
Back in June, notoriously pudding-headed NRO editor Rich Lowry did a blazingly moronic piece on NPR's "All Things Considered" where he declared that the Fitzgerald grand jury's non-indictment of Karl Rove meant that the Plame leak was not a crime and that all us liberals were morons for caring. Yeah, I know. It's difficult to listen to, but for pure "Ah-hah, sucks to you, Lowry!" value, it can't be beat. It occasioned an angry letter to NPR from me and a plea to be allowed to rebut, but, of course, they turned me down.
In the Antarctic, when scientists want to study the air, water, and weather of ancient times, they drill down into the ice and take a core sample, which provides them with a perfect cross-section of each epoch. The Libby case is like an ice core sample of the Bush Administration's incestuous, manipulative, and deeply disingenuous relationship to the media and how they played the press like a concert violin in the run up to the catastrophic set of errors that is the War in Iraq.
We may or may not ever see Karl Rove in leg-irons and an orange jumpsuit, although that would be a delightful cherry on the cake, but what we are learning through testimony about the catty, back-stabbing world inhabited by our major media pundits is not only highly entertaining, but it should serve as a valuable lesson to reporters, writers, and editors who may ever be tempted to let their desire for access cloud their judgement in the future.
There's more to it, though. This case has a certain hold on the public imagination that has more to do with the power of the narrative and the characters involved. In some ways, it reminds me of a massive multiple-night Wagner opera cycle. There's a Great War, passion, intrigue, dastardly villains, and a few heroes.
In fact, if there are any composers in the audience tonight, let me be the first to volunteer to write the libretto. It'll be great. We'll find some ponderous, ominous baritone to sing the role of Dick Cheney and Renée Fleming will sing the part of Valkyrie Plame. And in the end, after the great battle, they'll all fly off to Valhalliburton*.
(*That rather marvellous play on words came to us courtesy of reader punaise.)
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
fitz
Let’s see how the MSM covers it tonight!
FITZ!
It matters.
NPR is not radical (left) enough for me these days. Oh darn. Am I not being objective here?
Watching “Hardball”. And I don’t know why. Am I losing it?
Much like the Gannon scandal, the MSM will sweep this whole thing under the rug out of embarrassment. I’m pretty sure no one would know this trial was going on were it not for bloggers.
Oklahoma kiddo @
6
It’s that or listen to Wolf say, “ahhhhhh” between every frickin word he utters!
Oklahoma kiddo @ 6
Of course not! David Shuster will be up soon!
Oklahoma kiddo @ 6
C’mon over by me, OK Kiddo, rest and let li’l Hil give you a neck massage.
Oklahoma kiddo @
5
Actually, they’re kind of sickeningly Center Right.
But don’t tell them I said that.
Why it matters…
Because criminal conspiracy has always been and always will be a crime. What is so hard to understand about that.
The problem with wingnuts is they have the Fonzie syndrome.
They just can’t admit they were wrrrrr
wrroo
wwwwwwwrrrrrrooooonnn
AP - Bombings and mortar attacks killed dozens across Baghdad on Monday as Iraqi troops set up new checkpoints and an Iraqi general took command — indications that the much-awaited operation to restore peace to the capital is gearing up nearly a month after it was announced.
Well now. Finally some action. This will surely win the war. I’m thinking of getting PO’d.
raven @
2
Probably won’t.
_
We may or may not ever see Karl Rove in leg-irons and an orange jumpsuit,
When we send him to The Hague.
TRex, you’re great. Thanks for all your writing.
Crazy Horse @ 10
;0)
How would the writers of 24 get Irving out of this bind he’s in?
Jacqrat @ 9
not soon enough for me
Jacqrat @ 9
get her a cool drink and a fan….
Mauimom @
16
No, no, thank YOU for reading. I could write in my diary all day and it would mean nearly nothing without someone to read it.
Dead Horse @
7
I dunno. So far, the interest of the MSM (read: cool high school crowd) in the lovely gossip of this case (”Russert hates Matthews - pass it on!”) is outweighing their vested interest in sweeping it all under the rug, partly, I think, because like the high school crowd, they live in blissful ignorance of just how pathetic this whole episode makes them look.
Plus Libby’s gonna get convicted, and then there will be appeals - we’ll be living with this for a while.
“they played the press like a concert violin”
Asjournalists, I wouldn’t call Novak OR Miller a Stradivarius (SP?).
But one of them might make a decent fiddle.
Barf. Ed Rogers, some “Republican strategist” up now. Big snore. Mark Green is pretty horrible/boring too.
