
The animated movie Happy Feet soared to the top of the box office receipts the first week it was released, with parents only too happy to take their kids to an animated movie that features penguins. As we all know, penguins are everyone's favorite formally dressed bird, and possibly the one animal that makes everyone who ever felt awkward feel that they are not alone. Even better, the star of Happy Feet is a cute oddball of a penguin that dances like Gregory Hines, while all the other penguins of his species establish their identities and attract friends and mates by singing. All of us know how it feels to be an outcast in some way.
Kids and parents alike seem to love this movie — the theater was filled with families with young children when I saw it recently — and it's probably because these types of animated films have funny scenes and hilarious dialogue and feature the voices of familiar stars, in this case, Robin Williams, Elijah Woods, Hugh Jackman, Brittany Murphy and Nicole Kidman. And there's a fun soundtrack with one great soul or salsa song after another, but that's getting ahead of the story.
I don't usually go to these movies. My kids are grown and gone, and I saw enough emperor penguins in that exhausting penguin documentary. No, I went to this movie because CNN's Glenn Beck and Fox News told me not to go.
You see, the Protectors of Family Values at Fox had warned me that Happy Feet was nothing more than barely subtle liberal propaganda, disguised as a cute, innocent family movie. That sounded promising, because if anyone understands subtle propaganda disguised as something innocent, it's the folks at Fox "News." Steve at Crooks and Liars thinks this is just silly, [check out the original link to see the embedded links] and from one perspective, he's right:
. . . conservatives believe the cartoons are part of some nefarious liberal plot. CNN Headline News' Glenn Beck, for example, railed against the animated film Happy Feet this week, calling it "propaganda" and an "animated version of An Inconvenient Truth." Discussing the movie with Bob Thompson, director of the Center for the Study of Popular Television, Beck went on quite a tirade.
Similarly, Fox News' Neil Cavuto whined incessantly about the movie this week, calling Happy Feet "offensive," "big-time objectionable," and "far left" political propaganda. Of course, it's not just this movie. From Tinky Winky to Shrek, Shark Tale to SpongeBob, conservatives seem to have an unhealthy fixation on the alleged dangers lurking in animation.
But I think Beck and Cavuto are also right, at least from their right-wing point of view.
I can happily report that Happy Feet is possibly the funniest subversive, liberal/progressive movie this year. It's got many issues liberals love and conservatives hate: environmental harm caused by indifferent corporate greed and industrialization, dangers of overfishing and global warming, dependence on oil, ethnic stereotyping, religious fundamentalism revealed as extremism, fact-finding science confronting faith-based beliefs, and the sin of casting those who are different as both subversive and morally wrong. There are even scenes depicting renditions and psychological torture as shameful. My goodness! This will not become the neotheocon's favorite flick.
From Fox's perspective, it probably seems even more dangerously subversive than the revolutionary movie V, not because we see penguins blowing up the British Parliament buildings after the fall of a fear-mongering Emperor Penguin, but because the not-so-subtle messages of Happy Feet are aimed at children, innocent, unsuspecting children, whose parents think they're just bringing their kids to watch a cute kids movie about penguins.
If you're a Glen Beck/Fox fan, it's easy to see the risks of movies like this. Those liberal bastards are going after our kids! or so it must seem to them. No matter how hard they work to purify the school curriculum and make sure that only appropriate materials are provided to schools, or rescue them through home schooling, they just can't seem to shield their children from this propaganda. Subversive messages are everywhere, even on popular PBS kids programming that feature cartoon aardvarks condoning lesbians, for heaven's sakes. And will the NRA ever trust Walt Disney again after Bambi?
The risks to Fox' viewers of allowing children to see this perversity may increase as parents are forced to explain to young inquiring minds why people are doing all those awful things to these cute, hip penguins who dance and sing soul and salsa. And there's the ever present danger that unprepared parents might not yet know how to deal with those questions about such liberal myths as global warming. Before you know it, the kids will be clamoring to get their parents to take them to see [gulp] An Inconvenient Truth and asking to watch the "big bang" and evolution reruns of Carl Sagan's Cosmos. No wonder Fox finds it necessary to warn parents. Their kids may soon be wearing buttons that say "Penguins and Kids for Gore."
