(This is a guest post from Scout Prime of First Draft. Scout has been following the situation in New Orleans and all over the Gulf Coast closely since last year's hurricane Katrina. (Even though Scout doesn't live anywhere near NOLA, she understands that when some of our fellow citizens are in trouble, we ought to all pitch in to help.) Since it is already hurricane season again, I thought an update on how our fellow Americans were doing was needed...and the news is not good. -- RH)
That is their Flag of Distress designed to tell you that despite what you may have heard or assumed it is not OK down there. In fact life in New Orleans is grim. For over 9 months residents have gone through what I would term, The Long Wait.
They have waited for FEMA maps that would determine how they must rebuild their homes. They have waited for insurance checks and basic services like water, electricity, operating stoplights, mail, clearance of debris, collection of bodies and garbage pick-up to name just a few. They have waited for the politicians to hammer out federal funding for a housing program that would allow them to rebuild.
They have waited for Levees and the Army Corps of Engineers to admit responsibility for the flood that destroyed their city. They have waited for their fellow Americans to offer moral support and hope rather than blame and apathy. In a few areas the wait appears over. FEMA did finally release flood map advisories, the Corps of Engineers admitted their terrible mistake and just recently it appears Louisiana will receive federal funding for the Road Home housing plan and levee repair, though those repairs are deemed woefully inadequate.
In most other respects they still wait and now comes The Hard Reality.
What is truly difficult to convey about New Orleans is the scope of the destruction, the loss of infrastructure and the effects of such destruction and loss. Whole areas of the city lie in desolate ruin. The lower 9th Ward was the hardest hit. However go to Gentilly, Lakeview, New Orleans East, St. Bernard Parish and these areas are devastated too. People of all races and income levels have had their lives ruined by the man made disaster that was Katrina. The rebuilding of those lives has been so painfully slow to nonexistent that residents feel they have been abandoned by America and would want all to know...”We Are Not OK.”
80% of the city flooded because of the failure of the federal levee system. This is a very important point so I’ll say it again this way....It was not Hurricane Katrina that destroyed NOLA, it was the "catastrophic failure" of the Federal levee system which caused a flood that left the city devastated. “Researchers now say as many as 30 breaches in the system accounted for 84 percent of the metro area flooding.” The Army Corps of Engineers has finally admitted responsibility for design failures which caused the system to fail. In fact it was a “system in name only.”
To date 1577 people from Louisiana died due to Katrina. (Bodies are still being found) 75% of the casualties were elderly. ”Poor, elderly and disabled people were the most likely to be living in the lowest elevations behind levees, the least likely to be able to evacuate without assistance and most likely to die.”
Property damage and the loss of infrastructure was staggering. It can be still be seen and felt to this day. In fact people who go to New Orleans and venture out in any direction from the relatively undamaged downtown area, find a scene that leaves them shaken and outraged as it looks as though it all happened yesterday. And this is what approximately 220,000 New Orleanians live with each day.
Picture each and every facet of your daily life and then imagine it as either damaged or destroyed. Grocery stores, schools, fast food restaurants, strip malls, parks, coffee shops, churches, hospitals, clinics, sewers, courts. The list goes on and on. Imagine areas without stoplights and still some without electricity. Fires are fought from the air with helicopters as it is difficult to get water pressure for hoses on the ground. Garbage pickup is spotty. Debris is everywhere. Imagine living in a small trailer in front of your now destroyed home and you are the only living person for a block in what is a ghostly wasteland. Imagine on your drive to work each day, you pass a certain house, only to find out in your evening paper that another body was discovered in that house you’ve “been driving past" each day.
Rebuilding has been in fits and starts, if at all. Mainly it has consisted of individuals working on their own homes such as gutting them down to the 2x4's. Then they have waited…..for a FEMA trailer, for insurance checks, for a roofer, for federal funding to reach them, for neighbors to return, for levee protection, for the coming hurricane season, for what will happen next in the hard felt absence of A Plan. The uncertainty is palpable. Fear, anxiety and depression are growing as people face The Hard Reality of grieving the loss of what their city was and the question of what will now become of them and the city they have loved. Should they stay or go? Are the levees safe enough? There is acceptance that the city will not be restored exactly as it once was, but what will it look like in the future? No one really knows.
Crisis abound.....the levees, an acute shortage of workers as there is an acute shortage of housing, budget cuts for police in the face of rising crime, a judicial system that collapsed and just now is coming back to life, 105 of 122 public schools remain closed. There isn’t enough space to detail the devastation to all of the infrastructure so I will describe what is happening in just one area to hopefully illustrate the severity of life in the the city at present.
Health Care
The status of the health care system in New Orleans is desperate as there is a severe shortage of health care workers, clinics, hospitals, services and funding. Charity and University hospitals remain closed. Hospitals in areas surrounding New Orleans are overwhelmed. Ambulances can line up for hours waiting to bring patients in for treatment. Hospitals are bleeding money each month “because they have to pay more for temporary personnel and care for uninsured people who otherwise would have gone to Charity Hospital.” Hospital inpatient stays have become longer as there is no long term outpatient care or home care in New Orleans at present.
There is a severe shortage of all health care workers, clinics and hospital beds. For example New Orleans City Business reports....
New Orleans had 5,400 physicians before the hurricane. The area has only 1,400 now, including 500 private practice physicians, according to the Louisiana State Medical Society. The number of primary care doctors has fallen 77 percent from 617 to 140. Dentists have decreased 70 percent from 259 to 77, and psychiatrists have dropped 89 percent from 196 to 22, according to the Louisiana Department of Health and Hospitals.
Login Here
Spotlight



Support this site!
Keep
up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search


RSS/XML Feed
Fitz?
I’ll add one more thing to do. Come on down and bring your tourist dollars.
Blogger conference, anyone?
Blogger conference, anyone?
