The top three auditors of Iraq reconstruction reviewed $57 billion in contracts, one-seventh of the total U.S. expenditures, and found $10 billion in "fuzzy spending."
"$4.9 billion in 'questioned' or overly expensive charges, and $5.1 billion in "unsupported" or undocumented expenses," writes Dan Duray in the San Francisco Chronicle.
More than $10 billion of the money paid to military contractors for Iraq reconstruction and troop support was either excessive or unsupported by documents, including $2.7 billion for contracts held by Halliburton or one of its subsidiaries, Congress was told Thursday.
The three top auditors overseeing work in Iraq told a House committee their review of $57 billion in Iraq contracts found that Defense and State department officials condoned or allowed repeated work delays, bloated expenses and payments for shoddy work or work never done.
With only $57 billion reviewed, Chairman of the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, Rep. Henry Waxman (D-Los Angeles, Calif.), warned that the total overcharges and fraud could be staggering.
"American taxpayers have already spent over $350 billion for the war in Iraq," said Rep. Henry Waxman, D-Los Angeles, chairman of the committee. "There's $300 billion still to audit. The total amount of waste, fraud and abuse could be astronomical."
As the article notes, the audit highlights Halliburton's role in scamming the government out of billions, mostly on contracts that aim to "feed and support American troops." This would include things like $45 for a six-pack of Coca-Cola soft drinks.
The auditors reported that a Halliburton subsidiary, KBR, overcharged the Pentagon by $212 million for meals served to U.S. troops in Iraq, $100 million for troop housing sites that already had been shut down, and $42 million in subcontractor costs that were duplicated.
Halliburton/KBR is not alone. Parsons, the company that built a fraction of the medical clinics they were contracted to construct, was another major offender.
Another major contractor, Parsons Corp. of Pasadena, holds more than $2.2 billion in contracts for reconstruction of public buildings and oil infrastructure in Iraq. Of that, the Defense Department audit report found, more than $90 million was either questionable or lacked proper documentation.
Republicans defended defense contractors and the massive waste perpetrated in Iraq.
The witnesses urged the Pentagon to reconsider its growing reliance on contractors in wars and reconstruction efforts. Layers of subcontractors, poor documentation and lack of strong contract management are rampant and promote waste.
The Pentagon did have some support among Republican committee members. "Taking risks, which sometimes leads to waste, is much better than having a perfect paper trail and a bad outcome," said Rep. Darrell Issa, R-Vista (San Diego County). [emphasis added]
Rep. Darrell Issa's (R-Vista, Calif.) suggestion that the reconstruction of Iraq had a "good outcome" is tragically laughable.
The Army Sustainment Command awarded the first piece of the LOGCAP contract, that was originally given to Halliburton, to Virginia-based Serco, passing on a bid from KBR. Three more contracts will be awarded later this year.
Speaking of which, the former U.S. envoy to Iraq says the new reconstruction plan for Iraq will not work.
A diplomat for 22 years, she quit her job last month as leader of a Provincial Reconstruction Team — groups made up of about 50 civilian and military experts that try to help Iraqi communities build their own government while strengthening moderates.
"In spite of the magnificent and often heroic work being done out there by a lot of truly wonderful people, the PRTs themselves aren't succeeding. The obstacles are too great," Munshi said this week in Washington, where she was pressing her view at the State Department and to Congress.
"Once again we are proceeding to lay people's lives on a line drawn with faulty information. Once again the fantasies of the 'policy-makers' drive decisions without much link to the realities on the ground," said Munshi, who retired from the foreign service in 2002 .
Related posts:
- Obama’s First Rendition Looks Very Questionable
- Sen. Inouye to Join Republicans for Rape?
- Report Confirms Poor Electrical Work by KBR Endangers US Troops in Iraq and Afghanistan
- Costs of Iraq, Afghanistan Wars Proving Unsustainable
- New Hybrid Military-State Dept. Agency Proposed: Blessing or Boondoggle?





Spotlight








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

Geld!!
follow the money! and an on the money post!
