There’s been some eruptions on the Gold-Plated Racism front lately:
– A Very Serious Author, using either bogus information or misusing actual data, tries to make the case that charity is icky, especially if it goes to non-European people.
– A Very Serious Pundit, using bogus studies that have already been debunked about eleventy-five-billion times over, tries to show that brown people just aren’t as good as white people and never will be.
The people behind many of these well-financed regurgitations of racism, cloaked in the mantle of faux-scholarship? Why, that would be the Pioneer Fund:
Behind the ideas of race scientists for the past half-century, there has been money — and lots of it.
If you scratch the surface of almost any of the prominent race scientists of recent decades, you will find the same well-endowed institution: the Pioneer Fund. Established in 1937 to “improve the character of the American people” by promoting the study of eugenics and the procreation of descendants of the original white colonial stock, Pioneer has funded many of the leading Anglo-American race scientists of the last several decades.
These grant recipients have included William Shockley, Hans J. Eysenck, Arthur Jensen, Roger Pearson, Richard Lynn, J. Philippe Rushton, R. Travis Osborne, Linda Gottfredson, Robert A. Gordon, Daniel R. Vining Jr., Michael Levin and Seymour Itzkoff.
Hmmm. Some of these names sound familiar. Ah, I see: Atrios has caught NPR — which along with PBS has been seriously trashed intellectually by the right-wingers Bush has appointed over at the Corporation for Public Broadcasting — treating one of the worst of them as if he was a Very Serious Person:
DNA pioneer James Watson caused a furor recently after saying Africans were intellectually inferior to Westerners. Farai Chideya talks about why the conversation of race and intelligence persists with Phil Rushton, a professor of psychology at the University of Western Ontario.
Like Watson, Rushton says people of African descent have a lower IQ and smaller brain size, which he says is “50 percent genetic and 50 percent cultural.”
Rushton is the head of the Pioneer Group, an organization dedicated to the research of intelligence and racial differences.
Ah, the Pioneer Group. AKA the Pioneer Fund. Which has ties to Jesse Helms, the oil-billionaire Hunt brothers, and various white-power groups such as the UK’s “Northern League”.
And here’s what NPR isn’t telling you about James Watson:
“Either he hasn’t paid attention to his own field for the last decade or he’s lying,” says my colleague Dr. Robert Pollack, quietly and matter-of-factly. “I’m not sure which is worse.” Pollack is a former dean of Columbia College. He has been a professor of biology since 1978 and teaches a required course that covers DNA-based evolution to 500 first-year students each year. …
“This isn’t about anything remotely contestable,” continues Pollack. “The genes that regulate the amount of melanin beneath the skin are simply not expressed in the brain. It’s been tested, reproduced, published, established. The social responses to skin color differences are real; race is not. Race is a choice. Watson chooses to hold on to a false construct about Africans. He could choose not to.”
[...]
A lot of people think a debate would be fair. What would Pollack say to a face-off? “You must understand: the London Science Museum and Rockefeller University revoked his speaking invitations not because of anything to do with free speech or fear of debate. He’s been allowed to retire from Cold Spring Harbor because he no longer speaks as a scientist. Under the First Amendment, you can be any kind of nut case and babble your piece. But honesty is the cornerstone of empirical inquiry…. You don’t, you simply cannot, either ignore or make up facts. Watson has trashed that precept. Watson’s fame rests on his being a consummate icon of the scientific profession. But he tanked the clearest of data. This is as inexplicable as it is inexcusable. The only legitimate question for debate is what conceivably could be in it for him.”
By the way: Ever notice that so many anti-tax and anti-social-spending people are also racist as all get out? Then again, they are Republicans: It comes with the territory. As Brad over at Sadly, No! says, what they’re REALLY saying is this: “No more money for stupid and hopeless ni**ers!! Spend it on no-bid contracts for my corporate masters instead!!!”
(Graphic created from this photo by yomanimus and this photo by blmurch. Both originals were posted under a Creative Commons license.)
Related posts:
- Can white liberals keep their eye on the prize when racism comes a knockin?
- Louisiana Justice of the Peace Keith Bardwell Tries to Justify His Racism
- Mopping Up Corporate Greed
- FDL Book Salon Welcomes Jonathan Tasini, “The Audacity of Greed: Free Markets, Corporate Thieves and the Looting of America”
- FDL Book Salon Welcomes Barry Ritholtz – Bailout Nation: How Greed and Easy Money Corrupted Wall Street and Shook the World Economy





Spotlight








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

PW!
Hey Phoenix Woman!
Hello, everyone!
PW!
Require basic bio and stat for anyone who wants to express an opinion on this subject.
Sullivan, Saletan and the rest clearly need to attend summer school.
Unless, of course, they are genetically incapable of learning the material.
ReBushLickens are suckers and fools.
