President Bush's statement on the commutation is up on MSNBC. And he flat out lies in it. See this:
...Mr. Libby was sentenced to thirty months of prison, two years of probation, and a $250,000 fine. In making the sentencing decision, the district court rejected the advice of the probation office, which recommended a lesser sentence and the consideration of factors that could have led to a sentence of home confinement or probation.I respect the jury's verdict. But I have concluded that the prison sentence given to Mr. Libby is excessive. Therefore, I am commuting the portion of Mr. Libby's sentence that required him to spend thirty months in prison.My decision to commute his prison sentence leaves in place a harsh punishment for Mr. Libby. The reputation he gained through his years of public service and professional work in the legal community is forever damaged. His wife and young children have also suffered immensely. He will remain on probation. The significant fines imposed by the judge will remain in effect. The consequences of his felony conviction on his former life as a lawyer, public servant, and private citizen will be long-lasting....
Wrong. Wrong. Entirely wrong. The sentence as laid out carefully by Judge Walton was well within the sentencing guidelines -- in fact, it was mid-range in the guidelines. The President may well feel that a 30 months sentence is excessive for someone who has been convicted of multiple federal felonies -- but, it is entirely false to say that the sentence is excessive within the guidelines. It is an attempt at spin and shold not be allowed to stand unchallenged.Further, as Marcy says:
Well, George did it. Made sure that Scooter wouldn't flip rather than do jail time. He commuted Libby's sentence, guaranteeing not only that Libby wouldn't talk, but retaining Libby's right to invoke the Fifth.This amounts to nothing less than obstruction of justice.
Amen. And now that the President has concluded that the proceedings are at an end and has acted thereon, I'm certain that the members of the Bush Adminsitration, including President Bush, Vice President Cheney and Karl Rove, among many, many others, would be more than happy to answer questions publicly about their conduct and involvement in this betrayal and the investigation thereof.
Oversight, please.
UPDATE: Just got this from Harry Reid's office:
Washington, DC — Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid made the following statement today after President Bush commuted the prison sentence of former White House aide I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby for obstruction of justice:
"The President's decision to commute Mr. Libby's sentence is disgraceful. Libby's conviction was the one faint glimmer of accountability for White House efforts to manipulate intelligence and silence critics of the Iraq War. Now, even that small bit of justice has been undone. Judge Walton correctly determined that Libby deserved to be imprisoned for lying about a matter of national security. The Constitution gives President Bush the power to commute sentences, but history will judge him harshly for using that power to benefit his own Vice President's Chief of Staff who was convicted of such a serious violation of law."
UPDATE #2: More statements from Dem. leadership: Speaker Nancy Pelosi, Rep. John Conyers, Rep. Louise Slaughter, and Sen. Chris Dodd:
"By commuting Scooter Libby's sentence, the President continues to abdicate responsibility for the actions of his Administration. The only ones paying the price for this Administration's actions are the American people."
Still waiting for the Presidential apology to Valerie Plame Wilson for his Administration betraying her cover and her work on Iranian WMDs, among other important national security investigations. Not exactly holding my breath for it, though...
UPDATE #3: Statement from former Sen. John Edwards:
"Only a president clinically incapable of understanding that mistakes have consequences could take the action he did today. President Bush has just sent exactly the wrong signal to the country and the world. In George Bush's America, it is apparently okay to misuse intelligence for political gain, mislead prosecutors and lie to the FBI. George Bush and his cronies think they are above the law and the rest of us live with the consequences. The cause of equal justice in America took a serious blow today."
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
Fitz!
Justice damn it!!
So, let’s make up an itemized bill for this SHAM and send it to Bush…
Impeachment had better be on the table now, Nancy.
IMPEACH THE BASTARD TODAY!
The criminal fix is in from the top down, publicly. This regime is nothing but rotten corruption. The Democrats are no better because they will not consider impeachment.
Corruption is running the United States government now in all branches.
I will bring Dick Cheney to his knees!
http://patrickjfitzgerald.blogspot.com
Chuck Shumer has already made a statement, but is not getting much press on the MSM news.
EPU’d:
TeddySanFran @ 149
Bush is a coward AND a liar.
Cheney is a crook and a liar.
Rove is a liar.
Gonzales is a liar.
Madame Speaker, it is past time for ALL of these to be brought before the Congress and forced to atone for their actions.
Obstruction. Impeach. No more excuses.
EPU-ed, revised and expanded:
Lead story on tonight’s ABC Nightly News:
Shorter Martha Raddatz talking to Charles Gibson–America’s #1 news anchor–about the commutation of Libby’s sentence…
the prez cut and ran from the press corps in Maine before the announcement was made [my paraphrase–she didn’t exactly say scuttled out of Maine, but it was damned close….]