Why won’t anyone talk about the $47 billion that *was* spent properly? That’s an awful lot of well-spent money to just ignore.
What I want to know is how many frog marches (of rethug profiteers) does $10 billion buy? We have to make sure that Fitz and his colleagues are kept busy for a long long time.
I recall Bush, thinking that ‘moment’ of accountability in 2004 was sufficient for his mis-rule.
It would be good to see that sound-bite come back with some teeth to it.
I was curious what $10 billion would buy in the real world, in order to illustrated the absurdity of $10 billion in theft and graft. Just a few numbers:–
- Annual budget, our local school district ($1.04 billion, serving 135,000 students)
- the entire public higher educaton budget of the State of California ($14.9 billion, serving about a million people)
- the entire corrections budget of the State of california ($10.6 billion)
- the entire housing, transportation and economic budget of the State of California ($11.8 billion)
We should just secede.
Eli @ 2
I won’t talk about it until you show independent detailed cites PROVING that some of this money was well spent. And even then it doesn’t negate the horror perpetrated upon the world.
i’m aghast that the senate dems are letting the meme “no money for a surge = no support for the troops,” when the obvious (at least to me) answer is incredibly simple:
create a resolution that will keep giving money to the troops but will suspend money given to pork barrel contractors.
nobody in america will deny that.
well, except the pork barrel contractors.
“Taking risks, which sometimes leads to waste, is much better than having a perfect paper trail and a bad outcome,” said Rep. Darrell Issa, R-Vista
This is absolute brilliance, no?
How about “Taking a gamble, which leads to money in pockets of cronies, works better than having a paper trail with a good outcome.”
skippy @ 8
The Bushies would just take the money away from the troops to pay the contractors, and then blame the Democrats.
oh.. more absurdity on what is it to lose $10 billion…
- The entire Homeland Security budget for Border & Immigration Enforcement ($8.7 billion)
- The entire DOD budget for homeland/internal security ($8.0 billion)
- The entire budget of the Dept of Health & Human Services ($4.3 billion)
And the most absurd figure of all:– the amount of oil revenue looted by Saddam in his last 7 years of misrule:- $10.1 billion.
In 4 years of fighting, we’ve lost as much, possibly more once the counting is done, to theft and graft than under the Saddam regime, considered to be one of the most mendacious on record.
skippy @
8
And the Senators and Congressmen who are beholden to those contractors. In my part of the country, the local economy is largely beholden to the Iron Triangle/MIC, what with the military depots.
‘Sides, I wanna write about more swimming pools in the Emerald City/Wonderland/WETA studios! C’mon, skippy, they can’t stop now, I need more material!! ;->
epu’d from downstairs — an idea to help any pro bono lawyers who need assistance with military law and benefits practice…very tentative, but I was hoping Christy might see it. I just got off work, so couldn’t respond sooner.
Double that number, $20B belonging to the Iraqi people, may have been wasted while the US government was responsibile for the operation of the Iraqi government.
Add in the untold millions of dollars looted during the earliest days of the war.
The scale of the graft and looting is immense. Much like conquerors of 2000 years ago pillaging their way through conquered territory, this time it’s under the banner of bringing democracy to the Iraqi people.
The world is watching.
How embarassing!
Thanks for this post.
I too wonder what the heck we have left in Iraq to show for the supposedly well-spent $47bn. Judging by Blub’s figures, there must be a really great educational system, health system, transportation system, corrections system, and more, much more.
In Russia people get in trouble with the law not for stealing, because it is assumed that everyone in power steals, but for stealing way too much. cough*twenty million offshore from a children’s hospital*cough
They have gone too far, hence the catchy nom de blog. New shiny thing at egregiousBlog.
Such a timely post of yours, Matt. I have just partially conceded in an argument with one of my children about the enormity of the theft, as to whether anything will be done. I remain optimistic, defiant.
[waving hey to eli.]
hmbnancy @
14
Only, they actually had something to show for all their pillaging. Much of the loot actually went back to finance the building and domestic programs of Rome. Much of this money is probably just sitting in Cayman’s bank accounts waiting to be spent on vacation villas and private jets.
