Oh, hypocrisy. Thy name is Sen. Susan Collins. From Maine Coast Now:
Susan Collins must hope that the media has a short memory.
There is no other explanation why Collins would be whining again that the opposing political party is — now get this — trying to hold her accountable.
A Collins campaign hack released a copy of a letter this week that had been sent by her to Democratic challenger Tom Allen, asking that the Democrats stop filming Collins’ every campaign appearance. The hack referred to the practice as tracking and said it demeans the political process.
Give me a break.
Collins tried this same tactic, successfully, in 1996 when she ran for the U.S. Senate against the Democratic former Gov. Joseph Brennan.
A few weeks before the election, Collins’ staff and the political reporter for the Bangor Daily News conspired to coordinate a story that made it look like Brennan was using dirty campaign tactics against Collins. In the weekend Bangor Daily, across the top of the entire front page, was a story that could have been written by the Collins staff.
And what, in reality, had occurred? The Democrats had hired a person to — gasp — research Collins’ political background….
The story and the newspaper’s subsequent follow-up stories came out so close to the election that it tipped the balance. In the end, the political dirty trick of the Collins campaign worked — she squeaked out a victory that she otherwise would not have earned.
After the fact, it came out that the reporter John Day had been in close contact with a Collins campaign that was in dire trouble. The scheme was unearthed when an e-mail sent by Day to the Collins campaign was inadvertently sent out to other parties.
Collins had denied any involvement in this orchestrated “scandal” but it became clear that her campaign was the source of this concocted story….
Nowhere in the story does it include the history of Collins’ prior plot to divert attention from her record by attacking the integrity of her opponent. (emphasis mine)
Well, that’s awfully illuminating, isn’t it? Take a planted political lie and a pliant member of the press that worked for you in a prior campaign season…and voila! The whole tracker tap dance has been a false, planted campaign tactic all along, and is a rinse, lather, repeat from her 1996 campaign. Classy. Fool me once, shame on you — try to fool me twice? Well, that’s just fraud, isn’t it? You shouldn’t buy it, either. But is the bulk of the press in Maine noticing that egg on their faces just yet?
You can help Sen. Collins enjoy an early retirement and plenty of free time to contemplate the meaning of the words “crying wolf” by contributing to Tom Allen at our Blue America page. Thank you!
(Photo via USAToday by Chip Somodovilla/Getty Images. Just a little reminder that Sen. Collins and her BFF Sen. Joe Lieberman have done a lot of tap dancing in place on Katrina. And not much else. Have you had your cup of accountability and sunshine today?)
Related posts:





Spotlight







Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

Zed. Glad you got some family time Christy.
leisure guy?
Allen!
So Close. Now to read post…
Morning all! Great way to start the week. Let’s get this show on the road!
millineryman at 1 — We had a wonderful time. We took The Peanut to Idlewild and Storybook Forest — she loved it, and it was wonderful to get some time with just the three of us.
Sharon @ 2
FDL institutional memory. I love it.
Have Lieberman and Collins visited the new luxury condos being built scores of miles inland from the hurricane damage path with the help of our tax money yet? Have Joe or Susan kept up on the progress on Trent Lott’s new porch?
A friend sent me the Frank Rich column from Sunday. Here is a small part of it on Karl.
now he wants to attack syria
lieberman-syria-iraq
Obviously because of George Allen’s Macaca moment, Repug candidates are completely spooked by YouTube.
How did she ever win an election in Maine? She seems like an irritating dim bulb of a politician.
Time had a special report about Katrina.
Why New Orleans Still Isn’t Safe
Steve-AR @ 12
She has good posture and viciousness.
OT: TPM reports that Leahy has scheduled a news conference on the subpoenaed spying documents for 2:30 today. WH has already said they can’t meet the deadline.
Mainers aren’t very fond of bullshit – ’specially when it reeks of the Big City kind…
I would expect that Susie is gonna get punctured by that dry, dry Maine humor.
Biodun@11: “Repug candidates are completely spooked by YouTube.”
