This morning as Marcy and I were headed to court we were listening to James Gordon Meek on Washington Journal. Meek was talking about the the bombing plot at JFK and Marcy and I were laughing as one caller after another expressed extreme skepticism about the seriousness of the threat. Meek did his best to be respectful and try to give some kind of context to their critique but almost to a one the callers were so skeptical about the Bush Administration and anything it might claim that all they could do was scoff.
We saw Meek later at the courthouse and he was good natured about the schism between the Washington Journal's caffeinated, east coast reporter's time slot and west coast callers who were still ripped at 5 in the morning. But he was a bit frustrated that nobody could hear what he was trying to say -- namely that as someone who covers terrorism all the time, it was his impression that George Bush was the very best recruiting poster that Al Qaeda could possibly have. That in the face of the Iraq war, their recruiting numbers were up, their fundraising was skyrocketing and even though many of the recent "terrorist" attempts were made by those with little competence the danger from anti-American forces was increasing. America is hated round the world and responsibility for this can be laid directly at the feet of the Bush Administration.
Meek's greater point was indeed lost. Contrary to what some Presidential 08s might want to believe, we are not safer than we were six years ago.
Which brings us to, oddly, what for me was the most telling moment of the Libby trial today. It is customary for those found guilty to express contrition during the sentencing phase, a factor that judges take very seriously when determining jail time. Libby expressed none. Zero, zip, bupkis. It was my impression during the trial watching Libby that he thought himself a great man to whom a terrible wrong has been done. Today Scooter's career as a man on trial ended and his life as professional right wing victim began.
Looking at the incredible collection of letters written in his defense is enough to give anyone the bone chilling creeps, but it does offer some insight into the sickness that governs beltway culture these days. As Rick Perlstein notes:
What's missing from every single one - every one: a single forthright statement about the magnitude of the offense for which he'd already been convicted.
Because they, like Libby, don't believe he's done anything wrong. The modern Republican party is built on the construct that all government is bad, and once in power they set about bringing into fruition this self-fulfilling prophecy with ruthless efficiency. They destroy everything they touch, but they are very good at what they are good at: PR, partisan politics and preserving their own power. From where they stand, from where Scooter stands, there is no culpability in anything done in the service of this, and Scooter was just doing his job. Read through the letters. The presumption of exreme moral rectitude even in the absence of any kind of moral compass whatsoever is gobsmacking.
But it does go along way to explaining why the Washington Journal is fueled by the anger of people who believe that the government is never to be trusted or believed. This is a terrible problem, probably one of the greatest that the next President will face. Even as we need to start redeeming government from Grover Norquist's bathtub and begin to have a conversation about what the appropriate role in our lives that government should play, people have been rendered so cynical and so jaded, so thoroughly convinced that those to whom governance has been entrusted like Scooter Libby and his letter writing pals can do nothing right that re-engaging the public at a level necessary to redeem this country from the problems we are going to face will be extremely difficult.
It was rendered just a little bit easier today when Reggie Walton recognized what Scooter Libby and his cronies did not -- Scooter is not a great man, he's a common crook and in the eyes of the law he ought to go to jail. This country will be just a little bit better tonight, a little bit healthier and closer to a place where faith in government and our system of justice can be restored because Libby and all his Very Important Friends were not able to hornswoggle Reggie Walton like they have been so many journalists who have fallen down on the job and failed to ask the kind of appropriate questions that should have kept us from getting to this place to begin with.
Thanks, Judge Walton. It was a privilege to sit in your courtroom and see justice carried out. I'll always remember the experience and I believe that as time goes on it will be seen as an important turning point, one where Americans began to shake off the cynicism that has creeped into our national consciousness and reconnect with the kind of faith in the system we will need in order to the face the challenges before us.
What a great experience. On behalf of everyone here at FDL, thanks to everyone who participated in the process and to everyone who shared it with us.
It was the gift of a lifetime, one I would not have missed for the world.
It did not disappoint.
Login Here
Spotlight



Support this site!
Keep
up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search


RSS/XML Feed
zed?
Jane and Marcy!!
you got it.
Jane!
Merry Fitzmas indeed
And speaking of not missing it for the world… namaste, Jane. Keep on keepin’ on.
Merry Fitzmas Jane.
Been a hell of a ride. Thanks for letting me hop on.
Every so often, I think of myself as a writer. Then Jane or Digby (or, back in the day, Billmon) uncorks something like this, and I come back to my senses.
big kiss. happy proud day. how fitz must feel!
WE were honored that you allowed us to be there. Thank you for your time, and especially patience in explaining all the details and why they matter. THIS is what citizen journalism is ALL about. And I sent in my donation for the whole year during the Libby trial, but I may need to send in some extra for today—it was great. AND, I called the sentence at 30 months, too sweet.
Thank you JH, MW, CHS for all that you have done today.
I just went over to InstaHillbillyLawProf to see what the other side has to say about Libby.
Crickets.
Great job Jane & Marcy!
And all I have to say is….
Thank You Jane, Marcy, Christy, Pach, Jeralynn, LHP and all the others who have help shed a little sunshine into what good governmental process looks like.
Fitz = Integrity
Walton = Integrity
FDL = Integrity
Today has been a good day!
I suppose I need to resign myself to the fact I’m being too hard on my party. If the majority of Democrats are too cowardly to cut off funding for the Iraq occupation then how can I expect them to go after Rove, much less Cheney and Bush? In a pigs eye. I demand my party stop the Iraq thing and go after Rove. Perhaps it’s not just the Republicans who want to run out the clock.
I noticed that too, and was surprised that Walton sentenced Libby to the lower end of the range recommended by Fitzgerald. After reading Libby’s statement, I thought for sure he had earned himself another 6 months, and that Walton would sentence Libby to 36-37 months.
That said, on reading your comment, Jane, my thoughts turned to Libby’s wife, Harriet. Somehow, I don’t see her being content as the spouse of a “professional right wing victim”.
I wonder if Libby’s marriage will end up another casualty of his actions.
Very Important Friends. Love that wrt Libby’s “Letter Writers of America.” They are a bunch of VIF’s, for sure.
Maybe they should all write some of them nice letters to the families of fallen soldiers.
The courts are clearly the last bastion in reality, at least for a little while. What we have is a political party that will claim black is white or just as easily, white is black, all depending on which argument will further their political goals. The good of the country matters not to them; it’s all about power.
The obvious, classic case for the history books is how these people howled about the rule of law over a president’s civil court case when the president was a Democrat, and then how they’ve turned the same argument on its head when the matter of truthfulness affects them adversely.
What is chilling to me is that there is simply no honor, no sense of right from wrong, no caring about the good of the country from this party of absolute power. You can expect no fair arguments in the future. If the courts fail to protect us from this craven attitude, where do we go from here?