Phoenix Woman @ 3
*waves*
watson is also a flaming misogynist – i had to walk out of a university lecture he gave about 10 years ago.
Happy Thanksgiving PW
I give thanks for you :)
Hey PW, great post!
Interesting how the wives of those racist corporate morons spend so much time trying to get brown skin — these guys literally get off on screwing people with brown skin.
Katrina made the racism and the anti-poverty policies completely transparent. Seems they would just as soon let them die.
Achtung baby.
you know, I’m beginning to think lincoln might have gotten it all wrong
maybe we should let the south break away from the north
maybe we should let all the blue states form a country and let all the red states have their country to themselves
selise @ 7
Somehow, this doesn’t surprise me at all.
perris @ 10
The problem is that there is tons of racism in the north too.
selise @ 7
this is an example to back up you up, selise
Phoenix Woman @ 11
yeah, amazing how supremist thinking is all related.
LS @ 12
they can move south
we will let anyone and everyone choose which country they want to live
and I want absolutely no religion in politics too
And this quote should be chiseled into the granite skulls of the right wing:
perris @ 10
The way the South controls elections and candidate selections, it’s like they have their own country already.
dakine01 @ 16
then there would be no gop and we can’t have that
dakine01 @ 16
Pretending to be moral and honest is a cornerstone of right wing ideology.
On the issue of race and IQ there is also another set of individuals at play in the race “game” – and in opposing affirmative action: http://pinker.wjh.harvard.edu/…..ublic.html
This is junk science as far as I can see, but then I am not a scientist (happily).
perris @ 15
But, but, but…don’t send them down here….I don’t want any more of them down here!!!!
The Saletan article is only the latest of what I call “labcoating”: taking a thoroughly-rejected notion, like racial IQ, and describing it in pseudoscientific language while at the same time distributing justifications and rationalizations across enough pseudoscientific source material as to make independent analysis cumbersome if not impossible. Thus Saletan is simply presenting racism in a lab coat. He’s obfuscating racism with scientific terminology in order to leverage scientific credibility and obscurity at the same time.
As despicable as this is, it is additionally distressing that over time the Big Lie begins to factor in, and contemporary labcoating bigots reference historical labcoating bigots to build an parallel body of scientific “evidence” to support their views, which only the diligent researcher can debunk.
Elliott @ 13
i used to think that watson’s silence about franklin’s work (effectively ignoring how central it was to his own progress) was just ego and professional competitiveness (not a good thing, but very common among scientists who try to build up their own reputation, even by putting another scientist down)… but after hearing him speak, i’m not so sure that’s the whole story.
selise @ 23
Crick’s a crook
selise @ 7
Cheating Rosalind Franklin out of a share of the Nobel Prize was a criminal act motivated by misogyny and antisemitism. Rosalind Franklin’s X-ray diffraction crystallography was the science that allowed the “boys” to play with tinker toys and “win” the Nobel. IMHO.
Steve-AR @ 25
Awomen!
??????
You know, even without the faulty “science”, the logic doesn’t make any sense.
If, in fact, non-whites don’t learn as easily as whites, then doesn’t that mean they need MORE education, not LESS? In other words, we spend extra money on the developmentally disabled so they can live relatively normal lives, so …
How their “minds” work is just baffling. We really need to spend more money educating them.
perris @ 10
You mean like this? United States of Canada and Jesusland
Steve-AR @ 25
iirc, franklin (who died quite young) was already dead when the nobel prize was awarded – so she could not have shared it.
however, imo, watson and crick should have asked her to co-author their nature paper (as it was based on her unpublished work).
Steve-AR @ 27
Looks like a version of Amen to me.
Richmond @ 20
i miss steven jay gould. he would have been all over this.
Albatross @ 22 –
“labcoating” – what i great term. hope you don’t mind, i’m planning to start using it.
PW – do you remember when Barbara Bush expressed her thoughts that those displaced by Katrina to Houston’s Astrodome were better off than when they were living in their own homes?
When was the last time Barbara Bush spent a week in a shelter, I wonder? She seemed to know what was best for “them”.
selise @ 33
quandary: what about black labs?
selise @ 30
You are right about the Nobel..but they used her unpublished data (stole it?) which is really despicable. It just pisses me off, having some understanding of the effort and mental ability needed to do the work that she did, with primitive lab equipment and no computers..and then to end up a “foot note”.
When was the last time Barbara Bush spent a week in a shelter, I wonder?
Hard to say. When was the last time the rent was due?
jayt @ 37
tax shelter, more likely.
Steve-AR @ 36
Let’s not let that happen to Marcy Wheeler.
Strange that some many of the recent white-vs-brown quackeries flutter down through the clouds above the AIP*C propaganda network.
I find the subject of male-vs-female IQ differentials more relevant to our future society.
The internet strikes again…Tuck FeeVee!
