Okay, everybody check the bottoms of your shoes. I think somebody here stepped in some conservative comedy.
Yes, at long last, and after truly staggering amounts of hype, Pox News has finally unveiled its "answer" to "The Daily Show", "The 1/2 Hour News Hour". Neither of the show's two hosts are who we were told they would be back in December, so this must be "The 1/2 Hour News Hour, Mach Two", or maybe even "Mach Two and Three Quarters".
And granted, it isn't quite as excruciatingly bad as the three ladies of "The America Show" , but stapling your tongue to a rotting corpse on a hot day in August isn't as excruciatingly bad as the three ladies of "The America Show". Really.
Kerry Lauerman at Salon's Video Dog says of "The 1/2 Hour News Hour":
It's essentially a righty version of SNL's "Weekend Update." But there seem to be some obvious problems with that. First, "Weekend Update's" targets don't ever seem terribly agenda-driven: When they work (and admittedly, that's not that often ) it's because of the universality of the joke. "Weekend Update's" mildly amusing Barack Obama sketch worked because it snatched a controversy (one shaken by Salon's own Debra Dickerson) and poked at it in a hilarious way (much the way that Stephen Colbert had). Played out to its ludicrous extreme, all sides can get a yuk out of it, without any one side feeling assaulted. Success! But making fun of Obama for using drugs -- when he's admitted in a book and on "60 Minutes" to using coke as a kid -- is so cringingly ideological, you can practically hear Karl Rove slapping his knee in the background.
Speaking of which, are they actually going to use a live studio audience, or stick with these canned hams? Because there's nothing like a fraudience to make your whole knock-off show, which happens to spoof another show, really seem like ... well, you know. A fraud.
What, those weren't real people laughing in the clip? But...but...Fox News never lies! Next thing you're going to tell me that the tooth fairy isn't real and that Saddam Hussein didn't have WMD's or ties to 9/11!
Think Progress has posted a clip of the show's lackluster promo spot and some words of warning by the TV critic of the Orlando Sentinel:
Fox News Channel does not know how to do slashing comical commentary. The channel debuts "The 1/2 Hour News Hour" at 10 p.m. Sunday and repeats it at 10 p.m. Feb. 25. This show was meant to be a conservative version of "The Daily Show." It is a botch.
"The 1/2 Hour News Hour" does not comment on what is happening; it simply takes swipes at people. These people include Howard Dean, Hillary Clinton, Dennis Kucinich, Barack Obama and Ed Begley Jr. Other joke topics are the ACLU, Time magazine, children's books and global warming.
Laughter, of an awfully canned variety, greets all the gags. Nothing happening on screen justifies these outbursts.
Hey, I'm all for a good dig at the high and the mighty. But these satirists fall short of hitting their targets with wit, timeliness or punch.
Which raises the point: What is a comedy show doing on a news channel?
"The 1/2 Hour News Hour" was developed by Joel Surnow, who has given the world many minutes of entertainment through "24." On the basis of the premiere, Surnow should stick to political thrillers.
At the top, Rush Limbaugh puts in a cameo as the U.S. president (the year is 2009); Ann Coulter drops in as his vice president. Then they disappear, a smart move.
Oh, would that they would just disappear forever. Seriously, though, if Limbaugh and Coulter become the President and Vice President, shit, I'll join Al Q'aeda.
Fox News Channel will offer a second episode at 10 p.m. March 4. If we're lucky, we'll never hear of this dreadful show again.
Oh, come on. Don't be such a spoilsport. Surely we can think of something nice to say about the clip above, like, oh, I dunno, "It ends." But while we're here, I really don't see what the big deal is about Barack Obama copping to some teenage drug use when our current preznint apparently spent much of the 70's and 80's trying to put the entire nation of Colombia up his nose and then going out and driving around Texas like a dumbass. (Must be nice to have a powerful father who can scrub your arrest record, by the way.)
For the last time, conservatives, you people just aren't funny unless you're trying to be serious. Julia Gorin at her best is about as funny as a plantar wart, but all 72 of Rick Santorum's passel of brats clutching their teddy bears, weeping copiously, and giving the camera death-looks during their dad's concession speech? Hi-larious.
Let's go over this one more time.
Ann Coulter making jokes about immigrants? Not funny. Just ugly and kind of tragic.
Michelle Malkin declaring that a decimated mosque isn't "destroyed", per se, just really, really well ventilated? That's comedy gold!