I wonder how much of that ended up in Issa’s campaign fund?
MattO- another fine and illuminating post. If you are reading, please let us know how you are doing, and what your plans are. Your series of FDL posts on war profiteering is quite an opus.
P J Evans @ 18
Probably very very little. It doesn’t take much to buy a Republican.
Blub, I wonder if any of the MSM will do an analysis of what we could have had without the theft. Imagine what we could have done without the whole war? Without sending the fleets near Iran? Imagine.
Somebody ought to write a song…
V.G.:
Hey, no real plans at the moment. Just trying to find another POL gig.
Ah, Issa’s biggest contributors last election:
L-3 Communications $14,100
BAE Systems $13,100
Science Applications International Corp $12,000
AT&T Inc $11,000
Aircraft Owners & Pilots Assn $10,000
Allergan Inc $10,000
Edison International $10,000
National Cable & Telecommunications Assn $10,000
Siebel Systems $10,000
And down from there.
Eli @ 20
Ya, but you still gotta buy him.
AZ Matt @ 24
No such thing as a free lege.
Blub @ 4
It buys 2000 years of Russert, and as of this week 2500 years of KO.
Matt Ortega @ 22
Another POL gig? Meaning, political? More about what you are looking for? FDLers are an amazing source of info and encouragement.
Sadly, the truth is that none of the good things that could have been done for people in the US or anywhere else would have been done. There is no money for the war. They have bankrupted us with it, putting the onus of the debt on future generations without so much as a “thank you” to provide a private social security fund (of course there will be no federal social security) for them, even after they have worked their entire lives just to pay this debt. And without a raise of the federal minimum/hour to boot.
Valley Girl @ 26
Yeah, a political job. I am hoping that something comes through very soon.
Terry Olson @
9
That’s Darrell Issa for you – the guy who trumped up the phony Gray Davis (gov of CA) recall because of the faux ‘energy crisis’ engineered by Enron and pals, and made Davis (no world-beater, but no demon either) the scapegoat to insert Schwarzenegger into office. Anything he has to say I automatically disregard. He is a tool.
Further Adventures in Reading the New York Times: February 17 edition
Michael Gordon and David Cloud have an article up “Planning Seen in Iraqi Attacks on U.S. Copters” to which my immediate response was “Ya think?” The article is primarily useful as a retrospective on the seven downings of helicopters in Iraq since January 20. Gordon and Cloud do a better job this time around of naming their sources, except for one glaring exception near the beginning where they reference “an American intelligence report that was reviewed by The New York Times”. This report was almost certainly classified and raises again the questions of who leaked it to the Times, why it was leaked, and why now. Since this was an “official” leak as opposed to a whistleblower, I would like to know these things.
In any case, this report discusses documents purportedly captured from al Qaeda in Mesopotamia from late last year which lay out a strategy targeting American aircraft. Al Qaeda in Mesopotamia has claimed credit for downing only 3 of the 7 helicopters. For me, this indicates both a wider phenomenon and a loosely coordinated strategy.
Criticisms: The article conflates al Qaeda and insurgents. It never mentions Sunnis once, not once, although this is a Sunni strategy carried out by Sunnis. While observing that a variety of methods have been used to down the 7 helicopters: machine guns, rockets and surface-to-air missiles, it never delves into the provenance of the more sophisticated of these, the shoulder fired surface-to-air missiles (one of which was used to down the Marine CH-46 Sea Knight helicopter, pictured on the nightly news, near Falluja on February 7). This seems especially odd to me since last week was taken up with accusations of the Iranian government and al Quds supplying EFPs and other weaponry to Shia militias. Nor did the authors ask their sources why, if the military knew targeting of aircraft was being planned at the end of last year, it didn’t take steps then to modify its tactics but waited until 7 helicopters had been knocked out of the skies.
