Rep. Bobby Scott at the House Judiciary Committee’s Hearing on: Jena 6 and the Role of Federal Intervention in Hate Crimes and Race-Related Violence in Public Schools from last week. More video from that hearing available here. Kathleen liveblogged most of the hearing in the comments the day that it happened, while I was swamped with SCHIP conference calls, but the available video from the hearing is worth watching for everyone who missed the hearing.
The Children’s Defense Fund had a summit recently on what they are calling the Cradle to Prison Pipeline. And they have produced a thorough and well-documented report on the problems that at risk children face in America. This is especially true for kids who are born at the dangerous intersection of despair, poverty and race in far too many communities in this country, as the report sadly and amply demonstrates.
Everyone in America should read this, but especially our policy makers, because these are problems that we cannot just wish away. Nor are they problems that we can simply continue to ignore or pretend do not exist.
I was reading a heart rending article the other day by Shaila Dewan in the NYTimes on artwork produced by children displaced by the flood waters and the never-ending string of excuses and red tape and neglect in the aftermath of Katrina. Shaila is one of the few journalists who have kept on telling the human stories from the Gulf Coast long after most news folks have moved on to statistics and press releases. And her hard work and compassion shows in this one.
“At first we thought it was a fluke, but we saw it repeatedly in children of all ages,” said Ms. Leopold, who with a team of therapists has made nine visits to Renaissance Village here, the largest trailer park for Katrina evacuees, to work with children. “Then we realized the internal schema of these children had changed. They weren’t drawing the house as a place of safety, they were drawing the roof.”
Countless articles and at least five major studies have focused on the lasting trauma experienced by Hurricane Katrina survivors, warning of anxiety, difficulty in school, even suicidal impulses. But few things illustrate the impact as effectively as the art that has come out of sessions under the large white tent that is the only community gathering spot at Renaissance Village, a gravel-covered former cow pasture with high truancy rates and little to occupy youngsters who do not know when, or if, they will return home….
“The real prescription for these families is to get them back into a normal community,” Dr. Redlener said. “We’re treading water doing these things, when I’d like to take my prescription pad and write, ‘Home.’ ”
So often in my legal career, I wished that I could simply wave some magic wand and make the parents of the kids I was representing in abuse and neglect or juvenile cases act like real, caring parents. That these children would have some semblance of a real home life, and a chance at growing up instead of just barely eaking out a survival for themselves and their siblings in far too many cases. The kids in Shaila’s piece may have had safe homes at one point or another, but now due to a storm that blew in out of the Gulf, they have no settled home at all. And the results for these children are just as devastating on so many levels.
There are so many disparate pieces in the situations we keep running away from resolving: extreme poverty and despair, SCHIP, racial and economic disparities in our judicial system, and on and on and on. What it comes down to is that we make public choices — or we make none at all in an “inaction as a policy choice” mentality that Douglas Brinkley has reminded us of so eloquently in his pleas for the Gulf region — for the least of these among us.
But for the wealthier among us? We have bail-out options and market adjustments. State-engineered socialism for the wealthy, but poverty for whomever falls below the “not one of us” line of the moment.
Marion Wright Edelman has said:
When I fight about what is going on in the neighborhood, or when I fight about what is happening with other people’s children, I’m doing that because I want to leave a community and a world that is better than the one I found.
When you start thinking about every single child as one from your own neighborhood, the profound truth of the need to care for them as your own — and the impact that this sort of care could have on our entire planet — begins to sink into your soul. Would that everyone would begin to feel the need for change, because the problems in someone else’s back yard have a way of getting into yours when you least expect it. From the Cradle to Prison Pipeline report — some of the issues that need solutions, or at the very least some leadership toward a solution to the conflicts involved:
Poverty
Race
Single Parents
Grandparents Raising Grandchildren Need Support
Unmet Health and Mental Health Needs
Criminalizing Children at Younger Ages
Homelessness
Girls in the Pipeline
Substance Abuse
Juvenile Detention
Child Gun Deaths
Intergenerational Transmission of Violence
Need for Community Supports, Role Models, Mentors and Positive Alternatives to the Streets
The fact is that these issues have been batted about by professionals in law enforcement, social work, counseling, education and children’s advocacy for decades. Isn’t it time that all of us took them on? Because the price we pay for inaction is far too high for all of us. Isn’t it time we started tackling our most difficult problems proactively instead of waiting for the next dire emergency in our own back yards? Because as sure as I am sitting here typing, there is another emergency or crisis looming down the road. How about we do some prevention now instead of just getting hit with another wave?