Funny you should say this. Some of us are looking into that
Scout, thanks for all your hard work at keeping us in the public eye. Come down anytime and bring your friends.
Sherman…Thank you. I was there at the end of Feb and beginning of March for 10 days and I will surely be back. Soon I hope
Simply put, NOLA is about as bad ad Baghdad, but without the expolosions. Bush is doin a heckuva job.
Goper’s Lament (Hard To Be A Republican)
a friend returned from nola just last night and said it is still a wasteland. he said he took hundreds of pictures because he couldn’t believe how bad it still was…
Thank you for this valuable update, Scout. It has p*ssed me off to no end that the profiteers within and without this administration weren’t competent enought to see the opportunity for long-term economic development of the Gulf Coast. They could have turned around the entire country and saved their reputations with right action, or at least effective action.
Letter going to my crappy Republican representative later today on this issue.
travy…I took pics and video when I was there and I have seen recents pics of same sites. No Change in the last 3 months. It really is unbelievable
Last night on one of the MSM channels, they were discussing the arrival of Alberto which led to a discussion of Lake Okeechobee. The jist of it is that the Army Corp of Engineers are certain that the levees will not hold and that it is not a matter of if, but when. When asked how far the flooding would spread out, the question could not be answered because it is a situation of national security and indeed terrorists do not need to know that answer. Possibly it was CNN last night, though I’m not too sure. Since I live close to that lake, I really feel that as members of this homeland, isn’t it more important that residents have this info??
Excellent Rayne
w
When I asked people in NOLA what can we do, they always said Call/Write your Congress rep
ccmask…in light of what happened with the Army Corps of Engineers and the levees of NOLA I think anyone living near an ACE project in America ought to take pause.
I think it is important that people understand that it is still so bad because of the enormity of the problem and the uncertainly factors (flood levels, levees, hurricane season) not simply because we are a bunch of lazy,feckless idiots. (Not that we don’t have our share of those, mind you.) You can’t simply rebuild your house and be done with it. Someone has to rebuild the infrastructure.
We need a Marshall Plan. We need levees. Hell, we need the Dutch.
Every day I think of NOLA, my favorite city of all the world I’ve seen so far, and my heart breaks again.
Please, y’all, please don’t believe for a minute that we’ve forgotten you. That what’s happened to you sometimes leaves us … just … speechless — don’t take those silences for our uncaring.
I have been and will continue to help in the ways I can from here, and I know most FDLers will too.
A couple of weeks ago, Mary McCurnin posted a description of what her middle-class NOLA family is dealing with. Her story tore a lot of us up, but we haven’t heard from her since, as far as I know. I wish she would come back and let us share her burden for another few minutes.
I hope all of you will do that.
Scout, thank you very much for today’s post, the good suggestions, and just in general, your ongoing devotion to NOLA. You couldn’t have picked a worthier cause.
I have been and will continue to help in the ways I can from here, and I know most FDLers will too.
FDLers are great. To have them fighting for NOLA and the Gulf Coast is/would be fantastic.
I heard on the news (CNN) that NOLA is now whiter and richer. Wow. Quelle surprise.
It was a long night here. I am afraid the Jacaranda tree is going to have to come down because it has gotten so big that it rubs relentlessly on the roof. It (Alberto) was a good test drive for us because I have been working since early September to get out lives hurrican ready and I can see the chinks in the armour.
I have to live here. There is no place for me to go.
I don’t want to end up like NOLA. I know that there is no one who will help us if Tampa Bay gets a cat 4 or cat 5.
Florida Mom…in their Disaster Response Planning, the parishes of Southern Louisiana are planning on no outside help at least in the early days/week after a disaster. Unfortunately every city should probably follow their lead.
The NOLA survivors and returnees have
shown astounding grit and determination.
And I admire the “of course we’ll rebuild” spirit.
But.
The protective marshes are in tatters; just about gone.
The land under NOLA is subsiding. The ocean is rising.
I think the city is now doomed, will we or nil we.
It gives me no joy to say this.
The entire era of Republican rule will be known as a chapter of American Shame.
end italics
Joel…I understand what you are saying. I would respectfully disagree though. The wetlands can be restored and NOLA can be protected even with the subsidence issues. Actually doing so would be invaluable in showing a path as to how we will deal with this in other coastal areas that face similar problems.
Well, Joel
You better alert all the farmers in the Midwest to quit growing wheat. And you might want to store up on pretty much everything we import.
Fill a few gas can’s too - oil will be in short supply.
There is more to this place than Bourbon street. Most countries don’t write off the port city to the largest river in their country.
Oh, and I am old enough to remember when Lake Erie was dead forever.
Scout, thanks again for reminding the rest of the country that NOLA and the Gulf Coast are very much not OK. You have been tireless in your efforts to keep the focus on the devastation of the area. Yes, something like the Marshall Plan is needed, and it is needed right now. Sorry about all the emphasis, but NOLA is my home town. I live about an hour away now, and it is still very hard for me to go there. Each time I go it’s like going to a funeral.
Scout saw it up close as I have, and I promise that pictures do not tell the tale. The sense of devastation and abandonment that you experience when you’re right there just blows you away.
The fate of New Orleans is a cautionary tale for all Americans. This government is bankrupt financially and morally. It is devisive. President Bush stood in Jackson Square and made promises…….when will the government honor his promises? lb0313 says we need a Marshall Plan, levees and the Dutch. Well said, but more than that, we need new government that has the energy and desire to keep faith with its’ citizens.
Hi janeboatler
Boudica…well said.
What is happening to NOLA ought to alarm Americans about their government and their safety
Semi-OT
Tony Campolo is a big name in the Evangelical Christian world, but to lump him in with Falwell, Dobson, and Co. is a big mistake. He’s got a post on HuffPo that is well worth reading, especially for those who are looking for a way to engage Bush Administration supporters on religous grounds.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/.....22895.html
As a Lutheran theologian, I’ve got problems with some of Tony’s doctrines, but I love what he’s doing here with contrasting “care for the poor and needy” with Bush policies like tax cuts for the rich, the Iraq war, minimum wage polices, etc.
