
(Sad teddy photo via R_Bish.)
Hilzoy from Obsidian Wings sent me an e-mail that I wanted to share with everyone. It is a poignant story, but one that all too sadly happens pretty much every day in communities everywhere. One of the more difficult aspects of this, though, is that it is apparently happening with even more frequency in Native American communities — who have very little in the way of resources oftentimes to cope with this. But I'm getting ahead of myself, and will let Hilzoy's e-mail speak for itself for a moment:
I thought you might be interested in a shelter I heard about yesterday on NPR. It was in a story about the vastly higher rates of sexual abuse of Native American women. From the NPR transcript:
"Ms. JACKIE BROWN OTTER(ph) (Resident, Standing Rock Indian Reservation): I’m in McLaughlin, South Dakota. I live on the Standing Rock Indian Reservation.
SULLIVAN: Jackie Brown Otter lives about 30 miles from the nearest shopping center. The reservation covers 2.3 million acres. There are seven tribal patrol officers. Otter’s little sister was raped, kidnapped from her home and murdered six years ago.
Ms. OTTER: Chingkawa Wastewi(ph). That’s her Indian name. And that translates in English to Pretty Bird Woman. She smiled and she was well liked and always laughing.
SULLIVAN: It took almost a day for tribal police to arrive when Pretty Bird went missing. Her house was torn apart. A window was broken and bloody bedding was stuffed into the trash bin. It took several more days for the FBI to arrive. Her body was found later, beaten to death along a rural road. Otter opened a shelter for women at Standing Rock in her sister’s honor. But the group will run out of funding this month and will probably have to close. And still, the attacks keep coming.
Ms. OTTER: We’re so overwhelmed that we can’t see beyond the perimeters of it. It’s just beyond words for me."
It's the only battered women's shelter on the Standing Rock Sioux reservation, which is huge and desperately poor. Even if they didn't provide shelter at all, the fact that they give people rides to the very distant courthouses etc. would be worth its weight in gold. I used to work at a shelter…, and we drew from the rather large nearby Native population; people had to come from way far away in order to get help, and we always used to wish that there were shelters on the reservations; the need was desperate.
As NPR says, it might close for lack of funds. I emailed the Director, and she says that small donations won't be pointless absent some large new funding source; they can, for instance, keep the hotline up, and so on. They have one paid worker and two volunteers, so, in some ways unfortunately, they don't use a lot of money. I don't know them, so for all I know they could be Donald Trump trolling for money in disguise, but NPR and Amnesty publicized them, and the South Dakota Coalition Against Domestic Violence and Sexual Assault just gave their founder an award for advocacy, (http://www.southdakotacoalition.org/) so they seem legit to me.
Anyways, this is just to say: they seem like a group that should not be allowed to sink below the waves without help…
If you are interested in helping this shelter, here is their address: Pretty Bird Woman House, P.O.596, McLaughlin South Dakota 57642. Every little bit helps — even being able to help sustain the phone hotline where people can ask for help or talk to someone who can just understand and offer a shoulder to cry on…it can make a huge difference for someone who has been cut off from the world around her (or him, because this sort of abuse happens across gender lines). I'm so glad that Hilzoy sent this to me, because she is absolutely right that having this shelter disappear due to lack of anyone caring would simply be too horrible to contemplate.
Beyond this one shelter, though, there are others like it all across the nation, and they are pretty much always desperately in need of funding help or donations of clothes or food or toys or anything else that you could ever think of that a woman or mother with children might need, having fled from an abusive partner with only the clothes on their backs.
This is the time of year that a lot of folks do some spring cleaning, and it is a perfect time to put a pile of clothes to the side to donate to your local women's shelter or homeless shelter. I try to do that every year — and I mix the clothes up between every day clothes and business clothes, because often these women will be interviewing for jobs to enable them to get back on their own feet, and they need interview clothes desperately when they do. They also need toys for kids who come with their mommas (stuffed animals are especially appreciated), cosmetics and toiletries, pretty much anything that you may use in your everyday life.
I have had folks who are very dear to me have to flee to shelters at various points in their lives, and so I try to do what I can when I can to help out our local shelter. Hoping, I suppose, that what I do can help someone else back on their feet as the people that I know found theirs over the years.
I have worked on a lot of domestic violence cases in my legal career, and there is such a similar pattern in so many of them. It is a very, very difficult cycle to break, all too often because both parties in the relationship have grown up in a highly abusive home and think that this sort of violence in the home is the way things are. There are issues of very low self-esteem, outright fear for the life of the person being abused or for the children's lives (a common threat is "If you leave me, I'll kill the kids."), or any number of other things that are intertwined in all of this. Without a lot of counseling and care and a safe place to go, the cycle does not get broken — and even with these, it is sometimes not enough when someone's spirit has been altogether broken.
I thought we could talk a bit this morning about what we can all do to help. Not just with local shelters, but in the broader context of violence and sexual abuse and all those other nasty things that go with it that rarely get discussed in polite company. Because these issues do happen — right under our noses sometimes in our own neighborhoods — and it is in that moment where we reach out and say "how can I help?" that we can sometimes save a spirit or even a life. And I choose to think that we can make a difference with just a little bit of hope and a whole lot of care. Pull up a chair…
Related posts:





Spotlight







Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

Mulch!
While “Central Americans” service Tobias, the Republican Ueberclass is thriving:
GM Chairman Earns $9.57 Million in 2006
Long-Serving AT& T Chief To Leave With Huge Payout
Investigation of Seattle Pension Fund Manager Widens
Good morning.
Good morning, Christy!
Native American women, whether they live on the rez or not, are far more subject to attack than are say… white women. This I suspect is the case for all females of color.
Morning all — coffee is hot here, and The Peanut and I are watching Cinderella this morning. How is everyone today?
Good, but my dishwasher isn’t working right. Might have to replace the water line today. How are ‘tings?
Donation to this shelter:
I’m in.
Ugh, Twisted, that doesn’t sound fun. Mr. ReddHedd got up and did dishes this morning for me. We were so tired last night that we crashed early and left dishes in the sink. He let me sleep in and cleaned up the kitchen with The Peanut. Am I lucky or what?
I’m ok. Just saw the guys off with another load to our new home. My weekend will be spent with the grandchildren helping me pack more boxes. Any volunteers? *g*
Lindy at 10 — I hope the move goes smoothly for you all. Have been thinking about you.
My friend of mine just got rid of his pickup truck and bought a small car. He claimed every weekend his friends had him picking up washing machines and moving couches.
Resource for sexual violence, which people close to me have used and is great:
Rape And Incest National Network.
They have list of places for referrals all over the country and lots of good resources.
And don’t think such things could never happen in your town. It’s everywhere.
Anonymous Liberal caught a dilly of an e-mail from Monica Goodling in the Friday docudump. Hoooooo Boy!
Christy Hardin Smith @ 14
That would be a Bozo NoNo, wouldn’t it?
The Fifth might keep her out of prison, but shouldn’t she be disbarred?
There once was a man who died in the gas chamber for abusing women. As far as I know the victims did not die. His name was Caryl Chessman.
Good morning from L.A.
What an excellent post to start the day, CHS. A topic very close to my heart- have donated to Women’s Care Cottage in N. Hollywood for many years. Spring cleaning is an easy & useful time to put clothing discards in the hands of those who have very few extra clothes. Many women leave batterers in a hurry w/not much but what they can carry out. Canned food & donations always appreciated, or just stopping by to lend a hand w/all the kids so moms can catch a break. Great local organization:
Women’s Care Cottage
Donated the results of spring cleaning the closets last weekend. Even though I’m not associated, the local church accepted the offering with open arms. A favoured item (up here in Canada) are 1-2 year old winter boots.
~~~
Also, a great cup of Joe can be found here;
http://www.salon.com/opinion/c…..candidacy/
Off to Flagstaff in a few to do shopping or I would love to comment on the issue posted above.
When you have, in many cases these islands of poverty, 50% unemployment, family stresses, alcohol and drug use can be very high. We get most of the folks serving time here due to drinking which is illegal here on the Hopi Reservation. Binge drinking is common.
