Scooter Libby, Casualty of War?
In "The Soldier's Creed," there is a particularly compelling principle: "I will never leave a fallen comrade." This is a cherished belief, and it has been so since soldiers and chroniclers and philosophers thought about wars and great, common endeavors. Across time and space, cultures, each in its own way, have given voice to this most basic of beliefs. They have done it, we know, to give heart to those who embark on a common mission, to give them confidence that they will not be given up under duress. A process that yields up Scooter Libby to a zealous prosecutor is justice gone awry.Mr. President, the one defining mark of your own moral outlook is the distinction between friend and foe, a refusal to be lulled into moral and political compromises. Your critics have made much of this and have seen it as self-righteousness and moral absolutism, but this has guided you through the great, divisive issues faced by our country over these last, searing years. Scooter Libby was a soldier in your--our--war in Iraq, he was chief of staff to a vice president who had become a lightning rod to the war's critics.
[]
Scooter Libby was there for the beginning of that campaign. He can't be left behind as a casualty of a war our country had once proudly claimed as its own.
I simply don't have enough tears to shed for all the pain and suffering this nation has incurred since 9/11. I can't even make my way to the casualties in Iraq. I'm just worried sick about the perils that Hugh Hewitt is gonna face in the elevator each day.
*sigh*
I think that Fearless Leader's refusal to let military coffins be photographed has had a few unintended consequences, since some people do not seem to realize that "casualties of war" wind up, you know, dead.
As AL says, "Libby isn't a fallen soldier. He's a convicted felon. There's an enormous difference."
(h/t LG&M)
Update: And then Crazy Uncle Marty runs out of the attic with an axe...
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
Hi Jane.
.
Jane!
(and free the zed!)
This Fouad Ajami character; just what kind of idiot is he? That has to be the lamest argument for Libby I’ve heard to date.
Jail with no television privilages I say!
Maybe a job in the prison laundry or kitchen peeling potatos.
That is, quite simply put, nuckin’ futs.
Who the hell is Fouad Ajami and why is he sucking up so hard ina an editorial?
I did like his acceptance of reality here though;
The Kool Aid must have been wearing off.
From the link, “Scooter, I said, has seen the undoing of his world, but he comes before a ‘just court in a just and decent country. I was joined by men and women of greater acclaim in our public life, but the petitions were in vain. Now the legal process has played out, Judge Walton has issued a harsh prison term of 30 months, and what will rescue this honorable man is the power of pardon that is exclusively yours.”
Mr. Ajami (and others) all seemed to feel that it was a just court in a just land — until things happened that they did not like. It IS a just court in a just land. Accept it! Scooter was guilty! He lied when he could have told the truth! His peers found him guilty — it was not an arbitrary decision!
Enough whining, already!
aah, poor scooter.
let’s all have a momemnt of silence and shed a tear or two of compassion for the poor guy.
after all, think of the aspens in the fall. the way they all turn color together …
Hi Jane!
Hope you weather’s nicer than mine, we’re melting here.
I like this part:
Poor, noble Scooter, so misunderstood, a victim of runaway justice! Boo-hoo.
Sojourner @ 8
Oy! Would that were the end of it.
AZ Matt @ 5
IIRC it’s called “KP” as in “Kitchen Patrol.”
And here’s the carefully-obscured-through-propaganda “common mission” that the Libby Lobby’s string-pullers on Wall Street and their representatives in government were working day and night to achieve, unbeknownst to the American people whose public offices they used and abused:
http://www.tomdispatch.com/pos.....ose_bases_
http://www.countercurrents.org/pilger080607.htm
Bustednuckles @ 7
* COUGH * speaker monkey * COUGH *
As far as I’m concerned Libby is damned lucky he’s not facing a firing squad or “a short drop and a sudden stop.”
30 months for perjury and obstruction of justice so his buddies could commit treason? That’s a slap on the wrist…
Course, this is just one of the beginning shots in what Jane said yesterday–Scooter’s new career as right-wing victim.
I wanna hear scooter say “It’s not fair! Mommy!” I’m waiting….
(Hi Jane!)
scooter learns about the realities of being ‘disposable’…
3, 505 real casualties, one fake one…
Why, why, why, should I. Lewis Libby be granted amnesty? Because he is a white Republican male? Because he has powerful friends in high places? Because loyalty to invididuals trumps patriotism to out country? Guess so.
Somebody please tell me that’s a parody.
Why aren’t any of these right-wing “patriots” calling for Scooter to step up and tell the truth. I don’t get it.
TiredFed @ 18
Let’s hope. The report was that he looked pretty pale at the sentencing (you were there, no?). Cause if he blinks, heads can fall.
burnspbesq @ 22
It’s the Wall Street Journal, they only do reality!
burnspbesq @ 22
It is. Of itself.