Excellent reportage from Charles Gibson and Raddatz
The reasonable thing to do now, is to begin impeachment hearings on Dick Cheney. John Dean believes there is a strong case to made for impeachment of the veep. As do I.
un-fucking-real.
i’m not surprised, but at the same time i’m shocked. know what i mean? i told myself that bush would pardon him-but i just wasn’t ready for it (i, know, i know,it’s not a pardon) when it happened.
i’m shocked and pissed. and that’s what bush just did– pissed. pissed on the criminal justice sysytem.
just who the
fuckheck is he to say the sentence was excessive?aaaaagggggghhhhhhh.
This president has just gone WAY too far.
4th of July coming up.
Time to celebrate the nation we used to be.
I wouldn’t count on the Bushies now feeling free to comment.
The will hide behind the cloak of Scooter’s “ongoing appeal.”
And the press will let them get away with it.
Yay for democracy! Yay for rule of law!
My e-mail to Box Turtle, Permanent Cheerleader, and Lamah Smith:
I will not be holding my breath for this action, however.
Ugh. Not surprising but still disgusting.
Raw Story link has statement from the Wilsons’ lawyers at CREW — not a ton of detail but at least something:
http://rawstory.com/news/2007/....._0702.html
What Bush meant was that any jail time for privileged persons like Libby is excessive. See, he and his friends don’t have to play by the same rules as ordinairy people. In fact they don’t have to play by any rules, except that of loyalty to la familia, above all.
I am just heartsick.
Bush just obstructed justice in a Monday Night Massacre of Nixonian proportions.
“It’s not right!” cried Scooter, “Mom!!”
Bush has been Cheneymailed.
Now I expect we’ll be hearing the conveeeeeeeient “I can’t comment while the legal process (Scooter’s appeal) is ongoing.”
Nemo @ 8
It’s been on CNN twice, not just read, but scrolled. Where is everyone else?
Jail time for Washington elites is just too excessive.
-Chimpy McDouchebag
What disappoints me the most is that there is no outrage out there.
Sickening…This president snubs his nose at the judicial system. It’s time for impeachment. Cheney first. I’m deathly afraid he’ll get us in a war with Iran, so keeping him busy defending himself and his criminal cronies could be just the ticket.
TRex @ 22
There is irony when Paris Hilton shows herself to be more of a grown-up and more respectful of law than the White House.
Archibald Cox? Deep Throat? 1970’s era Woodward, not modern Woodward? **sigh**
This spares him the jail sentence…. the other shoe drops in January 2009, when Scooter gets an outright pardon. Ugh.
/sigh
/scream
/cry
/wonder what happened to America!
Will bush’s poll numbers finally crater????
One more straw on the load.
Impeach the SOB now. And put him out of our misery. (He doesn’t feel it, so it must be ours.)
I’ve written to all three of my Congresscritters and said that it’s time.
I’m planning to stay p*ssed off for oh, another two or three years. Congresscritters take note!
Blub @ 30
The Whiskey Rebellion balloon floated must have gotten boosh’s attention. That way, he can compare himself to george washington.
To the streets!! We no longer have a nation of laws. This must not stand. Impeachment now.
GSD @ 25
I guess jail is reserved for the great unwashed.
some animals are more equal than others
Brian Williams did just report Chuck Schumer’s statement, tried to qualify it as a “Democratic statement”, but had to back off a bit and say it might be a common response by most Americans as we approach July 4.
Blub @ 30
Y’know, you’re right. Hadn’t thought of that. He’ll have it both ways.
EPUed from the last thread:
Does this open up the possibility of Fitz going after Bush for Obstruction of Justice, because now that Libby is not facing jail time any incentive he had in finally cooperating with the investigation to reduce the jail time has been terminated?
Incidentally, I am disgusted beyond measure with this, although hardly shocked given who we are talking about.
The comments are pouring in over at DailyKos like a thunderstorm. The toobz are overheating here, too. Maybe this will be the meltdown that will shake some sense into Nancy Pelosi. Will someone please administer the smelling salts to her?
Bob in HI
FYI. Cassie just sent a letter to Bush asking why Scooter deserves a commuted sentence while her mom sits in jail for 9 yrs. Letter is here.
Democrats. Do not let us down. Go after Cheney.
martha @ 38
I do hope that most Americans are repulsed by this act — may it be a coalescing moment. I wish. . . .
TexB @ 42
Please give that young lady a hug from all of us. And apologize to her for the country and mess that her generation is going to be left cleaning up.