The tribe does have a domesrtic violence prevention program but funds are limited and thereis not shelter for women or children. Funds are important but recognizing that you have a problem and must address it is the first thing. There are many programs like the one at Standing Rock that could use help be it in your local area or on a reservation. Be involved because the issue affects us all.
Christy @ 6.26 -
Oh, that’s a great good fun catch! Love the use of the term “friendlies”……..DING!
————————————
Has anyone seen Pfiff around lately?
Christy @11, we’re going to be fine…if I can wait out the rest of this month. The hardest thing is leaving my job. The people I work with are heroes to me. Lois Bujold said something through one of her characters in The Curse of Chalion that I think describes their strivings pretty well:
Good morning Christy. Thanks for all you do. Regarding domestic violence, do you have any sense of what percentage of these instances have a substance abuse component? I don’t want to bring back prohibition but it seems to me we are only addressing that issue half heartedly.
Dennis Cooper writes from Paris on his Blog (Misanthroupe is one of his many posters):
Part of the issue with enforcing the law with respect to the these serious crimes against women is that by law the FBI is required to investigate such offences and the local law enforcement people are helpless until the FBI manages to get to it. If I am not mistaken there is pending legislation to get this changed working its way through Congress. Sorry, I read something just a few days ago about this story and it discussed the problems with law enforcement as being a major contributor to the problem. Can’t recall the link at the moment but I will look further.
we can’t do enough for native peoples. their poverty is third worldish on many reservations, and i feel certain they’re continuing to get ripped off — refer to leasing fees trust fund run by BIA on their behalf.
How do those who say Senator Clinton “won” the debate the other night justify that position?
During last night’s debate, Hillary Clinton once again tried to fudge her position on Iraq, saying of the president: “He threatens to veto the legislation we have passed, which has been something that all of us have been advocating for a number of years.”
This was a deliberate attempt to mislead voters, and I said so on Larry King during our post-debate analysis.
From Arianna yesterday.
Good Morning Christy and Firedogs,
this is a subject that all but guarantees your Letter to the Editor will get published – of the 7 I’ve had published, 5 of them were about funding (lack thereof) for local domestic violence shelters
—
and sometimes within our own families . . .my beloved sister was on life support before we figured out what was happening to her . . .it was over 30 years ago and the abuser didn’t fit the profile we all had
she recovered and continues to work on behalf of families in need, but it woke us all up to just how widespread the violence is
Christy,
The kos article has put up a direct online donation Chipin for the Pretty Bird Woman House shelter.
Yo ‘Lakers. ReddHedd, that’s such a sad tale; Hilzoy is doing good work. Not to trivialize it by comparison, but I’ve heard many say that the relationship between our country and the Bushies is very similar to someone with an abusive spouse. Despite the pain, the injured spouse comes back and back because “They’ll change, I know they still love me…” but the abuse keeps coming and coming, and worsening. Fortunately, our sleeping giant, America, is slowly awakening and is on the verge of declaring its total “Independence Day,” [ http://tinyurl.com/38vo55 ] as Martina’s C&W song puts it so well… :)
It’s been a marvelously hectic week what with visiting with our first grandbaby (from our MA daughter), but yet it’s been the usual oodles of fun following (and rooting for!) the further crumbling of the House of Bushies. I’ve cleared next Thu to watch Comey’s testimony before Waxman’s House Judiciary Committee.
But as for today, I could use some energy cleaning the house for incoming CA daughter, who is way more of a neat-freak than I yam. So Pls pass that nice hot Java, CHS — aahhh…:)
OT: It was such a pleasure to meet another FirePup — at a rally Thu evening to bring progressive talk radio back to Boston MA. My black T-shirt with its huge white IMPEACH BUSH front and back assured that there was no need for a “best shirt” contest.
OOT: Where are other FirePups? – check out this earlier post to see (and join?) an unofficial map. At this writing, there’s 426 pins! :)
One of the organizations I try to support, when I can, is Mujeres Unidas, down in McAllen, TX.
This one is really important, because, like Pretty Bird Woman shelter, a lot of the people dealing with domestic violence are desperately poor and sometimes very isolated. The unemployment rate is incredible in the Valley (some towns, it’s as high as 22% or more), what jobs there are pay scandalously low wages, and so many women are trapped in a cycle of poverty and abuse. Add to that a culture of “machismo,” that has an expression in the local culture, “Chingasos ingreien,” that actually encourages domestic violence. That phrase, not very polite, translates to, “they take the beating (like medicine).” The men think that women need an occasional beating, to remind them of “who’s the man.” Imagine how chilling it is to hear a man casually refer to this when talking about the dynamics of marital harmony.
Mujeres Unidas was also there for me, when I needed them most.
But, ultimately, I wish our concerns about “women’s issues” in general got more respect, and more action. We hear all the time that our concerns aren’t as important as Iraq, or winning the House or, hell fill in the blank. Just about everything else is more important. Just look at the uproar over the stalked tech blogger, and some of the remarks from some of our allies in the progressive movement. We keep getting the pat on the head, even here, and told we’ll be taken care of…eventually, now be a good girl and do what we tell you.
Or that’s how it feels sometimes.
I do not believe that casinos are the answer to ‘native problems’.
Ex-Justice Dept. Lawyer Under Scrutiny in Probe
Ties With Abramoff Associate in Question
By Susan Schmidt
Washington Post Staff Writer
Saturday, April 28, 2007; Page A06
http://www.washingtonpost.com/…..id=topnews
I will tell you all this. I am a counselor working primarily in the field of domestic violence and sexual assault trauma. I work with both men and women. The most damaging aspect of abuse is the invalidating environment. I give this speech over and over again and I do it because understanding the process of invalidation and the consequences to our society is one of the most important venues to peace in our time. In other words, our society must get to the place where we accept that violence and trauma are damaging. Our denial is pervasive and actually doubles the consequences to those affected.
Let me explain. An invalidating environment is one in which a person’s personal experiences are not validated by the surrounding environment. Chronic invalidation has grave consequences for society. The way I make this case is to state: What would happen if you could abuse children with absolutely no consequences??? The consequences are part of the lesson. This creates a double bind for those affected. My job is to help them validate the consequences without invalidating their entire existence. If they heal it invalidates the consequences of abuse. Many do heal but many battle with this devil as they try to work their way out of the pervasive consequences of an invalidating response to trauma and to their lives and experiences.
What kind of environments are invalidating??? Drug addicted families, child sexual abuse, domestic violence, sexual assault, all racism, and sexism, mental health issues, etc. The problem with invalidation of a child is that it causes them to have a skewed or unreal view of reality and their interaction with it. This leads to:
(per Marsha Linehan)
1) emotional dysregulation-mood swings. No ability to regulate emotions since they are not validated.
2) interpersonal dysregulaton-this is what happens when you are unable to validate emotions that are stuffed and then explode.
3) cognitive dysregulation- black and white thinking that provides the answers instead of synthesis of reality.’
4) impulse dysregulation- got to regulate emotions somehow, find relief, using drugs, alcohol, shopping, sex, food, etc..
5) identity dysregulation-that is no realistic valid concept of self, no inner world, just the need to get identity through interaction with others…no solid sense of self.
These symptoms have invaded society and may also explain terrorism. The most serious cases of invalidation use self harm…to see, feel and make their pain real. Men tend to beat their wives to make their pain real and sort of give it away…to control the pain of intimacy they control the partner. See it on the face of someone else.
Understanding invalidation is necessary for peace. We must make the consequences of violence REAl in word and deed. We must validate its consequences by providing real help and helping those affected find themselves and validate their lives through action that is effective instead of leading damaged lives.
Validate the affects of violence!!!! Then we will all heal. Think of societies that have been horribly invalidated and the resulting outcomes, african american communities, american indian communities, Israel, Palestine. When the violence and it’s affects are invalidating it’s as if God (mother nature, the universe) doubles the consequences…which makes good sense. War is not the answer because it only produces more trauma and more invalidation.
