
(Photo by the ever-wonderful BobbyG at last year's YKos in Vegas.)
Summations in the Libby trial will begin today, and hopefully conclude, although you can never be sure of that in a trial that has defense counsel asking for four hours and having that whittled down to three by the presiding judge. (And with pending motions from both sides requesting additional time for arguments that were filed over the weekend, I'm thinking we are not likely to finish today.) This morning, Jane, Pach, and I will be sitting in the courtroom to watch the closings, and Emptywheel will be manning the keyboard to give you the liveblogging of the proceedings along with us.
Thank you so much for all of the support — monetarily and in the comments and with so much collective research. Without your help, we could not have done this comprehensive coverage of the investigation and this Libby trial. Your support has helped keep the blog going. If you have enjoyed the work that we have done, please consider a thank you donation that will enable us to keep doing this work for all of the investigations and action requests to come.
I spent time yesterday during my flight thinking about all of the work that Jane has done, and that I joined in with, about this investigation. Before I left for DC, I went back to a post that I wrote late one night, early in my blogging here at FDL, after some stray commenter made the mistake of telling me that this investigation didn't really matter anyway, asking why we even cared about it at all. The funny thing is, going back to read it takes me right back to that indignation and disgust at the comment — and my need to explain my perspective, as someone who has worked with officers who put their lives on the line in undercover operations. And I wanted to revisit a portion of that post for a moment this morning, as a reminder for all of us, why this matters:
Imagine that one day you wake up to the incessent ping of your beeper. It is still dark outside your window, and you slide out of bed, pad quietly down the hallway and try not to wake up the wife and kids, as you slip into your home office and place a call on a secure phone. You are told that your cover has been blown, that your family may be at risk. You have to make instant decisions for your own safety, that of your family, and of every asset you have in the field – and to do that, you have to prioritize which assets are more valuable and which you can afford to lose, if necessary. You have to decide then and there which of the people you cultivated, the ones you promised safety in exchange for information and cooperation, which of them may have to die because you may not have time to save them all.
Why has your cover been blown? Because you work as a CIA colleague of the wife of a man who dared to question the veracity of the President of the United States on a matter of national security, a matter of an exaggerated claim that was inserted in his State of the Union address to bolster his case for war in Iraq. And the President's cronies and hatchet men decided to out this man's wife for political payback, as a lesson to anyone else who would dare to question their decisions and as a means to staunch the bleeding from this initial salvo of criticism. Damn the consequences.
No consideration for all the lives interconnected in this network of agents and field assets, or the years it took to cultivate them. No thought of the impact that this betrayal by highly placed governmental officials would have down the line — how hard it would make it to recruit human intelligence assets in the field at the very time that we need them most to gather information inside the terrorist networks that threaten us more and more each day.
No concern for the years of set up it took for Brewster-Jennings and Company, the cover company set up by the CIA that both you and this man's wife used, to get up and running. The fact that you and she worked along with a number of other highly trained CIA officers around the world — trained in tracking down the weapons used by terrorists and thugs and the very people that threaten our nation's safety every single day wasn't important to them. Nor was the loss of the millions of taxpayer dollars it took to set this up and maintain it as viable cover in a number of countries worldwide.
Seemingly, no thought of the loss of ongoing investigations. If there was any consideration or calculation, a discounting of the loss of human intel assets dealing with WMD issues at a time of war, with terrorists who would like nothing more than to get their hands on the very chemical, biological, and nuclear weapons and materials that you have risked your life to keep out of their hands.
The next time someone opens their yap and says to me that this case doesn't matter. That everyone does it. That it was just politics. That this is how things are done in Washington. That the President is going to pardon them anyway. That they'll find a way to weasel out of it. That she wasn't really under cover anyway. That they didn't know she was a NOC when they outed her CIA status. Or whatever other talking head pundit crap comes out of the pipeline on the next talking points bilge memo…well, it just doesn't matter….
How dare anyone say that this case does not matter. You tell that to the family of anyone who has a star on that wall. Or to anyone who has ever had the honor of knowing and working with or living with any law enforcement hero who walks out their front door every day, knowing that it could be the last time they ever see their family. Knowing that a deep cover assignment risks not only their own life, but sometimes the lives of everyone close to them.
