This coming Sunday at 5 pm ET/2 pm PT, we will be hosting Anthony Romero, the executive director of the ACLU, to talk about his book, In Defense Of Our America. This book is as compelling a read as it is important, and I hope that you will join us for a discussion of the civil rights and liberties that so many take for granted…no longer.
Mr. Romero and his colleagues at the ACLU have been standing on the front lines of these battles since the 1920s, with the single-minded determination to stand for the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, even when it was neither socially popular nor publicly supported in the moment. Often when no one else would step forward to do so. And we cannot thank them enough for all that they do in support of the Constitution at such a critical testing point in our nation's history. (Hell, even Rush Limbaugh has come around to seeing their value as staunch supporters of individual liberties, at least when it means saving his own arse anyway.)
In light of the discussions that we've been having this week with the Senate Judiciary habeas hearing and the Goodling testimony in House Judiciary, I thought this bit from the very end of the book was incredibly poignant and yet altogether appropriate. And so, I give you a bit of a teaser for Sunday's book salon, in Anthony Romero's own words:
I am also unapologetically patriotic. That patriotism doesn't conflict with my day job. In fact, it is my day job. With all of its imperfections, and broken promises, and unrealized potential, America is unlike any other place on earth. A melding of people from the world over. A history of lofty ideals. And a commitment to realizing those ideals, even if it is through lurching progress and intermittent setbacks. I believe in the goodness and fairness of the American people, from South Dakota to Dover to the Lower Nines to Larned. Progress will come only when we demand it and when we refuse to allow America's rality to fall far short of its ideals. Upholding American values — in defense of our America. That is both our birthright and our responsibility.
My grandmother used to say, "La luz de enfrente es la que alumbra." The light in front is the one that shines the way. That light is America.
That light is also every American who stands up and fights for what is right. Anthony is right — it is our birthright and our responsibility. So let's all shine a little light where it is needed today.
And I certainly hope that you'll be able to join us for a discussion of this powerful book on Sunday at 5 pm ET/2 pm PT. Even when you think you know the law, taking it to the level of the personal — with stories from everyday Americans who fought injustice as they saw it in their own lives, who stood up and simply said "enough!" – is a powerful and moving way to learn more about the impact that each of us can have in directing our nation down the path of who we ought to be instead of being cowed into the corner of who we are in the moment. Powerful message, and it will make for an excellent chat this weekend.
Huge thank you to Anthony (and his co-author Dina Temple-Raston) for writing In Defense Of Our America. It raises a number of very important questions that every active citizen ought to be asking of themselves, and of the people elected to represent them. For every story in this book, each of us could say "this could be me." For that reason alone, it is a read that I highly recommend to each of you.
Related posts:
- Administration Still Defending the Indefensible DOMA
- July 4, 1776: Liberals Up, Conservatives Down
- FDL Book Salon: Idiot America with Charles Pierce
- FDL Book Salon Welcomes Jill Richardson, Recipe for America: Why Our Food System is Broken and What We Can Do to Fix It
- FDL Book Salon Welcomes Paul Starobin, After America: Narratives for the Next Global Age





Spotlight








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

zedaroo?
morning y’all!
I forgto to go back downstairs there for a minute. My bad.
Good morning, some more, Christy!
jayt @ 3
to the corner!
OT. Susan Ralston takes the Fifth. The WSJ broke this story yesterday on page A6. The NYT is running an AP wire today:
http://www.nytimes.com/aponlin…..unity.html
I’m going to take the Fifth…the one in my liquor closet. Is it too early?
Somewhat related (if thinly):
Interviewed for a Public Defender position Tues – send me some FDL posi-vibes, ok?
I’m looking forward to this salon, I may even peep up.
Wishing you good luck, jayt, on the outcome of your interview. Keeping my fingers crossed for the best.
jayt @ 7
posi-vibing here for ya!
One should always be suspicious of “patriotism” whether it be in one’s own breast or anothers. It is the emotional engine of the worst in man. Flags are for armies – armies are to inflict death. Patriotism and war are inseparable..war and death are inseparable.
