Fact Free Fred Hiatt is at it again. The man has never meet a Bush Administration crony op-ed he wouldn't run, no matter how factually challenged or inaccurate it may be. Mercifully, Glenn Greenwald has already parsed the dreck on the op-ed page of the WaPo today so I don't have to:
Many of these statements are highly misleading, as they strongly imply that FISA has not been amended since it was first enacted 30 years ago. But several of the statements -- such as: "the law has not been changed to reflect technological advancements" -- are just flat-out lies.In the wake of the 9/11 attacks, the Bush administration demanded a whole slew of changes to FISA which expanded the President's eavesdropping powers and which the administration claimed were necessary in order to bring FISA into the 21st Century by allowing surveillance of modern communication methods. Congress, needless to say, complied in full, and in October of 2001 -- contrary to McConnell's misleading Op-Ed -- it enacted, and the President signed, sweeping "modernizing" changes to FISA....
That FISA was substantially expanded in October of 2001 -- at the administration's request -- is one of the central (and often overlooked) facts illustrating how severe is the corruption and dishonesty which lies (still) at the heart of the NSA lawbreaking scandal.
The same President who demanded changes to FISA in light of the terrorist threat, who received all the changes he demanded, and who then assured the nation he had all the surveillance tools he needed under the law, then proceeded -- the very same month -- to eavesdrop on Americans in violation of that law. Then, once caught, he sought to excuse his lawbreaking by claiming that the law (which his own administration re-wrote and heralded as sufficient) was somehow inadequate.
In light of McConnell's Op-Ed today, it is also critical to recall that the administration had multiple opportunities since those post-9/11 changes to expand the scope of FISA, and it was the administration which refused those changes on the ground that they were unnecessary. In 2002, multiple Senators sought to make it easier to obtain FISA warrants, and the Bush administration opposed those changes, insisting that it already had sufficient eavesdropping powers. And all throughout last year, Senators such as Diane Feinstein and Arlen Specter proposed endless FISA amendments to expand the scope of government eavesdropping (in response to claims that FISA was too narrow), and the Bush administration was completely uninterested in all of them.
The administration is not, and never has been, interested in expanding the scope of FISA in order to enable them to obtain warrants more easily or accommodate "new technology." Their overriding goal has been, and plainly continues to be, the total elimination of meaningful oversight with regard to how the government eavesdrops on Americans. That goal of theirs was accomplished for many years by simply breaking the law which requires oversight, and now -- having been caught -- they seek to accomplish the same goal under the guise of wanting "updates" to the "rotary phone era" law.
It is probably too much to ask that Fred Hiatt would demand factual accuracy from a Bush Administration crony, but it isn't too much to ask that the WaPo's ombudsperson call him to task for failing to do so in the printed pages of the newspaper. Since it is her job and all. I am certain that Ms. Howell would appreciate you politely calling this inaccuracy to her attention in a briefly worded missive. (And I do mean politely worded, please.)
Since Glenn has already done the fact-checking for her (and please do feel free to include a link to him), it ought to be a quick correction note and a tsk tsk for Fact Free Fred for failing to catch the multiple errors in the op-ed prior to publication or at least noting them somewhere for readers on the printed page of the newspaper. Something like this can really tarnish the sterling reputation of a newspaper's op-ed pages. *cough* I'll be waiting to see if she does her job -- but you'll have to pardon me if I don't hold my breath.
(Lovely shot of a course in Dublin via pierofix. Someone wake rwcole once his golf daydream has ended...)
PS -- Huge congrats to the Balrogs for the birth of lovely little spark.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
a zed?? Moi??
#2!
Welcome back, Christy! We missed you.
wooooohooooo!!
Would I love to golf in that pic above. Weeping in my yogurt….
I’m shocked really, NOT. The wingnuts aren’t concerned about facts.
Hi Christy! Did you see the PBS “Frontline” special on surveillance a week or two ago? Utterly terrifying. BTW, how’re you and the Peanut?
goota run. See you guys later!