Speaking of convicted Felons, how ironic is it that terminally fluff-headed Paris Hilton is being tossed back into the hoosegow today, after a brief respite at home…Now, how do the wingnuts crow about deserved justice being met, no special exemptions for class…and in the next breath tell their followers that Scooter deserves a break and a pardon? They will delight in and relish her comeuppance, while beating the drum for Scooter? Don’t think so.
TiredFed @ 18
Hi, TiredFed. Nice to met you in DC.
O the tragic stoicism evident in that accompanying photo!
The yet-unajudicated ” “covertness” ” of Mrs. Wilson!
The remarkable lyricism of his [c’mon Fouad, you might as well write “His”] novel “The Apprentice!”
I can’t go on … but you can believe Ajami does. The thing is longer than a certain infamous minstrel number that I recently saw for the first time. And just as degraded.
interesting to see that the ron paul krewe hasn’t migrated over to this thread (yet?)
Casualty in the war against the Constitution and the Rule of Law…..
PeterK @ 25
yes, but I can’t be sure he doesn’t always look like that. he usually doesn’t see the light of day since his (former) boss is not allowed out when the sun is shining.
Dear wingnuts,
This is not rocket science.
A white-collar criminal defense lawyer (remember, this is the guy whose greatest achievement as a lawyer was convincing Bill Clinton to pardon Marc Rich!) lied to the FBI. Repeatedly. He also lied to a grand jury. Repeatedly.
If he doesn’t go down, the rule of law means nothing.
Is that simple enough for you?
Hey Jane.
I don’t know what to say about these people.
I remember when that punk Domenech got busted for serial plagiarizing, I went to a wingnut site to engage in a little schadenfreude. The comments section was full of cribbed quotes from WWI poetry or some shit, talking about “go gentle into that long night, faithful warrior.” Mind-blowing. I read only one comment along the lines of “wait…isn’t stealing wrong?”
It’s always been clear to me that the real enemy to these people is…us.
Jane Hamsher @ 29
was an honor and a privilege to meet you, and then to meet Marcy. well, you can imagine.
Don’cha just love how to this guy Cheney “became a lighting rod to the war’s critics” by some kind of cosmic happenstance that is not at all related to anything he did?
“Party of personal responsibility,” only for people who are not rich, white Republicans.
Couldn’t agree with you more. The decision to ban photos of the caskets is just another layer of bullsh_t heaped on the American Public by this Mis-Administration. If we could pile 3,505 caskets in a heap on the lawns of each of the members of the Congress, Media, State Capitals, School House Lawns, perhaps we could get the population to wake up and demand that their elected officials do something about the BushCo Criminal Enterprise. I am both outraged and broken hearted at what my Country has become at the hands of these Criminals… I am disgusted
Meanwhile, this “Soldiers Creed” is Hollywood bullshit. Sure, it’s nice to think you won’t get your ass left behind but the truth is there is always a breaking point where it’s not worth it to try to recover a dead body at the expense of live troops. There were 78,750
Missing and Unaccounted for in WWII.
TiredFed @ 32
From what I’ve seen of him on TV and in photos he generally looks pretty relaxed and composed. It was almost eerie, during the trial, no hint of guilt or worry in anything I saw. In contrast, I thought some recent photos of him showed some strain. But that doesn’t necessarily predict anything, of course.
Redshift @ 36
IOKIYAR
tommy yum @ 34
Yep. The only dishonest (as opposed to delusional) statement in the piece is that the war Libby is a “soldier” is in Iraq. It’s not; he’s a fallen soldier only in the war against you and me. And if these people had their way, the destruction of the rule of law would just be “collateral damage” in that war.
Gotta give ya’ credit Jane, you can sure pick ‘em.
‘Course there doesn’t seem to be any shortage of lackies for BushCo.
It is strange the disconnect from reality that these idjits seem to desire.
You want to hear about a soldier left behind? Col. Ted Westhusing was surely left behind. If you don’t know his story, read T. Christian Miller’s Blood Money. Equating Libby to this honorable man is sacrilege.
“Casualities of war” includes both dead and injured, not just dead. Just to add a pedantic note.
Did they think Cheney’s sneering condescension would win friends and influence people?
His rendition of ‘father knows best’ leaves me cold.
If it sails like a duck…Quack?
Worried about “premature cloture”? Some nice snark by millbank here.
If I write like Fouad Ajami, will get thousands of dollars from the right-wing money machine?
I’m not saying I’d do it. I’m saying I’m tempted. Hell, I don’t have writing talent, I’m not a professional anything when it comes to politics or history but I can blather with the best of them.
Nah, I can’t do it. Because if it means I have to compare Scooter to a CASUALTY OF WAR, pardon the shouting, then I have to say I’m just not up to it.