If this judge didn’t put law over party, the message to the country would be as terrible as the one Republicans are spouting on Fox and elsewhere today. We’re learning the importance of honor in serving one’s country, and our rule of laws is only as good as that honor.
If we keep going up the food chain, ten years from now we might get to Bush.
So, can we start ridiculing the letters (Jeffress had a point, there!)?
My favorites: Mary Matalin’s grim Halloween in an undisclosed location in the middle of nowhere with cranky Cheney grandchildred who were forced against their will to miss trick or treating, but Scooter and his universal love of families made it all better.
Alan Simpson’s praise of Libby’s Loyalty (underlined and capitalized), as well as the belief that the accolade, “The Good Soldier” should be emblazoned upon his brow.
And the fact that even Scooter can’t bear Vickey Toensigs company, and actually turned down a dinner invite to spend more time with the kids (that Scooter, such a family man). The only thing I have heard about him that I can relate to.
I admire you greatly Jane, not just for your writing skills, but also for your fearless ability to take on all the issues that I have followed here on Fdl (lurking)
Thanks also to christy and emptywheel and all
the other Firepups.
xxxxooooxxxx
.☼.♥.♥.♥.♥.♥.☼.
xxxxooooxxxx
I hope Harriet lays down the law to Libby and tells him to flip.
You, Jane, are
.
Thank you for all you do in the name of reason.
This is one of the many spin jobs in the last Democratic presidential debate that I was sorry to see taken seriously by Barack Obama and others. It kind of made me a little ill to see the gravity on Obama’s face as Wolf Blitzer mentioned this while oozing with gravitas and solemnity.
Demos. You really ought to get ‘real’. I am thinking in terms of becoming angry with you. Want to do something really constructive to bring back the Constitution? Think public financing of elections.
Elliott @ 20
me, too
jane - thank you for taking us into Judge Walton’s courtroom with you. and thank you to everyone who helped make it happen.
Thank you for being there since we all couldn’t go by ourselves.
Ach. Sometimes one thinks what’s the use, in weaker moments.
Jane, do we get some Politics TV?
Swopa @ 7
LMAO. Great tribute from a great writer in his own right.
Thanks Jane, I hope Judge Walton gets to see it. I’ll dust off my Spotlighting skills and forward it to the WaPo. I’m thrilled you and Marcy were there in person to see it.
Also a lot of these anti-government Republicans are NFL fans. They would never dream of letting their favorite NFL team play without referees, but that is just what they have tried so hard to eliminate in the markets. Robust investment is needed now more than ever, because free market forces have mostly been replaced by oligarchies. One or two major suppliers control a very high percentage of the world’s markets and in many cases it’s more profitable for them to
price fix and restrict competitionget along than to compete. It’s an extreme irony for me that one place where competition really exists is among the reality based blogs.Hi Jane - I have a “housekeeping” question about the hearing. I was considering coming down from NY today, but I was concerned that there was no way that I would get anywhere near the courtroom. What is your take on a civilian actually getting a seat at one of these things?
Thanks
It was my impression during the trial watching Libby that he thought himself a great man to whom a terrible wrong has been done
Shooter called Libby’s sentence a “tragedy” today. A tragedy!
It makes my blood boil.
These letters are a hoot. Totally formulaic, with little nuggets of mostly unintentional hilarity, like the Cheney gene pool being protected from terrorists. Do you suppose Mary’s lesbian partner Heather Poe got to go to the undisclosed locations for Halloween, too?
And just as my gag reflex kicks in, Judge Walton’s clerk folds in a letter from Outraged Q. Citizen, who asks for some immediate book-throwing. Lovely.
Hi Jane & the crew,
Came to FDL just as Plamegate & FDL got started. How sweet this day is for all of us and joy and pride for what you and FDL has brought to us, open eyes for me for sure.
Always :) :) :)
I first started learning about Valerie Plame and Joe Wilson from Marcy at TNH. From her I followed a link to FDL. MY life has changed immeasurably since I found you, Jane, and then Christy and Pach, and then personally Scarecrow and Selise and KathrynMA and Mommybrain and Teddy . . . and Ned.
You will never know how many lives you have changed by your courage, your wit, your dedication, your fire and passion.
Thanks for the ride. I have no intention of disembarking from this fabulous trip we are on together.
In my eyes, Judge Walton ranks up there near to Judge Sirica in the hall of honorable and admirable trial judges.
We’re a damn sight less safe than we were a few years ago. But I do not blame the GOP solely.
Common crooks do not commit national security offenses.
Elliott @ 20
Elliot, you’re an artist!
The old white guy’s are starting.
Thompson sez he’s the former governor, not the actor.
Thank you Jane and Christy and Marcy for doing you level best to make this little bit of justice happen. It was you who brought in the sunshine that allowed us all to see what was really going on in our own gevernment. And for that you did your country a true patriotic service. (And whoever says liberals aren’t partiotic can go Cheney themselves.).
Just one question on the sentencing for all the lawyer pups out there. In reference to the final discussion at the end between Fitz and Walton: What happens when Probation does the calculation of the sentence? What exactly does that mean and can that change the sentence at all?
have been going through all the letters to judge walton…
one writer states he could no sooner believe libby lied & obstructed justice, “then there is life on mars” haha (good fodder for jon stewart writers)
another writes of knowing libby since he, (libby) was a speech writer for al haig. WHAT??? never knew that tidbit!
cut his teeth early on someone who also didn’t understand the legal boundaries of gov’t officials eh?
TeddySanFran @ 33
EPU’d from last thread, but I think the formula goes something like this:
1-introduce yourself and tell how you know Scooter.
2-Tell a personal story about him (Vicky–I barely know him, but he turned down a dinner invite so he could spend time with his kids. Yeah right! Would YOU want to have dinner with her?)
3-Go on and on and on about his character attributes (with a provided list of suggested keywords, like honest, generous, selfless and so forth).
4–reminded not to argue with the points of the conviction as it would “seem” disrespectful to the court.
Something like that.
To be fair to Scooter Libby, he always obeyed the law when he wasn’t breaking it.
Just where in hell are we going to get the money to install this missle shield on Russia’s front porch?
Here’s a theory… Walton went on the low end so there would be less criticism of being partisan or grounds to overturn the sentence. Possible?
Now that this part is over, I really think that the IIPA violation needs to be tried. It might not be won, but as much of the facts need to get out as possible.
And for the record, I think Rove and Libby concocted the story together because they knew they violated IIPA.
Walton probably figured that there wasn’t much difference between thirty months and thirty-seven months so give Scoots the benefit of the doubt and take away another potentially appealable issue.
OT-Debate’s on
Jane says:
He’s not alone in his ‘impression’ BTW.
And, then you have Bush lecturing Putin on a free society and how “we won’t stray from our principles or our values.”
