It's been a heck of a week. Consider that it was only last Friday that we learned ABC was planning to broadcast its fictional, yet "based on the 9/11 Commission Report" docudrama, because Rush Limbaugh and all of wing-nuttery were singing the praises of "The Path to 9/11." I wonder what horrific end ABC is planning for the flak who had the idea to send advance copies to Rush et. al. Or maybe, the avowed right-winger screenwriter, Cyrus Nowrasteh, and director, David Cunningham, were so jacked up about the fast one they were about to pull on the American people, they couldn't stop themselves from getting a little foreplay before the screw.
And now, look. Medialand is rightfully all a-buzz with this controversy because of all the hard work being done. Even ABC News reported today that the network was under an "avalanche of criticism from Democrats." It's a rare treat to see the left come together so quickly and effectively. But we had to fight for the truth. We did not have a choice. We had to take a stand against ABC's efforts to airbrush history, and peddle a fraudulent pic with pivotal scenes that old Cyrus saw fit to let actors completely improvise. Believe me, I know there's plenty of blame to go around regarding 9/11. But this movie goes so far as to use fantasy scenes to smear the Clinton administration, while leaving out many true-to-life scenes that would lay blame on the current administration.
Let's take a moment to congratulate ourselves. We got the word out, people. And that's no small feat. But we ain't done yet.
ABC's statement today gives no sign that they will pull this mini-series, but they are supposedly making some final edits. Disney Board Chair George Mitchell is getting an earful in this 11th hour, but it remains to be seen how much power he'll have.
This afternoon, Scholastic announced that they would be replacing the original "Path to 9/11" lesson plans with new ones that will focus on media literacy and critical thinking skills. That cannot be good for ABC. While it's commendable that the folks at Scholastic showed the good judgment to actually think about what they will serve up to American classrooms, it ain't all good news. They'll still show this fraudulent movie, that relied on actors' improvisations in many pivotal scenes, to communicate the narrative of this great American tragedy.
As they are frantically making up the new study guides, to be released tomorrow, I have a couple of suggestions.
Scholastic: If you simply cannot stop yourself from serving this propaganda up to America's high school students, how about also showing "9/11 Press for Truth" as well. Allow teachers to lead discussions that will compare and contrast the two movies. You may not have heard about this movie , because it doesn't have $30 million and a corporate network behind it, but it is a well-documented film, which does not fictionalize scenes but relies on interviews with those who were closest to what happened. The filmmakers have said this film features exclusive interviews with the families of 9/11 victims and 9/11 researcher Paul Thompson, author of the "The Terror Timeline," which pieces together stories from over 7000 media reports about 9/11.
I also sent this letter to Scholastic today:
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Jennifer Nix <mailto:jennifer.nix@>
Date: Sep 7, 2006 2:18 PM
Subject: congratulations on your decision to produce new Path to 9/11 materials
To: mailto:kgood@scholastic.com
Hi Kyle,I was very happy to see the release about the new study guides that will be made available tomorrow.
Might I make a suggestion that you could pass along to your writers/producers/educators working on those materials?
I have been a producer for NPR and staff writer for Variety, and written for a number of outlets over the years. In recent months, I have been working with a number of the progressive bloggers, in part because I am so excited about these new avenues for engaged citizens to better participate in the public debate.
It was the progressive blogs who launched and have led this campaign, since last Friday, to get ABC to reconsider this project, particularly when we learned that right-wing media and bloggers were given advance copies of the film, even as we were denied. Then we learned that even President Clinton and many of the prinicipals portrayed in the film were also denied advance copies. What we saw here were engaged citizens, through the blogs, investigating this story and organizing in real time, to help members of the professional media understand the backstory here and to ask tough questions.I think this would all make for a very interesting case study for high school students, as part of your "Path to 9/11" study materials.
I would suggest including in your materials bits from the sites below. Blogs are in their infancy, and the rules are being made up as we go along. But they are becoming more and more important to our media and democracy, in my opinion, and, in this case, they have played a major role in the developing story.
http://www.openlettertoabc.blogspot.com/ (clearinghouse site)
http://www.thinkprogress.org/
http://www.firedoglake.com//
http://www.dailykos.com/
http://www.glenngreenwald.blogspot.com/I would be happy to help, pro bono, in the interest of media literacy.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
FITZ!