Campolo doesn’t mention NOLA, but you could easily add the whole set of mistakes and mistaken priorities that ScoutPrime lists above to his case.
For those of you who are Christian, it’s worth a read. For those of you who are not Christian, it’s even more worth the read. It may give you an opening to approach those of a more fundy bent, using some of their own language.
Hmmmm . . . I think I’ve got to pass it on to some of my more fundy relatives to read. Gotta work on that one . . .
FYI, if you want to see how a little storm affects tides up and down the Florida coast, go here http://tidesonline.nos.noaa.gov/geographic.html and follow your nose to Florida. Clearwater Beach and Cedar Key are especially interesting because you can see the storm move past (in the wind direction, and in the barometric pressure). Note that the storm’s eye stayed about 100 miles from Clearwater.
scoutprime-thanks for your #12-pause well taken. I wish I could use the “national security response” when dealing with unwanted problems in my life like this administration is able to do. Good Luck to you and thanks for the info regarding much needed books for NOLA.
I was there at the end of January, and it was exactly as Scout Prime describes. There were whole neighborhoods where I saw hardly a soul. The waterlines on the houses are halfway up the front door - and a visible-from-a-distance waterline meant the water stayed at that level for awhile, which means you’re talking about entire neighborhoods where the interiors of the houses need to be gutted. You could tell just by looking whether or not a car had been there through Katrina, and there were thousands of cars that had been submerged in the storm, and are unlikely to be functional again.
It makes me absolutely seethe when I think about the way the aftermath of Katrina has been handled - not just the immediate aftermath, when so many people died who surely could have been saved, but the continuing aftermath as well.
Can you imagine Clinton letting New Orleans go without a plan anywhere near this long? Neither can I. He would have met with his Cabinet, with Congress, with New Orleans and Louisiana officials, and there would have been a plan voted on before Congress took its Christmas recess.
Instead, we have this slow-motion, drawn-out death of people’s hopes for their homes, for their city. It’s a travesty.
I’d personally be willing to see Bush impeached over Katrina.
Well good then,I was almost ready to take another load of books to my library to donate them.I’ll send them down to NOLA instead.Thanks for the address and info Scout.
Sorry, EPU’d from the Rove thread but important:
emptywheel agres with me! http://www.dailykos.com/story/2006/6/13/9339/59486
She also sees that the gods of politics demand that Cheney has to go, and Rove is too valuable not to stay. Bu$hCo is trading Dick for Karl, or at least those wheels are in motion and TurdBlossom gets to “live free, to fight another day.”
So, we may not be able affect the legal processes and machinations, but we sure as hell have to try to control the narrative about them. Now, taking off my lawyer hat and putting on my message hat–
We need to get experienced Federal lawyers out there commenting for us. We have to get out the totally truthful story that the only reason someone (here, Rove, elsewhere, Sammy the Bull) gets “a deal” is because they are in fact guilty. If they were innocent, there’s no need for a deal and no one, including Luskin, has ever yet publicly stated that Karl got “no deal.” The government only ever trades the opportunity to prosecute a guilty person for the opportunity to make a case against a (usually ) more guilty person. That means that the only thing this circumstance proves is that the corruption goes beyond Rove to Cheney, and the President’s closest 2 advisors appear to be criminals. The ONLY fact that would change this narrative is for Luskin to publicly say that Rove “has no agreement with Fitz to provide cooperation in exchange for a non-prosecution agreement.” As far as i know he hasn’t and not being able to make such a staement is probably why he all of a sudden decides NOW is the time for him to “have no further comment on the on-going investigation.”
RT
I never imagined we would see what we are almost 10 months later. It is truly an ongoing disaster and trauma for the Gulf Coast
People keep saying it was mistakes, but I don’t believe it. I don’t believe the intelligence community within our government made mistakes which allowed 9/11. I don’t believe mistakes were made which allowed the NOLA levees to collapse. I think these were done quite intentionally.
The only way to salvation for America is if our President and the government believe it is their duty to govern ALL of America for the benefit of everyone. The current Bush administration does NOT do that. They serve a very narrow interest and everyone else is paying severely for that. We must win Congress and get rid of them all. We must fix the voting systems across America to ensure the election is fair.
It breaks my heart to hear of the devastation of NOLA and my only consolation could be that rich White Republicans would move in there and then be flooded to death for their hubris.
This ain’t just hardball politics. This is live and death.
Shoot, we’re not OK even in Ohio. I don’t know if this is widely known, but urban renewal grants have really gone down in W’s reign. I’m one of several houses in my neighborhood that have had tarped roofs since the heavy rains of summer 2004.
You guys get a hurricane, we get weeks of rain. Our insurance doesn’t cover it, and FEMA didn’t either.
“Hell, we need the Dutch.”
Maybe Bechtel or Halliburton could hire some Dutch consultants.
The lack of care for New Orleans is an embarassment for the USA.
Where can books be taken?
foo…Christy lists this address for sending books…
Rica A. Trigs, Public Relations, New Orleans Public Library, 219 Loyola Avenue, New Orleans, LA 70112-2007
Venice has been sinking for centuries and finally Italy has done something about it. more than 5 billion will be spent on an amazing dike like system. It’s enormous and weirdly beautiful in a sculptural way.
most of our port cities, ny, boston, la, etc. are threatened by global warming. joel - do you suggest we abandon all of these, or is it just that nola is expendable for the same rascist reasons that bush et al did nothing for days? it’s unthinkable that one of our most beloved and culturally rich cities could be abandoned.
While NOPL is happy to recieve goodwill and donated materials.. there are more effective ways to help the library rebuild. See the library’s guidelines here on their site.
jeffrey…thanks for sharing that.
Jeffrey has some good info at Library Chronicles.
