
Taylor Marsh has a fantastic interview with a freelance photojournalist who is embedded with a National Guard unit in Afghanistan. Really amazing stuff — Taylor does a superb job with the interview, and their discussion is one that is both incredibly informative and also quite haunting.
Scott Kesterson is the name of the journalist that Taylor talks with in the interview, and what he has been able to see — and document — in Afghanistan is worth a whole lot of consideration. Scott has served in the military, and comes at this project from a perspective of trying to document not just the Afghan culture, but what things are like for the Army grunts with whom he is spending his days.
My project is one of passion. It is the realization of a life long dream to work as a combat photographer. Having served with the Oregon Army National Guard, 41st Brigade during the mid 80's, in both the enlisted ranks, and eventually as a 2nd Lt., I also have a personal interest in documenting this narrative. My focus is and will be the human part of the story; that element that too often gets passed over in the face of headlines and dramatic events. I am a strong believer that the real drama is what happens in the lives of people through the events of the day to day.
Throughout my embed I will be reporting the events as I see them. Through my words, still imagery and video feeds you will be able to follow the operations of the soldiers of 41st Brigade. The mobilization and deployment will be in two parts. The initial 90 days will be at Camp Shelby, Mississippi, where the soldiers will be in-processed into the active Army, and, trained and conditioned for their work in Afghanistan. In June, the initial wave of deployment will begin, with deployments throughout the country of Afghanistan.
Scott has followed these folks through the whole of their mission thus far – with a unit in which he had previously served, and Taylor's interview allows him to tell the whole of the story — something that we see far too little of in a lot of the abbreviated articles and sound bite television news stories we've been able to get from Afghanistan (when we've been able to ge them).
Scott calls Afghanistan the "Forgotten War." Please, take some time to listen to this interview. It is amazing, and Taylor ought to be commended for doing such a fantastic job with it.
And for the record, and not just because I adore Taylor and think she's one of the hardest working people I know, but because her voice on issues like this is sorely needed in a wider public sphere – someone needs to hire her and put her on progressive radio pronto. THIS is the sort of work that needs to be going out to listeners across the country, because Taylor's gift is in making this sort of story accessible to everyone on both sides of the aisle. And we could use that gift of hers on a daily show, reaching out to listeners and grabbing not just their intellects, but also their hearts. Very effective stuff — and it is a shame not to have her on a more widely accessible format.
Related posts:
- Doing it Right in Afghanistan: You and Whose Army?
- More Troops for Afghanistan? Faster Withdrawal from Iraq?
- CA-10: National Media’s Forgotten Race Proves Victory for Progressives
- Washington Post: Rove More Involved in US Attorney Firings Than He Claims
- Report Confirms Poor Electrical Work by KBR Endangers US Troops in Iraq and Afghanistan





Spotlight








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

christy!
merry christmas and happy-cookies!
has any outside country ever maintained continued military success in Afghanistan?
jayt at 3 — no, not really — but then, it’s always about conquest and never about building things up. But then, that requires planning, which isn’t exactly the Bush Administration’s forte, now is it?
how disturbing – I just realized that *I’m* very good at taking things apart; putting them back together? Not so much.
Am I a Republican?
jayt at 4 — well, I hope that’s not the criteria, because I have some difficulties with that as well when it involves intricate electrical wiring. *g*
Afghanistan today is what the wingnuts call “bomb them into the stone age”.
After 20 plus years of war with USSR and then what the great “smart” bombs which destroyed what little that was standing.
From the beginning my thought was that we needed to send huge numbers of units of the Seabees, Army Corp Engineers and others to build water, sewer and housing. THAT is how you win a war, the hearts and minds of the people.
SeaBee’s
Fitzmas!!
Coming soon!
Mmmmmm…more coffee…
christy – thanks drawing my attention to taylor’s interview with scott… i’d like to listen, but i can’t seem to download any of the mp3s. :(
is it just me?
jayt @ 5
or a 5 year old. ;-)
jayt @ 5 – In their younger, more energetic days, I used to refer to my silver tabbies (Bob & Ray, after the radio comedy team) as agents of entropy.
You have made me realize that this is George Bush’s superpower. Everything he’s touched all his life has turned to shit, so imagine a comic book featuring a brawny Shrub with ripped shirt and abs on the cover, tearing apart a 3-D Iraq, all titled George Bush: Agent of Entropy.