Nixt!
going for three? Ah I suppose it was too much to ask for…
Hey diddle diddle
We’re breaking their fiddle
Any new updates in the donation drive for Wheeler’s book?
OT More truth; The Marcy meter doesn’t seem to be moving a lot today. Lack of input or broken meter?
I read a CNN story on this topic early today. No mention at all of the political leanings of the producers and proponents of the schlock-u-drama, nor a mention that it was provided to right-wing bloggers for preview. Gosh, they really put themselves out providing the context for that story. Pathetic.
Curious in Central Texas @
5
look in the righthand column of this page, under the Akaka ad and the PayPal donation buttons — the thermometer!
Steve @ 6
I’ve noticed the same thing, Steve.
probably coz there aint been too much flogging the book.
Donate! Now! Flog! Flog!
Jen Nix, grrrrl, you are doing grrrreat work for your country!
I’m just proud to get to hang out with you some.
OT.
But I had to share:
“This worm is the stuff that legends and fairy tales are made of,” worm supporter Steve Paulson declared. “What kid wouldn’t want to play with a 3 foot-long, lily smelling, soft pink worm that spits?
The big worm.
-GSD
During the last hour of CNN’s The Situation Room, their Internet Reporter (Jackie?) said that Hugh Hewitt has been assured by a source that the Clinton bashing will remain largely intact. It’s not in the CNN transcripts though!?
This thing needs to be pulled, take no prisoners. If not, boycott
Your daily gas and oil prices
Average price for regular gasoline 9/7/06 in 50 states and DC
$3.00 plus 5 states
$2.90 plus 8 states
$2.80 plus 5 states
$2.70 plus 9 states
$2.60 plus 10 states
$2.50 plus 11 states
$2.40 plus 3 states
Average national price: $2.700, down $.020
Highest recorded national average price: $3.057 9/5/2005
Highest average price: Hawaii $3.295
Lowest average price: Ohio $2.423
Nymex Crude Future $67.16, down $.42
Dated Brent Spot $65.37, down $.77
WTI Cushing Spot $67.32, down $.18
Gas falls. Oil drifts.
Wow. This thread is OT as a motherfucker.
Good on you, Jenn, to press the point. I wouldn’t recommend any breath-holding either.
we make a difference, we are firedogs!
and here we are, we firedogs can all take special pleasure for now and forever in what we’ve done today, what we’ve done in the past, what have yet to do
If America, her democracy, and our constitution is saved, we would have played certainly not the least role in that victory
Do we have any late developments on the donate-by-check front, *ilson (since the website doesn’t want to play with me)?
For a tongue-in-cheek visual primer on the Bush administration’s “A Guide to the ABC’s For Dummies”…link here:
www.thoughttheater.com
One thing I have taken away from this whole experience, is the conspiracy of the right-wing that exists to alter this country into something alien. (not a conspiracy in the tinfoil hat sense, but in a coordinated, networked, quasi-legal sense).
One of the things I hope we can do going forward, once the smoke clears from this current episode, that is, is to ourselves coordinate an attack on this entire right-wing network. Attack their funding. Attack their reach in the media. Attack their apologists. Attack their enablers.
This is something the netroots is ideal for.
OMG…I did a post with this video 3 days ago…The Director came to my site and invited me to a screening in Austin, TX on Sept. 11th.
Anyone wanna go with?
Thank you Jennifer for getting the word out.
Sure feels better now than it used to, doesn’t it, me to me?
Great post, Jennifer! I love all the links, both to the other blogs and to the other movie.
We should spotlight this post to everyone who should be doing their homework on 9/11.
Perfect.
Kurt @ 17
We may have to, since nobody else will.
OT: I was in Chicago today to see the archaeological evidence of New Kingdom Egyptian class warfare…er, I mean, the Tutankhamun exhibit at the Field Museum. Catch it if you can; it’s well worth it, and there are a lot of pieces from the tombs of Tut’s likely ancestors in addition to his own.