Polite queries, concerns and corrections will not change the minds of the publishers, editors, pundits and celebrity news readers as to the error of their ways. Only when they fear real consequences, economic or otherwise, will these purveyors of indoctrination and propaganda realize they have made a serious miscalculation in their support of the radical right. The fear of God has to be put in them before there is any change in the MSM. The radical right wing didn’t take over the MSM with velvet gloves when they started their subversion of the 4th Estate over 30 years ago.
Redd
OK- where’s the course. Is that your bag?
Nothin more beautiful than a golf hole that you just played well!
Does Li Debby at the Washington Post ever correct Conservatives when make stuff up “cough” lie? Li Debby is all over Liberals who use bad words I wonder if she has EVER complained about a conservative ussing bad words?
In the end, the MSM was compromised by being bought by larger corporations, whose interests and goals are inherently conservative, especially regarding regulation and tax policies. In short,the Right took them over by buying them.
Bluetoe @ 9
well said.
Maybe WaPo and FFFH believe the rule of law is a rotary phone era concept, too.
GabrielOak — I’m going to start using “FFFH.” Hilarious.
Good morning from L.A. Great to have you back, CHS. Two excellent posts right out of the starting gate!
oddmommy @ 14
The press in pre-revolution Saint-Petersburg was better than is our poor excuse for journalism.
Christy Hardin Smith @ 16
Thanks and welcome back!
Action Item:
A no confidence resolution on Gonzales has been introduced in the House.
http://thenexthurrah.typepad.c....._no_c.html
Marcy wants you to fire up those phone lines and start calling your Republican representatives!
Marie at 17 — Hope the weather is lovely in LA this morning. It’s gorgeous here today. The vacation was lovely, but it is awfully nice to be home.
1,522 DAYZ AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND..
Citizen Hardin Smith and the Firepup Patriots:
Haven’t we learned by now that not only is the Washington Post irrelevant but wastin’ time, energy and resources respondin’ to their printed tripe jest draws attention to their sorry operation. The corporately consolidated, print media are on their way to joinin’ the dinosaurs…what’s gunna be left of ‘em in five years won’t be enuff ta recycle into alternative fuel. So let’s not waste any time respondin’ to them…let’s spend our time workin’ over elected officials while they still have the opportunity to do sompthin’ about the shit the WAPO and those like ‘em have helped ta dump on our laps.
The Democrats in Congress hafta keep shovelin’ bills at this administration that,like the Iraq War supplemental, will do somethin to remediate the crimes of the last 6 years. Nothin’ may get past the veto pen of the Chimp-In-Chief but the accumulated weight of all the vetoes will send the Republican Party to the crypt with the Whigs. In order to accomplish this, we in the great unwashed nation need ta focus our energy and leverage our work on the elected Democrats…sendin’ polite e-mails ta Debra Goebbels Howell won’t get it done.
KEEP THE FAITH AND DON’T WASTE YER AMMUNITION!!
{{{ to the wee baby Balrog }}}
Welcome home, Redd!
1,522 DAYZ AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND..
P.S. Citizen Christy…welcome back, yer the class of the act.
Ed*ard Teller @ 23
oh, the baby has arrived — excellent! Do we know gender, weight, etc?
I am out of the business….but I loooove babies.
AP - Lebanese troops pounded a Palestinian refugee camp with artillery and tank fire for a second day Monday, raising huge columns of smoke as they battled a militant group suspected of ties to al-Qaida in the worst violence since the end of the 1975-90 civil war.
Israel steps up attacks on Palestinian militants
The U.S. and Israel are the real terrorists of the world.
Kiddo-
It said Lebanese troops.
Norske and ET — Good to be home. And good to see you guys. :)
rw — It’s not my golf bag, alas, but if I am reading the caption correctly on the photo link, the course is somewhere in Dublin. You can bet that if we were there, Mr. ReddHedd would be checking out the links. Unfortunately, good shots for me are few and far between. But Mr. ReddHedd is quite good when he’s having an on day, so perhaps one day in the future…ya never know.