Tex, that was a great letter from Cassie, asking boosh “why”.
P J Evans @ 33
I haven’t been able to stop being pissed off since the Iraq funding vote. This just is the f-ing cherry on the top.
Zee @ 36
via tpm - Conyers: Bush Decision “Inconsistent with Rule of Law”
Get Tough @ 64
I think we need to contact her
we need to contact EVERY DEMOCRATIC CANDIDATE FOR THE PRESIDENCY
our cnadidates MUST talk about this the way it is;
THE PRESIDENT COMMUTED THE SENTENCE OF A COVICTED FELON, CONVICTED OF COVERING THE TRACKS OF TREASON
and THAT’S the way they need to discuss this, they need to POUND the republican candidates and
CHALLENGE REPUBLICAN CANDIDATES THAT AGREE WITH THE PRESIDENT
when they do our candidates need to be INCENSED that they forgive the actions of this traitor
the discussion MUST be freamed, ANYONE that condones this decision by the president must be spoken to as if they WANT people to cover the tracks of traitors
IF a republican PRETENDS Valery wasn’t a VITAL asset the democrat needs to LAUGH IN THEIR FACE
ok, this is too frustrating and I really have to head home
Merry Fitzmas everyone! Thank Gawd that impeachment is off the table. Phew! That was a sa-weet move on Bushie’s part.
Bless you Pelosi. Bless you. Thanx to you, Bush-Cheney may NOW leave office with their reps intact, unsullied, and all precedents firmly set.
Merry Fitzmas!
Reid says “History will judge Bush harshly”
Aw Shucks!!
Among other things, it would appear that Bush ignores his own Office of Pardon Attorney Guidelines.
The guidelines require that ALL requests for clemency go through that office; that all requests will be investigated by the AG or his/her designee, obtaining reports from appropriate officials of the DOJ; and that the AG shall make an appropriate recommendation to the President.
Did Team Libby file any formal request for clemency?
Did AGAG and/or the Pardon Attorney instigate any formal investigation? Did they contact Fitz for his input? Did they contact Valerie Plame, as the “victim” at the heart of the investigation which Libby obstructed, which is required under the guidelines?
Did AGAG and/or the Pardon Attorney make a formal recommendation to the President?
Inquiring minds on the House and Senate Judiciary Committee would like the answers, please. Preferably in person, under oath, and live on C-SPAN.
Helen @ 52
And Reid will just be plain forgotten…
What an outrage to justice! Even though I knew something like this could happen, I still wasn’t prepared for it emotionally.
Had to come back here to the Lake after hearing this — the one place I know for sure that my grief at the loss of our beloved country’s sense of justice need not be explained. You all understand, you feel the same grief.
This is a dark day, yet it would be even darker without the assembly of Firepups as fellow witnesses to this evil.
I heart treason! (bush bumper sticker)
Also, a special request to those of you watching KO tonight–we’re at the cabin with relatively slow toobz and no cable. Please give me a summary! Thanks much…
I’m also emphasizing my earlier idea: we may not be able to pull off an impeachment (I have only a tiny hope), but we CAN control and create the messaging that can destroy Rethug candidates this year and next. This decision gives us ammunition that we cannot ignore.
Conyers:
“Now that the White House can no longer argue that there is a pending criminal investigation, I expect them to be fully forthcoming with the American people about the circumstances that led to this leak and the President’s decision today.”
Sick ‘em!!!
Helen @ 52
WTF History?!!?
how about congress?
I agree that a sentence of thirty months was inappropriate. It should have involved more months and more people.
CNN: congressional Dem response:
Reid: history will judge Bush harshly for benefitting Libby; disgraceful; no accountablility; done to silence critics.
Conyers: before, we just had blind eye to leaking classified info; now it shows Bush condones it; sends the wrong signal.
Idiot WH reporter wondering if Dems are over reacting.
Here’s the real core of Bush’s statement:
Shorter Bush: I thought I could wait, but I can’t. Scooter will talk if he’s going to prison. So — he’s not.
Also:
Very sweet downgrade from “obstructing justice” to “not telling the truth” — which are, actually, different even though Irve was convicted of both.
Fox news gave a balanced opinion. Renowned former ambassador carlson said … and then well no Bush hater Schumer said….
Helen @ 52
Gawd I’m fed up with Harry. ;0)
Waiting for the “uproar” to start.
Cranky
We must stand now for the impeachment of the criminal element running our government from the Whitehouse. The American people must rise up from the grassroots and stop the lies, cheating, and criminal activities that are destroying our system and causing the instability in the Middle East. God help us all if we let this continue. Join with me to send emails to all you know and to our Congress. Now is the time.