Shouldn’t that read “Repug candidates are completely spooked by the YouTube?”
snark/
Wow Cristy. Thems the goods for sure! Did this get any media play after the election? And, anyone know where that “journalist” is now???
OldCoastie @ 16
Ay-yep.
OC at 16 — That was my impression on this as well. It’s awfully early in the campaign season to get this panicky and to do something this obvious and stupid. Which makes me wonder how bad her internal numbers really are at this point?
Steve-AR @ 12
Maybe because she’s a “size teeeeew” she sounds like that creepy woman on the Nutrisystem commercial!
Collins will not be sent back to the Senate come next election – no matter how fast she twirls.
IOKIYAALBC
(It’s OK If You Are A Lieberman-Broderite Centrist)
yellowsnapdragon @ 15
Does anyone have an idea if the press conference will be broadcast somewhere?
1970cs @ 10
Why not? JoJo will feel no pain. Now you….well, you and I don’t count. We’re not the elite rulers.
Another sawbuck for Tom Allen from Casa Biscuitbarrel!
The last time I was feeling broke-but-militant and sent Tom $10, I got a hand-signed letter thanking me for my “generous” donation. Whatta guy.
OldCoastie @ 22
If she twirls as fast as she talks it will take her one year to make a full rotation.
I assume that there’s no primary opponent for Collins?
Her general election strategy appears clear—”He’s bein mean to a GIRL”.
I’ll check in later. Off to my local nursery for some ornamental Japanese grasses for my garden. Later….
KathieinMN @ 24
RAW STORY will report from Leahy’s Capitol Hill press conference at 2:30 p.m., but his intentions remain unclear.
rwcole @ 28
It worked for DiFi in her first primary to be Senator years ago.
I still remember listening to a debate and she let loose with “Stop attacking me as a woman” or something similar. It threw her opponent off his game and he ended up wasting time defending what he hadn’t done in the first place. It was my first case of being disappointed with her, I had vaguely supported her before that debate.
Loves Leahy!!
Christy, do you know if anyone is following up on Sara’s “Oath to the President?”
This is one of the most disturbing things I’ve heard in all of the testimony to date.
epu’d
christie-
there isn’t that much meat in this howard kurtz article, he leaves out most of the rove ‘doings’, HOWEVER, he DOES say, in plain english, that karl rove leaked valerie plame’s identity to two reporters…….that he did……i thought it was worth posting for that……
http://www.washingtonpost.com/…..newsletter
Loo Hoo. @ 32
Me, too. I was left feeling that she didn’t misspeak.
dmac, the Kurtz link didn’t work for me, it said the article was moved or unavailable.
It might just be me though….
Get a copy of this book, if you can, by the woman who ran last year against Olympia Snowe. When she wrote about Collins, she was writing as a journalist: http://www.amazon.com/Tale-Dir…..amp;sr=1-2
sorry about the long URL
let’s try that link at 33 again……..
http://www.washingtonpost.com/…..newsletter
Maine seems to love Snow- Collins not so much..Don’t know why.
Well Lieberman and Collins are so close, you’ve got to wonder. That orchestrated scandal. Sortof like Lieberman’s website before the primary.
Ah, the double-talk, both sides of the mouth:
mui @ 39
Rove seems to get credit for inventing the reverse backstab, claiming his office was bugged, but knowing exactly where to find the bug. Early Texas days.
I have an SIL who does this. What a victim!!! I don’t see her anymore. But we still have to deal with these ingenuous politicos, don’t we. The smell never leaves.
Smaller government, lower taxes, keep big government off my back, pick yourself up by the bootstraps, make your own way, work hard to get ahead, the gubmint never helped me out – why should the gubmint help you?, are the Republican sound bytes that appeal to Libertarians, Mainers and other independent strong-willed folksy types. They just pull the lever for the candidate with the R by his name so the government will leave them alone. That’s how Susan Collins gets elected in Maine.
All are lies, of course. Republicans have made bigger government than Democrats every time. R’s have raised taxes on working people every time. R’s have bankrupted the treasury every time, R’s want to legislate what you do in your own home – especially the bedroom. R’s want to impose their religion on you and R’s start wars.