Gay conservative pundit Doug Giles at Townhall says the following in his column, "It's Time for Conservatives to Take Comedy Seriously" (h/t Sadly, No!):
I know I’m not supposed to say this as a conservative and as a Christian, but Steve Colbert, John Stewart, David Letterman, Carlos Mencia, Dave Chappelle and Bill Maher are funny hombres. Even though I radically and fundamentally disagree with most of their content, funny is as funny does. They’re like farts. Most folks don’t really like farts, but farts are funny. Period. Especially, when it’s yours and it’s silent.
Uh, do what, now? Go on, Doug, I think you're about to make a point?
Look, as far as comedy goes, Mr. and Mrs. Conservative, you must bow and kiss the Left’s ring.
That's right, pucker up, bitchez! I've got something you can kiss. And it's not my ring.
But good luck and all. It's going to be really hard for everyone on "The 1/2 Hour News Hour" staff to hit the job market all at once come March, but you people on the Right always have your little think tanks and other Wingnut Welfare handouts to fall back on. I'm sure you'll all do just fine.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
TREX!
Okay, now I’ll go and get my noseclips and look at the linky thingy…
Thanks, Marion in Savannah, for the NYT columns . . .
Evenin’ kids!
By the way, YouTube is garbage. I wish blogs would stop relying on it. The media player interface is crude and unresponsive, and the way YouTube loads the video without caching is the worst way to do video on the internet.
Sorry for being cranky, but I’ve had to load the Libby Trial video three times now. And now another clip. Curse you liberal bloggers, heh.
but stapling your tongue to a rotting corpse on a hot day in August isn’t as excruciatingly bad as the three ladies of “The America Show”. Really.
at least your tongue will pull free after a few good tugs, or at worst you can bite it off
I think it has been said before, conservatives can’t do this. Don’t “get” the “news,” and don’t “get” irony.
So how could it be funny?
Okay. I looked at that. And some of the other links. Then I had to get out the brain bleach and eye scrubbers.
Does anyone at all think that’s funny? Maybe I’m just an old fart and out of touch…
oregondave @ 2
Oh! Wow! You’re more than welcome. I’m just glad that I can let y’all see what a doofus Babbling Brooks is…
conservative comedy = oxymoron
Joel Surnow loves to torture people doesn’t he?
Seriously, Fox would be better off with Baghdad Bob doing a straight read of the news from Iraq. Probably be cheaper too.
UptownNYChick @
10
You’re right… kinda like military intelligence? (Not the troops, but those who order them to do profoundly dumbphuck stuff…)
UptownNYChick @ 10
No, dearest:
conservative comedy = contradiction of terms
Rush Limbaugh = OxyMoron.
Marion in Savannah @ 9
Just don’t let the NYT sicc their army of flying monkeys on you…
Marion in Savannah @ 9
Yeah. Even worse than on The News Horror with Jim Lehrer . . .
Conservatives = fodder for comedy.
Twisted Martini, I’ve missed Baghdad Bob for quite some time now. Compared to what we hear from the administration now his reports were sober, considered, and factual.
Reminds me of the comedy stylings of Steve Doucy on Fox & Friends–or as Jon Stewart so aptly put it–Steve Douche-y.
It will be a pleasure to watch the show bomb and rapidly fade from the schedule….
Twisted Martini @ 14
Not to worry… I was born and raised there, so they can’t harm me…
its quite simple to explain why Bush supporters are not funny…they lack ’sense’, which is the first word in “Sense of Humor”.
It’s not like I was expecting flowers or chocolate, TRex, but egad, I wasn’t expecting to need my eye and brain bleach. Yuck.
it’s “answer”
s/b
its “answer”
back to read….
CityGirl @ 18
I’m obviously SO naive… We just got “The Dish,” and only the most basic of packages, so I’m kinda out of the loop… Is this thing regularly scheduled on a real (as opposed to Faux) network or channel? EEEEK….
thats so true @ 20
True, and, even more, to be funny you have to be able to laugh at yourself, and they take themselves way too seriously.
So much for that conservative plan to breed little creative conservatives…..
Suzanne @ 21
To clarify - the yuck was for the show, not TRex.
I see that it was at least in focus, so it has that going for it.
How will Faux viewers know the difference between their other 23.5 hours of news parody?
UptownNYChick @ 10
Who knew that oxy meant the same thing as comedy?
Well, my alarm goes off in 6 hours and I’m an old lady and need my sleep… I’ll be around in the morning with coffee, tea, and the NYT. Sleep well, everyone, when you tuck up to do that. I love you all.
OT and sorry to blogwhore, but for any Hoosiers in the thread, I posted a Valentine’s greeting on the new Blue Indiana community blog launched today. Its part of the 50 State Blogs Project from BlogPAC and I will be cross posting from my Monticello blog there regularly. Just wanted to let Bloosiers on FDL know we got a state blog finally!