These people are in an alternate universe.
Bustednuckles @ 42
They make their own reality, remember? (forget which WH hack said that, but it was memorable and right on.)
lee5 @ 40
sorry, what is IOKIYAR? I’m slow today.
You think that op-ed is good, you should read Marty Peretz’s blog post recommending it. Here’s an excerpt:
“The rabbis tell us that some people earn their life in the hereafter with one act. Scooter Libby’s act–long and painstaking–was to defend the American people from the further terrors like those unleashed on us on September 11. No one but God can grant him the hereafter. It is only the president who can pardon him. Which is what he should do.”
http://www.tnr.com/blog/spine?pid=115735
OT but it appears Tuckery is being pre-empted by the “Breaking News” that PARIS HILTON IS GOING BACK TO JAIL!!!
At least they seem to finally be recognizing that she’s in a jail and NOT in prison.
PeterK @ 50
It’s Okay If You’re A Republican
IOKIYAR=It’s OK If You’re a Republican
PeterK @ 39
He’s uplifted by his martyrdom.
It’s O K I‘m A Republican
PeterK @ 50
It’s OK If You Are Republican
I know I’m going to be too slow but what the hell
I’ts OK If You Are A Republican.
dakine01 @ 13
I think KP has been OS’ed. (”Outsourced”.)
PeterK @ 49
It’s a great way for a bunch of draft-dodging spoiled brat mofo’s to convince other people to do their bleeding and dying for them.
The RNC must have left over purple heart bandaids from their 04 convention. Maybe they should wear them in solidarity with Scooter.
Brisingamen @ 57
Whoops, wrong acronym! Sorry about that folks.
seanflynn @ 44
Good point. 25,000 plus real casualties, one fake one…
cosmosis @ 62
Don’t get me started!
Oliphant cartoon on Scooter, W, and Darth!
FYI, Replay of investigation of NASA, hearings just started on cspan1.
Shamefully OT to Dak and Raven. Forty years ago today graduated from basic and was put on a bus to Ft. Leonard Wood, MO. Gonna be a combat engineer. Don’t remember Scooter being there but then I’m a tad older. But Scooter’s a soldier, alright…..
Oh. My. God.
The stench of stupid roils off this piece of spoor; I don’t even know how Ajami sits up to take nourishment each day, so incredibly bereft of processing capacity he is. I find the willful ignorance so insulting to those who’ve actually paid a price beyond commuting to the office of the OVP.
David @ 51
wow … that is really teh crazy sh*t …
It’s
OK
If
You’re
A
Republican
IOKIYAR
David @ 51
Thanks, David. Added above. That’s just nuts.
Bearpaw @ 61
Maybe that should be the punishment for all these Republic apologists and war mongers, serving KP in Iraq for the active troops.
what can you expect from someone named fouad? This is a perfect reason why we need stricter immigration laws!
Thanks all for the quick reply. Actually, I’m making a list of FDL acronyms, etc. There are quite a few. I guess I’ll put it out there before long, maybe it would be useful for newcomers.
These people are crazy.
There are guys drunk-dialing their old girlfriends who show more self-restraint.
Ed*ard Teller @ 64
Your posting of the Liberty Vid was interesting. I was in Korea when they took the Pueblo and so much of it reminds me of that except that they didn’t railroad the Captain like the did Bucher.
weeping over Scooter invites a double entendre:
SOB
Jane nailed it in a post the other day:
The fact that a couple of U.S. soldiers are missing right now in Iraq — with the likelihood that they have been or will be tortured, killed, and dismembered — only underscores the moral repulsiveness of this claim for Scooter.
Still trying unsuccessfully to process this visually, but it would make a great epitaph!
I love that one.
Good job.
retirin’ in five @ 68
Yea, like Newt, Darth, GW. . . sheeet.
spurious @ 79
Good one. Of course, one might ask if he NOTICED that the war lost its luster.
Dang it, blew the HTML badly.
Preview is my friend.
Wow - you guess sure get a lot of milage out of the ol’ “fitzmas” routine - get real - it never came and this conviction is not going to resolve any of the issues.
24/7 fitzmas coverage, all the time, almost always wrong - but it was worth a kolfax, righ?
LOL
I meant to add, the GOP probably has this motto tacked on a wall somewhere, just like “The Economy, Stupid” for the Clinton campaign in ‘92.
A little OT, but since you are all so willing: what is FWIW? Somebody used it the other day.
when you mock scooter, a true casaulty of war, you mock, no! You haul Eve off the brontasaurus.
You haul her down with the snake in her hand and you are stained with her sin.