Good to see that ABC’s little propaganda piece is turning into the debacle it deserves to be for them.
Ahhh….premature prestidigitation.
HopeSpringsATurtle @ 18
Want? Totally. Can? Not even close, unfortunately…
Hi All–Be sure to check the links to 9/11 Press for the Truth. The movie is opening to day. I’m running over to Oakland now to see a viewing. But press for this movie. It’s a true antidote to all the spin and stonewalling.
Jennifer, great work you’ve done over the last few days and a very good proposal to Scholastic. I hope they have the good sense to understand the implications of your offer. We are not going away.
HopeSpringsATurtle @ 18
I might be able to go — I work downtown Austin.
tommy yum -
I left a message in the prior thread for you at 5:35 pm.
Jennifer - Your tireless work has been amazing! If no other steps are made everyone who participated should find comfort in the scholastic results. One for the little people and kids!
Jennifer- huge thanks for this article.
There were a lot comments on the Late Nite thread yesterday/today about Scholastic (see there, if you wish). I got to poking around on the Scholastic site, and imo, this is not the first time that they have swallowed propaganda hook, line and sinker. Two links follow.
http://teacher.scholastic.com/.....epth/iraq/
http://teacher.scholastic.com/.....ticle=tips
~~~Teacher Tips
It may seem like yesterday that our nation was on edge, waiting for an announcement of war with Iraq. Now the war is over, Saddam Hussein has been removed from power, and the people of Iraq are struggling to rebuild their war-torn land. []
Objective: Students will explore the history of America’s conflict with Iraq using a time line dating back to Saddam Hussein’s rise to power.
Getting Ready: Point out to students that the friction between the United States and Iraq did not happen overnight. In fact, trouble has been brewing for well over a decade. ~~~
From my site:
The film “Press For Truth” will be screening one night only on September 11 in Austin, Texas. I will be there. I’m posting the info and if you are anywhere near the Austin area it is a tremendous opportunity to meet and network with others who want the truth about 9/11.
SEPTEMBER 11 – AUSTIN, TX
Regal Arbor Cinema at Great Hills, 9828 Great Hills Trl.
(Free, Donations accepted. 1 Night Only. 7:30PM)
SEPTEMBER 11 – AUSTIN, TX
University of Texas at Austin, 2400 Inner Campus Dr.
(FREE. 1 Night Only. 8:30PM)
Jennifer, your leadership on ABC’s treason has been extraordinary. I hope the Mouse has learned something from the ‘lake this week — we’re here now and we’re not gonna stand for this shit anymore.
ABC- 7 (which has neither acknowledged nor answered my several emails) tonight ran spin control on the local news, saying Democrats, including Harry Reid, were calling the movie “fiction” and then pointing out they hadn’t seen it, so viewers should watch and “judge for yourself!”
========
Had Enough?
========
Ilson@10 Maybe a meter with smaller divisions to give more immediate gratification. Another c for Marcy to prime the pump tonight.
One more quick note. Yes, FDL’s commenters were all over the scholastic news–great stuff!! I had some technical difficulties getting this post up, and basically had to rewrite half the thing, so thanks for reminding to mention a big thank you to you all for keeping on this, too!
HopeSpringsATurtle @ 32
HopeSpringsATurtle — which theatre?
ABC- 7 (which has neither acknowledged nor answered my several emails) tonight ran spin control on the local news, saying Democrats, including Harry Reid, were calling the movie “fiction” and then pointing out they hadn’t seen it
And why might *that* be, hmmm?
Valley Girl @ 31
Don’t forget to pass out copies of this photographic evidence of America’s long-standing opposition to Saddam’s tyranny.
lotus @ 17
Nor me. I want ot send a check for Marcy and another to FDL! please
I’m going to the Regal Arbor..the 7:30 show. I’m going to meet the director.
Can you make it Cen Tex?
EvilDrP, linky no worky, drat the luck.
For an LA Times story (pulled from HuffPo), click HERE.
