Via the WaPo, from Amy Goldstein and Carol Leonnig:
"Evidence in this case overwhelmingly indicated Mr. Libby's culpability," U.S. District Judge Reggie B. Walton said moments before he handed out the sentence. The judge said he was sentencing Libby "with a sense of sadness. I have the highest respect for people who take positions in our government and appreciate tremendously efforts they bring to bear to protect this country."At the same time, Walton said, "I also think it is important we expect and demand a lot from people who put themselves in those positions. Mr. Libby failed to meet the bar. For whatever reason, he got off course.["]...
Prosecutors successfully argued that Libby had lied repeatedly to the FBI and a grand jury about how and when he learned about Plame's identity--and what he told reporters about her.
In the court filing that sought Libby's prison term, Fitzgerald emphasized that Libby's lies prevented investigators from learning the full truth about the campaign to discredit Wilson, and may have helped conceal another administration official's criminal leaks. Fitzgerald noted that Cheney was one of the first people to tell Libby about Plame, and that Libby has testified that Cheney and he may have talked about sharing information about Plame with reporters....
The month-long trial cast a harsh light on the way power and information flow through Washington. It offered a window onto the nation's divisions over the war, the Bush administration's disdain for critics and the complex working relationship between an elite tier of Washington journalists and their confidential sources inside the government.
The weeks of testimony and evidence also exposed rivalries within the White House, and the close guarding of information, even among the president's top aides. The trial also made clear that Cheney was involved more personally than had previously been known in the administration's campaign to discredit Wilson.
Former Deputy Secretary of State Richard Armitage was revealed as Novak's original source on Plame's identity, a fact that Fitzgerald learned early in his investigation....
In the weeks before today's sentencing, admirers and detractors of Libby sent Walton more than 150 letters recommending leniency or a harsh prison term. Walton today released the letters, which come from high-ranking government officials and ordinary citizens. Among the current and former officials are former defense secretary Donald Rumsfeld, former secretary of state Henry A. Kissinger, and Marine General Peter Pace, chairman of the U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff.
Ten days after the trial ended, Plame broke her long public silence about the case during an appearance on Capitol Hill. Calmly but bitterly, she lashed out at the the president's aides, telling a House committee that they had destroyed her career and slipped her name to reporters for "purely political motives That same day, the CIA confirmed for the first time that Plame had been working in a covert capacity when Novak's column disclosed her identity and that her employment status was classified under an executive order. (emphasis mine)
Libby lied -- repeatedly -- for a reason. He is a lawyer, one who has practiced criminal defense law and was well-versed in perjury issues from prior representations of clients. He was a high-ranking public official. We may never know the exact role that Dick Cheney and others played in this whole mess because I. Lewis Libby declined to be honest with investigators and a grand jury. That is wrong, and an affront to our nation's system of justice -- and, as an officer of the court, Libby knew that when he was repeatedly lying. He was convicted by a jury of his peers, and now sentence has been passed on his conduct for a 30 month sentence to federal prison.
Arguments on whether or not Libby will be allowed to remain free on bond pending appeal will occur next week -- but Judge Walton has already indicted that he is disinclined to buy such arguments from defense counsel. That sets a high bar for them in terms of changing the judge's mind on that issue. In the meantime, Libby was sentenced today to a 30-month term in federal prison, with a 2-year term of supervised release following the completion of that sentence, a $250,000 fine, and a requirement of 400 hours of community service.
No pardon. No commutation of sentence. Not now. Not ever.
We will have more on the case throughout the day as we get more information. Thanks to everyone for all of the support throughout our reporting on this.
UPDATE: From Amb. Joseph Wilson:
As Americans, both Valerie and I are grateful that justice has been served, reconfirming that our country remains a nation of laws.We are also saddened for the pain that Mr. Libby has inflicted on his family, friends, and the nation. Mr. Libby benefited from the best this country had to offer: the finest schools, a lucrative career as a lawyer and many years of service in Republican administrations. That he would knowingly lie, perjure himself and obstruct a legitimate criminal invetigation is incomprehensible.
It is our hope that he will now cooperate with Special Counsel Fitzgerald in his efforts to get to the truth. As Mr. Fitzgerald has said, a cloud remains over the Vice President.
Every official in this administration must be held accountable for their actions.
Wonder who the first reporter will be to ask Vice President Cheney about his cloud?
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
CHS, change to “culpability” in headline… whoohoo!
Almost a zed!
Christy — Isn’t it “culpability”?