This media outlet formerly known as the Washington Post is really quite dead. I got these news alerts in my email this morning:
Mind you, since I subscribed to this alert service I’ve gotten less than one alert a month. The criteria used to determine what is alert worthy is not obvious; I got an alert May ‘05 when Lexis-Nexis computers were seized because of data theft…and then nothing for months.
AND NOTHING ABOUT THE CONTINUING DEVASTATION OF NOLA, EITHER.
I got an alert when Arthur Andersen’s conviction was overturned. Another when Libby was indicted (newsworth, I agree). A f*cking alert when WaPo won 4 Pulitzers (sorry, not newsworthy) — but nothing on Port security in February or March, nothing in March or later about immigration. Goss resigns and SnowJob makes PressSec, I get an alert for each.
And then today’s almost uncanny alerts — the second one occurring within minutes of seeing on NBC’s Today Show the same announcement.
Shills. F*cking propagandists. Karl Rove’s puppet. It’s not just that NYT was chosen last night for the Luskin report, but that WaPo made the push this morning with their latest State Party Bulletins.
WaPo is dead. It is no longer
It’s not pining. It’s passed on! This WaPo is no more! It has ceased to be! It’s expired and gone to meet its maker! It’s a stiff! Bereft of life, it rests in peace! If we hadn’t nailed it to the perch it’d be pushing up the daisies! Its metabolic processes are now history! It’s off the twig! It’s kicked the bucket, it’s shuffled off its mortal coil, run down the curtain and joined the bleeding choir invisible!
THIS IS AN EX-WAPO!!
(With great thanks to Monty Python.)
Before you pack up and mail your books to NOLA, check out this rundown on Snopes.com:
http://www.snopes.com/katrina/charity/library.asp
Apparently the library recommends sending money instead of books. While book donations are being accepted, the library is short on personnel to sort and process them.
In light of this, I’m going to mail the NOLA public library a cash donation and donate my extra books to a local charity.
I recently sold my house in Seattle. My agent was from New Orleans originally and his parents still live there. In April, he hired a crew and sent them down to NO so that his parents could live in their house again. They are in their 80s and would not move. He said there was no one to hire in NO to do the work.
New Orleans is referenced by so many different types of music. I think it is at least once a week where I hear some song - punk, rock’n'roll, rap, r&b, country, or blues where New Orleans is mentioned. Every time I hear them, I think of pre-Katrina.
And then I wonder in 10, 15, or in 50 years, when music changes and becomes a new style or a new genre, what will those songs sound like when they mention New Orleans?
re 43
There is a lack of affordable housing for workers of all sorts. There a signing bonuses for working in fast food restaurants.
moe99…I’ve heard people have to wait for construction crews and others find some. Many are still waiting for insurance checks. Others received just paultry settlements of a few thousand dollars and have no means to rebuild on that.
This is why the appropriations bill making its way through Congress right now is so important. It has $4.2 billion for the state’s Road Home program that would at least get them some more money. but they won’t see the money for months. So more waiting
Thanks for the update. I am a N.O. resident living in my home on the 2nd fl. (1st floor destroyed.) I feel a bit more hope lately, but the pace of progress — as you pointed out — is terribly slow. Thanks for the kind words.
The situation in New Orleans runs parallel to those of Iraq and Afghanistan after war. In all cases, our government has set up people for additional suffering because of greed and incompetence and lying. Reconstruction of the kind Germany and the rest of Europe had after WWII is what is needed, but the controls are not in place to prevent the corruption of effort to rebuild.
It is paramount that we elect people who will live up to the promises made by the preseny government, even if it is one we don’t associate ourselves with, philosophically. When Democrats win the elections, this should be one of their main priorities, after cancelling all the tax breaks for folks who don’t need them, so there will be enough money to do the job right.
Educator…lot of 2nd floor dwellers huh.
What’s happening with your first floor?
margaret…yes. We should be putting the question to all candidates…What will you do different for the Gulf Coast?
i just got back from nola and i’m a wreck. help ACORN, they need it and they know what they’re doing.
You can bet your bippy Trent Lott has a new porch though.
bustednuckles… Trent is suing his insurance company as they refused his claim along with so many others. Another promise (we’ll sit on Trent’s porch) that Bush hasn’t kept
MISSION ACCOMPLISHED!!!
Maybe you think I’m being glib and/or facetious. I’m not. One of the grand goals of the Republican criminal conspiracy is to get people to stop thinking about government as an entity that can help them in any part of their daily lives, yea even unto their very survival. They’ve been working toward that end since the day Ronald Reagan took office. (Nobody noticed, though, because he had such wonderful hair.) It’s hard work, but they’re making good progress. FEMA was a cabinet-level office under Clinton, one that worked reasonably well. Now it’s merely fodder for Jay Leno’s monologue.
Make no mistake — they knew that at some point something like New Orleans was bound to happen. But it didn’t matter. It wasn’t going to happen to them or anybody they knew or, most importantly, anybody who attended their fundraisers. However, they didn’t anticipate it happening quite yet. The little things, the things that only affected individuals and families, the things that don’t merit coverage on CNN, were supposed to go first. That way when the big things –like cities and wars — started to go, people would just shrug their shoulders and roll their eyes and say, “Well, you know, what else would you expect from the government? I mean, look at how they handle the mail!”
(Lest you think I’m being callous, I live in Los Angeles. It is an accident of timing that we are not having this discussion about my part of the world. There is a good chance that at some point in the near future, we will.)
I’ll say it again: Mission Accomplished!
> scout prime says:
> The wetlands can be restored and NOLA can be protected
> even with the subsidence issues.
I would love to see this happen.
But.
Subsiding delta wetlands could be restored. How?
By frequent floods that deposit lots of sediment.
So the required solution:
- restores the pre-urbanization flood regime of the delta system
- but doesn’t allow New Orleans to be flooded, even though its streets now lie many feet lower than the pre-urbanization ground level.