RevDeb @ 35
Amen.
Educated Plaintiff @ 42
The Mars comment was from a notable person (was it Carlson?). I recall recalling the name, but my understanding is that right at this moment, I don’t recall who wrote that!
Jane, Chrsty, Marcy, Swopa, Pach…
Thanks so much for being fantastic tour guides on the Firedoglake Tour Bus showing us the first, and hopefully not last, prosecution of the criminal minds in the Bush fascist regime.
Such powerful and high-profile citizen journalism was truly groundbreaking and history in the making.
In a great essay that came out last year, that I can not find now, an historian wrote how the clandestine citizen journalists in France published new briefs overnight and began disseminating them in large networks… that eventually brought Napoleon and his ilk down.
The historian likened political blogs of today to the peasant rebels of France.
You are a wonderful example.
Educated Plaintiff @ 42
Did Scooter draft Haig’s wild-eyed “I’m In Control!” speech following the Reagan shooting?
Or was that just the impromtu outburst that it appeared to be?
Write letters, send email, make phone calls and give money in support… to Gore for president.
Rudy — missiles, nukes, terror.
This site breaks new ground daily in terms of actually reporting the news as today- and in terms of the analysis which is first rate. Congrats to all involved.
Hugh @ 44
Scooter was for obeying the law before he was against it?
Loo Hoo. @ 39
shh, don’t tell my sister, she really is one! :)
If any of you see SouthernDragon, please tell him/her I left a reply @ 147 of the last thread.
It might be a story that interests you as well.
P.
Thank YOU, Jane! And Marcy! And Christy!
And thanks to all Firepups who make the Lake the place to come for encouragement in the fight to make this country the real embodiment of democratic principles, and to rescue our Constitution from death-grip of the neocons.
Love to you all!
Bush: Putin has ‘derailed’ democratic reforms
But Bush hasn’t derailed democracy in our country?
wrt libby’s love letter writers…kevin hayden asks an important question:
What Scoots was thinking but didn’t say:
neurophius @ 57
Nah.. he was creating his own reality while us reality-based types are just left to read about it (isn’t that the neocon Empire doctrine)?
Watching the rethug debates now. Brownback’s in favor of partition (isn’t that Biden’s strategy too?).
Mrs. K8 @ 60
;0)
Oklahoma kiddo @ 13
I agree, being a long time Democrat. I think the majority of D’s are against the War. But it does not matter. It is “Destiny” to keep this war going. Laws by Congress are swept away with a “Signing Statement”. The Constitution is…”paper”. Most Republicans are supporting the War and they should have most of the blame. But we will get Rove.
However, we should start with James Carville. I believe he is with Hillary’s campaign. We have to demand that the Hillary campaign, repudiate him. His wife Mary Matalin is a neo-con who helped promote the War and that is enough!. But Carville says he has deep respect for Libby’s integrity. K-street has corrupted Carville.
We also must demand that Carville stops pretending to speak for the Democratic party.
Shouting out to Jane, Marcy, Christy, et al., for all the good work. Although I rarely post, I have become addicted to the Lake and all the great information here.
Thanks for all you do, and I’m so glad you were able to be there today, Jane. Wishing you the best…
So many of the letters evoke Libby and his children, a kind of emotional blackmail and somewhat at odds with the argument that he was always super, super busy.
In response was a handwritten note by if I read the name correctly Tripp Badger:
I’m thinking that Dick, Karl, George and Fred are feeling pretty good tonight.
Gonzales Contradicts His Sworn Testimony About Bush’s Warrantless Spying Program
Frank33 said,
“we should start with James Carville. I believe he is with Hillary’s campaign. We have to demand that the Hillary campaign, repudiate him.”
That sounds like a worthy undertaking for the left Blogosphere.
Woodhall Hollow @ 43
there’s got to be a copy of that little directive somewhere!
Jane,
Thanks again for all your work today, and every day! You wrote,
It struck me that one could substitute “the netroots” or “progressives” for “Al Qaeda,” and maybe a few other simple substitutions, and the statement would be just as true, wouldn’t it?
Any good Coach knows how to use adverse press clippings to galvanize your team for the Big Game. Well, maybe let’s put it this way: I’ll bet Phil Jackson knows when to post in the locker room a newspaper clipping about a snide remark by, say, Amare Stoudemire claiming that Kobe never shows up for the big games. I don’t think Stoudemire is stupid enough to say something like that within range of a microphone or sportswriter, but if he did, Jackson would know how to use it to energize the Lakers in their next game with the Suns.
But our Preznit seems clueless. “Bring ‘em on!” he boasted. And we know how the Iraqi insurgents responded.
And after campaigning as a “compassionate Conservative”, after the election he just told America to STFU, he now had “political capital” and by God, he was going to use it. So we saw the result of that last November, and in a powerful netroots that has kept the pressure on Congress.
Bob in HI
omg Huckabee reminds us it’s StRonnie’s birthday today!
Hugh @ 44
that about sums it up.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 45
China
twolf1 @ 70
Even my rethug friends are starting to wonder how this scumbag could still have a job
Someone posted earlier that Carville is not connected with Hillary’s campaign.
TeddySanFran @ 74
HUckabee has that wrong–Ronnie was an Aquarius.
Frank33 says
We also must demand that Carville stops pretending to speak for the Democratic party.
Carville’s performance on MTP and his letter for Libby signals the absolute END of his career. Enough. They absolutely must go. Absolutely. must. go.
Dems in DC: Don’t get too comfortable while you’re sipping that martini.
Reagan- Feb 6 1911.
LS @ 21
Isn’t it too late for him to flip?
Bob in HI
cc in nm @ 52
gee, I bet emptywheel could help you there! ;)
Duncan Hunter will nuke Iran.
Boston1775 @ 80
Must be that Mary is the one raking in the real $$ in the family. So he has no point, either at home or in public.
rwcole @ 78
Are you sure about that? He was at least until recently and I don’t recall that changing.
Anybody?
rwcole @ 82
That date is only correct if you believe in evolution.
TeddySanFran @ 85
and people will VOTE for that? don’t they realize Iran and the whole middle east will FIGHT BACK?
RevDeb
Nope- I’m not sure- but a regular here posted it- can’t remember who.
Jane and the entire crew,
FDL was the first blog I read. What drew me here was the coverage of the Plame affair in the fall of 2005. What a joy it was to see the truth of this smear in “print” at FDL. For the first time in my politically liberal life, I was not alone. Thank you all for helping me gain a sense of community and for holding this administration accountable. FDL has demonstrated the power of citizen journalism with this story. Congratulations and thank you.
The Repubs are INSANE and DANGEROUS. I want to barf.
Ghouliani gets claps for saying Islamic Terrorists that just this week to tried to blow up JFK.
Did the Wolfman just say “Iraqi nuclear facilities” when he meant “Iranian nuclear facilities?”