Speaking of beautiful women that make a difference …
“And Natalie Portman fans won’t want to miss the actress, who’ll be on ABC discussing her upcoming documentary about the role micro-financing plays for women in third-world countries.” (as seen at the politico).
… and some that don’t have time to testify but will shameless shill the Sunday storyline;
“Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice will defend the administration on CBS and on ABC’s “This Week.”
My niece works for the Haida people in British Columbia. She has 5 kids herself, and is raising 3 who have been orphaned or abandoned. One of the things she struggles with is the after effects of the people who had been forced away from their own homes to Indian schools. They were more like reformatories.
The last Indian school in US was closed in 1981. The ugly underbelly of our intolerance of anyone who isn’t anglo saxon. Same sentiments being expressed against Iraqis or Latinos today.
Violence and abuse has been systemic in our country, but it doesn’t fit with our view of America the best, number one, without blame, ever. Our denial of this dark side of American life needs to have light shed on it and I thank you Christy for doing that this morning.
Got to run, time for choir.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 31
I don’t care much for them myself but if a tribe is limited in its resource base then what options are there especially when most administrations fall well short in their trust responsibilities? States aren’t much willing to help. Not every tribe has natural resources it can sell. Many tribes like the Navajo are still dealing with the effects of past uranium mining. Economic development is difficult at times due to geographical isolation.
carmen @ 35
Ahh, the boarding shcool effect. Very true. Kids were gone 9-10 months a years and really were not parented as teenagers especially and that generation has problems at times in parenting.
Fallenmonk at 24 — There has been pending legislation on something like that for years, unfortunately. We never seem to get the whole law enforcement on reservations mess sorted and, in the meantime, things like this happen with tragic consequences. It’s frustrating to watch from the outside — but imagine how much worse it is when one of your family members is dealing with it. What a mess.
The “Take Back the Blog” blogswarm is today. Click my name for more details. I also mention there why I won’t be around for much of today–so I’d really, really appreciate it if some good citizens would take it upon themselves to help spread the word.
Gotta run.
This is a tough one for me. My neighbors called my mother on September 18th 2005 to ask her if she would take me in if they helped evacuate me and my little one. She agreed. They called me and in under two hours, my girl and I, and bags of our clothes and a few toys and a box of books were in my mother’s extra bedroom. I had nowhere near the nightmare, I think, that others have had, but my neighbors were rightly horrified that my ex had the night before threatened me (yelling about how I might just happen to die from a gunshot, after he’d gone on a rampage in our house, tearing things down, breaking things). By that time, I was always stunned. I would think maybe I wasn’t remembering right, that I was building it up in my head.
They asked me to get a civil protection order. My lawyer advised me that since I minimize everything, that I’d cost myself money if I used him, and that I would not describe the problem vividly enough, that I should hold off for right then as there were no other threats. Just hold off. He was right in my case, I think. The horrible thing is, I wanted so, so much not to be called or viewed as “hysterical,” that I really did downplay everything. And couldn’t stop downplaying it. I don’t know, though. Do civil protection orders do any good anyway? Anyway, until that night, he’d only screamed at and insulted me for years. That was the first physical threat.
Thank God for my neighbors. Thank Goddess for them. Thank anything that has anything to do with people who will stick out their necks when you finally have nothing left inside yourself. I wish I had something more intelligent to say.
funds for shelters and other support for those fleeing domestic violence have been cut across the board and all too often those monies find their way in to so called faith based groups !
over a year ago I read of our county’s only family shelter had had it’s funding slashed by 60% and 48 women and children were on a ‘waiting list’
. . .so I did a little googling and found the congresscritter boasting on his web site about $410,000 going to faith based initiatives in the district – half of it to so called abstinence only scams – the local shelter only needed 68K to keep it going for a year
so I called the reporter with the numbers, she verified it, called congresscritter’s staff to let them know she would be reporting on same -
miraculously, she got a call from the idiot himself to let her know it was a just a paperwork bugaboo and the shelter got it’s money
it may not work out so well everytime, but I urge any of you being represented by a Loyal Bushie to follow the money and keep the locals informed
I want to say that the one thing I am trying harder than anything else to do raising my daughter, is to respect her feelings, know them, and to teach her to do the same. That isn’t to say that I’m not a pretty firm and bossy mother, but when my girl is mad or angry, that’s how she feels. If some kid bothers her and she doesn’t want to play with him, guess what, I support her in all of that. I think believing that being angry or disapproving of what makes you uncomfortable makes you a “bad girl” got me into that situation, and it’s not going to happen to my daughter.
carmen @ 35
I was pretty naive about things like this, until I moved to Rapid City, SD. The local paper ran a column from Tim Giago about his experiences with the boarding schools, and I couldn’t believe we’d heaped that indignity upon them too, after everything else.
It’s a wonder my kid turned out normal. I moved to RC just after learning I was pregnant with him, and spent a lot of it weeping over what I was seeing and reading about Native Americans.
God, my writing normally sucks, but on this subject, worse than ever. What I meant to write is:
I think that the BELIEF that being angry or bearing feelings of disapproval makes you a “bad girl,” a harpy, a shrew, is what got me into that situation, and it’s not going to happen to my daughter.
JoyB at 42 — Hugs to you, and it sounds like you are doing a wonderful job with your daughter. You’ve already done the best thing that you possibly could do — make a conscious choice for safety for you and your kids. I had a friend whose mom did the same thing for her and her brother — best thing possible for them.
((((JoyB and Daughter))))
so glad you are both out and safe
the sister (and her daughters) I described upthread don’t take any guff from anybody, and I mean anybody!
thrive on with your bad selves!
Hugs right back at you CHS and CBL. We ARE thriving on with our bad selves! It is sooooo good nowadays.
Christy: thanks.
Brownandserve: “Regardign domestic violence, do you have any sense of what percentage of these instances have a substance abuse component?”
I don’t know the relevant figures. However, while I’m sure there are cases in which the two are connected, when I was working in shelters domestic violence seemed to me to involve very different issues (and when substance abuse was involved, it was sometimes more of an excuse for violence than a cause of it.)
It seemed to me, at the time, that abusers fell into two broad classes. The smaller group was composed of people who somehow hadn’t learned that violence isn’t a part of normal human relationships. The much larger group, however, was different, and its members tended to follow a certain pattern.
They tended to fall for people very hard and very fast. They had, in general, a lack of measure in their response to things. They became hugely dependent on the (mostly) women they abused. They had big problems with trust, and the combination of that and their genuine and massive vulnerability to the women they were involved with meant that they often felt they needed to exercise control over them by other means, including not just violence but (for instance) the elimination of other (”competing”) sources of the women’s strength and self-esteem (relationships with family, friendships, jobs, etc.) They often felt they needed to know where the women were at all times, and were irrationally jealous.
(In one case, a woman I knew could not go anywhere without her husband thinking she had been having sex with someone. E.g., when she went grocery shopping and spent 20 minutes in the supermarket, he accused her of having sex with one of the guys who put the cereal on the shelves. For the record, this was a very shy woman; on a list of “women I’ve known who might possibly have sex with random strangers”, she’d be close to last.)
This is not about substance abuse. Sometimes substance abuse is an enabling factor, but I think, as I said above, it’s as much an excuse as a cause.
As to casinos. Here in Oklahoma, I would advocate forcing the oil companies to pay long over due royalties to the different tribes we have here. With the proviso that a substantial portion of these monies be directed to the construction of modern schools, clinics and hospitals filled by extremely qualified staff. My belief is that education and good health is the key to equality and freedom. Not running gamboling houses. However, I do realize many tribes do not have an oil history. However many Natives all over America had their land appropriated by the U.S. government and should be reimbursed for that loss. With the reimbursements being directed in the same ways as mentioned above.
U.S. military says colonel accused of aiding enemy in Iraq is 51-year-old from Virginia
BAGHDAD The military says a U-S officer accused of aiding the enemy in Iraq is a 51-year-old from Virginia.