This is not a simple undertaking.
And I really can’t see any solution to the subsidence of the city itself.
In one human lifetime, NO will be below sea level, I think.
The required engineering is possible, I guess; but it’s gargantuan.
> lb0313 says:
> Most countries don’t write off the port city
> to the largest river in their country.
You misunderstand.
I’m not _advocating_ abandoning New Orleans –
I’m _predicting_ that our best efforts will be futile, and that in a century’s time our Mississippi seaport will be on higher ground,
somewhere along the lower reaches
of the present course of the Atchafalaya.
OT - CSPAN now has the following 3 DVD’s from YearlyKos:
http://www.c-spanstore.org/sho.....d=192913-1
An afternoon panel focused on progressive web logs and issues surrounding “blog” coverage of a CIA leak investigation involving the disclosure of Ambassador Wilson’s wife, Valerie Plame Wilson, as a covert operative with the Central Intelligence Agency. The video feed from Las Vegas was often interrupted, resulting in a program that contains continuous audio with moments of pixilated video footage.
$45
http://www.c-spanstore.org/sho.....d=192913-2
Senator Boxer gave a keynote address at the annual YearlyKos convention. Prior to her speech comedians provided political satire and commentary on recent public affairs events. Due to technical difficulties, the program contained brief moments of incomplete video. The audio portion was not affected.
$29.95
http://www.c-spanstore.org/sho.....d=192913-3
Internet columnists for Daily Kos spoke about journalism, the impact of web logs on news coverage of events, and the role of political opinion in topic selection for on-line columns. Due to technical difficulties, the program contained brief moments of incomplete video. The audio portion was not affected.
$45
Well Scout Prime, Thats good.I wonder how long it will take for his suit to be adjucated compared to all the rest. This is another glaring example of the “fuck em, let em eat cake” attitude we saw right after the hurricane hit.Btw, What is the status on the port facilities?
EPU’ed from the Plameology panel.
Desi at MiaCulpa has tracked down the video on YouTube.
http://miaculpa.blogspot.com/2.....y-kos.html
I have been taking moments to watch it on ForaTV, which is one wildly inconvenient registration.
This might be lots easier.
Back to the mess in NOLA. Sorry for the distraction.
55
You may indeed be right - there has long been talk of the folly of the Army Corp trying to control the river.
But personally I’d take the Dutch attitide of ‘This will never happen again’. A unified national will coupled with a plan and money.
God might win in the end, but not without a damn good fight.
Roddy McCorley….you raise an important point. I don’t think you are at all glib. This whole affair should have us looking at the fundamental role of government as the choice seems to have been bad government or no government or hand off government to faith based groups. Is that what the majority of Americans want?
I don’t think so.
57
Last I heard on the ports was quite some time ago - but that they got things moving again amazingly quickly
OT, but House Appropriations committee chmn Jerry Lewis has a lawyer…and Babs Comstock will be handling press inquiries for the Lewis legal team. You think she’ll be handling his legal defense fund too? My, my.
Make that “criminal defense attorney” rather than just “lawyer”.
Joel….I still disagree.
One of the authors of one report on subsidence says it can be done. He points out the importance of the report isn’t that it Shouldn’t be done, rather it tells them how they Can do it. Here is a link for an interview with him.
Here is a snippet from that….
DOKKA: No. It’s not a — it’s not a death trap. What we now — we now know what we need to do. Now we just need the money to go and fix the levees and make them — make them high enough to protect our — our citizens.
Thanks for posting this and discussing this. I belong to a couple Yahoo groups that discuss animal rescue and I am so surprised that none of the blogs have picked up on that angle, and particularly the suicide of Shannon Hartwick Moore (May 30, 2006). She was the leading animal advocate. I understand the suicide rate in NOLA is very high.
Bustednuckles
I think what lb0313 says is right. A great guy who is a diver in NOLA took me on a tour of the port area and did say some big companies just pulled stakes and left though.
Another issue is the MRGO channel which is for ship traffic. It also is believed to have been a conduit of storm surge. Recently a study has been funded as to whether it should be closed (something many in NOLA want) But it will be tough as it would mean many busines interests would have to relocate their facilities. The fear is they would just pull out of NOLA also or at least threaten to do so.
Dianne
I believe Louisiana just passed a bill to allow people to take their pets when evacuating in the future.
There has been a national bill on this I believe but I don’t think it went anywhere. Some reps fought it.
A lot of pets were lost inspite of valiant efforts from so many volunteers and groups. Those folks really did so much.
I hadn’t heard about Shannon Hartwick. There seems to be anecdotal evidence of increased suicide though I haven’t seen studies yet. I’m sure it will be so. The numbers of those dealing with mental health issues is mind boggling.
Great post, Scout. Another thing people may not realize is the damage the hundreds of tons of debris still left on the streets of NOLA will do to what’s left of (and what’s been rebuilt in) the city should a hurricane or even a tropical storm hit.
Not surprisingly, FEMA’s denying responsibility clearing debris - and saying it won’t be cleared before next year.
Rebuilding the levees and restoring the LA Wetlands is what, something like a 25 to 30 billion dollar job?
What’s that — 2 or 3 months in Iraq?
What slim says at 68.
slim’s blog called no fish, no nuts is another good source for info
ck…good point. It would be interesting to see some pols make it
Focussing on just the end of the piece - the part on the New Orleans Public Library needing books. If there are specific ones they want, they could be listed online or even in an Amazon Wish List, and they’d get them immediately. Even better if someone set up a special web site for this function, with software that monitored the “active” wish list and noted immediately when someone had pledged to buy specific books on that list. Otherwise they’d get dozens of each copy, I’d imagine. If I were a geek, I’d try to do it, but I’m not.
There is a whole nation full of people who want to DO something, if we can set up a system to funnel their efforts - and I don’t just mean books, of course. And I’d like to see an aggressively updated list of web sites where people from around the country can address specific tasks in the Katrina-hit states.