I am not a pacifist- but I support war as only a last resort in self defense or in the defense of the helpless.
Few wars meet my criteria.
Our president fears the blogs. Now he feels he has to defend America against them… ( h/t huffpo.)
Hey Karl — What’s your screen name? How much does this cost taxpayers?
I want our America back.
I think this is EPU’d from the last thread but this hearing also is revealing some good stuff about document and tape destruction following a speech by the NASA administrator to the OIG.
http://science.house.gov/publi…..ewsID=1835
Elliott @ 13
I want the forces that have taken away your America to leave my Canada alone,
something it appears they are intent on not doing.
America has become a threat to my future, and my children’s future, and it terrifies me.
Anthony Romero speaks for me !
good gaia, what a beautiful quote Christy
I highly disagree that the ACLU wants to help with discrimination cases. I have a HUGE tremendous provable disability discrimination case. ACLU ” doesn’t want it”. I am going for it all alone. It is very very expensive and time consuming and believe it or not, I am having loads of success proving what really did happen. At this point, I wouldn’t take their help if offered. THE ACLU TURNED ME AWAY>
Beautiful.
plainjane @ 6
As the saying goes, I’d rather have a bottle in front of me than a frontal lobotomy. Cheers!
Sophist @ 15
I’m thinkin’ we may need your help to get the original United States of America back!
Sophist @ 15
Even more terrifying to those of us who live here, and have already been overrun.
I’m what they call a foreign-born US citizen. I came to the NYC when I was 14. I am proud to be an American citizen. This country began as an experiment, and over the centuries, for the most part, it has proven to be an experiment that works, with some hiccups, that is: there’ve been quite a few ugly incidents in US history.
But I have to say this: the US is the most multiethnic multicultural country in history. It is the only country that reflects the world. We must not let Repugs and the Right define patriotism for Leftists and progressives. We must not let them hijack the US flag for their own purposes. We need to take back the country and the Constitution from Beltway liars and criminals and shameless political minions.
Here’s what I wrote a couple of weeks ago about the appropriation of the US flag by the Right.
Good morning!
Excellent post, Christy. I really like the excerpt you posted. I can’t make it to the Sunday event, but I’ll read up after the fact.
I guess the Chimp in Chief is going to give either a speech or presser this morning. I don’t have the stomach for it. He may be talking about Petreus’ new Iraq plan “redesign” (no, it’s not Plan B – they don’t do Plan B – it’s just a redesign of the military plan along with some, dare I say it, attempts at diplomacy. I was listening to the Stephanie Miller show about a 1/2 hour ago, and their “Stand Up News” segment on this was freaking hillarious (Christopher Lowell does a redesign of Iraq – it was fab-u-lous!) I’m sure Bush will also talk about how the Congress should pass his Iraq Supplemental Enablement Bill. He’s also supposed to talk about how scary Iran is. Ugh, my stomach.
If you want to inject a little humor in your day, I highly recommend this clip from a Mad TV show a while back. It’s in the style of a Steve Jobs unveiling of an Ipod-related device, but it’s rather political. Very funny stuff. Make sure to watch through the credits, as the bloopers are quite funny.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AGHty_S0TU0
it has become obvious we are a nation of sheep. we talk and write, and complain, baaa, baaaaa. ever comforted by the delusion that our government couldn’t do this to the people of america.
doomsday? sure. life as we know it, obviously. third world, certainly. when? plan for it and stop ignoring reality. your government is.
rwcole @ 11
Does patriotism equate with a desire to go to war? The present task of real patriots is to take back the country and reinstate the Constitution. The flag-waving warlike idiocy of the Bushites is a perversion.
what Christy said of La Luz:
Biodun @ 22
Amen.
Good morning, Christy and everybody-
Beautiful post-and heartbreaking, indeed what has become of this country that a high-ranking DOJ official can subvert the concept of “ignorance of the law is no excuse.”
Anyway, I’m going to Peru tomorrow (seriously!) for a couple weeks. Can you all clean up this mess while I’m gone? Thanks. I don’t really want to hide out in Machu Picchu for hundreds of years-although it did work for the Incas.