For over six years people have pointed out the factual errors, outright lies, misdirection and shallow meaningless coverage in the MSM. They have written letters, made telephone calls, sent emails, contacted their representatives, marched in the streets and signed petitions in an attempt to express polite, respectful concern. What has been the result? A MSM that is so corrupted and compromised by power and priviledge that they are unable to change course to reassert the the honest role of the 4th Estate in political life of the nation. Thankfully, more and more people able to think for themselves are cancelling their subscriptions to the NYT, WaPo, Time, Newsweek and turning off the network news and the Sunday talk show bubble heads. The sooner the MSM is relegated to the trash can of history the sooner the country can be reclaimed by the people.
xyz
My congresscritter is Bilbray- not much chance but I’ll drop him a line.
It’s a boy, 8 lb 11 oz.
Edward Teller–How went the performance of Tschaikowsky (NOT Beethoven, my bad)?–and again, good on you for your post-taps statement about this !@#$%^&* war.
I think that the foul-mouthed Texan who is the WaPo Ombudsperson long ago claimed that her purview only includes reporting,
not opinion pieces.
Besides, she has more important things on her mind than the Fourth Amendment,
like whether an office betting pool crosses an ethical line.
Redd
Dublin is it? Well anything Irish is worth looking at- but the west coast if magic.
ccmask @ 8
…he says, grabbing golf clubs.
Wee Balrog is named Garrett, and weighed in at close to nine pounds. Mom and babyrog are just fine.
My clubs are in the car waiting while I do my mandatory home duty for a couple of more hours.
Bluetoe at 29 — I thought about mentioning a subscription cancellation, but so few folks that I know even bother having one to the WaPo these days that it would be a not-so-substantial effort, I should think. It’s sad, really, when you think of the stories that used to be dug into and broken in the WaPo and the NYTimes and other press outlets how little of it is allowed to break through these days. All the more so because I know that many of these outlets still have excellent journalists on their staffs — but they have been relegated to non-story infotainment reporting and steno duty. Beyond irritating, and something that no doubt has some of the greats of the past spinning in anger.
rwcole @ 27
“It said…” What said?
Christy Hardin Smith @ 21
Foggy in Santa Monica, but I like fog. Agreed, vacations are great, but nothing beats being back home (glad you’re enjoying settling back into your abode & FDL)…
rwcole @ 30
I’m sorry, rwcole, mine’s Issa. I’ll call too.
Kiddo
The AP story you quoted in your post- it said “Lebanese Troops” not Israeli troops.
Maybe I didn’t understand your point.
oddmommy @ 25
from late late night:
Balrog @ 169
I think 8′11″ means like pounds and ounces…?
Loo Hoo @ 36
so pleased to hear it. BIG baby.
OT–
Some firepups might be interested in attending this event that raginggurll and I are presenting in Second Life.
It’s a panel discussion taking place on the day between the Democratic and Republican debates in Manchester, being hosted by CNN. The event starts at 10 am. Frank Luntz. Bill Schneider, Lawrence O’Donnell are among the attendees. It will be a live video stream of the panel discussion. Virtual attendees will be able to watch the discussion, and discuss it among themselves in chat and IM. Kind of a like an FDL comment session during a live blog.
We expect you’ll be able to submit questions to me via SL IM that I will in turn ask the panelists.
If you have questions, please drop me a note jay@ackroyd.org. Also, if there’s interest, I’ll have a newbie orientation session on Saturday morning in Second Life.
No. The Rog is 8 feet 11 inches tall- and still growing of course.
My God. Baby Balrog was almost 9 feet tall!
Hope the Missus is OK.
-GSD
Christy Hardin Smith @ 28
bet if you buttered up Tom DeLay he might get you in at St. Andrews.
Oh, Ms. Howell’s doing her job alright, her job being like that of the pedantic schoolteacher who keeps the kids in line with stultifying busywork. Here’s from her latest.
“Half pages in The Post’s Sunday Source, Health and Home sections are a growing irritant with readers. A steady chorus complains every week, and as the use of half pages grows, so do complaints. Readers find those flapping half pages maddeningly hard to read on the Metro, at a desk or table, or even sitting in a chair. Just listen…”
http://www.washingtonpost.com/.....01647.html
rwcole @ 46
Mr. & Mrs. Balrog kin to Trex?