NWH 72, I agree, but and just took care of a new NGatlas, annotated complete shakespeare and a “sibleys guide to birds” and some Douglas adams for good measure. Hubby is shipping off the old paperbacks as I type. Hope they got lots of room.
new thread
I would really urge folks to call their reps or
hit this link for levees.org where you can contact your rep and send an e-letter about the levees.
It’s quick, easy and so important
Sorry. Messed up the tags…
I would really urge folks to call their reps or
hit this link for levees.org where you can contact your rep and send an e-letter about the levees.
It’s quick, easy and so important
OMG. I am so choked up after reading this.
I try to put it all out of my mind just to go on. I am not sleeping well. On the radio the other day they said many in town are not. I think it is the start of hurricane season causing uneasyness.
It is all true. Every bit of it.
I am on the Board of the Epilepsy Foundation. We had our board meeting yesterday. People with seizures have no way to get care if they are not insured and are not on Medicare or Medicaid. The emergency rooms only treat “emergencies” after the seizure is over and you haven’t died, it is no longer an emergency.
Unfortunately even our neighbors in the north part of Louisiana are “tired of hearing about Katrina”. How do you make people understand what is going on without witnessing it? I just don’t know what to say.
Thanks Jane and Christy for posting this. We are trying so desperately to rebuild our community. Any little bit of help you can give would be appreciated.
I just contacted the National Customer Service Center for the Post Office. The supervisor I spoke with indicated there is no official program in place for reduced rates to NOPL for book donations. It would be classified as “media mail” only, weight limit is 70lb.
Still worthwhile to donate, just ship it slow boat to save money.
A good book can really take you away from your problems for a few hours and it’s much healthier than doing drugs, which is what I used to resort to when trying to escape my problems. Reading is much better!
scout prime - Trent Lott was getting pretty whiney back in January about how he was suffering, too. Despite the fact that the beach house was his third house, and the other two were doing just fine.
His whine isn’t online, alas - it was in the NOLA paper on 1/29/06, and I can’t find it on their website. But I kept the print copy, and I’ll try to remember to post from it after dinner tonight.
TeeDub: that reminds me of what Groucho Marx once said: “Outside of a dog, a book is man’s best friend. Inside of a dog, it’s too dark to read.”
Yes, I hear that people are “tired of hearing it” too. The thing that’s different between now and the way things used to be is that there used to be an emergency PLAN in place so that essential services and infrastructure repairs went fairly quickly. That’s no longer true (at least, not here) and services that should have been restored and repairs that should have been made have not been. If you protest too loudly, you stand the risk of going to jail. I had to leave work four hours early last week because there was no water pressure in the building at all. It’s nearly impossible to plan anything.
Thanks for the awesome post.
I don’t know if it’s a sign of hope or a sign of lunacy on my part, but I’m moving back after having been gone twenty years.
One correction: The NO public library really prefers cash donations to book donations. Unfortunately the call for book donations meme got loose in the wild and once out it’s hard to squash.
See the following on what kind of help the library really needs:
http://nutrias.org/~nopl/found.....onsfaq.htm
This is a rant and not directed at any one particular person……
Stand in line… Elkport Iowa has been waiting 2 years for FEMA buyout after declaring the town nolonger fit after being flooded out. There are still people waiting on some issues related to the Floods of ‘93.
Just how long do you think it should take for the area to rebuild?? It took nearly 20 years for Biloxi to recover completely from Camille, but Frederic also went through in those 20 years.
Having spent 8 years in Biloxi, I’ve been through my share of hurricanes. We’ve been taught year after year not to expect any help for at least 3 days, except perhaps from the locals.
There’s been mismanagment from all levels in regard to Katrina, including the residents themselves. Are you suggesting we should empty out our hospitals and building crews, just so NO can be big again?? Are the rest of us to not have our homes rebuilt after the tornado went through Iowa City on April 13th because NO is more important than our homes?? What happened to the 3 billion dollars dontated to Habitat for Humanity, the Red Cross, Salvation Army?? The railroad that goes through the Mississippi coast (it’s located between the beach and back bay in Biloxi) has already been rebuilt, but now they want us to pay to move it somewhere else…. I don’t think so. That railroad burmming is what saved sections of the coast. Then there are these people…. http://www.newyorkmetro.com/ne.....161/?imw=Y
We’re still having issues with FEMA and the Army Crops of Engineers over the Floods of ‘93. Flooding so bad that the *ENTIRE* state of Iowa was declared a natural disaster. The Mississippi went from a meandering 1 mile width to 15 mile width of raging water. We lost so many bridges, it’s not funny and lots of them will never be rebuilt.
To expect NO and the coast to be a pristine, rebuilt area in less than a year after such a huge storm is folly. I’ve heard enough stories from family of friends in the area on how some there expect us to build them McMansions, furnish them and then provide for them for the rest of their lives just because they went through Katrina that I am quickly loosing patience with the whole deal.
I’ve got more rant to go…. and lots of it. But, I suspect y’all don’t want to hear about it.
Ray
I’ll try to pass that onto Christy and perhaps she can do an update
Still no money for NOLA and its residents, yet somehow the House manages to scrounge up a $3300 pay hike for themselves???!!!! I barely get by, and those in NOLA aren’t getting by at all!! Where’s our cost of living pay increase??!!!
My head just exploded.
iowa christine
I’ve not suggested it is a choice between NOLA or any other place that needs help be it Iowa, MS, AL, name the place. I believe our government can do better to marshall resources and help people help themselves.
The Army Corps should be held accountable and there ought be better oversight for ALL its project throughout the country. This should be a lesson from this disaster. No one wants to see anyone else become victims of their mistakes or Congress’ again.
No one expects NOLA or the Gulf to be rebuilt or “pristine” in one year. It will take years to rebuild NOLA. Most believe at least 10 years but more like 20-30 years. But it is undeniable that in many areas of NOLA and the Gulf NOTHING has happened. Not even debris removal.