ABC won’t even be airbrushing the bias if the report is right, but I’m not sure I trust it. How’s this for slant:
And there’s worse in this gem.
charge!!! let’s save the Republic and the truth and hold ‘em all accountable!
what a wealth of patriots we have. let us try to save the world by smashing lies all day long.
Thank you Jennifer!!!
========
Had Enough?
========
Kurt @ 19
Yeah, I gotta give Hillary props here. She was right, there is a VRWC.
Jennifer Nix @ 25
Hey Jennifer, do you know about this?
HopeSpringsATurtle @ 40
Yes, I’ll be there. I’ll go to your blog and send you my contact information.
Yep.
Boycott Disney, Boycott ABC(Advancing Bush’s Cause), the whole schmear.
I have sent some e-mails and will make some calls tomorrow.
Boy that liberal media. You know, Clear Channel and their Pro-Bush pro war rallies and anti-Dixie Chix efforts. Sinclair and their proud Swiftboat docugandas and now ABC/Disney and this disgusting smear and blatant piece of rightwing shit straight out of the PNAC/AEI/Limbaugh wing of the fascist revisionista movement.
F them all including “New Pud on the Riech” Wahlberger, Stephen Root and the Harvey Keitel and his small weenie.(I saw it in The Bad Lieutenant)
-GSD
EvilDrPuma- that link (photo evidence) didn’t work. [[Not Found
The requested document was not found on this server.]]
I am eager to see…
Nice work kids. Thanks Jennifer.
BTW, I was listening to KABC in L.A. today (don’t ask why, it’s kinda like poking at a sore to “make” it hurt) and those clowns were all over this, totally misrepresenting the story, as though “the Clinton’s were trying to suppress this broadcast”.
Sounded desperate but still bugged me. (”poke”)
lotus @ 21
it sure as HELL does
now, we HAVE to make sure there is NO E VOTING
and THEN the republic our forefathers died so we might live in freedom will be won again
Here’s the link to the CNN story I mentioned above:
http://www.cnn.com/2006/SHOWBI.....index.html
Press For Truth
Screenings (near you) searchable by zip code ; )
http://pressfortruth.bravenewt.....?zip=27021
The Bushaholics have gotten so used to framing and controlling events and media that they assumed they’d be able to carry off this Dem- bashing the same way. Frame it as, see when Dems were in charge, look how they screwed up. Part of their grand scheme to “terra, terra, terra” all the way to election day.
Sorry if I’m being redundant–flying by via dinosaur dialup [with apologies to TRex]–haven’t read the earlier threads.
Kudos to all you bloggers leading the battle on this…And KO. And wasn’t Dan Rather hounded out of television by this same bunch of lie-spewing slime?
And razzberry to David Broder–newly out of the closet Bushaholic–for saying Fitzgerald should apologize to Rove.
Cool…I’ll check my mail in a bit.
Teddy,
Asking viewers to judge for themselves whether the movie is fact or fiction is akin to push polling. We know that much of the public is swayed by whatever they are told that looks authentic or that fits or reinforces their own pre-concieved notions.
It is a totally fatuous answer to a serious query that has been put to the stations. Don’t let them get away with that!
GSD @ 45
OK, GSD– but Harvey’s butt was ok in “The Piano”.
jest sayin’! *g*
Boycott– I am on it!!!
Jeez Jen! The great work continues. Thank you so much!
I had the day off - sent dozens of emails, including this cut & paste from earlier today - great find xyz, via Kos:
http://www.firedoglake.com/200.....ent-282645
What follows is just to paste into CC (I deleted 4 add’s which were kicked back - bad or blocked):
robert.a.iger@disney.com, rich.ross@disney.com, sean.cocchia@disney.com, gary.marsh@disney.com, shelton@disney.com, scott.garner@disney.com, karen.myer@disney.com, meredith.metz@disney.com, lisa.salamone@disney.com, joanna.spak@disney.com, mark.kenchelian@disney.com, jewell.engstrom@disney.com, olivia.stafford@disney.com, albert.cheng@disney.com, karen.hobson@disney.com, george.bodenheimer@disney.com, nicole.nichols@disney.com, aime.wolfe@disney.com, patti.mcteague@disney.com, siobhan.kenny@disney.com, paul.lee@disney.com, annie.fort@disney.com, alex.wallau@disney.com, mike.shaw@disney.com, kara.rousseau@disney.com, kim.harbin@disney.com, anne.gates@disney.com, james.fielding@disney.com, deborah.dugan@disney.com, graham.hopper@disney.com, angela.emery@disney.com, chris.bess@disney.com, peter.murphy@disney.com, jestrin@packetdesign.com, john.bryson@edisonintl.com, monica.lozano@laopinion.com, john.chen@sybase.com, tom.staggs@disney.com
Shrub mentioned OBL, what? 14 times yesterday.