This is not a slam on anyone because I am not really sure of the nuts and bolts that go on behind the different political blogs and websites. There are so many good writers on the left side of the aisle and they do a tremendous job of debunking the crap that ends up in the national newspapers, but I am wondering…
Has Jane, Christy, Glenn, and the other fabulous writers in the lefty blog arena tried to get their own op-eds into the national papers? Have they tried and gotten shut out of the process, or have they not tried at all? It would be rather nice to get a wedge put into place on the op-ed pages to counter the usual crap that gets published.
just wondering…
Welcome back, Christy. Great post.
Gosh - what a coincidence - the weekend after we learn about Card and Abu creeping into Ashcroft’s room to get a delirious man to authorize Bush’s criminal domestic spying, WaPoo gives op-ed space to Bush’s man McConnell - asking for the same retroactive changes.
Bush is frightened about this.
Lovely.
The weather in southern california this spring has been very substandard. We haven’t seen much of the sun and we’ve been stuck in the low sixties.
That’s not bad for much of the country- but it sucks big time for those of us here.
OKKiddo
about my Falwellian Fly:
John Lennon’s Karma song was PERFECT!
Welcome back, CHS. You missed another fun week, but it just keeps getting better and better…
Reading Greenwald (and being in a dark deep subcategory of newsconsumer), I have to say that I had no idea about the October 2001 revisions of FISA. Following this (warrantless wiretapping) and the various other threads (USAs, Plamegate, etc.) for awhile now, I wonder how many Pups and others knew that FISA had been thoroughly revised?
I don’t think somebody like McConnell makes an honest mistake here, but the October revisions are definitely not part of the mainstream–or, I don’t think, naive blogstream like me–understanding of the sequence of events in the NSA story. For instance, were the revisions mentioned in the Frontline documentary last week?
zhiv at 55 — It hasn’t just been a single revision, either — it’s been several. There has been tinkering and fine tuning — and some chime in revisions among the Patriot Act as well. Any claim that it hasn’t been touched is so incredibly far from honest as to be completely laughable. Which is exactly why FFFH jumped on it. Pa. The. Tic.
Ed*ard Teller @43
8′11″ either means pounds and ounces, or..
There was a mix-up at the hospital and the Balrogs ended up with T-Rex’s offspring.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 26
We see the genius of the neo-con foreign policy. The Middle East has never been more peaceful.
With the exception of all of the wars, potential wars and future wars and the empowerment of radical elements and constant military intervention by the US and Israel they’ve got a real winner of a strategy.
-GSD
In light of the no-confidence vote now going on in Congress, this is what Bush has to say:
Christy Hardin Smith @ 38
Your absolutely right. Edward R. Murrow et al are spinning in their graves and yes, there are some good journalists still employed by the MSM. Unfortunately they are unable to do the work that has traditionaly been that of their chosen profession. I would hope that these men and women that still have their intergrity and professional ethics will see the handwritting on the wall and ditch the dumps they now find themselves and come over to how information is disseminated and digested in the future, the internet.
rwcole @ 42
Let me be clear. The U.S. government, through their actions in the Middle East and blind support of Israel (Iraq, Lebanon, etc.) and the Israeli government (Palestine, Lebanon, etc.) through their actions, are the primary terrorists of the world today. Want to talk about U.S. actions in Africa?
Christy Hardin Smith @ 38
well, the investigative tradition has moved on to places like firedoglake — and friends. May not be MSM yet but the desire to get at the truth and get out the truth has not passed away.
rwcole @ 53
I’m betting we make up for it w/a blazing hot summer, though, but yeah, it’s been chilly. For us.
Lack of rain this season a big factor, also. We already had a forest fire in Griffith Park, for godsakes…
Loo Hoo @ 41
you have my deepest sympathies, Loo Hoo.
8′11″ either means pounds and ounces, or..
or in terms of arc, 8 minutes 11 seconds. (Good practice, though, to show 0 in front however to indicate zero degrees.)
jayackroyd @ 45
I’d be interested in an orientation.
rwcole @ 46
He eats small cows.