Deep in the EPU zone, but I have a day job and have to catch up on my FDL in the evening, if my lovely wife will let me on her computer. I live and work in New Orleans, and have to say that the entire story is NOT being told. Yes, the US Army Corps of Engineers screwed up several levee designs and rightfully share a great deal of the blame for flooding this city. Give them credit for stepping up and acknoiwledging their responsibility, because there are quite a few other folks who desaerve blame, and are laying low, hoping we won’t notice. Yes, I’m talking about the Levee Districts, the Orleans Levee District in particular, and (to a lesser extent) the N.O. Sewarge & Water Board. The Levee Districts shared with USACE in passing out contracts for design and construction of levees in their districts. Many of these contracts were awarded to a favored few, the politically connected, and to say that oversight was inadequate is to say that Joe Stalin let a few people starve to death. The Levee Districts are also charged with maintaining and inspecting the levees, and together with a compliant USACE, conducted an annual “inspection” that was more about LUNCH than ensuring that our levees were sound. See Gordon Russell’s Pulitzer Prize winning article here: www.pulitzer.org/year/2006/pub.....sps08.html
To see how well they inspected the levees, you should know that trees and shrubbery on your levees and next to your flood protection structures are VERY BAD. The failure at the 17th street canal (here’s a picture of the failure: what do you see next to the failed walls? trees? shrubs? www.orleanslevee.com/images/Hu.....ina05.html) is thought to have occurred in part when a large oak tree fell over and left a huge hole for water to flow through where the root ball came up out of the ground. The increased water flow through and under the levee caused the whole 400-foot section to slide into the neighborhood. Here’s another photo from the Orleans Levee District’s own website: www.orleanslevee.com/images/Hu.....ina61.html … see those trees in the foreground? That wall a few feet behind the trees is a flood protection wall. The trees fell over, and water came through the holes. The street you see runs right in front of the building that was the headquarters for the Orleans Levee District, half a block away. The people responsible for inspecting these levees and flood protection walls drove by this EVERY WORKING DAY. Can you say “negligence”? How about “incompetence”? How about “negligent homocide”?
airportcat
I was at the 17th St Canal break. I talked with the people who lived around there. (I was there the day members of Congress was coming to see it so quite a few of the residents showed up and I was able to talk to them). They told me that about the tree being removed by that break.
And the water and sewer never did anything about complaints of water leaking before Katrina. IIRC they never passed that along to ACE. It sounds like the big culprit was the design. (I walls, soil, height) but water leaking, well not good.
It’s hard to include everything in one post. Thanks for bringing it up
More EPU’d, but what the heck … Joel Hanes is out to lunch, there is plenty that can be done, including diverting Mississippi river to restore disappearing delta / wetlands. Go here www.saveourlake.org/press_room.htm to see a great local conservation organization. One thing about the wetlands: Louisiana gets a far lower share of offshore oil & gas revenues from the Federal govt than do other states that permit offshore exploration and production. LA has been fighting for an increased share of this revenue. Please support these efforts! It will make a LOT of difference, especially because the money will be targeted to saving and restoring our disappearing wetlands. The oil companies bear a large responsibility for this destruction, they should also be taxed to repair it. Lawyers out there, is a lawsuit possible? This is well documented, it is well known that the oil companies knew about the bad effects of dredging channels, knew it was destroying wetlands, but did not care. Profits and all, you know.
AirportCat
Hey what is EPU? I’ve seen it a few times and I’m not familiar with it.
Thanks for all the good info you’re bringing up
Airportcat,
The Levee Boards were useless. That is why I am fighting hard to get the new board system passed. But in the end, it wasn’t the boards fault. Forensic testing has shown the levees were built to design levels. It was the design that was at fault. The design was done by the Corps.
Airportcat… In some of the arial photos by NOAA in the week or so after Katrina, it showed that Chandeler Island is for all pratical purposes gone. Is that true?? If it is…. you can kiss a lot more goodbye when the next hurricane comes through. The Barrier Islands are speed bumps for hurricanes.
Yes, the Federal Gov’t could have done many, many things better. But, so could have the State and local Gov’ts. It’s not the sole fault of the Feds. Yes, I can agree that this ‘outsourcing’ of relief efforts is a money grab by the powers that be, whether it be Fed, State, or local. Then there’s the bureaucratic mumbojumbo put forth by the insurance companies. I have heard from people that do some work in the NO area saying that if you were white and had insurance, you’re getting NO help from anyone and that includes FEMA.
As I’ve said before, I have absolutely no problem giving a helping hand. This may include low interest loans, or small grants, etc. There were a few families that moved up here because they had other family up here, or had kids going to the university. Most of them have been very accomodating to our ways of doing things, have worked hard to re-establish themselves, and truely appreciate the help our area has given them. Then you have people like what is mentioned in the article I linked to. Which makes it extremely difficult to be sympathitic to others plight.
I remeber when Frederic went through, they were threatening to take names and next of kin if people wouldn’t get off the beach areas. That and comparisons to Camille got an awful lot of people to move north. We were lucky and got the easy side.
Another thing, I’m not sure if you’re aware of…. As a result of the Floods of ‘93 new guidelines have been made for flood plains. Most of the levees that broke then are not allowed to be rebuilt and in many areas, if they flood again, they’re being banned from being rebuilt. This is for all along the Mississippi. Ohio, and Missouri Rivers. It was my understanding that this policy was to extend all the way to the Gulf.
AirportCat, the levee districts, the levee boards, and the New Orleans Sewerage and Water Board all bear responsibility for not doing their jobs and for fighting among themselves. I am lobbying now too to get the boards consolidated by the Louisiana State Legislature. There’s blame to spread around, but the disaster was so huge that IMO, it’s just too much for the local and state governments to handle on their own. If the feds neglected Iowa as well as the Gulf Coast and NOLA, then that’s wrong too.