Evil Parallel Universe @ 28
And what fact-free half-hour’s been bumped for this insanity? A 24-hour cable news channel is programming against The Daily Show? Mr. Murdoch, meet your shark.
UptownNYChick @ 25
Consider the case of William F. Buckley Jr. Teh Giant among conservatism; but his greatest ideas and postulates could not be thought of as anything other than stayed, stoggy and stagnant. The very nature of conservatism is to preserve what is and to be suspicious of change — it is the antithesis of creativity.
That, and you’ve got to be playful to be creative. Conservatives, as a general rule, were wholly unloved as children and wouldn’t know how to play if they got hit in the head with a baseball…again.
For Liberal Bloggers, Libby Trial Is Fun and Fodder
By SCOTT SHANE 55 minutes ago
Firedoglake.com has offered intensive trial coverage, using some six contributors in rotation
(WaPo)
Congratulations team!!
Evil Parallel Universe @
28
That’s a very good question, although I thought that You in Your Omniscience would have the answer already.
I’m not sure my TeeVee goes to Fox News- course I’ve never tried. I’ll have to take someone else’s word for the quality of the show.
That’s an excellent one-sentence summary of Faux News in general, or for that matter, of the whole of the right-wing political “strategy” in America today. No genuine issues, just mean-spirited potshots.
Oh wow, this conserva-comedy looks just like the “comedy” skit done for the homecoming carnival by the Alpha Betas in Revenge of the Nerds. Bad jock frat house comedy attempt, more juvenile and less sophisticated than what third-graders would do. Here’s one description:
Sounds just like the FOX conserva-comedy to me.
Actually, I wish he’d just go into the self-help lecture circuit. Those guys are much easier to simply ignore.
start_beating_around_the_bush @ 29
If oxy = comedy, does it follow that conservative = moron?
Okay, who’s starting the pool on how many episodes air before Dennis Miller is brought on to try and save it? Bahaha.
Left - better at Comedy…
Policy
Empathy
Diversity
Prosperity
rwcole @ 36
Yeah, I know what you mean. Like my amp doesn’t have an “11″ setting . . .
Joking about lies without acknowledging the lie?
TRex just discovered the mother lode.
Suzanne @
40
That’s how I figured out what oxy means.
puppethead @ 40
I was actually thinking why didnt they have him produce this thing, at least he has elicited laughs once or twice. Fuck, he was the best Weekend Update guy on SNL if you ask me. He must have either not been asked at all or shot them down.
The wingnuts hate the show. (Link if you insist.)
And in other news…don’t you just love it when the MSM finally gives in to the zeitgeist…
Unionizing bill advances; Cheney threatens veto
I guess that means the 25th Amendment is in play after all. {Bush section 4rd — pronounced “Ford”}
puppethead @ 40
Whoa, ease back on the stick there Cha Cha, or to quote Hieronymus Bosch, “What the hell is this?”
…funny, funny stuff.
FiniFiniTOOBZ! @ 45
He had a stroke or something from too much Bushmills. His comedy circuits are fried. Not funny anymore.
It’s a shame. There was a time when he was funny, but that was 25 years ago. The only way he could make me laugh now would be by falling down a flight of stairs or accidentally driving an ice-pick through his hand or something.
Farts are funny… hehehehehehehe
I think you are selling the shows chances short. Look at the target audience. Sitn roun n sipn koolaid. The title will be the problem though, setting the vcr for an hour and only recording a 1/2 hour and who am I kidding, they can’t program a vcr.
neokneme @ 46
Nice catch.
Shorter Acey: “I’m not a dipshit, but I play one on my blog.”
TRex @ 48
He was funny as recently as 8 years ago, during the Monicagate crap. He did a HBO special during that wonderful year from DC that to this day is hilarious to me.
Somewhere around 9/11 or actually maybe just before he went wingnut on us. I think he was having career issues and when pressures like that begin to mount on a guy like Dennis who made a name and a bit of money he wants to protect what slice of the pie he has left and that leads to wingnuttery. Its an ideology of fear and loss.
TRex @ 48
I’m not a New Yorker and I can’t imagine what it must have been like; but I’ve always equated Miller’s turn to the darkside with the events of 9/11. I’m sure the impact must have been greater for someone living in the city (I am imagining that he did, or at least held it dear). So, I don’t condemn him for his cowardly subservience to the right wing noise machine, I just don’t listen anymore, like most thinking people.
FiniFiniTOOBZ! @
46
He really *was* funny. Did zombies eat his brains or something?