Christy Hardin Smith @ 38
I’ve said this here b4, but…..as frustrated as I am with the WaPoop, I still maintain my subscription. It IS the hometown paper, and I am old enough so that I still like a printed product in my front yard every morning. Plus, there are good features….columnnists like Eugene Robinson, Harold Meyerson, Marc Fischer (local stuff), and sometimes Milbank; lots of info about local events; occasionally good Sunday magazine features…..and, of course, COMICS.
I think it also should be pointed out that the Post, even as it currently exists, is not ENTIRELY a propaganda mouthpiece. There are still a few hard working reporters who break important stories….some have been quoted here, for instance.
That said……I f******g HATE Fred Hiatt, Krauthammer, Will, Novak, and the entire rest of that ghoulish tribe. Many’s the morning poor mr oddmommy has awoken to one of my blood-boiling rants about their latest fetid drivel.
(There. Now THAT’s fair and balanced. :))
What kind of pressure is being brought to bear on Lebanon to attack a Palestinian refugee camp, and by whom?
The White House said it supports Lebanese Prime Minister Fuad Saniora’s efforts to deal with fighting, and the State Department defended the Lebanese army, saying it was working in a “legitimate manner” against “provocations by violent extremists” operating in the camp.
zAmboni @ 51
No. This is strictly reserved for leading public intellectuals
like Ann “A Wasted Legal Mind is a Terrible Thing to Watch” Althouse or
Glenn “My Parents Had the Same Last Name” Reynolds.
Yes… and we’re (Bush) working in a “legitimate manner” in Iraq.
Meanwhile, a nutshell assessment of the current situation:
On topic, from today’s 11 am chat with Howell:
loo hoo
I’m think of scheduling the orientation Saturday at 11. Can you drop me an email so that I can confirm that it’s on? jay@ackroyd.org
Gotta run. See you later, everyone! GREAT to see you back, CHS!
jayackroyd @ 73
Right, Deb. And corporate financial statments are audited by CFO’s.
You silly, silly woman.
Biodun @ 59
Did you notice the condescending tone he expressed towards Congress? “Ought to Get the Job Done of passing Legislation”. Wow - Bush is showing his contempt of the CO-EQUAL branch of Government. I bet he does not even understand that oversight of the Executive branch is a primary responsibility of congress.
I just started “The One Percent Doctrine”
Suskind named the book out of the Cheney dictum that any possibility that has a one percent chance of being true must be treated as an absolute certainty.
Pretty good so far.
Hey! No Confidence is in da House!
Schiff introduces Gonzales no-confidence resolution
Woo! No Confidence in Gonzales. I wonder if I can get my rep to add to the bill ‘ No Confidence for entire Bush Administration ‘
allan-in-upstate
What really go me in that one was the reader asked about outright lies–as in today’s McConnell piece–and she responded by talking about mistakes.
I’m sorry I missed this live chat. I wasn’t planning on sending her a note, because I’d just sent her one last Thursday on the Comey coverage.
But this exchange just goes too far.
Cheney on the pleasures of international travel and hard work:
Re: James Comey’s weekend commencement address- Wm. Mitchell College of Law put this up a while ago (includes brief remarks synopsis):
Comey Addresses WM Graduates
Christy Hardin Smith @ 56
Yes, pathetic only begins to cover it. Moving on to perfidious comes to mind as a start…
But my point is that I don’t think a lot of people know about these revisions. Obviously there’s some general knowledge about the Patriot Act changing things.
And I use as an example the Frontline domestic spying documentary, that played on the night of Comey’s testimony. Maybe somebody else can remember it more specifically, but my sense is that it shows Frank Church and the post-Watergate creation of FISA, and then moves to 9/11 and the legitimate international espionage challenges, but then jumps to 03 and 04 the discovery of warrantless wiretapping. I’m almost positive there was no discussion of what Greenwald is talking about today, how in FISA was revised in October 01. Now, Hedrick Smith and Frontline were making a documentary and they left it out, so I have a clear sense that it’s not general knowledge.