Yea, like he cares
Valley Girl @ 49
Well, then, let’s try that again.
The problem is that the 9.11 commission scenario is hardly the unvarnished truth.
Is this push to the right simply a strategy to get everyone behind the “conventional wisdom” (9.11 commission)story and kill the rising outcry for a new and thorough investigation of the attack?
PRESS for TRUTH
john in sacramento @ 56
17 times.
john in sacramento @ 59
Emmanuel Goldstein Lives!
RevDeb @ 55
KGO/ABC-7 hasn’t come close to answering ANY of my questions, framed with the help of this community and the former President of the United States. Believe me — when they’ve just about got a response prepared and approved, I launch another polite missive over their transom, sending them back into their little damage control huddle.
Their on-air statement this evening about Democrats commenting on their precious tripe without having seen it has earned them another email from their faithful correspondent, me.
========
Had Enough?
========
Well, then, let’s try that again.
Nope, not that time either, EvilDP.
EvilDrPuma @ 60
Dammit. You may want to do this manually–that works for me, anyway.
http://www.stpeace.org/gallery.....ges/saddam rumsfeld.htm
How convenient to have an annual celebration and reminder of the fear the administration needs to keep everyone quiet and compliant.
Fake stories
OBL videos on que…
Skeery prisoner trials a comin..
Are you safer?
Are you skill skeered?
I am sick of this nonsense
RevDeb @ 54
I like this comparison a lot. In fact I can hear the automated phone message: “Who would you vote for if Jiminy Cricket told you that …?”
EvilDrPuma @ 63
OK, my ignorance is showing, Emmanuel Goldstein???
TeddySanFran @ 61
I’m impressed by the chutzpah of complaining that Democrats are criticizing it without having seen it when ABC WON’T LET THEM.
I sent three emails to the local ABC affiliate in OKC, which, in my opinion, were very well reasoned letters objecting to a gift to the Republican Party during a superheated election season by catering to the default position of the party of personal responsibility–It’s Bill Clinton’s fault.
I got a single reply from them today.
“thanks for the feedback”
No smiley faces, hell, not even a capital letter to start the sentence.
Guess I told them.
Wonder if I should visit them with 30 or so sign carrying friends?
newtonusr @ 58
Awesome!
We must continue the fight! There are only 2 days (plus 2 hours, here in EST) before they will SHOW this drivel!
We must all email, email, email!
I am going to copy and paste this throughout the sites.
We are making a difference! Don’t stop now!
EvilDP, you must know some secret juju, then.
:-(
john in sacramento @ 65
The designated villain of the totalitarian society in 1984.
Prairie Sunshine @ 54
Waves to Prairie
I feel like I’ve been missing in action for the last week. What a week to get back. Yay Marcy-Yay FDL and Yay Byron Dorgan for the letter to Disney/abc. Gotta go write some emails!
EvilDrPuma @ 65
Why does America hate me? I didn’t realize the system would try to convert that into a link…the last part is “/saddam rumsfeld.htm”…let us spray.
‘ere & then scroll up to the top and read the first Q&A:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/.....01524.html
17 mentions down to 14– Great, we’re winning the war on terra! To Mars next!
HSAT - congrats.
Poor mouse, no one told him that the D in FDL has JackRussellTerrier instincts when it comes to rodents.
OT - So far the only piece I’ve seen, but it would probably be the definitive one, even if there were many. Ray McGovern at Tom Paine re: the Torture Revelations (via Larry Johnson’s No Quarter)
The question everyone is ducking - what about our torturers? Lederman has touched on it too, but in an analysis of the pending legislation. Ray just says - without regard to the trial of KSM, why aren’t we talking about what happens about torture done pursuant to Exec Authorization?