Striking Movie, TV Writers Get Last Laugh With Web Postings
The sound of TeeVees crashing down on sidewalks everywhere…
That’s what it takes to change the world!
William Shockley was a rock climber. The best rock climbing area in the east is right near my country house (met my late husband on the “rocks”), the Schwangunks, aka the “Gunks”. Shockley put in one of the best intermediate climbs on the cliffs, & named it (right of first climber on the route) Shockley’s Ceiling. You can find a discription & photo here http://www.billandcori.com/gunks/climb.htm#shock
I could never climb it without a strong pull on the rope from the leader. The crux move involves something close to a one arm pull-up (you can actually smear your feet under the overhang), but the hold is a full arm reach for me.
Steve-AR @ 27
you may be more familiar with
Amen.
;)
PLovering @ 40
YUP – ditto some of the male-vs-female. Sadly.
Elliott @ 43
One of the side effect of concrete thinking.
The reich-wingers and their master race of colonists.
That wear diapers and have wide-stances, wet suits and are crystal methodists.
Might declare based on recent press reports Republicans are the party of unbridled hedonistic hypocrites.
Steve-AR @ 36
oh, i completely agree.
PW,
Thanks for yanking away the curtain to reveal the cranks behind this nonsense. “Race” is a psuedo-scientific social construct. Our U.S. census continues to perpetuate the idea of race by continuing to use racial categories. We need a different term, like ethnicity, or ancestral affinity. At least the federal census term is now voluntary self-identification.
Bob in HI
punaise @ 35
aawwww.
An equally appalling act as making up facts is making up laws… Rummy’s case was dismissed by the French under the guise of ‘Customary Immunity’ granted to Heads of State and Govt. Depts, irregardless if they’re out of office… WTF?
http://talkingpointsmemo.com/n….._out_r.php
Here in Oklahoma, we have to put up with the worst newspaper in the country. With editorials like this:
From The Daily Oklahoman.
I used to enjoy taking advertising dollars away from them to use in the paper I worked for.
teh “coalition” looses yet another, this the lead at think progress;
pretty much it’s now “the coalition of errrr…us”
CTuttle @ 51
IOKIYAAHIF
Its OK If You Are A Hoover Institution Fellow
perris @ 53
Don’t forget Poland!
oh wait…
Its OK If You Are A Hoover Institution Fellow
They suck.
Oilfieldguy @ 52
Oilfieldguy,
I know you said that this is an editorial, but I have to ask: did a newspaper editor actually write this?
allan_in_upstate @ 54
It appears that Sarkozy is Shrub’s newest French Poodle… Now that Blair’s outta the job…
Oilfieldguy @ 56
but they’re upright
Shockley had trouble in his day job too.
I’m trying to remember what I learned in his class. Hmmm…drawing a blank. The four layer diode is kind of cool though. I started a company that used the concept in a consumer product. The only thing that survived however is my email moniker.
Maybe i’ll blame my failure(s) on him! …NAWWW
Boston, just hit the link.
CTuttle @ 58
Please don’t curb him in my neighborhood!
OT: Lebanon on brink of political calamity
How are those birth pangs working for you now, Condi?
perris @ 53
US and Blackwater. Or whatever other mercenaries we can find. Bush can point with pride to the international representation therein: Goons from Chile, Apartheid South Africa, Croatia, Uzbekistan, hey! They’re worldwide.
Bob in HI
The “Bell Curve Wars ” is a great book that takes apart the arguments in the Bell Curve plus its short.
punaise @ 59
707!
I’m making it my personal mission to convert these people when I get out to California. Some of them are probably salvageable.
punaise @ 59
Heh. How much sucking power do they have?
Bob in HI
what they’re REALLY saying is this: “No more money for stupid and hopeless ni**ers!! Spend it on no-bid contracts for my corporate masters instead!!!”
this is getting very close and it is a critically important point that it isn’t that the rich don’t want huge government, its just that they want to raid its revenue collections to further enrich themselves.
But its a little distracting and isn’t quite right that its just people of color they’re attacking. Its total class warfare – the rich against the poor and middle class, i.e., the non-rich.
The rich have been attacking and oppressing the non-rich for centuries. In America, the republicans use their racism to attack all programs that would assist the non-wealthy, regardless of the recipient’s color.
.
What the heck is this? Says it’s on FDL today at 3:28 pm. Paul and Kucinich run?
The whole immigration issue as defined by the goopers is officially sanctioned racism and the Bigot Buchanan recent’s book is the workbook.
Things Come Undone @ 65
Over in England the guy who did the heavy lifting in the Racism department was Cyril Burt, who was knighted for his work. He was the guy who figured that if they did early testing in English schools, they could decide who not to waste money on for higher education. This, of course, reinforced existing patterns of racism by making it even more difficult for racial minorities to escape from their backgrounds. They did this testing at about the 8th grade level, and your test results affected eligibility for scholarships for higher education, IIRC. Can you guess who was impacted the most?