P.S. Pachacutec, should I say hi to your ancestors for you? *g*
landofthefree @ 23
Here’s another one (may be old but I hadn’t seen it).
jayt @ 7
Best luck, jayt. Especially after reading Christy’s earlier post, we need you!
Patriotism- love of the fatherland.
Interesting that in wartime the nation is seen as the father and god is seen as the father as well
The father protects and defends- so our God and our Nation State protect us and make the weak children strong. We are obedient to our father- who may at any moment claim our very lives.
The father calls us to courage and strength- to be “all we can be”. The father demands our very best on his behalf. Before the father- our individual wants and needs fall as nothing. We come before the father with bowed head and on bended knee- to demonstrate our subservience to Him- just as a small weak dog shows subservience to a greater dog. When we leave the father though, we are filled with strength- our heads are held high- for we become a collective- not an individual- and as a collective- a pack- we have all the strength we need.
Spurious- yes it does (equate to war).
Patriotism should not be confused with nationalism; I think we’ve increasingly conflated these two concepts, and in this country in particular they should be separate.
IMO, the patriot puts the principles of the Constitution ahead of his support for the notion of the nation-state. Without the Constitution as formulated by the founding fathers, the nation we’ve known as these United States would not exist.
It is because of the systematic desecration of the Constitution that this no longer feels like the America we’ve known. We’ve become a super-sized banana republic; who really wants to advocate as a nationalist for an overgrown third-world country?
It is the Constitution that delineates us from all other countries of the world, and in three words in particular is the core of its value.
We, the people, of these United States.
A real patriot defends the values that bind them, not the concept of the nation-state so labeled the United States.
The earliest references to the Judeo/Christian God are to a member of a pantheon- the God of war.
The root of “Patriotism” is “Father”.
looks like today is the day for the house vote on continued funding of the iraq war.
my rep, jim mcgovern is now speaking on the house floor (c-span)
but i can’t figure out what’s up (i probably just don’t understand enough about how the house operates).
can any firepups explain it to me?
here’s david sirota’s take (warning – it’s not good).
here’s today’s house floor schedule
here’s the house rules for H.RES. 438
here’s H.RES. 438 (Provides for consideration of the Senate amendment to H.R. 2206.).
“Americans are forever proclaiming our boastful aspersions to the world . . . that our government was based on the consent of the people,” though in fact “it rests upon force, as much as any government that ever existed.” : Letter from Robert E. Lee to E.G.W. Butler, Oct. 11, 1867
Just thought I’d highlight that point, and the date, just to remind about the perennial nature of that Myth of American Exceptionalism thing.
And yes, I am a cranky cynical bastard.
GWB presser – “expect heavy fighting and more American and Iraqi casualties.”
Once again, thank you Democratic congress – for not a damn thing.
Spurious @ 29 – that’s a great one. I remember the original skit (from SNL or MadTV or something). The kid does a great job with the facial expressions, hands & body language, just like you’d expect Bush to do.
I’d like a little humor in my day today. Like many, I’m frustrated with this new enabler bill (I love how they added a minimum wage hike – gee, are they trying to blackmail pro-timetable Dems to vote for it?) and I know Bush is going to speak today. Some chuckles are in order. Thanks for sharing that one.
o/t (well, kinda)
Rayne,
your, um, deabtes w/spousal unit on Scandal – wanted to link this for you yesterday – all about the fairness – something a sports fan could appreciate :)
booman
gotta go dawgs!
Have A FDL day !!!
One last comment on patriotism:
Patriotism is effective in bringing a nation to war- it attaches itself to VERY DEEP psychology- psychology that is largely connected to us through a subconscious channel. It lives in a psychic location where it’s closest neighbors are primitive religion and tribalism.
Some try to summon an evil God to do a righteous thing. This is very dangerous. Once summoned- Satan does not slink quietly back to where He came from.
fionnbarr @ 37
On point one, you realize you are quoting a man who defended a culture that relied upon the enslavement of human beings, yes?
On point two, we’ve noticed previously. Thanks for all the constructive help.
Excellent post by Juan Cole today, which also cites an article by Chris Floyd at Empire Burlesque. A sample:
house floor debate on the iraq occupation supplemental funding is happening right now on cspan-1
jayt – good luck on the job prospects. We do need people like you defending the public.