Related posts:





Spotlight








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

ZED!
Morning, Christy! Powerful article…
Everyone’s obviously off getting their coffee ;-)
This is a topic particularly frustrating for me, since I seem to run into so many “bootstrap” people who think that these kids should just chin up and work their way out of it. I don’t know what to do about that kind of lack of empathy.
As I’ve said here before when this subject comes up, the White leadership of the Democratic Party could give a flying fuck about this. The continued enabling by the white Dem leaders of minority voter suppression and of an awful, unfair, racist criminal justice system is the biggest domestic stain on that leadership.
Good Morning Christy.
Finally getting some rain here in neOH. We’re dry and need it, but I surely wish we could share the precious stuff with some others this morning.
You are not just “back”. You’re on fire. Your mind never rests, does it, no matter where you are or what you’re doing?! Thank you for all the good fodder for thought and reasoned discourse.
peanutbutter @ 3
And this is against a backdrop of a generation who got aid: with school lunches, with the Poverty programs that worked, with Rural electrifiaction, with the GI Bill and FHA mortgages, and the whole array of direct and indirect government subsidies/corporate welfare/aid to the middle class.
They got a leg up, and now want to kick the next generation back down to Dickensian poverty and Gilded era politics.
peanutbutter at 3 — Well, there is an element of “chin up” that does have to occur. Personal responsibility is a big part of it for these kids, and it has to be, honestly. But most of them learn it all too early — as in at the tender age of 4, in one case that I worked in private practice, where a wee child was caring for his younger sibling(s) at that age. When people talk about these kids picking themselves up, they have no real idea how far up they have to look in some cases — it is a completely alien world to a lot of folks who have no experience working with at risk kids.
There is a big element of doing the work yourself. But there is also a substantial benefit to all of us having a stake in how these kids do — we learn compassion and the true meaning of sacrifice, for one thing, let alone feeling more invested in the whole of who we are and ought to be as a nation rather than dividing ourselves continuously between “us” and “them.”
Ed*ard Teller @ 4
yeah – off the top of my head, it’s hard to think of anything worse.
otoh, evidence of selective prosecution of dem politicians does appear to be something of concern (hearing has begun). guess it is our job to work for the day when concern for selective prosecution is extended to all our citizens.
great post christy.
My son, who is now 23, was essentially thrown away by his high school. He was skipping day after day and taking notices out of the mail and erasing phone messages from the school while I was at work. HE was depressed and in therapy, but until the truant officer came to where I worked, I had no idea in spite of the fact that the principal’s secretary knew me personally. I accessed every service I could find through the court, the social servica and mental health departments. I quit my job to take him to appointments and got him disability. Within three months, he was in a good group home and receiving daily care. This required my giving custody to the State and feeling his father’s wrath, but he is alive and well today and we both agree it was completely worth every heartbreaking conversation and moment.
There were other boys who were not so lucky and who ended up in jail from the halfway houses. This is not just a racial issue, this is a human issue, These were all white boys in serious mental health trouble with nobody to advocate for them.
Thanks very much Christy for shedding sunlight on Jena. It’s an example of what I refer to as the new and refined Jim Crow, because the European Americans involved substituted the noose for the “n” word.
I work in an organization where ending racism is part of our mission statement. It’s really amazing to realize how much we have benefitted as white people from the subjugation of minorities. Slavery got a lot of white folks very rich and educated. Being white gives us advantages that many of us are just not aware of. It also costs us our heritage, our culture, our individuation.