Oh crap, and Tweety is doing a love-fest re Rudy. Plueeze.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 13
Just wait till “clear and hold” takes hold. We’ll have small units serving as sitting ducks in populated areas where our fire support won’t mean shit.
Nice metaphor about drilling the ice cores, T-R. Or was that a simile…? I can never remember.
David Shuster? Actually, he sort of reminds me of Pee Wee Herman, in a nice, not-unbalanced sort of way…..
howdy TRex! i’ve been missing you (not staying up for late night)… great to read you during the middle of the day. hope you are enjoying DC… thanks for helping to be our eyes and ears there.
You’re never fully dressed without a simile.
There’s some real estate developer in Houston now planning its next exclusive gated community: Valhalliburton…. :)
If the good Senator Lieberman wants to know how the Iraq situation is really going and what the Boots On The Ground think, he might tune in to this from McClatchy:
http://www.realcities.com/mld/.....616389.htm
Bring our people home!!
presque vu @ 18
I don’t know, maybe something like this:
CTU Agent Grouch: We have these recordings, they are showing a tag that points to a liberal bloggers site
Jack Bauer: Dammit Chloe, when did you get off whore island? Gimme the address on the bloggers and I will go rough em up
CTU Agent Rico Suave: Jack, go easy. These bloggers may be Natural Born Killers. See if you can trick em
JB: Go to hell Rico! I will prove that the bloggers have subverted justice, created this terror on our beloved Scooter and forged these incriminating tapes
(All Wingnuts Dancing in the streets)
zeppo @ 26
analogy, i think?
selise @ 32
It was a joke anyway….
presque vu @ 18
Easy, they’d have Jack Bauer torture him until he spilled everything about the rest of the conspiracy.
Or were you wondering how they’d do it if he were were on the side of the good guys? *g*
Former Fed @ 30
He doesn’t want to know. Glenn has his number.
TRex—
Didn’t know you were leaving DC so soon :(
Hope to see you yr next time up here.
I have been in hibernation mode and trying not to get over-extended and over-excited. [moi?] Resting up fm a fairly disastrous trip tho we did get a million out of the governor for equipment. Dollars not rubles. Disastrous in that between the hassles at customs, worst ever, and a strange man trying to get into my room, I had enough. I never really quit but this time was pretty close.
I remember telling a rethug co-worker that watching the PBS NewsHour should be required before being allowed to vote.
These days the fuc*er would agree with me.
Playing the press - The problem with that is that it assumes that the CM is innocent. No one was “played,” they all “play” each other.
The only people who are “played” are those who watch or read the pundits pundicate and don’t realize they’re watching a giant circle jerk.
Fortunately, most people probably do know that.
The pressing question from today’s testimony: Is “Scooter” really a common nickname in the South, or a personal descriptor?
Pssst oddball, over here.
You can tell me, no one else is listening. You write for KO, yes?
JEP @ 23
I think they were more like banjos…no one who hears a banjo can get upset at the music, right!
Glorfindel @ 39
It’s common for toddlers. ‘nuf said.
Bush tells us the economy is doing great. Tell that to the soon to be laid off 10,000 workers from Chrysler.
Marsha Blackburn said “77% feel like that we haven’t aggressive enough”!
My rule of thumb: He ran like a deer is a metaphor. He is/was a deer is a simile.
montag @ 29
“Now you can live in your very own private seaside refinery.”
OT - and EPU’d on last thread!
Biodun said:
John Forde, johnSwifty, and I are having lunch tomorrow at Sawatdee in the Warehouse District in Mpls, at 11:30. You’re welcome to join us.
Kathie responded:
Wow - I would LOVE to - but I unfortunately have to be teaching during the day! John,johnS, and Biodun - hoist one for me! Hope I get a raincheck!
Thanks,
Kathie
raven @ 44
77% of what? cockroaches?
RevDeb @ 48
Well, it was a Fox poll, you fill in the blank!
The Traitor Joe Lieberman theme song.
-GSD
One of the essential features of all wingnut arguments (like Lowry’s, for example) is “if we’re right about anything, it means you’re wrong about everything.” That they even try to make that argument tells you a lot about how often they’re right.
jeffreyw @ 45
Umm, that’s backwards. (Sez the English instructor.)
Senate Republicans are still playing shitheel games.
With a little help from Lost Cause Joe.
-GSD
You might have the Wagnerians heros in this story but the villians in this piece are third rate fools.
montag @ 52
He blushes like a beet,nay, he is a beet.