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/02…..ref=slogin
Matt Ortega @ 29
Do you mind saying what kind of thing you are hoping for? General area, not specifics. Also, I would love to hear some reflections from you as to what you have learned about the political process, etc. in the past year, and where you feel you can “make your mark”.
BTW, for those reading who don’t know Matt O., I first noticed Matt O. at FDL when he started his series of profiteering posts last year. Somewhere along the way he mentioned that he was a “student”. Well, I figured “grad student” at least. Nope, our Matt was finishing his undergrad. degree when he first started writing the series. I was bowled over by his fine writing and his impeccable research skills! I have spend 20 years teaching undergrads, and so I do have some perspective.
Kudos, Matt!
bg @
28
Then Hemmingway summed it up nicely:
“Some lived in it and never felt it but he knew it all was nada y pues nada y nada y pues nada. Our nada who art in nada, nada be thy name thy kingdom nada thy will be nada in nada as it is in nada. Give us this nada our daily nada and nada us our nada as we nada our nadas and nada us not into nada but deliver us from nada; pues nada. Hail nothing full of nothing, nothing is with thee.”
Valley Girl @
19
I agree. This has been a brilliant and vital series of posts. Well done, Matt O!
I have saved this (oh, like Libby, but on the “refrigerator file”) for a long time. Back in the day, Reagan wanted $3 trillion for “Star Wars” defense. I think the estimated cost for this mess in Iraq is said to be a trillion or three?
Ann Landers had a reader (Frank A. South, Plainfield, NJ) who reported that it would take 32 years (one per second, 24/7) to count to a trillion.
He said with a trillion bucks you could buy a $100K house for every family in Kansas, Missouri, Nebraska, Oklahoma and Iowa. Then you could put a $10,000 car in every home and still have enough money left to build $10M libraries and $10M hospitals for 250 cities in those states. Then there would still be enough left to build $10M schools for 500 communities.
And still enough left to put into the bank, and from interest alone to pay 10,000 nurses and teachers plus give a $5K bonus for every family in those states.
We are talking serious cash here.
Valley Girl @ 31
In the last campaign, I certainly learned the nitty-gritty basics of running a grassroots campaign.
It was the funnest job I ever had and working on campaigns is something I would love to do again.
In terms of specifics, either online work, field staff or a combination of the two.
Matt- I hope that you won’t be shy about calling on your “network” for leads and help, in reaching your dreams.
Valley Girl @ 37
You go, Matt! We’ll help out.
Terry Olson @ 38
Terry Olson- Thanks! I’m not sure I’ve embarrassed Matt enough yet, but he really is quite amazing- unlike many FDLers, not “older and wiser”, but “younger and wiser”!!!
Inspector Matt O remains on the case, thank gawd.
From a Times UK Article
in all, $12 billion in cash, weighing 363 tonnes, was flown into Iraq. On December 12, 2003, one single flight to Iraq contained $1.5 billion in cash, the largest single Federal Reserve payout in US history, according to Henry Waxman, the Democrat congressman who is investigated the funding.
snip
FRITTERED AWAY
$108,140 paid to contractor to refurbish Olympic swimming pool in Hilla. Work never done
$662,800 paid to repair Hilla hospital. Much of work never done, including renewing central lift. Three people later died when lift crashed
$40,000 gambled away by US soldier assigned as assistant to Iraqi Olympic boxing team on trip to Philippines
$2 million locked in a the bathroom safe of a US official
$678,000 stashed away in an unlocked foot locker
$473,000 paid for internet installation in Ramadi. Work never done
It seems Darryl Issa is often referred to as a car thief, although I don’t know if it’s ever been proven:
http://www.google.com/search?h…..221;darryl issa”carthief&btnG=Search
I vote that congress be supplied with a laugh track!
Well, I should have known that link was too long. Anyway, he’s a car thief.
Remember the President’s Speech back in Sept. 2005 about how he was asking private citizens to contribute to the IraqPartnership.org Fund? Then a month after it was up the Gaurdian announced it had received a grand total of $500!
Well that was so embarassing that a flurry of Conservatives decided that they had to pare their padded expense accounts and a half year later Iraqpartnerships had about $5000 in contributions!
