
Last year, just after the Sago mining disaster, I wrote a piece that haunts me to this day. So many of my relatives disappeared into the earth to work the mines, and so many of the folks who lived around them did the same, deep in the hills and hollers of West Virginia. So it is, so it always has been.
What I wrote the morning after we all found out that the miners who everyone thought had survived in a miracle were actually being brought out of the mine without a breath of life left in them, save one remaining miracle who somehow, by some grace, managed to escape with his life barely hanging on from the gasses that seeped out of the rocks through the darkness that surrounded them, lulling the men into the twilight sleep that has felled many a miner in our hills, came straight from my heart. From all of my years of watching these men breathe the dust of the earth, only to cough it back up again in a foul mass of blackness from their lungs after they re-emerged, squinting, into the half-light of evening at the end of their shifts. West Virginia is filled with working folks, with men and women who have broken their backs and their souls to make the company balance book tally ring with black gold.
It isn't just the coal industry, but many others in West Virginia that keep the working folks busy. And the opportunity to earn a good wage, with the risks laid flat out whan an individual makes the decision to work for a particular company, isn't some exercise in fraud (for the most part, although there is certainly an argument to be made where a particular company' shoddy safety record comes into play on occasion), but simply a matter of how much money one is willing to take in exchange for how much risk to one's life in the process. Not nearly that cut and dried, though, in the real world as it might be argued in the abstract, as anyone who knows any person who works in the mining indiustry can tell you -- be it management or miner alike.
But so much of our state's history and culture -- including the immigrants who swarmed here to work the mines from Scotland, Ireland and Italy, among many others -- that form so much of the bedrock of who we are still today, comes from the mines and the folks who worked them.
I am a very proud mountaineer, but I also know that this legacy of strength, of tenacity in the face of so much adversity and tragedy, was bought and paid for with so many lives in the name of expediency and cutting corners for profits. Accidents happen, certainly, and they are unavoidable in an industry as dangerous as mining has always been and will continue to be, but there are a lot of questions that need to be asked and answered about the sheer number of mining disasters that my state has undergone -- along with a whole ot of other states -- in the past few years as prices for energy have skyrocketed and the push for profits has led to some ricky decisionmaking by some folks who ought to know better.
And one of those questions ought to be why it seems to always take a tragedy of death or destruction before some changes are made to mining safety, when a proactive approach might yield a much safer -- and better -- result for everyone who works the mines. Mining regulation and safety is built on a foundation of tragedy, and we simply have to do better going forward before another fire or flood or gas incident takes even more lives needlessly in an incident that could have been forseen and prevented with a little thought being put forward earlier.
The WaPo had a poignant piece in the Sunday magazine that brought all of this home in so many ways. This single section is the story of so many folks that I know and have known through the years here:
Richard Crockett's grandmother ran a boardinghouse for miners, and Crockett's father had grown up packing lunches for the men and listening to their stories about the hard life in the tunnels. "It was worse back then," he says. "My granny had seen so many miners die or get mangled up. She made a vow that none of her boys would ever go into the mines." Like Plumley, Crockett, 51, had set his sights on college and a career. But after two years of struggling with the books, he dropped out and returned home to marry his high school sweetheart. Not long afterward, he was trying on a miner's hat.Darren Blankenship, 46, had once thought of mining as a temporary job, a way to sock away some savings until he could afford college. His father was a miner at a time when much of the work was still done by drilling beneath the coal and blasting it with dynamite. "You could see when he came home how worn out he was," Blankenship says. "Early on, he worked in very small mines, where the seams were 28 to 30 inches high. He would tell us how he would have to crawl on his belly all day and lean on his side to take a drink. I remember telling myself I would never do that."
But Blankenship's temporary job ended up dragging on for 28 years.
I don't often send you to an article simply to get a better understanding of who we are as people who walk this planet together. But this article is a glimpse into the world of Appalachia, into the poverty and the tough choices that have to be made to feed your family and take care of your kids when there are not a whole lot of choices to be had. While I was reading this, I kept thinking back to that scene in October Sky that I talked about last January...and wondering how many of these miners have those same feelings as they watch the light of the sky get blotted out by the darkness of the earth as it swallows them whole.
Take some time to read this article today. It is some wonderful, stark writing, and a portrait of my state in all of its many facets, wrapped into one snapshot of an industry that is almost as old as the hills themselves.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight



Support this site!
Keep
up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search


RSS/XML Feed
Fitz!
And thoughts of healing
FITZMAS
Have you seen the movie “How Green Was My Valley”?
Christy,
I still remember the pictures of Eleanor Roosevelt and RFK who went to see America and brought the photo journalists with them. It was as if each time for the first time the newspaper reading city folks saw that there was another America.
Even in this day and age, we just don’t realize what life is really like in other parts of the country. With our outrage meters running in over time, we need to be continually grounded and our empathy button pushed.
Thank you.
RevDeb at 4 — I thought it was a good evening to take a moment and think about this sort of thing…before the SOTU tomorrow. You are more than welcome for the read. :)
I visited your state once, Christy, and understand. I came from a line of blue collar folks, that came acrooss after the Irish potato famine.
I’ve known poverty too well, been homeless more than once. Yet even at my lowest, I knew I was better off than some of my ancestors who had no safety nets beyond a willingness to work, no matter how awful the risks.
More people need to know it and see it. Visit Appalachia even now. Go look at Mississippi Delta country and tell me what Third World nation it is.
And people take it, because it’s all there is. Not because they’re dumb or lack ambition. Sometimes, when you’re poor, you just find your choices are very few.
Thanks for posting that.
I strongly suggest (if anyone is, as am I, a progressive-labor type, or for that matter not) a viewing of the old Welsh coal mining movie, “How Green Was My Valley” is a must.
Thanks for this Christy. I’ll go read it.
I’m a sociologist by training, and I worked on a research project more than 20 years ago with Kai Erickson, who wrote Everything in Its Path, a study of the aftereffects of the Buffalo Creek flood disaster on the individuals and their communities.
Have you read this book? I now live in east-central Ohio, which has a large population of West Virginians, including some from the Buffalo Creek area. My experience with them seems to bear out Erickson’s observations.
Community is so vital to this area, and the flood and subsequent resettlement of those who lived along the creek destroyed their communities and resulted in illness, depression, suicides.
I imagine that the large-scale displacement of so many from New Orleans is having a similar impact. Especially when you live so close to the margin,family/community is vital.
Hey sports fans.
Pach! I just read your meta post–too late to participate in the comments.
It’s excellent: thought-provoking and informative. I especially liked your discussion about what I’d call the unintentional consequences of the small world journalists live in inside the Beltway combined with their lack of awareness of the dangers of this.
Christy; How do I e-mail a FDL post ? I have a friend
in Lewisburg who needs to see this.
OhioTex: thanks.
Didn’t Emptywheel take the liveblogging to a whole new level today? You should see her fingers fly on that keyboard.
I was like, um, yeah, I’ll get you some coffee. Or whatever you want.
OhioTex,
We’re probably neighbors, then, as I’m about 60 miles due east of Columbus.
Pachacutec @ 12
Oh my yes. I’m trying to figure out how to work and keep up with all this abundance in the coming weeks.
“Men going down to the mines” transcends appalachia- and the US- the tragedies (and the rich bastards who own many of em) are world wide– tough, tough, men- sad, sad stories- and sadly- they continue.
Margot @ 13
Sounds like it. I’m in Granville.
Just about every time, if not every time, an anti-labor Republican gets elected prez, it takes an awful lot of Demos to help the GOP do it.
Amazing post Christy. I know you’ll dig this, one of Sting’s songs that I recently rediscovered is “We Work the Black Seam”:
That post on Sago has popped into my head off and on over the year. I don’t know why, It just does.
That brings to mind that industry lackey that had to take lunch, and walked out of Arlen’s hearing with the celly in ear.
I’m still seething on that. Don’t have name title, just the visual and his exchange w/Arlen.
THAT bugged me. Big Time.
I recommend a steady supply of Snickers bars for Jane. They’re good fer ya - amd bound to make anyone feel better, imho.
DC beckons Jane!
CHS,
The poverty of place due to the unequal distribution of wealth will always force people into choices that are dangerous. The communities you talk about have great social strengths but not the economic capital they to provide opportunities for the next generation. On the reservation where I live young people who want to stay here have few good paying opportunities. Those who go get a good education often cannot find jobs to match their skills when they return. In this place family and cultural ties are exceedingly strong but with 50% unemployment the choices are few. Many times they must work out in a culture that does not want understand theirs.
Can anybody please point out to me how it is the DLC helps labor in this country?
Twisted — I love that whole album.
OT From today’s White House press briefing with Tony Snow, slim pickings I’m afraid.
On the State of the Union:
With his job ratings through the floor, Bush still can’t get enough of that boldness thing. He’s even willing to share it with the Congress as long as they do what he says. Oh and as for the American people? He’s too bold to listen.
On unity:
It was Deputy Press Secretary Dana Perino who used the word poisonous. Naturally Tony Snow sidesteps this fact and delivers the standard pap about working together blah, blah, blah.
My overall impression was that Snow was even more unprepared than usual. This may be because all of his time is being taken up trying to salvage the SOTU tomorrow evening and things are going badly with it. Snow said that the speech would be 40 plus minutes long and would be organized by theme. I suppose themes are what’s left when success is gone. Per recent briefings, Bush will not concentrate on Iraq but rather a moonbeam healthcare insurance plan, an immigration reform that will accomplish little even if enacted, and so on. All in all we should expect a performance os a Bush even more out of touch than many of us thought. You have to wonder about the degree of delusion in the White House at the moment and if there is anyone there who seriously believes that, at best, this speech can be anything more than irrelevant.
http://www.whitehouse.gov/news.....122-1.html
Small towns in places with no opportunity. My wife and I are presently hosting her niece, who is from one of those places. She’s a talented pianist with a BA from a provincial university. We talked her into coming to our city because she was going nowhere in her home town. Her boyfriend threatened her, and said he would leave her if she didn’t start having children right away (she’s 22). We’re subversive. We got her out here. She’s now got an apartment to share in the Plateau (the best place to live in North America), and a job offer with the Heart Foundation. Holding out for more.
The thing people don’t understand if you aren’t from there (I am) is that most people don’t know what opportunities there are out in the wide world, and so they settle for something among the alternatives they know. It’s easier now than it was 40 years ago when I was at that stage, but it’s still tough. To uproot yourself, and move to a place where the odds are someone will take advantage of you.
I have great respect for miners. I wish their kids had a better chance than they have.
Fine post, Christy. Your essays on the mining folks remain some of my favorites.
Pach @12. Liveblogging was a wild ride indeed today. Shifting back and forth between ew’s amazing posts and your, Christie’s and everyone else’s comments had me breathless, and I’m just a lowly lurker. Great work, everyone!
punaise-forgive me:
“Sixteen words and waddya git?
Regime change in iRaq and a bloody civil war.”
sharonhutton @ 26
There are no “lowly lurkers.” Just modest commenters. Welcome.
As a former steelworker, I can relate. I remember a situation in the coke plant where two workers got themselves into a life-threatening bind, and two more workers went to try to save them, and two more went after them. I can’t remember whether the total dead was 6 or 8, but it was all due to lack of safety equipment being in the right place at the right time. I believe it went something like, the company felt the gas masks and some other equipment needed to be under lock and key instead of where you could grab them fast when you needed them. They felt the threat of theft was too great to leave them out.
The mill I worked at was one of the newest and cleanest in the country at the time (this was back in the late 1970s to early 1980s.) I was a mail girl, so it was my job to travel thru different parts of the mill delivering mail from various offices to other offices. Once I was on a mail run at the BOF (Basic Oxygen Furnace-that’s where steel gets produced from raw materials. It comes out molten metal,) and I saw one of the workers working a train car full of molten metal with a remote control. I nodded to him as I drove away. Later I found out that something had gone wrong, some of the molten metal slogged out of the car and onto the worker. They said all that was left of his clothes were his semi-melted hard hat, his steel toed work boots, and the cuffs of his long sleeve shirt. He didn’t die immediately, but ultimately he was just too burned to survive. I can’t remember whether he lived for days or weeks. What’s upsetting is that the danger that these workers live with, and the heroism that they display when things go wrong, is seldom considered seriously by those making the six and seven digit salaries, the ones that wear suits and ties and go to meetings all day. They usually consider the men and women actually producing the steel just worker bees, especially when it comes to negotiating salaries or union contracts. Makes you want to say, “What’s wrong with this picture.”
Jane was lurking today too. Vive los lurkers!
Hugh -
I saw that ‘bold’ message, too. Had the exact same thought.
Y’all seen Cook, I assume:
http://www.cookpolitical.com/c.....011607.php
Diminishing Returns
By Charlie Cook
� NationalJournal.com
This column was originally featured on NationalJournal.com on January 16, 2007
It is now ‘on-the-table’.
And I’m in this one, I think:
http://zogby.com/news/ReadNews.dbm?ID=1240
Hi lotus, wherever y’are. And thanks.
Sorry for OffT
0o
Christy, thanks again for your evocative writing.
My mom and her family roots are from Logan, OH (county seat - all 6,704 of ‘em) of Hocking County, on the northern edge of Ohio’s Appalachian counties.
