind. Speaking of Rep. Foley, is he in jail yet?