We may or may not ever see Karl Rove in leg-irons and an orange jumpsuit,
A while back there was some discussion of a case “Sealed vs. Sealed” which might involve Rove. Any update on that business?
jeffreyw @ 45
‘Fraid you’ve got that backwards, jeffreyw.
Tweety fixin to discuss “Scooter Libby, where do we find such men”? Right after the commercial for the anti-depression program.
Matthews informs us on “Hardball” that this (U.S.) “isn’t a fascist country”.
egregious @ 42
…and dogs whose anal glands need expressing.
Wiki says that Irving can’t keep his story straight on the origin of his nickname; one of his stories is that he was nicknamed after Phil Rizutto, the other because he was an active toddler. In all my years in the south, I’ve never known a Scooter.
Love ya, TRex!
Week two of Firedogging the Libby Trial is just as yummy as week one.
Wow, it seems like every time I try to make a joke, it bombs miserably and then starts off this incredibly weird conversation, e.g., nuclear footballs.
Now you know why I use the name “zeppo”…..
Libby. What a sap.
The trial’s up next on Hardball. Can those of you who’ve carefully followed the trial please give the rest of us your impressions of how this is going for Fitz’s team? I know we can’t know anything for sure until after the defense presents their case, but how do you feel about it so far? Thanks.
OT Via Froomkin, Howard Kurtz gives us the lowdown on the press. Apparently, we were wrong that the media were KoolAid chugging cocktail weenie lovers. Turns out they were deceived (for 6 years) by Bush and his winning ways. Well, Howie, that could happen to anyone. Did I mention that it only took the professional press a mere 6 years to tumble to this fact?
See, they really wanted to do their jobs. They really, really did, but gosh darn they just didn’t expect the Prez to feed them a line. I mean he gave them nicknames and everything. How could they know? How could they suspect? They were being played. *gasp* So now according to Howie this explains why the media has become “aggressive”. It’s not about them (and we should include Howie here) doing their jobs. No, it’s that they’re pissed for being made to look stupid. Thanks again for the clarification, Howie.
Mauimom @ 24
Chris seems to go for those “manly men.” If Rudy wore a flight suit, Matthews wouldn’t be able to contain himself.
Oklahoma kiddo @
59
Pro-fascist yes, full blown fascism is waiting in the wings.
Mr. Goebbels, I am ready for my close-up.
-GSD
P.S. Us troops will need to get a permission-slip from a foreign country.
“The only people who are “played” are those who watch or read the pundits pundicate and don’t realize they’re watching a giant circle jerk.”
Just call em’ “poundits.”
dab from CT @ 66
Rudy? A manly man? I laugh!!
zeppo @ 33
yeah. but i love, love, love analogies. did i tell you how much i LOVE analogies?
here is a great lecture by Douglas R. Hofstadter, (you-all have read Gdel, Escher, Bach: an Eternal Golden Braid, right?). if you think that thinking about thinking is fun.. this is the lecture for you… entertaining, mind twisting and humorous. highly, highly recommended.
Fugg Rudy
…it should serve as a valuable lesson to reporters, writers, and editors who may ever be tempted to let their desire for access cloud their judgement in the future.
Yes it should, but it won’t. I believe very few (if any) of the current crop of reporters, writers and editors have the capacity for introspection, let alone an ability to admit errors of judgment. For them, learning any lesson at all is not in the realm of the possible.
David Schuster on Hardball. Sounds like Scooter is really in a bind with his grand jury testimony. Cheney told him about Plame in June and he forgot all about her until Russert [allegedly] told him about it in July? Not likely.
hpschd @ 56
I emailed Truthout asking if they were going to write an update on Sealed v. Sealed (and whether Leopold was at the courthouse reporting or reading the transcripts). The answer was something to the effect of we think a lot of information is going to come out of the Libby trial. No response on the Leopold question. I, for one, would like some kind of explanation from Truthout. Their credibility continues to shrink daily.
neurophius @ 73
He’s caught in rather proactive affirmative detail lies. Guilty.
This Iraq resolution business is becoming a bit tedious.
The guys in my car club call me the Scooter, cause I like fast cars and fast women.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 76
Kongress needs Kaopectate. (For its binding)
jeffreyw @ 55
Umm, the first rule of holes is, when you find yourself in one, stop digging…. :)
How, exactly, does a beet blush? :)
Have you ever thought of entering the Bulwer-Lytton competition? I rather think you’d do well at it. [teasing just a bit here]
JEP @ 68
Hee hee. Well said, and welcome.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 76
According to McCain yesterday, voting for any anti-surge resolution is “a vote of ‘no-confidence’ in our troops. You’re saying to them ‘we’re going to send you over there, but we don’t believe you can get the job done.’“
When I heard him say that, I wanted to reach through the TV screen and choke him.
