The best thing about getting an “exclusive” is the exhilaration, the thrill of digging out new information which casts a big story in a different, and significant way. You get a warm feeling, a glow all over. And when competitors comes up with their own “exclusive,” you smile and grit your teeth and say, “Nice job” and try to submerge all those nasty green-eyed feelings of jealously.
The absolute best exclusive is not the one where you pry loose the lips of an insider, or take a tip over the phone and. if it checks out, run with it. The very best exclusive is the one that is just lying there, in plain sight, obvious to anyone who cares enough to root around and dig it out.
It is the stuff of the old radio program “The Big Story” – the Pall Mall cigarettes $500.00 award for outstanding journalism, a dramatization of “You lived it! You wrote it!” Today’s Pall Mall award would go to Vanessa Blum of the South Florida Sun-Sentinel. Her lead – while not exactly rubbing your nose in it – just notes that anyone could have pried this out from the government documents – but didn’t.
It's a passing reference that could easily go unnoticed on the dozens of government wiretaps in the Miami trial of Jose Padilla.It has nothing to do with terrorism or militant Islam or any of the crimes prosecutors hope to prove in court. It has to do with a tape of a radio interview Padilla gave in the mid 1990s about his troubled youth and conversion to Islam.
For the first time in this 45-minute radio interview we gain an insight into someone whom the public (including yours truly) and the police had basically dubbed “a thug,” back from the Middle East and “terrorist training,” only to be arrested at O’Hare airport and charged by the Attorney General of the United States himself, John Ashcroft, with planning to explode a radioactive “dirty bomb.”
But here is another Padilla in 1997, recently released from the South Flordia Broward County jail where he had served 303 days for firing pistol shots at a motorist who had offended him. Padilla reflected on his life as a young criminal,
I was really, really on the wrong path," Padilla says of his brushes with the criminal justice system. "I know for sure now why I had to go through those things in life because now I'm a Muslim."His conversion was sparked, he says, by two visions he had in Broward County Jail. In the first, he saw himself walking in the desert wearing Muslim garb and a turban. In the second, a woman led him down a long hall toward a door. A light so intense it made his flesh tremble shone from behind the door, Padilla says.
"I was going to go inside because it was beautiful and I really wanted to go," he says. Then a booming voice from behind the door told him "Not yet."
Blum writes about Padilla’s feelings of despair:
"To be honest with you, it really didn't matter to me whether I was dead or alive," Padilla says. "I had no goals. It was like I was dead mentally."He began reading the Bible and resolved not to eat until God gave him a sign. While fasting, he experienced the two visions.
"It was something so real, like I was sleeping with my eyes open," he says, struggling to put the experience into words.
After his release from jail, Padilla says he sought to obtain a Koran. At the same time he found work at a Taco Bell, managed by a Muslim, Mohammed Javed, who gave him a copy of the Koran. Blum continues with Padilla’s radio interview:
"I stuck to the book and just read and read and read," Padilla says. "I read it once and then I went back and read it twice."Javed invited him to attend a South Florida mosque. When Padilla saw the clothing and the worshipers' turbans, he recalled his vision.
"I said 'yes' this is it," Padilla says. "This is what the Almighty wants me to be."
At the end of the interview, the host asks Padilla for his advice to non Muslims.
"Don't believe all the propaganda that is being portrayed out there about Islam, about terrorism and extremists," Padilla replies.
Blum, in her exclusive story, offers insight into a Jose Padilla never seen or heard before. It makes one wonder why the prosecution, who know about the radio interview from the wiretaps, hadn’t offered that profile of Padilla.
The government had to have known about the 1997 interview because one of the co-conspirators in the case, Adham Housson, makes mention of listening to Padilla’s radio interview, and commenting, according to Blum’s story,
"I put the tape in and I was going to Hollywood, [Florida] and I listened to it on my way going and coming back," Hassoun says on the 1997 wiretapped call. "It was good, man ... " Hassoun says. "I didn't know what you have been through."
Neither, it appears, did the rest of the nation. While Vanessa Blum’s story qualifies as a first rate scoop, does it come too late to humanize an individual who has been cast in lurid colors as a terrorist?