My mom’s family had second-hand tales of mine communities, but none went underground - the miners’ lives were as distant rumors.
Your writing brings that world up close and personal. Thanks.
_________________________________________________
Pachacutec @ 30
!Vive bien - y muy “long”!
(Ms. Parker would be disappointed in me. Mi “esquela alta” espanol se va.)
Christy -
Heard of these folks ?
Appalachian Center for The Economy & The Environment
http://www.appalachian-center.org/about/index.html
and for those of you outside mining communities -
dynamite is more cost effective than people . . .
http://www.mountainjusticesumm...../steps.php
fyi - Poster Boy for mountaintopping - one J. Steven Griles is in receipt of a DOJ Target Letter for his, um, work with Jack Abramoff
http://www.law.com/jsp/article.....9028147485
What is John Gaventa doing these days?
Stories about the mines are always devastating, one way or another.
It is so hard to escape, from whatever confining family/cultural history, and mining is really among the worst of the binders. Like the Lyndie Englands and Jessica Lynchs who join the military, for example. Then when it goes wrong, the W.VA. connection comes up, and immediately, stereotypes, the worst kind, come up.
So hard to escape. No escape, maybe.
cbl @ 32
fyi - Poster Boy for mountaintopping - one J. Steven Griles is in receipt of a DOJ Target Letter for his, um, work with Jack Abramoff
Griles and his friends are so going to suffer but not enough. I would like to leave them at the bottom of a mine. What he and the rest of the Bushies have done through the Interior Department boils me, ticked off I am!
Hey, look at the site meter-over 25 million visitors.
CHS- I lived in the UK for ten years, cohabiting with a Welshman. He was from one of the Welsh valley mining towns, which is now a ghost town. I got to know about the history and hard scrabble times of the miners in South Wales. And, for all we have seen, there is nothing to compare with what happened in Aberfan
Taylor Marsh does it again:
Clinton can talk all she wants about moving from “merit” to “need” in school loans and supporting small businesses, but her actions, at least on the web, say otherwise. I believe this matters.
Tomorrow, Senator Clinton has another chat. Someone tell her to stop shaking her head “no.” Even with all this inevitability blah-blah-blah it’s sending a bad signal.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/.....39321.html
OT- punaise, I dug out your email and responded. For some reason you were rated as “junk mail” in my U’s inscrutable filters.
Touching stuff, Christy. Great to see it in the Washington Post, in that some of the DC folks could use a reminder about “the poverty and the tough choices that have to be made to feed your family and take care of your kids when there are not a whole lot of choices to be had.” Folks are making tough choices like this in every Congressional District, as every one of the Distinguished Ladies and Gentlemen of the Congress could see if they would but open their eyes.
Yep. EPU’d.
Should’ve known.
Still need to make the comment though . . . because it needed to be said.
On to TRex!
AZ Matt @
20
Matt, I am not being facetious, I would really like to know how the casinos have affected the tribes in terms of net plus or net minus?
Were I to read Griles and his friends had perished in a Yellowstone hot spring, I could grieve for their families.
I’d also wonder why the Park let the limos drive so near the spring.
‘Cause that’s the only way Griles and his Gucci-clad co-conspirators would get near a National Park.
The only way they’ll see a Wilderness Area will be be from high.
When their volatile components waft out of the Park and into Wilderness.
Along with the credibility of all the other GOP cons, neo-cons, neo-liberal economists/economies, and other neo-fascists.
______________________________________________
And cbl - thanks for spotlighting the destruction wrought by dumping mountain tops into mountain valleys.
aka “mountain top removal mining”.
The good folks from Appalachia at Mountain Justice Summer welcome volunteers and contributions from all who wish to save local communities from physical peril and destruction inflicted by the usual absentee mineral title holders and corporate psychopaths.
In the early 70’s I was practicing law in Columbus, Ohio, and at lunch one day, I heard a group from West Virginia singing coal mining songs. One of them i still remember:
O Daddy won’t you take me back to Muhlenburg County
Down by the Green River where paradise lay
I’m sorry my son but you’re too late in asking
Mr. Peabody’s coal train done hauled it away.
The sorrow in their singing remains with me over 30 years later.
My father came from WV around Clarksburg. My grandparents came from Italy and settled there. All my uncles worked in the mines but finally left for Detroit to work in the auto plants just before WWII. My father was one of the youngest so he actually got a degree (the only one). All my uncles had black lung. What a tough life they had. There are many reasons for unions and OSHA. I hope we can reclaim what we have lost in the last 30 years for labor.