But please don’t imagine that if you’ve just eaten.
Mutant Poodle at 12 — Uh. Mah. Gawd. You made me snort my coffee…
Mutant Poodle @ 12
Hurl warning?
George W. Bush, Super
heroputz.Sower of Discord, Destroyer of the English Language, Master of Mumbling and Diss
aembling, MasterDebater, and the Scourge of Brush and Perch the world over…Oh thank you Christy for highlighting what is largely “the forgotten war”. I cannot stomach the spin constantly thrown at the American people by pundits and the administration that Afghanistan is a “success.”
It’s a total failure, and Pakistan and this administration are responsible!
selise– I can’t get the interview to play either. ;(
Thank you Taylor Marsh for doing this important work!
angie and selise — if you click through on the link on Scott’s name, it will take you to the blog that he’s been doing along with the photojournal reports from Afghanistan. Some very good reading there, if you are interested — and hopefully someone can help with the mp3 problems. As you guys now, I’m not going to be much help on that — but maybe someone with a better tech understanding could step in and assist?
NPR had mention this morning of the “reconstruction” monies now being given, by the people in S. Afghanistan, to the Taliban for “protection.”
George WTF Bush is FUBAR. Like the Midas of Sh*t.
The fields of killing. I forget none of them. Afghanistan, Iraq, Gaza. And there will be more fields.
Wow.
After a very hectic week where I had to have ConSec re-burn my CDs due to a defect we discovered, I just got back from mailing them out. So everyone who ordered them will have them in a few days.
Now to concentrate on performing my Holiday Extravaganza for the rest of the year.
http://teocawki.blogspot.com/2…..world.html
w00t!
btw gang — am putting together my usual Saturday round-up of good links. Anything catch your eye this week that you think deserves a nod and some exposure? Let me know…
Three necessary conditions for me to support any candidates for anything in ‘08 is to advocate a pull out from Afghanistan and Iraq, and a just settlement of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. Anything less will not do.
TPM has a good one this morning of myths & realities regarding Iraq.
http://www.talkingpointsmemo.c…..011590.php
thanks christy and angie – i left taylor a comment (if both angie and i are having problems, we’re probably not the only people). hope to get to listen later…
Cheney distancing himself from Bush on Iraq. Since ‘the Dick’ will never run for anything else, one might think it would be the other way ’round. U.S. News and World Report. I think.
I found this article submitted by Dru earlier this week fascinating (in a horrid fascination kind of way) and incredibly, sadly, true.
http://www.realclearpolitics.c…..istan.html
Oklahoma kiddo @ 25
Cheney Burrows as Bush Ponders Iraq
Condi says Baker wants Iran to have nukes…
http://americablog.blogspot.co…..ry-of.html
yeah, she’s presidential material…
The NATO coalition is disintegrating: only Canada and Britain are operating in the south, where the US is concentrated. The other countries won’t deploy forces there.
With a spring election in Canada, it seems likely that the new government will be less committed to operations in Afghanistan. Who knows what’s next in British politics and foreign relations, but NOBODY is as hawkish as Blair.
The US is about to be isolated as an occupying force without allies in yet another arena.
So where did Lincoln Chafee go? K Street?
NO.
http://www.thewashingtonnote.com/
gotta give credit where credit is due.
He also cares a lot about Afghanistan, Iraq and Palestine and our use and abuse of our soldiers and our reputation in the world.
angie @
30
Senator Webb was once a more conservative Republican type. And, in point of fact, the democracy concept in this country works well when there are intelligent discussions and debate with conservation minded folks who tend to lean towards maintaining the status quo. It hones the arguments, as to why move off the status quo, to a finer point. An important purpose is served.
Progressive ideas cannot exist in a vacuum. They need to be rooted in the reality of a current circumstance as a starting point in order to show the direction in which to progress, and conservative opinion aids in defining ‘current circumstance.’ That is also a crucial element that has been missing from America’s political discourse for the last six years, (and before, since 1994, really).
As a liberal, free thinking individual, I am constantly amazed at how narrow minded the conservative view point is; but — and this happens more and more of late — I am made aware that true conservatism would not have lead us to where we are today. Sure, it is not nearly as free wheeling, socially conscious, environmentally concerned and education centric as I would like; but, conservatism in the good old William F. Buckley vein would have taken a very dim view of engaging in the Afghan conflict, much less ever starting the Iraq war.