This is why I have followed this investigation, this case, this particular trial so closely. And why Jane and I got caught up in making certain that the false narrative of "everybody does it" was not allowed to just sit out there on the surface. Some things are just wrong. Period.
This was wrong. It was fundamentally wrong, for our nation, for our national security, and for the way business ought to be done by the supposed adults who are charged with keeping our nation safe, and not just with saving their own political bacon and trafficking in gossip and innuendo and carefully crafted leaks when it suits their political payback purposes. And for political operatives and craven power junkies like Karl Rove and Dick Cheney, who have made their lives and their business running over top of anyone who got in their way because they could, this was, truly, the last straw. That this was done by the highest reaches of power in the Bush Administration — the very people who should be guarding our nation's national security secrets the closest — was truly the last straw.
It is time that people in Washington took a good, long, hard look at themselves — and asked a fundamental question: am I here to serve myself or the public's interest? Because if the answer is (a), you are now on notice — we are not backing down or going away quietly once this one trial has concluded. If you will not provide oversight and accountability on behalf of all of the public and not just your cronies, we will do so. If you will not stand up for what is right, we will.
This is our nation, our government, our values that you are supposed to represent. All of ours.
Citizenship is not a passive endeavor, it requires active participation — and we plan to be very, very active in the next few years leading into the Presidential and Congressional elections in 2008. Now, more than ever, it is imperative that elected officials and political appointees remember that they are supposed to work for us, and not the other way around. This nation has substantial problems that need to be addressed, born of the last five years of rubber stamp Republican parliamentary behavior, the utter lack of any demands for accountability, and the overreaching tantrums of an out-of-control unilateral executive and the figurehead he put on the throne.
Jane and I want to thank each and every one of you for all of the support you have given us through our coverage of this case — from the inception of the investigation all the way to today. All of your comments, the collective research that we have all been able to pull together, and for all the donations of time and money and effort from everyone to help make our liveblogging of the Libby trial possible.
Where does all of this go next? Absolutely no idea. But we plan on being on the front lines of the next battle of ideas, and the next and the next. For as long as it takes.
To do that, however, we need to have enough to keep going forward. As you all know, Jane is facing a battle of her own at the moment, and will be starting chemo soon in the next front of that portion of her life — I've said this to her, but I'm saying it here as well — that cancer had better be scared, because she is going to kick its ass, just like everything else that gets in her way.
If you can afford to do so, and you feel that our coverage has been worth all the time you have spent here following proceedings — or all the reading that you have been able to do in all of the months and months of work we have done leading up to this — we would certainly appreciate a donation of thanks.
We are hoping to have something in reserve after this trial to help us move onto the next one or to the next Congressional investigation, whichever comes first. – without Jane having to worry about funding site costs while she is fighting her own battle. You guys know that asking for money is not my forte — I hate it — but for Jane, I'm more than willing to do some heavy lifting on this one. As you read this, I'm already on my way to the courthouse for summations, and we will have much more coverage for you as the day goes on, including liveblogging of the proceedings every step of the way today.
In closing, thank you so much — all of you — for all of your support. We are looking forward to a lot more work in the days, weeks, months and years to come. And we are looking forward to doing all of this work together with all of you.
The bottom line is that we could not have done this without each and every one of you. And every donation that we get will be put right back into the expenses we plan to incur for all of the battles yet to be waged. If you have enjoyed the work we have done on this trial — and the entire investigation — or all of our work on the last election for candidates across the country, please consider a thank you donation to help keep this blog and all of our work moving forward. Thank you. For everything.
Related posts:
- Why Self-Regulation Doesn’t Work: Lenders Pursue Fees to Bolster Bottom Line
- World Economy Finding a Bottom Because the Keynesians are in China
- Obama, Gates, and the Thin Blue Line
- Mike Farrell Thanks Progress Illinois, Jesse Jackson Jr., Phil Hare, Luis Gutierrez for Holding Line on Public Option
- Marcy Wheeler Wins Hillman Award, Gets NOI $5000 Matching Grant





Spotlight







Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

Christy & Jane!