Rayne @ 70
kinda sounds like Larry Johnson’s take at No Quarter on Tom Maguire “You are wrong on so many levels that the english language needs a new word to describe a vacuous twit like yourself.” It gets better.
raven @ 82
I rolled in a little behind the times. I spent Christmas and New Year’s 76/77 in basic but don’t think I saw any of these guys during that time. And there were a fair amount of fellows in their twentes then…
Swopa @80:
Considering what has turned up (the body in the canal?) I think those missing men are already dead.
I alternate between anger, anguish, and nausea…I would love to see the entire bunch impeached.
Rayne @ 69
:~)
Scooter is a causer of war, not a casualty of war.
Scooter is a liar, a felon, and a fraud, judged to be so by twelve properly chosen jurors who listened carefully to the testimony offered at trial and the instructions from Judge Walton.
Scooter is a soon-to-be-disbarred lawyer, who knowingly disregarded the canons of his profession, who intentionally dishonored the court he pledged to serve, and who sought to evade the constitution he had sworn to uphold.
Scooter is an embarassment.
PeterK @ 88
FWIW, it’s for what it’s worth. ^_^
PeterK @ 88
Buffalo Springfield, “For What It’s Worth”
Somethin’s happenin here. . .
from the previous thread:
Ed*ard Teller @ 90
Big Mitch never responded. I’ve known Mike Gravel for 34 years and this is the first time I’ve seen him accused of what appears to be a claim of anti-Semitism. I’ve seen Big Mitch post at fdl a couple of times in the past, and he didn’t respond then to queries about claims he made. Sorry for being a concern troll and sorta OT, but I can’t abide with Big Mitch’s assertion about a person with whom I’ve been on first-name basis for decades, especially because I don’t regard Big Mitch as a troll.
PeterK @ 88
For What It’s Worth
‘milage’? ‘kolfax’?
Did somebody let Ajami in here?
PeterK @ 76
we have one somewhere, but of course I don’t know where it is and can’t find it now. wait a few minutes and one of the regulars will tell you about it.
OT, USA’s in the news:
In a move that could signal his hopes to replace the late Sen. Craig Thomas, the U.S. Attorney for Wyoming, Matthew Mead, has resigned, effective immediately.
wapo linky
dakine01 @ 91
Not at Campbell, Munsani, Vihn Long, Sa Dec. . .
Toles cartoon on Scooter underlying crime!
can Scooter serve out his time as a guide at the new Creation Museum?
Eh. Meh. Gehd.
Bustednuckles @ 84
so is the edit button …. stays live for 5 mins after you post
AZ Matt @ 103
Thanks, that hit the spot!
Mods — clean up on Aisle 52…
Fouad Ajami is on the Council of Foreign Relations for crying out loud. Is it too much to ask that membership in such organizations be limited to patriots?
Time for the rest of the Council to call on Ajami to resign.
lee5 @ 101
wapo linky
Oh great. I think Mead was a member of the DOJ-USAG’s Native American Issues Subcommittee; he spoke at a Native American law enforcement event along with Heffelfinger when Heffelfinger was still USA-MN. Unlike the other NAIS members who were dismissed, this one will be encouraged to stay away from serving the Native American constituency.
PeterK @ 106
De nada!
Rayne @ 99
Righ
*sigh*
Must. Not. Feed.
Rayne @ 100
aren’t those the telltale signs of a hoax? misspelled words, bad grammar, typos, etc. or worse. hmmm.
Mabel’s Wig Shack @ 89
Just wet my pants.
My personal trainer, whose husband is an officer in Iraq and is about as conservative as they come, said right after the verdict:
“He lied to the FBI” with a look of complete disgust in her eyes.
Case closed. Guilty. Some people get it, even if the paid propagandists don’t.
I can’t wait for Irve to flip on the cabal; you know Harriet won’t let him serve time on their behalf. When he flips — and he will, he must — watch how fast the regime’s adherents turn on him: “who you gonna believe, a four-time convicted felon or the Vice President of these United States?”
They are championing the pardon to protect the regime; when Scooter flips to avoid jail, they’ll be the first to disown him.
It’ll happen. Pass the popcorn.
egregious @ 113
Some folks are just infected by beltway blindness.
“There are none so blind as those who will not see”
Jonathon Swift(?)
TeddySanFran @ 116
I hope he’ll flip … but guessing there’ll be sime fuckery to keep him away from serving any time. If he were really scared, he would have turned by now. Maybe SCOTUS will find some way to step in and just shut off the appeals process …
so is the edit button …. stays live for 5 mins after you post
Tried that, got an error message.
He lied under oath to a Grand Jury.
He betrayed the identity of a covert operative to the news media which resulted in the gutting of an entire covert operation concerned with nuclear proliferation in Iraq and other countries.
Prison’s too good for him, but that’s as good as it’s going to get…more’s the pity.