SnarKassandra @ 89
Yes people will vote for that. The real wing nuts have convinced a large number of people that Iran plans to nuke us. Scary isn’t it?
Gotta run. Back later. . . .
Then there is the head flight attendant on Air Force 2 who thought Scooter was a great guy because he wasn’t p*ssed that he the flight attendant delivered his dufflebag late. Wow, that Scooter, a real saint.
Elliott @ 76
Thanks for saying that. ‘Cause it’s too true. ;0)
Oklahoma kiddo @ 61
Bush thinks democracy is whatever he says it is.
So, he thinks we’ve got democracy in Iraq right now, don’t we?
Bob in HI
Jane.
What a solid thought provoking post. Indeed one can almost feel the unbelievable pressures bearing down on the shoulders of all players in that courtroom. Every word and glance askew sifted and dusted with antropological acumen.
In the end, it has to be about the law.
No way possible for me to keep up with the dizzying array of names and dates and conversations that you and Marcy and Christy seemed post with such fluency.
You ladies seemed to know instictively that in the deep weeds cases can be lost.
In my own way I deemed it thusly:
The CIA requested an investigation which Scooter Libby obstructed.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 13
No, I think you are not, because I think what Jane said is absolutely correct: There is a tremendous and dangerous problem of distrust of anything issuing from government right now. The Democrats are going to have to be even better than they’ve been at their best to avoid being engulfed by this problem even if they win big next year. And they certainly will have to move far away from the stunts, flubs, and foolishness of their worst moments.
Wolf — “if you are hearing sounds out there, it’s lightning here in Manchester.”
No, Wolf, that would be thunder.
Carville’s website doesn’t list Hillary as a client.
RevDeb @ 95
Exactly. S.O.S. This is the mushroom cloud debate. Booga Booga!!!
Just a heartfelt thanks to FDL.
Thank You Jane and Marcy for all your hard work on this.
Thank You TeddySF for the link to Smoking gun. It took a while but I scrolled all the way through the letters.
There were at least a couple of shout outs to FDL that I noticed.
Most all of Scoots old law partners and associates/secretaries musta been told to write a letter or no bonus this year.
Two particular letters stood out from the crowd:
The gentleman who wrote the articles of impeachment and submitted them to the media as well as to all the congress critters
And the “victim impact statement” detailing the impact as an individual.
I also recognized Loo Hoo and Suzanne.
Tuckery needs to fess up on his conflict of interest with daddy dearest running the campaign to save scoots a**
Natasha and Boris AND Cruella and Wormtongue were the only double signatories. Otherwise, it was back to back letters from spouses or the whole family with their connection to someone who had worked for Scoots.
But Scoots was SUCH an honorable man, playing touch football, and doing all these great things that it was just SUCH a shock that he could be accused of these crimes that weren’t there. Just not the Scoots that anyone could ever have imagined.
twolf1 @ 70
THIS should prove interesting! *G*
uh oh, we’re becoming bi-lingual
Thanks to the FDL troopers who really made this happen. It was your hard work and dedication that made this accessible.
As for Judge Walton, ,you may never understand the depth of gratitude we share. Without your indulgence we would no doubt have to relay on a compromised source for information ( NYT, Russert, Time, et al ) who we now know were used by the Whitehouse to “control the message”. Truly thank you.
Rudy wants to throw you out if you’re not in his database.
Woodhall Hollow @ 79
NOOOOOO!!!! Say it ain’t so!
I feel soooo . . . dirty. Tawdry. Ughhhhh!
Jane, Marcie, Christy, et al:
Thanks so much from this mostly-lurker but perennial reader for your 150% effort to make it possible for all of us to celebrate this glorious day. It’s been a long time coming (and hopefully he’ll be a long time gone).
And with that snippet now fully earwormed, please do keep speaking out against the madness.
My knowledge of the infamous letters of shame to date is pretty much limited to the handful that have been excerpted various places, including, unbelievably enough, in court today (to what was I gather was guarded but detectable disgust and loathing on the part of Judge Walton). I don’t know that I am going to be able stomach much more of them, perceiving generally the limits of the sub-population involved and the odorous contents. Hell, I already have a rant going:
What strikes me from the letter fraction I have seen is how much credit they all seem to want to give the convict for actually behaving like a half-way decent citizen a good part of the time. He shows up for work, doesn’t stab people, isn’t known for infecting others with disease, and doesn’t kick animals. Wow! Once in a while he has probably even put country and we the people as a whole ahead of sordid party politics. But the insights various trials and investigations have now begun to reveal strongly suggest that in reality there is a considerable part of Libby’s time that was spent playing the role of what we might coin Public Disservant by not following those principles. I can’t see major kudos just because most of the time he has been clever enough to not actually be convicted of a crime for it.
And I think it also needs to be said in the way of context that until recently way too many of these so-called “internal investigations” reluctantly allowed to meander along by the White House appear almost certain to have consisted largely of assuring they had been careful not to leave fingerprints, lose emails, assure deniability, and rehearse their talking points so as not to avoid being held accountable for the innumerable crimes and unethical acts they have undoubtably been engaged in.
If that’s was passes for Good Soldier and Loyal American I want none of it.
TeddySanFran @ 101
You know, Teddy, that about sums HIM up, eh not?
prostratedragon @ 100
I hear you. ;0)
Jane. I want to thank you for all of your incredible work and the incredible work of Christy, EW, and everybody else. Thanks for letting us share this with you!!
I can’t wait for Rudy to say Z-visas. As someone with a corrected lisp (better corrected than Rudy’s!!) I will laugh and laugh.
Has Ron Paul had a question yet?
larue @ 110
But I can Gay-roan-tee that TRex and I are both quite happy he weren’t a gemini.
Of course, I share a b’day with the Bargoyle (this Friday) so can’t gloat too much
Bob Schacht @ 98
;0)!
SnarKassandra @ 89
Naw, they’ll greet us with flowers and kisses. I know because Elliot Abrams and the Vice President told me so.
(/snark)
Bob in HI
Wolf cannot get OldLord McCain to stop talking!!
and
that is a
truly historic
blogospheric entry
there jane
heh…
Bob Schacht @ 98
Yes, and he’s doing what he can so that our form of government more closely resembles theirs.
TeddySanFran @ 85
Duncan Hunter will nuke Iran.
before or after he’s indicted?
Duncan Hunter- steamin pile of shit who shares my home county. Yikes!
I’m tellin’ ya, Terra is all they’ve got.
Even Fred Thompson was hammering away on it today while the committee was on break.
jayt @ 123
before or after he’s indicted?
What did Hunter do?
TeddySanFran @ 85
Did he really say that? I had to turn it off.