It’s not a level playing field and that is what community and social services are for. We are all better for helping our fellow man and leveling the playing field. We all benefit from improving quality of life for all. Someday I pray that we realize this. The first step is recognizing white priviledge and using it for the good of all, instead of selfishly profiting from it.
Congratulations zennurse on getting your son the help he needed.
HJC – simpson is being called a liar and worse. knives are out.
Spotlight!
good morning!
How do we get the MSM to focus on problems like this, instead of wasting all that power tittering about whether Brittany squashed some photog’s toes as she flits in and out of make-believe-rehab?!
And now we have another set of awful fires, this time worthy of 24/7 because !EGAD! they’re displacing the ultra-rich along with the lowly. Not hard to see who gets the lion’s share of attention there also.
Our society is sadly out of balance right now, and seemingly choosing to hide under the bed instead of tackling what problems we can and should.
selise @ 13
Selise, please amplify. My cable is out.
MR. Bill @ 16
it’s not on cspan – you can stream the webcast (see link here)
i’m not going to be able to liveblog – maybe a random comment. but i am recording the audio and will post immediately after the hearing if there is an interest.
selise @ 17
Thanks!
Boehner just moved to Censure Pete Stark…
Selise. Thank you!
selise (sorry folks, from last thread)–
yes, the US produces twice the oil of Iran. It’s just that we consume so much that we still have to import.
Actually, it brings up a point that often gets lost. If ME oil supplies came to a dead halt, the US would lose about 50% of its oil. So somehow our economy would have to readjust by 50%. But Japan and Europe would find they have to adjust by numbers closer to 80-90%. In many ways they are more vulnerable to oil shocks than the US is.
Sorry for the OT, I got overly excited!
Am I crazy or is there this growing acceptance that it is OK to dislike children?
When my eldest was in high school, she had a friend, a boy, who was having some issues with his parents.
Rather than try to work it out, the parents took him to a doctor and demanded that he be put on Prozac. Huh? I felt given the situation, this was like trying to kill a flea with a nuclear bomb. Having to be parents was just more “work” than these folks wanted to put in.
I’ve got a bunch of stories that all seem to end up with people who became parents who frankly, could not do a good job with a dog that had been previously trained.
What they want are kids who feed themselves, clothe themselves, raise themselves, are completely self-disciplined and so on.
Either not willing or totally unknowledgeable of what it takes to be a parent.
Not sure where the disconnect happened, but it just drives me nuts when I see it.
Adie @ 15
Send money to FDL and click through the advertising. The more the MSM sees the progressive blogs stealing their subscribers and advertisers, the more likely they are to reconsider their horrendous coverage. Per others above, spotlighting articles is also good.
Professor Foland @ 21
WOW.
Thanks you so much. I had no idea.
prof foland – thanks! i just didn’t know that our oil production was still so high.
nonplussed – thanks for the ot! if it weren’t for the hjc hearing, i’d be listening to the house floor right now.
I notice segregation’s not on the list. Oh well.
I would like to also say that whem my son created his first web page, he had all the usual stuff at the top like favorite bands, songs, hair colors etc, but near the middle he had a little area that basically said “Need help?” and as you scrolled down he had linked to every hotline, information page and resource for teens that I had ever heard of. He is 6′3″ and about 235#, but is just a teddy bear about other people. His experiences could so easily have made him bitter and uncaring, but he is strong and sweet. And yes, I do take some credit for that in terms of modeling but it also has to do with the luck we had with the community around us during those few fragile years.
Just as it is difficult for people to negotiate the medical maze without support (which is what I see so often), it is incredibly difficult to know who to call, beg, trust when your child is in crisis. I had more people gasp and warn me not to get involved with Dept of Social Services (MA children’s welfare), but my esperience was that they were right there with me, shoulder to shoulder, trying to find everything from winter coats to group homes for us.
Christy, anyone, is is just funding? Or is it ignorance?