It’s five years after former Attorney General John Ashcroft held his 2002 news conference labeling Padilla a dirty (nuclear) bomber. It’s three years after former Deputy Attorney General James Comey labeled Padilla a “high rise gas stove bomber.”
It’s almost two years since Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, on November 22, 2005, remembered that— No, it wasn’t a dirty bomb that the man was planning to detonate here in
America, it wasn’t gas stoves in U.S. high rise buildings he was going to explode.. I’ve got it now. Aaah, yes. Padilla was conspiring to commit “violent jihad.”
After Jose Padilla has been branded with more labels than Phineas Fogg’s steamer trunk, will one reporter’s humanizing depiction transform his image? Will Padilla’s surprising epiphany –almost like Malcolm Little becoming Malcolm X–ever reach the jury?
The trial begins week seven Monday.
(With Rachel M. Koch)
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight


Support this site!
Keep
up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

RSS/XML Feed
LZK!
Dru at 1 !!!!
Yeah, live and in person, thanks Dru.
FITZ!!
Obviously this will not be given to the masses, the gubbimint don’t want you to know how badly they have handled this whole thing. Good on her for digging it out and good on you for bringing it here.
Passed up the Zed to read the lede!
What a story.
A young man I know here in Hawaii once told me excitedly, what do you do to hide a national historic treasure? You leave it out in plain sight, with no labels or markers! He then took us to see a great volcanic stone that is their equivalent of the rock from which King Arthur extracted his sword. Those who realize what it is come by from time to time, leaving their offerings. But mostly, people just whiz by in their automobiles, paying no attention to it.
Bob in HI
Thank you, Lew - i’m glad i read it.
Bustednuckles at 4
What is a a surprise is the people covering the trial are damn good reporters. Vanessa didn’t get “lucky” — she just got her fingers dirty digging it up.
Great tale Lew and hooray for Vanessa! Looking beyond the obvious … amazing!
(and now off to a gathering in support of Daniel Biss here in Chicago - he’ll be a Blue America guest soon! - Daniel Biss
I’m a pro at getting my fingers dirty.
And I can relate, sometimes the problem is right in front of you but you aren’t looking at it right,or as my Dad says,”you’re not holding your mouth right”.
Whole thing is beginning to remind me of The Front Page.
Hi Lew, thanks for this. I look forward to your posts and info on Padilla. But one small point — I believe you meant to say former Deputy Attorney General James Comey, rather than Robert ;-)
Beer o’clock here on the left coast, it’s been a looooong week.
Have a good one pups.
Bob Schacht at 5 and Kathryn in MA at 6 –
with reporters like the ones covering Padilla — they don’t let the G get away with the kind of bull**** the media, for the most part of 2001- Nov. 2006, let them get awat with, notable exceptions of course, but damn few of those. That ain’t happening so much, less and less as the media uncovers more and more, each day, each week.
LoudounLib at 11
MY BAD! Dumb, dumb, dumb, fingers flying. I DO know better
while i agree padilla was harmless and the bush administration evil, people who fast and have visions generally scare me…
Lew Koch @ 14
Hey Lew, need a little backstage assistance?
Right On, Lew! And, Rachel! What a revelation! I thought this was the money quote:
“Don’t believe all the propaganda that is being portrayed out there about Islam, about terrorism and extremists,” Padilla replies.
A similar revelation as GWB had, only a different path!!! 8-)
RBG at 16
OBVIOUSLY! All the help I can get!
Aw Lew, don’t beat yourself up! Stuff happens, right?
Lew Koch @ 18
Refreshing your browser makes Mr. Comey a completely different person.
CTuttle at 17
Back when, there was a radio drama called, “Mr. District Attorney” — and one of the catch phrases introducing that role, was something about prosecuting the guilty but defending the poor. Somewhere in my head is the idea that if you represent the United States, or just your state, or county, prosecutors are supposed to play fair.
Something disappeared.
Lew, Would you happen to know if anyone plans to post the audio of that interview on the net?
LoudounLib at 19
Thanks. Next Wednesday, I get to root around a bit in the law books and I come up with some interesting…history.