Thank you Christy, Jane and Marcy for all of your great work! FDL Rocks!
Sanity returns!
I’ll believe it when I see it as far as Libby actually ever serving time. I hope my cynicism is unfouded.
Thanks folks — it was a typo. It’s fixed.
Libby in jail. Where he belongs.
No one is above the law!
Thank you Fitz and Judge Walton!
will this sentence even get a third of the attention of paris hilton’s?
I keep wondering what kind of deal Cheney and friends have lined up for the Libby family in order to keep Scooter from talking. They have to have guaranteed Scooter a very nice income of some kind for life.
what are they going to repossess first, my keyboard, my car, or my house?
Merry Fitzmas, beloved ‘lakers.
dmg @ 9
Only if Scooter exposes most of his body parts.
Thanks FDL for all your hard work. Now off to hit the donate button.
Gnome de Plume @ 10
it’s prolly all ready in an account in Switzerland, with a nice lot down Paraguay Way.
will this sentence even get a third of the attention of paris hilton’s?
Only if scoots has a VERY successful sex change operation.
dmg @ 9
Yeah, I had to laugh, a bit ruefully, when MSNBC was covering Paris with the headline, “SHE SPENT HER SECOND NIGHT IN JAIL” while the hearing was going on.
Talk about yer not-so-bright shiny objects…
Madness, madness, madness
I am so frustrated. We need to get our eyes on the ball.
NO ONE HAS BEEN INDICTED OR PROSECUTED FOR OUTTING A COVERT AGENT WHO WAS WORKING TO THWART TERRORISM.
…sorry to scream. But they have ALL skated. Again. My entire political life, it’s the same thing. Iran-Contra. Lord, I refuse to list the corruption, graft and treason. Makes me sick.
No one has been prosecuted by what some consider the people’s hero, Mr. Fitz. Doesn’t anyone have any anger about that? Ugh.
I don’t suppose the Scooter conviction this morning will be mentioned tonight at the Rethugican candidate debate. Pity it won’t.
OK, in my dreams, Scooter sings and implicates Bush and Cheney.
And then Monica Bellucci walks in and asks if I’d like a…well, you get the picture
Thank you, CHS and FDL!
“Via the WaPo, from Amy Goldstein and Carol Leonnig:”
What are the odds that Fred Hiatt and his flock of neo-cons on the editorial page have any remorse for their wrongful tales than Libby did for his wrongful deeds?
tommy yum @ 12
And a Happy New Hearing this afternoon.
Big pdf of all the Libby letters on this page at Salon: Link.
dakine01 @ 17
did you hear Jon Benet’s dad is dating Natalie Holloway’s mom!!!!
Wow! Have been having my eyes examined all morning and just got back. I was hoping the judge would throw the book at Scooter. Finally, some justice. Does anyone think he will start talking now? His wife must be furious with him. Will she talk about his so-called Friends in High Places? Keep them doggies rollin.
I think W. will pardon Scooter before he serves a day.
I think there are several reasons for W. doing so. They are:
1]To maintain Libby’s silence;
2]To let others caught-up in administration scnadals know thier silence will be rewarded;
3]To appease the far right that is currently
raising hell over the immigration bill; and,
4]He is at 28% and doesn’t have much left to lose.
Amy Goldstein chatz at 2pm eastern, at WaPoO, about the sentencing today. Questions accepted anytime!
No pardon. No commutation of sentence. Not now. Not ever.
But, but, what about a presidential pardon?
Thank you to the entire FDL squad of reporters and bloggers!
My mom is in prison for selling drugs. She went straight to prison after she was sentenced. She didn’t make plans for us or the apt or the car or anything. We had to do all that and learn to live without her here. She didn’t get to stay home in case she wants to appeal. And nobody started any wars or killed hundreds of thousands of people because she has a drug problem and sold drugs to an undercover cop.
That was my prediction that I left over at TNH the other day. first half came true, I will have to wait to see if the second part does too.
Question: In cases like this, when supporters set up a defense fund or pay fines for a convicted felon (kinda fun typing that), is the financial support considered part of the felon’s income for tax purposes? How does that work?
.
New Froomkin leads with Libby
EPUd from last thread:
Jane S. @ 177
Please let him know a kindly soul tried to spare him…
or Twain @ 13
or appears on mtv ahead of his booking.
Perhaps both of you could pull on Shuster’s trouser leg & demand that YOU be on KO tonight!!!