Boo Radley @ 24
Thanks. Yes, we in this household try to keep up the pestering and re-education of MSM, Congresscritters, et al. It used to feel like a very lonely fight, indeed, before we found the Lake. It’s still horribly frustrating (hence, my rhetorical question above), but KNOWING we have company out there in the “real world” helps keep us going. Thank you pups, for all you do. ;->
Decades of heavy bombardment of “welfare queens driving cadillacs’ type rhetoric have infiltrated the attitudes of even those I would consider decent, caring folk. They can get worked up over their neighbors they think are milking the system but ignore or shrug their shoulders over massive welfare handouts to corps. I don’t know how this misdirected (imo) anger can be changed. I hope it doesn’t take decades for people to realize that we all benefit from investing in helping vs punishing people.
zen — It’s that the problems are not easily solved, very complex, and layered — you have health care (or lack thereof), access to mental health resources (or lack thereof), poverty, hunger, preventative care, education, drug/alcohol abuse, physical abuse, prejudices, and on and on and on…there isn’t any one answer, but everything needs to be tackled in the mix. It’s a tough, tough set of problems.
And funding for any and all of these issues — as we saw with SCHIP — is not easy to come by these days.
An example of how a flood can affect a child:
Many years ago there was a flood in a community we lived in. We ourselves did not have a flooded home, but our son was in daycare right next to a small stream. And as a 3 year old, he watched that stream flood a house just across from that daycare center, which was on a hill, whereas the house was down by the stream
After the flood, our son became terrified of water running into the bathtub or of the toilet being flushed. I concluded that a young child cannot understand a flood, except that water has become dangerous. Gradually, over time, he got used to the fact that the bathtub would not overflow and flood the house, that the toilet would not overflow either.
For a child who has actually seen their house fill with water, seen their community under water, it would be even more confusing, scary, and difficult to overcome the emotional and actual events the child has experienced.
Now that the Republicans have used the repopulation of New Orleans to capture the governorship, do you suppose they will get out of the way and let people go home?
On second thought, don’t answer that. Silly question.
Also, just a reminder, please keep the calls going on Southwick today. Thanks so much gang!
I”m really sorry to be OT, but I want to share this sentence which made me laugh out loud. I have no idea how I got to this site, band all of Matthew’s subjects don’t interest me, but the section in the archives about the birth and growth ofhis child (The Squirrelly) had me laughing and crying. and writing a fan letter He just has a way with words I respond to. Worth bookmarking for future easy reading.
“Of course I’ll be the first to pull the lever for Clinton if it’s Hillary v. Rudy in the general election. Standing on principle is noble, but Giuliani eats power for breakfast and shits crazy in the afternoon.” Matthew B @ defective yeti
http://www.defectiveyeti.com/a…..relly.html
back to regular programming, thx
Morning, Christy…
Morning, all…
i just saw this note from jane at the top of the last thread:
woo hoo! and i know exactly what i want to ask!
(((((zennurse)))))
You obviously have raised a very caring son. Somehow that does not surprise me at all.
I am so glad he found help, with your guidance. Neither of you should have had to go through the agony you did, if the system was working as it should. It is very touching that he would put links to help for others right in the middle of his webpage. That speaks volumes.
Good wishes for you.
Toby@23,
I think there is a bias right now, against teens. I am a counselor. I practice a type of counseling that requires that parents figure out what they are projecting on to their child. Lots of parents want fixes that mean that it’s not their fault, that they had nothing to do with creating or enabling the problem and that their anger at the child is valid. Some of the most popular programs are the ones that practice “tough love” despite the fact that empirical research data continues to negate the effectiveness of these confrontational, projections laden approaches.
When I am working with teens the hardest part is often getting the parents to understand that when they act “childish” by throwing temper tantrums, punishing in an emotional way instead of a rational way, projecting insults against their kids, they are teaching their children how to behave. Parents get very angry when they are told to change. They would much prefer a pill or that we change the child. It’s takes both. There is success when I can get the kid and parents to practice news skills with each other and when both can learn to recognize that judgments and feelings are not facts.