FRom Watching the Watchers. Some folks simply have Kool-aid for blood:
Dangerously Crazy
Few politicians who run statewide can afford to be straightforward on any controversial issues—it’s always “Some of my friends are fer it and some are agin it- and I support my friends.”
Few politicians have ever been elected because of a well thought out policy on the issues..
If you take a stand on a 60-40 issue- you lose 40%
If you take another stand on another 60-40 issue- you lose ANOTHER 40%
That’d be OK of it was the SAME 40%- but it usually isn’t.
Take three principled “stands” and yer screwed.
Politicians learn this on day one. It’s MUCH better to attack your opponent- that costs ya nothing.
AZ Matt @43
Puke!
Rove called the press to come in and witness the bug that he found in his office. When examined- it turned out that the bug had an 8 hour battery life and had 4 hours left- in other words- Rove had planted it four hours before- when he called the press..
Rove is a great practitioner of humbug- and you’ve got people fallin for it every time. In another period he’d be sellin patent medicine.
Well to alter the famous Bill Clinton campaign quote: “It’s the values stupid.”
You can’t be too specific on individual issues in a statewide campaign, but you can take a principled stand on your values.
If the Democrats had been more focused on creating a compelling narrative of Progressive Values these past 20 years or so, I dare say they would have had more electoral success.
AZ Matt,
I linked to that nutso article here last week. I’ll bet a good one-third of Bush’s remaining 28% believe what that guy wrote.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/new…..irq120.xml
Things are going “swimmingly well” in Basra…
“In the last three months more than 450 rockets have rained down on the airbase with insurgents using the control tower as an aiming point that can be easily seen from miles away in the desert.
“The situation is far worse than is being portrayed back home,” said one RAF officer.
“We have no hard cover in most accommodation so people are just relying on luck to stay alive.”
Ed*ard Teller @ 48
And the rest would follow if Bush said it.
Susan Collins on her BFF Joe Lie-berman:
What a twofer pic…one supposedly “liberal” republican and one supposed “democrat” standing in front of Hurricane Katrina signage.
Could there be any two politicians with less compassion between the two of them for the victims of Katrina than say, Darth Cheney or Preznit Fly-over?
Just checking the facebook linky…
rwcole @ 38
Snowe’s centrist talk is usually followed by at least some centrist action. Collins does the talk, but votes like Santorum.
I voted for Hay-Bright against Snowe, but I do have some respect for her. Collins is pure slime.
LS @ 49
But gee, that pales in importance compared to Susie Q being “stalked” by a polite videographer. Scary! /s
I just cannot get over how callous our government is.
peanutbutter @ 53
it doesn’t work for me.
Traitor Joe and his sh-eaten grin.
Looking good.
Ed*ard Teller @ 48
I hope not but here are the really, really far-right types who would dream of that and want to invade Iran and Syria.
Oh, Joe Lie3brman wants to invade Iran and Syria.
ET, did you see this piece on Don Young?
http://www.tpmmuckraker.com/archives/003951.php
peanutbutter @ 53
it works!
SufiLizard @ 47
The Republics keep two sets of values: the ones they preach for voter consumption and the ones they practice but hope voters don’t notice. Blogs like this one are making it harder for them to hide the latter.
That’s why Republics are going after blogs.
SufiLizard @ 47
I agree. Now, instead of espousing critically important bedrock progressive values,
(such as: keep the government and churchy out of your bedroom; absolute separation of church and state; fair wages and union support; women and minority rights.)
they attempt to match their phony religious faith with the phony republicans’ religious faith. And they are mired in it! Democrats, you dumb clucks, please get churchy out of our government!
And they say by ommission, “well, maybe abortions should be outlawed. Maybe American labor is too expensive. And maybe prisons should be full of mariju*na users”.
Loo Hoo. @ 60
Yep. Warms the heart.
Gettin video of everything a politician says is threatening behavior- it could keep em from sayin one thing to one group and the opposite to another- a favorite game. Can see why it pisses her off.
and guess who wants to bomb Syria? Wow, that was quick! Yes it is our ol’ reliable CT junior senator, Joe. Jerome a Paris has the details…
Loo Hoo. @ 60
If you read the comments, you’ll see my acid critique of local coverage. LOL
Don’t think separation of church and state is a winner—the vast majority of americans belong to some christian church and aren’t afraid of religion.