At the very least, he should give you a shout out (and an acknowledgment that he cheats off your paper).
Yeah, it’s beer-thirty in Europe.
newspaperbrat @ 20
Some CNN talking head said he expected the pardon topic to come up tonite. I hope it does. I want them all on record in favor of pardoning a felon who lied to federal agents and perjured himself to the grand jury investigating the exposure of a national security asset in a time of war.
Not that I expect the question to be phrased that way, but still….
newspaperbrat @ 20
Nah, it’ll be mentioned when Wolfie asks for a show of hands on how many would Pardon Libby for no underlying offense…
SnarKassandra @ 29
DING!!!
ifthethunderdontgetya @ 22
Hiatt works on the editorial side of the Post. I don’t think he reads articles from the news side of the paper since this would influence his previously formed opinions.
RadRobin @ 19
In a weird sense (if I understood today’s cross-referencing proceedings correctly), someone was sentenced for IIPA, i.e. outing a covert agent. IANAL, so it would be nice if one of our actual legal types could comment on that.
It’s not quite an indictment or a conviction, but it is something.
WaPo (quoted by CHS @ Top): “[The Libby case] offered a window onto the nation’s divisions over the war, the Bush administration’s disdain for critics and the complex working relationship between an elite tier of Washington journalists and their confidential sources inside the government.”
It’s kind of interesting how the word ‘complex’ has become synonymous with ‘corrupt’ in this administration.
SnarKassandra @ 29
Wow. Cassie, I am so sorry to hear that. I really hope that your mother is getting better. I am sure she is very very proud of you–I would be if you were my daughter.
LS @ 38
And nobody pardoned her either.
RadRobin - And you’d like him to prosecute a case for which he could not prove the knowldge componant as required by law due to Libby’s obstruction? That would have been prosecutorial misconduct to file a case he could not prove. We know about Bush, Cheney, Rove, Armitage and others involvement in this mess because of this case — it is all in the public purview at this point to the extent that evidence was revealable.
Fitzgerald and his team are prosecutors — they do what they can under the law, only bringing the cases that they can successfully prosecute because THAT is their job. Anything else is up to the rest of us in the political arena. If you were expecting them to save you from the Bush Administration, then you do not understand what being a prosecutor is.
old gold @ 26
No matter what Bush does, there always seems to be 28% who support him. He could be eating raw fetuses on a friday night and still have support from 28 percent of americans.
Bush can pardon, and probably will. The result will be that the rest of the 72% who think he is doing a poor job as President will just start getting more vocal about Bush’s incompetence. So the quiet majority will get louder..And louder..And louder.
looseheadprop @ 30
You got me by a month. I had 29 months; should have never picked an odd number, I know better than that. Unless pardoned, I think he will serve at least 22-24 months.
Mauimom @ 35
I believe Joe Wilson is KO tonight for the entire show…
dakine01 @ 32
… and very appropriately tips his hat in Emptywheel’s direction:
Woodhall Hollow @ 42
Thank you.
No, she is still using even while she is in prison. And the Texas prison she is in doesn’t have any psych services at all (which she needs cause she’s got 3 different diagnoseses) and the only drug/alcohol rehab stuff is done by volunteers.
I am glad she isn’t here cause she was pretty abusive and not a good mother a lot of the time, but I would prefer if she was in treatment or psych hospital and not in prison.
lhp, since you are here — did you see Anthony Fauci’s letter on official stationery? Who prosecutes this kind of error?
Smoking Gun
cancer_cures @ 45
At the time of his resignation, even after it was obvious to msot of the world that he had broken more than a few laws, Nixon STILL had 24% apporval ratings. The Chimpenfuhrer is about at the bottom of people who actully use brain power.
TeddySanFran @ 36
Thanks TeddySF - I hope it does too and will be sure to watch the Rethug hopefuls squirm tonite after all.
must.
not.
feed.
Froomkin is absolutely right when he says “invaluable” wrt to Emptywheel and the liveblogging. Heck, FDL and everyone associated with it are invaluable!
Professor Foland @ 40
IANAL either but my answer would be yes and no. The importance of the cross-referencing is not just its effect on the length of the sentence. It is an admission by the court that it recognizes that there was an underlying crime the investigation of which was obstructed.
Christy Hardin Smith @ 44
I don’t know if I would go so far as prosecutorial misconduct; the scienter could be established by circumstantial evidence. Difficult to see a “likelyhood of conviction” though.
Teddy- It’s already gone. Impersonating someone else by using their nickname is not something I am in the mood to tolerate today.