Treason Bushstyle.
From TPM, Conyers Office:
We are all pissed. We need to find a way to channel that anger constructively, in a way that will produce results.
What can we do besides contact our congresscritters and congressional leadership?
What else can we do?
History, quite obviously, is not a Democratic politician.
Lucky for Bush - Reid and Clinton and Obama and Pelosi and Hoyer and Carville etc. are of the “judge not lest ye be judged” mindset.
Hillary Clinton et al loses or preserves my possible support in the next 30 minutes. Tick tick.
Scooter Libby - the Paris Hilton of the administration…
Tex B–Cassie’s letter is excellent. I remember her comments a few days (weeks?) ago on this subject. She’s a remarkable young woman.
Cranky Observer @ 65
I’m sorry I uttered the word.
I guess they couldn’t bribe this court….
Reid is such a wimp. He personifies the wide-held perception that the democratic party is weak. If the democrats just huff and puff, and don’t do anything, I think they are as complacent as this administration.
Fully aware that this is a progressive blog, and there are probably few republicans in here, I have to think guys like Bruce Fein and others have to be pissed off, too. I mean, the republicans, outside the cult of rove and W, like the rule of law, too, don’t they?
I’m dying to hear a statement from Walton….
OldCoastie @ 72
Nah, Paris took responsibility and acted like an adult.
OldCoastie @ 72
Scooter makes Paris jealous.
Suzanne @ 69
I’m chewing some glass, seems to work…
OldCoastie @ 72
At least Paris did her time. The Bushies are into deferments and have been since Vietnam.
Helen @ 52
Oooh scary, Sen. Reid! I’ll bet Bush is quaking in his boots. DO SOMETHING!
TeddySanFran @ 63
EXCELLANT
the democrats need to hit on THAT point too, that THE PRESIDENT is impeding the investigation that is trying to find the people that committed treason
HIT THAT HARD
martha @ 57
Since the Repugs own the media, I have little hope. And, why in hell is Michael Gordon still allowed to publish anything in the NYT. Bad shit, same day. Press for War, Pardon Scooter.
ccmask @ 77
My guess is he won’t say anything. Ditto Fitz.
I have quite a different view of basic matters than the posters and commenters here, so I know that it would be useless to try to argue on first principles. But isn’t your animus against Libby irrational even on your own terms?
At the heart of the evil - as you see it - is that principals such as Bush and Cheney lied to the public in order to get us into a war for nefarious reasons, and then sought to retaliate against good folk such as Joe Wilson for telling the truth. Libby, then, is at best a bit player. So wouldn’t it actually be an injustice for Libby to do prison time for the sins of others? Or do you just require the blood of someone - anyone - connected with the doings of your political opponents?
I am so mad. I think my post got scratched last thread but I had just won $350. in the c*sino and came up to my room when I heard this Libby crap. What a downer!!
whats the move now? i emailed speakers office - i had to restrain myself but still managed to convey my exxtreme anger at this cowardly move - lord i despise this corrupt administration!
Elliott @ 26
I’M outraged!! Even my 80-year-old mother is outraged. I have a DSL line and I have to wait five minutes to get on my Websites because the tubez are all clogged up. You wanna have a demonstration — I’ll come.
And what message does send to our kids? That’s the real crime.
perris @ 82
Yup! What is the President hiding?!
We need the equivalent of the Boston Tea Party. What could it be?
This is it.
We live in a world of two kinds of people. The ordinary, like Cassie’s Mom who are sent to the slammer for years and years for the crime of suffering from the same illness which affected Bush (addiction) and that of the elite, who are to be afforded every bit “understanding” and “mercy” which is to be availed of them due to their special status in life.
Bush does not care about people. He only cares about the people who like him.
OldCoastie @ 72
Paris did time.
Interesting that so far there have been almost no LIbby/Cheney hacks with immediate reactions, as though they didn’t know this was coming and weren’t ready with their spin.
History will judge Reid harshly.
Thank Ganesh for all you FDL compadres. I’m sitting in my office, where no one here understands the import of this moment.
Must leave now and find something small and helpless to crush.
Eureka Springs @ 92
yes, but look at the outrage when she got special treatment…
AZ Matt @ 89
NICE!!!
Elliott @ 26
NO OUTRAGE??? You haven’t been in my office the past few minutes, have you. Wrath of Barbara is in full spew.
Okay. All right. Here’s my utterly naive question. Promise you won’t laugh me off the site.