_
montag @ 79
It was a dark and stormy night, and the blushing beets were oblivious to the flashes of light that illuminated their ruddy faces.
Give McCain a break, he’s mentally ill.
-GSD
Did I just hear Matthews say there is “no one to the right” of Hillary in the Democratic party on Iraq? And a follow up; will Hillary stop the Iran (that’s IraN) war if she becomes prez.? And Matthews calls attention to Rudy vs. Hillary in ‘08. A battle between two war “hawks”, I think he said.
yellow snapdragon @ 74
Leopold has had some credibility problems, but I like TruthOut. TruthOut was the first online site that got me seriously interested.
BobbyG @ 81
Repugs are masters at setting up false constructions. It’s actually a vote of no-confidence in the policy and the people who dreamed it up, i.e., Herr McCain, himself. God forbid he would ever admit to that realization, no matter how apparent that truth may be.
hpschd @ 56
A while back there was some discussion of a case “Sealed vs. Sealed” which might involve Rove. Any update on that business?
I dream that there’s a cheney indictment in there.
The Colombia Encyclopedia, 6th edition, explains the difference as:
Many would say that the distinction is trivial, and Roget’s has them as synonyms
jeffreyw @ 82
Oblivious blushing beets. Yer on yer way to stardom. :)
beth @ 69
I am being facetious (but you probably knew that). Chris seems to develop “man crushes.” When Bush wore that flight suit I thought Matthews was going to wet himself.
Darling TRex,
some Lowry loopiness after a long day -
Rich Lowry - 5/9/05
April 06
September 06
oh and,
We’re Whining !
Rudy says being manly is a drag.
-GSD
Evil Parallel Universe @
38
Actually, they used them like toilet paper.
dab from CT @ 90
Rudy, a Manly Man. Yeah, right.
egregious @
42
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scooter_Libby
VG - Who does the “they” refer to?
And the “them” for that matter.
GSD @ 92
So as a simile … being manly is LIKE being in drag?
yellow snapdragon @
74
yellow snapdragon @
74
I am confident that Truthout is sitting on some VERY incriminating information. Some of it is uncorroborated. Some of it came over the transom and can’t be revealed - it would be too perilous to the person who provided the info.
The hassle over the Libby tapes took me right back to the Watergate hearings and the dispute over playing and releasing the Nixon tapes. History may not literally repeat itself, but it sure is self-similar (like fractals).
Senate votes against debating the Iraq War Resolution. Does this have meaning?
A note on the picture, please. Waterhouse?
Off topic -
Breaking news from MSNBC:
Reuters: Senate votes against debating troop ‘surge’ resolution
I would like McCain to explain how sending troops to die for a mistake and a lie amounts to supporting them.
Evil Parallel Universe @ 97
The Bush administration used the press like toilet paper. I was rephrasing TRex’s original.
Stephen Parrish, CPA @ 103
Guess which “Independent Democrat” senator from Connecticut voted to continue the filibuster?
Oklahoma kiddo @ 101
can’t wait for the list of the roll call vote. names to remember on the wall of shame.
it was just on a watered down non-binding bill (really a resolution that could be ammended) on the escalation. don’t think it could be any more mild.
jebus. we are governed by idiots.
Stephen Parrish, CPA @ 103
A cloture vote is usually described as a vote to cut off debate, does this mean that there will be a vote?
Leopold has had some credibility problems, but I like TruthOut. TruthOut was the first online site that got me seriously interested.
I don’t want to beat a dead horse about Leopold’s credibility, but Truthout has been standing behind his reporting 100 percent, to their detriment. I desperately want Leopold to be right about everything. I don’t think he is.
Stephen Parrish, CPA @ 103
I think this refers to the cloture motion that was just defeated in the Senate. So actually the opposite is true: no time limit has been put on the debate so that the resolution can move to a vote.
jeffreyw @ 108
It can also mean moving a piece of legislation out of committee and onto the floor for debate. That’s what this was about. Voting against cloture, in this case, prevents the resolution from coming to the floor for debate and a vote.
Stephen Parrish- happen to know who the artist is for the pic TRex used?
montag @
106
I can’t imagine… :)
Grassley on the floor talking about minimum wage. They seem to not want to talk about the war.
Ostrich brains.
Hillary is crushing her Democratic opponents. This poll guy on Tucker says Hillary “owns the woman vote”.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 115
Bull Sh*t. She can’t even rent mine. Haven’t talked to anyone who supports her either.