We blow away 10 billion a month in Iraq for what?
I have heard from people that do some work in the NO area saying that if you were white and had insurance, you’re getting NO help from anyone and that includes FEMA.
Christine, that’s just not true. I do know white folks - my daughter and her family are one example - who have gotten FEMA help. They got their blue tarp for their roof, they got money for damage to their house, along with displacement money. Fortunately their house was not that badly damaged, and they could move back into it fairly quickly.
The ones who suffered were those whose houses were destroyed, and FEMA was slow to give the help.
In the end, I believe that some parts of Greater New Orleans will not be rebuilt and probably should not be rebuilt.
Scout Prime, thanks for this post and all your support. “EPU” is from a long-time poster here (”Evil Parallel Universe” who (as the lore has been passed down from those who were here since the beginning) would often post long, thoughtful comments at the end of a thread that would not get read because a new thread was up … now referred to as “being EPU’d [from last thread]”, sometimes put in comments on next thread to alert those who moved on.
iowa christine, I think you are right, I agree (if that is what you are suggesting) that there are some areas that should not be rebuilt, no matter how big they make the levees and I’m sorry for the people who lived in those places, understand their attachment, but how many times can we pay to rebuild in a place where we never should have built to begin with? definition of insanity, anyone?
doctorj, Levee Boards are STILL useless, Sen Boasso’s bill was a good move in the right direction, but I think they ought to do away with the Levee Boards completely, have a professional-based (NO political appointments, please!) State agency for flood protection and coastal restoration, same level as DOTD, DEQ, etc. Also, I don’t think ALL design was done by USACE, although they reviewed and approved everything … didn’t Modjeski & Masters do the design on the walls at 17th St Canal? I thought there were some contract engineering firms involved in some of the design work. Anyway, yeah, bad designs, also bad construction the St Bernard levees were mostly friggin’ SAND fer crapsakes but all that evidence washed away and the odious Odinets are still pursuing their public lives of crime or at least criminal stupidity.
> Joel Hanes is out to lunch
Perhaps.
I sincerely hope so.
The FAQ from the library says they prefer you have a local book sale and send the money to them. Save shipping, get more bang for the buck, if you will.
“What is the best way to help New Orleans Public Library?
Monetary donations are the best way to help the library rebuild (NOPL Foundation Rebuilding Campaign Donations). If you would rather mail your donation, please make your check payable to NOPL Foundation and send it to New Orleans Public Library Foundation, 219 Loyola Avenue, New Orleans, LA 70112.
What are other good ways to support NOPL?
Our library is also selling “Rebuild NOPL” T-shirts (link here to buy a T-shirt online) and bookplates (to purchase bookplates, contact Kim Tran (ktran@gno.lib.la.us).
Does the library accept book donations?
Yes. However, due to storage and staff limitations, we ask that donors consider a few suggestions:
If you are a publisher, please contact us in advance at wmascari@gno.lib.la.us before shipping large quantities of books.
If you are an individual sending your own used books, please consider making a cash donation instead.
I have already collected a great many books for NOPL (or we would like to organize a book drive for NOPL), but I don’t want to cause a burden to the library system by sending a large shipment of books. What should I do?
Consider holding a booksale in your city to benefit our library and sending us the proceeds. This saves you the expense of shipping costs, eliminates storage and staffing problems on our end, enables library staff to purchase those materials that are most needed, and helps to generate additional publicity about NOPL’s needs. “
From Donations to NOPL FAQ
janeboatler,
Good for your daughter. Maybe it’s just hit and miss on who’s getting help.
I also agree with both of you that some areas just should not be rebuilt, no matter how sentimental, historic, whatever, they are. After the Floods of ‘93 and subsequent floodings, things aren’t being rebuilt and returned to ‘natural’ state in an effort to mitigate damages from future flooding.
In all honesty… urban sprawl will be our downfall. We need to build up, not out. Make a smaller footprint. But, we’ve become so conditioned on the ‘American dream’ of owning a few acres and a detached home.
Add me to the list of people blogging about NOLA. I actually just put the blog up today because I couldn’t find much about Katrina or what the current status is. Also, I know that there are fundraising efforts underway as we speak. I picked up the book “Through the Eye of the Storm” by Cholene Espinoza a few months back and couldn’t put it down. The beauty of the book is not only is it a good read, but all the proceeds are going to help build a community center. Anyway, thanks so much for the new and current information on the state of affairs in NOLA.
We will not lay down and die. We are New Orleanians. This is our home.
Thank you so much for keeping our story alive.
Folks,
Check you facts:
I left New Orleans, the place I grew up, because I fell in love with a girl from out of town 20 years ago. I felt I could not protect her from the rampant crime in the place of my birth.
Yes, we lived knowing this disaster was coming. All expatriates and citizens lived with it.
Governor Huey Long was assassinated because because he knew what the oil companies were doing to our wetlands.
People that I grew up with and loved their city, are leaving the city in droves because the Republican “puppet” Ray Nagin, who’s only response to the disaster was to make money off of “FEMA” grants ($1500.00 per car to remove drowned cars) got re-elected by people bussed in to vote, but chose not to bus in (Jesse Jackson) to help rebuild.
“Carpetbaggers” will buy up the the property in the neighborhoods where we used to live, and Ray Nagin is calling for “projects” (Federal subsidized housing) to be rebuilt so non tax-paying “citizens” will supply this administration with more votes.
The Gulf Coast was destroyed from south Alabama to East Texas, yet all we hear is the “Lower Ninth Ward” in the “press”.
When is anybody gonna call these people out?
All the hard working people of the Gulf Coast want is to get the insurance companies to pay off what people paid premiums for, a cut of the royalties to rebuild the levees correctly
, and reconstruction of wetlands (God gave us) so we can live where we were born and live.
The most important thing you can do is contact your representative.
Thanks,
Tired of the B S