TeddySanFran @ 54
My arm feels like Dr. Strangelove’s arm..I want to hit the button. But I won’t. :>
Professor Foland @ 40
Not really. The way cross referncing in an obstruction sentencing works is
The bigger/more important the crime you are obstructing the investigation of, the higher your sentence should be for obstructing. This prevents obstruction from being the lesser of two evils for the witness.
So if you obstruct a murder investigation that is worse than obstructing a jay walking investigation and the sentence handed down should reflect that.
TeddySanFran @ 53
Exactly. Although we appreciate the concern!
The “Quote This Comment” link doesn’t work and there is no button to refresh the comments. Does anyone know why?
yeppers, just looked, and James Carville’s signature is indeed on Mary Matalin’s letter for leniency.
Buh-Bye Mr. Carville! May your unemployment as a democratic strategist be long and non-profitable.
But in order to be of at least some help to Mr. Carville - I hear that there are openings at Chuck E. Cheese. Even if they have no current openings, I’m sure that they’ll keep your application and resume on file should something open up.
@ 10
“I keep wondering what kind of deal Cheney and friends have lined up for the Libby family in order to keep Scooter from talking. They have to have guaranteed Scooter a very nice income of some kind for life.”
IMHO: dead eye DICK will not lift a finger for scooter. scooter will live the rest of his sorry life in fear. he will not be given anything from DICK et al for not squealing —- except his life . . .
scooter is already a wealthy man so wing-nut welfare will man little to him.
Christy Hardin Smith @ 44
And that deserves widening: Fitz tried a case that he felt could survive a greymail defence. That, I think, is one big reason why Rove didn’t get indicted.
My gut feeling is that Judge Walton is well aware of the spectre of a pardon hanging over this case, and doesn’t particularly want to see the judicial process nullified by Bush’s presidential Sharpie.
Bad typo on last comment. Make that likelihood….
looseheadprop @ 30
I thought Federal Courts require a mnimum 80% of the original sentence to be served. That makes two years anyway.
noen at 62 — It sounds like your browser cache is full. Try refreshing the whole page and, if that doesn’t work, restart your computer. It’s workng fine for me but sometimes a full browser cache — especially if you have had your computer on for a while, can cause a blip.
jayt @ 62
Bad idea. He would scare the children.
SnarKassandra @ 49
I really understand what you are going through since I grew up with an alcoholic mother who was also very abusive. I always wished that there could’ve been some way for my mother to get treatment (this was during the days before treatment) and I wish your mother could too. For your sake as well as hers.
I just heard the news!
Congrats to Christy, Jane, and all the FDLers who worked so diligently to see that justice was not only delivered, but explained in a clear and understandable way so even this numbskull could comprehend it!
Thank you all!
Christy Hardin Smith @ 67
Switched from Firefox to Explorer and it works now. Thanks
Connecticut Bob @ 72
I mostly understand it. If I read this and Huff Po and the links, I’ll understand all of it by tonight.
Connecticut Bob @ 70
Hear Hear!
Huzzzzah and all that stuff.
I’ve been skimming through the letters. Seems like they called up every single person who worked in the OVP (and on Air Force 2) and told them to write a letter or else.
thugs.
From a Palm Beach Post editorial:
This other numbskull agrees with Bob. Thanks so much for making this accessible to me. I love being able to yell at the blond CNN bobbleheads at the Prettyman courthouse, “No, he didn’t!!” Seriously, FDL has provided an amazing public service.
Present at the creation of a new media paradigm, etc.
NPR reporting that the WH says that there will be no pardon … now.
Hugh @ 68
not according to matalin: children looooooooooooove the scooterman.
Thank you Jane, Marcy, Christy, and all the Firedoglake stars and firedogpups for your tenacity and support through all this.
Below is our statement on the sentencing.
As Americans, both Valerie and I are grateful that justice has been served, reconfirming that our country remains a nation of laws.
We are also saddened for the pain that Mr. Libby has inflicted on his family, friends, and the nation. Mr. Libby benefited from the best this country had to offer: the finest schools, a lucrative career as a lawyer and many years of service in Republican administrations. That he would knowingly lie, perjure himself and obstruct a legitimate criminal invetigation is incomprehensible.
It is our hope that he will now cooperate with Special Counsel Fitzgerald in his efforts to get to the truth. As Mr. Fitzgerald has said, a cloud remains over the Vice President.