TeddySanFran @ 85
Duncan has too passions in life: military hardware (the bigger the boom, the better) and hatred of brown people. He never loses and opportunity to combine the two interests… nuking Mexico will be next, I suspect
So what do the gooper do AFTER the phony “whose is bigger?” contest?
Well said Jane. You, Marcy and all the others that provided the indepth, thoughtful coverage so lacking from the MSM are to be commended for you persaverence and insight. America does indeed have a long ways to go to put to rest the Republican mantra that all government is bad. As you so elequently stated, perhaps today was the first step in reclaiming the soul of the nation.
woops.. typos “two passions” and “an opportunity” sorry..
They just sound like a bunch of angry, frustrated, power hungry, old men.
There seems to be some uncertainty about Carville and Hillary. But he is not a Democrat. Also, remember he tried to have Howard Dean fired after the election last November.
The “Office of James Carville” Web site says:
We no longer handle domestic races and have not taken a new domestic client since President Clinton in 1992.
Let’s impeach the prez, sisters and brothers:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v.....mp;search=
solai @ 107
?Que dice?
One thing I have to agree with about the immigration issue, I hate the argument that these are jobs Americans won’t do. And don’t look now, but white collar jobs are in jeopardy too.
It’s been a helluva ride, but let’s not obscure how everyone around here made it possible. We showed up only because you made it possible for us to do it. Hell, you demanded it, and that’s why we love you.
Just like you, we couldn’t not do it.
“I’ll invade em”
“I’ll bomb em”
“I’ll roast em”
“I’ll eviscerate each and every one- every man, woman, and child in that god forsaken towel headed country’ll get flayed and barbecued”
Wolf– OK- well there’s some tough foreign policy for you- let’s move onto the domestic front—what da ya think bout Capital Punishment?
Others are probably a lot further along in their reading of the letters than I am, but Cheney’s photographer? The flight attendant on Air Force 2? It really seems something of a stretch, that they went out and tried to enlist everyone they could find who didn’t hate Libby’s guts, a pretty tall order.
Frank33 @ 133
Sending email to HC in the morning. Thanks for the link. Car-vile must go!
Bob Schacht @ 83
i think libby has made it pretty clear by his actions & non actions, by his lawyers words & his lack of words, that he is willing to go to jail & remain a loyal bushie. theres no way he will ever “flip”. he’s no jack abramoff
as unpleasant as jail will be - he knows there will be plenty of jobs waiting for him from other loyal bushies after he serves his term (depite loosing his liscense to practice law)
plus didn’t he recently receive a standing ovation at a function he attended?? that adoration wont change
rwcole @ 124
Hello. What is it about this county?
rwcole @ 139
I wanna kill and taste the blood and guts between my teeth as I tear the illegal immigrants and terrorists limbs off, one by one, and then nuke the entire middle east until it turns to glass…oh, sorry.
LooHoo
Got invaded by aliens- gooper aliens…
Actually it’s probably a combination of defense industry and military bases.
McCain gives a shoutout to the President’s brother, Jeb!
Frank33 @ 133
Wasn’t there a big to-do during the last election where Carville gave some advantage to Bush through Matlin? must see if I can find reference to it.
Blub @ 128
Extention of his c*ck. Like all the warmongers.
Hey McCain, on the subject of the Native Americans, WHERE ARE THE 750,000 DOCUMENTS YOU WOULDN’T RELEASE FROM THE ABRAMOFF INVESTIGATION, you insincere nut.
Blub @ 77
Just tell them a Republican is stopping the ‘no confidence’ vote and all the Republicans are stopping his impeachment & removal.
Republicans, not just the Bush administration, are destroying us. We must band together to fight back and kick them out of office.
Frank33 @ 133
check this out!
TeddySanFran @ 146
Like as a running mate?
Oooooh, it looks like TPM may have found a bit of a smoking gun…Alvin Goodlings Donsanto.
Here’s how things stood goin into tonight’s fiasco:
Rudy 23%
Freddy 17%
Romney 15%
McCain 14%
McCain’s strategy of embracin ol Clusterfuck an pretendin that his shit didn’t stink ta high heaven didn’t seem ta work so well.
I am the most conservative!
I am the most conservative!
I am the most conservative!
A sinking ship, they all cling to it.
neurophius @ 134
Translation: I live on cocktail weenies and CNN gigs.
With an occasional suck up to Timmeh thrown in.
Just stopping by to say Thanks! for today’s wonderful coverage. You guys are the best.
Loo Hoo. @ 143
I’m in the ‘lil blue spot in the middle surrounded by vast seas of corrupt rethug red. It’s called gerrymandering.. basically, they gerrymandered progressive areas into Davis’ and Filner’s district, leaving for themselves secure rethug districts for Issa, Hunter and Federal Prisoner #94405-198 in the ‘burbs
For my Cherokee family and pals and I know you are looking and watching:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v.....A&NR=1
God is messing with Rudy’s microphone, as he speaks about the bishops and his view on abortion.
Woodhall Hollow @ 153
good name - mind if i use it?
:)
Elliott @ 151
Carville = Quisling
I think this is an unofficial Hillary website.
http://www.votehillary.org/CMS/node/321
Mitt Romney:
“I’m the most radical, Right Wing Republican you have ever met.”
SnarKassandra @ 152
bite your tongue! ;)
Blub
Yep- an it was dems what did it.
I’m out here in the criminal division.
allan_in_upstate @ 156
No actually, it is a lot worse than that. He spends a lot of time messing around with the electoral system in Central and South America. Where democracy is a new and fragile thing. I wouldn’t be surprised if he has a few gigs in Europe (like the UK Labour Party?) as well. Every now and again I mean. The serious electioneering $$ is to be made in this country and Mary makes that.
The Idiot King was blabbing and smirking on TV while broadcasting–in his diplomatic way–to Putin that the cold war had ended but Putin should trust him when he puts missiles in Europe (missiles that don’t work and in Europe where critics say they aren’t needed). The war prez at work with an unlimited amount of buffoons like Libby to help him spread his evil far and wide. Will South or Central America be next for the cowboy freedom fighter?
Elliott @ 165
Did I say something wrong?
Duncan Hunter is running for PRez??? OMG!!! He is a total whackjob!! I don’t even think he’d carry his county…although, RW, y’all keep asking him back. Wasn’t it Hunter’s wife who showed up one day, some years ago, with two black eyes and bruises all over and accused him of beating her, then recanted the next day? Or was that Dana Rorabacher? I can’t keep those crazy OC dudes straight.
omg they are asking Huckabee if he believes the earth was created by god in six days 6000 years ago.
jeebus
Huckabee is scaring me. He’s asking and answering his own questions.
Duncan Hunter is tied into Brent Wilkes who’s been indicted and who is tied into Duke Cunningham another Representative who is now in jail.
“Ahm gonna lower yer taxes”:
“Ahm gonna cancel ALL the taxes an send people money every month!!”