All this cycles back to Mr. Chafee. If he were to enter public service again, having learned lessons and thereby expanding his perspective towards more socially aware concepts, he might not be a bad guy. I’m not saying he would be Jim Webb, necessarily, but who else could be.
Christy Hardin Smith @ 21
this may not be appropriate for your round up (it’s multiple hours of mp3s)… but it’s something that has little exposure and i expect would be of interest to fdl’ers. i especially recommend mark danner’s and philip zimbardo talk.
it’s from the event, Thinking Humanity After Abu Ghraib, on oct 19 & 20 at stanford university, although the podcasts weren’t available until this month.
some of the speakers were:
Seymour Hersh – “Chain of Command: The Road from 9/11 to Abu Ghraib”
Mark Danner – “Into the Light of Day: Human Rights after Abu Ghraib”
David J. Luban and Jenny S. Martinez – “The Poisoned Chalice: Humanity at Nuremberg and Now”, “The Law of Torture”
Philip G. Zimbardo and Gerald Gray – “The Lucifer Effect: Understanding How Good People Turn Evil”, “Torture Policy at Abu Ghraib: Military Use of Science for the Control of the Country”
available via stanford podcasts (either itunes or rss).
itunes: go to this link, click on “open stanford itunes”, in itunes click on “heard on campus” and then select “visiting lectures and speeches”.
alternative link for rss feeds. you’ll have to scroll down to choose the podcast by title (not speaker).
jayt @ 28
And here I thought Kindasleezy was some kind of Soviet/Cold War expert. Surely she knows that we didn’t come out of that period by sticking our fingers and singing loudly whenever the subject of diplomacy came up. Stupid chimpsucker.
EvilDrPuma @ 33
…in our ears…
johnSwifty @ 31– agreed.
Basically, Chafee is more correct than most (conservatives and dems) on foreign policy issues, imho.
thanks, selise for those links at 32!
CHS–Alternet has a couple of things today. One on robo calls in Baghdad, one on Apocalypto.
i realize my directions to the podcasts above are kinda complicated. here’s some direct links to the mp3s:
mark danner – m4a
philip zimbardo – m4a
This is more like it, Democrats.
Incoming Chairmen Ready to Investigate
Democratic-Led Panels to Probe Administration’s Actions in War and Counterterrorism
http://www.washingtonpost.com/…..01680.html
Thanks for the comments on my dive video. My wife and kids have seen it all so often that they run from the room when I’m working on it.
Mr. Ray
Rumor is there is a new Al Qaeda video out that makes the claim that Osama Bin Laden was inspired by the writings of Michael Crichton.
-GSD
OK-Kiddo, Woo Hoo!! I hope we have lotsa hearings, lotsa oversight. Lotsa smart questions for these thugs who have hijacked our democracy and thrust their misguided thinking onto the world with such terrible fury.
May they twist in the wind for the next two years.
CHS — This link is a week old but is still a valid opinion from middle America concerning the ISG report. Some of the more interesting aspects are in the response comments — showing how parts of middle America still react to these circumstances.
It fits my personal criteria for an important link in that it includes the prescience of RFK and a Sophocles quote. It just doesn’t get any better than that…you’d think it would…but it doesn’t.
I want investigations into AIPAC and this groups influence on elected American officials and money flow from AIPAC to these officials. I want investigations into why the U.S. government allowed the invasion of Lebanon.
Aw, crap. I missed the happy, feel-good thread about cookies, and got here in time for the depressing thread about Afghanistan, the country where arrogant world powers go to die.
And I have good cookie recipes, too.
johnSwifty @ 42
“There is a prophet for our times, but you don’t know him. His name is Yeshua.”
How…interesting. I wasn’t aware that the subject of the American presence in Iraq was addressed in the Gospels. What a chimpsucker.
cleter @ 43
ROFLMAO! I don’t think I’ve ever heard Afghanistan’s role in global politics so neatly described.
Fresh thread, chock full o’ links.