Eureka Springs at 22
I think it’s available. It’s a matter of getting through. I’ll try if I can get some help downloading it. I’m usually a quill and parchment kind of guy.
Be careful Lew…. lots of firepups will be glad to help, imo. *s*
At the end of the interview, the host asks Padilla for his advice to non Muslims.
“Don’t believe all the propaganda that is being portrayed out there about Islam, about terrorism and extremists,” Padilla replies.
hmmm. Not exactly sure whether this constitutes exculpatory evidence or not.
But if I were on the D team, I’d sure as heck be making a bunch of noise, very quickly, that it *is* in fact exculpatory, was withheld, and is grounds for mistrial.
Lew Koch @ 13
The young cub reporters of today had better be taking notice: What with all the oversight, and the Internet, there’s a World of Opportunity waiting for some reporters to do something that will make their fame and fortune– like Bob Woodward before Watergate. Maybe like Marcy and Anatomy of Deceit. Like the Padilla interview, there’s information lying all over the place. Like during Watergate, what one needs is a nose for news. But even Woodword & Bernstein needed a guru: “Follow the money,” they were told. And they did– right back to the White House.
That’s why the Abromoff scandals are key. And that’s why the 750,000 emails that McCain got for his Abromoff investigations need to be obtained by Waxman. Thar’s gold in them thar hills!
Bob in HI
Lew Koch @ 21
You nailed that one down! It is going to take years to remove this tumor from the Body Politik, we may be able to excise it soon, yet we must stay vigilant for a relapse!!!
jayt at 26 –
That’s what makes Judge Cooke’s order shutting the press out from any contact with the defense is frustrating. I can tell you the prosecution is going to attempt some very UGLY things next week. I’m ready for it.
Perry Mason. Where are you?
Lew Koch @ 29
When is the Defense expected to present their arguments?
Bob Schacht at 27
That was why City News Bureau in Chicago (back then) was so great. You were taught NEVER to trust anyone. Ever. Not until YOU checked it out, personally, did it become a printable fact. It’s much easier to sit back and let someone hand you a press release or attend a news conference. I’m almost positive of this — but I don’t ever recall Seymour Hersh attending a press conference at the White House of the Department of Defense, or any damn place. He roots around, like we were taught, and find out for ourselves.
CTuttle at 31
Defense probably starts end of July, start of August. And expect it NOT to be a united defense.
CTuttle at 31
Check the column Wednesday for something on the defense.
Lew Koch @ 29
but if some private citizen, say from South Florida, were to, umm, just happen to drop a copy of said article into the mail to the D Attorneys…or e-mail a link…
Ya never know, it could happen. heh.
I have to wonder how many innocent people are sitting in jail as a result of being pressured to take a plea.
Well this is sort of OT but one detail of this drive home for me just how corrupt and awful BushCo has been. We have recently lionized Comey because he has shown some level of integrity. Yet he was a willing participant in the destruction of this young man. The best of them are still criminals.
Lew Koch @ 32
Yeah, Old School! Where the leather hits the pavement, and, what made the venerable Papers, well, Venerable!!! WTF Happened???
realworld at 37
I’m not so sure one should be praised for finally doing your job.
Lew Koch @ 34
Wilco!!! ;-)
OT, Rachel Maddow on KO
“Don’t believe all the propaganda that is being portrayed out there about Islam, about terrorism and extremists,”
There we have it.
Obviously, wanting to kill all Americans he can get his hands on.
Lets see now. We have Padilla. And we have Bush. Anyone see what I’m getting at?
Lew Koch @ 39
True, and one’s conscience needs to be addressed, it’s such a Nag!!! ;-)
Think about it. If somehow I were to take a vaction to Cuba, and got caught, I could spend the rest of my life in prison.
Lew Koch @ 32
The WaPo and the NYT used to be great. Then Punch and Donald inherited those papers.
Billionaires, living comfortably. What the hell do they care? Cue Judy Miller, etc. and Fred Hiatt, Michael Gerson, & company.
Dirtbags, everyone.