Fiscal conservatives in action
SnarKassandra @ 169
Actually, I think that John McCain - Jeb Bush ‘08 would be a dream team.
For the Democrats.
TeddySanFran @ 171
I can’t watch. What did he say?
Loo Hoo. @ 136
Quo vadis?
LooHoo, great letter!
jayt @ 123
before or after he’s indicted?
Heh, that’s too funny.
‘Course I also read it as “Before or after he’s elected.”
Maybe he could win the Repub nomination and be indicted the same day.
Mommy- He ain’t OC. He’s SDC. He presides over the great east county sea of cactus and desert rats as I recall.
Mommybrain @ 176
pretty much: yup
jesus, kathleen kennedy townsend just dropped the ball. she’s on tweety and the squeaky-voiced wingnut (i forgot his name) just asked her if she thought clinton should have gone to jail, if libby should. she should have said clinton wasn’t convicted of perjury! (or any other crime).
damn if she can’t stand up to that assclown, she should stay off the tv!
Woodhall Hollow @ 167
probably a pre-nup agreement ;)
What did Libby do that was so wrong anyway?
It was Eve who fucked everything up for the dinosaurs!!!
rwcole @ 166
I guess, politically speaking, both sides benefited… the Dems and the rethugs all got safe seats out of it. I still like the idea of running somebody like ex AUSA Lam (an independent, apparently) against Bilbray and at least kick the machine out of the fairly progressive NW corridor. Otherwise, the ‘burbs are kind of a lost cause. I mourn of them :P
TeddySanFran @ 171
Huck - “…if you want to believe that you descended from a primate (he pronounced it pri-mitt or prime-it), that’s your prerogative…”
What writing… what sentences. Jane, you’ve outdone yourself. Thank you so much. It means a lot to many, many of us “out here” to know how much all of you have put into this effort. Three time, ten time, a hundred time winner is what you are, kiddo. We love you.
FYI, new thread
um.. mourn for them.. I can’t type today
Love to see someone kick BRIAN in the nuts.
Mommybrain @ 170
I don’t know, but I intend to do some googling.
rwcole @ 180
That, actually, explains a lot. I’ve known quite a few desert rats in my time.
allan_in_upstate @ 156
His Web site says,
“We do handle all international and corporate consulting.”
He is for sale.
neurophius @ 164
Mitt Romney:
“I’m the most radical, Right Wing Republican you have ever met.”
I think he trains for debates by reading the PNAC report of 2000. I keep waiting for him to say that “what we need is another Pearl Harbor moment”.
Mabel’s Wig Shack @ 184
And she wasn’t covert, either.
Libby::::::::::::::::::
:::::::::::::::::Carville
Hillary::::::::::::::::
triangulation!
SnarKassandra @ 169
Sorry, Cassie, I was teasing you. The idea of a 2008 race between a Clinton and a Bush will send me to Canada! I’m so done with both of them, ENOUGH ALL READY!
Mommybrain @ 192
Actually, most of the desert is in Filner’s lefty district, I think. Hunter is basically the fault of decaying ‘burbs like El Cajon, Santee, Lakeside etc etc
JPL @ 172
Are they better questions than Wolfie asks?
jayt @ 194
I think he trains for debates by reading the PNAC report of 2000. I keep waiting for him to say that “what we need is another Pearl Harbor moment”.
Too late. Some other Repub has already said that. I forget who, but it was on news sites recently.
Perhaps because Scooter is such a great guy, wonderful dad, attends many soccer games and did public service, maybe, just maybe that is why we might expect some integrity when it most counts?
Byron York got b*tchslapped a few times on Newshour for clinging to the no underlying crime excuse. Korn (or Corn) told him “well, you didn’t attend the sentencing so you wouldn’t have heard Judge Walton speak to this directly” ie obstruction of justice, impeding the investigation, etc.
The WP reporter sorry, forget her name, concurred with the Ladies of the Lake, in that she has attended many many sentencings and thought Libby’s statement was remarkable in that he expressed no contrition or remorse to even acknowledge the jury’s decision. Defendents usually do that when they want a light sentence.
ANd jeepers, 30 months? Is that really such a heavy cross to bear? Goopers are making him out to be Billy Bud for crying out loud.
Actually, never mind, rwcole’s right. CD52 (Hunter) includes the hill towns and Borrego Springs while Filner’s district is the southern end of the county all of the Imperial high desert. I still blame Hunter on the mobile home parks in El Cajon and Santee, though :P
Keith up with Joe Wilson!!!!!!!!!!!
52nd congressional district (Hunter) includes the east county burbs (El Cajon, Lakeside, Alpine, and goes up to include Anzo Borrego and the Salton Sea.
Educated Plaintiff @ 142
He’ll have time to do another book.
More animals, more sex positions.
He’s a thinker, that Scooter. A right wing Jean Genet.
Marcy your live blogging is just the best anywhere!!!
I first came to FDL because of the vlogs you all had done and Steve posted on his News Blog. I was so impressed and thankful for this coverage. Excellent job for you all. Good for you! Good for us!
My first thought was that bush may very well pardon Scootie but ONLY at 11:59 of his last day in office. Scootie better get on board assisting that effort ASAP!!! :D
Jane, your thoughts that this conviction will somehow restore some faith that the government is worthy of trust, is somewhat negated by Congressional capitulation on a key issue. I realize they don’t have much to work with, but a few more vetoes on that bill would have gone much further to add value to this conviction cred you refer to. It’s unfortunate too because this conviction is a huge leap in the right direction.
Thanks to FDL for all the excellent coverage of this event!
Thompson: Bush has wonderful characteristics, honesty, integrity, I would send him out as a spokesman for youth. Shoot me now.
Quote from Paul Wolfowitz’s Libby letter citing examples of Mr. Libby’s service to individuals - “One involves his effort to persuade a newspaper not to publish information that would have endangered the life of a covert CIA agent working overseas”
Of course he wasn’t worried about outing Valerie Plame ’cause she wasn’t covert, or working overseas - what a guy.
All of these OWGs (Old White Guys) scare the crap outta me!
All that fear-mongering.
They must be compensating for the lack of somethin’….hmmmm…what could that be???
KO now on the Libby case, and Ambassador Joseph Wilson up in a moment.
rwcole @ 204
Here’s the map http://www.calvoter.org/voter/.....s/CD52.pdf
I think Imperial/Salton may be in Filner’s district.
Tancredo nailed Bush and Rove. Got some applause.
Blub @ 198
You mean (heaven forbid) Blackwater territory?
LS @ 207
living or deceased youth i wonder
Wilson has a beard and grew his hair longer since he moved to NM. Dirty hippie!! /s
solai @ 191
Actually, I think it was Bob “B-1″ Dornan.