Rayne – spot on about how there is a big difference between nationalism and patriotism. A rise in nationalism has caused many a problem in our world’s history. Often, when a group wants to rally “their people” for an insidious cause, they push the notion of “patriotism = love those who are like you, hate the others”. A rise in nationalism is an important ingredient in creating war. It’s a manipulative tool, and people never seem to learn.
OT Gonzo’s going for the hysterical woman defense:
“The statements made by the attorney general during this meeting were intended only to comfort her in a very difficult period.”
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05…..mp;emc=rss
Unbelievable.
OT, but a suggestion for TRex and Late Night – Do Monica Goodling and Ann Coulter have the same hairdresser?
selise @ 44
So if 20 Dems vote nay, it dies, no?
Patriotism PRESUPPOSES nationalism
rwcole @ 35
rwcole @ 41
So basically you’re an advocate of “matriotism” instead?
Hey, Mother Christy…do you think we matriarchs could do a better job at this nation-thing? I think I could get behind it.
This mom says, Sit up straight, pay attention, keep your hands off other people and their things, and mind the Constitution.
edit: cbl — thanks, I’ll check out the link. He’s been sucking up since the blow out, actually handed me an article from a guy who’s farther to the left of me with whom he golfs. (I think I owe the golf buddy a beer…)
Sorry, but Bush talking about beef…that just made me laugh
I’m very excited about this book salon, Christy. It’s an important book and you’ve done great work on the topic a along, I’m really happy that you and Anthony be here talking about it.
Am sitting in a Starbucks not far from the Prettyman courthouse. Boy it sure as shit was cold the last time we were here. Sunny and warm today, what a nice change.
Rayne
Others have commented at much length and with great clarity on the significance of the lack of a female religious figure in the “religions of the book” (judaism, christianity, and the moslem faith). It is what makes them most distinct- and most revolutionary. Paganism in most forms included strong female religious figures.
Muzzy @ 48
that’s what david sirota says… but, i don’t understand how that is (DS is very knowledgable – but i’d like to understand it for myself).
anne @ 51
specially when everytime you look at him you’re wonderin’ “Where’s the Beef”
Does the Israeli lobby own Hillary?
http://www.jta.org/cgi-bin/iow…..ising.html
“tracking donations say Clinton leads among Jewish donors, especially among those whose emphasis is purely pro-Israel”
Why is it that a candidate can not be PRO-PALESTINE PRO-ISRAEL?
I really don’t think either patriotism or nationalism are useful terms. It seems to me that government is a tool of a society to realize the collective will. And, yes, I am in a Jeffersonian kind of mood today.
kathleen @ 56
Maybe because Hamas is trying to destroy the Israeli state?
Jane, good to hear from you. I hope you are feeling well. Your note about baths and dog noses last night led me to believe that they are not with you. Did they stay behind in CT.?
Israel threatens Haniyeh @jta
Israel could kill the Palestinian Authority prime minister if he is deemed responsible for Hamas rocket attacks, a senior Israeli official said.
Asked Tuesday if Ismail Haniyeh, a top Hamas leader, is on Israel’s hit list, Deputy Defense Minister Ephraim Sneh said: “There is no one who is in the circle of commanders and leaders in Hamas who is immune from a strike. For what does political Hamas do? It gives the operational approval to those doing the fighting.”
Sneh, who was speaking on Israel Radio, came out against calls by some Israeli leaders to cut off power and water supplies to Gaza.
“We want to drive a wedge between Hamas and the populace, not to rally the populace behind Hamas,” he said. “The more collective the punishment, the more people are swept up to back Hamas.”
These book salon’s are great.
a couple books i’d like to plug (and see as salon’s)are:
Nemesis – Chalmers Johnson
Nixon And Kissinger – Robert Dallek
The Assault on Reason – GORE (Is he a one word celebrity yet??)
rwcole @ 49
Most definitely. And those with insidious intentions are adept at making nationalism look patriotic. They can whip up public support for an insulated society that lashes out at others.