Good morning y’all!
Damn Christy, that was one of your best, which is really saying something. I admire your values only slightly more than your natural born way of expressing them. Rock on.
Please give Jane a peck on each cheek for tommy yum when you see her.
Fitz, Jane, Christy and what tommy yum said.
Great post, CHS.
Thank you.
Good morning! As soon as time permits, please read Marcy’s most recent Next Hurrah thread: http://thenexthurrah.typepad.c…..dick_.html
Just sent a little love your way, Christy. Thanks so much to you and Jane, and everyone, for all you have done.
The passion of Why This Matters is what touches me the most. It’s inspiring to us little bloggers, to keep doing what we do, too. It’s going to take time to change the perception that ‘it’s okay, because everyone does it’ no matter what the issue is, in this country. Thank you, Christy and Jane, et. al., for your passion in making this change happen.
tommy yum @
3
HEAR! HEAR!
also, for those who missed it, the NYT has an article on the trial this a.m., focused on machinations of Cheney and Libby that were revealed by the trial evidence. Trail spotlights Cheney’s power as an insider.
If you’ve been following the coverage here, you’ll notice a couple odd things about the Times story. This morning’s treasure hunt.
Bravo, Christi.
There are actually still some good people in Washington who consider public service just that. Service to the people of this country. They need help, though, from the people. People in government service, particularly the politicals, need to be help accountable for their actions. You can’t swoop in here, spend four years pillaging to benefit yourself or a small number of people or corporations, then swoop out to a cushy job in the industry you just helped. The laws/regulations/orders they are passing or changing affect the nation as a whole in some very fundamental ways. You CAN’T be allowed to hurt the nation at large to create profit/benefit for the few. The Bushies were given a pass for years after 9/11. This, thankfully, is coming to an end. It needs to stop entirely.
I am working my day job 20 blocks from you guys. If I were rich, and did not need this day job, I would walk out of here and bring you guys coffee (or bourbon, if appropriate.) Heck, I don’t even know you, but I know whom you are tormenting, and that’s good enough for me…
Christy, two checks I sent separately to FDL several weeks ago by snail mail have not been cashed as of yesterday. I’m wondering if mail has not been retrieved at that address for awhile or whether there is some other explanation.
Amazing job as always Christy. You guys all helped me get through my crisis, and I’m thrilled to be able to make a small contribution. Have you looked into setting up recurring donations? I already do that for my Democracy bond, be nothing but a ‘thang to do it for you too.
Chri$ty,
You may not like fundrai$ing, but you’re pretty good at it.
It worked on me [again]…
Tom Friedman on the fone w/ Imus now…
christy,
as always thanks, but especially today, especially now, thanks for this post.
as i’m sure you’ve picked up being there, the beltway crowd’s argument has been reduced to the lame-ass talking points you cite: where’s the crime? and everyone does it.
the crime was enormous, both in practical scope and in the intent behind it, the sheer arrogance and indifference to the true national interest by these thugs in power.
and as far as everyone doing it, oh really? please cite another case when the vice president, his chief of staff, the president’s chief adviser and a whole nest of other white house officials (probably including the president of the united states himself) punished or helped to punish a critic by blowing the cover of an operative and the program she served? please tell me just one other time.
there is no other time. perjury is apparently enough to get a president impeached. it certainly will be enough to get libby found guilty. and we can only hope that the majority of the country sees what kind of psychopathic administration we have allowed to tun our country into the ditch.
I’ll donate a little something later today. Bravo to you & Jane and Emptywheel and…oh, hell, the whole gang.
Sally @
13
With so much of our efforts focused on live blogging, it is possible that some snail mail checks have not been deposited. Rest assured they will be very soon. Thanks for your continuing support.
Wonderful post to wake up to this a.m. Really gets the cylinders firing. So looking forward to reading the live blog from Prettyman today.
Some in my address book have asked the “why do you care, why does this matter” question, too.