TRex @ 48
I’ve read Miller’s funny was all from his writers, his entire career. But his schtick worked in the 1990s. Looking back at it now, though, it doesn’t seem the same. Either his act doesn’t age well, or I just can’t stand the wingnut lunacy he’s decided to adopt.
Miller is one of those people who suffered what I call “terror shock” (similar to Alvin Toffler’s future shock), where their world view was so damaged by 9/11 that they became frightened children hiding under their beds waiting for daddy to save them. Ron Silver and James Lileks are other notable pants-pissers who have just lost any ability to reason.
The NYTimes web site posted a story about Jane & FDL live blogging coverage of the Libby trial by Scott Shane - sorry no linky - but as we used to say in the old era - above the fold & easy to spot.
They could joke about Baptists at a non dance.
The happy authoritarians.
Greedy CEO’s and tax evasion
Fun with militias
Deviagra for cured homosexuals and hot tempered husbands
The happy athiest who sleeps til 9:30 on Sunday
Renee in Ohio @ 54
Nope. Ann Coulter did. It’s the only solid nourishment she’s taken since 1986.
FiniFiniTOOBZ! @ 52
Dude, did anyone ever tell you you are just a freakin’ genius! Love your ideas!
Renee in Ohio @ 54
Pretty much.
puppethead @ 55
This is why I love FDL. Only here could I find myself in a discussion about where Dennis Miller’s comedy, which used to rely on funny but obscure references to intellectual authors and artists, went wrong AND have a fellow commenter make a reference to Alvin Toffler’s Future Shock in the process of discussing Dennis Miller. I may have just had a braingasm.
They could joke about Baptists at a non dance.
The happy authoritarians.
Greedy CEO’s and tax ev*sion
Fun with militias
Dev**gra for cured homosexuals and hot tempered husbands
The happy athiest who sleeps til 9:30 on Sunday
puppethead @ 55
I like the writers angle, it would explain why he ever had a funny line; but, still, his timing was his own, and that was good.
That “pants-pisser” line is gold. Can I use that?
Hey, T,
I talked to your bro today.
finifini: Hey!
TRex @
58
So everyone’s in agreement.
TRex!
Evening all! I finally washed my polyester pants suit. (obscure ref. for fini).
And, how was YOUR day?
Not. funny.
Wingers just don’t get comedy. Or irony. Or sarcasm. Or art. Or music.
Of course, they laugh their *sses off at mean and vindictive and racist and violent. Good times…
SteveAudio @ 63
Woohoo! SA is in the house!
AP
Romney To Deliver Commencement Address At Christian Right Pat Robertson’s University
So you think you’ve had a bad day? Imagine what gooper presidential candidates have to go through-
8:00 speech to Jerry Falwell’s Univesity on the 5,000th birthday for the earth.
10:00 speech to Robertson’s University on capital punishment for stem cells.
2:00 Meeting with surgeon to have brain removed.
Valley Girl @ 66
{{{{{{{VG}}}}}}
Baptists think that pre marital sex is a sin- cause it can lead to dancing.
everhopeful @ 67
And fart jokes, never underestimate the power of the fart joke, Luke.
Hmm, conservative comedy… that’s casting Ron Silver as the lead in the “Charlton Heston Story,” right?
That’s Bush telling fart jokes to Kofi Annan when Annan’s trying to get his attention about Darfur, right?
That’s Sean Hannity dressing up Karl Rove to look like Heinrich Himmler and then having a half-hour discussion with him on immigration, right?
That’s a “Candid Camera” discussion between Tommy Franks and Doug Feith, right?
That’s like having Ann Coulter trying to lip-synch Kate Smith, right?
That’s like Rush Limbaugh singing “Hadji Girl” naked with an umbrella up his ass, right?
Or, something like that….
puppethead @ 56
I think Dennis Miller went conservative long before 9/11. If I remember correctly, he seemed rather down the middle for a long time, even after he left SNL. Then, he started coming out as a conservative comedian.
As far as the linky to this “1/2 hour News Hour” goes, I’m on the fence whether or not I actually want to see it. I despise and avoid anything Coulter does. Maybe I’ll check it out when I have an empty stomach.
Goodnight, all!
late to the party, but- that clip is just so… unspeakably unfunny…oh my gawd. It’s true- righties just don’t have any sense of humor.
Heading home, gang. See you in a bit.
More Righteous indignation… (don’t go there girlfriend)
Gosh, Tennessee can give it a death certificate (!)
Wow. Jon Stewart better start looking for a new job. Fascism is hilarious! I couldn’t stop laughing. BWaaaaaaaaHaHaHahahahahah! BWWWwwwwwaaaaaaaaHaHaHahahahahah! Ha!