Army Lieutenant Colonel William Steele is accused of providing an unmonitored cell phone to detainees while he commanded an M-P detachment at the Baghdad jail that held Saddam Hussein.
http://www.wric.com/global/story.asp?s=6436353
The charges were announced yesterday but the military did not release the personal details until today.
Steele faces nine charges in all, including fraternizing with a prisoner’s daughter, storing and marking classified material, maintaining an inappropriate relationship with an interpreter and possessing pornographic videos.
Steele was detained last month and is being held in Kuwait pending an Article 32 hearing, the military equivalent of a grand jury hearing.
So rarely do we hear the truth, who knows if this is?
And JoyB: my heart goes out to you. It takes guts to leave.
Also, why isn’t he being detained in the US???
Christy thank you for shining your light! Very intense, violent, criminal, and often ignored by the media. Will share it with others and hopefully folks will send $ and prayers. Here is the link to that story.
http://www.npr.org/templates/s…..Id=9852741
Reminded me of another story NPR did recently on a similar rape situation in Mexico.
http://www.npr.org/templates/s…..Id=5683793
There is often so much focus on how women are abused in Muslim countries, while rape and abuse in this country is out of control!
A (very) incomplete list of Republicans with “issues” when it comes to women:
Rush Limbaugh , caught returning from a “guys weekend” in the Dominican Republic with a suitcase full of V*a*a*a. Also on board his private jet was “24′ producer Joel Surnow.
Don Sherwood , former Republican congressman, tried to strangle his mistress.
Bernard Kerik cheated on his mistress in an apartment intended for WTC site workers.
Rep. Randy Kuhl (NY-R) uses a shotgun instead of words to settle family discussions.
It’s very easy to play this game.
Simply type the name of your favorite Republican, followed by “mistress”, into Google and starting surfing.
Thanks Hilzoy @ 48. Appreciate the insights.
Christy Hardin Smith @
9
He sounds like a keeper. There’s something about a man voluntarily doing housework that makes me week in the knees.
Lindy @
10
I’d love to, really…but I have a thing with a guy at the place…
Christy at 35
I finally remembered where I had seen this.
Devilstower at Kos did a piece yesterday and as a result one of the Kossacks set up a page where you can donate to Pretty Bird Woman House
Last I checked there had been over $3000 raised.
In my experience w/battered women & children, the primary issue always boils down to control- from put-downs & continual criticism to the ultimate control of beatings, forced sex, threats against the kids or relatives, threats of killing or maiming. The control issue runs so deep for many of these guys, the only recourse is to get out & stay out.
Unfortunately, many times women feel so trapped w/nowhere to go.
Women’s Care Cottage puts up flyers all over the L.A. area. Many who call or just show up say they had no relatives here & no place to go- some just out on the streets- when they saw the flyer or were told about one…
Women’s Care Cottage
Several years ago MrsCO and I took a road trip along with two friends. We drove from Denver up to Rapid City, visited Mt. Rushmore, the Badlands, and then through the Pine Ridge reservation. MrsCO studied native American history & politics, and wanted to visit some of the historical sites there.
I was shocked at the third world poverty there. At one point we got lost and stopped near a house (shack?) to ask a man for directions. He obliged, and then asked us for money. We gave him a few bucks. Later, we exited the south side of the reservation, on the South Dakota/Nebraska border. The first town we passed through in NE was a place called White Clay. It was basically a couple of run-down buildings, and a liquor store. All down the street there were people (all native Americans) in various states of intoxication, including passed out. As we drove slowly along the street, people approached the car, holding out their hands for money. The juxtaposition of four white, middle class, professional thirty somethings on a Labour-Day jaunt in an expensive SUV, and these poor, benighted, forgotten souls was jarring, to say the least.
I’m English. I didn’t know that conditions like this existed in the US. You certainly keep it well-hidden from outside eyes. I realised that day that our travelling companions (one from CO, the other from NJ)didn’t know either.
The third world, five hours drive from Denver.
Paging Mr. Gore.
Interior to propose expanding offshore drilling
Lease plan targets areas in Gulf of Mexico, off Alaska and Virginia
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/18358714/
A Native American acquaintance of mine was married with two children years ago to a middle eastern man who brutally attacked her with a machete nearly killing her because of his religious issues. Later in her life, she married another guy who was extremely well off and a businessman, and he also became violent. When she left him, he stalked her. She moved out of that state and was given a beautiful, trained Briard or Bouvier des Flandres protection dog. Last year, she came home, and the dog had been shot outside her home within the yard fence by the Ex who had tracked her down. Apparently, no help from the “law” has ever been forthcoming.
Neither of the two men are in jail. Horrifying!!!!
OT CNN – Suicide bomb in N. Pakistan kills at least 7 and injures Pakistan’s Interior Minister.
I’ve known about and supported the work of these people for years.
o/t
hey hippies !
did you know today is the kickoff for
Impeachment Summer
that’s right, Impeachment Summer, just click on my name to get info for your area and other things you can do
today our family is flying giant Impeach! kites
but I ordered a giant (72 inch) balloon to fly over the homestead
I was too young for Freedom Summer, but I’m not missing this one – howzabout you?!?!?
Oklahoma kiddo @
32
You forgot the “Steno Sue” disclaimer.
I wish the comments hadn’t wandered so far off point here. What I see is a local situation that is desperate and so desperately disconnected from the internet and fundraising that its not easy to help them *even if* the will were there. If someone would/could set up a web site with a donation button for this organization and help the organization handle the money that would do more than all the random comments of sympathy.
aimai
In a nutshell what keeps people in abusive relationships is that they are attached to the abuser.
Thus, even though they are abused, there are also times when the abuser is kind, repentant, and easier to live with.
It is the positives that keep them coming back to the abuser.
In animal research they have found that a variable schedule of rewards is the strongest reinforcer. So if an animal never knows when the good things might arrive (food, for example), it will work very hard, nearly all the time – in hopes of a reward.
Well, the good times are the “reward” for the abused person.
Also, the abused person is told over and over that the abuse is their fault (not the abuser’s). Coupled with the abused person’s desire for the “good side” of the abuser is this sense that they somehow could control the abuse, could prevent it, because they believe (as they’ve been told) that they are responsible for incidents of abuse.
Maybe you get the picture now. This is a very difficult cycle to break, because it has become encoded as part of someone’s brain. They are attached. They want the “good side” of the abuser. And they believe that anything bad that happens has been caused by them.
It takes a long time to change a mind. And to break that kind of malignant attachment.
Oklahoma kiddo @
16
Wan’t he the last before the initial ban went into affect? Played by Alan Alda in a movie IIRC.
JoyB @ 42
I’m a fellow survivor, or whatever the term is now. I’m so glad you’re okay now.
You’re right–we have to let our children understand their feelings, and own them. That doesn’t mean they can do anything they want with them, but that they know they’re there, and need to work through them. The reason I found myself in a domestic violence situation is because I wasn’t allowed to feel at home. My feelings were constantly invalidated–so you didn’t get that toy, suck it up. So someone doesn’t like you, suck it up. Don’t you dare cry. I was literally told not to cry, not to be angry, not to be jealous (and especially stop making eyes at those boys–I can’t remember a time when I wasn’t interested in boys as boys that way).
Anyway, it became second nature to sublimate my feelings, rather than dealing with them. And so I was an easy target for a man looking for someone to control and intimidate. The ultimate irony is that my mother pushed me not to cry or show emotion, so that I wouldn’t be seen as vulnerable. I spent a lot of years enduring egomaniacal control feaks until I figured out why.
per Lindy’s comment above -
you may be surprised to find how easy it is to get your employer to support a local shelter
and if they’re real corporate, a lot of shelters have a back to work program (resume writing, clothes, interview skills, etc.)and companies ‘feel good’ about supporting same
kinda like turning down Little League sponsorship – few want to be that kind of grinch
hilzoy @48
Yes, dependency underlies the aggression of the abuser.
Lindy @
64
I have supported them too, but in my opinion they have been increasingly focused on their religious affililation to the detriment of their mission. They have been through a great deal of turnover, staff, management and board, and it has its roots in this problem. In recent years, it has not always been true that “no religious obligation” was imposed on women in distress. There have been ideologues in ascendancy, and that has turned off people, including former donors.