Usual answer: Do you think the people running this country @ the highest levels should be allowed to engage in this kind of conduct w/classified material? With starting an unnecessary war? No? Then this trial is a first step toward doing what you were bitching about the Repub Congress not doing- calling the Bush administration to account on its sorry brand of “leadership” starting from whatever level you can (Libby).
I then mail them the part of Fitzgerald’s indictment news conference where he says that this wasn’t just done to Valerie Plame, it was done to all of us…
I was schooled on Friedman last night. Thanks to all.
Thanks Christy! You said it all.
It is Fitzmas!!
it’s an awesome post christy
I have come to a sad realization because of this case though…sad to the marrow of my soul;
the wing nuts care less about this country then they do about their party leaders
this includes the elected officials who’ve sworn their solemn oath before their maker, before their constituents and before this country’s constitution.
no matter what is shown before them, their party image and their party’s leaders must be protected at all cost…at pain of their very way of life
it’s not even cognitive dissonance, for they know with no doubt the damage these people have done to their country, their kids future, their grand kids future.
their party leader has been taken under seige by these neo fascists, but they pay no mind at all.
party before country, party leader before party
brutal analysis, but sad to say, true
RBG, thank you for that and for all the work you do here.
Today feels like “Watergate, The Sequel”
Congratulations everyone. Today is ours.
Hi Redd, I know this has come up before, any consideration to adding a paypal subscription button? If FDL needs the tech know-how, digby has one. I tried setting up a monthly check cut through on-line bill pay, but they want a phone number. Any-who, thank you.
Lot’s of love to peanut.
I got a bonus at work, so I can send part of it your way! Thanks for everything you’re doing!
Christy – While Marcy is live-blogging, would you, Jane and Pach please observe the jury closely (if you can see them) and note their facial expressions, nodding or shaking heads, and report on it by the end of the day?
Those expressions will give us a clue as to what they might be thinking or buying/not buying from prosecutor or defense.
Yeah, I agree with ecoast, give us the red dress part of the story.
By the way, Boston, how much is that Friedman unit going for today?
Morning All,
thanks RBG, was wondering the same thing :)
Donation$ – been using the snail mail option – but thought I might pick up one of those load-as-you-go credit cards today and hit the mc/visa buttons upthread – will let others know if it “works”
thanks everyone downstairs for the Imus heads up
CHS says “It is time that people in Washington took a good, long, hard look at themselves — and asked a fundamental question: am I here to serve myself or the public’s interest? Because if the answer is (a), you are now on notice — we are not backing down or going away quietly once this one trial has concluded. If you will not provide oversight and accountability on behalf of all of the public and not just your cronies, we will do so. If you will not stand up for what is right, we will.
This is our nation, our government, our values that you are supposed to represent. All of ours.”
Redd, This is why I love FDL! You fire me up to fight the good fight. Next stop PayPal.
Thanks for all you do!
If Cheney is forced out (he’ll not resign voluntarily), might a push be made to replace him with Jeb? It’s painful to contemplate, but I’ll wager Babs and Poppy and many others are thinking it’s a wonderful opportunity to carry on the monarchy. Things being what they are, I suspect it could be a done deal. There’s no end to the mischief these hoods are capable of.
Thanks, Christy, for all the work you all have been doing. I’ve been following ever since this thing started and I agree about the importance of this trial. It just burns me up when I hear people callously dismiss it as a non-issue. Nobody has come anywhere close to reporting this the way FDL has. I think it’s ground-breaking.
I’m sending a little something your way.
Thank you, Christy, Jane, Marcy, and especially Valerie and Joe and all the rest of the pups here at the Lake.
Questions of life and death? Yeah, they matter.
AMEN Christy! This is, INDEED, what it’s all about. It’s so unimaginable that we have amoral men and women at the top of the dung heap. They all need to go. Most excellent post..thank you.
Good morning, all…
excellent post, Redd…
tossed a little “cha-cha” into the pot… payday not for a couple weeks…
While I’m thinking about it and before the live blogging begins for the day, we’ve got some abbreviated Rules of the Road. Thanks to Peterr for creating the first version of these tips.