Ed*ard Teller @ 66
nice!
Elliott @ 56
Well I’m confuzzled. I can’t figure out which link in facebook to put into the FDL registry page. I come up with a link that looks something likehttp://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=606423320 but that doesn’t seem to be correct, and other people’s links are of the formhttp://www.facebook.com/p/Ellie_Elliott/557354858 but I cannot seem to find my own equivalent of that…grrr….
Any Mainers out there that can give some advice to a Christy article-forwarding fiend?
In checking the Maine radio/tv/print options to SPOTLIGHT, I can guess who to send your fine article to at WAGM and WGME, but who are the people I should send it to at the Portland Press Herald / Maine Sunday Telegram?
peanutbutter @ 70
Did you re-load your browser? and re-log into FDL?
peanutbutter @ 69
Interesting. Maybe it just needed some time to “settle in”. I now seem unable to edit my posts! Ah well :-)
The Alaska Dems put up this Don Young humor page a couple of weeks or so ago. I did a lot of the research for the ties between Young and all those crooks in the graphic.
Loo-Hoo, What’s the deal? I’m away for a couple of days and you just assume that I wouldn’t be interested in the news of my congressman? Or you just like ET more than me? Well, okay then!
Actually, ET, Rich Mauer got to the bottom of some of Little Ben Stevens’ shenanigans first. And this may be the thread that unravels uncle Ted’s vestiments.
peanutbutter @ 69
It works fine now!
rwcole @ 68
Yes, but allowing Americans to freely practice their religion (or lack thereof) is a bedrock American value and in order to do that separation is essential. Don’t focus on the specific policy “separation of Church and State” but focus on the progressive value “Freedom Of Religion.”
And if you have a contentious issue you think you might not be on the same side as the majority of voters, don’t back away from it, and don’t be apologetic, but keep your answer short and quickly get back onto the things with which most people will agree with you.
“Yes, I do support a woman’s right to chose, but I also believe that EVERY American has a right to good health care….”
The folks in maine appear okay with bamboozlement in general. they allow the shrubs to come and risk nuclear attack. last time these tweakers were in our state they violated numerous laws and are subject to lawsuits for the violence they caused.
hope they get rid of this piece of garbage, like the turd that should be flushed standing next to it.
Where been ya, Big Mitch? We’ve missed you! (and punaise and petrocelli)
Nice comment, ET!
My son moved in with me, which is great blessing, and my two daughters have been visiting. So my access to the computer is somewhat restricted. You would think I have seniority, but it doesn’t work that way.
BigMitch @ 75
Rich and Lisa Demer have both had to tone down many articles before the editors would let them through. APRN (Alaska Public Radio Network) also has a heavy editing hand at work on their coverage. They nixed a big story out of Kodiak last Friday on Ted Stevens being booed by commercial fishermen there.
The guy who gave Mauer the most crap recently was Jack Frost, during his dismal run against Mark Begich.
Can we find a picture of Snow kissing Joe?
Like the Bush smooch?
Surely there’s one somewhere!
’scuse me, I meant “Collins” not Snow, I get them mixed-up for some odd reason……
SufiLizard @ 47
This tidbit from Rove on Temmeh: The number one issue for people who voted R in 2004, and D in 2006 was the scandals in Washington.
Who woulda thunk that Congressman Mark Foley did more for Dems than all the efforts of blue workers?
By the way, I took the advice to Rinse, Lather and Repeat, and now everyone wants to know why I am walking around with a head full of shampoo lather. Woouldn’t Lather, Rinse and Repeat be better advice?
rwcole @ 68
You may be correct, but it could have been a big winner had it been embraced, contextualized, sound byted and repeated by the Democrats 20 or 40 years ago. They let the importance of it slip away and getting it back is now a tall order.
You do agree that it is an important element in the operation a Democratic Republic form of government?