Oklahoma kiddo @
5
The recent report by Amnesty International shows that Native women experience the highest rates of sexual assault in the country (the link is here: amnesty pdf). Even more disturbing, over 80% of these assaults are committed by non-Indians. This is line with department of Justice reports showing Native people experience far higher rates iof violent assault overall and the 70% of those assualts are committed by non-Indians. For the record Oklahoma (which is my home state) has the 12th highest rape rate in the country.
JoyB @ 40
What’s more intelligent that someone who knew it was time to allow themselves to be saved. You did good for yourself and your little one.
The Clothesline project is worth bringing to your town!
http://www.clotheslineproject.org/
America has never dealt with the shame of the treatment of the Natives.
A truth and reconciliation commission for that and for slavery and Jim Crow are still needed in my opinion. For all of our sakes.
-GSD
dakine01 @ 69
“In 1954 or 1955, California repealed the Little Lingbergh Law and converted the death sentences of those who had been convicted under its statutes to terms of life in prison. Some of these inmates earned parole years later; Chessman, however, never had his sentence repealed. His sentence was upheld and then-Governor Edmund Brown refused to grant clemency. (Brown was beaten in the next election by Ronald Reagan, who supported the use of the death penalty.)”
“Brown’s stay of execution, along with Chessman’s last appeals, ran out in April 1960 and Brown subsequently declined to grant Chessman executive clemency. Exhausting a last-minute attempt to file a writ of habeas corpus with the California Supreme Court, Chessman finally went to the gas chamber on the morning of May 2, 1960.”
amen TheraP !
so many victims keep trying to apply ‘logical, linear’ thought processes to the illogical, non linear mindset of the Abuser
if I just do this or stop doing that it will stop
is so tragically common
dmg @
25
When the Oneida Nation opened their casino in upstate NY, they started funding education and services for the nation. They also mad a conscious decision that they would NOT serve alcohol in their casino. The head of the nation at that time (assume he is still there) said, “Given our peoples historic problems with alcohol, it would be the height of hypocrisy for us to push this substance.”
TheraP 68,
Yes, all of that is true, but there are many cases of perfectly functional people who find themselves and their children’s lives threatened if they attempt to leave. They want to leave and have no attachment at this point to the abuser at all – they just choose the chance to survive by staying rather than testing the threat in leaving.
DrDick @ 74
Yes… I know this. And thanks for pointing it out for us.
TheraP @ 68
I believe Christy hit the nail on the head, it is often a very vicious cycle something witnessed and learned, deep in the cells and psyche. I have also done a fair amount of volunteering in a few shelters.
Many of these womens lives and the lives of their children are threatened with death!
PeteCO @ 60, it’s hideous. Terry Gross did a segment a few years ago about doctors convicted of “white collar” crimes who were offered community service on a reservation instead of jail. Many took the community service option, then, after a matter of days/weeks, would request jail.
CNN headline:
Link.
Yes, it’s all about you Mr. President.
PeteCO @ 60
They exist. Take a four-hour drive south from San Antonio. We have something there called “colonias.” These are illegal subdivisions of “housing” that struggling people get suckered into (I won’t go into how they work–it’d take a while). Anyway, there are no building codes. Often, there is no running water. No electricity. No trash pick up. Sewer systems? Ha! If they have a ditch for disposal, they’re lucky.
I went to one home when I was distributing information about preventing cholera and dengue fever (Gee, wonder why I would need to do that…), and the house had no doors. No windows. The people were living in their house while they were building it. They had dirt floors. The woman who came to the door looked about 60, but she couldn’t be…because she was at least 7 months pregnant, with a baby on her hip. It was cold that day–so terribly cold, for the Valley, and they had no heat, no running water–
That wasn’t the only home like that. It was just the one that hit me the hardest.
I went to my car after leaving that colonia and wept. I couldn’t believe that the richest country in the world had people living like that. The stock market was going through the roof, and that pregnant woman had no doors on her house to keep her warm on a cold day.
You never see your country the same way after something like that.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 82
This maybe so. But I think many white women are more reluctant to admit that they are abused, especially women in who are in more stable economic situations.
OKkiddo: Casinos aren’t all that bad. I grew up here in coastal northern California, and it used to be that every year the indians would get their annual “Indian Money,” and buy a new car, get drunk, get in a fight and crash their cars. If they survived that, they would do the same thing the next year.
Then I left for many years to do my career and returned to retire here. The change in the indians was amazing. They started casinos, took the profits and sent their kids to professional schools (usually law schools), and the domestic violence went down and there were no longer the ritual drunken car crashes. They spun off businesses from the profits from the casinos, and things look much better for them now.
aimai @ 67
There is an online site which I referenced at comment 28. It was put up by kos poster nbier (Norman Bier), but I don’t know this person and recommend investigating further before sending any substantial contributions.
Maybe someone can call the shelter and see if this person is legitimately raising funds for them.
AZ Matt @
36
While I agree that casinos are problematic in many ways, the benefits for some tribes are undeniable. As AZ Matt points out, many (most) tribes lack any significant reousrces and virtually all reservations are plagued by economic underdevelopment with few opportunities. Unfortunately, the relative benefits of casinos for tribes is entirely dependent on location. They would be of little use for most of the tribes here in Montana (would even lose money on some reservations), as they are in the Dakotas. Further, they are probably not sustainable over the long term, given the rapid expansion of the gaming industry across the country and political opposition by non-Indians. Generally speaking, for the tribe who are more fortuitously located, they provide the best short term solution to underdevelopment and produce a vitally necessary capital flow which can be used to finance infrastructural improvements (water, sewage, electricity, housing, roads, etc.) and to invest in other economic endeavors which are more sustainable over the long term.
cbl @ 65
Thanks for that-the Denver rally is six blocks from my house, so I’m going to take a walk down there; it’s a beautiful day.
LJ/Aquaria @ 86
I mentioned the Oneida Nation in upstate NY previously. Before they got the bingo halls and casino, most of the nation was living on a very small reservation, maybe a couple of hundrred acres max, in trailers and shacks. I can in no way begrudge them using the income from the casino to build homes and provide medical and education services to their people. They also recognize tha sooner or later the white man will capitalize on things and try to take over.
Rice to Congess: Go Cheney yourself!
It’s called constitutionally mandated oversight, Condi.
But I do like your shoes.
PeteCO @ 91
Have a nice day! http://www.a28.org/actions.shtml
Susan in Iowa @73:
I was afraid of that, and I suspected that it would happen, even though I maintained hope that it would not. I’m sorry to hear it.
My mother-in-law’s husband is Navajo and they live in New Mexico. Both are involved in education on the reservation. Right now, they’re trying to decide whether they’re going to move their trailer to a plot of land that has electricity but no water or another plot that has water but no electricity.
Hummm, that’s odd. My earlier comment seems to be stuck in moderation. Hasn’t happended in a month of Sundays.
[Mod: try refreshing. You might have mentioned a gambling related filter]
Another great campaign against the physical, sexual and verbal abuse of women.
http://www.sexualassaultresources.org/wrc.html
Kathleen @ #87…
What you say is true. The impression here is that most violence against woman goes unreported. Regardless of enthnicity, economic or social strata. A sense of shame, if you can believe it, among other factors of course, plays a perhaps major role.
allan_in_upstate @ 2
Andrew Card, Bush’s Chief of Staff for abt 5 years went straight from working for GM to Bush’s Chief of Staff and it seems many of Bush’s policys have hurt the auto workers. Bush came here to Mi just before the election 06 and there were protesters who wanted him to meet with the Big 3 automakers. As you all know, the auto biz is in trouble. Any ways, Bush’s answer was he’d met with the representatives of the Big 3 after the election. Why did he make it political, why did he want to wait to see who was in charge of the House & Senate before talking to American Companies?