Some liberals, of course, are upset at Senator Hillary Clinton, because she planned to spend the day after the release of the Iraq Study Group report warning parents not about the unspeakable violence of the Iraq policies she embraced but rather to be careful about the violent content of video games.
I understand parents have to make choices about what their young children see. So my advice is, "teach your children well." Go see Happy Feet, and if you don't have kids of your own, take your nephews and nieces and cousins, and their kids and neighbors, and then sit down when they're ready and talk to them about other inconvenient truths.
Related posts:
- An Offended Mother on President Obama’s Speech to School Kids
- Can white liberals keep their eye on the prize when racism comes a knockin?
- Brave Conservatives Battle to Rescue Your Children from Obama’s Sinister Cult of Learning
- Late Night: Fox & Friends Have No Clue About School
- Liberals Need a 12 Step Program – We Ask Taibbi What We Should Do Next





Spotlight








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

Scarecrow!
Hi scarecrow! Just started reading – what a great post.
Thanks!
speaking of penguins and polar bears;
in the NYTImes tomorrow
Arctic Ice Melting Faster Than Expected
By ANDREW C. REVKIN
Published: December 11, 2006
New studies project that the Arctic Ocean could be mostly open water in summer by 2040 — several decades earlier than previously expected — partly as a result of global warming caused by emissions of greenhouse gases.
The projections come from computer simulations of climate and ice and from direct measurements showing that the amount of ice coverage has been declining for 30 years.
Do you mean Z or V?
Scarecrow!!
Cool, another subversive teaching opportunity. I’m takin’ the Sprout.
I thought the same about Robots, another Robin Williams-voiced cartoon. Dangerous, the message that the world isn’t always the way it is portrayed in inspirational stories and on picture postcards.
So wonderful to see you and Hugh frontpaged with all of your wisdom and skill, scarecrow!
well done and thought out as usual, sir.
i think you mean V, and not Z.
just sayin’, cuz it’s my fav movie.
Ah, grasshopper, Z was the V of our generation.
I always thought “cartoonish” critters were meant to tickle my funny bone.
Ya know, critters like Mickey Mouse, Huey, Dewey and Louie, even Bugs Bunny.
Who knew they were really crypto-subversive-terrorist-lovin’ malcontents?
I never knew that wingnuts grew up bein’ skeered of these critters. Kinda ’splains why they’re all members of the NRA.
If I had nightmares as a child of rabid lambs, maniacal bunnies or demonic teddy bears, I too could have become a Repug.
Now Fritz the Cat however…
“Z for Zed-Etna” …it’s explosive!
scarecrow, roaming the front page!
He may dance like Gregory Hines- but they did motion-capture of Savion Glover to animate it.
Credit where credit is due.
Evening folks. Was wondering where this post went. Thought I lost it! Must be the elves.
I have to say that I was a little disappointed with this movie, because it wasn’t what was advertised. Though it gives me the heebie-jeebies, I do see what some conservatives might object to: in ads, the movie is portrayed as a film about a misfit and his journey to acceptance. But the film is a rather disorganized mish-mash of that and five or so other plots. (the love story, the overfishing of our oceans, environmental degradation and garbage loose in the environment, corporate malfeasance w/r/t the environment, religious figures who are given power under false pretenses, zoos and their questionable ability to give animals adequate habitats, did I miss any here?)
It’s kind of like the filmmakers took all of their ideas about liberalism and environmentalism and threw them into a pot, stirred, and out came this movie. It was okay, but just okay.
YMMV.
Peterboy @ 3
there’s a new Coca-Cola ad in the cinema that shows polar bears and penguins together. would that be the southern hemisphere polar bear diaspora?
Oops, you’re right; it’s V not Z. I’ll fix in a minute.
Yup, profoundly subersive innuendoes abound in pop culture works…yet a 2,000 year old book must be interpreted literally.
Scarecrow @ 16
Yes, “Z” is the one about the Greek penguins. Casting Yves Montand was a real coup.
Newtonian counter-force: digby writes:
Norman Conquest @ 17
It was written before the auteur theory. I read that in Cahiers des Eglises.
All of us know how it feels to be an outcast in some way.
Yeah sure- Like, for example, the fact that I live in the ONLY county in Florida to give a majority of votes to Katherine “Pink Sugar” Harris over Bill Nelson. Though that might make me an outcast, I feel safe in the knowledge that I know **I’M** right!