I’m guessing you just keep running legislation through Specter and putting the folks like Bybee, Haynes & Co on the court. I’m waiting for the lovely epistle from everyone in the AG’s office recommending Addington for USSCT, along with a resurrection of Padilla.
Keep in mind, the pro-torture assault has a lot of different fronts. Tossing Arar and al-Masri as state secrets; military commission rules to allow torture testimony; a pass with Salah on maybe just get them looking good and prop up Judy Miller to testify and pretend it didn’t happen; torture act amendments; claims of “good faith reliance” on OLC opinions, court packing with Bybee,Kavanaugh, Haynes, etc.; assaults on the whole of the JAG system - led by Addington and Cheney; war crimes act amendments; challenges to enforcement issues in respect of the Geneva Conventions; and then there’s the biggest and most insidious:
Just do it, claim it as a wonderful indication of how tough you are and own a DOJ that won’t even have one person pipe up. When you own the prosecution mechanism, it doesn’t really matter what the law is or should be, and when you can publicize your crimes to acclaim, then what?
john in sacramento @ 68
The perpetual scapegoat figure from Orwell’s 1984.
From Yahoo: The Pet Goat Kids remember 9/11
A video interview with the kids who were in the classroom with Bush….
http://www.yahoo.com/s/385740
Let’s not forget just how hard the Bush/Rove machine worked to initially stonewall and prevent the 9/11 commission from doing their work.
Ratbastids.
(Snip)
White House Opposed Formation of Commission: President Bush and Vice President Cheney both contacted then-Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle in the months after 9/11 to insist on strict limits in the scope of any investigation into the attacks. Newsweek reported on February 4, 2002, that Vice President Cheney called Sen. Tom Daschle (D-SD) to “warn” him not to open hearings into the attacks. If Daschle pressed the issue, Cheney “implied he would risk being accused of interfering with the mission” against terrorism. And despite entreaties from the families of victims of 9/11 attacks and a bipartisan group of senators and congressmen, the president vocally resisted forming an investigatory commission. President Bush only relented on November 27, 2002, a year after the attacks.
-GSD
Thanks Eli, “Duoooh!” (slaps forehead)
Linky to Saddam Rummy pics
So now we’re being treated to an ABC/Disney publicity stunt to get more viewers? Hey guess what? There’s no freakin’ way I’m watching one second of that fiasco. BOYCOTT this lie.
http://www.stpeace.org/gallery.....ges/saddam rumsfeld.htm
hell’s bells. this (above) doesn’t work either. But I found it by going to
http://www.stpeace.org/gallery/interestingPhotos/
and cliking through.
Oilfieldguy @ 71
I know you drive trucks for a living, and for some reason the climactic scene from a really lame old movie “White Line Fever” came to mind (guy drove his truck into the evil corporate HQ or whatever) … yeah, go picket with friends. Be nice, polite, and unyielding.
My letter to everybody in Newtoners 58:
“Please tell me you will not be airing this partisian piece of propaganda. it is unfair and unbalanced. I can’t wait for them to sue you.
Mary, just in case I ever wake up President one morning, have yer robe measurements ready, okay babe?
Nice that we won’t hafta worry about any Gilbert&Sullivan yello* stripes on the sleeves of yours, though . . .
Sorry to be a wet blanket
But the bflight 93 movieis on A& and they just ahd a really obnoxious path to 9 11 promo
Sorry kids
It ain’t over till t’s over
Teddy,
I would NEVER doubt that you are TOTALLY on top of giving them all the grief they deserve. That is one thing about the FDL community that I so love. We are knowledgeable, dedicated, and dogged in our search and work for truth, justice, and what should be the American Way.
I am so proud of everyone here and so jazzed by what this group can accomplish when the need or opportunity presents itself.
It ain’t over till t’s over
Thought this might be useful. Letter I sent to ABC lackeys who first told me they’d send me a copy, then wouldn’t, after ABC put out their statement today. Use those email addresses!
———- Forwarded message ———-
From: Jennifer Nix
Date: Sep 7, 2006 12:13 PM
Subject: Regarding the ABC statement on Path to 9/11
To: Hope.C.Hartman@abc.com, Alison.Rou@abc.com, tchen@mprm.com, tblack@mprm.com, jmcintosh@mprm.com
———- Forwarded message ———-
From: Jennifer Nix
Date: Sep 7, 2006 12:06 PM
Subject: Re: Path to 9/11 outreach
To: patrick.k.preblick@abc.com, jonathan.hogan@abc.com
Cc: Matt Stoller < <a href="mailto:stoller@gmail.com rel="nofollow">">stoller@gmail.com>
Jonathan Hogan and Patrick Preblick:
Just saw the ABC statement about “The Path to 9/11.” Unfortunately, it ignores many of the key concerns people have about your project. We’ve put together a clearinghouse site, to help you better understand the many issues at play here.
http://openlettertoabc.blogspot.com/
I also saw on Rawstory.com, Jonathan, that you say many of the people who are criticizing the film have not yet seen it. Indeed! We’ve not seen it because you’ve refused to make copies available, even after you said last week that you would. And we are only calling out certain scenes that have been reported by people who have seen the film. In particular, we are quoting from reports and reviews made by right-wing partisans to whom you did see fit to show the film.
From Hugh Hewitt, another right-wing pundit that ABC apparently has time to communicate with, I learned that that producers have been assuring right-wing partisans that any edits to the film will barely be noticable, and that the project will still blame Clinton. Is Hewitt reporting fact?
Here is something, from our Open Letter to ABC project that may illustrate to you how irresponsible and indefensible ABC’s actions are. Remember back in 2003, when Republicans objected to the CBS production, The Reagans? Here are some comments from Republicans at the time. More can be found at our web site.
Ed Gillespe, RNC Chairman — Scarborough Country, 11/6/2003 (via Lexis)
GILLESPIE: And I think it was important that it be historically accurate. And if they didn’t intend to make it historically accurate to make surethat viewers understood that it was not intended to be historically accurate but a fictional portrayal. So we made two requests: One is having historians review it for accuracy if you’re going to broadcast it. And if you’re unwilling to do that, inform the viewers that it’s not historically accurate. That’s not censorship, that’s common sense. . .
I’ve sent a similar letter to the head of Showtime making the same point: “If you’re not willing to have it reviewed for historical accuracy, make sure your viewers understand that it’s a fictional portrayal. You know, in this society that we live in and with the media culture that we have, there’s infotainment and docudrama and reality TV, and the lines between fact and fiction blur. That’s fine when it’s entertainment, but when you’re talking about the formative phase of the Reagan legacy formation, I think that it’s important that we get things right. . . .
I think that same standard should apply to the late president John F. Kennedy or to Jimmy Carter or any president. If you’re going to portray a presidency and a president, I think you should do all you can to make sure it’s accurate. . . .
Bill O’Reilly, O’Reilly Factor “Talking Points”, 11/4/2003 (Via Lexis)
Well, fine, but how could CBS green light the film in the first place knowing that the producers, the director and the featured actors are all left wing thinkers?
That would be like CBS commissioning a movie about the Clintons written by Rush Limbaugh and starring Dennis Miller and Ann Coulter.
I hope this helps to inform your efforts, Jonathan. Even some conservative commentators are admitting that ABC is out on a limb here. You really need to address public concerns in a meaningful and responsible way.
All best, Jennifer Nix
Thank you, john in sac’to!
OFG– do not despair. Your heart is in the right place and you live in an area I care about. Lots of people don’t even know what they are losing, and we should be helping you daily. You also move across the country, meeting people every day and are interacting constantly and making a differance.
Please do not be discouraged! I have your back, sir.
Thanks EDP @ 79
Oh and BTW Clinton did more to counter “tearism” than Shrub and his mafia ever did
Click
Oh, and before I forget, it seems the Bush Crime Family let 911 happen or carried it out
Click
OT
Chafee good, Schumer a rat according to Matt at MyDD re Bolton.
AirportCat @ 84