Every official in this administration must be held accountable for their actions
i heart jane @ 63
And Libby is a true neo-con believer. No need to worry about him, his brain is freshly washed everyday.
Good news: Scooter’s going to prison.
Bad news: He’ll have time to write another novel.
Really bad news: It could contain a bear.
Ambassador Wilson! Hello to you and “The Wife”!
looseheadprop @ 59
This was precisely the “weird sense” that I was referring to.
But I wasn’t quite clear on whether Walton was ruling that there was a “preponderance of evidence” that IIPA had been violated, or that because IIPA was the subject of investigation, the fact of investigation alone was the reason to raise the sentence.
SnarKassandra @ 43
You are a very strong young lady. Your mother must be very proud of you.
Hey Joe Wilson, good to see you here! I hope that today’s courtroom events augur well for the future of your and Valerie’s legal travails!
Ambassador Wilson, it’s an honor to see you here!
Joe Wilson @ 79
Have fun on KO tonight and best of luck with the civil case!
Holding the Wilson family close to my heart today.
All the “Irve loves families and children” chatter in the sentencing letters really makes me hurt for the loss your family has suffered, Ambassador. Thanks to you and your extraordinary wife for your service to the United States of America.
Walton was clear in that he wouldn’t even say that Plame was covert. He didn’t get involved in that issue.
Connecticut Bob @ 71
Hear Hear! Multiple DINGS! If only there were a Pulitzer Prize category to honor these leading edge blogger,reporters.
OMG, check out this pure spin lead in Time:
When I. Lewis “Scooter” Libby was sentenced Tuesday to a surprisingly long term of 30 months in prison for perjury and obstruction of justice, he became a victim of one of the most troubling aspects of federal sentencing laws — allowing harsher sentences for a crime that was never actually proven.
AND THIS: JUDGE WALTON “BOUGHT IT” MEANING FITZ’S POSITION:
The leak was the key issue for most Americans, the crux of an apparent White House campaign to discredit Plame’s husband, Joseph Wilson, who wrote a 2003 op-ed piece debunking WMD justifications for the Iraq war. But while outing a CIA agent can be illegal, neither Libby nor anyone else was actually charged with doing that to Plame. In fact, pre-trial maneuvering found the prosecutor, Patrick Fitzgerald, insisting that this was not a case about a leak and fighting defense requests for documents about whether Plame was ever a covert agent, a status that could have made intentionally leaking her identity a crime.
http://www.time.com/time/natio.....73,00.html
WHAT PURE CRAP. THIS IS THE MSM? THIS IS “NEWS”?
FITZ “CHANGED HIS TUNE” AND WALTON “BOUGHT IT” LIKE A CON OR SOMETHING?
Completely off topic:
Today is World Environment Day, which is celebrated in other countries but not in the U.S. Except ….. it is being celebrated with an education campaign at YouthInkLeft.
dmg @ 78
Matalin scares the heck out of ME! Are we sure she isn’t a shape-shifting reptilian?
Joe Wilson @ 79
thank you, ambassador — i hope that statement sends a shiver down the backs of rove and cheney.
Hugh @ 68
But, but, but according to Cruella DeCarville, all the little childrens just LUVS them some Scooter…
Mary Matlin’s description needing to work with Scooter in the desolate “undisclosed” location during terror threats with Cheney was really creepy. She says that Cheney’s grandchildren were “required” to be there and that it was Halloween. Then she goes on to describe herself as “whining” that she was missing her own young children and how Libby went to great pains to create halloween for the kids…while, presumably her very own children were in danger of being what; getting killed by terrorism? That scenario is surreal.
looseheadprop @ 86
Not really. I don’t talk to her anymore. But last I heard, she thought I was a spoiled brat cause no one here makes me go visit her. But lots of OTHER people are proud of me and I am proud of myself, so it’s 99% OK.
Joe Wilson @ 79
Thank you and Valerie for being real patriots and standing up to this administration. If only they’d have listened to you and others in their own administration….we would not be where we are today.
Sparkles the Iguana @ 75
Her memoirs can be printed, but first must be sent to the CIA for editting classified information. I guess I base this on Robert Baer’s book on CIA strategy in the Middle East. A lot of content, and every few pages, paragraphs of blacked out lines.
This is good news. I hope he doesn’t write another novel. & We’ll have to get Darth indicted before he tries to pardon Scooter.
Best wishes to Joe Wilson & family.
Professor Foland@84 - The sentencing order/minute entry should spell all that out better when filed.