Your agenda going down in flames?
That pesky war just won’t go away?
Your boy king not working out?
There’s only one thing left to do:
Go after the animated penguins!
LOL! Thanks.
punaise @ 19
You know Ann Coulter thinks she’s Dagny Taggart.
awww … “Z” is the most amazing film about political repression … I enjoyed V but Z changed the world (or at least helped toss out the Greek Junta!)
http://rogerebert.suntimes.com…..00301/1023
No, I went to this movie because CNN’s Glenn Beck and Fox News told me not to go.
Damned fine reason for most anything.
Patrick 4/4 @ 20
I thought Hastings was out as intelligence committee head…
Scarecrow! great post!
and cartoons are definitely dangerous … I always thought that Crusader Rabbit (dating myself mightily) taught my generation that we were supposed to fight for justice.
Okay, gang. Z is now V. Refresh with F5, please.
But Z is pretty awesome too.
punaise @ 26
I give that comment a 1066.
A woman I know said her pastor warned the congregation about the dangers of watching the Smurfs. (Years ago.)
The kids in our house loved the Smurfs, so I asked why. This is what I remember:
They’re communist, they have ill-defined roles. Girl smurfs and boy smurfs live together but aren’t married, and that Papa Smurf…who knows what he’s up to?
Made my head ache.
Patrick 4/4 @
18
You’re right. Arianna Huffington is one of the voices.
Scarecrow, loving your post.
Yes, the wingers can find offense in anything. They hunt until they ferret it out, or invent it.
I wish, instead of “offense”, they would take “a fence” and keep themselves and their opinions behind it.
Margot @ 30
Smurf are fine. But those tubby tellie thingies really spook me out.
Scarecrow, my friend,
Great post. Again.
Been wanting to get hold of a copy of Z for a while now. I remember it from my more youthful daze but know that I’d have a much better understanding of it today!
As for the little dancing bipeds, my administrator saw it over the weekend with her kid and told me this morning that it was much more a movie for adults than it was for kids. Sort of like Alice in Wonderland was in its time. Many of the great children’s classics are so because of the appeal to multiple audiences through layered meanings and plot lines.
Now, I was planning on getting a full nights’ sleep for a change and turning in early. Way overdue.
Margot @ 30
BTW – the girl Smurfs also did all the traditional housework and the boy Smurfs got to do the cool stuff.
There’s nothing wrong with reading subtext. If it’s there.
Scarecrow @ 33
especially the purple ones. Gotta watch out for anything purple.
it was a Catharctic experience
Oh, and scarecrow,
Your movie is on the teevee yet again as we type. Another subversive plot put forth by the libruls. Wicked witches, little people, men behind curtains. . . it’s all a plot!
Liberals love libraries – and reading!
Rahm needs a copy – many copies – of Lolita.
He’ll need it for the book report.
We are a loving tribe.
(apologies for OT – epu’d)
Being that my work is with little people, I’m hip to the kings of video. Currently “Bob the Builder” is a favorite and “Thomas the Tank Engine” is always en vogue. I draw the line at “Teletubbies” Way too weird.
punaise @
37
Heresy loves company.
Scarecrow @ 31
Arianna. Queen of progressive perceptibility.
Siun @
27
I agree Siun, great post Scarecrow! I like old reruns of Rocky and Bullwinkle. So much stuff in there I didn’t get when I was a kid. Like the General with the zany eyes–an obvious slam on military intelligence.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 42
Arianna. Queen of progressive perceptibility.
She notices a little more each time?
telllatubbbies -
just sounds so soothing….
Wait a minute, wasn’t it just a year or two ago that movie penguins were all conservative and promoting traditional family values by forming monogamous relationships and raising their young together?
My head hurts.
Joel @ 46
Yes, until it came out that some of the penguins were gay. Then all bets were off.
RevDeb @ 47
And expecting.
Scarecrow @ 48
Are you suggesting that the vice president’s daughter is a penguin?
RevDeb @ 47
Yes, but those were German penguins. They even tried intervention with penguins from Sweden with no success. American penguins aren’t gay ;-)
kirk murphy @ 45
Not to be cruel, but do you find this soothing??
Patrick 4/4 @ 44
She notices a little more each time?
I visualize no better way to say it.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 52
I visualize no better way to say it.
“I see,” he said, sawing on some wood.
Are you suggesting that the vice president’s daughter is a penguin?
No, but I’ll bet any penguin could be a better Vice President than the one we have.
speaking of expecting… happy news and best wishes for the Senator from VA and his family.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/…..00437.html
Another Sag! woot!
Speakout @ 51
Why do the yellow tellatubbies remind me of Jonah Goldberg?
Mad Dogs @
9
And, here I was set to make a subversive comment about why there are no “Fritz the Cat” revivals…. :)
Then there was that book about a same sex couple of penguins adopting a baby penguin.
Maybe it’s those damned penguins who are responsible for Mary Cheney choosing to have a baby even though doing so is “bad for America”.
Yea, they are commies and gays also. Or so the TV told me. Like stories and movies have like parables, and like metaphores, and like reflect the real world and shit.
Speakout @
21
Ho Ho he he heh. That is just so sad it’s funny.
Heaven forbid that any of the children (or adults for that matter) watching this film take away from it the idea that a person doesn’t have to kow-tow to conventional and societal wisdom…and can march (tap?) to their own drummer. Q’uel Horreur (sp?)!! Then what will happen? In the minds of the controlling…good grief! They might…lose control!
Fox and the right wing nutcase conservatives et.al. THRIVE on making sure the masses stay within the box…it’s all about control.
Little children who are raised to *think*; scare the bejeebus out of the establishment.
Thank you very much for giving me the opportunity to vent :) Great post Scarecrow…
Speakout @ 51
errr…my inner Luddite only allows dial-up here – do I want to hear the synopsis?
(does ‘Cliff Notes’ do ‘Teletubbies’?)
Joel @
46
Yeah, I noticed this too. I think it’s another reason the wingers are in a snit over the film.
It’s a kick in the teeth of their precious Intelligent Design God who would never have thought of a movie like Happy Feet.
oilfieldguy @ 43 – ah, Rocky and Bullwinkle! And Mad Magazine! Bless my mother for exposing me to those at a young and impressionable age…I know it contributes to me deep love and appreciation for the likes of Stewart and Colbert. Intelligent humor is something else that scare the sh** out of the control freaks.
Siun @ 27
Crusader Rabbit and Ragland T. Tiger (Rags). My favorites!
kirk murphy @ 62
As real rabbits hop about, a purple tellatubbie and a maroon tellatubbie decide to hold hands.
Then along come two matching yellow tellatubbies.
Eventually all four tellatubbies decide to hold hands and form a circle.
The end.
Horsewoman — yeah, the fundies especially are good with that control thing. And they know when their control is threatened. It must be a very frightening world out there.
Yamara @ 63
Once again the thugs confused fact and fiction.
They meant swans and got caught up with the tuxedo- clad lads and lovely, comely lassies.
kirk murphy @ 62
Definitely not worth the time. It’s something I imagine would be playing in my own personal hell- Where I’d be married to Bill O’ Reilly.
Scarecrow,
I’m sure the penguins are nice and all (my eight year old will probably drag me to it) but the all time greatest liberal propagation via animation has definitely got to be Fern Gully
It’s got a messiah story interwoven with the complexity of a neolithic Wicca religious theme; saving the last rain forest from evil petroleum sodden machinery of death. It is everything and every archetype you could ever want or desire from liberal clap-trap. It is the zenith. Oh, and the base requirement of Robin Williams, of course.
neurophius @ 66
In public? In front of the rabbits?
(clutches pearls)
OK Kiddo!!!!!
You are the first person I have ever met who also remembers Crusader Rabbit and Rags!!!
wow!
Of course, we must note the brilliance of Miyasaki … Christy’s Peanut if a fan of his work, as was Kurosawa who named Miyasaki one of the greatest filmakers of all times. Totoro is my fave but Princess Mononoke is essential viewing as well. (And Spirited Away won the Berlin Festival, finally giving anime the recognition it deserves)
Speakout, I’m not sure if you’ll want to hear from me after this, but some of my smarter friends turned me onto teletubbies enlightenment – watch, giggle, zone out…. and no lung damage.
(Of course, their side effect concerns were less strong – they were trying to come off Hanna-Barbera.)
I see there’s a link that got lost in translation. It’s fixed now, so refresh F5
The missing link was Laurie David’s article on schools backing away from Inconvenient Truth under pressure.
Generally speaking of animation, when I was in the bowels of the liberal beast, going to college in Boston in the early `70s, one of the local TV stations (WCVB-5) began what they called “Five All Night,” (gee, imagine a time when it was new for the television to be on all night) and it was hosted weekends by Robert Gardner of the Harvard film school.
One of the interesting things he did was host entire nights of animation. Without his tutelage on TV, I never would have known that Zagreb, Yugoslavia (now part of the Croatian state) was a hotbed of political film animation at the time.
Nor would I have ever known about Bruno Bozzetto, and his brilliant “Self-Service” or come across a Canadian public service announcement on electrical safety that has one of the funniest punchlines ever to a house burning down.
Disney was a piker compared to what’s out there.
Hey folks, theropod upstairs
montag @ 76
Did he also do 30 min program of animation (shorts) as a series carried on PBS stations in late 70’s/early 80’s?
If any of those animation shorts (or the series) made it to DVD, that would be wonderful.
[In SoCal on KCET it came right after the Pythons, of course.)
Trex and Late nite upstairs.
kirk murphy @ 78
He might have–I don’t recall. The national PBS film series at that same time was hosted by Charles Champlin, so you may be thinking of that (it might have originated out of KCET, too).
Bruno Bozzetto has his own site, and there’s, at least, videotape available for sale of various collections of his animation.
kirk murphy @ 74
lol
Hey man- It’s all about choice, I guess. Was Dave there?
johnSwifty @
70
It has Cheech Marin and Tommy Chong. I’m renting it.
Now I have to go find my “Born in East LA” tape….
Siun @
72
http://theimaginaryworld.com/pic463.jpg
I’m old enough but I don’t remember this. I do remember the Froggy with the magic twanger, though…
Glen Beck is absolutely right about this movie being liberal propaganda. In fact, a lot of those old cartoon movies are pure and simply tools for the liberals to spread there agenda around…
Take Bambi for instance, this movie is evil on so many levels that I don’t know where to start. Particularly the part that actually shows hunters out in the woods. WTF!!!! To my knowledge real hunters like Ted Nugent and Dick Cheney have these animals caught, put in pens, and then they fire away at them with automatic weapons!! How the heck would a kid learn to hunt watching Bambi I tell ya…Damn liberals!!!
Margot @ 83
I remember it – up ’til now, I’ve only met one other person who remembered it.
I loved it.
BTW, Producer Jay Ward later did Rocky and Bullwinkle
hpschd @ 85
Margot @ 83
(((Froggy Crusader Rabbit Rags)))
Why not bring back ‘Felix the Cat’ ? That was animation.
Coming soon from Fox: Passion of the Penguin.
p.s. With subtitles.
I love penguins, especially liberal ones! Don’t these douches realise what fools they are by saying this stuff?
The film was directed by George Miller, who directed Mel “I never met a Jew I didn’t hate” Gibson in the Mad Max series. In other words, it’s a dirty foreigner (this time an Aussie) directing a liberal, Jew-loving, Hollywood propaganda film about keeping the Earth safe for all living creatures to be able to exist.
I think the following snippet explains why some of us turned out the way we did. :-) Politics and propaganda in cartoons are traditions.
what a funny post. Scarecrow you kick butt.
An animated cartoon about dancing and singing penguins is disturbing to conservatives because it’s too realistic!
How funny is that?!
Princess Mononoke is essential viewing as well
If I recall correctly, it offended a lot of indigenous people in Japan, since Miyazaki simply made up the underlying mythology. (I was told that since there isn’t any consensus on the details of Ainu myth, he was afraid to go with one or the other version, and took the easy way out.) It’s pretty, but on the cigar-store Indian level in many ways. I much prefer Spirited Away.
Great post, Scarecrow!
I went to see Happy Feet with another middle-aged friend. We both loved it, subversive overeducated liberals that we are.
We had been forewarned that the film was not all light and happy as the trailers would have you believe. False advertising of children’s films, that’s a big issue with me. And I don’t even have any kids of my own. I’m still haunted by the trauma of taking my niece to see a falsely advertised Disney film, ages ago.
Just one nitpick: It’s Elijah Wood. Without an ’s’.