EvilDrPuma @
34
i don’t know where that “Soviet expert” meme started, but she was jibber-jabering about what a serious threat the Soviet Union was right up to the moment it burst like a soap bubble. Every major pronouncement she made about the USSR was, in fact, remarkably wrong. She was wrong like the 1930’s Republicans who said Chancellor Hitler was a stern-but-fair guy with whom we could deal. In the run-up to Iraq, on Tim Russert’s show, she said that containment had of the USSR had been a mistake and we should in fact have attacked them in 1948 or so. Russert just stared at her goggle-eyed. After all, that attacking the USSR thing has worked out really well for everybody else who had tried it. Just ask Hitler!
She is not a Soviet expert. She is technically what we refer to as “an idiot.”
GSD @ 40
I would have bet on another hack, Tom Clancy (disclosure: I’ve read a lot of Clancy and didn’t hate every minute of it), but Crichton is one of those rare instances of some minute talent being in exactly the right place at exactly the right time. Any thing which moves Crichton down a notch or two in the course of this generation’s public estimation, can only aid in history thinking better of us. Now, if we can just manage to insure that Tom Cruise never gets another award for ‘acting,’ I think we will go even further towards restoring our credibility as a society.
EvilDrPuma @ 44
I know! But don’t kid yourself, fundies quote whole swaths of Jeremiah and show how the events of the ‘prophecy’ (which was some 2000 year old version of Moab, in the prophet’s vision) are occurring today. It’s scary stuff, but it is a part of the religious base’s thought process. If you ever wonder who or what comprises the foolish 30% who still thinks Bush is an act of God, those are the folks.
Now, I don’t know anything about this Yeshua guy and I’m not going to look into it — there’s enough false prophets in the world today without rooting more out.
Interesting that nothing in the WP article involved plans by Senate Foreign Relations Committee (Biden Chair) regarding his planned 8 weeks of hearings.
Back in 2002 when the Democrats briefly controlled the Senate, Foreign Relations had a sub-committee on South-Central Asia (I think that was the designation) that dealt with Pakistan and Afghanistan. Paul Wellstone was the Sub-Committee Chair for a brief time. If we are bothered by State and AID’s efforts in Afghanistan, we ought to bring some pressure on Biden to include in his plans for hearings, a set of sub-committee oversight hearings on the matters set out in Barnett Rubin’s rather clear and to the point article. We need to be smart about this — hearings are not just for the purpose of looking at deliquency — they are also about change, in this instance, probably a change in the appropriations and authorizations for State and AID programs. Then we need to make certain there is a continued interest in these programs from a broad enough strata within the American activist community, that they get oversight, evaluation, and general support over a number of years.
People may not realize, but once upon a time we actually had the Peace Corps in Afghanistan doing rural development work. The first projects went in late 1962 — early 1963, and they stayed about ten years, mostly building clinics, ag training schools, a sort of “county agent” extension service for small and medium sized farmers, and some construction projects done coordinated with AID projects, mostly aimed at irrigation. Some of the best “joy” for the reputation of the US derives from these projects — and it would be nice if first of all Americans could learn about what we once did, and that in many cases actually was of value — and demand an intelligent analysis of whether something similar could be done again.
One upshot of an old Peace Corps project was that the University of California at Davis acquired the genetic material for Fruit Trees and grape culture that had been selected over a very long period (perhaps a thousand years) suited to Afghani conditions and soils. They have the capacity to essentially regenerate the fruit culture, a culture that was largely destroyed by the wars in the 1980’s and 1990’s. I’ve tried to follow the funding for what is known in AID circles as the Roots project — and it is off again, on again and just barely funded. What’s needed of course is the building of nursery facilities in Afghanistan, training of workers, and eventually working with farmers to rebuild this sector of the ag system. (for a thousand years Afghanistan exported fresh cold weather fruit to the Ganges valley in India, — all the way to Calcutta — as a major source of income and exchange.) We are talking Melon, Cherries, Nectarines, Plums, Grapes, and a huge range of pears and apples. But re-establishing the vines and orchards is not short term aid. It will take 10-15 years to bring a newly planted orchard to production — thus the importance of nursery facilities. It will also require the rebuilding of the irrigation systems which conserve and deliver snow melt to the crops. I’d like to see congress knowing enough to ask pointed and detailed questions about such projects.
iirc, Afghanistan’s produce was second to none, with fruits and veg bursting with flavor and delicacy.
Thanks, Sara– it is important that the history modern Afghanistan be known– it was truly on the cutting edge during the reign of Zahir Shah and the democratic legislature.
From an article in 2002(!)
the seed bank issue is enormous: