Tonight at 9PM ET PBS’ Wide Angle will broadcast A Woman Among Warlords, a documentary based on Eva Mulvad’s film Enemies of Happiness about Malalai Joya.
Malalai Joya is a very young woman who stood for election in the new democratic Afghan Parliament. Her campaign was based in speaking out for an end to rule by warlords and for the rights of Afghan women. She has faced innumerable attempts on her life and has now been thrown out of the Parliament for pointing out that Donkeys in a stable do more for the Afghan people than the current representatives (a notion we might find familiar!) Back in May, Jane had sent me a news clipping about Joya and the resulting post has more background: This is How It’s Done. Joya could certainly teach our party a few things!
Mulvad traveled to Afghanistan and followed Joya as she campaigned – and her film has won recognition from Sundance (World Cinema Jury Prize:Documentary), Festival Amsterdam’s Silver Wolf Award and the Nestor Almendros Prize from the Human Rights Watch International Film Festival.
An excerpt from the film and short interview with Joya can be viewed here and a podcast interview with Eva Mulvad can be heard here.
Mulvad wrote the following from Farah, Afghanistan as they were making the film. It’s a beautiful message for us all:
We are among mystics, refugees and neglected animals. It is hot and the people are poor. Every day is full of bargaining and debate. These are days of apprehension and apprehension creates distance. The nights become hostile. People reveal intentions they may or may not have. The enemy is abstract but feels real. The enemy could be every one and no one. Car lights shine on rifles. I yearn to leave this place.
This film was made in spite of this apprehension: Malalai Joya’s apprehension for her own life, our apprehension for being in Afghanistan and among people we did not know.
How does the story we choose to tell effect our society, our world? The great “mono-narrative” has to be broadened. The world hungers for more dimensions, more voices so that the we can create our own opinions, our own sense of awareness about what is really happening in the world—especially when it comes to Islam.
This film was made to tell another story from one of the world’s most talked-about regions: Afghanistan. The stories we hear are always full of bombs, torture and terrorists, stories full of apprehension that create distance: between “us” and “them”.
The world is not about villains who lurk outside awaiting us. The world is more than that– full of everyday people who fight everyday battles for their and others right to life, dream and happiness. Muslims are not a monolithic villainous entity just like we in the West are not. We can understand each other. There are many who profit from making us think that we can not. But in them we can not believe. They create our apprehension for the world and each other, an apprehension that leads to distance.
Joya has continued to speak out even knowing she is risking her life daily to stand for the women of Afghanistan and against the warlords. I can think of no better way to mark September 11th than to watch this documentary – and work for the day when we have representatives with half the courage of Malalai Joya.
You can check your local PBS listings for Wide Angle by clicking here.
Related posts:





Spotlight








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

Siun!
A brave woman!
OK, I’m going to notify downstairs.
FunnyDiva
3?
Cool, for once being on the left coast has an advantage. I will watch it later.
Fareed Zakaria, showed a powerful clip of it on Foreign Exchange, last Friday, I’m looking forward to it…!!!
I’m so excited that this is showing tonight … just the excerpts alone look so very good.
HRC at bat…
ohh i hope this ends well for her… somehow i dont think so….sad to say
Doesn’t look like Austin is going to carry it:{
Dayam, Hill is calling out all the lies…!!!
Thanks for the heads up.
Have been learning a great deal about Afghanistan from two friends studying here at Ohio University from Afghanistan (both on Fulbrights). They say things have gotten so much worse in Afghanistan
Joya. When I compare this individual to many, perhaps most in my party leadership, I get angry. This person I respect and admire.
Hillary piling on the facts so smoothly. Bingo
Thanks for the heads up, Siun. I just set my DVR.
Hillary joining the “Blame the Iraqi’s” club. Helps get her off the hook for her part in this
Heh, ‘I don’t think it is only the Iraqi Gov. not carrying out a coherent strategy…!!!’ Hmmm…
HRC gets close to saying where is the middle east conference on Iraq?
Sounds suicidal
Kathleen @ 12
but rummy is telling Esquire it is a “great success.”
Goodness gracious. What an arrogant lying asshole you are, rummy.
F*ck, if our own state dept doesn’t want to go to Iraq, why the f*ck should ‘major’ European ministers want to…!!! 8-(
Here’s info for September 15th and the days after:
http://www.dailykos.com/storyo…..164746/527
“After the noon rally, there will be a march from the White House to the Capitol, to begin a mass civil-disobedience die-in around the Peace Monument. The die-in will be led by an Honor Guard of Iraq Veterans Against the War.”
I’d like to see the republican convention held in Baghdad.
oddmommy @ 23
Good one.
oddmommy @ 23
Sadr City…!!! ;-)
Bring Senator Clinton back here for a question and answer thing. I promise to be polite.
oddmommy @ 23
so would I!
But they will be taking big hits in the Twin Cities, if that’s any comfort.
Senator Thune from South Dakota is up at the Petraeus hearings. What’s wrong with the Dakotas? Larry Craig and this a**licker. Disgusting.
Elliott @ 27
How many will actually drive over the bridges there?
Oklahoma kiddo @ 26
Sure, just keep Lahoma outside of the room…!!! *g*
Oklahoma kiddo @ 26
I’d love to see this encounter! ;)
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/200…..wh/us_iraq
Breaking…Bush to announce a reduction of US forces in Iraq by 30,000 next summer (maybe), following the recommendations of the generals (like Shari Lewis following the advice of Lambchops?)
So the tours of the surge forces are going to be extended?
Insanities piled upon insanities…
btw, the receptionist in Pelosi’s DC office was a tad defensive — “Congresswoman Pelosi isn’t in charge of the Capitol police.”
Like I used to say — “Don’t blame me, I voted for Harry Britt.”
carmen @ 28
Craig is from Idaho.
I’d love to bottle some of Joya’s spirit and feed it to our Reps … they have no idea what political courage is.
A good friend of mine took a year-long job as head of projects for USAID in Uruzgan Province in Afghanistan. He’s doing good work, and has some interesting observations. He blogs about it occasionally at A Year In Afghanistan.
Kirk Murphy if you’re lurking …
Re: your post @ 135 previous post
They’re doing the same types of things in Canada
Siun @ 34
even her name is beautiful!
Elliott – yep! and her smile as she speaks … the warmth that comes through even with all she faces is a great reminder of what we can be.
Elliott @ 27
The GOP seriously thought about holding their convention in Baghdad, but when they discovered how few men’s restrooms there are in the airport in Baghdad, they looked for a more attractive venue for off-hours activity, and came up with – Minneapolis.
Not enough hookers in Baghdad
Cliff Varnell @ 32
The only sensible response to this is “Okay, you’ve finally told us how long the temporary ’surge’ is going to last, now when do we find out when the regular troops are coming home?”
Siun @ 38
oo it sounds like her spirit is contagious, too!
like you :)
Could someone introduce Joya to Nancy Pelosi?
If Joya can keep fighting against such seemingly insurmountable odds, Nancy can find a way to at least bring contempt charges against Harriet Meirs.
Joya’s story is heartening on one hand and depressing (when you compare what she’s doing against what the Dem leadership isn’t doing)
can joya come to the us so dems can see what REAL COURAGE looks like….
Siun,
Thanks to PBS– and you! for spotlighting Malalai Joya. She represents the vision of a new Afghanistan that was promoted so extensively 4 years ago, but has been chopped off at the knees by an administration fixated on Iraq. I have known about her for a long time, and am glad to see her getting this “exposure” — um, maybe I should say “publicity.”
I have a friend who is a Gynecologist, who provides pro bono work to a hospital in Kabul. Her letters about the condition of even the best hospitals in Afghanistan is shocking. Women’s needs are neglected if not abused in most of Afghanistan, due in part to poverty, but also to the Taliban mentality over most of the rural countryside. Mostly, they die young.
Bob in HI
Unfortunately for me, it won’t be broadcast tonight on any of the PBS stations I have access to. I’ll have to catch it later :(
Petraeus: Biggest enemy in Iraq is militia extremists (shia) backed by Iran, bigger than AQ.
Oy Vey.
I am a bit confused by what I think Petraeus keeps mentioning and nodding towards Senator Levin for approval on. Petraeus keeps saying something about 1.5 billion in weapons sales and hopes it will rise to at least 1.8 this year. Does anyone know what he is talking about?
Tross @ 43
Good point!
Nancy Pelosi also couldn’t hold a candle to Barbara Jordan
bobschacht @ 45
9 PM for you and I!!! 8-)
On Tucker Pat Buchanan just said that the Iranians are killing us in Iraq and will be here soon. Idiot.
CTuttle @ 25
At the mosque.
If there is any voice I miss in congress, it is Barbara Jordan. We desperately need her wisdom and guidance.
Eureka Springs @ 48
When Pryor brought up his “bipartisan” bill, which he prefaced by saying that Arkansas constituents want the US to leave Iraq in better shape than when they invaded…in other words, perpetual war, because that is not going to be possible…he said there were a bunch of Dems and a bunch of Repubs..I noticed Levin inhaled and rocked back in his chair in some kind of tension..he nodded to Petraeus, and I thought that was weird. Hmmmm…war-profiteering???? Lobbying?? Something is up, and Levin seemed to have an “understanding” about something with Petraeus.
QuakerGirl @ 52
Collins, Snowe, and Hutchinson would look good in Burqas…!!! ;-)
Eureka Springs @ 48
Well, I think his point is supposed to be that the Iraqi Army is getting equipped and they’re paying for the equipment, but it comes across as if he’s saying they’re good customers. Kind of creepy.
Ed*ard Teller @ 39
LOL-good one!
John in Sacramento,
What I wouldn’t give to have Barbara Jordan and Russ Feingold as Speaker of the House and Senate leader, respectively. A guy can dream, can’t he?
LS @ 47
Would those be the same Iranian-backed Shia militias that are part of the Shia political parties that the Bushies put in power, back when they were in a rush to have their purple-finger moment and didn’t require groups to disarm as a condition of participating in government?
Crocker: Iraq much greater strategic importance than Lebanon.
Yeah…it’s right next to Iran.
Iran is surrounded with US military. Iraq with 160,000 troop plus 100,000 mercenaries, and Afghanistan on the other side with 25,000 and who knows how many mercenaries. Iran is what all of this is ultimately about. They have the most oil.
There will be war with Iran, I’m pretty sure.
LS, Pryor leaves the DC Lieber-club only to go home and spend time with the Junior League. He is one dim bulb.. a dangerously dim bulb, but dim nonetheless.
Every time I hear him mention the ISG report I just want to scream. He just loves that flawed and dated piece of pre surge cosmetic work.
Thanks P J, Need to pay closer attention. Still creeps though.
P J Evans @ 33
CTuttle @ 30
Lahoma v. Clinton? Oh gawd. That would be one-sided (and I don’t mean three sided as in triangulation) and brutal. After it was over the poor Senator wouldn’t even know what hit her. I don’t know that I’d wish that spectacle on anyone. Even Hillary.
Redshift @ 56
This must be one of the real benchmarks. Funny how weapons sales are succeeding and nothing else is. Thanks Redshift.
Our government and the Karsai government have done nothing but wag a disapproving finger. The assassination of activists women in Afghanistan has a long and bloody history, kept silent. Here are a few of the women who have given their lives in the cause of justice. The list is too long to list.
MEENA (1956-1987) was born on February 27, 1956 in Kabul. During her school days, students in Kabul and other Afghan cities were deeply engaged in social activism and rising mass movements. She left the university to devote herself as a social activist to organizing and educating women. In pursuit of her cause for gaining the right of freedom of expression and conducting political activities, Meena laid the foundation of RAWA in 1977. This organization was meant to give voice to the deprived and silenced women of Afghanistan.
May 5, 2005 – (IRIN) Several hundred women demonstrated on the streets of the Afghan capital, Kabul on Thursday, calling on the government to improve their security and to bring to justice those responsible for the deaths of five women over the past two weeks, three of them on Wednesday.
Safia Ana Jan, head of the women’s affairs department in the province of Kandahar, was killed by armed men on motorbikes as she got into her car outside her home. 9/25/06
Oklahoma kiddo @ 63
Shall I reiterate…!!! ;-)
Show Me, Claire…!!! ;-)
CTuttle @ 67
que?
Matthew 16 modern wingnut edition:
Thou art Bush, erstwhile 30% wingnut messiah.
Thou art Petraeus. And upon this piedmont of putrefaction I will build my fantabulous freedom institute. And those evil democrats can do jack shit about it.
commentary: The next schnook in office will inherit the mess in mesopotamia.
Elliott @ 68
McCaskill(D-MO) asking what leverage do we have…!!! 8-)
QuakerGirl @ 65
For about four years before the November, 2001 invasion of Afghanistan, I donated to a group working out of Vienna, that helped smuggle Afghani artists, mostly women, away from the Taliban and out of the country. They also provided financial suport for the hiding and/or restoration of musical instruments and works of art there. I’m not going to give the group’s name, as they’re erroneously listed as a marked group by the USA. But my contacts have assured me that the lot of women artists there is, in most parts of he country, every bit as bad as it was under the Taliban.
CTuttle @ 70
Oh-oo!
shes says knowingly — at least now she’s knowing
Doug Powell’s photos of Afghanistan from 1976-8, before the Soviet invasion, give a sense of three decades lost to war.
And yes, Petraeus is setting the table for Operation Bomb Iran. Expect the 2008 State of the Union, slap bang in early primary season, as Bush’s double-down-double-dare to the presidential candidates.
LS @ 60:
There’s way more oil in the not-yet-tapped Caspian Sea fields. Afghanistan is one of two routes from there to the sea. We already control that one, we can get the oil out that way. Iran is the other route. Even if we can’t use Iranian territory to get the oil out that way, we can threaten anybody else who tries to: Can you say “25 permanent US Military bases in Iraq?” Any questions?
Actually yes, I have a question: Why the hell didn’t they just SAY OUT LOUD that that’s what all this is about? Goes all the way back to the secretive Cheney Energy Task Force. Sad to say as it may be, they’d probably have raised popular support domestically.
Hmmm.
(P.S. Back from vacation now, hi all y’all!)
It appears that Chris Matthews stood up. Only watched a bit, but he seems fairly emphatic.
Now here’s a woman (Joya) willing to put her life on the line for justice. And our sickening politician’s biggest worry is that they might loose their $165,000 a year job and the martinis and cocktail weenies. Puts me to shame.
Hi Hmmm
Joya, Dr. Maryam and Rachel Corrie. Does it get any better?
Aloha, Elliott. Nice to be back, I missed this group somethin’ fierce.
Hmmm.
Show me… the money trail… Yee-haw!!!
Charlie Cook takes a serious look at the 08 senate elections
Bottom line- 9 problemetic gooper seats vs 2 dem seats
Gooper seats Allard’s, Warner’s, Hagel’s, Sununu, Collins, Coleman, Smith, Stevens, Domenici
Dem
Landrieu, Johnson
Sounds pretty good
Hmmm. @ 74
It’s not. You are missing the critical “I” factor too.
Matthews has been good right along on the issue of Iraq.
Hmmmm 74,
I agree. But, from what has happened here in our country, it looks like their agenda was two-fold…turn our country into a police state and make the people have to rely on mega corporations for work ultimately; and steal all they oil they can find to make a profit and live in luxury, while served by slaves.
It won’t work.
Sell everything you’ve got and buy oil stocks. Think Iran.
rwcole @ 81
Didn’t ya neglect wide-stance’s stall, err… seat???
Freddie Thompson has already caught Roo-dee according to CNN.
That didn’t take long.
and Vitter..
hey hmmm
back in time for the fall follies…lol
McCaskill: Privitization of the military is the future, we just have to learn how to do it better!!!!
Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
Tuttle
Cook thinks that wide stance will almost certainly be replaced by another gooper- sounds reasonable.
Ever throw up a thread for the first 30 minutes of Olberman? Can’t wait to hear a leader speak.
Mathews is now calling out Rove and the guy now working for Mitt on the lies he spread on McCain (love child, racsims and all that). Of course he just transitioned from that swipe into perhaps a segment on the Hill raiser -scandel.
Bah ha ha – now the tape of the Prostitute that Vitter hired (on of them) telling it what a liar he is (on the stand). So we are looking at two US SENATORS lying on the stand in one month. Yeah, I know they are liars 24×7 anyway.
Richmond @ 82:
Go on…?
Hmmm.
LS @ 90
Seriously?
Eureka Springs @ 88
is he bitter?
Vitter isn’t up for re-election until 2010 I believe.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 78
Not for Joe Lieberman, who would probably label all three, especially Corrie, as terrorists. He’d rather spend September 11 at an event in NYC with (gag alert!) – Ann Coulter, who had this to say about the wives of 9/11 victims:
These self-obsessed women seemed genuinely unaware that 9/11 was an attack on our nation and acted as if the terrorist attacks happened only to them.
And:
[T]hey believed the entire country was required to marinate in their exquisite personal agony. Apparently, denouncing Bush was an important part of their closure process.
And:
These broads are millionaires, lionized on TV and in articles about them, reveling in their status as celebrities and stalked by grief-arazzis. I’ve never seen people enjoying their husbands’ deaths so much.
well we know the MSM annoints the repug they like…now its freddy t
Well, it’s all over but the crying…!!!
It really is absurd that our Reps have spent all day in a hearing about the situation in Iraq on 9/11.
Who planned it for this day? Loved when Senator Byrd asked again did Iraq have anything to do with 9/11.
Reps should have objected to this day for this hearing. They should have been with the faimilies of 9/11 and the rescue heroes
LS @ 90
*spits drink out of mouth*
Whaaaaaaaaaaaaat!
Siun, you never fail to bring the greatest international stories to out attention. I don’t know where you find the time and energy, but I’m grateful. I don’t have TV and can’t watch this until I find it inline, but it sounds wonderful.
I just had an interesting and depressing time looking at the front pages from around the country for today, from Birmingham to LA, Brockton MA to Boulder Co, and it’s interesting to see how the testimony as well as the 9/11 anniversary are prioritized across the country. It certainly explains a lot to me about why Americans are so uninformed about the details of these issues.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer’s cover spoke eloquently to me about the aftermath of both and the price we are paying.
http://www.newseum.org/todaysf…..mp;b_pge=8
Rover an the Clusterfuck planned to remake the middle east and create a permanent GOP advantage..
Well they DID remake the middle east- turned it into a shooting gallery..
As far as gooper control of congress, it’s becoming more difficult every year as more and more MODERATE voters run away from goopers as fast as their touchscreens can carry em.
Ed*ard Teller @ 71
Bless you! The small NGOs I supported or knew of are on the hit list also. Some disbanded. One group is under suspect but they are always suspect regardless of the new military conflict. They have enough support and a long history in aiding peoples in conflict that they can sustain. The small ones comprised of two or three people really get hit hard though you would expect they would be under the radar. I’m sure you’ve seen some very courageous people out there. And they aren’t in a uniform.
Vitter’s got another hooker alert goin on. Wonder how many more are out there waitin fer their 15 minutes of fame….
This new one looks pretty good.
If we discover that CRAIG AND VITTER did a tapping routine together in a mens room this thing will have come full circle
rwcole @ 91
But, that’s assuming he won’t fight for re-election…!!!
Hookers have to be taken more seriously than “Bimbos” their PROFESSIONALS.
Tuttle
Yeah- but we couldn’t get THAT lucky—could we?
new thread, folks
rwcole @ 103:
“‘Voters’? What of these so-called ‘voters’ of whom you speak? We need no ‘voters’! Who needs such ‘voters’ now that our new, mandated-by-law, totally hackable, digital tabulation systems are in place?”
Hmmm.
Thanks for this post, Siun and thanks to Redshift for the link to your friends blog.
Off to teach and rehearse, rehearse and teach. But I wanted to thank Siun for her excellent essays ,especially lately.
I love the coffe-spew-inducing humor, irreverrence, snark, cussing, blasphemy, spirited argument, inspired logic, brilliant writing, family friendliness and other things at fdl. A lot. But Siun’s humanity and the way she brings it to our attention are among the very best things here, or anywhere in interactive journalism.
{{{{{Siun}}}}}
Hmmm. @ 93
Demasculating (destoying) Iran is also about protecting Isr*el, yet by the very act of bombing Iran, both that country and Syria will counter attack Isr*el and the whole will turn into a full scale multi-nation conflagration that has the potential to embroil Europe (including Russia), the Middle East and the U.S. in a truly massive scale world war, replete with Nuclear bomb attacks.
Eureka Springs @ 94
I wouldn’t put it that way, she was seriously concerned about the hyper-trend towards privatizing many prior self-sufficiency measures the military had traditionally performed! She pointed out the blatant cost discrepancies for services provided now, as opposed to the prior norm…!!!
Oh, that “I” factor.
You see it as a real scenario, or a “Don’t cross us or we’ll unleash Armageddon on everybody,” mutually-assured-destruction sort of stance on BushCheneyCo’s’ part? Both interpretations seem plausible to me.
Hmmm.
KO is on.
Courage personified! As she noted, women’s rights are what both Afganistan and the US need to make peace and rebuild the country.