Loo Hoo. @ 213
Yep. Check out this article http://www.signonsandiego.com/.....black.html
Filner and Hunter are at war over the Blackwater base, which Hunter is proposing to dump onto Filner’s district. The coup starts in East County :P
Ah, so. The spin is in. “No underlying crime” sez them all.
For shame.
I see a lot of old names in the comments threads today. We’ve been waiting with you, Jane. And, after reading what Judge Walton had to say, it’s nice to know that we’re not all crazy. Justice is possible.
It just occured to me that if Hunter gets his Blackwater base, the drive to Imperial County is going take an extra 45 minutes via Julian, unless one wants to get shot at… I’m only half kidding
Blub, I know the townsfolk are fighting it. Seems the mayor or council was most amenable to the idea. Wonder why?
YOU did not disapoint either! You allowed us to see justice being carried out.
The right wing spin ’she was not covert’ did not phase Judge Walton. A man in Libby’s high government position should have found out her status before setting out to harm her, her agency and her country he said. (in so many words.)
I thank you, all the way from west coast of Canada.
Loo Hoo. @ 221
Those hill towns are impoverished and suffering economically… even welcoming mercenaries is better than the alternative
okay FDL folks:
i CANNOT STAND THIS ANY LONGER!
dick cheney, in an OFFICIAL white
house press release, on the tax-
payer-funded-government web site,
just put out a statement of deep
repsect and support for the CONVICT!
join me in making a scream about this,
please — CHENEY swore to uphold the
law last in january 2005.
really. i am crazed! WTF!?
What a great piece Jane. BUT if Libby does not go to jail, does not do any time , what does all the time, money and attention on this corruption really do? If Libby is out on bond during the appeal process, what does that continue to say. Our Justice system is not just.
If he walks it will prove once again that position does trump justice! That truth is not the engine of our judicial system.
oddball @ 12
I’ll second this!
oh.. on Blackwater, lemme guess… once he gets his merc’s into East County he’s gonna suggest that they be used them to secure that idiotic wall of his… just what we need, half-trained idiots shooting at people on US soil
OK.. from the April ‘07 article:
“County officials said Blackwater’s proposal will take at least two years to process and ultimately will be decided by the Board of Supervisors.”
So that means we have two years to either get Hunter voted out of office or indicted, convicted an’ sharin’ the Dukestir’s labor camp cell.
way to go FDL, you hit the nail on the head!
the neo-cons believe the end justifies the means, which means they are above the law. or should i say, ‘they are the law’.
” “What’s missing from every single one - every one: a single forthright statement about the magnitude of the offense for which he’d already been convicted.”
Because they, like Libby, don’t believe he’s done anything wrong. The modern Republican party is built on the construct that all government is bad, and once in power they set about bringing into fruition this self-fulfilling prophecy with ruthless efficiency. They destroy everything they touch, but they are very good at what they are good at: PR, partisan politics and preserving their own power. From where they stand, from where Scooter stands, there is no culpability in anything done in the service of this, and Scooter was just doing his job. Read through the letters. The presumption of exreme moral rectitude even in the absence of any kind of moral compass whatsoever is gobsmacking.”
Thanks so much Jane and Marcy for your coverage of this incredibly important story. I enjoyed seeing a couple of the letter writers to Judge Walton mentioning FDL (e.g., at p. 111)
Blub @ 228
But I don’t think there’s any evidence of corruption. He was the friend who showed up at Cunningham’s sentencing though.
Dust finally settling after running around all day. Wow, look what I missed…and it’s all here at the Lake.
Thank you so much, Jane, for pursuing this so determinedly. I am so glad that you, Marcy and Christy were on top of this.
Check for my 2Q2007 “subscription” going in the mail.
nolo @ 224
I second your outrage. Too bad there is no comment feature on the WH website so we can tell Dick to go Cheney himself. What an unholy #######. What a chickensh*t. He is a despicable man. I just don’t care for him one little bit.
Hugh @ 96
That is funny!
Rayne @ 232
Hi to Mom, Rayne!
Anyone still on know the link to the letters
Add my voice to those who are thankful for FDL.
All of you are wonderful and your hard work has truly made a difference. You should all be very proud. You are respected and loved.
Nolo,
If it makes you feel a little better, Lawrence McConnell (sp?) on KO just ripped Wolfowitz and others (military people in particular) apart on their love letters for Libby, asking where are the letters of support going to come from for those soldiers who put it on the line, and who are speaking out against this war/now occupation that we were all lied into? Just for starters.
It was a bit cathartic but I don’t think any of us will begin to feel better until we end the occupation and Bush/Cheney are out of office.
Kathleen @ 236
http://salonmedia.vo.llnwd.net.....etters.pdf
Loo Hoo. @ 231
If we get that base, I’m movin’ to the Bay Area
Posted on the other thread I think: Bolton wins my most ostentatious letterhead award. His name is in the biggest print. I guess his love for Libby is exceeded only by his love for himself?
Kathleen @ 236
kathleen, way up thread TeddySanFran had a link to HUGE pdf file from smoking gun…
do-si-do @ 238
You mean standing trial in The Hague?
dakine01 @ 242
Sorry that was last thread # 116…
Blub @ 240
Jealous. Want to go with rwcole and I to visit Darrell Issa if I hear back from them?
dakine01 @ 242
Here ’tis
from Smoking Gun, in case the other link doesn’t work
love letters
Loo Hoo. @ 245
Maybe. What’re you seeing Darrell about?
Loo Hoo. @ 243
Well I am just working on cessation of symptoms. You’re on to a cure…
Blub @ 247
The occupation, mainly. I’d like to ask him about his vote against class action suits against pharmaceuticals as well. No law firm can afford to take on class actions without lots of money.
Reading the letters to help Scooter one can only be reminded of all the defense witnesses/character witnesses in murder or domestic violence or child abuses cases: to wit. You would never suspect that/he could do a thing like that…beat his wife, burn the kid, kill the neighbor next door. Just a nice friendly guy, good parent: never would have thought. Just can’t believe that nice man (or woman) would do something so awful. Such a good neighbor, went to church: do we really think someone we know is going to violate serious federal law and it be OK because it was just my friendly neighbor. No, Scooter, that really is not the way the world is supposed to work. Thank you, Judge.
Loo Hoo. @ 249
Sure, if you want more bodies I’d be happy to help buttonhole my congress-critters. Mine, Susan Davis, is very nice but I don’t know how effective she is, and her letter to constituents explaining the dem collapse on war funding was completely incomprehensible.
Wells’ suggestion that Libby has been exceptionally dedicated while most government workers are just hacks whose overly generous civil service protection allows them to loll back in their comfy office chairs until they reach pension goal didn’t go down so well with Walton, did it?
These people think the rest of us are chumps.
Who’s sorry now?
Blub, sure I’ll go with you.