That meant that it had raised less than 1% of the projects that it had placed on the site.
Well apparently the Conservatives have been so generous to the fund that USAID or the folks that manage the site have even failed to notice that the link has failed and IraqPartnership.org is really inoperable.
Conservatives talk with their money…and it’s pretty clear that Iraq is simply a pig in lipstick to them. They’d rather have the taxpayers ripped off…and embezzle their “fair share” of those dollars so that posterity can pick up the tab.
http://www.usaid.gov/press/rel…..50909.html
Oilfieldguy @ 42
He made his money on car alarm/protection systems. I believe his brother was involved in possible car thefts…
Terry Olson @
45
Didn’t he also boast of contacts to/links with Hizbollah at one point?
Blub @ 46
Do not know. Let’s see what we can find out.
The truly obscene part of this is that the auditing would find much more wasted money, except for one thing: the contracts signed permit such. Even those things that did get done properly cost more than they should have because of the contracting rules. Cost-plus contracts without per line item ceilings encourage layering of contractors–and that’s perfectly legal–note that the article only mentions excessive layering of contractors.
The lack of any real accounting systems in place from the time of the CPA means that there’s no way to determine the waste, even if auditors are looking at satisfactorily completed projects. And, the absence of auditing during the contract terms has meant that the money couldn’t be saved before it was spent. At a time when the DoD seized partial control of such projects from State and USAID, the DoD was also reducing the number of auditors available to the DoD. (Thanks, Rummy, sayeth the war profiteers.)
Then, there’s the practice of evading outside scrutiny by contract terms allowing firms–especially those privately-held–to withhold contract practices information even from auditors as confidential, proprietary information and you’ve got an unholy mess–just like the rest of the war, just like the rest of the Bush administration.
Add it all up, and I’d guess about one-third of the money has been lost, in one way or another, either by contractor-friendly contract terms, outright theft, lack of generally-accepted accounting practice and failure to oversee contracts during and after initiation of work.
Darrell Issa can eat my shorts.
Terry Olson @
47
Googling revealed the following rather amusing column on Issa by Debbie Schlussel. Of course, knowing Schlussel, this may all just be her usual creative imaginings, but given that she’s bashing a fellow rethug here, perhaps there’s some merit in her charges. Either that or her rethug penchant for racism exceeds even her party loyalty.
http://www.politicalusa.com/co…..el_003.htm
Agreed. There were no bullets in what I found. I can only say that he votes the opposite of my wishes almost all of the time.
San Diego, being a military town, in a sense, loves his kind of talk. Less and less though. I think a good opposition candidate could take him down.
Every cent, every life – wasted.
bg @
35
Yes, it is. Levees, physical, transportation and social infrastructure for NOLA. Free post secondary ed. Free healthcare for everyone. Any one (or more) of these would have been a far better investment of money and energy.
The “culture of corruption, graft and greed” Republican Party strikes again!!!!!
Eli @ 3
You’re kidding right? That’s like a bank robber saying, “Why won’t anyone talk about the 50 banks in the city that I DIDN’T rob?”
Sounds like a “War Profiteers” committee is in order.
Note to Dems: Balk and that money will be coming back to the Republicans in the form of ‘campaign contributions’ for DECADES.
i’ve said over at skippy that threatening to cut off funding for pork boondoggles in contractor’s pockets is the perfect antidote to the “they’ll cut off funding to support the troops” meme.
.
.
bg @
35
Thirty-two years are about equal to, not a trillion seconds, but “only” a billion (a thousand million). A trillion would be 1,000 times greater — that is, a trillion seconds are equal to roughly 32,000 years.
If Paul Bremer were to sit on the tailgate of a pickup truck in Baghdad and wad up and toss a $100 bill each second, day in and day out, for an entire year, at the end of that year after all of his hard work he would only have thrown away about a third of the ten billion or so that actually disappeared under his leadership as head of the CPA.
And ten billion is just one percent of a trillion.
These are very big numbers.
With kind regards,
Dog, etc.
god knows i tried