AP - An Army officer with a key role in the U.S. military hearings at Guantanamo Bay says they relied on vague and incomplete intelligence and were pressured to declare detainees “enemy combatants,” often without any specific evidence.
Oklahoma kiddo at 47
Do you have a URL?
Lew Koch @ 21
Having lived through the ’60s/’70s and all the criminal misconduct by prosecutors in those days, having followed the Chicago 7/8 trials, the Black Panther trials and even the trial of Patty Hearst (which I still do not understand why and how she was prosecuted and convicted), there really is no way that I will swallow the spoutings of a prosecution just because it is the prosecution.
Lew Koch @ 48
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/200....._tribunals
Lew Koch @ 48
Here Ya go:
http://apnews.myway.com/articl.....6CNG2.html
Glenn Beck WPITW for saying “Maybe Jimmy Carter was booked” about the supposed suicide bomber “graduation” video…
dakine01 @ 49
the trial of Patty Hearst (which I still do not understand why and how she was prosecuted and convicted)
Lefties have cooties, remember?
Lew Koch @ 39
Exactly, but if one looks at the commentary on Comey, that is what many of us (myself included) have done. It is a sad statement in my opinion.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 47
Or here’s MSNBC’s version
Oklahoma kiddo @ 50
Sorry, OKK! I’m too slow! ;-)
GordonM @ 53
But that’s it, she wasn’t then a leftie (and I doubt if she is today). Remember she was the victim. Kidnapped at gunpoint and held in a closet for a long period of time. And the Hearst family for damn sure ain’t lefties. This was prior to recognition of the “Stockholm syndrome” but still…
dakine01 @ 52
I love that pic they use of Beck each time ;-)
GordonM @ 53
Blame the victim, again.
dakine01 49
I was in the newsroom when word came, we had film of the Cook County State’s Attorney Edward Hanrahan (close buddies with Mayor Daley) who were celebrating their killing of Fred Hampton (and Mark Clark.) I knew Hampton, knew it was murder, and just about called in like that on the air at noon. The Chicago7/8 was like old home week. I had the pleasure of knowing Abbie, pretty well, and was on the streets in Lincoln and Grant Park and, later, at the Federal Building for the circus of the century-trial. Damn, those were the days.
LoudounLib @ 58
He and Tuckery battle each week for the lowest ratings which makes me wonder what blackmail pictures they have on the management of CNN and MSNBC…
CTuttle @ 56
That’s quite OK. The more verification we have, the better. I don’t mind a bit. ;0)
John Travolta-second level worst person in the world for agreeing with that little guy, the one interviewed by Matt Lauer.
Beware Neocons and Scientologist.
dakine01 at 61
If we could only know what was on those pictures…
Eli’s upstairs on Cheney
Lets see, where are we today:
This Administration condones and has endorsed torture:
I’m pissed.
The Military is pissed.
You’re pissed.
The world is pissed.
The voters are pissed.
Those tortured are pissed.
Cheney is grabbing power:
Attorneys are pissed.
Congress is pissed.
I’m pissed.
You’re pissed.
Bush might even be pissed.
Cheney wants to attack Iran and Syria:
I’m pissed.
You’re pissed.
Congress might be pissed.
Bush might be pissed.
Blair converted to Catholism:
Somebody must be really pissed.
Libby might get pardoned:
I’m pissed.
You’re pissed.
Fitz must be pissed.
Walton must be really pissed.
Libby might not get pardoned:
Victoria Toesuck is pissed.
Neocons are pissed.
Ann Coulter is probably pissed.
So where does that leave us? I think we are winning.
FYI, new thread
1,555 DAYZ AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND..
Citizen Koch and the Firepup Patriots:
Thank you for your act of citizenship, ya know Izzy Stone woulda loved yer coverage. And as for your brothers and sisters in print journamalism…well , let me say that you have a much higher expectation of their integrity than I. And remember about the corporate media, it ain’t about the journalists or the talkin’ head readers, it’s about the owners and their toady editors and writers.