I found this article about the increasing amount of money being poured into Judges elections: The Situation of Judging
It really is disturbing when viewed of a piece with the whole DoJ scandal, the Rovian “math” and so many other things…
Re: separation of Church and State
The dems answer to the questions of prayer were very interesting last night. I thought that Edwards told the truth as usual, even though he could have dodged it, when he said that he didn’t think that prayer averts hurricanes. I also appreciated Richardson emphasizing the issue of privacy in response to a question about his religion.
Interesting to note how many Catholics were on the Dias: Kucinich, Gravel, Richardson, Biden
5 students from a dorm at VA Tech are in the hospital in either serious or critical condition, following carbon monoxide poisoning from a leaky valve in the water heater.
AZ Matt @ 43
Attacking democracy seems to be the new rage with the radical right – there was an article on the Cato website that advocated free markets as a form of decisionmaking that was less “inherently biased” (paraphrasing, sorry, couldn’t find the link).
I guess since they’ve been caught stealing elections the next best thing is not to have them.
Dow down – 80 plus
MayDaze @ 89
Or to translate their point of view into more straightforward terms: stealing elections is a lot of work, it’s much easier just to buy them.
peanutbutter at 86 — Federal judges are appointed, not elected. It is only at the state level and below that you get elected judgeships. And, yes, the amount of special interest money alone — let alone campaign cash, that pours in on all sides is a very disturbing trend. Since federal judges are often pulled from state ranks, it is entirely possible that some of this seeps through — but not in all cases.
It’s tough to divorce politics from legal and judicial practice — there isn’t any pure way to do it when you have politicians making the choices for appointments. But there used to be a huge disincentive for stepping outside the bounds of decency, honor and integrity — and what we have seen that the Bush Administration has injected across the board in so many of their administrative actions has been anything but.
We are going to be a long time in the undoing of all of this. My greatest wish is for there to be an ethical backlash wherein we see a rigorous internal enforcement across the board once these soundrels are out of the Beltway altogether.
BigMitch @ 87
Very interesting article in this issue of Mother Jones re. Hillary and her churchifying. She really is panderer in chief.
LS @ 87
Oh jeez. Haven’t they had enough?
Democracy does have a soft underbelly, which is that ideas can be popularized the same way pet rocks, hula hoops and soap flakes are. And then popular ideas prevail over wise ones. This is why the fourth estate is so essential. Democracy depends upon it to expose bad ideas, and publicize wise policies. Only then, can majority rule lead to good govenment.
See what happens when a direct mail genius undertakes to subvert democracy.
SufiLizard @ 77
Freedom of religion can also be put in terms that even a small-government conservative can understand: We don’t support government telling people how to worship or what religious beliefs to have. We don’t support government enforcing one church’s beliefs. We don’t support government instead of parishioners deciding which church should get funding.
BigMitch @ 87
I didn’t see it. I like Edwards’ answer and Richardsons’ too. Whenever I go to church, the priest always prays for our troops, but never for the Iraqi’s. I got a Congressional Survey from church (Orlando, Florida, Diocese) that guided parish members to vote for republicans. I faxed it to a group working for Separation of Church and State.
If someone prays that a hurricane won’t hit their town aren’t they hoping that it will hit somewhere else instead?
peanutbutter @ 69
Go to your Facebook profile. Click your profile. Copy the url in the window–should have numbers at the end. Paste that url on your FDL registration. Go to login on FDL page–on the right.
BigMitch @ 95
and yet there were those who were onto Rove from the beginning, like Wayne Slater and James Moore. But their warnings fell on tragically deaf ears.
BigMitch @ 95
I agree. A fair, informative, analytic media is the often unrecognized fourth check & balance to precisely this weakness of “mob rule”. And of course that’s what the first amendment is really addressing.
But really, we haven’t got a democracy in this country. We’ve got a representative government, which was also considered by the FF as a check on “mob rule” (which they were cautious, if not actually afraid, of).
I know, I’m nattering about things y’all here know. Down here in conservative county, I tend to break out into basic talking points…!
hackworth–sure I agree that it’s an important principle of a free govt.- but it’s not a popular one- not one a candidate will run on and win on- except perhaps in some exceptional congressional district.
Biodun @ 98
Thanks for the help. Yes, that is what I did, I think it just took some time to “kick in” or something.