I read an editoral by a conservative who wrote, I’m paraphrasing “is GM is the business to make cars or sell health insurance?” He was berating the company for even having health care. How crazy is that? Conservatives are now against universal health care AND health care benefits from compaines? It just doesn’t make sense. Well, that editorial didn’t mentioned any thing abt the dividends GM was handing out. Is GM in the biz to make cars or to give bonuses to people who hold stock in a Co. and have never enter a GM facility or worked the line to make those cars?
Today in history…
Benito Mussolini executed: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benito_Mussolini
Coincidence? http://www.a28.org/actions.shtml
TheraP @ 68
Uh, not always is it about the attachment. I hated my first husband after a while. I wanted to leave him…
But where could I go? I was living in SoCal, working barely above minimum wage. Then I lost my job. All of my family was in Texas, and I didn’t leave on good terms with them. My husband didn’t let me have any friends–hated anyone I befriended. I thought I was entirely alone, and entirely dependent on him. How could I survive out there, without a family, home, food, clothes? Of course I was young and naive, only 21 at the time, and I’d grown up in Texas where there were almost zero social services. I stayed because I didn’t know where else to go. I stayed because the “unknown” out there that every woman is taught to fear (you’ll get raped! murdered!) was more frightening than he was.
This is really hard to get people to understand, that we have an entire culture that reminds women of how powerless they are (and men face some other cultural bugaboos from the other end that can victimize them), so that, when things go haywire with someone they love, they will stay, rather than risk the unknown. I was lucky. I called my mother in TX at last, confessed what was happening, and asked for her help. I couldn’t handle it anymore. She caught the next plane to Los Angeles. Some people don’t have someone like that to turn to.
Lindy @ 95
That is not to take away from the great good that they have done, and if they have lost their way, I hope they find it again. It will probably take some restructuring, to maintain more distance between the church and the work of the shelter. As an institution, they are sorely needed.
dakine01 @ 91
I mentioned the Oneida Nation in upstate NY previously. Before they got the bingo halls and casino, most of the nation was living on a very small reservation, maybe a couple of hundrred acres max, in trailers and shacks. I can in no way begrudge them using the income from the casino to build homes and provide medical and education services to their people. They also recognize tha sooner or later the white man will capitalize on things and try to take over.
Conditions like this are unfortunately pervasive on reservations all over the US. There are currently people on the Blackfeet, Rosebud, Pine Ridge, and other reservations living in cars and buses, as well as trailers (high class digs on many reservations) and shacks. In 1955 the average house on any of the Montana reservations was a one room log cabin with a dirt floor, a fireplace for heat, and not running water, electricity, or sewage disposal.
sofistic @ 88
After moving as a five year old from Oklahoma with my mother and grandmother to Sacramento, I spent most of my time in the Delta, Santa Rosa, Bodega Bay and Placer County. I’m just not into casinos. For a varity of reasons. ;0)
Atrios has a clip from the situation room, with former Senator Cleland discussing Bush’s will power and the comments of current Senator Chambliss, who he calls out for a chicken hawk. Just watching the part with our slumping president describing the state of his will power is infuriating.
Bush’s will: if he bends, he’ll break.
btw, gang — Cong. John Hall will be Howie’s guest today for Blue America!
Oklahoma kiddo @ 98
It is also the case that many Indian women do not report assaults, primarily because the (mostly white) authorities do not care and subject them to racist assaults.
More abuse stats…
http://www.theawarenesscenter.org/statistics.html
Oklahoma kiddo @ 31
i don’t either, but they are one of the only economic enterprises open to the tribes that can provide a substantial return on investment — if not the only one.
speaking only generally, because native americans are of course not monolithic, but casino culture pretty much does violence to the natives’ cultures and traditions.
sunshine @ 99
Back in the day, GM led the charge against the Clinton health care plan.
Absolute idiots. But of course, the workers (and shareholders) pay the price;
the executives never do.
Roger Smith ( of Roger and Me fame ) is still pulling down a $1,200,000 per year pension.
DrDick @ 104
Conditions like this are unfortunately pervasive on reservations all over the US. There are currently people on the Blackfeet, Rosebud, Pine Ridge, and other reservations living in cars and buses, as well as trailers (high class digs on many reservations) and shacks. In 1955 the average house on any of the Montana reservations was a one room log cabin with a dirt floor, a fireplace for heat, and not running water, electricity, or sewage disposal.
I also have always applauded the Oneida’s refusal to serve alcohol at their facilities. I mean who has a casino with no drinking? The Oneida Indian Nation’s Turning Stone casino in Vernon, NY (between Syracuse and Utica), serves no alcohol at all and has done a marvelous job of providiong services to the Oneida Nation.
egregious @ 28
Thanks, eg–have just thrown in my mite. Sure is easy when you can do it via PayPal! Wish some other charities would figure this out.
One out of 3-5 girls and one out of 5-7 boys are sexually abused before their 18th birthday.
http://www.theawarenesscenter……abuse.html
Susan and Lindy,
per my story about our little county upthread -
by Bushco standards, the $$$ are a mere pittance but make a huge impact on these programs – it is probably tough to turn down the cash – in Raphael House’s case, am willing to bet some faith based snake oil salesman came in with a big fat community grant and they had to listen to him
Everything is a Ponzi Scheme to these thugs !
p.s. I acknowledge there are pleny of faith based resources that provide much needed services in their communites
[CHS notes: No. Just no.]
Oklahoma kiddo @ 31
WTF? [several more outraged deleted words here I’m editing out] I and my Tribal card are here to say you are dead wrong, and who are you to judge? I saw #49 too, no dice.
I clearly remember my Chippewa tribe fighting the government tooth and nail in the 70’s over their fishing treaties being broken time after time (my grandfather and uncles were Indian Commercial Fishermen) and through much blood, sweat, and preserverance they finally retained their rights and won a settlement from the government, which they put in escrow for a decade until they could afford to build their first casino in the impoversished Upper Peninsula.
Today that casino has multiplied into 9 of them covering every county in the U.P., my tribe has built clinics, hospitals, businesses, programs, schools, college education grants (complete books and tuition), Elder payments, job creations, and much, much more. They’ve won awards and have set an excellent example for others to prudently do the same thing to lift themselves from poverty and help every one in our tribe when they had no other viable choices, and add to the State base tax revenue.
Go tell our 30,000 members to their face that casinos don’t help our ‘native problems’. I have much more to say but I better stop now.
I’m not trying to justify casinos, it is just that the local tribes took one of the only economic options available to them and did some really good things with it.
dmg @ 109
To my mind, gross poverty and disempowerment does far greater violence to Native traditions. Though I am also ambivalent about casinos.
OT- Strobel & Landay, McClatchy reporters highlighted in Bill Moyers’ Buying the War, had this truth to tell on Friday:
Terrorism Report Will Show 29% Rise in Attacks
Quite honestly, I think we pale faces discredited ourselves from deciding what was best for Native Americans, long ago. We did it quite spectacularly.
Shez @ 116 aptly illustrates the point I made above. For his and many other reservations casinos have been a lifesaver and have revitalized areas formerly characterized by third world living conditions. In many cases these tribal enterprises have not only revitalized the reservations, but also the usually economically depressed surrounding communities. The Shakopee Reservation in Minnesota anf Couer d’Alene in north Idaho are good examples.
When I met my wife 24 years ago, she was married to a Doctor who had been abusing her with injected prescription drugs for 15 years. The drug was called Talwin (pentazocine lactate) which is a chrystaline pain killer in an acidic solution. At the height of this abuse he was administering over 20ccs of this stuff every 9 days. So much substance that much of it was “unabsorbed.”
What wasn’t absorbed chrystalized in the soft tissue and turned into numerous shrapnel like chunks that have been painfully emerging from the affected areas ever since, in spite of numerous surgeries.
Every time I read another abuse story it tears me right to the core.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 26
In regard to her war resolution vote
Hillary keeps repeating “if only I knew then what I know now”. This is a bunch of hogwash! Unless Hillary can provide a more honest and substantive explanation for her yes vote, whe does not have mine.