They all missed WV and wished they could go back. I think they missed the mountains and the green. Detroit was a big city and so grey in the winter to them. Jane Fonda did a film called the Doll Maker about the migration of Appalacians to Detroit and the cultural difficulties of the move to a northern industrial city. Another good movie about mining and unions was Matawan (I hope I spelled it correctly). If Americans really studied labor history in this country, they would be appalled at the corruption and colusion of government against the people.
Good post CHS. Plus I read the article you linked to. Amazing the sense of duty and accomplishment people desire. I waved a big ol’ hand as I drove by your town today.
I like good hardworking people, and I like intellectual professionals, but those professionals who truefully appreciate the hard working folks, without a hint of superiority or intent of exploitation, are the best people I know.
I count you as one.
Angry Black Bitch has a thing or two to say about “choices” - personal and governmental.
Members of Congress may moan and groan about facing tough choices, but I have a feeling that they know not of what they speak. ABB knows, and she speaks loudly and clearly.
My great-grandfather and grandfather worked the Welsh valleys before they came to the Ohio coalfields. My great-grandfather, who had begun in the mines at 10, finally came out of the tunnels and opened a bar. He did jail time for selling booze to miners on Sunday, their only off time. One uncle was killed in a mine; another injured. My grandfather died of black lung. I can recall the deaths underground of at least four fathers of school friends. When the miners struck for higher wages, most of the local mines were closed–and the wealth went with the owners. Many families joined the migration north to what is now the rust belt. Others stayed put–it is beautiful land which they love, but Southeastern Ohio has been struggling for years. I was lucky. My dad made college possible for me. But my school friends, most very able? Only one other went to college. This was a long time ago, but unfortunately, it’s not very different today. Such a waste of talent!
Twisted Martini @
18
I thought of Sting’s song when I saw that grimy face on the front page.
As for this tune:
.
It’s ‘Paradise’ by John Prine.
I hauled coal out of Bluefield east by rail in the 70’s. During the strikes, miners respected us even though they could have made things very difficult and dangerous. A few jack-rocks here and there to remind management, but a finer group of people I couldn’t imagine. Thanks for the article.
We lived across the border from Wales and used to take food every weekend to the Welsh miners during the year long Miners’ strike when Thatcher was determined to get them. After whining about how tought our life was I got see how tough some peoples’ lives really are. I will never forget those amazing people who stayed together despite the cold ferocity of the Iron Lady…
My Mom’s side of the family were immigrant miners in Penna, that stretch between Altoona and Johnstown (Laurel Highlands). “Dumb Hunkies”, along with their Irish and Italian neighbors, going down dark and dangerous holes in the ground to feed and educate their kids. I never knew my grandfather or some of my other male relatives. Work place accidents and lung disease took them before I was born. My mental images of them come from old photos, men walking home covered in black dust and carrying lunch buckets. These days, the mines are mostly closed. The hills in that area have the soft coal and are pretty much tapped out anyway. The men who were miners recently have mostly moved on to other industries, hopefully safer ones.
So much changed in the mines just during my Grandfather’s life. He arrived in the US as a kid in the late 1890’s and went to work straight in the mines, like so many of them did. The improvement in working conditions, both in terms of child labor, length of work days, and health conditions, were a direct result of the Union. Mom said that every night at Grace, they’d thank God for their food and thank God for the United Mine Workers.
As Christy has said better than I ever could, we’ve been backsliding. Bush has been breaking the Unions, dismantling workplace safety rules, and diluting environmental and health protections. We can’t let this occur. We can’t as a society return to the world my Grandfather worked in (regardless of the industry in question) and Upton Sinclair exposed (he was from Baltimore, btw).
angelina @ 46
Matewan should be required viewing for every American.
-GFO
And people take it, because it’s all there is.
Except for the fact that it’s not all there is.
They have a ballot box available for their use.
And twice in a row, they voted for Chimpus Maximus.
Because, I suppose, The Jeebus hates him some faggots.
My sympathy for the Appalachian downtrodden would be greatly magnified if they were not such frequent and enthusiastic collaborators in their own economic and political exploitation.
I know a couple of people who grew up in WV. They got the hell out as fast as they could. One said that in his home town, reading a book in public was and is a surefire way to get the shit kicked out of you by the local young toughs. That’s a backward-ass culture by anyone’s definition. (Just as it is in black ghettos. Wilful ignorance knows no color bar.)
Let ‘em start reading and voting in something other than a pathetically retrogressive way and we’ll see what happens.