Merry Fitzmas
Please help the FDL Servers keep humming along by heeding the following tips.
1. Stay on topic. Please keep your comment(s) on the
topic of the current live blogging.
2. Size matters. Try to keep comment length to a minimum –
especially during live blogging.
3. Links matter. More than 2 or 3 links in a comment may cause that
comment to get caught in moderation.
4. Beware the ziggurat! Please don’t nest more than 2 or 3
quotes in a comment. It may bust the margins and makes more work for
the people behind the scenes.
5. Words matter. Avoid words like “ins*rance” or “vi*gra” to
keep things from getting caught in moderation.
6. Do not feed the trolls. It just encourages them and makes
life difficult for the mods. Ignore the trolls.
Moderators really don’t like to delete comments….really, they don’t…but if comments don’t follow these tips, sometimes your witty and well crafted comment will be caught up in the clean up and may never be read by your fellow commenters.
Oh…and did I mention, please Stay on Topic and Don’t Feed The Trolls?
Thanks.
I can’t thank you enough
What time does court start today? 9:30am?
Watched the Frontline story last night, was pissed at it. Much of the show was about the Plame leak. Played it as much ado about nothing, everybody does it.
Steve G is required reading this morning…
http://www.thenewsblog.net/200…..world.html
I watched “Born on the Fourth of July” last night, my wife was getting quizzed on it for a crisis intervention class. It sickens me that the same shit Ron Kovic went through is happening again, in spades. We never learn.
There’s a new thread upstairs, so I’m going to be EPU twice with the NYT folks (Althouse and Kristof).
http://mgpaquin.blogspot.com/
Friedman hysterical on Imus
I hope someone had a tape of that. It so clearly demonstrates how ignorant the chatterers are. I just caught the last 30 seconds or so, and he kept repeating over and over, how could anyone go to an African country and find yellow-cake? As I reporter I couldn’t do that, what would you do walk up to someone and ask where’s the yellow cake? — Maybe you can send a “Seal” over but how would this guy be able to find it… then he went on flip out about how he couldnt understand how Cheney and them would think that the story that his wife, who works for the CIA could discredit him, that he thought they could paint him as a girly man? So, that’s why he never followed the story, because it never made sense to him. OMG. These people are the worst.
Christy,
Great post, but it doesn’t relate to what this trial is about. No one is currently charge with outing a covert agent. Libby is on trial for perjury and obstruction of justice. If Fitz has evidence of the former crime, he hasn’t charged anyone for it.
Live blogging up top
Sally @ 32
Considering Poppy’s tears for Jeb a couple of months ago, I think they realize that Junior has completely trashed Brand Bush in the eyes of the voters. Jeb running as an incumbent can’t save it. They’ll let memory fade for a few years before they try to continue the dynasty, and it’ll be one of our easier tasks to make sure it doesn’t work.
“Stay out of the Bushes!”
Thanks, Christy, for an inspiring read with which to begin my day.
Thank you, Christy, for the eloquent reminder that we bear witness deliberately to the prosecution of only one layer of a much deeper, larger crime against us, against our nation.
Thanks to all the FirePups who’ve stayed with this case so tenaciously, so that it received the attention it deserved. And thank you to all of you who’ve been able to offer financial support to this historic effort; you know that the truth would be buried in detritus and obscured by groupthink were it not for FireDogLake and its collective efforts including the immense talents of Emptywheel and Swopa.
Thanks to Arianna Huffington and Markos Moulitsas for their roles as godparents.
And thanks to the ghosts-in-the-machine here at FDL who keep things running smoothly while invisibly.
Thanks most especially to Jane, as she continues her own personal fight.
edit: p.s. check in the mail, 1Q2007 subscription payment.
Awesome post.
This one gets forwarded and spotlighted.
Paypal, here I come.
Amen! The Wilson-Plame family gave their lives to this country as did their colleagues and these SOBs trashed them on a political whim. May they rot in hell.
Donated and I am happy to help.
Good luck to Jane in this next battle. I am sure she will win.