It’s a tough go. It’s important for parents to learn not to enable “problem” behavior but it is even more important for parents to “role model” effective behavior and quit expecting kids to learn it through osmosis. Tough love practices without understanding judgements, projections, and plain controlling behaviors just confuse the matter and create this very inconsistent damaging kind of dynamic.
I want parents to hold themselves accountable and stop expecting teens to handle life more effectively than they do. Parents go through a divorce, struggle with impulsive spending, drink a little more, go out more, escape more but we expect kids to go through a divorce and keep their grades and coping up. It drives me crazy. We expect more from teens than we do ourselves. And their brains are not done growing.
Okay…sorry for venting but this one really is damaging and I have had more than a handful of parents absolutely refuse to aknowledge their parts in the child’s problems. Blame, blame, blame. How can a kid be responsible and accountable when a parent refuses to role model this??
venting complete.
Christy Hardin Smith @ 31
Christy,
One of the biggest holes in the Child Welfare system is lack of funding for any types of services for the parents or children. This includes parenting training, treatment of the victims of abuse and neglect, and support for the children who “age out” of the system.
But plenty of IOUs for the continuation of wars of choice.
(edit: But you know all this from first hand experience).
Christy,
This is such a telling post, and a topic that many avoid because it requires one to be introspective, honest with oneself and then active in altering one’s mindset…change, in other words.
OT (sorry), but I just can’t imagine where the ‘little extra’ profit for AT&T came from: /s
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21433452/
Kickbacks, anyone???
Katie Jensen @39 -
I’m with you there all the way.
katie at 39 — Oh my. I so recognize that from the parents of juveniles I used to represent and/or prosecute. We would try to hard to get the kid some assistance, regular counseling, intervention services, etc., but none of it would help without adequate parenting. And far too often, the parents were the biggest part of the problem — it was so incredibly frustrating to try to help the child and deal with the family issues at the same time because the bad parents never, ever wanted to accept responsibility for their inattentive crappiness. (And the good parents were always so wonderful, but so sadly few and far between…)
ironranger @ 30
The process of change cannot even begin so long as Republics have any power.
Toby Wollin @ 23
This morning on npr there was a story about those wilderness camps where “troubled” kids are sent away to be “corrected”, but are frequently abused and have been killed. I don’t think parent’s are willing to put the kid first, to recognize that there is nothing more important than that soul. My son was in group homes near me and I was in those folks’ faces frequently, along with his mental health worker and educational guardian. It takes personal work, not turfing the kid off to others until they’re fixed.
I do think there is a role for antidepressants or other meds but only if there is a complete evaluation and appropriate management with ongoing therapy, psychiatric care. It can be just one tool in a crowded drawer.
Adie @ 15
My God. Hundreds of thousands of people, including a couple of dozen Firepups, are at risk, and all you can do is bitch about the media coverage? How callous.
OT before I have to drive in to work- twolf posted this link @ end of last thread to an updating map of SoCal fires. This is for San Diego county. I’m sure there is an equivalent map from Google for the areas north of this, but I don’t have time to find link right now. This map includes evac centers, horse/large animal evac sites, road closures, updating fire info & other relevant info:
Google Fires Map/Info
Please hold positive thoughts for those in the affected areas & the firefighters who are working tirelessly to help them.
Have to go- read you all later.
katie jensen @ 39
Bless you, Katie, you are like our Tara who could never get my ex-husband to admit that he was the adult and bore some responsibility for his son’s issues. It’s not an easy admission, but just because your teen is as tall as you are, that doesn’t mean they have your insight or experience.
Burns, are you in danger? What’s going on out there?
Christy Hardin Smith @ 31
And I am fortunate to live just north of Boston in a blue state where the state does recognize the importance of these things. My son’s adult group home was nearly closed due to cuts by Bush but the state stepped in somehow, can’t remember the details. Even Mitt couldn’t change that more than the Feds required.
Badwater @ 44
I sooooo agree with you BadH2O!
The conflict is evident to me.