Can citizens bring civil suit against Cheney, Bush et al? Via the ACLU, perhaps? Or, if that’s even feasible, does it just wind its way back to Gonzo and the Supremes (a 60s rock group)?????
SPEW! Foam. Snarl.
TO THE MALL!!!!!
(not the “go shopping” one )
OUR NATIONS MALL…WHERE THE WASHINGTON MONUMENT STANDS GUARD.
DeeCee Dems, grab this and go, please!
from marcy:
Maybe the CIA will go on strike…I mean imagine! We are at war because of Weapons of mass destruction and this ibby outs an officer and he gets off scott free, or should I say scoots free.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 88
There shall be no adverse consequences for those who break the law in the service of partisanship. If you want to get ahead in life, join the rethuglican party.
Bush has commuted Osama Bin Laden’s sentence since 9/11. Why wouldn’t he extend the same courtesy for convicted felon Irve Libby.
-GSD
No one involved in the case is going to say anything. Fitz is an employee of the DOJ, and Bush.
HILLARY NEEDS TO SAY SOMETHING. IF SHE DOES NOT, THEN I CAN ONLY ASSUME SHE IS SALIVATING AT THE CHANCE TO HAVE THIS MUCH POWER.
perris @ 83
Well OF COURSE they need to…but they wont because they are in the thrall of the James Carvilles, the Hillary Clintons, the Rahm Emanuels. They don’t DO “little people”. I mean, eeeew!
We will now see precisely what we’ve come to expect from our stalwart “representatives”. Nothing less (nor more) than JACK SQUAT.
Sherrod Brown reaction. “Disappointed; doesn’t hold anyone accountable; no justice.”
Scarecrow @ 71
It’s a sad situation. I think. But you are right.
Peterr @ 3:48 pm -
Please repost your 3:34 pm comment from the previous thread; those Department of Justice guidelines that you quoted in that thread should be posted in this thread as well.
IMPEACH THESE CRIMINAL FUCKERS NOW!!!
Scarecrow @ 71
She never had mine, but you’re right, 30 seconds and out forever.
Al? Time to speak truth to weaselness???
The DOJ Office of the Pardon Attorney guidelines for clemency can be found here.
At the bottom there is disclaimer that says in essence, “Constitutionally speaking, nothing here restricts the president from doing what he or she damn well pleases.”
The disclaimer is right. But in that case, if Bush did not follow the guidelines which require a formal clemency request, DOJ investigation, and a DOJ recommendation to the President, I’d like to know why. What was so earth-shatteringly pressing, so incredibly time-sensitive, and so appalling to the good name of justice that Scooter didn’t have to file any paperwork and the clemency process was short-circuited?
Other than growing fears that Scooter might spill something unflattering about 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue into the ears of one Patrick J. Fitzgerald.
I am speachless. All I can say is the son of a bitch/Bush did it. And yes, I mean SOB. Once again he gave the finger to the American people and the rule of law.
There is absolutely NO rule of law in the land that I used to call my country any longer. The so-called Justice department under Gonzo is a joke with attorneys and lackeys alike jumping ship. They will soon find some more suitable political lackeys to fill their shoes.
Meanwhile, Bush, the has-nothing-to-lose president, taking orders from his VP continues on his mission of “bring em on”.
This is beyond disgusting. They have nothing to lose, while the American people have everything to lose.
I do not think I have ever felt real hatred for Bush, but at this moment I’m sorry to say that I do.
Meanwhile, the mainstream media is treating this as business as usual, even more disgusting.
Senator Dodd Statement:
Senator and Presidential candidate Chris Dodd today released the
following statement on the commutation of Lewis “Scooter” Libby’s
prison sentence:
“By commuting Scooter Libby’s sentence, the President continues to
abdicate responsibility for the actions of his Administration. The
only ones paying the price for this Administration’s actions are the
American people.”
Hey Shrub, Karla Faye Tucker’s sentence was excessive, not Libby’s.
i’ll grab my cane and hit the bricks - when do we begin ;o)?
0
any statements from Leahy?
THE SPEAKER’S COMMENT PAGE
http://speaker.gov/contact/
go there and make sure you are respectful, get her as incensed as we are, suggest a sentence or two in her press conferance
How about hanging the flag upside down and reading the Declaration of Independence in front of every courthouse and public square on Wed? How about doing that where every celebration and fireworks display is happening?
The country is in distress. We need to signal the SOS. Ring bells. Make noise. Sound the alarm.
And Congress needs to do what Suzanne called for: return to Washington now and take immediate action.
Pelosi:
http://www.speaker.gov/blog/?p=543
“The President’s commutation of Scoot