Pathetic right wing loosers.
FOX 2-14 Today there was a major patchouli oil spill in the Golden Gate Park. DFH’s from all across the land are here to help wipe it up with food stamps. developing
Revolutionaries are funny- reactionaries are not funny–fighting to defend the status quo is rarely a laugher.
There was a funny 80s Miller meets 00s Miller–click here.
Anybody who thinks that Half-Hour show is funny should be declared mentally incompetent and unfit to look after their own affairs (let alone vote). That was the dumbest, dullest two minutes I’ve ever watched.
TRex, I thought you were going to go after Camille Paglia tonight, and I was looking forward to it. I can see how this conservative pseudo-comedy got in the way, though. I’ll just wait patiently.
montag @ 73
Ok, that one got me…707. Doing my best Dennis Miller, “Don’t go getting all Mapplethorpe on me now.”
fini #72! backatcha. I don’t have anything to say about “corporate” comedy. Especially as I am not a TV watcher…. not been for ages. Most of what I find funny is purely personal and absurd.. often laughing at myself. Like when I go to the ladies room at work, and notice that I’ve put my underpants on inside out, with the cotton crotch on the outside instead of the inside. That tells me that I might be in line for a “bad day”.
neokneme @ 77
Thats better comedy writing from a conservative than what was on display in that promo clip.
Sometime in the early 90s (I think) Dennis Miller admitted to voting for the first President Bush. I’m sure 9/11 pushed him way over the edge, but he must have been heading there for a while.
Frankly, this segment, at least, doesn’t seem any worse than “SNL” over the past 25 years or so.
Which is to say: spectacularly not funny.
Blue Dido @ 87
Miller’s just waiting to be old enough to qualify for entry to the Screen Actor’s Old Age Home. Captive audience and subsidized meals, etc.
The NYT piece tonight also reports Jane is moving to Connecticut - I’ve got to start paying more attention.
Anyone got any good pro life jokes? There are some real knee slappers about mothers murdering their babies-
See why conservatives can’t be funny?
Righty bloggers either want new day jobs, or they’re really afraid of losing their Fauxutopian mind meld.
newspaperbrat @ 91
News to me too! Assuming this detail is correct…
Valley Girl @ 84
Maybe that’s a day nothing particularly absorbing will happen.
Do you not understand the concept of the rhetorical question? (And that was a rhetorical question).
I’ll always be omniscient (even if Scooter walks, as I said in the last thread).* And I am feeling particularly omniscient today given that Schaller article parrotting my points on repug “marketing” failures.
_________________________________
* Plus, I have an unassiable argument that supports my omniscience. But that will only be revealed if I ever leave FDL b/c I get a real job.
Did you hear the one about the loggers who decapitated a tree hugger?
I remember his HBO show, he used to take potshots at both sides of the eisle in politics. I lost track of him around the 00s, and that seems to be when the change happened. It’s like he couldnt’ maintain the act the George Carlin has always kept his edge. Then again, Carlin’s out to have fun and piss people off. He’s usually effective at it becuase he doesn’t give a crap, and nothing is sacred to him either.
The minute Miller started taking one side too seriously? Is when he likely lost it. I’m just glad i haven’t seen him since.
montag @ 90
I bet his captive audience will turn their hearing aids off.
Blue Dido @ 98
And that would be different from his current audiences, how? :)
Link to the FDL/Jane piece at NYT site tonight.
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/02.....r=homepage
johnSwifty @ 62
Sure, go ahead. And yes, Miller had the timing to make the bits work. I thought he was funny back in the 1990s, but I don’t even like listening to his old stuff anymore. He’s just really become so unhinged that hearing his voice reminds me of his current state of decline.
(And FiniFiniTOOBZ! @ 60, I never realized that angle, it’s pretty amusing that I sort of went “meta” with my critique of Miller. But I am serious about my “terror shock” concept. I’ve seen a lot of seemingly functional adults become so cowardly and in need of the strong-father government figure to guide their lives since 9/11.)
Will Marcy Wheeler go onto this show for a book promotion?
John Swifty #95- hahahah! That is a great way to look at it! I confess, I previously viewed it as “okay, this is a bad omen”.
puppethead @ 100
John Dean’s Conservatives Without Conscience is right there with you!
Greatest oxymoron ever-conservative comedy.
-GSD
If you haven’t seen this before, there are some good laugh out loud moments here:
Unfortunate Valentine’s Cards
“Comedy is a dead art form. Now, tragedy–that’s funny!”
–Bender, “Futurama”