Torturers…can we please impeach or arrest these people for crimes against humanity:
http://rawstory.com/news/2007/….._1022.html
LS @ 52
Since Democratic Congressional leadership remains the same, apparently not.
burnspbesq @ 46
ROFLMAO. Millions of people in the Middle East are at far greater risk, than US citizens in California. No one comes to FDL for currency trades either. Do you want Christy and Jane to hop on a plane and fly to San Diego? If it bleeds it leads. MSM is terrific at covering natural disasters. Please very promptly and sincerely apologize to Christy.
Race (and class) problems even in self declared nuclear-weapons-free Ithaca, NY.
burnspbesq @ 46
It was interesting that overnight the BBC interviewed a reporter for the Malibu paper where apparently Barbra Streisand’s home was burned, but didn’t talk to San diego where things are far worse, even according to the Malibu reporter.
Blessings to all in the area, my prayers are there.
Chris Dodd is upstairs with Jane.
[Mod: In a half hour]
A very fine article, Christy.
You continually amaze with the depth and breadth of your compassion and desire for justice.
burnspbesq:
October 23rd, 2007 at 7:53 am
Please also apologize to Adie. Her comment was in no way dismissive of the very dangerous situation in CA.
How much have you sent to the Red Cross?
Biodun @ 57
Mod: Thanks. I saw that after I commented.
Toby Wollin @ 42
Second!
I have been stunned more than once, when trying to express my feelings among mixed groups of older folks about how tough life is these days for youngsters, especially teens. Often, the reaction is quick, loud negation of any and all thoughts of that sort, mostly driven by “evidence” dredged up concerning all the electronic toys, mall schtick, fancy cars & the like, that former generations did not possess.
I do what I can, but am really frustrated witnessing the blatant lack of rapport tw’ old and young. Something very fundamental has obviously broken down within the basic communication between generations.
Many older folks see all the slick toys of today and falsely think such frills more than make up for the lack of a caring touch and attitude toward each other. To me, it is all too clear why many teens feel emotionally abandoned, and why they act out in anti-social ways. Such behavior cannot be condoned, but its roots need to be addressed earlier and better. Doing so surely would be more effective than merely building more prisons and blindly issuing more mind-numbing medications.
zennurse @ 56
I agree, zennurse.
burnspbesq, I fear you have missed my point by light-years. Of COURSE we all ache for those folks and what they’re going through.
not to complain, but I’m getting cranky about “resource management”… those super scooper planes are doing a great job up in Castaic on the fires… ya think you could send ‘em down our way for an hour or 2? I’m sure San Diego is thinking exactly the same thing…
allan_in_upstate @ 55
Allen – I have lived all my life about 45 min. from Ithaca and this is nothing new. In the 1960s, I remember when Cornell had its first big sit-in and the big concern was that a lot of the blue-collar workers (who actually at that time earned pretty poor wages)at Cornell who were from rural areas in Tompkins County showed up for work with their hunting rifles in their trucks.
It has always seemed that Tompkins County was sort of a donut economy – the “haves” from Cornell and Ithaca College and all the rest.
For all the 1960s “we’re all hippies here” atmosphere, that was not really true.
Christy Hardin Smith @ 43
Unfortunately, the problems are sometimes multi-generational. It is very difficult for people to be good parents when they have not been well parented themselves. People learn to be parents by watching their parents.
Hope we can agree that there are many terrible things going on, including the fires and the war in Iraq, without getting competitive about it.
Fern at 65 — Absolutely — saw quite a bit of multi-generational issues in my day…too much.
The Lurking Mod @ 66
Yep. Every disaster deserves coverage.
Boo Radley @ 59
Thanks much for the thot, but no apologies necessary. We’re all wrought-up in the Lake these days, for good reasons. It would indeed be nice for overall comity if we could mostly attack real problem-makers rather than each other. I’m no fan of road-rage, or blog-rage either. But I don’t think FDL has a huge problem thereabouts. Everyone’s hearts are pretty much in the right place or they wouldn’t be here. eh?
((((peace))))
Lurking Mod at 66
;->
There are a lot more TV cameras (on the ground or in the air) in CA than in Iraq, and more in LA county than in SD county. Fires are also impressive to watch.