The back of my head (RT) I’m honored.
Thanks, Christy. Another check is on the way. I will almost miss this trial, just because of the riveting coverage. On the other hand, I’ll get a lot more work done.
Even though Mr Fitzpatrick has not (yet) charged anyone with the crime of unauthorized disclosure of an intelligence officer, this case has nonetheless laid bare some of the machinations of this Administration in making that unauthorized disclosure on multiple occasions. It has also laid bare the lying and manipulation of powerful officials of this Administration and their cozy relationship with the so-called Fourth Estate, which clearly views itself as part of the power structure, largely unaccountable to both its readers and the American public generally. Lying, manipulation and cozy relationships are at the heart of how we find ourselves in the worst foreign policy disaster in American history, having intentionally blinded ourselves, both by ignoring evidence that didn’t fit the plan for war and then by damaging the nation’s intelligence community, both directly through “blowing” Brewster-Jennings, and indirectly through intimidating anyone who would dare to speak truth to power.
Another great post Redd!!
Thank you for all that you have done.
FDL seems to be an island of sanity on a sea of craziness.
I want to take this moment to thank all of the Firedoglake crew for their excellent work over the years on this atrocity. I have lurked here for years, used this site to stay current on all things Plame related as like CHS I had a good understanding of what happens when a covert asset is outed because of family that had been such in the 2nd WW and first half of the Cold War (btw, I loved the post you quoted from early on in this post when I saw it the first time CHS and thought it was excellent, and it stands the test of time well so far IMHO). I freaked when I saw this happening, I really couldn’t believe what I was seeing even from this partisan and political an Administration, as has been noted already what other example exists of political figures outing a deep cover asset for political purposes, hmmm?
Anyhow, I just wanted to let you know the work here is appreciated by many not just within your country but your neighbours/allies as well. Thank you very much for being a reliable, credible, and reality based place where this disgusting act of treachery is exposed for exactly what it is even if the courts are unable to do so as they should thanks to the games played by those involved.
Should checks be made to “The Fire Dog Lake Company”?
You all are awesome. What you are doing is what citizens do.
Tracy @
57
Yes, please…and we couldn’t do it without your support. Thanks.
check’s in the mail.
Try this version on. Haven’t heard much consternation about these events from you folks.
“You have to decide then and there which of the people you cultivated, the ones you promised safety in exchange for information and cooperation, which of them may have to die because you may not have time to save them all.”
“Why has your cover been blown?”
Because someone leaked the entire operation of your: (pick no more than three)
1. Secret flights of captured terrorists, including pictures of the plane you fly.
2. Secret holding facilities of captured terrorists, including the address where you work.
3. Secret program to trace financial transactions by terrorists to fund their networks.
4. Secret program to listen in on phone calls between terrorist leaders and their minions in the USA.
to the New York Times…
teeceecee @ 59
Do we still add the .07 cents for monthly payments?
Thanks, Sharon. The .07 is not needed but is always appreciated.
Powerful – we all need your resolve to stop the mafia criminals who have taken over our government.
Thank you all for your steadfast courage esp. Jane who I love and send best wishes for full recovery.
Olberman couldn’t have said it better.
Sent a contribution your way.
Change is inevitable; growth is optional.
It matters because we are a nation subject to our laws. Not when they are convenient to Republicans attempting to unseat a president they don’t like but because they require a certain decorum, a certain mode of behavior, a certain trust in one another and in our actions. The Bush junta has made a mockery of our laws and our Constitution. If Libby is found guilty — and all the handwaving and 4 hours of defense summation can’t change the basic revelations that have come out in this trial — then at least we’ll be starting down the path to a restoration of those laws. When someone talks about the Rule of Law in the future, about democracy, it won’t be mere empty rhetoric to bolster some underlying illegal activity that they’re engaged in.
Dear Jane & Christy,
Your passion, honesty and perseverance are incredible. You managed too, in the quoted piece above particularly, to put ‘human’ back into this… you made the truth an emotion and not just a debate. Thank you.
Namaste,
Tina Louise
http://www.armsagainstwar.info