I think that the outcome of this trial is gunna show us jest how far the corruption extends into our justice system…if he is exonerated or if the judge throws the whole bogus thing out, I’ll believe that maybe there’s some healthy tissue left in the body of our justice system. But if, as I expect, he is convicted and the appeals courts don’t overturn , then we will know for sure that we will need to push for a general purging of the entire federal judiciary after ‘08.
So thanx again brother Koch and…
KEEP THE FAITH AND DO THE WORK…ALWAYS DO THE WORK!!
NorskeFlamethrower at 68
God bless Izzy
Padilla is a perfect example of why the Bush administration labeled the people they caught ememy combatants, and put most of them in Gitmo, or undisclosed locations.
If the light of day is seen, most of them will seem like Padilla. They can not be convicted in a court of law, or even a military tribunal without it being a kangaroo court. That is why so few prosecutions have even been attempted.
Simply put, if this administration does try these people, they will be caught in a lie. They would have us believe that they have rounded up a bunch of terrorists, when in fact they have rounded up a bunch of criminals, misfits, and in all likelyhood, innocent bystanders.
There is a reason that Gonzales, against all odds, still stays in the Bush administration. He is, always has been, their dirty work legal expert, their firewall.
I really want to see him pay! I want to see someone put in the AG position who will get closer scrutiny of congressional approval than he had at the time he was confirmed.
Wow. Thanks for this, Lew! Great catch on Vanessa’s part!
How bout this, I’m in second? Nope, I see #72 when posted. Very interesting, Lew! I only read the Sunday Sun-Sentinel; nothing re the trial there.
Bustednuckles @ 4
She writes about a human interest angle to a long and wierd tale NONE of us know squat about . . . that’s all it is!!
He’s not less guilty, or more guilty . . . this is just a READ.
Padilla could have EASILY had malice on his mind . . . there’s plenty to suggest he did . . . question is, had he ACTED on any of that malice? Or WOULD he?
We nabbed him at a really bad time, but he still could be a really bad guy . . . what’s this uprising about his humanity all of a sudden in here?
Now, you wanna rail about the usurping of our constitution and habeus, that’s a different story . . . but for crying out loud, a human interest story? To be judged and used as a MEANS to judge his standing? NO!
Gimme facts.
GordonM @ 53
Bullshit, Patty Hearst was the Paris Hilton of the day . . . I followed that from start to finish, from San Mateo, CA where I lived . . . she was spoilt, pampered, and drugged up BEFORE the SLA took her . . . she did it all voluntarily most likely under the same drug haze they took her in. I worked with people in restaurants who LIVED in Hillsborough and told stories of Patty’s Proclivities . . .
And her daddy and her money got her less, MUCH LESS, than others who were involved, as a sentence . . .
Like the Padilla theme, there’s too many folks believing a kind of kool aid that don’t follow facts . . . a human interest story about a ‘victimized’ person being prosecuted does NOT excuse them from being judged one way or another . . . granted, Padilla deserves a FAIR and complete judging (again), but for crying out loud, that he’s a CARING human being after finding Islam and he was a LOADED DANGEROUS FOOL before, stretches my human loving heart in all the wrong ways.
Harumph.
Neoliberals.
Everybody makes this mistake–it’s Phileas Fogg. Love y’all and everything you do.
@ 73
“Gimme facts.”
Yes well, that’s just the problem, isn’t it … for years we were told of “the worst of the worst” with no supporting evidence. Remember the old axiom of “Justice must not only be done; it must be seen to be done.”
We’ve seen a lot of claims about the “worst” and few of those claims supported in any meaningful way. So, from “dirty bomber” to a human interest angle, why take exception now?
Not a very good way to run the ship of state.
@ 74
I am not a neoliberal.
Maybe I don’t even ‘belong’ at Firedoglake. =:)
If not for the Libby trial liveblogging, I might not even have discovered here. But I’m glad I did. Even if I do not share a lot of the ideology, I do appreciate educated people who express themselves well.
I probably wouldn’t choose to have a beer with Padilla, but I would always have advocated his right to ‘rule of law’ in an open American criminal justice system. And let the chips fall where they may.
Just ask Donald Vance his impression of how far wrong this administration has gone …
test3
If this is a Rovian trap it’s a good one.
If it’s for real, then WOW what a story.