Prior to the invasion there were just too many experts (General Zinni, Flynt Leverett, Scott Ritter, Jimmy Carter, Madeline Albright, CIA analyst, Zbigniew Brezinski etc. etc) questioning the validity of the intelligence, and the wisdom of invading a nation that had not attacked the U.S.
Unless Hillary can indicate(they may not be able to talk about this) or provide more information that they had access to even more frightening (probably false) intelligence that the public was not, then she is obviously covering her stupid strategic vote.
RUN AL RUN!
Shez… #117
I’ll be glad to tell anyone my views on casinos. Perhaps we shall just have to disgree on this.
LJ/Aquaria @ 121
But we knew what was best for the Vietnamese, and we know what’s best for the Iraqis!
Fresh thread, up and ready for the reading.
PeteCO @ 123
And we have done such a good job for all of them. Native American life expectancy is 4 years less than the US average (which is the lowest in the industrialized world) and Native infant mortality is 20% hiigher than the US average (the highest in the industrialized world – Finland’s infant mortality rate is 1/2 the US rate).
Oklahoma kiddo @
49
Agree w/ you about the casinos, making $ from gambling may be lucrative but it is not ‘right livlihood’. Royalties for resource extraction should be paid, billions are owed. Kirk Murphy did an extensive comment about this about a month ago. Non-pmt of royalties for timber and mineral extraction has got to be the biggest domestic scam in the Bush Admin. The scope, audacity and dollar amounts are breath-taking. Of course, it involves Gonzo, also Susan Woolridge and Steven Griles.
Pls do read it, this is far too little-known. Kirk also gives links to American Indian sources and blogs. Btw, am I referring properly? We have been taught to say Native Canadian/American here, not Indian.
To go back on topic, thank you so much Christy for this post. Following the links I would like to make sure everyone sees Hilzoy’s exact post on this:
http://obsidianwings.blogs.com…..ault_.html
and one of links embedded in that:
http://www.southdakotacoalition.org/
A friends daughter works for this group. Native American Economic development. Seems like one of the big question is what to do with all that casino money
http://www.eda.gov/Research/NativeAmerican.xml
Been trying to find stats for domestic violence on Statemaster, and haven’t so far. Here are the stats for forcible rape. Percapita forcible rape data from Statemaster
Subway Serenade @ 123
Terrifying. Hope she is doing so much better!
sofistic @ 128
DoJ gives state by state crime statistics (including sexual assault) and breakdowns by race/ethnicity (or at least they used to, I haven’t checked in a couple of years).
PeteCO @ 126
A strange story about my days living in a heavily NA area:
A bunch of people were bitching one day about the NAs, a popular sport in Rapid City for the pale faces. I was enduring this, because I worked with these people
One of these neanderthals, to emphasize his point that they were “worthless,” related how our Great Father government tried to be “so kind” to the NAs as to build them a bunch of pretty little suburban houses, but “those animals” knocked out the walls of their new homes, so that their horses could drink from the bathtub.
I noticed the obvious, and stated it: “I’m sure the intentions were good, it was generous to build them homes…but why didn’t anyone ask the NA’s what they needed from homes, before building them?”
To me, it’s pretty obvious that, even when we’ve sincerely tried to help, we never could wrap our mind around the notion of listening to them about what they needed.
And, yes, that’s why we failed in Vietnam and why we are failing so terribly in Iraq. We’ve never considered what these people we’re “helping” needed. We’ve never really tried to listen to them. Hell, a lot of times, we didn’t even ask. We just went in with an idea of what we thought they needed, and they’d learn to like it or else. Everybody wants things the way we want them, right? RIGHT?
And then we wonder why all these people we help don’t appreciate our efforts.
# 102 Aquaria thanks for sharing your story Brave woman.
Casinos, no matter the location attract criminal elements. From small timers to big timers like Jack Abramoff, etc.
Shez @ 117
Thank you, Shez. I wondered at what point a Native American would pipe up.
There is the little matter of nearly $200 BILLION dollars in land use and other royalties that have been bilked from the Native American tribes, going back over 100 years. That’s what underpins some of the rapid scurrying we are seeing related to both the U.S. Attorneys’ dismissals and the Abramoff scandals. The tribes have been dealt raw deal after raw deal by the American government for decades after decades; they come to believe that they cannot get representation without buying it from lobbyists like Abramoff (even though he respected them as little as the many generations of non-Natives before him). Abramoff bilks them handily, with the help of squeeze-players like Ralph Reed and John Cornyn who put coordinated pressure on gambling at Abramoff’s encouragement.
John McCain, the so-called straighttalking express, has made little headway into the missing royalties, either; I doubt any Native American, if they aren’t being suppressed from voting by the politically placed U.S. Attorney appointees, will vote for him. One has to wonder why McCain hasn’t gotten anywhere into the BIA’s problems in spite of his tenure and his seniority within his party’s ranks…?
The story of Pretty Bird Woman and many other Native American women like her is not just a story of inadequate tribal policing. The U.S. Attorney General’s Native American Issues Subcommittee, responsible for developing and improving law enforcement cooperation between U.S. and tribal law enforcement organizations, was systematically undermined by the U.S. Attorney dismissals, starting in early 2006 with NAIS chair and MN USA Thomas Heffelfinger’s “departure”, and the subsequent dismissal of more than 30% of the NAIS members (Iglesias, Charlton, Chiara are more examples). How should the Native American tribes perceive this continued undermining of their law enforcement?
Pretty Bird Woman symbolizes the ultimate outcome of not only inter-gender violence, cultural violence, but societal and national violence, the gross invalidation of an entire gender and an entire sovereign nation. You can see portrayed in JoyB’s first comment here, writing about her experience initially in almost third-person fashion, how detached from self one can become in order to survive. Imagine how an entire group of women, how an entire nation thinks of itself, in light of more than a hundred years of invalidation.
“Native problem”? That “native problem” is a symptom of a much, MUCH larger problem, and Native Americans aren’t the source.
Kathleen @ 136
I was an idiot, Kathleen. I’m not one anymore.
Christy this is a very difficult topic to discuss. Most are either embarrassed or completely traumatized by these abusive situations!
I grew up in such a household (and this type of abuse can take place in all economic backgrounds)! I repeated the cycle that I grew up in and married an abuser. Broke the cycle through divorce and a great deal of counseling. While bringing up three daughters who are now (29,27, and 19) I tried very hard to provide information and classes for them so that they could recognize the early signals of an abusive relationship.
Also provided them with numerous opportunities to attend classes with a dear friend who has a Ph.D in counseling and also conducts classes for young women (and men) to be able to recognize verbal and sexual abuse early on. And how to verbally and physically defend themselves from this abuse.
This is so pervasive in our society, and difficult to talk about. Breaking the cycle early on is key! Thanks for bringing attention to this very serious topic!
Breaking the cycle of violence is difficult but completely possible!
sofistic @ 132
New Jersey and West Virginia at the bottom of the list. I don’t think so!
LS @ 81
My comment (@68) was not an argument against shelters. Just an explanation of what keeps the cycle going.
Sadly, even people in shelters often return to the abuser.
So, yes, shelters are absolutely necessary. But they are not sufficient.
LJ/Aquaria @ 102
You describe well the powerlessness induced by the abuser. That too is part of what I described as the “attachment.” Yes, you hated the guy. Sadly, hatred is one of the strongest types of attachment. And yes, the abuser does everything to break the ties that connect a person to anyone except themselves. You did a good job of describing that as well. Your pattern is all too common. Glad you got away.
OT to this thread but, from a comment at Marcie’s (emptywheel) blog. Check out
http://blog.washingtonpost.com…..ing_i.html
(excerpt follows)
McKay, the ousted U.S. attorney for the Western District of Washington, is now a visiting professor at the Seattle University School of Law. On May 9 he’s hosting a pair of his fellow fired federal prosecutors for a forum on the mass sackings last year.
Joining McKay will be David C. Iglesias, the former U.S. attorney for New Mexico, and Paul K. Charlton, the former prosecutor for Arizona. McKay, Iglesias and Charlton are three of the most controversial firings of the eight ousted prosecutors, because they were either conducting sensitive investigations of Republicans or under fire for not prosecuting Democrats around the time of their dismissals on Dec. 7. All three were also contacted by members of Congress or their staff at a sensitive time regarding ongoing criminal corruption investigations.