The LA Times has a page with evacuation and road closure information (not necessarily correct: they have the south Fallbrook one on the wrong side of I-15). The current forecast is winds through today (at least), red-flag fire warning until tomorrow afternoon (at least).
This just shows how capitalism doesn’t really work. Not for society. It works for the greedy few. The insensitive, selfish, hateful, greedy few. I’ve always thought that the near-perfect world would provide housing, clothing and food for all, available to all at no cost. When those three basic needs are provided to everyone, those basic taken care of, there would be much less crime in the world. Maybe we could through in education available for all. Instead of spending billions a week on killing in Iraq and billions on stupid super weapons, let’s spend billions a week on providing the three or four basic needs everyone in the world needs. Then humanity would have the chance to live to its greatest potential.
fern@65..
I totally agree, which is why the sound bites against teens just fuel the idea that “kids today are so screwed up…” If there is a serious problem with a child, it is likely that the whole family needs to learn some interpersonal skills, some attachment skills, some emotion regulation skills, some distress tolerance skills and some mindfulness skills.
I am willing to be nonjudgmental about how sexual abuse, substance abuse and domestic violence dynamics are passed down from generation to generation. I just get upset by the media, sound bites and those lovely conservative black and white thinkers who pass on the notion that bad kids are just “bad”. It’s just like these pedaphile religious freaks who judge clinton. Judging that teen for smoking pot, or wearing baggy pants does not do anything but increase shame and fear. It’s not nor will it ever be the solution.
I think the current republican climate reinforces intolerance…for every set of folks who are different or vulnerable. Teens fit this bill and are suffering right along with all the other minorities. They don’t have a voice and they are being scape goated by adults who need help.
ew! creepy Michael Chertoff is on my tv saying brilliant stuff like, “the fires are bad!” and “it’s windy!”…
once again, the feds are a day late and a dollar short…
hey, Chertoff! just send some damn fire fightin’ planes, you nitwit!
Boo @ 59 – FYI – the fire is at burns’ backdoor, as it is mine… you might want to dial it back a bit…
Some have asked about the effect that the deployments by the California National Guard to Iraq might have had on their ability to assist in the current firestorms.
In California the National Guard performs a wide range of activities during emergencies, such as fire-fighting, evacuating residents, providing security and provisioning supplies at emergency centers.
Approximately 2500 California National Guardsmen are deployed abroad, most in Iraq. That’s out of approximately 20,000. Over the last few years most of these CNG’s would serve a year tour and then have a year to 18 months of home training/deployment in the Ready Reserve. Secretary of Defense Gates has reduced the “home deployment” to practically nothing…although these individuals would still be called up in a declared emergency. However, there would be a lag time between their call up and deployment to the fire-zones. In addition, other States with “mutual aid” agreements with California may be unable to deploy their NG’s trained in firefighting or natural disaster management as they may also be deployed in Iraq.
But more debilitating than the units deployed abroad is the fact that about half of the Guard’s equipment remains in Iraq, to be used by CNG and other units on their rotations.
In May of this year California Guard officials predicted equipment shortages could hinder the guard’s response to major disasters.
The readiness of the Guard is a national problem and major political liability for the Bush administration. Kansas Gov. Kathleen Sebelius, a Democrat, said the National Guard in her state was hobbled in its response to tornadoes that flattened the town of Greensburg and killed a dozen people. Sebelius said the Kansas Guard was missing trucks, bulldozers and helicopters that could have helped in the search for survivors.
According to California National Guard Lt. Col. John Siepmann, the Guard can handle small-scale emergencies, “our concern is a catastrophic event. You would see a less effective response (to a major incident).”
“We are ready to respond, and we will respond to anything,” Siepmann said, noting that problems would arise only in the case of a disasters equivalent to Hurricane Katrina or the LA riots of 1992. But given the increasing frequency of catastrophic firestorms and the ever present threat of earthquakes and floods, having a ready emergency force would seem essential.
Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger personally acknowledged the State National Guard’s equipment shortages were the result of the Iraq War. “A lot of equipment has gone to Iraq, and it doesn’t come back when the troops come back,” Schwarzenegger said when reporters queried about emergency readiness at a news conference in Sacramento earlier this summer. “So this is one thing we have been talking about, how do we get this equipment back as quickly as possible in case we need it, and we also need it for training.”
The California National Guard is missing about $1 billion of equipment, according to Guard inventories provided to The San Francisco Chronicle. Much of the equipment would be useful in handling events like electricity blackouts, fires, floods, earthquakes or other emergencies.
Siepmann reported the Guard’s aerial equipment used to fight fires, such as C-130 airplanes and CH-47 helicopters, was in good shape. But in the event of heavy Santa Ana winds when fires might need to be fought on the ground equipment losses could play a role. Over two-hundred vehicles, including 110 humvees and 63 military trucks that could be used to transport troops or supplies, are out of the state. Over one-third of the CNG vehicles are no longer available for emergencies.
Despite the massive amounts of money budgeted for the Wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, and the Department of Homeland Security, many equipment needs have not been funded by the federal government, which provides virtually all of the National Guard’s budget. Guidelines indicate the Guard should have 39 diesel generators on hand, but it has none.The Guard doesn’t have 1,410 of a specialized GPS device also suggested in readiness guidelines.
The U.S. Commission on the National Guard and Reserves found additional responsibilities increasingly imposed on the Guard since the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks and the Iraq war have resulted in stresses on National Guard personnel and equipment that “is not sustainable over time.” The deployment of the National Guard to Iraq and federal funding shortfalls for equipment to be used in the country could lead to a situation in California similar to Kansas or Katrina said state Assemblyman Pedro Nava, D-Santa Barbara, chairman of a legislative committee on emergency services and homeland security.”These are policies that are putting California residents in jeopardy,” said Nava.
Based on….
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/…..PPB2D1.DTL
nonplussed @ 19
For what? Insulting the President isn’t one of the dishonorable acts noted in Jefferson’s Rules. The President isn’t a “fellow member” of the House. Seems that the “censure” is an effort to “insult” the House, and Boehner should be censured.
cinnamonape @ 77
I’d like to see that.
is smarmy the right word?
Boo Radley @ 25
And an attack on Iran, if it inflames the Shiite populations in the Gulf monarchies to the South would threaten that supply. Surprisingly, 70% of the population in Bahrain, and about half the population of Kuwait, are Shi’a. The other Gulf states and Saudi Arabia have smaller, but still significant, percentages of permanent Shiite residents…usually treated as second-class citizens.
The monarchies realize that there is a substantial danger of civil uprisings against their regimes if the US attacks Iran. The US military would be at great difficulties keeping the oil production and shipping lanes open in such a self-inflicted crisis.
someone musta heard me cussing out Chertoff – word is air support is on its way to the Santiago fire!
OldCoastie, keep us posted.
egregious @ 82
Eg – we’ve been very, very lucky down here – lots of acres burned, but great “structure protection” going on… with a little air support and with the winds dying down, we may be in pretty good shape pretty soon…
Thank God and the moon, wind and stars for Christy Hardin Smith…and for all of FDL.
Christy Hardin Smith @ 7
I’m curious if anyone knows, is Tom Flocco a total nut job or on to something important?
http://www.tomflocco.com/fs/SenClintonGrenada.htm
MarkH – are you sure you want to link that trash in here?
Great piece CHS. Most of us want to think that racism is no longer an issue in the states but we know that is just not so.
NPR has been more committed to coverage and updates on the after effects of Katrina more than any other MSM outlet than I am aware of. I will not forget when just after the storm Chris Matthews said “Katrina has ripped off the scab of racism and poverty in this nation”. The problem being is that on MSNBC’s Hardball and other programs the scab came off for about a month.
If only they would do consistent programs on this critical issue there would be more constructive change in the critical areas of racism and poverty.
Come on Matthews rip the racism and poverty scab off for more than a month.