QuakerGirl @ 25
And just when Israel is trying to de-escalate tensions with Syria. He’s such a good friend to Israel too!God save us all from religious fanatics.
AnnieW @ 34
My impression was that she probably took the same oath to the Constitution as every other government employee, but she is incapable of conceiving of any distinction between that and an oath to the president personally. I don’t think they made them swear personal loyalty oaths because the people who would take them seriously (and not blow the whistle) didn’t need them; they were hired for slavish loyalty above all in the first place.
Christy at 92:
Not all states have elected Judges, but appointed judges can buy their seat on the bench by donating to Governors’ campaigns, as it were.
Alaska has a very good system. Judges are appointed by the Governor from a list supplied to her by the Alaska Judicial Council. The Council’s work includes interviewing and most importantly, surveying attorneys, cops, the public, and soliciting comments, etc. Judges are required to stand for retention elections, at the first election after they are appointed, and these elections are not political. The judicial council will occasionally recommend against retention, which ususally results in the judge withdrawing and resigning. No campaigning by judges is allowed.
Fresh thread for everyone…if you want one.
Here is a link with Maine Newspapers for those who want to spotlight this or other Collins things.
http://www.usnpl.com/menews.php
New poll out on abortion—62% of americans approve of Roe/Wade. Pretty consistent feelings on this.
Redshift @ 104
My guess is that this is partially correct. The oath they took was too the constitution but I will bet that they talked among themselves as having taken an oath to Bush without making the distinction. It just seemed too ingrained in her when Leahy pushed back on her having taken an oath to the president. IIRC she had to keep correcting herself and each time it looked like an inward struggle. It did not look like she just thought of it that way but hadn’t really thought much about it.
rwcole @ 101
Its a bad platform (or plank in a platform) b/c the Democrats surrendered that ground. It was good ground and high ground, but they didn’t protect it. Now they gotta run around splainin that they’re just as religious as Rove’s brand (and as bellicose too). It’s me-too-ism and its weak. If your selling the same thing as the other guy and the other guy’s is the original…
rwcole at 68 says-”Don’t think separation of church and state is a winner—the vast majority of americans belong to some christian church and aren’t afraid of religion.”
oh yes it is…….i was a life-long methodist…….i quit going to church because ‘government issues’ were creeping into the church DURING church services……….it is appalling………there is a new minister there, and many have tried to get me to come back, but the fact that noone saw the danger in that, makes me not want to be a part of it….what bush and his neocons have done to the church makes me barf………church was the one place where it didn’t matter who you are, what party……and government used to be didn’t matter what religion you are…….outta be the same, both places, shouldn’t matter….well, not anymore……..and i think that’s dangerous for our freedoms……..all of us, to live as we choose, think as we choose…..
don’t want government in my church
don’t want church in my government
(you got your chocolate in my peanut butter, no, you got your peanut butter in my chocolate)
I remember seeing a video on TV of an honorary dinner for Tom DeLay. He was cracking jokes about not having a heart and right up front was our Susan laughing like old Tom had said something funny.
OldCoastie @ 16
Maybe the Mainers will also wonder if she would help them the way she, Lieberman and Rove helped New Orleans after Katrina decimated the city.
Really, could Mainers (or anybody for that matter) depend upon Republicans (or Lieberman) to help them in an emergency?
I sometimes wonder…there’s a tactic I’ve seen a few times where I live and I wonder if it’s common Repub tactic in other communities and states.
First the Repubs set up a a “Dems for Candidate” office and then they maybe firebomb it or soap the windows or something, and claim Dems are attacking them.
Is this the kind of stupid dirty trick seen around the country.
It certainly sounds more old-fashioned than bashing your own web site and then blaming it on the opponents.
Since I haven’t been in tight with a campaign and felt the sting of negative campaign attacks I generally feel the best way to fight is to simply get your opponent on the record and then highlight the better differences in your opinion or to point out really egregious positions/votes/speeches of the opponent. Straight up debate stuff.
Collins seems determined to go off track on the wacky train, so we should just point that out to the public, right along with her lack of concern for the video tracker and her Conservative Bush Republican voting record.