Jane at 52 — Damn, that sounds lovely. No way in hell we could have sat outside when we were there for the Libby trial. Brrrrrrr…
I am so looking forward to this discussion on Sunday.
Dickhead is mouthing off
Rayne @ 33
Amen.
Oops I mean Bush’s presser
Hamas wants comprehensive truce@jta
Hamas offered Israel a full truce. Ahmed Youssef, a senior Hamas member and aide to Palestinian Authority Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh, said in an interview published Tuesday that Hamas could halt its rocket salvoes if Israel were to agree to extend a cease-fire called in the Gaza Strip last November to the West Bank.
“Israel’s agreement to extend the cease-fire to the West Bank would enable the government headed by Haniyeh to convince the groups to cease-firing Kassam rockets,” Yussuf told Ha’aretz. “We have the tools to enable us to do this. We are interested in a comprehensive cease-fire, and the question is whether Israel is also interested.”
Israeli officials have made clear that they consider the Gaza truce over. Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni said Monday that Israel has to press its current military campaign against Hamas.
“We have to understand, as we have understood in the past, that sometimes a cease-fire is also a kind of illusion,” she told reporters. “And we need to understand that even during periods when there is apparently quiet, Hamas exploits it in order to build up its power.”
Jane Hamsher @ 52
Both the atmospheric and political weather have become much sunnier and warmer since then, huh? We can see many more rays of sunshine than we saw a few months ago.
Fresh thread, for everyone who wants one.
selise -I read that as well. I guess you have to have the numbers to compute. I don’t have the numbers, but such a situation would give me hope today.
Muzzy @ 69
i’m watching c-span now… still trying to figure it out… not a transparent processs at all.
rwcole @ 53
The goddesses live again, though, they walk the earth. Glad you come here to worship at the altar. ;-)
But seriously, to my mind there is an imbalance in our society that cries for remedy, and it’s along gender lines. Think of how many key whistleblowers in the last handful of years were women — Colleen Rowley, Sherron Watkins, Sibel Edmonds, so on. In a society that actually listened to women, they’d not have had to jump through hoops to be heard nor denigrated for truth-telling. In a society that actually valued women, spineless and mindless drones like Goodling who only follow orders would not be glorified while Plame is vilified for her independence and forthrightness.
Jane Hamsher @ 52
Thanks once again for launching the FDL Book Salons. What a great idea. And whatup at Prettyman? anything exciting?
Rayne, you are a raging fire today!
I’m just gonna follow you around and go “what she said!” ;)
Rayne @ 33:
Well said. I couldn’t agree with you more about that distinction between patriotism and nationalism. For emergent third-world nation-states, nationalism was the passion and vehicle that helped liberate them from colonialism. But sadly, some of these postcolonial states are still neocolonial.
earlofhuntingdon @ 43
Bush’s whole MO is about deception. Cassie was working on a list of ‘what Bush calls it’ vs. ‘what it actually does’ (can’t find the link). Truly disgusting.
From wiki:
My bold.
Biodun @ 22
Oh, my GOD, belly-button gaze much?
Have you ever even heard of Canada or Australia? Per capita Canada is much more culturally diverse than the US. Not only that, they have a better attitude to diversity than we do. Nobody there has a freaking nervous breakdown about signage in third languages (English and French being the official ones). Lou Dobbs would have a stroke there.
God, our insularity is apalling. No wonder you’re oblivious to how we are viewed by the rest of the world.
spurious @ 25
I like Sen Edwards’ remark to the ffect that “it’s time patriotism be about something other than going to war”.
Shrub using his old line again. Why does he think it still works? Has he ever said how he thinks they’ll ‘follow us’?
P J Evans @ 79
That, and ‘over here’ and ‘over there’ aren’t mutually exclusive
Sophist @ 15
Thank you for speaking up. We don’t have many non-American speakers here who remind us we are but one country in the world.
OTOH, we who oppose the stupidity, the greed and criminality of the politicians and the Rich are doing our best. Support us, support the cause and never stop calling for Liberty.
kathleen @ 56
Maybe she’ll take triangulation to a new low by including a foreign power. Call it quadrangulation or just plain strangulation.