What amazes me is this idea that because someone successfully obstructs an investigation from indicting on the primary focus of the investigation that means the person(s) convicted of lying, perjuring and obstruction of justice does not deserve to be even tried because of no underlying crime being charged. This premise has always sickened me because of the level of naked contempt for some of the most basic precepts of the rule of law common to all English law rooted societies. It shows that the requirement of absolute honesty when involved in a criminal investigation is selectively applied by anyone making this argument, for it is premised that in some circumstances it is alright to do these things in such an investigation (in this case a national security investigation about outing a deep covert active operative) because they are on your side/on the side of the angels/etc. Such a mentality where the rule of law applying equally including requirements to be truthful in testimony is not an absolute is one to be feared by all those that do respect the concept of the rule of law applying equally to all without fear or favour.
Thank you Jane Hamsher for all your hard work, along with all of your regular front pagers and the most vibrant and wonderful blogging community it has ever been my pleasure to encounter. FDL is a truly wonderful place, and a blog I believe will truly be remembered in the history of how the internet and politics converged is studied down the road. Again, you have my deepest thanks and gratitude for making it so much easier for a poor Nova Scotian to follow in close detail this scandal from the outset, as it mattered greatly to me from the moment I first read the offending Novak column.
Upstairs
http://www.firedoglake.com/200.....gitmo-iii/
it was quite a day. met the unsinkable Jane Hamsher AND the inestimable MT Wheel (yes, folks, she really can type 1,000 wpm). thanks to Judge Walton (who may never see this) for giving Lady Justice her day in court. Fitz, as always, did not disappoint (Truth Matters). quite a day. and then there was the SJC.
The NewsHour had a pretty good spot on the trial, and one of the high points was a very clear explanation for why proof of an underlying crime is not relevant in this case. The investigation itself deserves honesty, transparency, etc. If some of the other talking heads still don’t get it, the conversatin with Lehrer was in straight and simple language. In other words, that claim was zip and dumb.
bookwoman @ 22
.
Thank you for all you do in the name of reason.
that goes double for me. dont know how I would have kept my sanity over the past 2 years without you and ReddHedd, Marcy, Pach, TRex, lhp, scarecrow, and the list goes on.
Jane,
Thank you once again for your fabulous efforts. You, Marcy, Christy, and all the FDL contributors have done a great service for our country.
And to you personally, please know how admired, loved, and cared for you are.
Now then, in the words of the best president of our generation, Josiah Bartlett…What’s next?
Helen @ 31
would not have been a problem if you had been there by 8:30 or so. not a lot of regular folks show for these things.
The sooner the Democratic Party realizes that James Carville is a Republican mole the better off the party will be.
To: 261. Thank you so much; Eureka. Now we can finally understand how he and the bride are able to get along.
Loo Hoo. @ 39
??? are ya supposed to stare at it?
the gang at firedoglake, vis a vis the libby trial, has proven that blogs aren’t just for breakfast any more.
cc in nm @ 52
emptywheel to the white courtesy phone please
((((((Jane))))))
I am just sorry that the neocons only spent $5M.
TeddySanFran @ 155
let’s hope so.
LS @ 149
Does he still have control over those? Don’t the Democrats on that committee have control of them now? This is a highly important archive that may have many of the “lost” e-mails.
Bob in HI
Frank33 @ 163
Translation: She’s the only one who listens to me. The others all told me to take a flying leap.
Bob in HI
brownandserve @ 230
Oops. Try p. 241 of 373.
desertwind @ 252
that comment certainly did not sit well with me, let me tell you. it was all I could do to sit quiet in the back of the courtroom (well, maybe not completely quiet).
“This country will be just a little bit
better tonight, a little bit healthier…”
So, vitally true. I will sleep easier tonight because those who deserve prison are finally receiving there justs…and those who have been punished unmercifully in Guantanamo are seeing freedom.
Thanks FDL.
Good! I wish you the very best health and thank you for all your hard work.
I came of age under Reagan and I was so cynical, so jaded by the end of it. I found it hard even to use words like “honor” or “patriotic”, so fouled were they by their misuse.
I’m over that now, and so eventually will those coming of age under Bush. Honor and patriotism are positive goods even if scoundrels wish to take refuge in them. Part of our job will be to speed the recovery of that recognition.
There were no FDL’s when I was recovering from Reagan. Our country is lucky there will be for recovering from Bush.
Bob Schacht @ 270
Carville also wrote a letter in support of Libby-lenient sentencing. Buzzflash has the link. Matalin and Carville co-signed one. Amazing.
I was in the court room today and to Helen who posted above, it is not that hard to attend - you need to get there about an hour earlier to be sure you get in.
I was waiting in line with an older gentleman who had two valises. He was complaining to me about going through security etc with the luggage. He sat next to me in the court room, then told me he was a close friend of scooter’s and put the valises at the end of the row. When libby et al came in he walked down with them and sat next to Harriet for the rest of the hearing. So, did he have the toothbrush - just in case?
Mary Matalin was queen of the letter brigade, I suspect. Really decked out today too - if you like teen wear. I LOVED Judge Walton’s comment after the first letter rendition, “I’ve read the letters.” Meanwhile after the wind-up about Libby’s “good life,” I expected to hear letters from his volunteer service, the Lion’s Club, Make-a-Wish, anything charitable. Every one of the six letters read by Wells talked about Libby doing a good job - at his job! No Mother Therese, he.
THANK YOU for Judge Walton - you restored my faith in humanity and
THANK YOU to Jane, Christy and March - you saved my sanity!
Nice feelgood article. But here’s the real deal. Fitzgerald didn’t get the guy who outed Valerie Wilson. Nobody got fired except Scooter. Justice was not done. How many wouldbe critics of the administration had their courage chilled? These bastards went after a guy’s WIFE. And in doing so they harmed our anti-prolification program. Two and a half years is going to be an unhappy time for Scooter, but no worse than the enlistment period of the guys who are fighting a war these mother-fuckers lied us into. My, oh my, how the bar has been lowered if we are to think that this is justice.
Please visit the Schapira blog, “What we know so far …”
“… and tell ‘em Big Mitch sent ya!”
And by the way, the judge could have hammered Scooter a lot more than he did for the reason’s I stated in Relevant Conduct and Scooter’s Sentence
Thank you very, very much, Jane. You are an inspiration to us all.
Late to the party - thanks for the ride, Jane, Christy and emptywheel.
Goodness! Snippet:
Errrr, NOT! Keep away from kids. Read his novel.
Good on the Judge!
I am happy to have done my part to have served and to have been a footnote to this affair. Justice was served, and in no small measure due to the steady and guiding hand of Judge Walton.
- Juror #1
Thanks also to FDL, whose coverage I could not read during the trial, but which proved a treasure trove of delight once the verdict was announced.