McConnell is completely disingenuous–I’m not trying in any way to say that he isn’t. But I think that Greenwald bringing this up in his response, and getting this item out there as the Comey testimony and Gonzo’s teetering collapse shine the light on this crucial issue (where Greenwald has been leading the way, starting with a great shout out the day before Comey’s stirring narrative), is pretty important stuff.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 69
It’s simultaneous with Israel’s Gaza bombing, a lot like the events of last summer.
Saniora is our creature. I’m sure he’s blubbering about all this, though.
The Israeli government is prodding the U.S. government to the max, to attack Iran.
brendan @ 85
What you say is precisely right.
Great post, Christy! And welcome back! I’ve missed your insights and incisive truth-telling.
A bit of historical perspective occurs to me.
Remember the days immediately after 9/11? We were giving BushCo in general, and Condi Rice in particular, a ton of grief for failing to “connect the dots.” Remember that?
Unfortunately, BushCo decided that the answer to that criticism was to collect more dots. And Rove & Cheney decided to use their improved authorizations as cover for collecting certain kinds of dots that interested them.
Bob in HI
Christy, good for you and Glenn Greenwald. We need to keep focusing attention on both of these issues–Bush’s illegal easedropping (and lying about it) and the WaPo’s
liesethical shortcomings.Oklahoma kiddo @ 86
From AP:
oddmommy @ 68
Only Hiatt and his Neocon pals could make the Moonie Times look like a respectable newspaper compared to the Wapoo.
Lil Debbie just doesn’t seem to mind fact-challenged pieces o’crap ending up in her paper.
And they just can’t understand why their subscriptions are falling. Totally clueless.
allan_in_upstate @ 76
Allan, you’re too funny. No fair making me spit coffee! ;)
Right, so that you can scribble your veto crayon over any effort to fix health care, expand stem cell research, stop corporate looting, reform the tax laws, and any other piece of legislation designed to help real Americans….right Mr. Prez? And then get your goons in the Senate to make it stick.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 86
And here we have the absolute height of hypocrisy. Should they not stop fouling their own nest first?
http://www.commondreams.org/news2007/0521-01.htm
Oklahoma kiddo @ 86
It’s amusing sometimes to read the portfolios some of these Israelis hold. It reminds me of how Vito Corleon ran an “olive oil business”. Much like that “minister of tourism” Hamas killed last year, here’s their “infrastructure minister” talking:
“I don’t distinguish between those who carry out the (rocket) attacks and those who give the orders. I say we have to put them all in the crosshairs,” said Benjamin Ben-Eliezer, the national infrastructure minister, on Israel Radio.”
Complete goons.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/isra.....85,00.html
State Dept. spinster Sean McCormack said without a hint of irony that the Palestinians are bad actors because they use violence to pursue their agenda.
This guy should fill in for Letterman.
-GSD
A no-confidence vote on Abu should be only the first step. I received e-mails today from two organizations that are gathering signatures on petitions to IMPEACH Gonzo.
Kevster, Bluetoe:
Don’t waste your time at this juncture complaining to the Post. Follow the helpful leads of others hear and communicate with your elected representatives. They’re driving the train. The Post, even with a series of admirably indignant editorials about Gonzalez/Comey last week, is still in the caboose.
kirk murphy @ 52
I think you’re on to why this op ed is out there. There were two very strong editorials by Hiatt last week on Comey’s testimony, so I’m sure the WH asked for an opportunity to respond — and this is what they got: a dishonest diversion with no acknowledgement of Comey’s testimony, let alone any discussion of the fact that there was a program that the AG, DAG, and FBI director were willing to resign over before the current(later?) version. So instead of responding to the concerns about what they were doing before, and what they’re doing now, this op ed is designed to divert us into thinking about the statute instead, as though that’s the problem.
At the moment both sides seem to like the Gonzo wars.
Bush likes em cause it keeps the focus off HIM- the REAL criminal- and the dems like it cause it’s like shootin fish in a barrel and the pleasure goes on and on like Lil Abner’s Endless Hot Dog–while yer eatin at one end- they’re still makin it at the other.
Great fun to be had by all.