Bob in HI
egregious @ 66
in the shadow of Hoover Tower…
bobschacht @ 67
get a load of their hosed detachment.
Loo Hoo. @ 69
Loo Hoo, did you follow the link? Took me to Ron Paul. Very strange.
Why are the Racists coming out now?
Immigration only works as a wedge issue as long as its one sided code, The brown people are taking our jobs. Notice the other side to the question is never really discussed the Corporations are only hiring brown people.
But the majority of Americans do not want to appear openly racist. Desite the best efforts of the MSM to demonize the term politicaly correct. I wonder how many Lou Dobbs voters would go to an antiimmigration rally run by the Klan?
We need to encourage/piss of the hard core racists they help our cause. The Krugman, Bobo was Regean a racist, war in the NY Times for example is helping us a lot.
Who is letting GOPers speak iabout racism without ussing code? Is the GOP that desperate, or is Karl loosing control of the message?
punaise @ 71
AKA Hoover’s last erection…
From The Daily Oklahoman.
Maybe they should change to “The Sanctimonious Sooner”?
I’d like to know exactly what Watson said. US white-vs-black racism doesn’t go by melanin. It’s directed specifically at people of African descent and skin color is just a shorthand for it. But for example, it generally doesn’t apply to southern Indians (like this guy) who are just as dark as Africans. Of course Watson can perfectly well be full of shit regardless; however, Pollack is criticising an argument that the quotes in the article don’t show Watson actually making.
neokneme @ 76
it’s a phallus, see?
Race for the Goopers is the original issue for ‘fixing the facts to fit the policy.’
They believe the Lie because they want to.
I remember reading “The Double Helix” in a 9th grade biology class and even at that tender age noticing what a stupid sexist pig Watson was. (e.g., saying Franklin should “do something novel with her hair.”) I said something about it in my book report, and the teacher chided me, saying that it was supposed to be a “very human book” and not a scientific treatise.
Hmmph!
Nice to feel vindicated after all these years.
Boston1775 @ 74
The other weird thing is that the Americans for Paul has the same little square icon on the bar thingy at the top of the page as Firedoglake – I don’t know if that means anything…?
punaise @ 79
AKA Coitus erectus
We know that old Lillie had a thing for firemen.
Is there something that Rummy hasn’t told us?
Maybe there is going to be a post on the Kucinich/Paul video.
bobschacht @ 71
How sad are they still doing this? I wonder what a graph of money spent on the education of Prince Charles and George Bush might look like vs Bill Clinton. If money does correspond to grades along with your parents education level then.
Well ok maybe I was hard on the Prince but Bush? Cheney? all the NeoCONS withcollege degrees have they ever succsed in doing anything? Have they ever been right about anything, besides stealing elections.
I want an education test that can find me a Bush so we don’t waste any extra time or money educating him. I think that if we spend education money more equally we increase our odds of finding geniuses.
I think that if we spend extra to educate a few in private schools etc, or in Darth’s case his education was more a place to hide from the draft. Then we have less eggs in our basket, sure they are really educated eggs, but what happens if a few are BAD EGGS?
Things Come Undone @ 75
It is eerily reminiscent of Germany in the 20’s and 30’s…We already know KKKarl and the neocons have followed their playbook..
selise @ 7
I know I’m late here– but his treatment of Franklin made that clear back when he and Crick first published their work on DNA.
Good evening all. Thanks for the post PW.
Damn racist bastards.
Oilfieldguy @ 56
President George Walker Hoover raised taxes when the Great Depression set in and gave corporations a block grant of $4 million to get the economy moving again.
After Hoover, the next president to preside over a lot-jobs economy is, well, you guessed it.
We be spinnin’ upstairs
http://www.firedoglake.com/200…..s/#respond
here’s to Rosalind Franklin, the brilliant scientist — taken to soon!
she wuz robbed
*raises glass*
and to every other person denied their due because of race, creed, or gender.
Donita…
http://www.firedoglake.com/200…../#comments
LS @ 86
good point, and sad. True too, it is pro-Rethug pro-business folks who are most in need of using immigrant labor for their uber profits- e.g. hotel chains (Blondie Hilton where are you, I thought you wanted to do good now?), local contractors with support-the-troops and buy-American stickers on their trucks, etc.
And as I trust we all know, one of these racist-enablers — Patient Less Than Zero — put “Brothers Welcome” on his “Barebackcity.com” profile. Why? Because he’s a masochist longing to get fucked by an HIV of a “lesser race.”
That’s why I’m giving him and his new Husbear a Freidman.
jayt @ 37
See the Republicans do speak to the interests of the poor. It’s just that all they have to say is, “I’ve got mine. Go Cheney yourself.”