The four-hour symposium could spark sharp criticism of Attorney General Alberto Gonzales and the White House for alleged politicization of the Justice Department. One session is titled: “The 2007 Experience — Myths and Realities: explanation of the current incidents, with comparison of historical similarities and differences.”
When you address “cycles of violence” they apply to so many situations. The Israeli Palestinian conflict, Native Americans etc. When we look at the European conquest of this continent the genocide of Native peoples and the enslavement of Africans. We do not have much to be proud of.
We continue to live up to our ugly U.S. history. The pre-emptive invasion of Iraq and the Bush administrations (looks like planned) failure to establish order there created an enviroment for a genocide to take place. While multi national oil companies move into position to privatize the second largest oil reserves in the world. Diane Rehm hosted a very informative program on the oil situation in Iraq last week
http://wamu.org/programs/dr/07/04/26.php#12837
The U.S.’s addiction to a cycle of violence continues. The world body needs to conduct an intervention on the U.S.
Hello, My mothers english blood gave me blue eyes, but my sir name ancestry is French/Cana-
dien with a great, great, great grandma from the Chipewaen nation up their by Great Slave Lake, my dad’s family are early Michigan Pilgrims, and the only thing they really had in common was they were both alcoholics! And both their families were either in or out of various stages of denial about it. I know what abuse is, my wife is also from a dysfunctional family
which is where I usually let that lay. Anyway I once knew a gal from South Dakota, and once one of the Rosebuds called me for donations, and I said I could give them five bucks at the time. (I was job hopping doing a Wal-Mart gig at the time living on my own sorting some stuff out) It was useless, a five dollar donation, so I blew it off and said on the rebound. So if I’m not on the rebound now, I’m atleast doing a lot better than cleaning up the meat cutters shop at the Super Center. So I copied your P. O. Box on a post-it and I’ll snail mail you guys a money order, or orders ASAP. Anchors Aweigh I got to get back to work!
Kathleen @145
Our current situation under bushco is like a cycle of violence. They abuse anyone who disagrees. They reward those who are docile and do their bidding.
You are correct that this applies to so much.
Rayne at 138,
Even Gonzo agress that it’s $ 200 billion we (Dept of Indian Affairs, Nat Resources, and various industries) owe to Native Americans. Some estimate the true figure, reflecting accurate record keeping, interest and penalties, could top a trillion. Indian Affairs says getting real numbers would be ‘too hard’ and Gonzo’s DoJ has recommended settling for $7 billion. Does this have anything to sdo with which AG’s got fired? Could very well be, many of them are involved with Indian issues, as Rayne has showed.
Shez, absolutely, take the money and run. Indians have been fucked over since day one. It’s more than poetic justice that most of the $ comes from white pockets, too. But I feel uneasy about it, I have seen gambling eat homes and families, but perhaps I’m too sensitive.
Kirk Murphy’s summary here, w/links to Wampum and other native American sites/blogs that have been tracking this.
Please contact Bill Moyers and encourage him to do a present time documentary on how the MSM has allowed the “cakewalk in Iraq” liars to repeat unsubstantiated claims about Iran for the last three years.
Ask Moyers to do a show on Iran and the media. Why has the MSM allowed the claims about an “alleged” nuclear weapons program to go mostly unchallenged. (Chris Matthews has been consistently challenging these claims). The rest of the MSM allows the unsubstantiated claims to be repeated over and over again.
Polls report that 70% of Americans now believe that Iran posesses nuclear weapons instead of a nuclear energy program. This belief did not happen via osmosis.
Please contact Bill Moyers so that he does a show NOW on the media and Iran not in two years after the Bush administration pre-emptively attacks Iran! Moyers can help stop aN illegal, and immoral pre-emptive strike on Iran by digging for the truth instead of repeating the “cakewalk in Iraq” liars inflammatory rhetoric about Iran.
CONTACT MOYERS
http://www.pbs.org/moyers/jour…..dback.html
This is a great article and I agree with it to some degree. Moyers did not mention how much anti-invasion info was on the web, and did not show very much coverage of the anti-invasion marches( we know the MSM did not)
http://www.axisoflogic.com/art…..4430.shtml
Firepups, it’s shaping up to be a glorious day in SillyValley. So what better kind of day to fire up the smoker and do some REAL barbecue.
I’ve got a seven pound brisket and a slab of pork spare ribs that just went in. THe ribs will be dinner today, I’ll do the brisket until midnight. You just can’t overdo the brisket as long as you keep it low and slow.
The hickory chips are smoking already and the wood smoke already smells glorious.
Anybody else got some low and slow cooking planned for this weekend?
Guitar_Playing_Bastard @
150
God, that sounds divine. Unfortunately I am in grading hell for the next couple of weeks and only doing quick and dirty cooking in the interim. Once the semester is over, however, the smoker is going to fire up.
Hi, Waccamaw @6:34! I’m sorry that I missed you. I hope you were able to solve your C-Span reception troubles in time for Gonzo’s appearance last week!
~~~~~~~~~~~
Although I don’t think it specifically deals with women who are victims of violence, I wanted to mention a program in CT called “Growing Through Sewing” that caught my eye in the NYT.
According to what I’ve been able to find out about it online, it teaches sewing skills to women who are recovering drug addicts, living in shelters. The goal of the program is to teach these women marketable skills, but I think it’s also great that they’re being given an outlet for creativity, too, which I think we all need. Here’s another article about the program.
LJ/Aquaria @ 70
LJ/Aquaria, that is one hell of an irony, and it’s spot on. After I got spanked, I was ordered to “SMILE!!!” or “WIPE THAT SOURPUSS OFF YOUR FACE!!!” by a yelling father who could otherwise be so generous, and have a concern for others. Set me up beautifully to be a flight attendant. And, a wife of an abuser.
What Hilzoy wrote about the attachment is true. I spent years trying to “earn back” the respect of the adorable and vulnerable guy who “fell hard” for me in the first couple of months I knew him. I had no idea it was a syndrome.
You know, what basically got me out of this hell, started before I was evacuated. I had already told him it was over, and I was divorcing him (so, I was in the most treacherous situation, trying to stay in the house, which was originally mine–I’d bought it with my VA loan when single). Despite all the hell (which involved so much more than the yelling), the thing that kept me there was my sense that he’d be “devastated” if he couldn’t live with his little girl. I knew I sure would be. So, I stayed.
When I came home after work and from her daycare, to find him out gardening and a nasty porn video in the DVD player (instead of Prince of Egypt, which my two-year old and I expected), after I flusteredly got the thing out of the machine as she asked what she’d seen, I realized:
- he was a creepy presence in the house (this was 6 PM)
- and no way was he anywhere NEAR as connected to our child as I was. To watch the thing, and then just rise and leave it there? I KNEW he would not be devastated.
I called the lawyer the next morning and mobilized.
The thing is, the connection might not be that you think the abuser is so great, but could be something to do with not upsetting your kids, or your parents, or empoverishing your kids. It’s not just romantic attachment. There are all kinds of attachments to break when you must break them.
If anyone is reading this and feeling trapped, can I tell you that it is so much better out here, free? He left me with all of his debt. I still have to hear him yell on the phone (until I hang up). I have a sense that he will never see real justice. But I’m telling you, it does not matter. It is so much better out here, my fanny hanging in the breeze, walking a tightrope, paying his stupid bills, being my, perfectly myself, passing my own decisions through the filter of, “Is this good and is this right?” Not “will this keep him from screaming at me?” Find your reason for attachment, and seriously question it. I believe that no abuser actually merits the faith we try to put in them.
Sorry about the long, probably epu’d post. I want to send money to Pretty Bird. I could send my usual little $10. It’d do me good.
ok, I sent $20.00. That felt GOOD. It’s a start. Time to do better right here locally. Thank you, Christy and Hilzoy, for this thread.